TBI Recordings – 01-120408 1512-01

8,161 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. Explains the twelve links as they operate for one sentient being over two or three lives, distinguishing the general causal presentation from the actual sequence. Karmic imprints are activated by craving and appropriation at death, so the mind at death is critical. The talk then covers purification versus prevention strategies, and the Q&A addresses ritual for the dying and the practice of phowa.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: ee45a90a-60ee-485b-b253-ae39bc692bbb

Words: 8,157

So thank you all for coming to the question and answer session. Then because of the difficulty of the topic we covered today, I thought I would recover it with you in a more formal fashion on the whiteboard and then I would take your questions, on it and on the topics covered during the last three days. So the main problem with the 12 links is how to posit them for one individual sentient being. The presentation of the 12 links which you have on page two of Asaṇga’s Abhidharma Samuccaya, the 12 links ranging from ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness, name and form, all the way to birth, to aging and death, is a general presentation of the 12 links for sentient beings in general. It postulates a general causal relationship between the various 12 links.

It is not the actual sequence in which the causes and effects of the 12 links follow each other for one given sentient being. Then there has been a lot of debate in the Buddhist tradition on what this actual relationship is. And that’s we are going to cover together. I don’t have my little laser pointer, so we will do this in a more archaic fashion. But basically, this is the traditional sequence of the 12 links.

Ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness, name and form, the six spheres, contact, sensation, craving, appropriation, existence, birth, aging and death. Now, you have 12 links. They are actually subdivided in two broad categories. Six of the 12 links are causes and six are effects. The six links which are causes are the three first links ignorance compositional factors and consciousness.

I put this in red And the four links from link eight, excuse me, eight, yes, the three links from links eight to 10, craving, appropriation and existence. These two are causes. Then you have in addition to the six causes, six effects, which are the four links of name and form, the six spheres, contact and sensation and the two final links of birth, aging and death. So far so good. Six causes are the cause of the six effects.

Okay? So these six causes here are the cause of these six effects. Therefore, for one given being, what is the sequence you have of the links? You have for one given being in one cycle of the 12 links, ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness, which are the three first causes followed by the three remaining causes which are craving, appropriation and existence. These follow each other causally for one being.

Then these give rise to the six effects. The six effects are in sequence name and form, the six spheres, contact, sensation followed by birth and aging. This is the actual sequence of the 12 links for one person, then I haven’t had time to write it down, but if I were to put a new numeration here, it would be one, two, three, then four, five, six, then seven, eight, 910, and then eleven and twelve. So far so good. Okay?

Now, the causes themselves are six, six fold as we say. Limbs one, two and three and limbs eight, nine and ten. They are subdivided into two, impelling limbs and actualizing limbs. These are both causes. What is the difference between them?

The impelling limb impels an existence. It defines a general feature of an existence. For instance, the impelling limbs might impel a human rebirth with nothing more said about it. The actualizing limbs actually provide the fleshing out of this human rebirth. We likewise have six results, the impelled limbs and the actualized limbs, four and two.

The impelled limb is the actual body. Name and form is the actual body in the room and the question is a bit where it stops as Geshe-la says. So that’s name and form, the six spheres contact sensation, and the actualized limb is that life from birth until death. So for one given person in one cycle of the 12 links, this in red is a sequence of development, not the sequence in blue. The sequence in blue is a general sequence of the causal relations of the 12 links in the abstract.

In other words, to repeat myself, for one given being the sequence of the 12 limbs is first ignorance, then compositional factors and then consciousness, the three first causes, impelling causes, followed by the actualizing causes of craving, appropriation and existence and then the causes are complete. At this point you start having the results which are name and form, the six spheres, contact and sensation and birth, aging and death. So what actually happened in the 12 links is that Buddha Śākyamūni taught with the sequence of the 12 links the development of a given karma over a minimum of two lives and that’s why we have to break it down in this way. As Geshele explained today, it’s a minimum of two lives and a maximum of three lives. Now, If we look carefully here, you will see that some of the limbs overlap.

For instance, if you take the limb of name and form, This limb ranges from conception until the time when the six sense organs are present. This limb actually overlaps with the limb of birth. Likewise, you can clearly see just in general here that, there is overlapping between other limbs such as contact sensation, craving or appropriation and aging and death which is a totality of a life. But when posited for one being in one series of the 12 links, this is your sequence. Now this sequence can occur normally in three lives but sometimes in two lives.

If it occurs in three lives, during the first life, the first three causes are accumulated, right? Ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness. That’s during the first three lives. Then during the second life, the following set of causes, the actualizing limbs are accumulated. These are craving appropriation existence and it is during the third life that both the impelled limbs and the actualized limbs are accumulated.

So during the third life, you accumulate six limbs, name and form, the six spheres, contact sensation, birth, aging and death. I do miss my laser pointer. So if we apply this let us say to myself, what led to my present human rebirth? If I assume this happened over three different lives, three lives ago and this could be these are lives which can be separated between each other by an infinite amount of lives. These are not subsequent lives with one exception we will talk about a bit later.

But if I put it on the board, let us say, to settle ideas, we will call one life 50, another life 120 and the following one life a 121. During life 50, under the power of ignorance, since I’m reborn as a human being and this is a virtuous, a happy rebirth, I accumulated the virtuous karma of ethics, abstaining from at least one of the 10 non virtues and this was implanted in my consciousness. So the consciousness here is what is known as the causal consciousness. This occurred during life 50. Then during life life 50, this karmic imprint was set in my mental continuum.

Then during life 120, the second group of the 12 limbs was accumulated. During that life, sometime before I died, craving, appropriation and existence were accumulated. In other words, in the death process, I was on my deathbed and craving arose, this craving would be a wish for a higher rebirth. This craving became more powerful and as it became more powerful, it reached the point where it could trigger this karmic imprint and became appropriation. At that point, it was able to trigger that next rebirth and the triggering of that next rebirth begins with existence which is actually the triggering of that karmic imprint.

Existence here refers to the death process. It’s a case of causing of calling the cause by the result. The result will be the next birth but the cause is called by the name of what it generates. So in that second life, life 120, under the power of craving appropriation and appropriation, this karmic imprint was activated and became the substantial cause for my next existence. My next existence which is life 121 necessarily follows immediately life 120.

There cannot be a gap between the two. It’s obviously the intermediate state but we don’t talk about it. But you cannot have a scenario where you have life fifty, one twenty and one thirty. It’s not possible. Why?

Because the limbs, the actualizing limbs here trigger immediately the maturation of this karmic imprint. When that is triggered, six impelled limbs are activated in life 121. It is name and form, which is my embryo until the sense spheres are functional. Then the six sense spheres which is the appearance of the five physical sensors and the mental potency. Then contact which occurs when these can connect with the object and sensation which occurs when I can differentiate between the pleasant, the unpleasant and the neutral.

And then at that point I am born and aging and death begin. As we mentioned, there is overlap between the limb of birth and certainly these two limbs, maybe even these three limbs. That is open to debate, you know. Certainly these two limbs. I’m really sorry.

As I said, no laser pointer. I am opaque unfortunately. I’ll work on that. I promise. So if I stand here, it should be okay.

So what you see therefore is that there is overlap between the birth, limb of birth and two or three maybe even four of these limbs. The question is what can the embryo experience? Can the embryo have some sort of central experience? If that is the case, these two limbs are fulfilled. It seems to be the case.

Does the embryo have the experience of the pleasant and the unpleasant? If that is the case, this limb is fulfilled. So this would be how the 12 links would be postulated over three lives. Then over two lives, it is much simpler. You have the six limbs of the cause over one life and necessarily in the immediately following life the six limbs of the effect.

Is that pretty clear? Do you have any questions on this? Can you can anyone answer Judy’s questions? Pretty it’s pretty evident. Yes.

That’s exactly it. There can be no gap, of more or there can be no gap of one life between the limb of existence, the tenth limb and the eleventh limb. The limb of existence means that the karmic imprint deposited in the second limb of compositional factors is fully activated and operating. So as I died in life 01/20, my human rebirth was guaranteed. It’s a given.

There can be no longer any gap. This is the reason for which the thoughts of the dying person are critical. What you have here is an explanation of the 12 links rooted on or rooted in karma and in klesha. This is karma of which we have infinite karmic imprints in our minds. This is the klesha which in these two forms craving and especially appropriation activates the karma.

Existence is the activated second link, second limb. Does this make sense? Okay. It’s set in life 50 and it will stay until life 2500. Until whenever.

It will stay until appropriation the ninth limb is present. Now craving is a preliminary to appropriation. Craving is actually desire. Craving and appropriation occur before death and they activate this impelling karma. So we have an infinite amount of impelling, karmas in our mind.

We don’t know what we have. We have little or no control. We do have control over the generation of craving and appropriation. This is where the effort has to bear. So if you look at the Tibetan traditions, there are some who take this on on board and some who seem not to take it on board.

Because when you have karma and klesha, you have two strategies. You can focus on the purification of karma. You’re working in that case here. You have an infinite number of these. Or you can focus on preventing this from happening.

You can focus on preventing the klesha from triggering the karma. Those are your two strategies. Now if you practice for instance Vajra Sattva meditation, you’re focusing on purifying the karmic imprints. If, however, you take vows and you practice meditation, for instance, on death and impermanence, you are focusing on preventing this from happening. This is a much more robust strategy, much more robust and both are necessary obviously.

Both are necessary but purifying all the karmic imprints is a gigantic process and the arhat, the ārya beings, they don’t go through all of this. The ārya beings still have negative karma within their mind stream but they have no afflictions, therefore this triggering process never happens. In the case of the 12 links, the ārya beings reach this point. They reach sensation, they experience pleasant, unpleasant and neutral experience but craving and appropriation which are afflictions never arise within their minds therefore these compositional factors never trigger a rebirth. Then they only come back by choice.

Do you have any questions about what we covered today or this topic? What the key and I if you don’t have any, I’d like to read you a passage I took from Nāgārjuna’s Bodhichitta Vivarana and heartily encourage you to reread Khensur Rinpoche’s commentary on it. This wheel of the 12 links circles on the road of existence. Apart from that, there is not a single sentient being who experiences action. This is the Buddhist vision of sentient beings.

This is all there is. Now this is just one chain of interdependence covering lives fifty, one twenty, one twenty one. If you were to imagine how a human existence or the existence of any being would look, what you would have would be this. Let us say, as we said, fifty, one twenty, one twenty one. That’s one such chain.

Then we would have a second chain of 12 links, 51, 52. Then we would have a third group of 12 links, Fifty fifty three, sixty, sixty one, etcetera, etcetera, etc. In other words, we have groups of 12 links comprising two or three lives which are interwoven like a chain. Apart from that there is nothing. There is no soul which is the experience of the experience.

There is no truly existing self. There are just these 12 links which include all five aggregates which are in this case contaminated. Yes, Richard. Well, such a life, life 01/2021 let’s say we take my life as a basis is a human rebirth which means there is an upper and a lower boundary to suffering which is defined by the human constitution. Now if you view it this way, whatever suffering is experienced in this human rebirth cannot go above or below that bracket.

What happens between that bracket in turn depends on how do we call it already completing karma. Now that completing karma may have been accumulated in life 50, it may have been accumulated in other lives. So the chain becomes incredibly complex. In this life as a human, depending on the range of suffering, one has a greater or lesser latitude of action. If one has a very high level of suffering, normally one’s freedom of action is restricted.

If one has a lower level of suffering, one’s freedom of action is greater and one can perhaps accumulate some virtuous karma which then becomes part of a new set of 12 links ranging over two or three lives. Yes, Lemmy. No, no. This is a process of maturation of one single karmic imprint, compositional factors which can, but there’s some debate about this one, be fleshed out by the thoughts which arise in the context of appropriation. But it is one single karmic imprint which matures because the main topic here is how the impelling limb leads to the actualized limb.

That’s the main topic. No. No. Completing karma would not instigate an entire cycle of 12 links because it basically is merely fleshing out a life. It’s putting in the details.

So it’s positioning you on the bracket. Let’s say for instance, you have the impelling karma of being reborn as a human being but unfortunately, you’re completing karma is, let us say, that you are supposed to be reborn in Afghanistan, you know. Then you are reborn as a human being. There’s a bracket of suffering, but you are rather on the higher end of the bracket, you know. Does that answer your question?

Yes. So one coming day, you can produce a number of different types of There’s there’s a big debate about that. Asaṇga and Vasubandu have different positions and I remember I don’t remember exactly whose position is which. I think Asaṇga asserts that one karmic deed can produce several results and Vasubandhu does not, then it’s open to debate. Do we have other questions on this topic?

That’s exactly how it is. That’s exactly how it is. Yes, please. Well, it’s set within boundaries. Let’s say beyond a certain level of suffering a human being dies.

I mean if you torture someone past a certain level they die of heart failure. Right? So there’s a boundary which is tied into our constitution. My uncle was tortured to death, know. It took three days.

Then he was leading, he was second in charge of the royalist insurrection in Yugoslavia, the communists captured him. Then they they wanted him to confess, you know, they had very good people work on him, people who knew what they were doing. Then they never allowed him to faint, you know. They never allowed him to faint. But there’s a limit to what the human body can take.

Now in other existences, this is not the case. In the hell realms, for instance, there is basically in function of the hell realms, a higher and higher limit to the amount of suffering. In the lowest of the hell realms, the limit is almost infinite. Does that make sense to you? It is but it makes sense, doesn’t it?

I mean if the mind is a phenomenon which is non material and which can be infinitely better and experience infinite bliss, there’s no reason that the counterpart shouldn’t be true and that it couldn’t couldn’t become infinitely base and experience infinite suffering. Do you have other questions? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

So the encounters are the field of completing karma. Definitely. Your encounters, your marriages, your divorces, your children, your wealth, your disease, professional success or failure that is all completing karma. The thing to keep in mind is that basically life one twenty one is spoken for. A life one twenty one, let’s say I’m living life one twenty one at present as a human being, my lifespan is spoken for.

My maximum lifespan is given. I don’t know what it is, but there is a maximum. Then I can reduce it actually. If due to completing karma from other, karmic backgrounds, I for instance smoke, drink, whatever behave foolishly, then my maximum lifespan will shrink. But I cannot normally expand my maximum lifespan beyond the maximum for life one twenty one.

This life is spoken for. Life is spoken for. The only sign that we are practicing well is that at the end, we’re going back one life, in my case at the end of life 120, whoever it was in life 01/2020 probably was a good practitioner because he must, he or she must have had positive appropriation. Appropriation can be positive or negative. It is still contaminated because it’s affected by the ignorance which apprehends the person as inherently existing, but imagine for instance, let’s say a bodhisattva takes the vow to lead all sentient beings to full enlightenment, but has not realized emptiness.

Such a bodhisattva would generate appropriation. Then once he has realized, he or she has realized emptiness, then he cannot generate craving or appropriation anymore. You know? And he is he or she is in control of the rebirth process. So this is how it works.

Yes. And that’s a difficult topic. Basically, you can say, I haven’t looked into this so I have to do it on the spot. Then ignorance, craving and appropriation are afflictions. So they they clearly fall into the realm of the second noble truth.

Compositional factors and existence are karma. They also form in the realm form in the realm of the second noble truth. There’s a little bit of a debate in it regarding existence. Whether you view existence as karma or that actually existence of the death process, but normally these five limbs fall in the category of the second noble truth. Then consciousness is infused by the compositional factors.

So consciousness can be seen as part of the second noble truth or as part of the first noble truth. There is a doubt regarding consciousness and then apart from consciousness, Name and form, the six spheres contact and sensation are the first noble truths of suffering and birth, aging and death are obviously the first noble truth. Then here we are talking of what is known as a thoroughly afflicted sequence of 12 limbs. It’s a sequence of 12 limbs with no hope, in other words. There is neither the third noble truth of cessation nor the fourth noble truth of the path.

This is the 12 links of hopelessness. We were reborn from affliction into suffering, into more affliction and karma into more suffering. This can only be reverted by actually blocking ignorance. When you block ignorance, you eliminate ignorance as Geshela explained. For instance, you’re meditating on the subtle selflessness of persons, you prevent compositional factors from arising.

In other words, you prevent karma from arising. If you prevent karma from arising, then the consciousness infused with the karma will not arise. If that does not arise, then craving, appropriation and existence do not arise. If they do not arise, then name and form of the six spheres, contact, sensation, birth and death do not arise. Consciousness Consciousness and existence are debatable because they have a bit of both.

The first noble truth is noble truth of suffering. So you have the three categories of suffering. The second noble truth is the origin of suffering. Then here you have a consciousness, it’s not consciousness in general we’re talking about here. It’s consciousness as the bearer of karma.

Then is consciousness as the bearer of karma? Suffering or the origin of suffering? The two are not incompatible, no? An affliction is part of the second noble truth, it is also the noble truth, first noble truth. Anger is part of the second noble truth, but it is also the truth of suffering.

In general, however, anger is always put in the second noble truth. Then existence. Existence is this karma once it has been potentiated by appropriation. It’s just before my my own case, as you’re taking this as an example, just before my own death and life one twenty. Now this is potentiated.

This life is already guaranteed. There is nothing once this is potentiated which can prevent this from happening. This is the reason in Buddhist terms for which we say that prayers are useless. Because once limb 10 has been potentiated, then there can be no gap between limb 10 and limb 11. Until limb 10 is potentiated, it is possible to help the person.

So you can direct limb nine in the death process. You can direct appropriation. If for instance, and this is what Geshela was saying, when someone is dying, as long as their ear consciousness, their eye consciousness are functional, when we speak of appropriation, we speak of wishes, powerful wishes. It’s not just an ordinary wish. You can turn that limb of appropriation in a positive direction.

Then the tenth limb which arise arises will be a positive one. Otherwise, no. Yes. Well, I have to give you a bit of the background about the Tibetan Book of the Dead, which is very famous in the West and totally unknown in Tibet. The Tibetan Book of the Dead is very famous in the West in the West because of a historical coincidence.

It is the text which Evans Wentz who translated it and who was one of the early Tibetanists in the nineteen twenties and thirties, it is the text he had in hand. He translated it, then Carl Jung relied very heavily on it, seeing in it premises of all of the later developments in Jungian psychology and it became a representative of the Tibetan understanding of the death process. The Tibetan Book of the Dead is actually a manual which was composed probably in lay circles in the Nyingma tradition. In lay circles in the Nyingma tradition, it’s not accepted as authoritative by any of the other traditions. In the Geluk tradition this type of manual actually is very strongly frowned upon because the goal of the manual is perhaps I have to enter into some details here.

That component of the Tibetan Book of the Dead, which is recited to the ear of the dying person while they are still conscious is of benefit. That is clear. Then the recitation continues once a person is no longer conscious. At this point and until the person enters the Bardo, they cannot perceive anything. There are stages in particular in the death process where no thought, no perception of any type is possible.

Once the Bardo starts, the being of the intermediate state has a full set of clairvoyances. Then any religious ritual which is performed within the room of the dying person will be perceived by this person. The problem is, is that of benefit or not? Now based on the teachings on the 12 links, there is very limited benefit. Generally speaking, the position which is maintained I think by all of the scholars I have met is that all the rituals which are performed in the room of the dying person after they are dead can accomplish is modify the completing karma.

They cannot affect the impelling karma. So if that person for instance generated a limb of existence for rebirth, let us say as my Westie Bobby, then the only difference those rituals will do is that Bobby will be reborn in a very loving family. But his rebirth as a dog is unfortunately no longer something which can be changed. That’s the first part. Then the second part of your question regarding the Tibetan Book of the Dead.

The position of the Tibetan Book of the Dead is a position you find in some of the Nyingma schools, which is that mere experience of the mind of clear light is sufficient to lead to enlightenment. This position is excluded completely by all of the new traditions which means the Sakya, Kagyu and Geluk traditions. I mean, their rejoinder is very simple, if that was the case, all sentient beings experience a mind of clear light in the death process, all sentient beings would be enlightened. So I think Tibetan Book of the Dead is very interesting but it does not represent in any way I would say the dominant position of Tibetan Buddhism of any of the schools. Do you have other questions?

Yes. No. Because as we said, as usual in all the great religion, right, there is a discrepancy between popular practice and the teachings. The death process is a profoundly disempowering process. People are desperate to be empowered.

Then there is a gigantic demand for ritual, for the sake of the dead. It helps the families much more than the dead person. But what it does indeed do is even though once a person is dead that tenth limb has been set, as we said during the forty nine days of the intermediate state, the intermediate being can perceive the rituals performed for it and that in turn affects the completing karma. So for that reason these rituals have sense but these rituals and this is something that there’s a consensus on this from all of the great teachers, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, Khensur Rinpoche, the consensus is that it is practiced up to this point, up to the ninth limb which makes a difference. From the ninth limb, let’s say this is, an unfortunate existence, which has been, generated, the boat is sinking.

The only issue is how fast. Does this place power in the same position that you’re discussing then? No. Phowa is a very different set of practice. POA is a practice of voluntary directed death, but what is not said frequently enough is that it is not sufficient to have received teachings on poa to be able to practice poa effectively.

Rinpoche taught poa here at TBI and Rinpoche and all of the teachers in the Geluk tradition emphasize that to practice Poa you need a huge store of merit. If that merit which is like your rocket fuel isn’t present, you know, then you can do the visualizations, they don’t work. I had an old friend, a geshe at Sera, he said to me once quite sarcastically, if Poa worked this well, believe me, we would be all practicing it. He said the truth of the matter is that Poa is a little bit like a bird with a stone tied to its feet trying to fly. The bird can fly but until the stone has gotten rid of, there is no flying to be talked about.

Poa as a technique works but the merit to practice POA and the purification of non virtues must have been performed before. POA, there are two different viewpoints. No. There there are two different viewpoints on POA. In the most influential traditions, are in the Tibetan tradition, the Geluk and Nyingma tradition, these are the intellectual and meditative heavyweights, if you want.

Phowa is seen seen as reincarnation insurance. In other words, if everything else fails, you practice phowa. And there are a lot of great masters who do not practice Poa at all because Poa unless practiced very carefully shortens the lifespan. Right? You train for that.

In the Geluk tradition, there are very specific teachings which Rinpoche gave. These are public, so we can talk a little bit about them here. Poa is practiced only until the signs of Poa, of success arrive, then one stops. And then one practices long life pujas or long life retreats to try to restore the life force. Now there’s one exception.

There are some small traditions such as the Drikung Kagyu tradition which have specialized in the practice of Poha within the six yogas of Naropa and the six yogas of Niguma. Then those traditions, some teachers in those traditions teach exclusively Poa. There’s a very big risk with this approach and Rinpoche criticized, one of those teachers quite directly for this reason. A POA has to be like your car insurance. It’s in case you take, you know, third party insurance and accident insurance in case you have an accident.

It’s not something you plan on relying upon. The POA is there if everything else in your practice fails. The POA is very difficult to engage. In case of accident, you can’t. If you die under morphine, you can’t.

Right? It’s not possible. You have to be conscious. The death must be conscious. If there is too much pain, it’s very difficult.

Then you have to have the merit to do it. It’s not easy. Are there other questions? Yes. Yes.

There was necessarily a positive appropriation. I didn’t suggest it, I put it quite directly. Necessarily. Necessarily. Yes.

Yes. Yes. All of us in this room, owe depending on whether we are the recipients of a three life cycle of 12 limbs or two life cycle, we owe gratitude to one or two persons. Life 50 who implanted the karmic imprint, the second link and life 120 who brought it to fruition. Then life 121 has to spend this life meaningfully.

Right? So the minimum, right? What’s what’s the minimum payback, right? If someone’s given you a thousand dollars on loan to start a business, what’s the minimum you owe him? You owe him a thousand, right?

Then if you have inflation, you owe him a lot more than that. So your minimum pay payback is one karmic imprint to give rise to a human life in the future. That’s your minimum payback. Yeah. And you can see if you look at the, 12 links postulated over three lives, how difficult it is to gain result one twenty one because life 50 is has to have been a higher rebirth.

You do not create positive karma in the lower rounds. It doesn’t happen. My dogs I’m sure would be love would love to do this. It is impossible for them. Impossible.

Right? You have to have intent to create positive karma they do not have. Right? I mean and what is the specific karma for human rebirth? It’s ethics.

Why is it ethics? We say this all the time. What is ethics? Ethics is restraint. It is restraint from desire or anger.

This is what enables one to rise above the animal. An animal is incapable of this. We have dogs, I can punish my dogs if they behave badly, if one of them bites the other, but the restraint of one of the two in not biting the other is not ethics. It is fear of punishment. There’s no restraint from the dog’s side there.

There is not the seed for human rebirth. So in life 50, at least one element of restraint must have been present with the 10 non virtues, at least one of them must have been voluntarily abstained from. In life 120, in addition, one must have had a higher rebirth because one must have been able to generate a limb of appropriation which activated this virtuous karma. So these are two virtuous or two higher rebirths which are necessary for one higher rebirth as a result. All of us in this room all of us in this room are going straight to the lower realms.

Because if we look at the mechanism here, what is most present in our mind? Negative karma. I mean, we have beginningless ages of lives as animals, insects, whatnot. If you’re an animal in the wild, what do you do to live? You have to eat other animals alive.

This is how animals you eat or you are eaten. So dogs, cats, whatever in the wild, they kill on a daily basis to live. Each time they kill, they implant negative karma. The amount is infinite. Then if we actually examine our minds, if we practice Sattipattana, mindfulness, we examine our minds and as Geshe Ben Gungyal, we try to see what is good and what is bad.

We see immediately the majority, the overwhelming majority is bad. Then why do I say all of us are going to the lower realms? Because at the time of death, it is this which triggers the next rebirth. What will be your state of mind at the time of death? Who in this room can guarantee that they will have a virtuous mind at this time of death is difficult.

In this room maybe some of us will be able to. But if you die under morphine you have no control. If you die of cancer in great pain, there would probably be anger, resentment, you know. If your family is weeping at your bedstead, there would be anger, resentment and desire. Alright.

So this is why this point is the most critical one and this one we have little guarantee. People on the outside who do not have an idea about these teachings, they have no control. Then it’s like throwing dice. This is why the most important thing is in this process to generate a virtuous state of mind. And the easiest way to do it, it depends on the person, but is for the person to practice their religion at this point.

Whether they are Buddhist or not is irrelevant. The Buddhist mechanism of causality works. Someone who is a Christian at this point and who recollects Christ’s teachings will have a virtuous state of mind, will think of Jesus. This triggers positive karma, they will get a good rebirth. Someone who thinks of Moses’ teachings, is Jewish or good Muslim.

But if we train in a religion which we do not really believe in, then at the time of death when we want to trigger a higher rebirth, we may very well be unable to do so. Does that make sense to you? So it’s it sounds very bleak but we are actually training for that moment. And that is why the essence of the Buddhist tradition is repetition. Meditation means repetition in Tibetan.

Gom means habituation. Why? Because if we do our commitments for instance, when we meditate our commitments every day for twenty, thirty, forty years, then at the time of death, there are very strong chances we’ll be able to meditate them. And the criterion what we are looking for is the point where we move from the course to the subtle mind. Right now when we meditate, it’s only the coarse mind which is triggered.

But His Holiness has pointed out in the Lamrim this year that a sign that karmic imprints have taken the subtle mind is when these experiences dawn in the dream state. So you meditate and you keep on meditating until good signs appear in the dreams. Why? That means the imprints are present in the subtle mind. Then the odds of their being triggered at the level of the ninth limb are very high.

Depends on the person. I mean, there’s a long list of traditional signs in the Tibetan texts. The vision of one’s teacher is one of the best. Giving or receiving teachings, then there are numerous ones moving upwards as opposed to moving downwards, meeting beings of light, meeting white beings, ingesting nectar or light, but the sign itself is almost irrelevant. It’s an interpretation the mind makes of a certain state of affairs.

Well, we we’re not able to we’re not able to practice dream yoga. I mean, that’s very advanced as a practice. But what we’re looking the the one reason we do check the dreams and it’s one category of dreams, it’s a dream in the early morning is because if parts of our practice appear in that, that means they have penetrated deep down. Deep down enough that when we die there are good chances they will penetrate again. This is why repetition is so important.

Mindful repetition. There’s only one way to do that. You have to practice what’s going is good. I mean, this is now is the time for practice and you have to use the accidents, the hardship in your life to train your mind to become accustomed to greater hardship. It is point one.

Point two, all of us must pray for good death. So those prayers, if they rooted in an accumulation of virtue, lead to a result within reason. If we have strong karma leading to a difficult death, then it’s difficult to obviate. What is a good death? From a Buddhist standpoint, a good death is a death with little suffering.

It is a death alone. The more people are around you the more problems there are and it is a death in which your body is left undisturbed for at least three days. That we have to pray for. And death under under morphine, as Gesheera said, the only thing you can do is control the mind before the morphine is injected and hope it works. You have no control.

Hope it works. Then what you do then what you do is you pray first for a good death, in other words, no suffering, and then the moment the person has died, while you have still control over the situation, you touch their body at the top. Ideally, if they are, let’s say, they are Christian, you must do this in keeping with their own religious tradition. This is what is of benefit to them. They are Christian, they will be the bible.

You put the bible on their head. If they’re Jewish, you will put the Talmud or the Torah. If they’re Buddhist, in the Tibetan tradition, It has to be a pretty sharp tap, not just a gentle touch. This basically is perceived by the subtle mind of the body and causes the mind, they say, to exit towards the higher realms. They say.

What all of you who are in that age group should be doing is making arrangements for instance with Geshela or a monk so that the moment you are hospitalized and it becomes terminal before you die because after you die, there’s very little one can do before you die that you have a good monk come to you so that this is oriented in the right direction. Our families will not know how to do this. This is a service I was planning on giving to my mother when I I thought she was going to die and I got some very precise instructions on this. But you should have a good monk, you know, not only a pious monk, but a monk who’s actually studied the signs of death So that he knows whether consciousness is in the body or not, what to do before it leaves the body when the sense consciousness is still work to trigger an appropriate limb of appropriation and how to check which Geshela knows exactly, how to check how long the consciousness is in the body and once one is sure it has left, then the body can be disposed of in any way.

But what is catastrophic for instance is incineration where the consciousness is still in the body. You know, or what happens very commonly in hospitals, I don’t know the usage nowadays, but when I used to visit hospitals, typically, the moment the dead person, had breathed his or her last, the body would be removed and unfortunately, once the death process has started, the sphincters loosen, you know. So whatever waste material is in the body is immediately voided. Then they would plug the waste material, the orifices, the sphincters with cotton. Then you’re basically triggering certain types of rebirth.

De facto, you know. This was standard when I was visiting the hospitals. Standard. And there was nothing we could do about it. How do you treat the Well, the body well, typically, for instance, would plug the anus, right?

So you are, triggering, a lower rebirth through touching the body in its lower extremities first. So when something like this may be happening, I do not know the usage nowadays but may be happening, what you do is before the body is touched, by any of this the clinical the medical personnel, you touch the top of the head sharply, if possible, with a picture of the teacher or a holy book. The most important thing is if they’re not religious, most important thing both actually for religious and non religious persons is that the mind not be troubled in death. So do not try to change somebody’s religious perspective as they are dying. It only creates anger and irritation.

It pretty much guarantees a lower rebirth. The person must be left as they are and then if they had a higher interest, it might have been charity work, funding the Red Cross, something of that nature. Then if you put, for instance, some pictures of the Red Cross in front of them, if they had kept the blind, which I think is a big thing in Australia. Something like that, these lead to elevated thoughts and the person dies with virtuous thoughts. Then there is one thing which as westerners is very alien to us.

One should not mourn the dead person. It’s an extremely problematical approach to death, not just from a psychological standpoint because once the person has died, body is dead, the Bardo being is attracted to those who think about it. If there is strong bereavement, the Bardo being may try to stay in the area or even take rebirth and this is actually how what we know as ghosts are generated. Ghosts are Bardo beings who take rebirth as spirits because of a very powerful negative experience in the context or excessive bereavement by the family. So the Tibetans for instance are very wise in this respect.

Before somebody dies, it’s something we as Westerners can do, a Tibetan will give away everything he owns without exception. By doing so, he rids himself of attachment of any type of living. He gives away his property, let’s say, if I had a son or a friend I would give him my watch, the glasses, everything is given away. Then donations are made to the monasteries, to centers for publication of books and the person dies in a state close to non attachment. Upon death, nobody talks about the person anymore.

The name is never mentioned. One invites monks and they perform pujas in the room, in our tradition would be Lama Chöpa. Typically, they might recite, for instance, in our tradition again, the Guhyasamāja tantra is a standard recitation, the Lama Chöpa. The battle being has full telepathy and clairvoyance. If the the person who is reciting the text understands it, the Bardo being understands it.

So if it’s recited in Tibetan by a Tibetan, not by a Westerner. If it’s recited in Tibetan by a Tibetan, the Bardo being understands it. If it’s recited in English by a Tibetan who doesn’t know English, the Bardo being does not understand it. So then the Bardo being through understanding these texts does not develop any attachment to the place of death moves on. This is the goal actually of the Tibetan Book of the Dead, the part which are really useful, you know.

And even through generating virtuous thoughts can generate good completing karma. So this is how one should try to proceed. Then you shouldn’t worry too much because if you think carefully of the traveling, what do you see? This here is guaranteed. So if in let’s say let’s say you are all in life 01/21, we all are in this room, we all have a human rebirth, we have met the teachings.

If in this life you generate one good karmic imprint, that good karmic imprint, if it’s been dedicated, if it’s in other words, if it’s been rooted in an effect which you have oriented it towards, it cannot be destroyed. So even if your death process is difficult in this life and unfortunately life one twenty two you are reborn in the lower realms as an animal, which is I think with death by with, death under morphine it must be extremely common. I would assume rebirth as an animal would be pretty standard. Nonetheless, this is present. This will mature, you know.

It might even mature if at the time of death, the dog has a strong feeling of love for its master and a wish to be like its master. That’s enough, you know. But if this is not present, then you don’t know how many of these you have in the past because as you can see to gain a higher rebirth like a human rebirth in the cycle of three one series of three groups of 12 links two have to be higher rebirths. It is really difficult to gain. It is really difficult to gain.

Well, there are lot of human beings that let you look at the other species. Right? I mean, you just take I don’t know. The ants in Adelaide, there are more ants in Adelaide than many human beings in the whole world. You know?

Four tons. Four tons. Yeah. Then we don’t count the spirits. We, in the West, discount their existence, but they do exist.

The far more spirits than human beings. The prettas are generally spirits. So I’m sorry. I’ve taken a lot of Anila’s time. She’s been very very very very understanding about this.

If you have no more questions, I think Anila would like to lead the concluding meditation. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
Six Yogas of Naropa naro chö drug (Tib)
Six advanced tantric practices transmitted by the great Indian pandit Naropa: the yogas of inner fire (tummo), illusory body, clear light, the dream state, the intermediate state (bardo) and transference of consciousness (powa). LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top