TBI Recordings – 16082017 LAMRIM

3,144 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. Continues teaching on the third preliminary, generating a special virtuous mind of refuge focused on future lives. Explains refuge for beings of small scope (fear of the lower realms) and middling scope (protection from the afflictions), and the value of meditating on the uncertainty of death. Also distinguishes Hinayana and Mahayana by motivation versus tenet view, with questions on the Prasangika system.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 2c1eaa3f-021d-4676-a291-5d1acf173bc3

Words: 3,140

The third preliminary practice within a special mind generate the mind of refuge is particularly profound. A special mind was explained last time, and a mind of refuge here refers, as far as the term refuge is concerned to the act of refuge and mind refers to bodhichitta. Now, how are we to understand a special virtuous mind? Geshela suspects that one can understand a special virtuous mind as any virtuous mind focused on future lives and beyond. Now within their form, a special virtuous mind, has just been explained.

One generates a mind of refuge and here refuge obviously can refer either to the refuge shared with the being of the small or of the middling scope, the two refuges we saw. So now as was said within those two first refuges, the refuge shared as a being of the small and of the middling scope. Let us consider first the refuge shared with the being of the small scope. So as far as the being of the small scope is concerned, probably all religious traditions, Christianity and the other great religious traditions, including Buddhism, assert that after death, in our own case death is certain, it has been decided that we shall die already. After death, there are only two possible destinations.

For Buddhism, these are the higher and the lower realms. The Buddhist viewpoint is perhaps a little bit more comfortable because even though you’re reborn in the lower realm, sometimes you can get out. This depends on one’s type, one’s outlook. Then as was said, therefore, from a Buddhist standpoint, there are only two possible destinations, the lower and the higher realms. And in our own cases, it is decided that we will be reborn in the lower realms because we have great habituation with non virtuous deeds.

We have very powerful non virtuous deeds which are already present within our mind stream. As far as non virtuous minds indeed are concerned, we have engaged in them continually from the time of our birth from our mother’s womb until now. And not only have we engaged in them, and do we have great habituation with them, but in addition, all of these non virtuous deeds are complete. They have an application, in other words, an intention. They have an actual base, and they have a conclusion.

All of these are complete for non virtuous deeds. For virtuous deeds, is exactly the opposite. We engage in them seldom and with great difficulty, and the intention, the actual base, and the conclusion are often missing. This is easy to understand. It is very easy to see where we will be reborn after our death.

So as we said, there are only two possible destinations for us, the lower realms and the higher realms, and in our cases, it’s a given that we shall be reborn in the lower realms. Then when we reflect on the sufferings of the lower realms, what this entails, a very deep fear arises and a wish to be protected from this, to find a refuge which protects us from this. Now what can such a refuge be? Once out of a profound conviction, we generate a faith in Buddha Śākyamūni, which understands the teachings that happiness occurs through the abandonment of sin and non virtue, then this can qualify as a refuge shared with the being of the small scope. So when such a refuge is taken out of a conviction, which is based on study, then this amounts to a stable refuge, to the difference of the refuge, which is so common, which is just taken verbally, one just utters the statement of refuge without really understanding what one says and this amounts to a mere refuge.

Then Geshela cannot say for other traditional Buddhist countries, but certainly in Tibet, most people have this mere nominal refuge when they go to temples from time to time, and they wish to take refuge, and as far as they are concerned, the object of refuge are the statues of Buddha Śākyamūni in the back, then what precisely the Sangha refuge would be for them is open to question. Now it is very difficult for this to be a refuge, to qualify as a refuge. And one sees people folding their hands in the temple based on pure faith without any understanding, there is probably no practice worth talking about, it is really ignorance. So this is for the refuge shared with the small scope. Now as far as the refuge shared with the being being of of the middling scope is concerned, once one sees that apart from occasional moments of delight in this life, there is no durable or lasting happiness, and that we are beset and diseased by the afflictions, one investigates this mode of being this disease, this state of being diseased and one seeks for means to be freed from it durably.

And once one understands that the means to be freed from it durably are the teachings on the four noble truths which Buddha Śākyamūni uttered during the first turning of the wheel of the law, one takes refuge in Buddha Śākyamūni as a teacher of what is to be engaged in the four noble truths and what is to be abandoned. And when this occurs out of a firm conviction which amounts to faith, this is refuge. So when one goes for refuge at the level shared with the path of the being of small scope, one goes for refuge for protection from future hardship. In other words, the suffering of the lower realms. When one goes for refuge at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one goes for refuge for protection against the totality of sufferings of existence, of cyclic existence.

So therefore, returning to the third preliminary practice within a special mind of virtue. One generates a mind and refuge, and here, as was explained, a special mind of refuge is that focus on future lives and beyond. And refuge can be understood either in terms of the refuge shared with the being of the small or of the middling scope. In the case of the refuge shared with the being of the middling scope, we go for protection against the afflictions. Then, while no one is afflicted continually, nonetheless in this life, all of us are beset by afflictions occasionally.

So initially, one must reflect on one’s own suffering due to the afflictions, and then extend that to others. Whether one refers to all mother sentient beings, to all sentient beings, or to all sentient beings in front of oneself, the meaning is the same. And here upon reflecting therefore on how we are ourselves and others beset by suffering, once the mind resolving to be freed from these sufferings arise and motivated by this one studies or one engages in the threefold activities of hearing, thinking and meditating, at that point, all the totality of the Lamrim has been covered. So there is therefore here a sequential progression from the initial generation of a special virtuous state of mind towards refuge to the generation of the mind, in other words, bodhichitta. Then this initial generation of a virtuous state of mind is indispensable.

Without it, it will not be possible to give rise to refuge, let alone bodhichitta. And foremost, ideal for such a generation of a virtuous state of mind is meditation on death and impermanence, specifically on the uncertainty of the time of death. Do you understand? So therefore, our goal must be to generate a virtuous state of mind and to do so continually is extremely difficult. But we should generate a virtuous state of mind over and again, so that we are eventually able to die with a virtuous state of mind.

And precisely, we have no way of knowing when we shall die. The time of death is uncertain. Then from the future life onwards should be our principal goal and this life should be subsidiary or ancillary. So Geshela has explained numerous times the importance of generating such a virtuous mind and focusing one’s mind within a state of virtue, and the best means to do this is meditation on death and impermanence, and specifically on the uncertainty of the time of our own death. Then all of you in this room probably own your own car, you drive, you know how dangerous driving is, don’t you?

Then it is extraordinarily easy to lose one’s life. It is a matter of falling asleep and not waking up the next morning. Strange isn’t it that when we ask people when they go to bed, everyone can tell us precisely when they go to bed, but actually no one can give us a precise time at which they fall asleep. Then all people can say is probably I will have fallen asleep by 11:30 or twelve. They can’t be more precise than that, can they?

And therefore, based on these explanations on the third preliminary, which is extremely important, engaging in refuge and generating bodhichitta within an uncommon or special virtuous mind. Let us at present during a couple of minutes generate the motivation. So at present, Geshela will start teaching the Lamrim, but as a preliminary, he would like to point out that he has noticed that, most of our students are unable to make a distinction between, for instance, an Arhat and an ārya. Generally speaking, they know what a Buddha is because a Buddha is the supreme. But they are not able to make a distinction between an Arhat and an ārya, and this is due to not having studied sa lam carefully.

So as of next week, Geshela will start teaching sa lam in a concise fashion. The same thing for those of you who are attending the Tuesday class on Cittamātra. When one presents, for instance, the kliṣṭamanas, the afflicted mind, in conjunction with the alaya vijnana, then what precisely are their boundaries? What do they extend from from the level of someone who has not entered the path, until what level, until the level of full enlightenment and so forth? So as a preliminary to this, one must present the three vehicles.

As you know, the three vehicles are the vehicle of the hearers or the shravakaryana, the vehicles of the solitary realizers, the Pratyekabuddhayāna, and the vehicle of the Bodhisattvas, the Bodhisattva Yana. Now these three vehicles can be summarized into two broad subdivisions, the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna. However, at this point, Geshela has noticed that a majority of our students are unable to make the difference between being a Hinayanaist by view and being a Hinayanaist by motivation, a Mahayanaist by view and a Mahayanaist by motivation. They consider this to be one and the same, which is completely unsuitable. So initially, what is the distinction between a Hīnayāna being and a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets?

A propounder of Hīnayāna tenets can only be understood clearly in the light of the fourfold subdivision of tenets. And a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets can be defined as a propounder of Buddhist tenets who asserts the existence of indivisible particles. So propounders of Hīnayāna tenets, as you know, are subdivided into two schools, the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrandikas. However, a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets is not necessarily a Hīnayāna being. The classic example is that of a bodhisattva who is a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets.

This is a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, but it is not a Hīnayāna being because it’s a Mahāyāna being. Now a Bodhisattva who is a pro founder of Hīnayāna tenets is a Mahāyāna being simply because he or she is a Bodhisattva. Whoever is a bodhisattva is necessarily a Mahāyāna being. Now what would be a simplified definition of a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets? A propounder of Mahāyāna tenets would be a propounder of Buddhist tenets who asserts that form and so forth are not merely constituted of exterior indivisible particles.

This probably satisfies the meaning. A propounder of Mahāyāna tenets is not necessarily a Mahāyāna being or a Mahāyānist. The example given would be a hearer or a Shavaka who is a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets. This is a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets. It is not a Mahāyāna being, it is a Hīnayāna being.

So a Śrāvaka or a hearer who is a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets is a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets, but nonetheless is not a Mahāyāna being because he or she is a Hinayanist. In brief, the distinction between being a Hīnayāna and a Mahayanaist is made in terms of motivation. The distinction between being a propounder of Hīnayāna tenants and a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets is made in terms of the view, just as being a propounder of Buddhist tenants. Do you have questions on this now? Any question?

Propounder means someone who says an utterer, a speaker. So someone who is a Buddhist and who after study accepts the presentations of base, path, and result, which are taught in Buddhist treatises is someone who accepts Buddhist tenets. When that person, after reflecting carefully about these tenets and relying on scholars and realized beings gains realization of these tenets, he becomes someone who has realized these tenets. At the point where he utters them or teaches them to others, he becomes a propounder or a an utterer of those tenets. Generally speaking it is said that if one is a Buddhist, one is not necessarily a propounder of Buddhist tenets.

It’s a bit awkward, isn’t it? And obviously, if you are a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets, you do have to be a propounder of Buddhist tenets, otherwise it becomes very odd. And probably So and if one is a Mahāyāna being, probably that one is a being who propounds Buddhist tenets And if one is a Buddhist, probably one is not necessarily a propounder of Buddhist tenets. So now, how do you feel about the presentation of Mahāyāna and Hīnayāna beings on the one side and propounder of Mahāyāna tenets and propounder of Hīnayāna tenets on the other side? Do you have some understanding?

Sure? Oh, yeah. I’ve got a question. Oh, yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. You can question. How can a Mahāyāna being who is propounder of Hīnayāna tenets attain full enlightenment on the basis of Hīnayāna tenets? Good question.

So through studies, through studying carefully, such a person will eventually realize that Hīnayāna tenets do not enable one to attain full and utter enlightenment. So he focuses on these topics over and again. However, the Sautrantikas say that their system is the one and independence on it, you can attain full and utter enlightenment. However, through studying carefully over and again, one realizes or one sees the faults of one’s system of tenets. The mode of explanation of the four systems of tenets is probably done in terms of the acumen and the faculties of the trainees and the persons who study those systems.

Then Geshela is in no way saying that it is indispensable to progress through all four systems of tenets before attaining the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika system. If one’s mind is strong enough, then one can study Prasanghika Mādhyamika directly. Then the viewpoint espoused by the Lamrim is probably the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika one. If I heard correctly, you said that might be a Buddhist might not be a propounder of Buddhist tenets. If that is so, wouldn’t it be possible for a person to more or less propound a Vibhashika view, which is sort of the common sense realist view, without really having a name for it, or but believe it, basically believe it without knowing the details of it?

No, for Vaibhāṣikas, because it’s a tenet system, if one is a Vaibhāṣika, one is necessarily a pro pounder of Vaibhāṣika tenants. So Geshela says that you have a good translator and in his own case, he does not speak English as If I have a Good enough in his family, okay, but now still, you know. I said, please teach, I’m going on vacation. So at present, have good opportunities since we have translators and good facilities. Therefore, don’t waste your time, use this opportunity.

Yep. Is it possible to still be a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets on the path of meditation? And obviously one has to explain what someone in the path of meditation is. Geshela will do that. So you have three types of beings on the path of meditation, hearers on the path of meditation, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas on the path of meditation.

Have you? Yeah. I guess my question was that if a being on the path of meditation has a non conceptual direct realization of emptiness, then surely that would be the Prāsaṇgika view and not one of the other tenet systems. Yours is a very good doubt and Geshela answered somewhat erroneously at first, but needed to develop that answer. According to Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, there are indeed Vaibhāṣika propounders of Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika tenets who are on the path of meditation, because Buddha Śākyamūni taught so.

But according to Prasanika Mādhyamika, there are no Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika propounders of tenets on the path of meditation. For that matter, there are no Svatadrika Madhyamikas on the path of meditation either. There are only Prasanghikas. According to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, taking Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika as a basis, there are no hearer and solitary realizer propounder of Hīnayāna tenets above the level of the smaller path of accumulation, the mere path of accumulation. There probably, in Geshela’s opinion, would be none at the level of the middling path of accumulation, the first of the five paths, because at that point, one has to have an idea, an understanding of emptiness.

So when you look at the progression along the five paths, accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning, within one vehicle, this progression occurs in terms of the view. For this reason, Geshela thinks that above the level of the smallest path of accumulation, the first of the three subdivisions of the path of accumulation, according to Prasangika, there would be no hearers or solitary realizers. Now regarding the third path, the Mahāyāna, entry in the Mahāyāna, in other words, entry in the smaller path of accumulation does not depend at all on the view. It depends exclusively on the motivation, whether one has generated or not uncontrived bodhichitta, that is all. We shall stop here for today and do the recitations.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one day, two, three, four, and also page five. Number six, month of offering, verse one and a three. So we shall stop here today because there are some rituals to do with fitting the mani wheels.

Key terms in this teaching

higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Pratyekabuddhayana rang sang gyä kyi thegpa, rang gyälwäi thegpa (Tib)
The Solitary Realizer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of solitary realizers (pratyekabuddhas), practitioners who attain liberation from cyclic existence autonomously without relying on an external teacher or teachings. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
tenet system drubtha(Tib)
A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
yana
Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top