3,506 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The teaching explains that meditation on the Lam Rim must be relaxed and that practice means generating a sensation through awareness of the faults to be abandoned. It covers the lower realms, karma and how non-virtuous actions accumulate, and the counter to grasping at permanence through meditation on death, impermanence and the precious human rebirth. A question and answer session follows on death, bardo, and visualising a teacher.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: f31464f6-325c-4644-b6dc-147228795c4f
Words: 3,502
So to the difference of how we engage in physical action or for that matter how we think about things, one cannot engage rapidly in meditation. Instead, one must engage in meditation in a relaxed fashion. Then if the body is at ease and the mind is relaxed, it is possible to meditate. However, if the body is tight and the mind is scattered, then it is difficult to meditate on the Lamrim. Then, If one reflects on the advantages of the attainments and the attainments of bodhichitta on the one hand, or the advantages of attaining the state of liberation on the other hand, one can then engage single pointedly in meditation.
Now this is obvious in worldly affairs. In worldly affairs, when we are aware of the benefits or the advantages of the results which are aimed, it is easy to engage in the activities to generate them. So one must therefore reflect on the benefits and one must practice. Now if we take the practice the being shared with the the practice shared with the being of the smaller scope, And here it said, one should practice this. What exactly is meant by practicing the small scope?
There are five or seven, probably five topics of meditation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Then if practicing just meant covering these one by one, then that would be quite odd. Practice instead means that we are trying to generate a certain sensation which arises through an awareness of the rewards which come from this practice. So here nothing can be engaged in life without being aware of the faults of what we’re trying to turn away from. So as far as the path shared with the being of the small scope is concerned, we must first be aware of the faults or the objects of abandonment which we are trying to relinquish, and then try to attain the opposite of that.
So initially, obviously, one must know the topics of meditation shared with the being of the path shared with the being of the small scope. This is obviously indispensable. Is this sufficient? Does this amount to practice? Well, obviously not, based on experience.
So one needs something else. One needs to inflect the mind in a certain way. Then it is self evident we have to know the objects of meditation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. But it is also just as evident that knowing these and covering them does not amount to practice. If after doing this, like most of us, we are exactly the same as we were before we started, and the same is true for the path shared with the being of the middling and of the great scope, then this is not practice.
So what is practice? How does one practice? So how should you proceed? Clearly a majority of you seem to have a good understanding of past and future lives. But what is necessary to start practicing the path shared with the being of the small scope is to understand the faults or the defects of lower rebirth.
What happens if I am reborn as an animal? What are the problems of this rebirth? And once one understands this, then one turns away from the vanities of this life and then there are numerous meditations involved with the path shared with the being of the small scope, and one seeks means to actualize these. And imagine what would happen if you were reborn as a dog. Then obviously in Australia dogs have very good conditions, but they have no freedom at all, are slaves.
Then in India, it’s the opposite. Dogs have complete freedom and appalling conditions. So we need freedom. Then you can see in Australia, a dog is basically completely at the mercy of its master even if its master is a child. The dog wants to socialize with another dog and the child just pulls him away and that’s it.
So what happens to you and me once we are reborn as dogs? What will that be like? Then if we are reborn as a cat, same thing, and obviously being reborn as an animal in Australia is the best possible rebirth for an animal. And then we have to ask ourselves, well what will happen if I am reborn as an animal, as a dog, or as a cat? What will the conditions be for me?
And at this point, this connects with the notion of karma because one wonders what exactly does it take to be reborn for me to be reborn as a dog? So what therefore does it take to take rebirth within the physical base of a dog? And here, we can say that this does not arise causelessly, it arises from causes and conditions, it arises from heavy non virtuous deeds in a previous life. So to try to avoid a rebirth with a physical base such as for instance that of a dog or a cat, we need to avoid the causes and the conditions which give rise to such a rebirth. And what are these causes and conditions?
These are heavy non virtuous deeds. And at this point, then we will generate the wish to try to see how to give rise to powerful virtuous deeds. Understand how to abandon non virtuous karma, and how to practice or engage in virtuous karma. Now the body, the physical base we have at present, is the result of virtuous karma in the past. And likewise, if we wish to attain such a physical base in the future, we will have to accumulate the requisite virtuous karma so as to obtain it.
And it is through thinking in this way that we then engage the issue of abandoning non virtuous karma and training in virtuous karma. Now the core of the path shared with the being of the small scope is the practice of causality or the understanding of karma. And this is only possible if we understand the faults, the flaws of a lower rebirth and reflect on the sufferings of the lower rebirth. Otherwise it is difficult to do so. So it is difficult for us to imagine since at present we have we are human beings and we have a very comfortable and happy rebirth.
But imagine if you were reborn as a dog, then what would that be like? And once one engages this idea and one understands just how much hardship and suffering one would face, at that point, this really takes hold of one’s mind. Now this is practice. This is easy practice. This is not something which is difficult to engage in.
Then let us ask ourselves, if we were reborn as a dog, would we be able to support it? Then is it possible? It is definitely possible because one is reborn as a dog because of heavy non virtuous karma. Do we have heavy non virtuous karma within our mind stream or not? We ourselves know.
No one else can say this for us. No one else has access. And let us check-in one single day of our life what the ratio of virtuous to non virtuous karma which we accumulate is. And we all know what that ratio is, don’t we? Then if we are not careful, it is a given that we will be reborn as dogs.
Then we must therefore practice on a daily basis to prepare for the greatest hardship which we will experience in this life, which is our death. Then if we practice daily at the time of our death, there is some hope we will be able to generate a virtuous mind. Otherwise, to try to do this at the last moment is not possible. And then our goal has to be to increase the percentage of virtuous states of mind within our mind stream every day, and to decrease the percentage of non virtuous states of mind. This is possible and this is excellent.
And here, the overwhelming source of non virtuous deeds are physical and verbal non virtuous deeds. And their source? Their source is grasping at one’s own permanence, our sense of our own immortality. So we must seek for an antidote to this grasping at our permanence. This is very good, and I’m in no no way saying that you alone should put effort at practice, and I will stay up here and relax.
Instead, all of us together should put effort at this practice. And therefore, our biggest enemy is this grasping at our own permanence, our sense of our own immortality. For instance, this room, most of us are above 50. Then all of us are probably convinced we have another fifty years in front of us, which would mean that all of us would live to 100. And all of us are behaving at present as if we had fifty years yet to go.
Then obviously, we don’t. And then obviously, working on the assumption that we have another fifty years to live, we struggle at getting the best house possible. And once we get the fanciest house we can get, we need the best food, the best drink. And naturally, if we had another fifty years to live, this might make sense, but we don’t. So we have to find a way to counter this grasping at our own permanence, and it is not difficult.
And maybe four or five among you haven’t hit the age of 50, everyone else is above 50 I think. In our own cases, we are enslaved by grasping at our own permanence. Well, the being of the middling scope, understands that he is or she is enslaved to cyclic existence by grasping at a self. Beings of the small scope are enslaved to this life by grasping at permanence. It’s very helpful to understand this.
And in our cases, it is a particularly coarse form of grasping at our permanence, which holds sway. Then how do we counter this? We counter this through meditation on death and impermanence, or as Je Tsongkhapa puts it in the three principles of the path, through inseparably blending meditation on the difficulty in finding a human rebirth of leisure and endowment, and on death and impermanence. And within the three roots of meditation on death and impermanence, the most important is the uncertainty of the time of death. Once we have this deep conviction in karma or in causality, then even if we experienced considerable hardship in our life, we understand that this hardship was created by ourselves, and it becomes easier to bear.
Otherwise, we risk the run the risk of thinking that it comes from the outside. It might be due due to a god or something like that. So let us now think during a couple of minutes on the hardship which grasping at our own permanence inflicts on us. And let us think on what sufferings we would experience if we were reborn in the lower realms, and how to counter this. It is therefore extremely important to become repeatedly habituated to virtuous lines of thought.
And if in addition, we are able to stay in good health in such a way that at the time of death, we don’t experience extreme physical hardship. This will help greatly in dying with a virtuous state of mind. So as the mind of death becomes ever more subtle, it is very important to maintain a virtuous state of mind. If we are able to maintain a virtuous state of mind in the death process, then a higher rebirth is basically certain. If on the other hand, we are unable to do so, and out of great attachment to the vanities of this life, in other words, out of craving, we die with a non virtuous state of mind, then craving will cause a maturation of some of the numerous non virtuous karmic imprints in our mind stream, and then it is a given we will be reborn in the lower realms.
And therefore, as a preliminary to prepare for death, staying or keeping one’s health is very important. Then the means of dying with a virtuous state of mind, we already have in our hands at present. We should train to fall asleep with a virtuous state of mind. This is something we can do. And the process of falling asleep and the process of dying are quite similar.
As a result, we will be able to apply this at the time of our death. So as obtaining a an unhappy or a happy rebirth are contingent on whether we have accumulated non virtuous or virtuous karma, it is very important for us to understand the mode of accumulation of karma. Then let us take the case of the accumulation of non virtuous karma. Non virtuous karma is necessarily accumulated in dependence on the body or on speech. Things are more complicated with virtuous karma, which, can be accumulated in other ways.
We have the virtuous karma leading to a rebirth in the formless realms and so forth, but Geshela will not enter into that now. Then probably there is no non virtuous karma which is not accumulated in dependence on body or speech. So let us take the example which was taken last time. Let us imagine that we are relaxing, and suddenly a possum comes along on the roof and makes a huge racket interfering with our rest. And then immediately, anger arises within our mind stream, and we think whenever I’m relaxing, this bloody possum comes along.
And the deep wish to kill the possum arises. Now, to accumulate non virtuous karma, a motivation is necessary. Without the motivation, there is no accumulation of karma. And here, the motivation is anger, for instance. Therefore, motivated by anger, one adopts whatever means one chooses to adopt to kill the possum, and at the point at which the possum dies, that anger turns into the actual base of karma.
So here, motivated by anger, one kills the possum. It is important to understand that that angry motivation is an affliction, and what happens after killing the possum is actual karma, but both are present within the mind stream of one person. Just as for instance, when a child enters kindergarten and then progresses through kindergarten, and then into primary school and high school and eventually university, all that changes are the names of the classes, but you are speaking of one person. Likewise here, you have the continuum of one person in which an affliction eventually turns into karma, actual karma. Karma is a result.
Just as in daily life, we engage in activities for a result. The result of the motivation which wishes to kill the to kill the possum, is the death of the possum, and that is a karma. So here, this affliction, the faulty or defective component of this affliction becomes a karma, and this is what is meant when one says one accumulates a karma, in this case, the non virtuous karma of killing a possum. And then, after having accumulated this karma, a potency is imprinted in what amounts to our mental continuum. This is what is meant by accumulating karma, accumulating non virtuous karma in this case.
So this is how one accumulates non virtuous karma. This is how one accumulates impelling non virtuous karma. Now as to the accumulation of impelling contaminated virtuous karma, But irrespective of all of that, let us just understand that it is through accumulating non virtuous karma, and this manner of accumulating non virtuous karma that we are reborn in the lower realms. And let us generate the motivation. Open the prayer book, page one.
We recite one b. Here, the impelling cause for rebirth in the lower realms probably depends on physical and verbal activities, and likewise, the impelling cause for rebirth in the higher realms probably depends on physical and verbal activities, but this is something worth investigating. Then at present, Geshele will take your questions. The case of the possum that a person intend to kill but is not being killed but the intention is there, is that mean the karma it’s already like the anger that’s turning to the potency but the possum hasn’t died so is that mean that the verbal or the intention that the karma is there and it will go into the next life or In dependence on the motivation of killing the possum alone, one does not accumulate actual karma. It one needs to rely on physical or verbal action.
One does not accumulate karma without relying on body or speech. Then in this world, it’s obvious, right? You are accused of killing someone based on physical or verbal action you performed. No one says you killed someone when you just thought about it. Geshela said that practice means trying to generate a certain sensation.
Could it be said that as well as that certain sensation that practice has occurred if it has affected the mind and one’s behavior of body, speech and mind changes and turns towards virtue. Yes, definitely. When independence on a good, a virtuous motivation, one gains some type of sensation in this direction, then one speaks of practice. Geshela taught about countering the grasping at permanence of ourselves. And he said, he taught that one of the ways is that we blend the meditation on death with the meditation on the precious human rebirth.
What are the aspects of the precious human rebirth that are most important? I’m saying that for instance, of the three topics of the meditation of death, Geshela has told that the most important is the second one, it’s the uncertainty of its time. So what would be the most important with regard to? So the most important aspect is simply this physical human base. This physical human base is one of great significance because it is one of great power, and it gives us great capacities.
It is thanks to this physical human base that we can seize the essence of a human life. And then we blend this awareness with that of the uncertainty of the time of death. So in our daily routines, we are similar to animals. We get up in the morning, we have breakfast, we go to bed at night before that we eat something. There’s no difference.
So we need to make a difference which justifies of being human. Could Geshela please make a comment on if one was to think of the Buddha and also to recognize this image as impermanent and then a feeling of discomfort arises almost as though the thinker was being disrespectful by imputing emptiness. Can Geshela please make a comment on that? What’s the question? So this wasn’t for me but for a friend.
Sorry? This this is not for me but for a friend. Oh. And she said that when she thinks of the Buddha or a Buddha and she tries to understand that this thought, well, a Buddha is empty, she feels a discomfort because it feels almost disrespectful to think in that manner or non virtuous? She prostrates to the Buddha, right?
Geshela does not understand the meaning of the question. This is rather difficult for us when we think that something is non inherently established. It’s basically the same thing as it’s being non existent. And then at that point, if one thinks that Buddha Śākyamūni is non inherently established, then the fear that one is going to show disrespect to the qualities of the Buddha as well would arise. I’m trying to get an understanding of the subtle mind at death and at what point it becomes a coarse mind again when there are accounts of in the Bardo beings being impelled towards a particular rebirth, wouldn’t that indicate that that’s a coarse mind arising in the Bardo?
Bardo beings have coarse minds, right? Now, obviously, the mind of a Bardo being is more subtle than ours. Right? Is it okay do meditation or before sleep? I cannot I mean, I’m not familiar with statues, so like Buddha statue.
So I and I don’t conjure the image of the statue, but I conjure, you know, Rinpoche or His Holiness because it’s easier. Is that okay to do that? Yes, definitely, definitely. If one has faith, one should visualize his holiness. Then obviously, if one has no faith, one shouldn’t visualize, because it’s not a virtuous mind.
Just a reminder about the Choktrul Duchen tomorrow, Puja at six, and recitations, Heart Sūtra, etcetera, 10:00. Shared lunch if you’re free at twelve. Thank you. Yeah. So we’ll we’ll set the Gompa up for tomorrow in Puja mode.
I’ll purge you tomorrow. Yeah. Six. Six. Don’t need to bring food, but a financial monetary donation would be good.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Which aspects of the precious human rebirth are most important?
The most important aspect is simply the physical human base. It is of great significance because it is one of great power and gives us great capacities. Thanks to this physical human base, we can seize the essence of a human life, and we blend this awareness with an awareness of the uncertainty of the time of death. Without this, our daily routines are similar to those of animals: we get up in the morning, have breakfast, eat something before going to bed at night, and there is no difference. So we need to make a difference which justifies being human.