TBI Recordings – 23112016Lamrim

1 h 35 min · 3,894 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 23112016Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains that the true enemy is the inner afflictions such as anger and jealousy, which prayer cannot remove and which must be reduced through study and practice. It presents love, compassion and bodhicitta as antidotes, with forbearance and the first three perfections highlighted. The session closes with questions on forbearance, anger in animals, and prayer and mantra.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 36m

UUID: 4b1d04af-df8b-4b0c-a1ed-cfbda4c90a84

Words: 3,890

So the term Buddhism in Tibetan is Now has two components. The term means inside or within, and this indicates that Buddhism is focused on the transformation of the mind inside ourselves. So the term interior, therefore, refers to mental transformation. And here, in our own cases, we focus on the exterior enemies we have. But, actually, it is the interior enemy, which is within ourselves, is the true enemy, the definitive enemy.

And, this interior enemy is the afflictions. So this is precisely the meaning of the term, which is translated in Tibetan as. It’s an etymology of the term. Means enemy. Or means to destroy, a foe destroyer.

One who destroys what? The inner enemy of the afflictions. Then when we have an exterior enemy, someone who hates us and wishes to harm us, then we are uncomfortable, aren’t we? Then all the more so when we are dealing with the interior enemy whose function is to trouble our mind. And this interior enemy is the afflictions.

You are. So now happiness can be subdivided between physical and mental happiness. And the main enemy of mental happiness, what troubles the mind, is the afflictions. Now, here, it is of no benefit whatsoever to pray for the afflictions to subside. So if we pray, may anger subside, may jealousy subside, may competitiveness subside, it will not happen.

There is no means for this to be of benefit. Instead, as Buddha Śākyamūni said, I do not impart blessings nor do I purify through water. Instead, I teach the meaning of suchness. And therefore, it is through following Buddha’s advice that we are able to purify our minds. So you must study.

You must study as much as you can. Whatever you can do, you should put effort at study. Then, obviously, someone who has no possibility at all to study and who understands nothing, then will fold his hands and say, precious triple gem, help me. And maybe from time to time, this works. Then in my own case, you see, it’s something which is widespread in Tibetan society.

When I was at the monastery, conditions were very hard, and sometimes, I would get sharp stomachaches. And I thought, well, maybe reciting manis will help. So I recited manis. But, actually, this is not what helps. This helps neither the body nor the mind.

It is the which helps the mind. Then our problem is that we don’t know how to study. We don’t understand how study can dispel our difficulties, then we don’t engage in it. And this is why Buddha Śākyamūni said that he showed us the path, but it was up to us to study. And as Buddha pointed out, what he taught should not be accepted out of faith or out of respect for him.

Instead, one should analyze and see whether it is of benefit or not, and if it is put it in practice. As Buddha Śākyamūni said, scholars do not accept my words on faith. Ex instead, examine them like the goldsmith examines gold through rubbing, cutting, and smelting. This is a real scriptural passage, a famous one. Then if you have the time, don’t waste your time.

Use your time wisely. Use it to study dharma. Of the many important things in this world, none is more important than time. Because most of the other things we can buy, we can trade for, it is impossible to buy time. Once time has passed, it is gone, never to return again.

Then regarding happiness, happiness is attained through interior transformation. It is interior happiness which must be our goal, and this can only be attained through eliminating the afflictions such as anger, jealousy, envy, and so forth. This does not happen through prayer. However much we pray it will not happen, it happens through study. And in your own cases, you have been studying the dharma for quite some time, and you understand this, and this is rare in this world.

How many people actually study the means of mental transformation on this planet? Very few. Most people on this planet probably believe that anger, jealousy, desire, and so forth are present from the beginning naturally. Then we should rejoice. And truly, happiness is not exterior things like like Geshe-la’s glass case since after all, not everyone accepts that something like that is desirable.

Happiness is within ourselves, and our reward is also inside ourselves. It is a true reward, not a transitory exterior reward. Society. I guess, you know, Then, I don’t know this for sure, but I suspect that, in Australia, probably, for the majority of people, there is little physical suffering. Then, we can say that as far as physical suffering is concerned in Australia, people have enough.

That is not to say that there are not occasional problems, but this is these are not major problems. And here, it is important to understand clearly the distinction between physical and mental suffering. And since the majority of us are here because of mental suffering, to try to find means to establish or to alleviate mental suffering, Then this is just the way I look at things. Then we have to analyze in a society such as this one what the sources of unhappiness and suffering are. And, we can see that they are overwhelmingly mental sufferings.

It is mental suffering which causes people to be unhappy. It is mental in satisfaction which causes people to be unhappy even when physically, they are actually pretty happy. And then there is

A discrepancy between physical and mental happiness. Do you understand? So this is something one must understand. And after this, one must engage in practice. Now this is not easy.

And therefore, one must practice slowly. Slowly. As is always said, one must practice with great enthusiasm continuously. So we can see this very clearly if we take the example of food to start with. When we eat a good meal, at a certain point, actually, we are sated.

Our stomach is full. But because our minds are unsatisfied, we actually continue to eat to experience the taste, and eventually we feel sick. Then the same thing is true with drinking, setting aside, hard liquor. Let’s take the case of, beer for instance. Then people start by drinking one beer because they enjoy the taste of beer.

And then this enjoyment for the taste of beer is unsatisfied. The mind is unsatisfied, and they drink more and more beer and eventually become rip-roaring drunk. Crazy, in other words. Now in this society, I would say that broadly speaking, there is no major physical suffering. I mean, there is no starvation in Australia.

And therefore, the main focus should be mental suffering, and we should try to find the means to eliminate mental suffering. Then in a society like this in which physical needs are taken care of, we can focus on the means of eliminating mental suffering. In reality, we need both. It is clear for beginners like ourselves that if we were not to eat, we would not be able to practice. So we need physical contentment, but then we need to focus on mental happiness.

Then in this way, with physical health and happiness and subdued minds, it is definite we shall lead a long life. And then if we proceed in this way, at the end of this life, it is a given we shall die, but we will die peacefully. As falling asleep, I have physically myself seen many cases of this nature this nature. So this is what we should aim for. Then, obviously, if there are, diseases, one can experience insufferable pain, but that is another issue.

And then we should try to reduce the power of the afflictions, the afflictions under the sway of anger. Then how do we do this? There are numerous numerous aspects of, dharma, but the is particularly powerful because it is very concise. Now the the represents the source of the sufferings risen from afflictions under the sway of anger as twofold. On the one hand, there is ignorance grasping at a self, and this is the main focus of the practice of hearers and solitary realizers.

This is an interior practice. But on the other hand, it is true that the experience of suffering can come from the outside. And here, the Mahāyāna teaches that training the mind in love, great compassion, and bodhicitta is a powerful means to eliminate this. So we have two different means to address suffering. And, therefore, we can see how love, compassion, bodhicitta could act as opponents to to suffering, and we can see in society at large just how dangerous anger, jealousy, envy, and so forth so forth are.

For that matter, in the animal world, we can see that, carnivores such as lions, tigers, wolves, and so forth, who are basically possessed, inhabited by anger and by hatred to the point where they eat other animals alive are a threat to the remaining animals such as herbivores. And these remaining animals then live in herds for their protection. Buffaloes, oxen, and so forth live in herds to protect themselves from the anger and the hunger of carnivorous animals. Then why is it that so many of the great carnivores tend to be solitary animals and that so many of the herbivores live in large groups, probably among others, differences of species due to the presence or the absence of anger, Precisely because there is little anger in the mind stream of herbivores, they are able to live in communities easier. This is not to say that there is no anger in their mind stream.

It does happen. And then you can see how if one is able to generate a peaceful mind, to eliminate anger from one’s mind, then peace, happiness, and harmony will surround us, and our physical and verbal deeds, are the consequences of our state of mind, will be peaceful and harmonious, physical and verbal deeds. We will be surrounded by friends and have a happy expression. Then people who are angry or jealous end up alone. No one wants to be their friend, to be honest.

And therefore, we should have love and empathy for those who are close to us, for our relatives. Let us not talk about high goals such as having love and empathy for people we have never met. This is difficult for us. But at least for those who are immediately around us, we should have love and empathy. And, therefore, we should train our minds in love, compassion, and bodhicitta.

As was said, there are two means to counter the afflictions. Now the Lam Rim points out that through focusing on the welfare of others in a subsidiary fashion, we enact our own welfare. So through focusing on the welfare of others, actually, our own afflictions subside, and we will be surrounded by a circle of friends. And, therefore, if one has a family, then one should try to prevent desire and anger from arising in the family. And if one is single, one has no family, then one should try to avoid fighting at work in this sort of hostile environment.

And as a result, one’s own mind will be at peace. Since one’s mind is at peace, one’s elements will not be troubled. And as a result, one can can hope for a long and peaceful life. And therefore, we should try to reduce the amount of pride, of competitiveness, of anger, of jealousy within our mind stream. Then to eliminate them, that is difficult, but we should try to reduce them.

And this we do to becoming aware of their thoughts. As Je Tsongkhapa says in the Song of Realization, without reflecting on the thoughts of the truth of origin and cessation, how could the mind striving for liberation arise? And therefore, here, we must reflect on the faults of these afflictions.

And we should not trust afflictions such as pride. It is widely believed, for instance, that if we don’t stand up for ourselves, if we are not proud, nothing is gonna come our way in society. If we don’t desire things, we won’t get anything. This is not the way to look at things. We shouldn’t rely on these a 100%.

And therefore, one should aim to have a pure and strong mind and train quietly and progressively. Then when we train in love and compassion for others, our own afflictions decrease. Don’t you wonder why this is the case? Clearly, we train in love and compassion for others, as a result of this training, our own self cherishing decreases. As our self cherishing decreases, in turn, the afflictions under the sway of anger decrease within our mind.

Then to eliminate them completely, that is difficult. As points out in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, it is actually difficult to find a true exterior enemy. Since our minds are beginningless, who truly can harm us from the outside? Whereas an interior enemy, our own anger, that is a true enemy. And, therefore, as is said, once one eliminates the anger within oneself, and probably this will also cause the disappearance of jealousy, then one has no enemies anymore.

Our enemies are those who are discordant or at odds with us, but they arise out of our own anger. And for our society, therefore, really nothing is more important than these studies we are engaged in in how to reduce anger. As we reduce anger, society as a whole will be happy. Then, obviously, this is something I don’t know whether others will accept, but certainly for us, there is benefit. If this had value, monetary value, we could not buy it.

Now I won’t add anything more on this topic regarding forbearance. Probably, when we study forbearance and wish to train in forbearance, anger must come closer. It is when anger comes closer that we understand its faults and its defects and are able to train in forbearance. Now, obviously, once bodhicitta, great compassion, or love have been generated within the mind stream, probably anger does not arise, certainly not anger towards another person. So questions arose the last time regarding how to practice forbearance in the context of defending one’s reputation, which is one of the ancillary Bodhisattva vows.

If someone slanders and defames us, uttering lying and libelous statements regarding us, what exactly should we do? Then here, it is important to answer these lies with the truth, but to do so without allowing one’s mind to be troubled. The moment one’s mind is troubled, the practice of forbearance has collapsed. And, therefore, when someone utters libelous or defamatory statements regarding us, the most important thing is not to allow our mind to be troubled. If our mind is troubled, then our answers will be troubled and discordant as well.

However, with an untroubled mind, we must forcefully counter these accusations and eliminate them. Otherwise, if forbearance meant that we had to accept everything which another party said, it would be very strange. Okay. And therefore, let us meditate during a couple of minutes. First, on the faults of the afflictions within our own mind stream, and then on the fact that everyone else has the same afflictions, and on this basis generate compassion.

Mhmm. Page two. This is one b two three four, and then on page five, the mandala offering, verse one and three.

Oh, And therefore, we should put as much effort as possible in the practice of the six perfections. And specifically, the three first perfections are of great benefit to our society. The, training in the perfection of ethics, focusing mainly on abstaining from the, 10 non virtuous deeds. Then to completely counter the 10 non virtuous deeds is difficult, but at least when they arise, then we try to control and to purify. And then to train in generosity, and obviously, for us, it is possible to practice a generosity of giving material things as much as we can.

And, finally, to train in forbearance or patience. And in society at large, the principal form of forbearance is the forbearance of putting up with the harm inflicted upon us. So what is discordant with forbearance is anger, and anger does not arise continually. It is present only occasionally. However, we have numerous occasions to reflect on the thoughts of anger.

Then in our own cases in our own cases, we are not hermits. Living in a mountain retreat, a hermit has very few opportunities to get angry since he or she never sees anybody and never hears anybody. Then the only opportunities of anger would be the anger from within the mind. Then we ourselves are not hermits. We live in society.

We meet with people. Therefore, we have numerous occasions for anger to arise and for training in patience. And then, obviously, someone like that living as a hermit would have very few opportunities to be jealous or envious. There would be nothing to be jealous jealous or envious of. Then this is obviously not our case, but it is the reason for which beginners like ourselves, when they wish to train in calm abiding, live in solitude.

And in Australia, you value your Christmas a lot. And there is a lot of busyness which surrounds Christmas, flying places, driving places, cars, noise, then maybe there are occasions for anger there. So, obviously, in Australia, you have marvelous conditions. And you go outside, there’s nobody. It’s peaceful.

But people don’t go outside. They say they stay inside and become narrow minded and uptight. Then it’s not like that in India. Right? In India, at five in the morning, they’re beating the gongs.

And at 11:00 at night, they’re running around drunk. Yes. Honestly, you have favorable conditions. But the mindset is different. Then we will cover from next time onwards the perfection of perseverance.

In brief, perseverance can be defined as a delight, an uninterrupted delight in a virtuous object. And we will cover this next time. And at present, Geshe-la would like to take your questions, on forbearance. Please, short, clear questions. One question per person.

And when everyone has asked a question, you can ask a second question, and no multiple aspects to the question. Geshe la, just with regard to patience, His Holiness once said to me So his holiness asked the assembled monks not to give up on Westerners even though they were very fickle. And the reason is, His Holiness says, because once the Geshes should think that even though the students give them considerable difficulties, they should still not give up on them. Actually, you said something about training in forbearance and anger comes closer. Did you mean anger comes into focus?

What is discordant with forbearance? It’s anger. Right? Then since what is discordant with forbearance is anger, you can only practice forbearance when you are close to anger. At present, our minds are untroubled.

There’s no practice of forbearance possible. Geshe-la, when you said love, great compassion, and bodhicitta addresses external obstacles, is that because without anger, our enemies essentially won’t arise? Without anger, what? Yes. Precisely.

The Buddha abandoned his family and society and eventually his friends and obtained omniscience on the basis of his own. So how did he develop, forbearance? And if it wasn’t necessary to for it to be developed in a social situation, should we follow his example if we can? Should stay alone, those who are comfortably staying alone. I was just joking.

So for beginners, it is important to be alone since the opportunities for study and practice are greater. Then when one is more advanced in one’s practice, being alone is not really necessary or related to one’s practice. Geshe-la, I have a doubt about something that was said in the earliest earlier part of the teachings in which carnivores were described as more angry than herbivores. I’m not entirely sure that that that is so. Elephants are herbivores, and they can be and as someone who lives in India, Geshe-la knows how destructive they can be.

The most dangerous animal in Africa is a hippopotamus, and it is a herbivore. They’re angry almost all the time. I mean, they’re, like, boiling with rage. I don’t know why, but they are. And seemingly calm deer, at least the males, can be extraordinarily aggressive.

I’m not translating sexist statements here. One more thing. A shark is an eating machine, but we cannot necessarily say it’s angry. Just eats.

Yeah. It’s to it’s to be examined. Mhmm. Thank you. Yeah.

Yeah. Okay. Sometimes, you know. No. Yeah.

Yeah. Geshe-la, you said in a a earlier teaching, I think I understood that to be in relationships was to occupy the realm of desire. But, it seems to me that that in doing that, we give ourselves opportunity for practicing forbearance. So is it is it necessarily a negative? Is it necessary for us to avoid the realm of desire, to sacrifice the opportunity to practice forbearance?

That’s good. So, obviously, if you have a boyfriend or a girlfriend, the opportunities for forbearance arise, but that in no way means that you have to try to get a boyfriend or a girlfriend. So as I explained, when one has family members, one has the opportunity to practice patience or forbearance within the family. And otherwise, when one goes out in society for whatever reason, one has numerous occasions to practice forbearance or patience. The only situation where this doesn’t arise is if one stays in one’s corner like this.

Rather than praying to the triple gem to help, it’s better to stay. But then sometimes it might help. So Then if you pray with single-pointedly to the triple gem, then this single-pointed faith is a source of mental happiness, and this is the blessing of the triple gem. So when one prays single-pointedly to the triple gem, then this faith is actually identical to joy or delight in the triple gem. And this joy or this delight is fundamentally different from the joy and the delight we take in family members.

Such a joy and delight is an afflicted joy and delight, But the joy and delight in the triple gem is an uncontaminated joy and delight. However, it is difficult to see how this could act as an antidote to the afflictions. Just following on from that, could it be said that the benefits of study and practice are long term benefits, but with prayer and mantra, there’s a short term benefit then in the sense that particularly with mantra, you’re focusing the mind on a virtuous object, which can be used contingently, say if you’re having negative thoughts to kind of take the mind onto a virtuous object away from that negativity? The most important thing here is the motivation. So if the motivation is good, then when when when one recites mantra, one does accumulate virtue.

I think finished. So we can stop here for tonight. Thanks, Eddie. Saturday, 10:30, AGM followed by shared lunch. If you’d like to bring something, Geshe la will be giving motivation.

And, so that’s this Saturday. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top