Dalai Lama Talks – HH at Harvard – HHDL (21)

3,612 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. The speaker teaches that altruism and compassion are a common human good rather than a matter of religious belief, and that a wise selfishness serves others. Using the practices of taking and giving and of equalizing and switching self and other, the talk covers how to cultivate bodhicitta, how to develop patience by seeing enemies as teachers, and, toward the end, the three natures and the meaning of emptiness in the middle and third turnings of the wheel.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 8f84aa27-a0ce-445c-93ea-5d7d472989a1

Words: 3,608

Small dog or small, you see, what we call that, cat, cat. Oh, small cat. So you see, now these animals, their attachment or love is very limited. Are dogs, small ones, what you call child of dog, child of dog. For, you see, in certain time, some affection, there.

Then that small one, it should become grown up. That, how to say, sort of, you see, affectionate feeling. No more. Very limited. Now human being can think much more deeper, much more because of this.

So now you see, when you become angry, all these potential things lost, no more there. So, you see, the anger is the real destroyer of our human good quality. Right. So they are really our enemy. The enemy with weapon cannot destroy human, I mean, human good quality.

But anger can destroy. So therefore, the anger, if you look the hatred in the anger side, is nothing good. Now, side can love compassion concerning other people. Now, these are the real, real source of happiness. Now, with love, without saying, you see, compassion.

Even you remain, don’t know, sorry, remain in very uncomfortable place, The external, how to say, the uncomfortable may not disturb you. The other side, with full angry, the best facility, you remain despite you remain in best facility, you will not happy. So, we ever want happiness? That’s right. So, if you really want happiness, then you must follow a right, sorry, right path or right method in order to achieve happiness.

So, from these, this is not Buddha’s, I mean, special, not not not I mean, this is these are not particular religious thinking, but we we can think by common human color, common sense, human common sense. So, you say, and now you see the selfish, the importance of yourself and importance of other. Now, again, you see, my usual according Shantideva’s, you see, advice. Now, here we imagine, you yourself one side. The other beings is one side.

There’s other being, even a limited number, say ten, fifteen, 101 side. To visualize one side, you yourself, as selfish and proud, pride way, pride, such you visualize such a condition or such position. Then, the other side, the poor, needy people of group of people remain there. That moment you yourself visualize as a unbiased third person. Now judge.

This person, this one single person is more important or this group of people are more important. Think! Whether you join this side or this side, which is more important, which is more worthwhile to join this side or this side? Then naturally, if you are, you see, real human being, then naturally your heart will go this side because this is more number and more needy people. This is one just a single and pride and stupid one.

You see? So, you see, you naturally feeling goes this side, closer. So, like this practice, think, think, think, then gradually our selfish feeling gradually decreases. The respect for other will grow. That is the way of practice.

So this is you see, and this is the main point. So this is the main In other words, I usually say, you are really want selfish, then be a wise selfish, not narrow selfish. You see, it’s a wise selfish. Think other people, serve other people sincerely, not cheating, but sincerely, you see, self and helping as much as you can. You yourself regard as a secondary thing.

Then the ultimate result, you will get the maximum benefit. Clear? So that is why it is selfish. The other side, you see, fighting with someone, you see, killing or stealing, harsh words, these sort of things, and forget other people’s benefit, always think yourself, I, I, I. Result will be, you are looser.

You become looser. The other people also, gradually, front of you, wire. So therefore, practice of altruism is not a religion, but it is a real way of human life. Really, how to say, the I usually call real human quality. Whether you are believer or non believer, whether you are Buddhist or non non Buddhist, this is secondary.

Nothing important. The important thing is we, as a human being, we must live purposefully, because of purposeful or meaningful life. That’s important. Just eating. Ah, and not I’ll say, just eating means making that thing, what you call that?

This thing come out, what you call it? Peces. Ah, Peces. Oh, Peces. Really, you see?

So that’s not our purpose. Life purpose of life. You see? Purpose of life is I mean, increase the good heart, warm heart, and we will become a good human being. And with that quality, you will lead whole life as a meaningful light, meaningful life and purposeful life.

And you become friend of everybody. And you are you become the The helper helper of of everyone. Everyone. Helper for everyone. Whether you’re you see, in that sense now, through that we get real sense of brothers and sisters.

The full headed brothers, sisters, the word. Nothing. With this feeling, this motivation, now our big human and human community become one, harmony, friendly, you know, honesty, and justice is a human community. That is our aim. That whether we achieve this life or not is a different matter.

But whether achieve or not, it is worthwhile to to to attempt. To make attempt. This is my my my belief, and usually I call this sort of, you see, feeling as a universal religion. Not necessarily in this particular this religion, that religion. This is something universal religion.

So, you see, do you think? Do you agree? These things are, you see, important. It’s not necessary, the prasangika theory or this complicated theory. Not necessary.

Now think, using common sense. Think, think, think properly. Then we can convince that really the practice of altruism, practice of love, practice of compassion is something worthwhile, very necessary, very important. Then next, you see the taking and giving practice is Now you see, if you think these, now as a Buddhist practitioner, you see, think, think, think. For a Buddhist practitioner, you see, When one thinks a great deal in this way, one wonders what one can do when one sees suffering sentient beings.

Now, as you see, we already discussed today, all this suffering come due to their own karmic, their karmic force. So here, I can nothing I can nothing to do except, how to say, voluntarily and enthusiastically. Mhmm. Taking From the very depths of one’s heart, imagine or think that one is willing to take all of the suffering of sentient beings, together with the causes of that suffering into oneself, and allow it to ripen within oneself. This is called the practice of taking others’ suffering within emphasizing compassion.

Then the other is to give away one’s own happiness and causes of happiness, in that at least one has a little virtue, one has some roots of virtue, and from the depths of one’s heart, to imagine giving this to other sentient beings. This is called the giving away of one’s own happiness within emphasizing love. Now this actually is not work. But, you see, it very much help increasing your determination, your willpower. That’s the practice of the taking suffering and the giving away of happiness.

For somebody who knows how to engage in this practice, it can be done at the time when one gets some sort of illness, or unfortunate is happening, And then instead of one’s suffering getting worse, this acts as an aid and one gets to be more courageous. According to my own limited experience, these practices are really a source of courage, inner source strength. I think this may have some connection with why Buddhist teachers can be very humorous. Because if you worry, it doesn’t help, does it? There’s not much worry.

As far as my own motivation is concerned, I’m sincere. As much as I can, that’s my motivation. And that, you see now, whether it’s something achieved or not, that is different. So no regret. No sorry.

You see, thinking, the bigger issue rather than small, small one. You see, after all, one hundredth period of life, nothing important. As you see, I am now 67, so 67, I think. Sometimes not very sure. I always forget my own age, right?

Like that, you see. So, you see, the Suppose, you see, if I remain another forty or fifty years, not much important as compared to the infinite future. And also, as you compare the unlimited sentient beings, there is a problem. My own problem is nothing. So, you see, if you look a problem or suffering very closely, you can then it becomes very big, very complicated, very unbearable.

Look from distance, it becomes smaller. There’s not much, much, nothing worthwhile to worry too much. So, it’s his thinking, the bigger problem and bigger issue and small issues come and go, come and go, come and go, that’s the nature. Not much concern.

So, like that. Not too much. Now, it’s one most important thing is, as I mentioned yesterday, the practice of patience. Tolerance. Now you see tolerance learn only from enemy.

Without an enemy, from an enemy you cannot learn. I think you see here, you cannot learn tolerance, except when you are bowing, maybe you learn some patience. Otherwise, there is no chance to learn patience and tolerance. When you are meeting your real enemy who are going to really hurting on you. That moment, you learn the tolerance.

Saradeva says that one’s enemy is really a good spiritual guide, because in dependence on the enemy, one can accumulate a great store of merit. Because independence upon an enemy, one gets a chance to cultivate patience, which is very helpful to oneself. It is as if the enemy were getting angry purposely in order to help oneself. However, Śāntideva posits someone who objects and says, and this one who’s answering is the manifestation of one’s own inner afflictive emotions, which are saying, That isn’t the case. The enemy doesn’t have any sense to help me, just wants to harm.

Therefore, it’s suitable for me to respond and harm him. But the answer is that it’s not necessary for something to have an intention to help you in order to help you. For instance, you have great faith and you want very much and you like the true cessation of suffering, but the true cessation of suffering don’t have any intention to help you. But because they help us, but because they help you, you respect them. So then the manifestations of the afflictive emotions, what do you say, seemingly accepting that makes a further objection.

But it’s not the case, they say, that true cessation have an intention to harm, whereas the enemy has an intention to harm. Therefore, it’s alright to answer back and harm him. Clear. I’m not sure. So the the enemy has an intention to harm.

Therefore, even if, what do you say, unlike true cessation, which even though a true cessation has no intention to help, still has no intention to harm. You see, the enemy has an intention to harm, therefore it’s all right for me to answer back and harm the enemy. So then the answer is, if the enemy didn’t have an intention to harm, it wouldn’t be an enemy. So because it is independence upon an enemy that one can cultivate patience, one needs an enemy. Thus, in order to become an enemy, that one needs this intention to harm.

So thus, one should respect the enemy. And also now, you see, Śāntideva argued like this: Someone hit on you. Then we immediately, you see, angry toward that person. Now Śāntideva, you see, argues. If you think, If you’re considering what is actually harming you, then that not the person, but by the stick or the weapon.

But that which is actually creating the suffering is the stick or the weapon, whatever it was. Not the person. But if one thinks about what is bringing about the harm indirectly, it’s not the person, it is The main source is the afflictive emotion in the person. So therefore, either, you see, if you am angry, then either you should angry the weapon or the motivation. Anger, not the person himself.

Very true, you see. The actual hitting or pain created by the weapon. But we foolishly not angry to the weapon. Maybe sometime. Sometimes even like this, you’re angry.

Sometimes we get angry at things when we hit them. I had a friend who like working under a car. When I myself used to make some occupied by car. Fixing up cars. So, And he hit his head.

He got so angry he hit the car twice like see, except this one. Generally, you see, we are not angry, the weapon. And we choose the person particularly. If you think properly, either this or this. The person himself, without angry, he may not, I mean, he will not take the action.

So because of his angry, now he took that as the hitting action. So if we properly think the real source of the troublemaker is the angry. Therefore, one shouldn’t one shouldn’t get upset at the person but should get upset at the afflictive emotion in the other person. Then another type of contemplation that Śāntideva gives is advice to think about whether the person’s getting angry, whether that angriess is the nature of the person, or is something that is adventitious. And if it’s the nature of the person, then just as we don’t get angry at fire because it burns, so one shouldn’t get angry at the person just because he’s angry.

And if it’s adventitious or temporary, just as one what do you say? If it’s adventitious, then just as when a cloud covers the sun, one doesn’t get angry at the sun, but sees that the problem is with the cloud. So here one shouldn’t get angry at the person, but get upset with the afflictive emotion, the anger in the person. So then one can also think that one’s own body has a nature of suffering, the weapon has a nature of suffering, and when these two come together, it produces pain. Thus, it’s half half.

So then just as one gets angry at the other things, so one should get angry at oneself. So, you see, when you read Śāntideva’s work, this sort of, you see, really, how to say, worthwhile or how to say, meaningful, you see, idea, it’s very, very useful for self discipline or for self awareness. So I myself, you see, practice according to the Śāntideva’s book, which is very, very useful. So I think that’s it. Enough now.

Through this, one can develop a very strong sense of altruism. It’s not absolutely necessary that one recognize other sentient beings as mothers, but from these points of view, one can generate a strong sense of altruism. I left out the essence. Here, because one is not thinking about this is my mother, there’s some connection then with one is not thinking about that, but is merely thinking about others, that everyone equally wants happiness and doesn’t want suffering. And one’s sense of altruism is generated in this sense, it can get to be very strong.

When one is able to generate a strong sense of respect and so forth for one’s enemy, since the enemy is the hardest person with respect to which it is, many ways, difficult to generate a sense of cherishing, then all the rest of the people are easy. That’s the way of cultivating altruism by way of the equalizing and switching of self and other. Then when one is trained in this altruistic intention to become enlightened and has advanced with some experience? Then one assumes this aspirational mind of enlightenment in the context of making a promise. This is called assuming the aspirational mind of enlightenment through a promise.

And through this it becomes more steady. And having done that, there is training in the causes to keep this aspirational mind of enlightenment from deteriorating in this lifetime and in future lifetimes. Then one has to train in the wish to train in the bodhisattva deeds. So what are the deeds here? They are the deeds of the six perfections.

There are many explanations about the entity, definite number and order of the six perfections, and so forth, but I won’t go into those here. In any case, all of the practices of bodhisattvas are contained in the six perfections. These, in turn, can be contained in the three types of ethics: the ethics of restraining ill deeds, the ethics which are the composite of virtuous practices, and the ethics of bringing about others’ welfare. The root of the ethics of bodhisattvas is the restraining of self centeredness. Thus it is said that the root of Buddha’s teaching is compassion.

In the vehicle of the hearers, it is within the context of compassion that the hearers are engaging in ethics in order not to harm others. But bodhisattvas not only are refraining from harming others, but are seeking to bring great help to others. The whole of Buddhism, Buddhism entirely can be included into two sentences: If you can, help others. If you cannot do that, then at least do not harm them. The essence of all of the Buddhist vehicles are contained in this.

There’s not much time. I’m not going to speak much about giving, ethics, patience, effort, concentration. Now, with respect to wisdom, I’ll explain some about the view. There are different types of wisdom. The conventional wisdom The wisdom realizing conventionalities, that is to say, the wisdom involved in the five sciences Like medicine, artistry, and so forth?

Logic, grammar, and the inner sciences. Then there’s the ultimate wisdom, realizing the suchness of things, realizing the ultimate truth. We’ve already talked quite a bit about the ultimate wisdom. Because from among the four systems of tenets, the Cittamātrins and the Madhyamikas assert a selflessness of phenomena, I will mainly talk about these systems. In the Yogacāra or Cittamātra system, they mainly assert the third turning of the wheel of doctrine.

In the Unraveling of the Thought Sūtra, which is a sūtra of the third wheel, it is said that the doctrines taught in first two turnings of the wheel are doctrines to be interpreted. They say that if one asserted the teachings in the middle wheel that all phenomena are without their own entity ness, that they are without production, and that they are at peace from the start, if and one that they are naturally in nirvana If one asserted these doctrines literally, one would fall to an extreme of nihilism. Thus, independence on the doctrines of the turning of the third wheel, one needs to interpret these doctrines of the middle wheel. So then, if one asks, what is the meaning of the lack of inherent existence in phenomena that is taught in the middle wheel? In the chapter of the questions of Paramarthasamudgata.

The the Anyway, his questions, the chapter of his questions, in the Unraveling of the Thought Sūtra, the meaning of the teaching of the lack of emptiness of phenomena that is taught in the middle wheel is interpreted in terms of three types of lack of emptiness. For this, one needs to understand the presentation of the three natures. These three are imputations, other powered phenomena, and thoroughly established phenomena. And one need what do you say? The lack of entityness is interpreted individually with respect to these three.

Imputations are without entities in the sense of lacking their own character. This is because imputations are only imputed by conception. They do not exist by way of their own character. However, the meaning of being imputed conceptually, or by names and conceptual consciousnesses, here in the Chitamatra system and in the Prāsaṇgika system is very different. Even though the Chitamatrans view imputations as not existing by way of their own character, when the Prasangikas consider the matter in terms of their own interpretation of the meaning of being existent by way of the object’s own character, they say that the Chitamatrans actually are forced to assert such.

So now products are called other powered phenomena in that they are produced in dependence upon other causes and conditions. And other powered phenomena are said to be without entity ness in the sense that they are devoid of existing under their own power. Then the thoroughly established nature is identified as the object of observation of a path of purification, and this is emptiness. And it is what do you say? It is without entityness.

It is that lack of entity ness which is the ultimate. So thus, other powered phenomena are the bases of emptiness, and their emptiness of the imputed character is the emptiness of those phenomena, the thoroughly established nature of those phenomena. So then, since it is said that other powered phenomena are empty of the imputed nature, what is this imputed nature that they’re empty of? This is a very deep topic that requires a great deal of explanation, but in brief. Or The imagined character here is that, for instance, forms are naturally established as the bases of names and conceptions, whereas they actually are not.

Thus the emptiness of forms being naturally established as bases of thoughts and conceptions is a thoroughly established nature of forms.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
five sciences
Within Tibetan Buddhist education, they are: grammar, logic, medicine, arts and crafts, and religious philosophy. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top