TBI Recordings

2 h 5 min · 3,525 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche unpacks the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view of emptiness through the Bodhicitta Vivarana commentary, combining philosophical rigor with practical guidance. He opens by clarifying motivation—how the quality of dharma practice depends entirely on the mind behind it, and why practitioners should cultivate bodhicitta, the aspiration to achieve enlightenment for all beings. The core is a verse-by-verse analysis of how all phenomena—mind and matter alike—lack inherent, independent existence. Using logical syllogisms and concrete examples (seeds and sprouts, spatial directions, sensation), he systematically refutes earlier Buddhist schools and non-Buddhist Indian philosophies, culminating in Nāgārjuna’s four negations. The teaching concludes with the five degenerations and how merit dedication, grounded in emptiness understanding, preserves virtue. For practitioners with grounding in Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 100421-000.mp3

UUID: 9da40aff-a916-40ef-955a-dcabefc125d5

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,523

So much. Since whatever we engage in, whether it is teaching the Dharma or listening the Dharma becomes virtuous, non virtuous, or not neutral in the function of the motivation in which we engage in that deed, then we have to generate the requisite motivation. If the motivation is virtuous, then listening and explaining the dharma is a virtuous deed. If it is a neutral motivation, listening and explaining the dharma is a neutral deed. If it’s non virtuous, if it’s anger or desire, they become non virtuous.

The motivation we should generate is a motivation wishing to help others, and to help others in the fullest sense of the term through freeing them from the ocean of suffering of cyclic existence, and placing them in a state of unalloyed happiness, a state of full enlightenment. If we listen to teachings with such a motivation, there will be great benefit. Therefore, Rinpoche would like us to meditate for a couple minutes on this motivation. Yeah. So as Atisha said, whatever practice one engages in for this life will lead to no results beyond this life.

And the practices one engages in such as meditating on impermanence, taking refuge, or trying to understand karma and causality are the beginning of practice for future lives. So this quote clearly indicates that within the context of striving for the happiness of cyclic existence, we have to distinguish between the path which is specific to that of the being of small scope and the path of the being of small scope which is shared with the other vehicles. The path which is specific to the being of small scope is this path which only aspires to happiness in future lives, and therefore which only aspires to, for instance, rebirth as a deity or as a human being in the future life, an avoidance of the lower rebirth. Any practice which is focused only on this life does not even begin to be Dharma practice. It is not qualified to be Dharma practice.

So any so called practice we engage in for the sake of money, or for clothing, for food, such practice is not Dharma practice. It is merely worldly practice. And in dependence on those activities, we will accrue no benefit whatsoever for future lives. So within the threefold subdivision of beings, beings of the small, middling and great scope, beings of the small scope are beings who strive mainly for happiness starting with the next life, Beings of the middling scope are those who strive for that happiness which is a freedom from cyclic existence, the state of liberation. And beings of the great scope are beings who strive for that happiness of full enlightenment.

As great vehicle practitioners, we should however practice those components of the path of the being of small scope, are shared with the great scope. And these include, for instance, the practice of taking refuge or for that matter, karma and causality. In dependence on the practice of taking refuge, a great scope practitioner will then engage in the sevenfold cause and effect generation of the mind of bodhicitta, and even if he cannot generate it in an uncontrived state, he will try to endeavor it to generate it in a contrived state. So a Mahāyāna practitioner practicing the small scope strives for happiness in future lives, not for his own sake, but for the sake of others, which is the opposite of the practice of a being of small scope who strives for happiness in future lives for his own sake. It is therefore capital to be very clear about our motivation.

The main criterion for a great vehicle practitioner is that generation of bodhicitta, which in turn leads him to practice all of the aspects of the path. So a being of the lower vehicle wishes to attain higher states of rebirth as a gateway to liberation. He being of the great vehicle wishes to attain higher states of rebirth to attain thereby full enlightenment. Whatever we engage in for the sake of this life is not dharma. It is only worldly activities.

There is no common denominator between the two. And therefore, all of these so called activities we engage in which we call Dharma are very probably not Dharma. When we recite our commitments, when we engage in practices such as the practice of Heruka, Guhyasamāja, if we engage in them for the sake of this life, it does not begin to be Dharma. If on the other hand, we reflect on the well-being of just one insect and work for that insect’s sake, that work becomes dharma. So the great vehicle is an inconceivable vehicle which includes both the Pāramitāyāna, the vehicle of perfections, and the Tantrayāna.

It is extremely powerful in blessings and leads us swiftly to attainments. However, if we were to engage in such a practice because it is celebrated and famous without being wary of our motivation, If we were not to study carefully the practice and meditate carefully, then we would not have any chance of attaining the goals we set ourselves. But he says it would be akin to some people in Tibet who wanted to scale mountains. And the mountains were obviously very high, very notorious, and they would stare at the peak of the mountains and not look at the ground. And the end result of this is just breaking one’s leg, which is a very painful experience.

So this is what happens when we engage in advanced practices without refuge and without generating a powerful motivation of bodhicitta. We generate merely the causes for rebirth in the lower realms. So there is a great danger if we follow this path of ending completely empty handed without anything beneath us to support us and without achieving our higher goals. And this is completely meaningless. All of us therefore have to be careful in how we behave.

So as Rinpoche said last time, he would not enter into too much detail in the explanation of the Cittamātra view, and we’ll pass directly to the elaborate explanation of the Madhyamaka view from the standpoint of the last verse of the prologue, all things that equal in their lack of self at the beginning of your root text. So remember, mentioned that the first verse of this stanza of inherent being all that it is are free, refutes, as we mentioned in the previous courses, the position of the outsiders of the. On the website. So we will therefore skip the end of the Cittamātra section and pass directly to verses 46 onwards of the root text of Bodhicitta Vivarana and pages three eighty five onwards of the Tibetan text, which you do not have.

I’ll translate at site. And this focuses mainly on the explanation of the supreme view, the view of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school of thought. So in which he would enter into this because he feels it is more beneficial for us than the details of the Cittamātra view. So fifth fifthly, in Nawang Drapa’s commentary, when it is said that one’s mind is primordially uncreated and so forth, this refers to the first stanza of the Bodhicitta Vivarana. There are four meanings to this.

The first is an explanation of that emptiness, which is the Mādhyamika view. The second is an explanation in detail of emptiness from the standpoint of the Cittamātra tradition. The third is an emptiness explanation of inner dependent arising, and the fourth is an explanation of exterior dependent arising. Regarding the first, this is covered in the following verses, and these are verses 45 all the way down to verse 52 of your root text, pages 16 to 18, and translating from Nawang Drapa’s commentary. Now regarding the meaning of ultimate bodhicitta here, Rinpoche says this is ultimate bodhicitta from within conventional and ultimate bodhicitta.

Therefore, it is this mind which realizes emptiness. If one were to explain it in detail, it would be explained as follows. And therefore, the very first stanza of bodhicitta Vivarana on page three of your text, which encapsulates the gist of this treatise in its first verse of inherent being all entities are free. It excludes the views of the non-Buddhist outsiders. The second verse eliminates the views of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika.

The third verse eliminates the Cittamātra or mind only view. And the fourth verse, and especially the two last verses, and thus our mind primordially are unborn and their nature emptiness, formulate clearly the view of the Prāsaṇgika school of thought, the consequentialist school of thought. And generally speaking, it is true for both human beings and animals. Rinpoche says that our minds are primordially unborn and their nature is emptiness. What is meant here by primordially is that our minds are beginningless.

There is no beginning to our mind, and beginninglessly, they are not created by their own characteristics. Therefore, from the very beginning, they are completely empty of inherent existence. The same thing can be said of the bodies of beings that beginninglessly, they are not they do not arise by their own characteristics, and therefore, beginninglessly can be said to be empty of inherent existence. Body and mind here are given as examples for all phenomena. Therefore, it can be said of all phenomena in keeping with the that they lack inherent existence.

Generally speaking, all phenomena are divided into two broad categories, outer and inner phenomena. Outer phenomena are phenomena which are devoid of feelings or sensation. All beings are endowed with feelings and sensations. So outer phenomena would be, for instance, houses, stones, and so forth. Inner phenomena, on the other hand, are all those phenomena endowed with feelings or sensations.

Beings in general are endowed with feelings and sensations. And our body, for instance, is an inner phenomenon because it is subsumed within a being. If we cut our fingers, then we experience a sensation of pain. So this twofold division of phenomena encompasses all phenomena and is alluded to in Nawang Drapa’s commentary on the Bodhicitta Vivarana, when he says, its feature, which is the object emptiness, which has to be understood through ascertainment, is understood in keeping with the following syllogism. The subject, both outer and inner entities are necessarily lacking in inherent existence because irrespective of whether they are self characterized or generally characterized phenomena, they lack establishment by their own characteristics.

So here the subject has been explained, outer and inner entities, in other words, and inner phenomena, lack inherent establishment or inherent existence, because whether they are self characterized or other characterized phenomena, both categories lack inherent establishment. Self characterized phenomena are impermanent phenomena, these are phenomena which can perform a function. Generally characterized phenomena, on the other hand, are permanent phenomena. Now, if we take the case of human beings, generally speaking, human beings are defined as that which can speak and understand meaning. This is the characteristic of a human being.

And we can see that human beings would be marked by three characteristics. They could be said to be impermanent, in other words, self characterized phenomenon, selfless and empty. And then reading onwards with commentary, this subject, in other words, entities both exterior and interior, the same subject as in the previous syllogism. It follows that it lacks inherent generation because it is not generated at the time, as an existent at the time of the cause, and in addition, if it were not to exist at the time of the cause, it would not exist by nature. The first part of the reason given here refutes the position of the Sankhyas, which were one of the darshanas, one of the views of ancient India, which asserted the existence of the effect at the time of the cause, and asserted for instance that at the time of the seed, the sprout existed as well.

This is totally at odds with the Buddhist position, which asserts that at the time of the effect, the time of the cause, excuse me, the effect does not exist, and that at the time of the effect, the cause itself does not exist. Otherwise, Rinpoche said, if we were to assert as the Sankhyas do, the existence of the effect at the time of the cause, and we asserted also the existence of the effect at the time of the effect, we would have to assert a twofold existence of the effect, which is obviously impossible. So the Buddhist position regarding causality is that when, to take the example of seeds, seeds are planted in fields, in dependence on cooperative conditions such as the field, manure, water, and so forth, the potency of the seed to give rise to its effect is activated. And when the effect, which is the sprout, arises and exists, the seed itself ceases to exist. So you can see that when a seed sprouts, at the very beginning, you have a small sprout inside the seed.

At that point, there is no seed anymore. Therefore, at the time when the seed exists, the sprout does not exist. At the time when the sprout exists, the seed does not exist. And then, now, commentary continues. The first is established, in other words, the first part of the reason is established because otherwise it would be necessary when generation has ceased for generation to occur again.

So this reason criticizes in detail the position of the Sankhyas, which assert the existence of the effect at the time of the cause. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in the Mulamadhyamaka Karika, it is not generated from self, it is not generated from other, it is not generated from both self and other, and it is not generated from neither. Ārya Nāgārjuna was prophesied by Buddha Śākyamūni as the great master who would further the Buddha’s teachings. And this famous quote must be understood as follows. The statement that it is not generated from self is a clear refutation of the view of the non-Buddhist outsiders, of the Tīrthikas, who assert a generation from an inherently existing self.

While the refutation of the generation from other is a refutation of the view which will later be held by the Svatāntrika Madhyamikas, which assert a generation from an other, which is an existent by its own characteristics. The generation from both self and other is refutation of a view which asserts that effects are generated from the collection of both self and other. And the statement, it is not generated from neither, is the refutation of the view that there is no causality. I don’t know. Not the But we will stop here for today.

If you have questions on the topics he covered, this is the time to ask them. Yes. Arbitrarily position the four directions. Even if there’s one particle completely alone, and you posit the corner directions if you choose north, south, east, west. And then there is no particular problem.

If you were to take the case of a house, says, it is difficult to imagine a house for which you cannot posit the directions. He thinks a mono directional house probably does not exist. Are there other questions? So, Rinpoche thinks maybe between your sprout and your You see, I mean, there’s no point where the the seed becomes a sprout, And there’s no point where the sprout has arisen from the seed. They never meet.

So you could say that in between, it’s empty. So for instance, the outer skin on the seed is not the seed. It’s never called the seed. When we speak of the seed, we’re speaking actually of the potency to give rise to the sprout. That is what is called the seed.

Are there other questions? On agriculture? This is a position of the lower schools, specifically of the Sautrāntika School, which say that there are two categories of phenomena, self characterized and generally characterized phenomena. Self characterized phenomena are impermanent phenomena, which are able to perform a function. They are defined by their own characteristics.

Other characterized phenomena are phenomena which are defined in dependence on others, and which are permanent phenomena. So if you were to take the position of the lower schools, the nature of fire, the definition of fire is that which is hot and burning. That is the uncommon feature of fire, which characterizes fire. It is specific to fire alone, whereas impermanence, for instance, would be shared by fire and other phenomena, and this would be, which he thinks, what the lowest schools understand by generally characterized phenomenon. Are there other questions?

So here, feelings are obviously consciousnesses or sensations, and phenomena divided into phenomena which are held by feelings or apprehended by feelings and phenomena which are not held by feelings. And as for ascertaining which is which, somebody suggests that you take a knife and you try cutting your finger and it will become self evident. And then if you take the self same knife and you bang on a stone, it should also be self evident. If you go further in your self mutilation and you take a knife and you cut the tip of your nail, you won’t feel anything. But as you keep moving inwards, the sensation will arise.

Are there other questions? So there are two types of dharmakayas or two types of truth bodies. The truth body of abandonment and the truth body of realizations, which only the fully enlightened beings have. The truth body of abandonment is that truth body which is an abandonment of all of the afflictions as well as all of the faults without exception. And as a result of that truth body of abandonment, the Buddha has the truth body of realization which is that truth body which is an omniscient mind perceiving all of the phenomena both in their conventional and ultimate mode of existence exactly as they are in the same way as if one were to hold them on one’s hand.

Then to obtain the truth body of abandonment, the dharmakaya of abandonment, one must first have generated the wisdom which realizes emptiness, which leads to the abandonment, in other words, complete destruction of all afflictions and of all thoughts. Okay? Are there other questions? We we live at present in an age which is called the age of the five degenerations, which include the degenerations of the eon, of beings, the lifespan, of the afflictions and so forth. And in this age of the five degenerations, the five degenerations in turn give rise to major disruptions among the four elements, earth, water, air, and fire.

And we can see around us the huge disruptions, these elements which are disturbed are wreaking havoc. There have been earthquakes in Haiti and in Tibet which have caused untold suffering through disruption of the earth element. There have been tsunamis which have called caused untold suffering through disruption of the water element. Your country Australia has been afflicted by great suffering through disruption of the fire element, which has caused great suffering in Victoria. And now in America, untold disruption has been reaped by the upheavals of the air element and the hurricanes and tornadoes it unleashes.

In every single case, this is a direct result of the karma of beings accumulated through ignorance. In the fortunate ages, the elements were very stable. Unfortunately, we do not live in that period anymore. And as the disruptions of the elements increase, we can only expect more hardship. Specifically, it is said that when the disruption of the fire element reaches its pinnacle, much of the earth will be burnt to a cinder.

Likewise, when the disruption of the water element reaches a pinnacle, much of the earth will be covered in waters. When the disruption of the air element reaches its apogee, it will be almost impossible to breathe. So it is very difficult for us to do anything against this except to try to limit the potential damage to ourselves. And this we do through taking refuge, which is the gateway to Dharma and makes or is the criterion which differentiates Buddhists from non Buddhists. And through generating bodhicitta, which is the supreme mind for accumulating merit.

And then in addition to this, we should address prayers and try to meditate on emptiness. In that, dedication prayers are extremely important. And, in his Easy Path, it is also said clearly that dedication is the most powerful and easiest way to accumulate merit, especially if we dedicate the merit to all mother sentient beings as vast as space. Then we accumulate merit for each and every sentient being to whom we have dedicated this merit, and the merit very easily and swiftly becomes infinite. So this is how we should dedicate.

If in addition, one is powerfully convinced that the dedicator, the dedicated deed, and the dedicatee, the receiver of the dedication, are all three empty of inherent existence. This prevents the destruction of the seeds of virtue by anger and so forth. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
five degenerations
The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top