4,141 words · 16 May 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on relying on the spiritual teacher, covering the ten qualities of a teacher and the five foremost qualities, and the three qualities a suitable student needs: non-sectarianism, intelligence and diligence. It then turns to faith as the basis of all good qualities and to how a disciple should view the guru, with questions on sectarianism, faith and the teacher’s faults.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 3b05a020-f253-42ea-94a7-a9301ebdf40c
Date: 2010-05-16
Words: 4,137
Hello? Hello? Sorry. We will generate as usual the motivation to listen to these teachings, which is a motivation reflecting that all sentient beings must be parted from suffering and the causes of suffering and placed in a state of unalloyed goodness, the state of full enlightenment, taking ourselves the responsibility or the burden for this. We therefore will listen to this very essence of the Buddhist teaching which is the middling presentation of the stages of the path.
So we will do the visualizations we usually do before the Geshe-la’s teaching on Lamrim, visualizing Buddha Shakimoniya lighting on our crown and purifying through the threefold purgings, downward purging, upward purging through the mouth and purging at the heart. Imagining specifically that the two main obstructions to realizations at the level of wisdom and of the path are eliminated. The foremost obstruction to the generation of wisdom is the apprehension of the true existence of phenomena. And its foremost antidote is that wisdom which apprehends the non true existence of phenomena. Likewise, the foremost obstruction for the generation of the method aspect of the path is self cherishing and the foremost antidote to self cherishing is the generation of bodhichitta.
We shall therefore imagine that we receive uncommon blessings to realize both the wisdom which realizes directly emptiness and to generate bodhichitta within our mind So we are at present covering the presentation of how to rely on the spiritual teacher, which is the foundation of the teachings. And within the outline of relying on the spiritual teacher, we have how to rely on the teacher, which is the root of the path, subdivided into a somewhat elaborate explanation for developing certain knowledge and the presentation of the general characteristics of the teacher. These are the 10 characteristics of a spiritual friend or a spiritual teacher in keeping with my quote from the rely on a teacher who is disciplined, serene, thoroughly pacified on page 71 of your English translation. Discipline serene and thoroughly pacified refer to the first of the three trainings. The training in ethics, in concentration and in wisdom.
Has good qualities surpassing those of the students. Is energetic, has a wealth of scriptural knowledge. In other words has received many teachings, possesses loving concern, has sound knowledge of reality, in other words has some understanding of emptiness and skill in instructing disciples and has abandoned dispiritedness, in other words the laziness which arises when one reflects that the students do not follow the instructions of the teacher. Geshe-la has completed the presentation of these 10 qualities and at present, we will approach the next topic, which is which of these are central. And we are now at the bottom of page 73 of the English translation.
So Potowa said, Potowa is one of the very great Kadampa Geshe of the lineage of scripture. These five qualities, loving concern, knowledge of reality, and the three trainings are foremost. So these are the five qualities which are foremost from among the 10 qualities. My master, Sharawa, this was one of the teachers of Geshe Potowa, is not very learned with regards to all the scriptures and cannot withstand dispiriting circumstances. Therefore, he doesn’t even thank those who help him.
However, since he has these five qualities, the five qualities which are mentioned, he is helpful to whoever whomever is in his presence. Nyanyen. Nyanyen was another of the teachers of Geshe Potowa does not have any skill in speech at all. Actually, what is said here is that he is not learned at all in the Tibetan text. Even when giving a single dedication of an offering, he can only think none of these people here understands what I’m saying. But as he has five qualities, he’s helpful to whomever enters in his presence.
And then the following passage is not in the English translation. I will translate directly. In the light of the difficulty to find such a spiritual teacher who has completed all the qualities, one should not rely on a spiritual teacher whose thoughts are greater, greater here than his qualities. Nor should one rely on a spiritual teacher whose thoughts and whose qualities are equal. So Geshe-la says Je Tsongkhapa is indicating here, one should not rely on a spiritual teacher who has more thoughts and qualities nor should one rely on a spiritual teacher which has an equal number of thoughts and qualities.
It is said, returning to Je Tsongkhapa’s root text, that one should rely on a teacher who has superior qualities. And then the following passage is at the bottom of page 74, your English translation. The guru who helps you to achieve liberation, actually the guru who establishes liberation within your mind, is the foundation of your deepest aspiration. Therefore, you who wish to rely on a guru should understand these defining characteristics, these are the 10 or the summarized five characteristics and strive to seek one who has them. Also, those who wish to have students should understand these characteristics and strive to possess them.
So here Geshe-la says that both parties, he who explains the teaching and he who list he or she who listens to the teachings should strive to have the requisite characteristic characteristics for their position. So we have now finished the presentation of the spiritual teacher and the qualities at present of the listener on page 75 of your English translation. The defining characteristics of the student who relies upon the teacher. These are explained in the light of a famous quote from Āryadeva’s 400 Stanzas. It is said that one who is non partisan, in other words, one who is non sectarian, intelligent and diligent, literally the Tibetan says one who strives, is a vessel for listening to the teachings.
The good qualities of the instructor do not appear otherwise nor do those of fellow listeners. So if these three first conditions, non sectarianism, intelligence and diligence are not present, then neither the qualities of the teacher nor those of the students will appear. And Je Tsongkhapa then comments on this passage by saying, says that one who is endowed with these three qualities is suitable to listen to the teachings. The three qualities mentioned at the beginning of the stanza. He also says that if you have all these qualities, the good qualities of one who instructs you in the teachings will appear as good qualities, not as faults.
So if one has these good qualities, then one will see the teacher himself as endowed with qualities. Otherwise, the teacher’s good qualities appear as false to the deluded mind. In addition, on page 76, he says that to such a fully qualified person, the good qualities of fellow listeners will also appear as good qualities and not faults. So one who has the three features mentioned by Āryadeva of non partisanship of intelligence and of striving will also see the good qualities of fellow students as qualities and not as faults. It is stated in commentary that if you the listener do not have all these defining characteristics of a suitable recipient of the teachings, then the influence of your own thoughts will cause even an extremely pure teacher who instructs you the teachings to appear to have thoughts.
So if someone’s own side, one doesn’t have these three qualities mentioned by Āryadeva, then even though from the teacher’s side, there may be no qualities, the teacher will appear as having qualities. And then we are at present in second paragraph of page 76. With respect to these three court characteristics, nonpartisan or nonsectarian means not to take sides. If you are partisan, you will be obstructed by your bias and will not recognize good qualities. For that matter, Geshela says, you would actually see sectarianism within the teacher, whereas it is a projection from your own mind.
Because of this, you will not discover the meaning of the good teachings. As states in his heart of the middle way, through state through taking sides, The mind is the mind suffers literally in Tibetan whereby you will never know peace. And Je Tsongkhapa then defines sectarianism or taking sides. It is to have attachment, literally to have desire for your own religious system and to have hostility towards others. Look for it in your own mind and then discard it.
Then moving onwards at the lower part of page 76, one of the persons has a doubt question is just that one characteristic enough. The answer is though non partisan, in other words, though non sectarian. If you do not have the mental force to distinguish between correct paths of good explanation and forced paths of forced explanation, you are not a suitable vessel to listen to the teachings. So here one must be able to know when an explanation is a good explanation and when an explanation is a false explanation, one must be able to distinguish between these two and if one is able to do so, then one is a vessel for the teachings. Therefore, you must have the intelligence that understands both of these.
And the following question at the bottom of page 76 are just these two enough. The answer is though having both of these, if like a drawing of a person who is listening to the teachings, are inactive, you are not fit to listen to the teachings. So it’s not sufficient to just attend teachings physically and remain inattentive and not put effort. Instead, one must put striving and effort from one’s own side. Therefore, you must have great diligence.
Candrakīrti’s commentary. This is Candrakīrti’s commentary, the famous commentary on Āryadeva’s 400, which was the text quoted on page 75. Says, after adding the three qualities of the student, this refers to the three qualities of non sectarianism intelligence and diligence mentioned in Āryadeva’s quote of the Catuhshataka. To the two qualities of being focused and having respect for the teaching and its instructor, there are total of five qualities. Then in turn, Je Tsongkhapa says, these five qualities listed by Candrakīrti can be reduced to four.
The first of these is to strive very diligently at the teachings. The second is when listening to the teachings to focus the mind well on the teachings on page 77. The third is to have great veneration for the dharma and the dharma instructor. And the final one is to abandon mistaken explanations and to hold on to the worthy explanations. And moving onwards on page 77, having intelligence is the favorable condition that gives rise to these four. Intelligence here is wisdom.
And it is a favorable condition giving rise to the four qualities which are reduction of the five qualities listed by Chandra Kirti. Now from the standpoint of the incompatible conditions or the interferences, being non sectarian gets rid of the unfavorable condition, the incompatible condition of being sectarian. So here two are needed, Geshela says, one must have wisdom on the one hand and one must be non sectarian on the other hand. Investigate whether these attributes that make you suitable to be led by a guru are complete. If they are complete, cultivate delight.
If they are incomplete, you must make an effort to obtain the causes that will complete them for the future. The Tibet means actually for the future. And then the third outline on page 77, how the student relies upon the teacher. This I will translate directly. Likewise, one who is suitable to be a vessel should investigate whether the teacher has the characteristics which have been explained or not and should rely on a spiritual teacher who has those characteristics requesting from him the kindness or the benevolence of bestowing the dharma.
So here Geshela says, one should not rely on just anybody Instead, one should examine whether the teacher is qualified or not and one should teach whether he’s he one should check whether he teaches in keeping with the tradition he has received or not. And then moving onwards to the bottom paragraph on page 77. In general, a teacher is someone someone from whom you have received the teachings kinds words. Specifically, teacher is someone who skillfully guides you with the instructions of all the paths in their entirety. In other words, the totality of paths.
And at present, relying on the teacher is subdivided into two. Relying on the teacher through thought and relying on the teacher through behavior. And at present, the intermediate lambrem jumps the following two pages in the greater lambrem, and we pass directly to outline b on page 80. So I will translate first from the intermediate lambrim. Regarding the first, which is how to rely on the spiritual teachers through thought.
There are two subdivisions, training in faith, which is the foundation and recollecting the kindness of the spiritual teacher thus generating veneration. As to the first, it is said in the Sūtra of the Three Heaps. Faith is the prerequisite of all good qualities. A procreator of them like a mother who then protects and increases them and Middling Lamrim does not give the rest of the quote. So here, Geshela says faith is the mother of all qualities.
It is thanks to faith that the qualities are protected, not only protected, but because they do not degenerate, faith actually enables them to increase. And then moving onwards to the quote from the 10 teachings sūtra, the Dashadharma sūtra. It states, faith is the supreme vehicle, not the best of vehicles. Definitely delivering the wise and there’s a mistake in the English translation to renunciation not to Buddhahood. Therefore persons of intelligence rely on the guidance of faith.
So Geshela says that faith actually is the gateway both to renunciation and to full enlightenment in as much as when the faith is generated in the mind, in turn effort arises. And then through effort, one can progress both to liberation and to full enlightenment. Virtues will not arise in people who have not faith. So the first paragraph describes the qualities of faith. The second paragraph describes the thoughts of not having faith.
Virtues will not arise in people who do not have faith just as sprouts do not grow from seeds scorched by fire. So if one takes seeds which could give rise to a sprout and one burns them, then even if one plants them, the seeds have lost their potency. Likewise, without faith, it is impossible to give rise to qualities. All the qualities, Geshela says, arise on the basis of faith. And then moving onwards, we’re at the bottom of page 18 of your text.
In general, faith is of many types. So what is being referred to here as a general characteristics of faith. Faith in the three jewels, faith in common effects, and faith in the four noble truths. However, here we are speaking of faith in the spiritual teacher. This is a specific type of faith which is being spoken about here.
With regards to how disciples should view their gurus, the tantra bestowing the initiation of Vajrapāni says, Vajrapāni says this is probably an Anuttara Yoga tantra treatise and represents therefore the ultimate thought or the ultimate intent of the Buddhas. If you would ask all of secrets, which is a euphemism for how disciples should view their masters, then I would answer that they should view them just as they view the Bhagavan. So this actually is a position which is the common position shared with both the collection of Sutras of the Great Vehicle and the teachings of the lower vehicle, specifically what is known euphemistically as the Vinaya treatises. Moving downwards in your text, in the Mahāyāna Sutras as well, is thought that you must think of the guru as being the teacher. The text on discipline state this as well and the meaning of their statements is as follows.
When you recognize someone to be a Buddha, will not discern faults in the person and you will pay attention to his or her good qualities. So here Geshela says the meaning of this passage is, however, more we see the teacher as a fully enlightened being, that much more, we will be unable to see any faults in the teacher. This is the meaning of the passage in question. And then moving onwards to the next quote from this famous tantra. In the middle of page 81, the tantra bestowing the initiation of Vajrapāni says.
And Je Tsongkhapa gives a summarized version of this quote. Keep the masters good qualities in mind, never seize upon their faults. Keeping their good qualities in mind, will reach attainments, literally Siddhis. Seizing upon their faults, you will not. So here it is through being aware of the qualities of the spiritual teacher that we will attain siddhis and siddhis here refer to siddhis in the context of lamrim since this is a treatise in question.
Therefore, it refers to these three principles of the path, renunciation, bodhichitta, and the view of emptiness. And then the following passage indicates clearly how to handle situations where the teacher might have some small thoughts. Your guru might have good qualities for the most part and have only slight thoughts. This refers to a spiritual teacher who appears to have some small thoughts. If you examine your guru for those thoughts, this will block your own attainments, this will block your siddhis.
Whereas even in the case of a guru who mostly has faults, actually the Tibetan says even in the case of a guru who has large faults, important faults, you will give rise to your own siddhis if you train in faith by focusing on the good qualities while not looking for the faults. Therefore, once someone is your guru, whether he or she has small or great faults, contemplate the disadvantages of examining for his or her faults. Repeatedly think about eliminating that tendency and then stop it. Even when the influence of factors such as an overabundance of afflictions or a lack of conscientious leads you to conceive a fault in your Guru, take pains to confess this and restrain yourself from ever doing this again. Once you have done this, the influence of that conception will gradually diminish.
So the conceptions which arise within our minds and which see faults within the spiritual teacher, whether the faults may actually be present in actuality or not, must be eliminated. And then jumping to the second paragraph on page 82. This is similar to the following example. The great elder, in other words, Atisha, held the Madhyamica view and Serlingpa, who was his teacher, held the view of a true Aspectarian Chitamatrin. In other words, someone who considered that phenomena were truly existent.
Therefore, Atisha’s view was superior to that of Serlimpa. Atisha had some 150 gurus, Geshela said, but he considered Serlingpa as supreme among these gurus. Still, Atisha upheld Serlingpa as a guru who was unrivaled among his gurus because he had obtained the spirit of enlightenment in the general presentation of the stages of the Mahāyāna path, independence upon We will stop here for today. And if you have if you have questions, please feel free to ask them. Oh, yes.
Yes. So sectarianism does not refer to discrimination of the view based on pure reasoning to try to ascertain whether a view is correct or not. And it does not also refer to criticizing incorrect views or wrong views. What it refers to is rejecting other traditions, however worthwhile they might be based on attachment to one’s own tradition and enmity or animosity towards other traditions. That is what is meant by sectarianism.
Yes. For all five. So this quote of refers to three qualities, not five qualities. And these qualities, to be frank, Geshela, are qualities which are difficult to generate in one life. One sees them, in the person when they are young, when they are children.
They are present from, training in past lives. We can see that some children, for instance, naturally have intelligence, naturally have diligence or not biased or sectarians. So this is an indication of this training. However, having said this, what this quote indicates, the quote of Āryadeva in the 400 indicates is what the qualities of the best student or the best listener should be. Anyone who listens Lamrim teachings will benefit from them.
Likewise, whoever explains them benefits from them. With respect to the specific quality of intelligence, the cause for intelligence is study. So the more one studies, then the more one’s intelligence is developed and the more one progresses towards a path to to omniscience. Are there other questions? Yes.
So the definition of faith is a mental factor which is free of any connection with the afflictions. All virtuous states of mind without exception are accompanied by this mental factor, by the mental factor of faith. If the mental factor of faith is absent, then the virtuous mind decreases in its intensity. Moreover, for however long a mind of faith, the mental factor of faith is present within the mind stream for that long. Non virtue states of mind cannot be present.
So if the mental factor of faith is present for one hour, for one hour, the mental afflictions cannot be present in the mind. Likewise for however long the mental afflictions are present in the mind, the mental factor of faith is necessarily absent because the root of virtue is faith and the root of non virtue is non faith. So faith and non faith are mutually incompatible. Incompatible. Yes?
Are there other questions? No. It is not possible to lead an ethical life without faith. However, what is being talked about here is not reasonless faith, unsubstantiated faith. What is being talked about here is faith which is grounded in reasoning, which is grounded in analysis from one reason, from another reason faith arises.
So all three subdivisions of faith, faith which arises reflecting on the qualities of the object of faith or faith which arises reflecting on the capacity, the potency of the object of faith are rooted in this reasoning. And this is indispensable. There is no such thing as wisdom without faith. A wisdom without faith would turn upon itself. Yes.
Investing So investigation is extremely important and critical and analytical investigation, but it is important before the future teacher is accepted as a spiritual teacher. At that time, if one sees faults, then from one’s own standpoint without allowing irritation to arise with one’s within one’s mind, one must excuse oneself and depart. However, once a spiritual teacher has been adopted, the situation is different. So Geshela says one has to make a very, very clear distinction here between Christianity and Buddhism. There are great similarities from the standpoint of the method aspect of the path in the practice of love and compassion specifically.
As far as the views are concerned, Christianity and Buddhism are completely incompatible. There is nothing in common whatsoever. And this has to be very clearly stated. And then in turn, it is very difficult to apply the Buddhist teachings on relying on the spiritual teacher of Christianity because Christians accept the existence of a creator God, which is completely refuted in Buddhism. However, Geshela thinks from his own side that for a Christian who was attending teachings by a Christian teacher, well in general, he would have to examine the teachings of his teacher.
Clearly, if the foremost Christian teacher, which would be the Pope for the Roman Catholics, were to give instructions which were in keeping with the Christian tradition, Geshela cannot see how they would not be beneficial for the mind of a Christian student. Is that answer? So if the teacher, the Christian teacher is but has a good motivation when he gives a teaching, then if the student from his side is able to protect or to maintain these teachings, then there should be benefit for him. However, if he lacks faith in the teacher and has strong doubts, then it is perhaps better not to do everything he’s instructed to do. There is great danger in relying on an unexamined teacher.
There are many accounts of this in the Buddhist scriptures as the account, the famous account of Angulimala who was told by a Hindu teacher that if he killed 1,000 human beings, he would attain liberation. And he killed 999 of them wearing their fingers and garments around his neck and was going to kill the one thousandth, an old woman when the Buddha manifested to convince him that this was a heinously wrong path. Okay. Thank you. K.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
- The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
- The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.