1 h 8 min · 3,087 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen untangles a crucial distinction for Tibetan Buddhist philosophy in this 68-minute teaching on the Mind-Only school: the difference between proponents of a philosophical tenet system and practitioners of its corresponding path. Using rigorous logical analysis, he explores four possible combinations—a Mahāyāna proponent who is not a Mahāyāna practitioner; a practitioner with Mahāyāna motivation who rejects Cittamātra tenets; and so on—showing that philosophical position and spiritual motivation operate independently. The talk then pivots to textual proof for the Alaya Vijñāna (the basis-of-all consciousness) and the Klishtamanas (afflicted mind), foundational concepts Je Tsongkhapa calls “extremely difficult.” Geshe-la walks through the first proof—appropriation—using concrete examples: the six consciousnesses cannot connect us across dreamless sleep or explain vivid dreams unrelated to waking experience. These gaps reveal why we must posit a subtle, stable, neutral mind beneath the ordinary six consciousnesses. The session ends with a practical discussion prompt: students work in small groups to clarify the four logical possibilities and explore how dream consciousness relates to the basis-of-all. Intended for serious Buddhist philosophy students.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 24102017 Cittamātra.mp3
UUID: 9fd14712-4ffb-448b-9b65-52f7281aa870
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,083
So in the root text of Je Tsongkhapa, stanza two, Je Tsongkhapa says, for the sake of healing my memory and teaching clearly mind and basis of all, I will explain here the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijnapti Matrata. So here, these extremely difficult topics are subtle topics which need to be explained. So when Je Tsongkhapa refers to the extremely difficult topics, one must understand why these topics are extremely difficult. Why these are in Tibetan. And the difficult topics which are covered are specifically the Alaya Vijñāna and the Klishtamanas.
So even though these are topics which have already been explained, Geshe-la would like to emphasize the importance in distinguishing between propounders of Mahāyāna tenets on the one hand, and Mahāyāna beings on the other hand, or propounders of Hīnayāna tenets on the one hand, and Hīnayāna beings on the other hand. And he suspects probably you confuse these categories. Then if one is unable to clarify this, one cannot pose the foundation of Cittamātra correctly. So between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna practitioners, as far as what is practiced is concerned, there is not one iota of difference. Both rely upon the four noble truths, upon the 37 limbs of enlightenment, and on the presentation of the 12 limbs in the forward and the reverse sequence.
The difference between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna practitioners occurs in terms of the motivation. Now even though one is a Mahāyāna being, one does not definitely have to accept the establishment of the Mahāyāna view, and even though one is a Hīnayāna being, one does not necessarily have to accept the establishment of the Hīnayāna view. Now, in Tibetan, one refers to the lands of the Hīnayāna, Theravāda countries, and as far as establishment of the view is concerned, probably in Theravāda countries, one only accepts the sutras of the Buddha which are literal or definitive. Probably one does not accept any type of secret mantra practice, And this would be characteristic of the tenets of the hearers and the Pratyekabuddha. So the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrantikas assert that whatever is an utterance of the Buddha is necessarily a is necessarily a definitive truth and literal.
And in most Theravāda countries, it is considered that the Mahāyāna scriptures are not authentic. They are not the teachings of the Buddha, but they do accept the existence of Bodhisattvas since Buddha Śākyamūni himself traveled on the path of the Bodhisattvas. So therefore, one is a Mahāyāna being, if you prefer a bodhisattva, one does not necessarily accept the establishment of the Mahāyāna view. Likewise, if one accepts the establishment of the Mahāyāna view, in other words, is the propound of Mahāyāna tenets, one does not necessarily one is not necessarily a Mahāyāna being, and therefore there is three or four logical possibilities between these two and the same line of reasoning can be extended to Hīnayāna beings and propounders of Hīnayāna tenets. So as you remember, propounders of Mahāyāna views are subdivided into propounders of the Cittamātra and the Madhyamaka view.
And if we look at the logical possibilities, the moves between, on the one hand, for instance, a propounder of Cittamātra tenets, and on the other hand, a Mahāyāna being, we can see that there are four moves. There is a being who is both a propounder of Cittamātra tenets and a Mahāyāna being. There are propounders of Cittamātra tenets who are not Mahāyāna beings. There are Mahāyāna beings who are not propounders of Cittamātra tenets, and there are, there is a case of someone who is neither a propound of Cittamātra tenets, nor a Mahāyāna being. So if one analyzes in this way, things become clearer.
Now regarding the relationship between Mahāyāna beings and propounders of Mahāyāna tenets, can you give an example of a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets who is not a Mahāyāna being? We covered that already. So being with a Hīnayāna motivation, who has holds Cittamātra or Madhyamaka tenets? So can you put it in a clearer, more pure fashion? So the Hīnayāna by motivation, Mahāyāna by tenets.
And other one, yeah, you can pass. There’s a lot of, for example here in Vietnamese temple, they are Mahāyāna being. They follow Mahāyāna path, but they the the way they practice is only for their own gain. So is that that’s like a Hīnayāna. You?
Yes. But that’s not quite it. Lamrim speaks about this a lot that if the motivation is not stable, then one studies, but actually one studies are for one’s own sake. But Geshe was asking in terms of tenet systems. So to repeat, Geshe-la would like an instance of a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets, who is not a Mahāyāna being.
So think about it. So if you take our own cases, we are at present studying the Cittamātra system in considerable depth. But that does not mean that we actually endorse the Cittamātra tenet system and think this is a supreme tenet systems. If that were the case, let’s say in a country like this one, everyone would be in Cittamātra. Obviously, are not.
Then you are perfectly entitled to whatever view you wish to have. Geshe-la is not saying you must have this or that view. Buddha Śākyamūni taught four different systems of tenets, and we should endorse or accept the one in keeping with our mental disposition. So what is an instance of a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets who is not a Mahāyāna being? Okay.
Perhaps a scholar who has not generated any bodhicitta but agrees with the Cittamātra view of the universe. Yes. Yes. That is more or less it. Best of you say if he dwells in the Cittamātra view, you can just say someone who hasn’t generated bodhicitta, but accepts the Cittamātra view.
When we speak of a Mahāyāna being, such a being must have generated fully characterized bodhicitta, must have an experience of bodhicitta. So the examples you gave were those of beings who had not generated bodhicitta, but accepted nonetheless the Cittamātra view. A pure example, an accurate example would be to say a Śrāvaka or a hearer who is a Chitamatran by view. It’s better to put it like that. So what instance now can you give of a Mahāyāna being who does not accept Cittamātra tenets?
A bodhisattva who is either a practitioner in the Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika or Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. So in other words, a bodhisattva who accepts the tenets of the hearers. So indeed, a Bodhisattva who accepts the two systems of tenets of the hearers would be a Mahāyāna being who does not propound Cittamātra tenets. So what example or instance can you give of a more logical possibility of both, a part of Cittamātra tenets and a Mahāyāna being? A Cittamātra by view and a Cittamātra by practice.
Is that the case? I could say, okay, a bodhisattva with a Cittamātra view. So which move is neither? In other words, neither a Mahāyāna being nor a propounder of Cittamātra tenets. That’s easy.
A person who has a Hīnayāna view. So now likewise, let us analyze the moves of the logical possibilities between Hīnayāna beings and propounders of Hīnayāna tenets. So first, what is the more the possibility for a Hīnayāna being who is not a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets? A hearer who holds the Chitamantra view. What more can you give for a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets who is not a Hīnayāna being?
A propounder of Hīnayāna tenets who is not a Hīnayāna being. It’s not a private class. A bodhisattva who accepts the Vaibhāṣika tenets. That’s it. Or a bodhisattva who accepts either the Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika tenets.
So Geshe-la, wonder sometimes whether when you give these examples, you think that nonetheless this being is somehow practicing Hīnayāna Dharma. Are you not confused by that? Okay. If you’re confused, please ask questions. If you have doubts and you ask questions, your understanding will become pure.
You do understand that in the move for a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, who is not a Hīnayāna being, the example you gave is someone who does not practice Hīnayāna Dharma. Do you understand? Sure. Does that mean Hīnayāna Dharma and Hīnayāna Tenet, they’re separate things to be studied? Yes.
Big difference. Based on that difference, you gave the example. The foundation of Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma is the four noble truths, the 37 limbs of enlightenment, and the 12 limbs. There is no difference in terms of the foundation. The difference between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma is in terms of the motivation.
Then we say carefully that we are explaining or teaching Mahāyāna Dharma, or that when we read the Lamrim, we are reading Mahāyāna Dharma. But actually, unless we have generated a motivation of bodhicitta, it is difficult for this to be Mahāyāna Dharma. Okay. Now what is the move between someone who is a Hīnayāna being, but is not a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets? Can you give me, for example?
So the previous one was a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, who is not a Hīnayāna being, and that is a bodhisattva endorsing the Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika view. That was the first one. The second one is a propounder of a Hīnayāna being who is not a propound of Hīnayāna tenets. That’s what we’re talking about now. You are confused about the two moves.
Shall we cover again? So the first move is a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, who is not a Hīnayāna being. So what is that? So that is a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, but it is not a Hīnayāna being. It’s a Bodhisattva.
Right? Second move. So who is a Hīnayāna being, but not a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets? A hearer who accepts Cittamātra tenets. That’s it.
Yes. Who is both? A Hīnayāna being and a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets? A hearer who accepts Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika tenets. Who is neither?
A bodhisattva who accepts Cittamātra. So are you confused about these moves or not? Really? Sure. And a person.
Something about, you say about does not practice the Hīnayāna Dharma. Mhmm. What’s the relation with the mood? So in the context of the move of someone who is a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, but not a Hīnayāna being. Such a person is practicing, such a person is not practicing for their own sake.
Therefore, such a person is not a Hīnayāna practitioner. Even though they are propounder of Hīnayāna tenets. Do you understand? So the foundations of Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma are the same. It is the four noble truths, 37 factors of enlightenment and the 12 limbs.
The difference is the motivation. It is not the view. It becomes Hīnayāna dharma with a Hīnayāna motivation and Mahāyāna dharma with a Mahāyāna motivation. Alright. Okay.
So now returning to the root text of Je Tsongkhapa. In stanza two, Je Tsongkhapa refers to the extremely difficult topics of the Vijnapti Matrata. These extremely difficult topics are first the definitions of the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all and the Klishtamanas or the afflicted mind. Now that has basically been covered and at present we are moving onwards to the second outline which is the proofs of the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind bases of all and the Klishtamanas. And a third and fourth outline may or may not come later.
So this second outline, the proofs of the existence of Alaya Vijñāna and Cittamātra, and Alaya Vijñāna and Klishtamanas begins on page six of your text, stanza 35. The existence of a mind and consciousness basis of all different from the six consciousnesses should be interiorized through credible scripture and logic. And it moves onwards with stanza 36. Although, logical proofs are stated in the systems of treaties of the Vijnapti Matrata and so forth. Now here, the first category of proofs is scriptural proofs.
There are numerous passages of Buddhist scriptures such as sections of the Samdhinirmochana Sūtra or the Lankavatara sūtra, which refer both to the Alaya Vijñāna and the Krishnamanas. Although there are also a large number of logical proofs referred to in stanza 36, when you summarize them, there are eight. So in this respect, the first term of stanza 36, although, countless logical proofs are stated in the systems of the treaties of the Vijnapti Matrata is very important. The first is in Tibetan or appropriation. So this, it is precisely this which is referred to in the final verse of stanza two, the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijnapti Matrata.
This these extremely difficult topics are the final two of the eight collections of consciousness. In other words, the afflicted mind and the mind basis of all. Simply because we have direct experience of the five sensory consciousnesses, and we also have direct experience of thinking, the mental consciousness. But we have no direct experience of either the afflicted mind, the seventh, or the mind basis of all the eight consciousness. So the first proof is appropriation.
The meaning of appropriation or taking here is that if the ālaya vijnana did not exist, then the afflicted mind whose object it is could also not exist. Then if that was the case, it is the six collections of consciousness, the five sensory consciousnesses and the mental consciousness, which would actually have to link the aggregates of this life with the aggregates of future lives. Literally, they would have to take or to appropriate the aggregates of future lives. So an example will make this clear. Let us consider our present life.
Now to fall asleep at night, the six consciousnesses as we know them must cease. Then we wake up the next morning. Something must have related the aggregates before falling to sleep with the aggregates after waking up. That something according to Cittamātra is the ālaya vijnana, the mind basis of all. Do you understand, So let us analyze further.
One has fallen into a deep sleep, and one wakes from this deep sleep. In the sleep sleep state, obviously, it is a dream state. Now there are two types of dreams. The dreams related to what we have done the day before, and dreams completely unrelated to what we have done in the previous days. Now those dreams, what category of consciousness do they fit in?
Are they one of the six consciousnesses? And are they virtuous, non virtuous, or neutral? Do you understand? I was asking you if you have questions. He’s asking you, do you understand what he’s talking about?
Yeah. Okay. So all. Purely all. So now, obviously, Buddha Śākyamūni when he taught difficult topics such as the mind as a death state of which we have no experience whatsoever.
But as far as the mind of the dream state is concerned, we do have experience of the dream state. Then setting aside the dreams which are rooted in the experiences of the previous day. If we consider the dreams which have no relation whatsoever to what we experienced in the previous days, Are those dreams mental consciousness or not? Do all of you have clear dreams? Like I said, it’s very difficult to put this dream consciousness within the six collections of consciousness, the sensory and mental consciousness.
So these very clear dreams, they happen only from time to time. Right? So we’re talking of these very strange dreams, which has no relation at all to what we did during the previous days, are extremely clear. Are these mental consciousness or not? Consciousness.
Why is it a mental consciousness? What’s your goal? So the Geshe-la should ask you about the purpose — you started stuttering, right? Yeah. Well the purpose is that it appears to me in a similar form to my ordinary consciousness.
It’s unrelated to my everyday life, but it appears as in the same form as ordinary consciousness. Okay. So the examples Geshe-la is thinking about is pre cognitive dreams or dreams in which one encounters one’s spiritual teacher. Then these dreams are virtuous dreams. Then if they are virtuous dreams and they are not the mental consciousness, they have to be the ālaya vijnana, but the alia vijnana actually is said to be neutral.
It’s not virtuous. So generally speaking, when we speak of mental consciousness, we are speaking of a consciousness which follows sensory consciousnesses. It follows the experience of sight, of seeing objects, of hearing sounds, or for instance of the taste of a food. That is what mental consciousness generally speaking is. It’s important to reflect about this one carefully and quietly.
In addition, do not forget the meaning, the purpose of the mind basis of all which we studied already, and link that with what Geshe-la is saying about precognitive dreams, dreams of one’s teachers, and so forth. What is the meaning the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna? So it was an extremely subtle stable main mind partially posited as being the basis infused. Unstained and neutral. And another, You have to try to remember the definition.
It’s a fundamental mind, very subtle and cannot be grasped. A stable mind that is neutral and unstained, posited on basis that infuse of karmic imprints. So the definition of Geshe-la’s is extremely clear. A main mind which is neutral and unobscured, and has an extremely stable continuum acting as the basis of infusion of the karmic imprints. So this mind of the dream state which we were talking about is definitely not one of the five sensory consciousnesses.
And when we ask whether it is a mental consciousness or not, we must know the meaning or the definition of the mental consciousness. So Geshe, I would like you to give the meaning or the definition of the mental consciousness. Okay. So time is moving on, so at present we will generate the motivation, have the recitation of the prayers, and then discussion. So for the discussion session tonight, there are three topics.
The first is how many moves or logical possibilities are there between a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, and someone who is not a Mahāyāna being. The second is how many moves are there between a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets and a Hīnayāna being. And the third, if you are able to finish this, is discuss what the clear dream consciousness is and its relation with the Alaya Vijñāna. By groups of two, if that is not possible. By groups of three, please.
Okay. I have to group, please.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Are Hīnayāna Dharma and Hīnayāna tenets separate things to be studied, and how do Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma differ?
Yes, there is a big difference between Dharma and tenets. The foundation of both Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma is the four noble truths, the 37 limbs of enlightenment, and the 12 limbs, so there is no difference in terms of foundation. The difference between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna Dharma lies in the motivation. We should therefore speak carefully when we say we are teaching Mahāyāna Dharma, or reading the Lamrim as Mahāyāna Dharma. Unless we have generated the motivation of bodhicitta, it is difficult for this to be Mahāyāna Dharma.