TBI Recordings

1 h 2 min · 2,456 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 63-minute session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores a central puzzle in Cittamātra Buddhist philosophy: how karmic imprints are deposited and maintained when the six collections of consciousness cease during deep sleep or unconsciousness. He begins by establishing that while the agents depositing imprints can be virtuous or non-virtuous, the imprints themselves are always neutral. He then presents competing Indian Buddhist positions on whether imprints are primordially existent or dependent on depositing consciousness, before laying out Tsongkhapa’s own twofold system. The crux of the teaching is a logical challenge: if consciousness must be manifest to exist, and all six consciousnesses cease in deep sleep, how are imprints deposited when only the mind basis of all remains? Geshe tackles this by scrutinising what it means for a consciousness to be manifest, using examples of simultaneous sensory awareness and emotional states to probe whether different consciousnesses can function together. The session includes extended practitioner dialogue on the nature of consciousness, the possibility of subtle or non-manifest states, and whether anger and compassion can coexist in the same moment. Demanding philosophical work suited to students already familiar with Cittamātra terminology and debates.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 22082017cittamatra.mp3

UUID: 74d17cb5-916b-4648-8660-38bccccb0142

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,454

So at present regarding the imprints, the nature of imprints is to be neutral. And on the one hand, the depositors of the imprints, of the karmic imprints can be virtuous, non virtuous or neutral, but the imprint itself is always neutral. For this reason, in stanza 27, Tsongkhapa says in the root text, irrespective of whether the depositor is virtuous and so forth, the deposited imprint is neutral. Now moving downwards regarding the mode of deposition of the karmic imprints, scholars consider that it is threefold. And then moving on, this is not printed in your root text.

The root text of Jetsongkopa reads as follows. The mode of deposition of imprints is threefold. The, previously unabiding, thusness is generated apart from that twofold it is asserted to be. Now an Indian scholar is mentioned in the root text. Geshe does not remember his name, but he asserts that imprints are primordially existent.

So some scholars therefore including this scholar assert that imprints do not depend on their depositing consciousness, and this scholar therefore asserts that they are primordially existent. Others, on the other hand, assert that imprints depend on the depositing consciousness. So some Indian scholars therefore assert that karmic imprints are primordially existent, and they refer specifically to those abiding in thusness. Others, on the other hand, assert that karmic imprints are not primordially existent. They are asserted to be threefold.

However, Tsongkhapa’s own system is that there are only two categories of karmic imprints. The first are primordially existent. These are established from the beginning as thusness. And the second are karmic imprints which rely on the depositing consciousness. And therefore, as was said, karmic imprints are twofold.

The first are primordially established. These are imprints of the nature of suchness and specifically refer to the nature of the lineage. So next year, Geshela will teach in detail the Buddha lineage, sometimes called the Buddha nature. This is taught extensively in Tsongkhapa’s commentary, but Keshe la will not enter into it now. The excuse me.

The other category of karmic imprints are the usual karmic imprints deposited by consciousnesses. So here in the context of Stanza 27, irrespective of whether the depositor is virtuous and so forth, the deposited imprint is neutral. A doubt arises, which is covered on Page 47, I believe, of Tsongkhapa’s commentary, page 48 handed out to you, today. The doubt is as follows. Point three of the first section of, that doubt.

After obtaining vows for so long as they were not repudiated, virtue would not arise continually. Indeed, what is being said is that once one has taken vows, then when, for instance, the six collections of consciousness cease, then at that point, the infuser of the karmic imprints would disappear, and since an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues produces its results in dependence on karmic imprints, then there would be no more any accrual of merit. The same would be true for instance if one took refuge vows. So here the doubt which is being mentioned is that, for instance, when we are in deep sleep, the six collections of consciousness cease. Now, in as much as that which maintains the continuity of the vows is the karmic imprint of these vows, if we assert that this karmic imprint is neutral, as is asserted in the doubt in the root text of Tsongkhapa on page 48, then this would be inappropriate.

So according to Cittamātra, as you remember in deep sleep and when we faint or in a coma, these six collections of consciousness cease. Then in this case, that which is of the nature of the vows, the ethics of the vows would no longer exist. So what’s being said is that in deep sleep we have no refuge, right? Then as you remember in deep sleep or in a coma, the six consciousnesses have ceased or that is left is the ālāyavijñāna, then that would mean that we have no refuge. Then we would have to conclude that we are not Buddhist in this state.

This is a debate. So the crux here to understand this debate is that according to Chitamatra, whatever is a consciousness is necessarily manifest. Then if, for instance, the visual consciousness was present during deep sleep, it would necessarily be manifest. And obviously, in that case, we wouldn’t be sleeping to start with. So this is not something you need to refer to text to.

This was explained many times before. According to Chitamatra in deep sleep, the six collections of consciousness cease and the only consciousness which is present is the mind basis of all. So therefore, it is established as a base that in deep sleep, the ālāyavijñāna is present. Now, if according to Chitamatra, all consciousnesses are necessarily manifest, if the mental consciousness was present in deep sleep, the question which arises is what its mode of being manifest would be. Now this is a loaded issue which calls for careful analysis.

Now, here in Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen, the textbook author of Sera Je, commentaries on the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka system, it is taught that during the uninterrupted path of the path of seeing, in addition to the direct perception realizing emptiness, there also is present the six perfections, bodhichitta, and so forth, albeit in non manifest fashion. Here, in cittamatra, this is said not to be the case. And the issue which arises is whether the mental consciousness can be said to be present or not in deep sleep, and if so, what its mode of manifestation would be. So irrespective of the consciousness, what is its mode of manifestation? For instance, if we take the mental consciousness, how does it manifest?

It’s a question. Doesn’t matter, it is one way of looking at things. So if we take the case of someone who has realized bodhichitta, in other words, who has a realization or an experience of bodhichitta. Then in the mind of that person, bodhichitta is manifest, but, great compassion is necessarily also manifest. For that matter, Geshela says, the grasping at permanence would also probably be manifest.

So as is said in a passage of sūtra, sentient beings are their respective continuum of consciousness. So the meaning of this stanza is from the standpoint of Sūtrayāna that Buddha has taught that two consciousnesses of different substance cannot be present simultaneously in the same continuum. So this is quite important. What is being said is that two consciousnesses of different substance cannot be simultaneous. However, the six collections of consciousness are simultaneous, aren’t they?

Yes or no? Yes or no? Okay. So we therefore agree that the collections of sensory consciousnesses are simultaneously manifestly present even though they are different substances. This seems, however, to contradict the statement in sūtra in which Buddha says, sentient beings have individual consciousnesses, which is interpreted as meaning that there cannot be consciousnesses of different substance within the continuum of one sentient being.

So at present, let us meditate during a couple minutes on the mode of manifestation of the different collections of consciousnesses. Can they manifest simultaneously or not and how? So first, let us meditate on how consciousnesses manifest, and secondly, within the six collections of consciousness, whether they can manifest simultaneously or not, and if so, how. So what do you have to say about the mode of manifestation of consciousness? With regard to your first question about the manifestation of the mental consciousness in sleep.

I was wondering if in Cittamātra they could accept that there’s a subtle level of the mental consciousness as some of the other schools also accept. Well, when you talk of subtle mental consciousness apart from the ālāyavijñāna, there’s nothing else. Apart from the ālāyavijñāna, all the other consciousnesses have ceased. First, what is the mode of becoming manifest or manifestation of consciousness? It is the ripening of karmic imprints.

So first to understand what is meant by the mode of becoming manifest, ask yourself what it means when your mental consciousness becomes manifest or when your sensory consciousness has become manifest, and then extend or extrapolate this to bodhichitta and so forth. So what happened? Let me put it very simply. How do you know that you think? I’m aware of my thinking through How do you know that you think?

Through self reflection. So generally speaking, six collections of consciousness are present within our continuum. But whether they are manifest or not and their mode of being manifest, that is the question. Okay. Yep.

I would say that the consciousness takes an object and so to know that I’m thinking, I will take myself as an object of being one who is thinking. So the consciousness takes an object. Doesn’t really get to the hell part. A debater would answer to you in Tibetan. Something which is a consciousness is necessarily a subject.

You haven’t said anything. Necessarily has an object. So here’s the problem, as you understand, is that for Chitamatra, the mind basis of all is the basis in which karmic imprints are infused. The infuser are the six consciousnesses. Now these six consciousnesses are not present in deep sleep.

According to Chitamatra, if a consciousness is non manifest, it does not exist. So for the infusion of karmic imprints to occur in deep sleep, the consciousnesses must be manifest. What is their mode of being manifest? So let us make it simpler. Let’s set aside the six collections of consciousness.

Let us consider the five collections of consciousness, sensory consciousnesses. Can the sensory consciousnesses be manifest simultaneously or not? I would say yes. Because if I could only hear without any other consciousness being present, that would mean that whenever you speak, I would go blind. Is there a simultaneous utilization of the five sensory consciousnesses or not?

This is what you have to think about. So if we analyze, we first have visual experience, visual consciousness operating, then auditory consciousness, then maybe olfactory consciousness, then perhaps olfactory and gustatory may be simultaneous or not. That is worth checking. Then tactile consciousness, then mental consciousness. So can they be simultaneous or not?

So yes to what? Simultaneously manifest. Because I’m hearing and seeing and feeling, smelling all at the same time. Basically, it should be self evident to us that the visual consciousness, the auditory consciousness, and the mental consciousness can be simultaneous. So it should be evident the object of visual consciousness is whatever you see, The object of auditory consciousness is sound.

The object of mental consciousness is thinking. And these can occur simultaneously. Clear, right? Was thinking about the example of do you see water? You don’t see water.

You only know that it’s water when you feel it. So visual consciousness is seeing an object and it’s relaying that information to the mind, but it’s incorrect. When we say in a mundane context, I see water, what we actually mean is that we see the color of water, whatever the color of water might be under the circumstances. So we have established at least that three of the six collections of consciousness can be simultaneously manifest. This is a visual consciousness, the auditory consciousness, and the mental consciousness.

Now what’s your opinion about the other ones? So the question obviously is can we have a simultaneous manifest experience of all six collections of consciousness? Now when we talk of the Alāyavijñāna, obviously, we have no manifest experience of the Alāyavijñāna at all. Right? Let’s go.

What is your thinking about the manifest simultaneous experience of all six? If you were going to accept that three consciousnesses can be manifest at one time, then I would accept that all six could be manifest at one time. Interesting outlook. Certainly, you can have the physical sensation of touch and the mental consciousness manifest at the same time. Which ones?

You can have touch and the mental consciousness manifest at the same time. When I drive a very old car and it’s quite obvious that I have to be really careful if I smell something rubber burning while driving, then something happening in the mouth or smell. If I feel hot air from somewhere, then it could be overheating. It’s thinking, it could be something wrong with engine or these sort of things. So it could be spontaneous.

So the way to look at it is if we take, for instance, the object of the visual consciousness and the object of the auditory consciousness, they do not interfere with each other, nor does the object of the auditory consciousness interfere with the experience of the olfactory or the gustatory or for that matter, the tactile consciousness to the difference of, for instance, anger and bodhichitta, where they interfere with each other. This is how one should look at it. Now for instance, having generated bodhichitta, when bodhichitta is manifest, great compassion is necessarily manifest as well. Their manifestation is simultaneous, they depend on each other. Change.

Today, we have reflected on the simultaneous manifestation of the five collections of consciousness or perhaps their usage, I hope. And there is a lot of food for thought in the context of the Four Noble Truths with this. Let’s at present do the recitations. Page one. And on the other hand, it is important to understand why, for instance, anger observing a sentient being, and great compassion observing a sentient being, for instance, are not able to be manifest simultaneously.

And it’s not sufficient to say that they are contradictory. One must give a reason for this contradictoriness. Then whether the six sensory consciousnesses, the five sensory consciousness, sorry, can be present simultaneously and manifestly or not, I personally believe that they can be, and the example, he would give is that of having a good meal with a friend. Then in his opinion, all five are present, but you should check for yourselves. So one has to check whether sensation, tactile sensation, in other words bodily consciousness is manifest or not.

So you can see when you’re having a good meal with friends that definitely the visual consciousness is present. You see the food. The auditory consciousness is, present and manifest. You listen to the conversation. The olfactory present, you smell the food.

The gustatory, consciousness, you taste the food. And then one has to examine the status of the bodily or tactile consciousness. Then at present, let us start the debates. Please don’t have large groups like last time. Five is of no benefit.

By groups of two, three if you cannot do it by groups of two for the absolute maximum. Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top