1 h 39 min · 4,369 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that the realization of the great scope is counteracting self-cherishing, which gives rise to bodhicitta and great compassion. It explains why the realizations of the lower scopes are included in the greater path, and why self-cherishing is the root of suffering. It ends by describing how equalizing self and others leads to giving and taking, followed by questions from the audience.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: ec77f872-d915-4886-aa05-61d02480f16d
Words: 4,365
So if we were to inquire what the realization of the, being of the great scope is, it would probably be, to counter the predilection or the conception of self cherishing. This is a case because when we counter this powerful predilection or conception which wishes to establish our own happiness, is none other, then self cherishing, then probably we give rise as a result to the wish to establish the happiness of others. In other words, bodhicitta. Because to counter this predilection or this conception of self cherishing, one must become mindful of the thoughts of self cherishing. And once one has countered it, I suspect one has gained the realizations of the being of the great scope.
This is the case because just as, when one is able to counter the vanities of this life, one has gained the realizations of the being of the small scope. And one when one has been able to counter the vanities of future lives, one has gained the realizations of the being of the middling scope. Likewise, in parallel or in symmetry with this, when one has been able to counter wishing for one’s own happiness alone, one has been able to gain the realizations of the being of the great scope. So to have attained the realizations of the being of the great scope means to have attained stable experiences and realizations of the great scope. In other words, to have given rise to great compassion and to bodhicitta.
And here, one might wonder if one has attained these realizations of the great scope, would one necessarily have attained the realizations of the middling or of the small scope? And obviously, it’s a rather strange question because, it implies that when one gains higher realizations, one just throws aside lower realizations. So it is probably the case, that, when, one has entered the path of the being of the great scope, one has realizations of the being of the middling and of the small scope. In Sūtra, for instance, it is said that a being who has entered the path of the Mahāyāna has within his mind stream the paths of the, hearers and solitary realizers as well. So, if we take the example of a being who has attained, the path of the scope as the realizations of the great scope, and we want an example of this path within the mind stream of that being, Such an example would, for instance, be great compassion.
Then if we say that such a being has the realizations, of the path shared with the being of the middling and the small scope, we have to give examples. What would be an example of a path shared with the being of the middling scope and an example of a path shared with the being of the small scope in the continuum of a being of the great scope? So there’s considerable food for thought here. Obviously, when we say that the a being who has attained the path of the great scope has within his continuum realizations of the path of the middling and the small scope, the converse is not true. Beings who, are on the small scope or on the middling scope do not have within their mind stream realizations of the being of the great great scope.
Now when we take this case of the being of the great scope who has within his mind stream paths of the being of the small and middling scope, we have to give instances of this. So a being who is a being of the great scope would have within his mind stream paths of the great scope and an instance of such path would be, for instance, bodhicitta or great compassion for that matter, the mind wishing to benefit others. Now such a being, as we said, would also have within his mind stream paths of the being of the middling scope. And which would these be? We could give, for instance, the example of the Four Noble Truths or of impermanence.
Such a being would also have within his mind stream paths shared with the being of the small scope. An example would be, for instance, death and impermanence or for that matter, refuge and causality. Now, within the mind stream of a being who has gained the realizations of the great scope, the, thought of benefiting and actualizing the happiness of others is present. Would you say that this thought is one which is shared with the being of the middling scope? If you say that, you have to say it is also shared with the being of the small scope.
So here there is food for thought. So I’ll ask you the question. Is this a path of the being of the middling scope? No. Right?
So the thought of benefiting and actualizing the happiness of others within the mind stream of the being who’s gained the realizations of the great scope is specific to the great scope, isn’t it? It’s not a realization of the middling path. Why? Why? What’s the reason?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Come. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, come on. Yeah.
Yeah. Yep. You’re all the same. All the same is good. I’m different.
So, let us take the case of a university, student. A university student has all of the studies of a high school and a primary school student. So in other words, a university student has, as a condition for his study at university, these studies during primary school and high school. Now, you are implying that the realizations of a being of the great scope are contradictory with the realizations of a being of the middling or the small scope. So the realizations of the great middling and small scope are not contradictory.
So in general, these realizations are different. But within the continuum of a being of the great scope has gained the realizations of the great scope, what are these realizations? That’s what is asking. Is the thought, of benefiting and actualizing the happiness of others present within the mind stream of beings of the small and middling scope or not?
Basis. So so in order to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all beings, I must practice Yes. Exactly the answer. It’s a motivation. Then because it depends on the motivation, not only are they not contradictory, they’re probably synonymous.
So as Saphros said, in the mind stream of a being of the great scope, when the thought of benefiting and actualizing the happiness of others is present, this thought actually presupposes also the presence of definite emergence, and that presupposes also striving for future lives. So all of this is rooted in the motivation. So this meets or encounters the motivation. A practitioner of the Mahāyāna is a practitioner who practices for the sake of others. This is rooted in motivation.
When one is motivated exclusively by one’s own self interest, and one is striving for liberation, then one is a mere practitioner of the, middling scope. However, when, one is motivated by the wish to attain the enlightenment for the sake of all, even though renunciation or definite emergence is present within one’s own mind stream, it is not for one’s own soul’s sake. You can see why motivation is so important. And as, Je Tsongkhapa says in his three principles of the path, for so long as definite emergence is not upheld by the pure thought, it will not become a perfect cause for enlightenment. Now the pure thought here refers to bodhicitta, and this indicates that for so long as definite emergence is not upheld by the motivation of bodhicitta, it does not become a cause for full enlightenment.
Now the, thought, which wishes to benefit others and actualize their happiness is therefore a thought which is present within the mind stream of the being of the middling scope. Why? You could say because it is upheld by definite emergence. And this thought is also present within the mind stream of the being of the small scope. Why?
Because it is upheld by the wish to attain a higher rebirth. Also, at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, one has all of the realizations of the path of the being of the small scope just as when one enters university as a condition of entering into university studies, one must have all the studies of the lower levels high school and so forth. So what is the reward for ourselves of studying the Mahāyāna, the path of the being of the great scope? Why bother? We know in our lives that difficulties occur, difficulties with family, difficulties with relatives, difficulties with friends.
When these difficulties occur, these lines of thinking from the being of the great scope are probably of benefit. Then what is dharma? Dharma is basically advice for the mind. Advice is something which benefits us. Then ideally, we would engage in these studies with the intention of practicing.
But even if that is perhaps too advanced for us, nonetheless, when difficulties arise within our lives, this advice for the mind, it will be of great benefit. This is a great reward because, when we experience, hardship or difficulties at work or with our family, probably all of us, are convinced that these difficulties, these hardship, these problems come from others. They come from the outside. They have nothing to do with us personally. And, to understand that these hardships, root cause is our own egoism, our own self cherishing, this is a great reward.
Because if we view the source of the hardship as coming from others, not only will they they not, be eliminated, but the difficulties in hardship will become worse. Then as Togme Zangpo in his 37 practices of a bodhisattva says, childish ones do not see their faults within themselves. And ourselves, we see exclusively the source of unhappiness in others. Therefore, this is a great reward for us. If through studying the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism through numerous lines of reasoning and the qualities of altruism or cherishing others through numerous lines of reasoning, we understand that all our suffering is rooted within ourselves, then what exactly are we going to do?
Well, banging your head against the door won’t help. Other lines of analysis in Buddhadharma such as the fact that all our suffering arises from karma accumulated during previous lives are difficult lines of reasoning. We have to accept the existence of past and future lives. But, these lines of reasoning which point out that, our suffering arises from egoism or self cherishing, these are quite easy to understand. So there is really food for thought here.
So the faults of self cherishing, egoism have been explained in detail previously. And when one is able to counter self cherishing or egoism, then one will also have eliminated the wish to attain liberation for one’s own sake, the wish to attain the state of an arhat for one’s own sake. So even though in the very short term, the proximate cause of one’s suffering might be others, the moment we start looking at the long term, it is our own egoism or self cherishing. And this is evident if we take the example, for instance, of overindulging in food. If out of craving, for, good food, we eat well in excess of what we should, then unavoidably, we will get a stomachache.
Whose fault is a stomachache? Then, obviously, with worldly food, the problem is our incapacity to be satisfied with food. Then, the fault of self cherishing, are not difficult to understand. What is difficult is obviously getting a realization which enables us to discard self cherishing. And here in the Mahāyāna, courage is called for.
One needs to have courage. One should not be weak and bowed down like this. Instead, one must be strong and courageous. Now there is much food for thought in the reflections on the faults of self cherishing and the qualities of cherishing others. Once one has gained a realization of the faults of self cherishing, then an understanding of the qualities of altruism or cherishing others arises quite naturally.
Here, it should be pretty evident that, our happiness depends on others. If we take a simple example, when it’s cold outdoors, it is quite
Pleasant to be in the temple here, and to have a a source of heat. But the reverse cycle AC unit, which heats the temple, is not something we made ourselves. It comes from a factory. Others made it for us. Then, that reverse cycle AC unit needs electricity to work.
We didn’t make the electricity. Electricity is matter. Someone else provides electricity. So this all comes from others. I can see by your faces that these lines of reasoning are quite alien to you.
Then, ask yourself what exactly will happening happen in this fancy country if they they cut electricity for just one minute? Difficulties. Right? Everything stops. Right?
Imagine for yourselves what our lives would be like if there was no power for just one minute. We’d be freezing right now. Then, the only way to understand the kindness of others to us is to think where we would be if what they give us was absent. So the kindness of the people providing electricity is there. It’s very helpful to think along these lines.
The main obstacle to attaining final happiness is our obsession with short term contingent happiness. Short term contingent happiness prevents us from attaining final happiness. One of the main reasons for the mentality of entitlement, which leads people not to be grateful to others for something like electricity, is that I hear over and again people will say, well, after all, I paid for it. I gave others money for it. So when after analysis, we are finally able to, generate this understanding of the thoughts of self cherishing and the qualities of self of cherishing others, then we will discard our self cherishing or egoism and, we will embrace others and embrace altruism.
And an example makes this very clear. If you have planted a tree and you water only one, side of the tree, but never water the other side, You will notice that over time, the tree which is inanimate matter will lean in the direction, which you have been watering, and it will actually turn away from the dry area. Now this is what inanimate matter does. How much more so sentient beings? The side of the tree which is watered will be covered with leaves and fruit, and the tree will be inclined in this direction, and the other direction will be dry.
Then the part of the tree which is watered will have beautiful fruits and leaves, and the other part will be dry and withered. And this is how inanimate matter behaves. And, therefore, after engaging repeatedly in an analysis of the faults of egoism through numerous lines of reasoning and the qualities of altruism through numerous lines of reasoning, eventually, I suspect great compassion will arise naturally or spontaneously. Then once one has engaged in the equalization and interchange of self and others, at that point, as was explained last time, one engages in the in the practice of or giving and taking. So in the practice of giving and taking, the treatises present giving one’s happiness to others first and taking their suffering upon oneself in second place.
However, when one actually engages in the practice, one takes first upon oneself the suffering of others or the suffering of all sentient beings or the suffering of humans, and then one gives to others one’s happiness. Now, within the sufferings of the three times, past, present, and future sufferings, we cannot take past sufferings, upon oneself. They have already occurred. But we do take present and future sufferings of all sentient beings upon oneself, and these target one’s own self cherishing. Now those of low minds, in other words, those of dull acumen, will initially proceed by taking their own suffering upon themselves.
This refers to their suffering first of today, then of tomorrow, then of next week, and then they extend this to the suffering of their relatives, those who are indifferent to them, and eventually their enemies. Now probably once the stable practice of equalization and interchange of self and others has occurred, fully characterized great compassion will have occurred as well. Once one has generated a powerful and stable experience of equalization and interchange of self and others, at this point, one is able to take the engaging bodhisattva vows, which involve physical and verbal activities precisely because one’s inner mental state is stable. And at this point, one can engage in activities such as offering one’s body, offering one’s head and so forth, offering one’s body for instance, becomes easy at this point. At present, our incapacity to donate to others, our eyes, our limbs, our body, our liver, arises from the fact that we lack a stable interior experience.
At present, in the context of meditating on the motivation, let us reflect first on the thoughts of self cherishing and in dependence on this give rise to an appreciation of the qualities of cherishing others. Please open the puja book. We recite page one, and page two, three, four, and page five. Number six, Mandala offering, one and three.
So once through numerous lines of reasoning, one has generated this awareness of the faults of self cherishing, then one will naturally give rise to, cherishing others. And here, cherishing others refers to having empathy for others. This empathy for others, is probably, identical to great compassion. Then, this is all I had to say today. And at present, if you could ask your questions, short, concise questions, please.
From my observation, his holiness to Dalai Lama appears to try to help each and every being in any way he can who comes into his presence. Last week, Geshe la stated that the provision that you a mind of bodhichitta, which has been generated incontrovertibly, whether that necessarily entails helping every individual sentient being at a given point in time is open to question. So, my question is, don’t you agree that his holiness does try to help each and every being who comes into his presence? No. There is no doubt that someone who has generated a bodhicitta within his mind stream will help all sentient beings without exception.
What there is a doubt about is whether that help will take a physical and verbal form as I said last week. With respect to Tong Ling, is there any particular reason why in the text it might say giving and taking, in practice yes. Giving and taking, but in practice, the giving is is in many written teachings on giving and taking. Yes. I understand your question.
Yes. So the main reason is euphonics. Sounds better than. Apart from that, there’s no reason. So, the authors had to think here of euphonics.
I have two question. One question is the, just now when you talk about the, great vehicle, something about courage. What in what context is that referred to? So, here, when we speak of great courage, really what we mean is that the wish to help and to benefit others is not merely verbal, but arises from deep within the mind of the person. Then when it arises from deep within the mind of the person, that courage, that force will be present.
And this is why the sons of the conquerors are said to be beings of which have a strong heart or a strong mind. And another question is about a being of self cherishing that in the middling scope. Mhmm. Mhmm. They they already have the mind stream of liberation, but still have the self cherishing.
Mhmm. Mhmm. My question is, do they have ignorance in their mind stream? Those who have Still have basically. Yeah.
Yeah. Still have ignorance. Have self cherishing within their mind stream. They don’t have ignorance. Don’t have ignorance.
Sorry. Geshe la, I got a bit confused earlier with the motivation realization. I understand about the motivation, But can I clarify, were you saying that beings on the on the small of the small scope and the middling scope do have realizations of altruism? No. The beings who have trained in the path of the being of the small scope and have not the realizations of the path of the being of the great scope have no altruism within their mind stream.
Likewise, beings who have trained the path of the middling scope, but not in the path of the great scope have no altruism or cherishing others within their mind stream. So a source of confusion might be that one does not understand that while, a being of the great scope, has within his mind stream the realizations of beings of the small and the middling scope, the converse is not true. That’s what I thought. Thank you. But there’s the motivation is there even though it’s not a stable stable realization in the mind stream.
But the motivation is there which periodically comes up in in acts of kindness and and empathy for others even though it’s within the in the small and the middling scope. What’s your question? That there there would be the the motivation would be there, nevertheless, of kindness and and altruism. But even if it’s not as a stable realization within the mind stream, it might be there periodically. It would come up every now and then in in acts of kindness.
Would that be so? Yes. It happens. It happens. Geshe la, sometimes things are is it the case that things can be arrived at, not through, lines of reasoning, but through getting a really big wonderful shock from a teacher.
Like, for example, when you first taught eight verses for training the
Mind. You said your enemy is the cause of your patience, and that was a huge, big shock for me, but a really important one. I had no reasoning prior to hearing that, and it wasn’t until I heard that that I realized just how wrong I’d been. So sometimes it’s through a big wonderful shock or if that makes sense. Is is that the case?
Sometimes it isn’t just through numerous lines of reasoning, but shock. Yes. It does happen that through, such powerful advice, the mind changes, but it is only temporary. It is not a stable state of affairs. To change a mind durably and stably, we need reasons.
Yes. Clearly, when you actualize the welfare of others, actualize your own welfare. So for beginners like ourselves, obviously, when we, train, in the bodhisattva path, we have no experience of the bodhisattva path, and, we tend to look immediately at our own self benefit. Now that is not how we should practice. Instead, we should say, I’m just practicing the bodhisattva path.
When is it appropriate for, let’s say, someone who’s trying to develop bodhicitta? When is it appropriate for someone who may be trying to develop bodhicitta to think, well, that’s his karma. I’m not gonna worry about that person. Definitely, one can think about karma. And, obviously, when there are physical problems, health problems, then it is not terribly helpful to say this is due to karma.
Instead, we should go see a doctor, rely on the doctor’s advice, and do what he says. One question which or leitmotif in your questions is, here, if we are focusing on the happiness of others, what about our own happiness? Then, generally speaking, others experience two types of suffering, physical and mental suffering. The goal of these practices is to eliminate not the physical suffering but the mental suffering of others to lead them therefore to a state of happiness. Now when others are led to the state of happiness, this naturally impacts our own happiness.
Geshe-la, what if that person that you are trying to help lead to mental happiness is just going around in circles and doesn’t have the capacity to make that untroubled mind? Then if you keep on going, is that interfering with their karma? What do you mean when you say you’re preventing, him from experiencing his karma? I think it might be a Western thing where lots of people think that they can rescue somebody who’s obviously mentally suffering, and that person, either doesn’t have the motivation or the capacity to, have an untroubled mind. If you persist in a situation that you can see won’t be fixed, is that interfering with their mental destiny or what is going to happen to them?
Is that their karma ripening that they haven’t been given the opportunity mentally to resolve the troubled mind themselves. The most important thing, and the most important way to help people who experience mental suffering is to give them advice. That’s all you can do. So following on from that one, if you’ve had difficulties with somebody and that your interaction with them has caused them to become angry or negative emotions arise, is that their karma, or is there a cause and effect? Is there a mutual sort of exchange of of negative karma?
Do you can you understand that? I don’t think you can exchange karma. In cases like that, the most important is to think carefully by oneself what these difficulties or where these difficulties come from and, to see whether they come from one’s own egoism, the egoism of the other person, or both egoisms. Then to eliminate these difficulties, we have to reduce our own egoism, our own self cherishing. If we reduce it, they disappear by themselves.
Okay. Stop here tonight. Okay. Ejed, have your question? We can purify our own karma.
Then, obviously, we cannot purify the karma of another person. However, what we can do is direct them towards studying means to purify their own karma. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do practitioners of the small scope and middling scope have realizations of altruism?
No. Beings who have trained in the path of the small scope, but have not realized the path of the great scope, have no altruism in their mind stream. Likewise, beings who have trained in the path of the middling scope, but not in the path of the great scope, have no altruism or cherishing of others in their mind stream. A possible source of confusion is not understanding that a being of the great scope has within their mind stream the realizations of the small and middling scopes. The converse is not true: those of the small and middling scopes do not have the realizations of the great scope.