Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues a commentary on the Secret Life of Je Tsongkhapa, a verse text recounting his visions of Mañjuśrī, Vajrapāni, Atisha, Maitreya and other Buddhas. It teaches that his attainments came from accumulated merit, purification and devotion to the guru, whose kindness is presented as greater than that of the Buddhas. The talk also covers the importance of the Vinaya, the need to read Nāgārjuna’s statements of no-view in context, and the danger of misunderstanding emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 21m
UUID: fd26ee89-0194-4f72-ad47-032f9b04674e
Words: 5,483
So let us generate the motivation to listen to the secret life of Je Tsongkhapa and attain the state of Je Tsongkhapa with the motivation of attaining full enlightenment for the benefit of all suffering mother sentient beings as vast as space. So continuing with our texts, the secret life of Je Tsongkhapa, recounts the stanza which follows, in other words, in a former birth to the victorious one you offered a rosary of 100 crystal beads. Thus, you acquired a fortune later to attain the perfect view or illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. During a previous life was reborn in India at the time of Buddha Śākyamūni. And as a young child, he was the disciple of a great bodhisattva by the name of who was attending teachings of the Buddha.
And at this occasion, the young child who was a past incarnation of Jetsongkapa offered to Buddha Śākyamūni a rosary of Rinpoche says, probably 121 crystal beads and made strong prayers of aspiration on this offering, he should later on generate bodhicitta and the correct view, the view of emptiness within his mind stream. And it is because of this dependent arising that he eventually, many centuries later, manifested as. Continuing with your text. At the age of seven, you directly perceived Dipankara Atisha. It’s Dipankara Srijñana, the Sanskrit name of Atisha, the great path clearer, and Vajrapāni, lord of secret.
The exhortations of both the sutras and tantras dawned upon you. O illustrious lama, at your feet, I pay homage. Rinpoche says, when Jirempoche was seven years of age, he had direct visions. In other words, in Tibetan one says, actually, he saw the face. He had direct visions of Vajrapāni himself and of Atisha.
And independence on these, the practice actually, the Tibetan term is Dampa. Dampa, which he says means practice. It’s translated in your text by exhortations, which is not a very good translation. It’s the practice or the realizations, perhaps even better, of Sūtra and the Pāramitāyāna dawned, in his mind.
And then the, following stanza in the secret life of Jetsongkapa is one about which there is a fair bit of controversy. O Jetsün, lord of phenomenal existence, you directly perceived Mañjuśrī, Bodhisattva of the wisdom of emptiness, seated in a radiant aura as blue, you have to add to your text, radiating the five lights as the color of a perfect sapphire or illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. Khensur Rinpoche says, basically, there were several accounts of the lives of Jetsongkapa. The first and fundamental account of the life of Jetsongkapa was written by Kedrup Je, who was Jetsongkapa’s heart disciple, his closest disciple.
Kedrup Je wrote one biography of Jetsongkapa which is entitled gateway to liberation. And then he wrote a concise biography based on this first elaborate biography. The biography of Je Tsongkhapa we have, written by Jamyang Chöje, is a biography which is written from the standpoint of the uncommon trainee. Generally, these biographies were written for two different categories of trainees. If you want, one could say that one category of biography was exoteric and the other was esoteric.
Kedrup Je’s biographies were mainly mainly exoteric, so they referred to the life of Jetsongkapa as far as external appearances were concerned. This biography by Jamyang Chöje refers more to the inner experiences of Jetsongkapa and fuses several elements in Kedrup Je’s biographies with other sources so that, for instance, some of the presentation differs in Jamyang Chöje’s biography from that in Kedrup Je’s biography. Specifically with respect to this one verse, it is said in Kedrup Je’s biography that Je Tsongkhapa gained at first contact with Mañjuśrī through the great practitioner Lama Umapa, Pawo Dorje, also known as Sangdü Singe, who had from young onwards as a young shepherd direct visions of Mañjuśrī first as black Mañjuśrī. And he acted as it were as translator in the conversations between Mañjuśrī and Jetsongkapa. And at a certain point, Mañjuśrī said to Jetsongkapa, it would be good to have a direct vision of myself.
And Jetsongkapa entered into Shine, into Shamatha, and after leaving Shamatha, gained direct vision for the first time of Mañjuśrī. And from that point onwards, was able to converse directly with Mañjuśrī without the intermediary of Lama Umapa in the same way as a student would converse directly with his teacher. So this is the account in Kedrup Je’s biography of Jetsongkapa. Here, however, it is said that at the age of seven, Jetsongkapa had a direct experience of Mañjuśrī. This actually refers to the biography of Jetsongkapa from the standpoint of the uncommon trainees who are able to understand the uncommon attributes of Jetsongkapa.
And specifically, Rinpoche will gloss in detail, this verse. So what actually occurred is that at that age, Jetsongkapa saw manifesting directly in front of him the mandala, the celestial mansion of Yamāntaka. And upon seeing the mansion of Yamāntaka, it actually fused into blue light, and this is the beginning of your verse. The first stanza in Tibetan is actually line four of your verse seated in a radiant aura as blue. So it fused into a mass of blue light which radiated lights of the nature of the five wisdoms.
So this is what was missing in your text. And then in the middle of this mass of blue light which became spherical, manifested in the form of yellow manjushri, and Jetsongkapa at this point had direct perception, saw him directly. So this refers to the uncommon experiences of jit jitsongkapa recounted for the uncommon trainees. So, Lama who act as act as intermediary between Jetsongkapa and Mañjuśrī for such a long time, actually was a Kampa. And when he was a little boy, he actually was a shepherd, and he would go on mountain peaks tending his flocks.
And since no one was around, he would recite the mantra of Mañjuśrī, Om Ara Pa Tsa Na Dhi, and he would shout the mantra. And obviously, didn’t disturb anyone since the mountain peaks were completely empty. And at first nothing in particular happened and one day he had been chanting the mantra of Mañjuśrī and eventually he fell asleep. He dozed off and when he woke up, he saw next to him for the first time black manjushri. And he had the direct experience of black manjushri, and thereafter in his life was able to converse directly with black manjushri whenever he wanted.
And says, therefore, we can only imagine what an extraordinary practitioner and what a fundamental teacher Lama Omapa was. He was actually a Sakyapa Lama. And some of you may know that in the context of the practice of Yamāntaka, when we perform the offerings, the three first offerings of water are, water for the mouth, water for the feet, and then it’s an uncommon feature of the practice of Yamāntaka that we offer perfumed water for the heart in third place instead of offering it later on as in most of the tantras. The reason for this is connected specifically to the instructions which were received at this point. Insofar as the blessings of Mañjuśrī are received directly within the heart, they transform one’s mind which resides at the level of the heart.
And therefore, to signify this, the water which is offered, the perfume water which is offered to the heart is placed in third place. Likewise, when Lama Umapa was reciting the mantras of Mañjuśrī, he first recited them from the depths of his heart, and he in turn received the blessings of Mañjuśrī in his heart. And because Lama Umapa had actualized Mañjuśrī, had had the direct experience of Mañjuśrī, he composed many oral instructions and instructions in general on the practice of Mañjuśrī. And purportedly, when he met Je Tsongkhapa, he asked Je Tsongkhapa in a private conversation having himself realized Mañjuśrī, have you realized Mañjuśrī? And Jetsongkapa said to him, I have.
And this is the base of this verse where, it is indicated that Jetsongkapa, very young, realized Mañjuśrī. And then moving onwards in our text, we come to the following stanza. From this time onward, O high one, whenever desired, you could invoke Mañjuśrī treasure of stainless wisdom and constantly listen to the teachings of both Sūtrayāna’s transcendent wisdom and Tantrayāna’s secret assembly or illustrious lama, at your feet I pay homage. So this secret life of Jetsongkapa indicates that then from very young onwards, Jetsongkapa was able to have Mañjuśrī directly as a teacher and to listen to both the very essence of tantra, which is the Guhyasamāja tantra, and the great teachings of the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, which are the very core of the Sūtrayāna. And on one occasion, said to, there will not be great benefit in teaching to these obscured beings, instead gain attainments.
And the meaning of this is that because of the degree of blindness and obscuration of beings, Ariyamanjushri felt there was limited benefit in Jetsongkapa’s teaching, beings which would not accept Jetsongkapa’s teachings. And Ariyamanjushri said to him, if you practice as a hermit, if you practice in solitude and gain attainments, then there would be benefit both for you and for others.
And then because Ārya Mañjuśrī was Jetsongkapa’s root teacher, Jetsongkapa immediately followed the instructions of Mañjuśrī. This is much later on in Jetsongkapa’s life. And abandoned all teaching, gave up all teaching instantaneously, and gathered a collection of eight disciples, four from Central Tibet and four from Dokam from the East Of Tibet. And with these eight disciples, he went to a specific hermitage, Wolka, an area called Wölkha, which was a very harsh area and engaged there in great mortifications and ascetic practices. Specifically, he performed a gigantic amount of mandala offerings, so much so that his forearm became one large wound through cleaning the mandala base And he performed also a huge number of prostrations, specifically prostrations to the 35 confession Buddhas for reciting the Sūtra of Confession.
And while he was performing these prostrations, he actually saw in space in front of him all 35 Confession Buddhas, and this is referred to, in the following stanza of your text when practicing the seven limb, the ritual of the 35 purification Buddhas, continually and clearly you beheld them in all their forms, mudras, and symbols. Oh, illustrious lama, at your feet, I pay homage. And then during a break in his retreat at with his eight disciples, Jetsongkapa visited a small location, with a pool, which he doesn’t exactly remember the name, not far from Rilke, where, in a temple which was very decrepit was a badly damaged statue of Buddha Maitreya. And when Jitsongkapa and his eight disciples saw this, their hearts were ran apart and Jitsongkapa cried greatly to see the statue of Maitreya in such poor shape with cracks in the fissures and all the garments damaged.
And he and his eight disciples gathered all their worthy possessions, which amounted to a mere 3 sung, which is something like 3 Australian dollars, to try to see if there was anything they could do to repair the statue in the temple. Obviously, you can’t do a lot to repair statues in temples with that amount of money. And then Jetsongkapa had his disciples gather some butter, and with an old piece of cloth, after dipping the butter in cloth, he created a triangular torma and offered the torma to Vaishavana, the protector, the dharma protector, who is also connected with wealth, begging Vaishavana for help. And after offering the torma, a large number of lay people started coming to the monastery carrying with them all of the requisite goods and large amounts of butter, which was a bit like a commodity at that period, and they performed extensive renovations of the temple and of the statue of Maitreya until they were as new. Now this was to signify the importance of purification.
And his eight disciples in doing this performed tremendous purification, and as a result of these deeds, Je Tsongkhapa then had the direct vision of Mañjuśrī in which Mañjuśrī appeared to him and prophesied Je Tsongkhapa’s future manifestation as a universal teacher. And this is the following verse, in your text. Seated in the auspicious posture, which is not a good translation. It just means that seated in Tibetan. It says the good position, which means he’s seated as a westerner with his legs, touching the ground.
Hands in the dharma teaching mudra, which Rinpoche demonstrated. Buddha Maitreya prophesied that just as the Sugadas who possess the 10 powers, you will one day perform the 12 acts of a supreme universal teacher or illustrious lama at your feet, I pay homage. Is the protector of space and of the beings of the middling scope. So if one has good morality, then Vaishavana will definitely protect us. Otherwise, there isn’t a chance.
Says, the Singaporeans, he teaches often in Singaporeans. So Singaporeans, they really love money. So they practice Vaishnavana a lot. They do his mantra a lot, but no money comes in. So just as you see, he tells them always they have to have good morality because then if one progresses Vaishavana, then wealth will come like rain fell when Jetsongkapa practiced it.
And then continuing with the secret life of Jetsongkapa, Victorious master of both life and death, truth visions you received of Amitābha Buddha, the medicine Buddha’s in that teach of men and gods, Śākyamūni, prince of the Shakya throne, each of the retinue vast as the oceans, At your feet, I pay homage. So received visions of Buddha, medicine Buddhas, and Buddha. And I don’t know where the verse of victorious master of both life and death comes from. Mhmm. And then continuing with the commentary, saintly Tārā, source of all Sidneys, Uchnisha Vijaya, which is a long life goddess, the one exalted and radiant, Uchnisha Sitatapatra, which is the umbrella protectress, dispeller of obstacles, and other such mystic female Buddhas, again and again, you directly perceived or illustrious lama.
At your feet, I pay homage. So it is because Jitsongkapa accumulated vast collections of virtue and purified, vast amounts of nonvirtue that he was able to have the direct perception. He actually saw the face of so many Buddhas and Bodhisattvas and received many prophecies from them regarding his own manifestation of full enlightenment. And then he progressed upwards on the grounds and paths in keeping with the mantra, and so forth, which refers to the various paths.
He saw the faces. In other words, he saw manifestations of the Buddhas, received their blessings, and received as well prophecies from them.
So we recite the mantras of Tārā. We recite the mantras of the Medicine Buddha, Om Bekandze Bekandze and so forth. We recite the mantras of Buddha Śākyamūni, Muni Muni Mahamuni Svāhā. And yet, however much we recite them, never see the manifestations of the Buddhas. And therefore, it was said of your everyone recites a mantra and everyone has a deity.
And which is yes says, yes, indeed. Everyone recites a mantra and everyone has a deity, but nobody has any experience. And this is because in those people’s mind, dharma is not generated. Nothing ever appears. So all we can see is the spiritual teacher.
We are, Rinpoche says, like beggars who are destitute. We have no food. We have no clothes. We have no protector. We have no house.
We are powerless. We are really the dregs of the dregs, which have have just been born recently in the hell realms, in the lower realms. How could to to such like us the Buddhas appear? They do not. What does appear to us is a spiritual friend.
He who gives clothes to the destitute, he who gives food to the destitute, he who gives a dwelling, who gives protection to those who are destitute like us, is a spiritual friend. So says, to a beggar who is destitute, is homeless, a homeless person who has no food, no medicine, no clothes, one who were to help one such person would be very kind indeed in worldly matters. And we are in that state because nobody really wants to help the destitute, the forlorn, the beggars, lost. Once somebody has something, has a bit of a situation, has some money, then people flock to him to help him and to try to get the money from him. But when he has nothing, there are no friends, there is no one to help us.
And that is really a simile for the relative kindness of the spiritual friend of the guru and of the Buddhas. The spiritual friend, the guru, helps those no one else can help, those who are at the bottom of the pit, those who are beggars, who are destitute, who are homeless, whom everyone else has abandoned. And then once they have improved their lot a little bit, just as in worldly matters, once they have gained some money, once they’re a little bit better off, then they can see the manifestations of the Buddhas. Before that, it is not possible. So he says there was once a man who became a beggar.
He was destitute. He had nothing. No money. Nothing. And then nobody wanted to know about him.
Nobody wanted to help him. Nobody wanted to be his friend. People would turn their heads away when they crossed him on the street. And then he worked very hard. You know?
He gained some money. He became quite well off. And then all of a sudden, he was surrounded with people saying, one, I’m your maternal uncle. The other, I’m your brother. The third, I’m your friend.
Many maternal uncles came, Susan. And then he, one day, invited all of these long lost relatives to a big feast he was organizing. And, before they came, he put all his money. He had a lot of it, a lot of dollars on the table. You know?
And they all came and they feasted. And then when the feast was over, he said, the one who had no uncle now has uncles, the one who had no sister now has sisters, the one who had no brother now has brothers, the one who had no girlfriend now has girlfriends, To money the great protector, I prostrate. So when the going is good, Liberty says in, like this man, we’re surrounded with friends and relatives, girlfriends and boyfriends. And then, you know, when the going was bad, like for this man, there’s nobody. So what Jesus said, and then in the same way as a beggar, as a homeless person who is helped in his practice, which is what we are, helped by the teacher, enables us to eliminate all our thoughts progressively and to actualize all our qualities and to lead us progressively upwards on the grounds and paths.
Then, eventually, after being led up on the grounds and paths, we will reach a a state where we will see the Buddhas like Ayatara, like Mañjuśrī directly. Then we would be like the rich man who has many friends. And as said, then the kindness of the teacher is superior to the kindness of all the Buddhas for this reason. Says there is an anecdote told about an old which likes very much. It’s very telling.
Said, well, whether a little bit of meditation will fill one’s stomach or not is open to doubt. But thinking of the man, referring to the guru, that most definitely will fill one’s stomach. Like he said, for instance, Ariatara, I’m not quite sure whether she’s here or not. Avalokiteśvara, I’m not too sure. Vajrayogini either, but I am never separated from the vision of my teacher.
So most probably, I will be freed. I will attain full enlightenment. And then Geshe Möchog said, independence on this experience of the teacher, all of the Buddhas, Vajrayoginī,, Tārā will manifest. So Rinpoche thinks this account
Of Geshe Möchog is very profound. He likes it very much. Very good lama. Very good lama. So as an old teacher of said, and regrets, he does not remember the name.
He has become old. But as an old teacher of yours said, without the light of faith and veneration, the water of the blessings of the Lama do not flow. And what he says, this is a simile which is very talking, which is very pregnant for Tibetans because in the same way as if the light of the sun does not strike the peaks of mountains, then the water or the snow on top of the mountains will not melt and rivers will not flow. Likewise, from one’s own side, if we do not have faith and veneration for the spiritual teacher, then we will not receive any blessings from the spiritual teacher. And if we do not receive any blessings from the spiritual teacher, we are not able to gain any attainments.
And this is the reason for which his holiness, the Dalai Lama has said, seeing the face of the teacher, I progress on the limbs of faith and veneration. His holiness means by this that it is only independence on faith and veneration in the spiritual friend that we can go anywhere we want to go. Through faith and veneration in the spiritual friend, we can be reborn in Sukavati, the pure land of Amitābha. We can be reborn in the pure land of Tārā, the pure land of Avalokiteśvara, any of these. But these are not places we can hope to go to by physical means through walking, for instance.
We can only go there if we generate faith and veneration in the teacher. Therefore, it is very important for us to generate these. So the question is why was it necessary for Jirempoche to give up his aggregates in order to attain enlightenment in the intermediate state? Is it possible to attain enlightenment without an actual consort? So Jirempoche says Jirempoche himself deferred attaining enlightenment until he was in the intermediate state because to attain full enlightenment, it is necessary to retract together all the winds in the body and specifically to gather the all pervasive wind into the heart chakra.
Now it is not possible to do this without relying on a consort. And since Jiren Pajek himself was the founder of the Geluk tradition and, insisted on the importance of pure view and pure behavior, had he himself relied on a consort, then many of his disciples would have done likewise even if they were not qualified, and this would have led to a decay of the Geluk tradition. So to signify the importance of pure morality since it is inappropriate for a monk to practice with a consort, then Jiren Pace himself maintained pure bhikṣu vows until the end of his life, and in the intermediate state alone, then engaged in visualized practice and attained full enlightenment. And then because Je Rinpoche himself was very keen on making sure that the perpetuation of the Vinaya occurred and he himself lived in monasteries and founded monasteries, then it would not have been possible for him to adopt any other type of behavior than monastic behavior. We have to realize that the existence or nonexistence of the Buddhist teachings in this world of ours is contingent on the existence or the nonexistence of the Vinaya.
That is the criterion for the existence or nonexistence of the Sūtra teachings in this world of ours. So if the Vinaya were to cease to exist, then we could say that the Buddhist teachings have ceased to exist. And for this reason, Jitsongkapa put great effort in ensuring that great monasteries were created and that the purity of the monastic tradition was perpetuated, and he himself epitomized this. On the other hand, from the standpoint of tantra, one can say that the existence or the nonexistence of the teachings of the Guhyasamāja tantra are the
For the existence or nonexistence of tantra in our world. So if the teachings of the Guhya Samaja tantra cease to exist, then irrespective of whatever else may exist, the tantric teachings have ceased to exist. So the question is, do we know anything about previous life? We assume here we’re not referring to the life manifested as a disciple of Buddha Śākyamūni. And says there is a detailed account of the future lives of Jitsongkapa after that rebirth as a child who offered a crystal rosary to the Buddha in the prophecies of the coming of Jitsongkapa, which were made by Mañjuśrī.
In addition to this, one of the teachers of Jetsongkapa, the great Nyingmalama, Longchenpa, who was manifestation of Vajrapāni, gave very detailed teachings or very detailed explanations of the past lives of Jetsongapa. And if we rely on these two sources, we can know this in detail. And were teachers of each other. So each was a teacher of the other, and each was a student of the other. Life after life, Je Tsongkhapa manifested as a holy being, as a pandit, as a bodhisattva.
So we have another five minutes. If you have any remaining questions, please feel free to ask them. So says that there is a very big difference in that Buddha Śākyamūni was a universal teacher, and therefore, had already attained enlightenment many, many eons before this and merely manifested in this world of ours to teach beings how to strive for full enlightenment. He had already attained enlightenment before he was born. So as Rinpoche explained, then Buddha had attained full enlightenment before his rebirth as Buddha Śākyamūni and manifested the road to progressing towards Nirvāṇa, which is the practice of bhikṣu.
So Rinpoche says, Buddha Śākyamūni actually attained full enlightenment many, many lives before manifesting in the form of Buddha Śākyamūni. And at the point where he attained full enlightenment, he did practice with a consort. But even in the life where he manifested as Buddha Śākyamūni, since at the beginning of that life, he was a prince from the royal household of Shakya, He had a large harem and many wives, and he therefore practiced with these wives and this was part of the meaning of the Buddha’s being married to a large number of women. But at a certain point, the time had come for him to manifest the road to practice for ordinary beings. Generally speaking, there are two types of trainees for or two types of trainees the Buddha’s life was addressed to.
Ordinary trainees, those who actually thought that the Buddha was practicing towards full enlightenment in that very life, and the uncommon trainees who realized he was merely manifesting this for the benefit of others. So therefore, at a certain point in his palace, the Buddha realized that the time had come to manifest the practice of a bhikṣu. And then, his family to prevent him from leaving the palace closed all the doors and tried to prevent him by all means from leaving and becoming ordained. Well, the Buddha caused all of the inhabitants of the palace including his wives to fall asleep by his miraculous powers, and then his charioteer brought his horse to him, and the Buddha left on his horse to Varanasi and eventually to Bodhgaya where he abandoned all of his royal attributes, his clothes, shaved his hair, and became a monk. Then he practiced for six full years with an extremely ascetic type of practice.
His practice was so intense and so ascetic that all that was left really of his body, what was visible, were his ribs. And he did this not because he himself needed to practice but to show us how to practice. And then after this, he manifested full enlightenment in Bodhgaya. Now Rinpoche says more recently in Tibetan history, there is another account from the life of Jetsün Milarepa of how one should practice. Jetsün Milarepa, the great Kagyu Lama, once said to his disciples who were assembled around him, come close and I will teach you, I will give you the uncommon oral transmission for attaining full enlightenment.
And his disciples were very moved that their teacher should want to do this, so they all came close and begged him to give them the transmission. And then Jetsün Mila said, look carefully. And he lay down and took his bottom, clothes off, and he showed them his behind. And his behind was covered with wounds and with calluses. And these, he said, were what was needed to attain for enlightenment.
It was independence on these that he could attain full enlightenment in one life. There’s a very profound oral instruction, Rinpoche said. Said to his disciples, it is independence on this level of hardship that I have attained full enlightenment.
If you practice like me, accumulating the collections and purifying the nonvirtues with this hardship, you also will become enlightened. So said he heard a similar very profound teaching from who did not have a cushion to sit upon and who put tremendous effort in recitation of the texts he had memorized. And the Tibetans rock back and forth when they do this. As a result of this, he had an open wound. So which is we have to accumulate the collections.
Without the collection of merit and the purification of non virtues, there is no attainment. And, therefore, it is said that before had actually realized the view of emptiness, he had a vision of Mañjuśrī. And in this vision of he had of Mañjuśrī, he asked Mañjuśrī how he should practice. In those days in the Sakya tradition, it was in keeping with a famous quote from Nāgārjuna in which Nāgārjuna said, I have no view and let the others come at me with their views. In keeping with that quote of Nagajuna, in the Saka tradition, it was taught that the Madhyamaka position was to have no position, to have no tenets, and to have no view.
And said to Mañjuśrī during the vision he had of Mañjuśrī, I feel very comfortable with this approach of having no tenets and no views. Is this the Svatāntrika, Madhyamaka view, or is this the Prāsaṇgika, Madhyamaka view? And Mañjuśrī laughed and he said, this is not even the Madhyamaka view, let alone the Svatāntrika or the Prāsaṇgika view. If you want to realize the view of emptiness, you must first accumulate vast collections of merit, secondly, confess and purify all your nonvirtues, thirdly, make strong prayers to the guru seen as completely indissociable from the yidam you practice. And finally, analyze carefully using powerful reasonings the great texts of the ancient pundits of India.
And if you do this, you would attain the view. And therefore, this quote of Ārya Nāgārjuna, because I have no tenets or no positions, I have no thoughts, which is drawn from his great treatise, the Vigrahavyāvartanī, was actually or must actually be placed in context. The entire thrust of the Vigraha Viovartani is to dispel the belief in inherent inherent existence and self characterized existence or existence by its own characteristics. And the statements in Nāgārjuna’s treaties which say, I have no tenets or I have no exceptions must be understood as referring to the fact that he has no inherently existing tenets or no tenets which have which are characterized by their own characteristics. And because he has no inherently existing tenets, then he does not have any thought with that respect.
So it was a profound misunderstanding some of the Sakya scholars of your head of this treatise. Which is when you debate like this, there are many problems. And, therefore, it’s extremely important to understand the thought or the intention of the author of these various treatises. For instance, in the Heart Sūtra, the quote, there is no form, and later on, there is no sound, and later on, there are no smells, obviously contradicts direct perception. What is being said is not that there is no form or there are no sounds.
What is being said is that there is no inherently existing form. We have to qualify that statement. There is no inherently existing sound. We have to qualify that statement. Otherwise, it would be insane chatter.
So says we will stop here for today, and these teachings are given to generate strong faith in Jetsongkapa, who initially in Tibet, both the view and the behavior, the view of emptiness and the behavior were non mistaken. Later on, regrettably, they degenerated. There are many misunderstandings, and Jetsongkapa manifested to clear these misunderstandings. So we must be very grateful to to and we must also make strong prayers. May I meet such a teacher myself?
Okay. Prayer book, page nine.
Key terms in this teaching
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
- A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
- Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
- The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- torma balimta (Skt)
- An offering cake used in tantric rituals. In Tibet, tormas were usually made of tsampa, but other edibles such as biscuits and so forth will suffice. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.