TBI Recordings – Lamrim250516wed 4

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - Lamrim250516wed 4
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains that practitioners should first study and overview the whole Lam Rim before practising single points, and then covers the path of the middling and great scopes: the mind striving for liberation versus the mind striving for full enlightenment, and the training in equanimity and equalizing self and others. The talk also discusses the difference between self cherishing and self grasping, followed by questions from students.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: a35e31ee-0e73-4e87-b728-8623dcede9f4

Words: 4,873

Mhmm. As is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s Concise Meaning of the Stages of the Path, those endowed with powers of analysis would not be delighted by the teachings on the three principles of the path. And this implies that all those who think about these teachings will be delighted with them. What is implied here is that those of whose minds are impartial will be delighted by the topic of the which is the path of the being of the three scopes. There is no certainty that those who do not have these qualities will be delighted by such topics.

Most of you have received extensive teachings on all of the aspects of the Lam Rim. And the way one should proceed is initially understand the totality of the Lam Rim from its foundation, which is reliance on the spiritual teacher, all the way up to its culmination, which is the attainment of the state of union or Yuganaddha. And then once one has this understanding, at that point, one engages in practice. So, therefore, one should, initially, engage in an overview meditation on the totality of the Lam Rim. Now, it may be difficult at this point to gain definite ascertainment of individual topics, but one should engage in an overview meditation of all the topics from reliance on the spiritual teacher all the way up to the state of union in sequence without mixing or confusing the sequences.

And then after this, once you engage in practice. So, the way of study is similar to, engaging in a horse race. So before you engage in a horse race, obviously, you have to know how to ride. And then you walk the horse around the race course so that the horse is familiar with the obstacles. It is only after this that one engages in a horse race in front of a large audience.

And then the horse is not frightened, one knows the race course and things go well. Likewise, to practice the Lam Rim, initially, one must study and become familiar with the totality of the Lam Rim. And after this, engage in practice of individual points. Do you understand? However, the of your engaged in a different approach where they would listen or study a little bit and immediately practice this.

This is quite difficult and is akin to what is known as an experiential commentary. Generally speaking, there are four types of commentaries, Experiential commentaries, thought commentaries, so called red commentaries, and explanatory commentaries. But that’s a separate topic. So once you, therefore, focus on each of the paths, if we take, for instance, the path shared with the being of the small scope, then this is something we all know well. I assume you know at once that there are seven cycles of meditation within the path shared with the being of the small scope.

And one should become familiar with each one and gain experience in each one in sequence. The reason, we, even though we have decided to integrate these teachings with our minds, have not done so is, frankly, due to attachment to transitory happiness. We have lost sight of the durable happiness on the horizon for the sake of ephemeral happiness. And therefore, the reason for which we are unable to place these realizations within our continuum is due to attachment to ephemeral and transitory happiness and our incapacity to focus on long term happiness. Therefore, we should become familiar with, the root of the afflictions, identify the root sources of the afflictions, and proceed in this manner.

So let us take an example. In conversation with someone, it is very easy to incur non virtues of speech. Lying occurs easily, so does divisive speech, harsh words, and perhaps the most dangerous of all, gossip or idle talk. So at the beginning, we should abandon as much as we can these faults, and then progressively proceed higher. Otherwise, from the beginning to try to soar to the snowy peaks is very difficult.

Then we have to examine our mental continuum, obviously. And this is, therefore, a straightforward and easy way to proceed, to examine the faults and to see the faults as faults. And then, for instance, in the case of the non virtues of speech, which are lying, divisive talk, divisive talk, in other words, offensive or harsh words, and idle talk to abandon as much as one can. This is easy, isn’t it? To abandon faults like these, to turn away from faults like these is not difficult.

So initially, we should therefore reflect on the advantages of liberation and of the qualities of the fully enlightened body, speech, and mind. And then ask ourselves, what precisely is keeping us far removed from liberation or the qualities of the Buddhist body, speech, and mind? What keeps us far removed are sins. Therefore, we try to abandon as much as we can. Now when we speak of sins, sins really are faults within a religious context.

And one must distinguish between sins which are natural sins and those which are prescribed ones. And this is important because if we don’t understand what sins are, how precisely do we plan on obtaining the qualities of the Buddha’s body, speech, mind? It is very important to understand what faults are and what sins are. Now generally speaking, in the world at large, we speak of faults or defects. But within the context of dharma, then one speaks of sins.

Within a dharma center, one speaks of sins. Thoughts from the standpoint of dharma are sins.

So it is important, therefore, in the context of dharma to understand what a sin is, how sins are accumulated, how one differentiates them, how one purifies them, and so forth. So what is the first source of sins for us? The first source for sins for us is other sentient beings. That’s easy to understand. So the faults from the standpoint of dharma, in other words, sins find their their first source where their basis is other sentient beings or human beings.

Right? Do you understand? Very easy. Very easy. Yes.

If it’s easy, it’s easy to practice. Right? So, therefore, from the standpoint of dharma, faults or sins are accumulated initially with respect to sentient beings. Now, for instance, lack of respect for bodhisattvas, for arhats, or fully enlightened beings is a source of sin. Right?

Just as sins are accumulated with respect to other beings, likewise, the collections, in other words, the collections we have talked about so much, the collection of merit and of wisdom are also accumulated in dependence on other sentient beings. So now how do we purify or confess these faults which have been accumulated, these sins which have been accumulated? Then we can do this by means of the recitation of the Vajrasattva mantra, the recitation of the Sūtra of the Confession of Downfalls through offering prostrations, mandala, and so forth. But since the source of sins is other sentient beings, the supreme means for purifying sins is training in bodhicitta. Then you obviously might have been frightened when I said that to purify sins, you had to offer a mandala, recite the Vajrasattva mantra, offer prostrations, which as we all know is hard.

But it is much more straightforward to purify sins through bodhicitta, which has a very close relation with other sentient beings. I am in no way saying that reciting the Vajrasattva mantra, offering prostrations, offering mandala is not powerful and beneficial practices for specific situations. But here, we are referring to the training in Bodhicitta, which involves also a training in love and compassion extended to other sentient beings for the purification of sins. Now since we accumulate sins with respect to other sentient beings due to lack of respect for other sentient beings, then clearly, a training in bodhicitta, in empathy, in compassion, in love, which enhances our respect for other sentient beings, counteracts this lack of respect for others. The Kadam masters of yore said that through reflecting on bodhicitta, not only did one complete one’s collections, but in addition, one purified one’s sins.

There’s food for thought here. So this, therefore, is extremely important for the accumulation of the collections and the purification of obscurations, which is the foundation of practice. As, the glorious Atisha, for this reason studied, the training in bodhicitta under guru Suvarnadvipi for twelve years in Sumatra. Likewise, in Buddhist scriptures, it is said that Ārya Asaṇga entered in retreat twelve years to gain a vision of Maitreya. And leaving the retreat one day, saw a female dog in agony by the roadside.

And upon seeing her, he was overwhelmed with compassion. This compassion probably, became great compassion. And as a result, he saw Ārya Maitreya. He had a vision. So listen carefully now.

Then this is going to be straightforward to understand. Obviously, it depends on one’s practice. So all of you probably understand that the object of attainment of the path of the being of the great scope is full and utter enlightenment, and that the means is both method and wisdom. What is the object of abandonment? For the path of the being of the great scope.

Who said grasping? It’s not self grasping. Self grasping is at the level of the path of the middle scope. So now, on the path of the being of the middling scope, the object of attainment is liberation, and one generates, therefore, a mind striving for liberation. However, independence on which causes and conditions does such a mind striving for liberation arise.

It arises through seeing the faults of cyclic existence. So now for the path of the being of the great scope, the object of attainment is utter and full enlightenment. Just as with the path of the being of the middling scope, for the path of the being of the great scope, what are the causes and conditions for the attainment of full and utter enlightenment? Are you close? And And You have to sing by yourselves.

Right? So some of you have said that it is through understanding the thoughts of self cherishing that the mind striving for full enlightenment is generated. Some have said that it is through the union of method and wisdom. What is your understanding? So the question is, what are the causes and conditions for the mind striving for full and utter enlightenment?

Just as you gave the causes and conditions for the mind striving for liberation. Speak what you think. Yeah. Great compassion. That’s okay.

So it’s good. You have answered as best you could. It is important, that you say what you think. Because if you say what you think, then after when teachings are given, you can correct your view. That is how one studies.

So the answer is that the cause of the condition for generating the mind striving for full and utter enlightenment is the incapacity to bear the suffering of all sentient beings and the wish to free them from that. This is closely related to the cause of the generation of the mind wishing for liberation on the scope the path of the being of middling scope.

As a very close relation, as you can see, at the level of the path of the being of this middling scope, the striving for liberation arises when one reflects on the insupportable sufferings of psychic existence for oneself. And one asks oneself, why wouldn’t I be free of these sufferings? And one generates the wish to be free from them. Whereas at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, one reflects on the unbearable suffering of all sentient beings, asks oneself why wouldn’t all sentient beings be free from these sufferings, and then wonders in what state one would be able to help them in the state of full enlightenment where there is a perfection of both means and wisdom. Then one strives for this state.

So you can see there’s a very close relation between these two strivings. So some said the force of self cherishing. That isn’t quite it, although that does arise later on. What does happen is that it is through at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, realizing that one’s own suffering is insupportable and wishing for liberation from that, that one strives for liberation. Whereas at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, one extends this to all sentient beings, find the suffering of all sentient beings insupportable, and wishes them to be freed from this, and with this as a motivation, strives for full enlightenment.

Do you understand? These are very beautiful lines of thought, and I encourage you to think about them in your spare time. Then it is one thing to think about them. It’s a very different matter to transform one’s mind in their light because we have to transform totally our outlook. So at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, it is quite straightforward.

When one reflects on one’s own in supportable sufferings, the wish to attain liberation arises spontaneously. However, it is a very different matter at the level of the path of the being of the great scope. It is not sufficient to or it seems not to be sufficient to wish for all sentient beings to be freed from suffering. But in addition, there are all sorts of steps such as equalizing self and others, reflecting on the numerous faults of self cherishing, on the numerous qualities of altruism Mhmm. Then the thought of the interchange of self and others, and giving and taking.

Why is this the case? Then here we are explaining the generation of Bodhicitta by means of the equalization interchange of self and others. But there is also the sevenfold cause and instructions, which has even more steps. Equanimity, recognizing all sentient beings as mothers of yours, reflecting on their kindness, repaying their kindness, and so forth. Why?

Why? Could you answer? So this is quite close because clearly, to generate great compassion, we must reach a point where whatever sentient or whichever sentient being we meet, we spontaneously have the wish to free that being from suffering. It is easier to generate an aspiration for liberation at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope simply because we have direct personal experience of our afflictions and the suffering we experience as a result of them. It is, however, more difficult to generate great compassion at the level of the path of the being of the great scope simply because we have no direct experience of the suffering and the afflictions in the minds of others.

And therefore, to generate a fully characterized great compassion for that matter, love and empathy, The preliminary steps of the interchange equalization and interchange of self and others involving for instance, meditation on Tonglen, the practice of giving and taking, the numerous faults of self cherishing, the numerous qualities of altruism, all these are necessary as preliminaries. So the first step is equanimity, which is quite straightforward to generate. It is quite straightforward to understand that all of us, without exception, are equal in wishing for happiness and not wishing for suffering. All 7,000,000,000 human beings on this earth are absolutely identical in that respect. The following step is reflecting through numerous doors, numerous lines of reasoning on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism.

Now this calls for careful thought. And when this has been done, one endeavors to switch, to exchange the position of self cherishing and cherishing others or egoism and altruism. So after reflecting on the faults of egoism or self cherishing and the qualities of altruism or cherishing others, then we try try to interchange them. This is a very beautiful way of thinking, and when we read about this, we may be very inspired and feel great joy. It is, however, a very different affair to put this in practice.

Our reality is that 99% of the time we discard others. Others are completely unimportant to us. And 100% of the time Mhmm. We place ourselves on top of the world. This is something we are greatly accustomed to doing.

Now in the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect during a couple of minutes on these topics. We spoke last time of the possible identity or difference between self cherishing on the one hand and self grasping on the other. This is a complicated topic. We recite one b, two, three, four, and the page five, number six, number three. First one and the three.

So therefore, the mode of training the mind in keeping with equalization of an interchange of self and others has five subdivisions. The first is equanimity. The second is reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the faults of self cherishing. The third is reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of cherishing others. The fourth is the actual thought of interchanging self and others.

And the fifth is training the mind by meditating on, excuse me, the practice of giving and taking in dependence on that. So the second outline is reflecting through numerous doors and numerous lines of reasoning on the faults of self cherishing. And to do this, one must identify self cherishing. One must understand what self cherishing is. Is it identical or is it different from self grasping?

If it is identical with self grasping, that is quite awkward. But if it is different from self grasping, that is also quite awkward as well. So here, we have to analyze carefully using reasoning. So the best way to proceed is to first analyze the thoughts of both positions. If self cherishing and self grasping are one and the same, are identical, then since have eliminated self grasping, they have eliminated self cherishing as well, which is very awkward.

If on the other hand, self cherishing and self grasping are different, then when we speak of self cherishing, what exactly are we talking about? Self cherishing is self cherishing oneself. Just how is that different from self grasping? In our case, probably self cherishing and self grasping are intimately blended. So when we speak of self cherishing, we are cherishing the self, oneself.

In other words, the I. Then here, what is this I? How is it different from the eye and mind, which is present as mentioned many times in a child from the age of one or two onwards? Now when we engage in the analysis of the eye here, I have pointed out many times that the I exists. Based on experience, we all know when we are involved in a fight with someone that we will say, it’s your fault.

It’s not my fault. I’m okay. It’s your fault. And the I is very powerful at this point, isn’t it? So it is extremely important, therefore, for us who wish to understand emptiness to understand clearly the eye, to understand first the presentations of the eye in the non Buddhist systems, then the different presentations of the eye within the Buddhist systems, within the four systems of tenets, each system of tenets has its own presentation of the I.

So in the tradition of and which culminates in, the key to an understanding of emptiness is identifying the object of negation, which is the I, and this is done through analysis. Initially, in these great texts, Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, and so forth, presenting non Buddhist systems and point out that in those systems, the self or the person is perceived to be permanent, one, and independent. In other words, in a nutshell, to be permanent, and demonstrate through analysis that such a person is untenable. Then in our case, if we analyze, we are constituted of five aggregates. The form aggregate and form mental aggregates, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness.

We have to ask ourselves first, is it possible to identify the I of the self with the form aggregate? Obviously not. Because at the time of death death, the form aggregate, in other words, the body is discarded, but the eye continues. Then the position of the lower systems of tenets is that the eye is to be found within the four remaining aggregates. Then this topic of the eye is one for profound study.

It is one of great import. So we shall stop here for today. And if you have questions, I will take your questions now. In short. In short.

Without self grasping, they can’t be self cherishing. But you said that they can be self cherishing without self grasping. Can you explain that? So it’s it’s good good how you’re thinking. But let us say, if you were to say the opposite of what you said, if self grasping didn’t exist, So, basically, it’s the opposite of what you’re saying.

But if you give these lines of reasoning, you have to provide examples. For example, please. Self grasping is a believing in an independent autonomous self. Self cherishing, the way I see it, are things that come from the self grasping because initially there’s the self and then there’s the things that are associated with the self, the self cherishing. The egoism cannot exist without the self grasping.

So you’re saying also that if there is no self cherishing, there is not necessarily no self grasping. What can you give as example? What what are you saying? Repeat what you’re saying. No.

If if there is no self grasping, then? So what you’re saying is that if self cherishing is the result of self grasping, then once you eliminate the cause, self cherishing disappears. That’s what you’re saying. Once you eliminate self grasping, self cherishing disappears. Are you saying that when there is no mother, there is no child?

There are many orphans out there. No problem. It’s not what you’re thinking. No problem. Well, I, at present, have no mother, but I’m still here.

Geshe-la is an orphan. Well, my intent was saying that was had to do with My intent was well, my assumption was it had to do with you need a mother to give birth. So in turn, at that time so if there was no mother, then in turn, it would be not a mother to give birth to a child. Okay. That’s a different statement.

If you’re saying that there is no child who’s not born of a mother, that’s self evident. Nada? Other questions? I think this is possibly related to what Jad’s question was, is if if it’s

Possible to have abandoned self grasping as an arhat has done, but still have self cherishing. What is the nature of the self that is being cherished if it’s not the the object of negation? This is something we can best understand through giving instances. It won’t arise easily. We must reflect on it over and again.

Clearly, it is probably untenable to assert that if there is no self grasping, there is no self cherishing. But we have to analyze this one. Don’t be satisfied with easy answers and easy decisions. At the beginning, examine your experience and then analyze very carefully. Natalie and yeah.

After, I have long not understood why in the four faults of speech, gossip is considered worse than lying, harsh speech and divisive speech. Could it was mentioned today in the teaching that it was seen as probably the worst fault, gossip or idle talk. So could Geshe la explain that a bit further? I am not saying that gossip is a heavier sin than lying, let us say. But lying is rare for most people.

Divisive speech occurs more frequently. Gossip occurs almost all the time. Gossip is meaningless talk. In the context of this meaningless talk, a lot of faults occur. As a result of the scale of meaningless talk, it becomes heavy.

Anushaya? This is most likely a wrong line of reasoning, but I was contemplating self cherishing and self grasping in the context of the 12 limbs. And it feels like self cherishing arises at the second limb of compositional factors. I’m sorry. You have to speak louder.

Sorry. I’m starting to stretch over this. I’m gonna fall off the podium. Yeah. Okay.

Sorry. I was most likely a wrong line of reasoning. Contemplating self cherishing and grasping within the 12 limbs. Mhmm. And it feels that self cherishing is like into compositional factors of being a state of action unknown to to cause an effect in the mode of existence and self grasping arising upon at, say, the fourth limb or the fifth limb when there’s a name and a form and a base.

That’s my framework. If you want to include self cherishing or self grasping within the 12 links, they cannot occur at the level, let’s say, of the fourth link of name and form.. They must occur at the level of the first link beginning with ignorance. If they have the same meaning, then they have to be included in the first link. If Another?

A self cherishing is a passive, and the self grasping is like an action or active. Probably, yes. If self cherishing and self grasping are different, then since self cherishing is present within the continuum of an arhat it would be passive. Nothing? I have a question.

It’s quite beyond. In Heart Sūtra, there’s verse about there’s no self grasping and there’s no destroyer of self grasping. What does this mean? If you were referring to the verse in the heart sūtra which says from the nonexistence of ignorance and goes onwards, then there are two possible explanations of this verse. The first is that it refers to the mode of abiding of ignorance.

Ignorance is not truly established. It is not established from its own side. The second interpretation is that it refers to the reverse sequence of the 12 limbs. Having put an end to ignorance, one then has put an end to all of the 12 limbs all the way down to aging and death. But I think it is to be understood in terms of the object of negation here.

Back on to self cherishing and self grasping. So the object of apprehension of self grasping is an inherently existing autonomous independent self. Is the object of apprehension of self cherishing elevating oneself and discarding others? And if it’s not that, what is the object? Could you repeat your question, please?

So the object of apprehension of self grasping is inherently existent self. Mhmm. What is the object of apprehension of self cherishing? Is it elevating the self and discarding others? So it’s a difficult topic in liberation in the palm of your hand.

It is said that the object of apprehension of self cherishing is the incapacity to give up one’s body. Then it is not because it is said that it is not because it is said that it is true that we must accept it. We must analyze by ourselves. And, clearly, when we try to differentiate between self cherishing and self grasping, it is very difficult to do so correctly. Yeah.

A little more here. Yes. You know, I was struggling a bit like Jad at first. I thought, well, if there’s no self grasping, how can it be self cherishing? But then I kind of turned it on its head, and I looked at the antidotes, but I don’t know if I’m on the right track.

And I thought the antidote to self grasping, I think, is the wisdom realizing emptiness. But the antidote to self cherishing is altruism. And then I kind of flicked it, and I thought, well, I can see it’s possible to have the wisdom realizing emptiness but not altruism. So then it seemed to me very possible to have self grasping and not self cherishing or self cherishing and not self grasping. Do you understand what I mean, Leo?

Everything was right until the end. Oh, sorry. Yeah. Sorry. Yeah.

Yeah. Sorry. Exam finished. So, it’s not something one can decide, quickly. One has to reflect on it carefully to be able to posit the difference between self cherishing and self grasping.

And to do this, one must first understand the mode of self grasping. And, Natalie. With the fourth point of the five point mind training, the thought of interchange of self and others, is that the practice of, the interchange of self or others? Or does it refer to a contra contrived thought of interchange of self of others or an uncontrived thought of self interchange of self and others? So it’s not so much a case of being contrived or uncontrived.

It is the actual sort of interchange of self and others, which comes as a conclusion after training in equanimity, understanding through numerous lines of reasoning, the fault of egoism, and through numerous lines of reasoning, the qualities of altruism. Thank you. Very good. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
Kadam
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Atisha, Dromtönpa and their followers, the "Kadampa geshes"; the forerunner of the Gelug School. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top