TBI Recordings – 01-120930 1329

7,022 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. A question and answer session on calm abiding (shamatha). The teacher covers posture and eye focus, balancing stability and clarity, handling agitation and dullness, and short, high-quality sessions. Memory, diet, the benefit of calm abiding at death, and analytical meditation are also discussed.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 846fa2ac-58ff-4a20-ad54-3879cc698010

Words: 7,018

It’s very good of you, but it’s it’s not really necessary. Tiffany, then I’m at your disposal for your questions, which I hope will be numerous and sharp. I often get I sometimes get headaches. Mhmm. And could you Where do you get a headache?

Just here. What is your visualization? What is it? Yes. Image of the Buddha.

That’s normal. It’s because the lung gathers in the channels of the crown. Then, you have to be a little bit careful with these visualizations. If it gives a headache, you stop. Until the headache passes.

Until the headache passes. Or you could just reduce the intensity. If you have good visualization, then you just tone the intensity down a bit. You know? Because you’re visualizing at the at the level of Ajnaya Chakra.

Right? So you have to be a little bit careful not to push too much. You know? Whenever with calm abiding, whenever there are any pains, especially with the hand, it’s a good idea then to to wait until these subside. Do you have other questions?

Yes, please, David. I find that my it’s almost like my sinuses and whatever up here starts to flood. But, I mean, I get a tightness and then so it’s probably a similar thing possibly. I I couldn’t say. I mean, one of the things you have when you start meditating is you start noticing a lot of things which were there on and on, but which you haven’t been noticing.

But typically, you know, you’ve noticed that the moment you start meditating, everyone finds they have to cough. Right? So it’s it’s human. Right? And you get aches and pains.

It might be that. But if you get a headache, you know, not a pain up here that’s something else. Right? But a headache, then you should stop. You know?

Are there other questions? The Have one of the teachings I had was not to blink the eyes. Have you heard anything around that? What happens is when you engage fully into calm abiding by themselves, the or by itself, the blinking of the eyes will stop actually. It will be reduced.

But there’s no instruction in our tradition not to blink the eyes. Then when I myself started, but I practiced a bit differently. I practiced facing a white wall with eyes wide open. It’s you saw it says given this instruction in some specific circumstances. It actually makes visualization a lot easier.

But the problem is at a certain point, have to migrate from that to the traditional mode of of the traditional posture of the eyes. So it’s much better from the beginning to have them focused, not really on the tip of the nose, but in the prolongation of the tip of the nose. Like, if you have a big nose like me, it’s no problem. Right? But my wife has a very small nose, and she has a very hot.

Yes. So so what we is it that I find I go cross eyed and end up playing with vision? In the continuation, like, you you don’t have to focus actually on the tip of your nose. The reason for this posture is twofold, the eye posture. The first is you’re keeping the eyes partly open so that you get some stimuli through the light enough not to fall asleep, which is a big problem at the beginning.

But because your eyes are focused in front of you, you’re actually not seeing really anything, and that reduces distraction. It’s a balance of compromise. And do you have any other questions on the posture, etcetera? Just the mouth earlier. It’s said that we should have the lips slightly parted, but I find that I get a bit dry.

I just wonder whether whether it’s Whatever you are comfortable with. I mean, normally, the lips should be parted and the tongue should touch the palate. Now for us, it makes no big difference. But when the lips are parted, if your nose is blocked, you can still breathe. And, again, it doesn’t affect us, but someone who actually has calm abiding has no control over his body when that happens.

Right? So, if you don’t have that posture, you might actually start drooling, basically. So we don’t have calm abiding because if we had calm abiding, we would we would know it, and people who saw us would know it too. You know? Someone who has calm abiding becomes like a stone.

Yes, please. Just one and the other. Yes. I just wanna comment that some of us are too tight instead of being lazy. So some of us get quite anxious during meditation and feel like we need to grab the object.

And the analogy or the picture that we’re using refers to hooks and you know what the right word is. I’ve forgotten what the statement was. Rope. Rope. Rope.

Yes. And they’re quite kind of violent especially for someone like myself who already has that issue that needs to I need to soften up a bit around meditation. So I wondered if you could comment on that. Yes. I mean, that’s a problem.

Basically, all of the imagery is designed for a specific culture. Now Westerners in general and Asians are very different. The Tibetan let’s start first with the Indian imagery because this imagery originally comes from India. So in India, it would mean a lot. The taming of an elephant is something you do see in the daily base in India, and it’s not seen as something which is violent.

I mean, the elephant and the mahout cooperate. But as you know, the concentration charts given in Chan Buddhism use a buffalo simply because elephants were not widely used in China. Buffaloes were. Then regarding the nature of the mind, the nature of the western mind and of the Tibetan mind are quite different. Tibetans are more prone to dullness.

Then a lot of the remedies are designed to, address dullness and sinking. Tibetans are much more relaxed young Westerners. Most, I don’t say all, but most Westerners tend to be very uptight. Then if anything, the mind is a little bit too high toned, perhaps through the studies, through anxiety, something like that. Then you perhaps perhaps want to air a little bit more towards on the side of the remedies for agitation, perhaps.

And if the imagery is not helpful, the imagery itself is just an illustration. I mean, you don’t have to see vigilance like a hook. For myself, it’s not very helpful because vigilance really is more like a magnifying glass, which is observing the mind. But it just is very helpful as a metaphor for Indians and even for Tibetans. You mentioned, Billy?

Well, there’s several. I mean, the simplest one, Geshela has not talked about it. I mean, the key idea with calm abiding is to keep the mind on a mind on an even keel. Then you have your two thoughts. The mind can either be agitated or it can sink.

If it’s agitated, you bring it down. Then the simplest way to bring the mind down is to meditate on this. And you don’t have to do it in an elaborate fashion. You just as what I was taught, mean, in addition, may or may not cover this. You just visualize your body as a skeleton and that should bring the level of the mind down at once.

Alright? Then the key issue with thinking is that your mind has withdrawn too much inwards a bit dull. Then the way what you want to do is you want to elevate the mind. You elevate the mind by thinking about something which is positive. If you’re a well trained practitioner, then the precious human rebirth is an automatic means of doing it.

You just think, I have this human rebirth with which I can accomplish everything I want, the mind immediately goes up. And then to attain calm abiding, if any of you have sailed, you know exactly what I mean. You’re trying to keep the boat on an even keel. Then you’re going in a given direction. You keep having to correct a little bit to the right, a little bit to the left.

Right? And as you know so has anyone been sailing among you? Okay. I used to have my own boat. So I then as you know, you adapt the amount of sail to the weather.

Right? So if it’s very windy, you reduce the sail. If it’s not windy, then you have to put more cloth up. Right? So it’s a little bit the same thing with calmer minding.

You adapt your meditation to your mind. Your mind is quite intense. You bring the level a bit down. You’re not looking for supreme clarity from the beginning. That will harm concentration.

Your mind is a bit dull, then you bring the clarity up. And Geshe-la presented it very beautifully today in terms of the two factors. You can read Tsongkhapa’s Shamatha. It’s really the best way to understand how to practice calm abiding. The two factors of stability and clarity.

Calm abiding is a compromise between these two. You want a mind which is stable and clear, and they are to a degree incompatible. Right? If you target from the beginning extreme clarity, you make the experiment. You see the image starts wavering.

Stability is affected. If from the beginning you want rock like stability, you will find that the clarity is affected and your mind sinks a bit. You’re looking for a compromise between these two. Does that answer your question? Yes, please.

Yes, please. Ilya, I just if you could please explain. I just need a clearer clarification for take good care of the body, not push into harmful activities. Yes. That’s a very good question.

Geshe-la did not elaborate. He brought this up in the context of the development of memory. I actually wanted to talk to you about that. One of the very big problems with training the memory well are certain habits I think many Westerners have, specifically the usage of alcohol and unfortunately of drugs. If you want to improve your memory, the very best thing you can do right now is to give up drinking.

Now you will not feel the effect at once but if you give it a couple years, there will be a dramatic improvement in memory and recollection. And then obviously I would like to think that as Buddhists, none of you consumes drugs. If you did in the past, even the so called light drugs, as you now know from studies in The Lancet, you know, which have come out in the last four or five years, Cannabis, for instance, is far more toxic than was ever suspected. There are long-term psychotic effects. Then I’ve had firsthand experience teaching meditation to people who had drug usage in their background or alcohol usage in their background.

I have no experience certainly of drugs. And there are things they simply cannot do with their mind. It takes a long, long time. I know someone who used cannabis in his twenties and who is in his late thirties, he still has problems memorizing to the level, you see, which we expect. Then if you are in that category, if you’ve used them in the past, first stop using them and do purification.

Alcohol, the same thing. So those are two forms of harmful bodily behavior which we can avoid to improve memory. And when you’re speaking of calm abiding at the beginning, you’re speaking of memory. Then exercise, obviously. I mean, you you do want the brain to be oxygenated.

The mind depends on the brain. It’s a mutual relationship. Exercise helps and enough sleep. Especially at the beginning, I know from my own experience, I was engaged in heavy memorization at the period. I needed eight hours sleep.

If you start making do with six hours, definitely you can meditate. But if you’re looking for the development of recollection, I’m not quite sure that that would help. Does that answer your question a bit? Yes, please. Which way for your diet?

Yes. Whatever whatever fits you. I mean, diet’s a very personal thing. For some people, it means being vegetarian. For some people, it means eating meat.

Some people have high needs of in fat. Some people don’t. You know? Diet is a very loaded topic in the West, so I’m hesitant to go into it. I was vegetarian for many, many years, and Rinpoche strongly encouraged me to eat meat.

Whenever I speak to him, he encourages me to eat meat. And it makes a difference in terms of the practices I do, an important difference. Yes. Think personally, I think people need to actually tailor their body to the kind of food they need to, you know, that’s going to support their their meditation, their practices. So a good diet doesn’t necessarily mean vegetarian diet.

They’re a good diet. I think if we understand that every one of us are different physiologically, number one. Different in terms of their age, number two. What is good for a child or a teenager is not necessarily good for an adult. And also different in terms of their practice.

If you’re engaged in certain practices, need very high energy levels, which a vegetarian diet would not provide. On the other hand, if you are for instance focusing on, let’s say, Shamatha, and specifically, you are a beginner, you’re focusing on the restraint of desire, then a vegetarian diet is and a diet which reduces energy levels is helpful. You know? I think if one is very flexible flexible and adapts the diet to the conditions, then one’s on the good path. Like, you know, in hatha yoga, for instance, where the preliminary practices are mainly physical, then one is encouraged to have a vegetarian diet based on rice, ghee, milk, and honey.

You know? In other words, an extremely high protein high sugar and fat diet. I hope that answers your question. Well, it wasn’t really a question. I just really wanted to add diet into the mix because I think particularly with Westerners where a lot of people are really confused around diet and a lot of people are eating food that doesn’t really support doing spiritual practice.

I can tell you what really supports calm abiding. It’s celibacy. If you want to get results with visualization, you must be celibate. Celibacy is a major plus in visualization. Someone who has a very restrained lifestyle finds visualization easy, and this is why one is encouraged to have vows to engage in the practice of calm abiding.

So any excesses really impact we’re talking of using very fine capacities of the mind. Are there other questions? What and I I understand I’m asking for the definition of a word. So I understand you’re gonna come up with the exact off the top of your head. What do you mean by the limpidity?

Limpid Akeisha did not talk about that. Then, Basically, remember we talked of the two factors in mind of concentration must have perfectly to start to qualify for being calm abiding, which is stability and clarity. Now within clarity, there is an additional effector of what is called limpidity, dwang gsal. I translated duang chak as limpidity. You’d really have to experience to have some sort of experience of concentration, I think, to understand the difference.

But my impression is that clarity means that when you visualize the object, there is this is my private impression. There is a certain luminosity around the object. A tenuous luminosity. Then, limpidity means that the object is not troubled. Like, if you look at an object through assuming you have poor glasses, the object is going to appear somewhat deformed, somewhat perhaps fuzzy.

You know? Then that would be limpidity. Now according to Tsongkhapa, limpidity is a subset of clarity. If you have clarity, limpidity follows. The clarity that you’re talking about, is that the same word or description that is used to describe the nature of mind has been clear and known?

No. It’s completely the same word. It has completely different meanings. Different meanings. There’s no relation at all.

Clarity, we speak of mind being clear and cognitive, refers to the mind being clear of matter, nonmaterial. Then clarity here refers to a feature of the mind when it observes, which is that what is observed appears basically exactly as you wish it to appear and they say, you know, they say there’s a little bit of luminosity. Right? They say. Some translations, I’m thinking of the the people who translated.

Did I say that wrong? Yeah. That’s my old friend, Elio, my first teacher in Tibetan. So they talk about radiant awareness. And then Alexander Berson You are different.

You cannot compare pears and apples. So within functions in the Nima tradition, then you’re talking of the Doctrine understanding of the mind. It’s a different mental universe. Okay. So then go to that.

No relationship. Then is very good translator, but he has his own system of translation. Yes. And I I can’t account for it. Don’t mix things up.

Like, within the blockchain, you have a totally different viewpoint. This is something completely different. You’re using different levels of mind, Whether it’s legitimate or not, there is a fair bit of discussion. What types of are legitimate? There’s a fair bit of discussion.

There’s something else. Could you recommend within the Gulupa Mahamija Sangeetha tradition something in English that would help to clarify this meaning of stability and clarity? You will not get better than Tsongkhapa’s. There’s no point in looking elsewhere. Sure.

Everything else is a commentary on that. Then it is rather nicely translated in English apart from using the term serenity for calm abiding, which was a dogmatic decision because the team was trying to break off as Jeffrey Hopkins. That’s that’s the only reason they did it. I think once you know the meaning of the word, the word doesn’t matter. It’s only when you so I try and understand what the translator meant when they say that word rather than looking at a dictionary because dictionaries are really different.

Serenity is a very poor translation because it feeds into certain misunderstandings about calm abiding. That calm abiding is a way to be happy and peaceful, which it is just not part of the goal. Calm abiding is a a level in concentration. Then when you say to someone, he’s serene, it’s written in English, I think, you’re saying something about his his emotional state. This is a serene person.

That’s not what calm abiding is about. Yes, please. There were talk on yesterday about the teaching that you described as being like a stone. Mhmm. Was practicing calm abiding.

What level? We were wondering what level of the nine levels was that? Well, he had a tie attained calm abiding, which means he had what is calm abiding? Calm abiding means that you have attained the ninth level, and after that you have had both physical and mental pliancy which are basically blissful experiences due to the serviceability of the wings. When if you have attained the ninth level, but you have not obtained the pliancies, and the term pliancies is a bit unfortunate, it really Xinjiang in Tibetan means serviceability.

It means that when you say speak of physical pliancy, your body can be put to any virtuous purpose you wish. And when you speak of mental pliancy, your mind can be put to any virtuous purpose you wish. There’s no obstruction from the side of the body of the mind. He can obtain both of those. You know?

Then he can obtain direct experience of emptiness in addition. So, Eli, just going back to radiance, seeing the light, the luminosity of the Buddha is not contrary to stability of the object, or is it? Well, the extreme luminosity, extreme clarity it’s better to speak of clarity. Extreme clarity poses problems from the standpoint of stability. Extreme stability poses problems from the standpoint of clarity.

You’re looking at a conjunction of both. It’s a middle way. You know? That’s why at the beginning, the temptation is to go for extreme clarity. That harms stability.

You can see that for yourselves. I encourage you to to to experiment. If you try to get extreme clarity of the object of meditation, eventually, it can become so unstable, you can actually sense a wavering. You could even see a tilting of the object. You know?

That means in a nutshell, your mind is too tight because clarity comes with tightness. Right? It’s been saying. Let let let me to tighten your fist. Stability on the other hand comes with the withdrawnness of the mind inside.

Now what you want is a mind which is sufficiently withdrawn inside for the object to be stable, but not so withdrawn that you fall asleep. If you withdraw the mind completely, it’s not your sleep. So it’s a middle way. Does that answer your question? Two questions.

First a practical one. If you don’t fear or you don’t have a concern of falling asleep, is it okay to keep your eyes closed during meditation? If you don’t fall asleep If you don’t have a concern about falling asleep or you’re not feeling like you’re going to fall asleep, is it alright to close your eyes? Just drink. At the beginning it makes it easier.

The problem is always the same. Whatever you become accustomed to, you could want to continue. Then as you progress, having your eyes closed creates problems. Therefore, it’s probably better from the beginning to adopt the full eightfold posture. At the beginning, it’s much easier to visualize with your eyes closed.

It’s clear. If it’s really an issue, I would suggest facing a white wall. That works really well. Or a blank wall. Following on from yesterday and understanding how carbon binding fits into our practice.

My understanding of how we should take these teachings is that calm abiding provides the concentration we need to add depth to our visualisations in the Seven Limb Prayer and also the concentration needed for study. That how we should proceed to understand these teachings? To a degree, there’s much more to calm abiding. Calm abiding amounts to sharpening the knife with which you’re gonna cut the roast. Once the knife is sharp, you can cut not only roasts, but apples, pears or even wood.

So our minds right now are not serviceable. Now when we meditate, we lose the object of meditation. It’s either too clear or this sickness which arises, we fall asleep. Calm abiding gives us the mental tool to then meditate on anything. Once we have calm abiding, we can meditate on a visualized representation of the Buddha to perform the seven limb offering, but we can meditate also on emptiness, we can meditate on impermanence, we can engage in tantric meditations.

For that matter, once you have calm abiding, you have the paranormal powers just like that. So it is it means that your mind has become powerful and stable. Eliot, you mentioned five aspects of the you had the main mind and then five other aspects. Mhmm. And then you mentioned, I heard, concentration, recollection, and vigilance.

What are the other two? Consulate concentration, recollection, vigilance, aspiration, and belief. And I made a mistake mistake in translation. The Tibetan word for observation and belief is almost identical. So in that context, whenever I said observation, you replace it by belief.

It’s migpa and mobpa. These are the five factors of ascertainment. Normally it is said that if one is present, more five are present. They do but it’s irrelevant. Yes, please.

Just If following on from that, you have one, you have all five. So will different people have different propensities towards one or or another of those? Well, this is it’s it’s really a point in in Buddhist epistemology. If you have one, you have all five, but not all five are manifest. So then these are really points of debate, you know.

But it is true that you see, to ascertain an object, to engage an object, in other words, you need to wish to do so. You need wishing. You need some sort of commitment to the object, that’s belief. If the object has been seen before without recollection, you can’t ascertain it, so you need recollection. If the mind does not stay on the object, then you cannot ascertain it, so you do need vigilance.

And you need a modicum of concentration, but you can have these in very small amounts. You just need enough to link with the object. However, within the practice of calm abiding, of these five mental factors, there are three which we train to the highest degree we can and that is concentration first, which we all have to a degree. Otherwise, we couldn’t live. Right?

Then recollection or memory. I’ve really emphasized the fact in the translation this time that the Tibetan term can be translated as memory. Because when you say recollection, it sounds like something far out. It’s just ordinary memory. The stronger your memory, the better you’ll be in training as a meditator.

I mean, this is why in the Buddhist tradition, the sign of someone who has accomplishments is total recall. And finally, vigilance, you know, which is the final factor we train. Do we have other questions? Mhmm. After the question you posed to us yesterday, being what was our purpose for for coming, actually coming to these teachings, actually thought more about it throughout the day and and and during the evening last night.

Sort of dawned on me that I guess the ultimate reason is because at the time of my death, the only thing that’s of any use to me is is dharma in my state of mind. And I wondered if you could touch on how these practices will benefit us at at that time, the moment Well, of as Kishina explained, if you have calm abiding, you can enter the death process with a clear visualization of something which is of benefit, whatever you choose. Now for most of us, the death process is a process where we lose completely control physically, obviously, because we are losing this body, but mentally and emotionally. Then the person is overwhelmed with fear, with anxiety, often as a result of this anger arises. And then this anger causes the maturation of non virtuous karmic imprints which we all have in very large amounts.

And then even if one has actually led a very good life and has tried to be a dharma practitioner, a practitioner of any great religion, then the odds of having a lower rebirth are quite high. So if one can stabilize the mind in the death process, that is the best thing we can hope for as beginners. And then if we have calm abiding, it is certain we can do so. And we can stabilize it on what we want. On a Buddha’s image, on the recollection of our teacher, which will appear continuously within our mind as we are entering the death process.

Fear cannot arise. Right? We have single pointed focus. It’s an extraordinary tool. Does that answer your question?

In your opinion, states of concentration or visualization and the mind is it of any benefit to study what Western science says about the different brain waves that are generated or is it you know, is it are they, in your opinion, probably incorrect? Correct. They are. But, I mean, you’re using an axe to repair a watch. I mean, it’s extraordinarily coarse approach.

I mean, all you are doing is measuring basically the activity of the cortex. Then there are some there’s some research done by professor Davison from the University of Wisconsin Madison. This is very interesting. What he did is much more subtle than that and that’s what’s interesting. He used what’s known as functional magnetic resonance imaging to study the parts of the brain which are activated in various states of meditation.

Now it remains very coarse because you get some beautiful looking diagram showing that for instance when you meditate on compassion, the insula which is the part of the brain which is, it seems, intimately connected not only with the viscera but with empathy is activated. So this seems to prove the operativeness of meditation and compassion. But the problem improve that I’m looking to enhance my understanding because my understanding of, you know, Tom Harper’s is extremely coarse. So If you’re looking at it as a practitioner, I think it’s useless. If you’re looking at it as someone who isn’t quite sure that this works or not, then it’s extremely useful.

But it’s too coarse. Davidson does not distinguish between calm abiding and mindfulness. And you can’t put all meditative techniques in one package and to just make brain scans and try to figure what’s happening. Are there other questions? Then if you don’t have questions, I have questions for you.

Oh, okay. When you’re talking about migrating from a white wall in front of you to not having that, is the same sort of issue does the same sort of issue come up when you, for instance, took two weeks to do to to be in a place where there was no sound and no outside, you know, impacts? And then coming back and to continue your practice and then finding that there are things that you just can’t get rid of in your normal daily life. I think the benefit of the calm abiding teachings for us is to be able to develop a little bit of concentration. Like, reach the second, maybe the third, maybe even the fourth level.

Second or third is a lot. But realistically, we can’t develop them with our lives. We can’t reach the ninth level and develop the two pliancies with the lives we lead. Then if you really want to develop calm abiding, what you’d have to do is sell everything you own, become a monk, enter into retreat after receiving these instructions, and stay there indefinitely until you you attain the goal. This is how it’s done.

Now it will it said it will take six months, but obviously, it will take a lot more than that for most of us. You just stay until you get there. That’s not the goal of most of the most of us in this room. So what you can what happens in two weeks of retreat, as Geshe-la said, is your mind will settle down. You can certainly reach the first, second level where forgetting the object of observation is the biggest problem, then your mind becomes more accustomed to connecting with the object of observation.

You connect again and again, then you can progress up to the third level. It’s difficult to go beyond that. Then when you come back, the main goal is not to lose what you what you obtained, but you have obtained better concentration. That’s enough. Then my private opinion is that analytical meditation for most of us is much more beneficial than calm abiding.

This is my private opinion, don’t repeat this. It’s just I’m telling you my own opinion because it transforms the mind much faster. If you engage in analytical meditation on death and impermanence, within one session your mind is changed. Then calm abiding is not available for those of us who lead normal lives in the West, but increasing concentration is. That’s a worthwhile goal.

My personal opinion is if you have to choose, I would choose personally analytical meditation every time. Because really that is of benefit. You reap the results at once. The reason we take a statue of the Buddha as object in this practice of calm abiding is just that the time spent not be wasted if you don’t achieve anything. Most people who meditate or who train calm abiding don’t achieve it.

It’s just it is nowadays not easy to achieve. And then as Saffo was mentioning this morning, what helped her most was giving up television. And that’s something I would suggest to all of us. I mean, you start following the path of calm abiding, the goal is to reduce sensory dependency. The more you can give up, not just television but the Internet and this is going to be very hard for all of you but the crowds as well.

Right? The more you can do that, the better. Right? Because otherwise, you have powerful emotions involved, you know. And then some type of vows and a good lifestyle.

In other words, if you you really have to abstain from alcohol, then obviously drugs, it’s a it’s a given in our tradition And a regular life. And then one can start moving up in concentration. You know? Does that begin to answer your question? It seems, Elia, that just the practice of settling the mind, you know, prior to study or or anything, all that is is very beneficial.

And I mean, guess that’s a form of concentration, you know, the five minutes at the beginning, as Geshela was saying, seems to be a very good, you know, kick off because otherwise to try and do any form of meditation, for me anyway, with the busyness of everything, it’s sort of almost like trying to chop wood with a piece of celery. Very much. Very much. Each one of us has different levels of concentration, you see. You know for yourselves.

If you are able to study what is blaring music and people are coming in and out of the room, it’s a sign that naturally you have good concentration. And that’s a good sign. You might be starting at the second or even the third level. That’s due to past predispositions. Good mathematicians, for instance, can be so absorbed in the resolution of your mathematical problem they become absent.

You know, Socrates the the Greek philosopher had periods of absence when he was concentrating on the philosophical problem and he was absent to the world. You could pinch him, push him. There’s a reaction. It was something that close to calm abiding. I suspect he probably had something close to calm abiding.

You know? So therefore, if one is beginning to increase one’s concentration taking Geshela’s advice about starting slowly and five minutes and with as little outside. But increasing concentration is a good thing then how might I’m just wondering about how that might relate to if one is practising on a bus for example in terms of Don’t. Yeah. I mean, because if if you have to, you have to, but obviously it’s very difficult to practice well, isn’t it?

It’s better to get up a little bit earlier and do it at home and to try to do what one does well. So with calm abiding, we have a different outlook. We’re looking at quality. We’re looking at short sessions, top quality sessions. When there are big interferences, you just stop.

These are the instructions I received. And also how can I support other people’s concentration levels before, during, and after teachings come? That’s very important. You ask some good questions. If one harms other people’s concentration, one creates the karma for one’s own concentration being harmed.

Therefore one should never interrupt someone who meditates. And the biggest thorn for meditation is noise. The best thing you can do to create good karma for calm abiding is to be quiet around people who meditate. You see in India, people are very aware of this. Very aware.

Mark, you wanted to ask something? I was gonna ask about the the white wall with the eyes open. Whenever I try to meditate with my eyes open I blink and I find that an unwelcome distraction. Obviously I have to blink to keep my eyes open. I don’t know, any advice around that or I don’t really know how to overcome that distraction.

Blinking is natural. I wouldn’t focus too much on it. Clearly every time you blink there is a degree of conceptual activity. If you look at the neurology of the process, when you blink the stream of the eye consciousness is momentarily interrupted. We actually know that the apparent continuous stream of visual data which is coming into us is basically construction of the visual cortex because the stream of data coming into us is consistently interrupted and as you probably know, our eyeballs are roving consistently.

Right? So I mean I have never read anything about this in the context of calm abiding but there’s a lot of evidence that people who have attained calm abiding do not blink. Then when they meditate obviously, then you just put that aside. Don’t try to force yourself not to blink and forget what I said about the whiteboard. It doesn’t apply to most people.

It’s just better from the beginning to stick to the eight full posture of Vairochala which works very well. And then basically, you should leave your body alone. Your goal is the clarity of that image in front of you. It should be neither too small nor too great. Then that depends on the person, basically one or two thumbs, you know.

If it’s too small, you have great clarity, but that fosters agitation. If it’s too big, you will have stability at the expense of clarity. So one thumb, anything between 60 centimeters and one meter, 60 centimeters seems to be good for most people. Then you are seeing it with the mind’s eye. In other words, your eyes are focused in the prolongation of your nose and you actually see it here.

If nothing appears, as Geshela says, then you look at an object. In this case, a small statue of the Buddha, try to recollect the object and make it appear. If on the other hand you are working with a purely visualized object, that at the beginning you basically scan it vertically from the crown to the lotus on which it seats and back upwards trying to cause the features to appear. When something appears and here we’re talking of an outline, you stop the scanning, that’s enough to work with. You don’t aim for perfect clarity.

Now if you are very familiar with these images or if you have strong predispositions, it is possible at the beginning for a perfectly clear image to appear, then you are very lucky. Then you just keep it there without meddling too much and with a small portion of your mind, this is what we we refer to as vigilance, keep checking but not too much. The thing is to be skillful in this matter because too much checking harms concentration. You keep checking, am I drifting away? Typically, you will find if you if you are lucky enough to have a clear image at the beginning, that you get thirty seconds, a minute where it will remain stable and then through fatigue, the mind starts going off.

The longer the session, the more the mind drifts. Once you start losing regularly object, I mean this is what is meant by forgetfulness, you actually lost the object. You were visualizing the object here and then you’re at central market, then you’ve lost it. Then it’s time to stop. If you’re training in calm abiding, then the oral instructions I have heard emphasize the fact that the shorter the session the better.

You’re looking at sessions of five minutes and your your goal is top quality sessions. I’m assuming that a photo of a statue is equivalent to a thangka. That would be Same thing. Okay. Same thing.

Same thing. Then I think we we are at 02:15, so I had one question for you I’d like to ask you. And then maybe you can think over it quietly and share what you think about it tomorrow. Tsongkhapa says that there are four features of calm abiding. Non conceptuality, bliss, clarity, and stability.

Non conceptuality, bliss, clarity, and stability. Non conceptuality does not mean non conceptuality in the sense of the absence of a conceptual image. You meditating on a conceptual image. It means the absence of other thoughts. Now if you actually study the description of the great mystical experiences in Christianity, Islam, and Hinduism, you will find that non conceptuality, clarity, bliss, and a form of stability is their common denominator and in all these traditions this is referred to as the experience of God.

So my question for you is could it be that in these traditions we had practitioners who attained calm abiding or even a higher level of concentration and there was no framework to interpret it within their tradition. So they read it in terms of their extant theological framework. That’s my question for you. And if you have time, Google it, check what William James says about mystical experiences because it’s quite interesting and it’s one of the main doors of dialogue between Buddhism and some of the traditions, which is Eastern Orthodox tradition, which have highly developed techniques for inducing what is known as ecstasy. Also has a Hesychasm, precisely.

Well, I’m not saying they practice calm abiding, but they get something. They attain states whose description is the same as our description of Samādhi’s. Then my question for you is, is it the same thing or not? Personally, I think it is. And then that makes a lot of things very interesting.

So we have to stop here for today. Think about it a bit. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What does it mean to take good care of the body and avoid harmful activities, in relation to developing memory?

The point was raised in the context of developing memory. Alcohol and drugs are big obstacles to training the memory. The best thing to do to improve memory is to give up drinking, though the effect shows only after a couple of years. Even so-called light drugs such as cannabis are more toxic than once suspected, with long-term psychotic effects. People with drug or alcohol backgrounds find there are things they cannot do with their mind, and it takes a long time. Anyone who used them in the past should stop and do purification. Exercise also helps, since the brain needs oxygen and the mind depends on the brain.

Scroll to Top