2,511 words · 19 October 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. This talk continues an explanation of the four noble truths, using the example of sickness and medicine to show how suffering, its causes (actions and delusions), cessation and the path are understood. It then distinguishes the Mahayana path of directly realizing emptiness from the hearer and solitary realizer paths, and explains why a bodhisattva practises on impermanence in order to teach hearers.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: f317b851-fc59-41b9-9603-d7134302f7a1
Date: 1989-10-19
Words: 2,507
Truth of the cause of suffering. And after that, the person realizes or understands the cessation of the cessation of the suffering. And then he understands and realizes the what I call the truth of the path. So this is how the presentation has been established. It is from the same point of view how the four truths could be realized or understood from person by a person who wants to attain liberation.
The great work called Buddha Maitriya in his text called the Sutralamkara or ornamental sūtra where it goes in meaning saying that the sickness is to be understood and the cause of sickness is to be abandoned and the medicine is to be applied and in this way one understands the reality of things and how one has to apply the meaning. So our explanation will be followed. So this is, for example, in the daily life, if the person has a very heavy lunch and perhaps overeating, then tomorrow the person will get sick and when he gets sick he clearly have the feeling of sickness, so therefore searching the cause of the sickness comes first and then you might perhaps try to find out what caused the sickness and then you might find out oh yesterday I have overeaten so that could be the reason. The person would think, oh, yesterday I have overeaten and food hasn’t digested well so I’m sick this morning. So after that, the realization of sickness, he understands the cause of the sickness.
So in this way, firstly the person understands the sickness first, the suffering, and then the cause of the sickness, the cause of suffering. So being sick this morning is the result and finding what’s the cause and afterward understand it was because of yesterday’s overeating. So that is the cause. So in this way, we understand the truth of suffering comes first. So because of this reason in the four truths, the first truth of suffering as an explained first, and after that, the explanation is they called the truth of the origin.
So if a person becomes sick and is facing the case of intense, unbearable sickness, then the person will think, oh, I can’t stand this sickness. I must try to get rid of this sickness. So there would be a kind of interest to find out means to get rid of this sickness. And then the person will have an an aspiration to have happiness free of sickness and when he has that aspiration he will find or think, oh what should I do in order to have that state of happiness free of sickness? So when he tries to think that way, will come afterward, he will come to understand that it is possible if I take medicine.
So therefore his interest after that will be in applying or having the medicine. So in the same way, the truth of the cessation is like like the the what call happiness, state of happiness free of sickness and the person in the case of being sick he would try to find means to get rid of sickness and he would find out that it’s only if he takes medicine that he will have the state free of sickness so he will aspire and try to work towards inhaling the medicine. So in the course of trying to find out the right medicine if the person goes to and concerns an expert doctor then the person can really get rid of his sickness and he can attain the state of happiness free of sickness. So that’s in that case of Maitreya, this has been explained as an example. So in the meaning it also applies in the same way like it is we have a lot of suffering both from the point of our body and from mind.
So because there is whole lot of suffering to our body and to our mind, therefore our mind is to the suffering and our body also is to the suffering. And now when we understand that this the truth of suffering, our body and mind, now we should try to find out whether from what has these two truth of suffering has come from. So when we try to find out and examine, then we will find the second truth, the truth of the origin of the cause of suffering. So regarding the truth of the old soul, the truth of coarse surfing, when we try to examine, then we will find the coarse surfing are two, or the actions. The actions and the afflictions is normally translated as delusions.
So actions and delusions. So when we try to find out what are the causes which bring about this total suffering, we find all the negative actions, non-virtuous actions which we do are the causes and actions themselves are motivated by the three root poisons which can be grouped in the term delusions. So action and delusions are the cause And now we understand this is the truth of suffering and there are those two truth of the cause of suffering. And as we don’t want this, therefore, we will try to find out the cause by which this has come about. And we will also try to get rid of this suffering and in trying to get rid of the person there will be a natural feeling within us, oh what wonderful would it be if I be free of this suffering and if I have complete happiness complete happiness without all this suffering.
So there would be a natural feeling of a kind of wanting to be endowed with happiness. So regarding the happiness which is completely free of the suffering and the cause of suffering, so regarding that happiness it is of two. The which it is called a synonym of the teaching, liberation and the truth of cessation. So that liberation and the truth of cessation is what at this point in a certain course of finding he has to aspire to try to get try to attain. And that very state of happiness of liberation, free of the suffering and the cause of suffering is called the truth of cessation.
So repeating, that very happiness of liberation free of the suffering and cause of suffering is the truth of cessation. So after that, the person tried to examine, oh, from where can I have that state of true cessation? So in trying to find out, then the person will eventually understand that there is a solution by which I can really attain that cessation. Somehow after the person will understand the last truth, the truth of the path. Regarding that truth of the path, which is mean for us to attain that what I call, cessation.
So regarding this truth of the path, principally that truth of the path refers to what we just had explained, the realization of the Mahāyāna truth directly realizing suchness free of elaboration. So direct direct realization of the emptiness, the free of elaboration is what principally the path of the truth of the path The great compassionate teacher has taught us such unequal means and such unmistakable means and such matchless means by which we can attain that state of truth of cessation. So in many, the great compassionate teacher has really taught us this solution which is really a surprise, really unmistaken and really profound. So let’s meditate for about five minutes by remembering the kindness of such a teacher who has taught such meaningful, has taught us such meaningful, understanding our teaching on the four truths by which we can understand that ourselves and all mother sentient beings, are suffering which is the truth of suffering and there is cause for their suffering which is the second truth cause of the suffering and also for those who have a solution and which is the truth of the cessation and for trying to attain or as a means to attain that truth of cessation, we have taught such an unmistaken and profound path, the realization of emptiness which is the last truth, the truth of the path.
So by remembering the kindness of the teacher and by kindness of the teacher from the standpoint of view how he has unmistakably taught us this whole truth. Let’s meditate for five minutes. No. This one, we call knowledge of the path knowing the hearer path and solitary path. So these two knowledge of the path is only exclusively in the continuum of Mahāyāna persons, personal Mahāyāna paths with real life emptiness and it is not in any of those two I call it Titus Nile, lower rating, because with these two, the lower of the path, knowing the hearer’s path and solitary path.
So with these two, the great vehicle practitioner, who has realized emptiness, a superior great vehicle practitioner, he practices these things such as on impermanence, on emptiness and on selflessness which principally belong as a practice of the lower paths. So this person of great vehicle, he practices on that and when he knows and has realized these things, then he is teaching to the people or practicing belonging within the group of hearers and solitary realizers. So firstly, without practicing these things, without having realization on these things, person of great vehicle cannot give teachings on the other system. So this is the teaching which principally belongs to what’s called Hearer’s and Solitary Realizer’s path, but teaching to give is not the use is not the, what I call, knowledge of the path. It’s just knowledge of the path, some aspect which is similar to the part of the Well, it’s quite possible when we say the knowledge of the path on Hearer’s path.
It’s quite possible when we say that that some might there’s possibility of idea arising or arising in the continuum of the Hearer person on Hearer’s path. It’s quite possible to think that way, but it’s not like that. When a superior bodhisattva, when he does practices such as like on impermanence to principally with the purpose to subdue and attract the disciple’s longing to that kind of practice. The superior bodhisattva does practice on impermanence and afterwards he gains realization on that topic of impermanence. So that mind is called the mind which has realized impermanence.
So that is why it’s called, that is the knowledge of the path which belongs to the hearer’s path because it has a well called attribute of being similar to what the hearers normally would practice. So why a bodhisattva will have to do practice on impermanence is because person who does practice on hearer’s path, they principally do their practice on impermanence. If Bodhisattva, if he hasn’t done any practice on that impermanence, then he would he will not be able to explain what impermanence is all about. So firstly, the Bodhisattva superior superior Bodhisattva, he has to practice in permanent means that, and then he has explained to Hearers about that. So it seems like in the example normally with the teachers who go to teaching in educational institutes and like schools.
So let’s say even if it’s a teacher who has to teach to third or fourth grade, so firstly, teacher, even though he might have studied this subject before, but right before, he goes to class with the pair. And in some cases, even though he has studied before, to recall the practice and have a kind of clear realization on the topic and then he has to teach to the student. But of course, whatever he is going to teach, topic, firstly the teacher will have to have a realization within the teacher’s mind. So it doesn’t mean that the student also has that wisdom with the teacher present. So it’s just a kind of a teacher, prepare and try to, in order to get the students more into the student be attracted that the teacher has to learn all these things.
And in the case, even though the subject may have been learned by the teacher before over many years, but still in order to make it a more complete better presentation, you may still have to work on. So that’s part of our practice and afterwards whatever the teacher has a clear realization of the problem becomes what in this case, the knowledge of the path knowing the hearer’s path. So the word called clear knowledge and realization within the teacher’s mind, it is something exclusively at that point within the teacher’s mind. And afterwards, the teacher tried to explain it and teach it in a very nice way as possible to the student. But still the case remains that the student hasn’t got that realization in So think that we’ll have to try every means to have this knowledge and realization in part given to the students.
I know this Michael Peter, when he is speaking, So it’s just a difference in what I call faculty and difference in the wind power of the capacity. The Hearer will have lesser faculty and a wind power not very strong. So it’s just the way it’s called grades in accordance to what we normally have grades in school. And also it’s not necessary that the person of Hearer’s path, when he’s perfecting that one, that he should pass on to the Solitary Realizer’s path. It’s not necessary.
So let’s say with the class two and three, those in class two will definitely have more lifting and wind power will have to be more. But seeing those two paths like the Hearer’s and Solitary Realizer’s path, it’s not necessary that the hearers automatically go into Solitary Realizer’s path because implying that those two are completely different sets of paths. So why there are two completely different sets of paths because of the difference in in the perseverance, weak powers and faculty. So the hearers will have to go on their own path and solitary realizers on their own path. It’s also possible that it’s also possible to have cases of hearer who go on the paths of accumulation, application and meditation of their path, but when they come to the part of meditation instead of continuing on their hearer’s path, they go on into Solitary Realizer’s path And also, of course, we have cases where hearer may go on his own part, process the part of the accumulation, process the part of application, and after that, instead of continuing, he may go on to Solitary Realizer’s path.
So within the Mayan practitioner, there are various kinds. There could be Mayan practitioner who has left or completed the Hearer’s path and has entered the Mahāyāna path. And there could be Mahāyāna practitioner who has left the Solitary Realizer’s path and has Why do you have to why do you have to enter minor part because all of them afterwards have to attain Buddhahood, understanding that that’s the only way ultimately everyone should come to.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.