TBI Recordings

1 h 56 min · 3,997 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 116-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche works through why emptiness is Buddhism’s central path to liberation. He begins with the “decaying composite” view that underpins saṃsāra, then explains the logical frameworks Buddha used for emptiness, focusing on Je Tsongkhapa’s unique way of refuting both eternalism and nihilism. Rinpoche covers the five features of emptiness as a meditation object, compares it to space as a non-affirming negative, and addresses persistent Cittamātra misunderstandings. He emphasizes a critical distinction: the inherently existing self that must be refuted does not exist, while the nominal self that acts, accumulates karma, and transmigrates definitely does. Includes Q&A. Aimed at serious practitioners.

Flags: []

File metadata (for organising)

File: 100428-000.mp3

UUID: 6f71b63e-cc9f-408c-99fe-9717923e22fc

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,992

We will meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation of benefiting others, which is a motivation striving to benefit others, all mother sentient beings as vast as space. Space, both in the conventional and in the ultimate sense. So, conventionally through obviously giving them food and clothing, but ultimately through placing them in a state of unalloyed bliss, a state of full enlightenment. And with this as a motivation, we will listen to these teachings and through listening to them implant within our mind stream the karmic imprints to gain realizations later on. So as Ārya Nāgārjuna said, I praise the Buddha who out of his kindness taught the view of emptiness for the benefit of beings.

Here, teaching of the view of emptiness for the benefit of beings was a teaching for the benefit of beings as vast as space. And Buddha trained in empathy and great compassion for countless eons to reach the point of full enlightenment where he could be of benefit in that sense for others. The goal of the Buddha’s teachings were through great compassion to eliminate both suffering and the causes of suffering. And for this reason, the Buddha taught an abandonment of views. The abandonment of views which is taught here is actually an abandonment of the five wrong views.

This is how the term view has to be understood here. And of these five wrong views, the foremost is the view of the decaying composite or the degenerating composite, which is the very foundation of cyclic existence. Since it is on that basis that we accumulate karma, which in turn causes the wheel of lives to cycle. So it is precisely for this that the Buddha taught the holy Dharma to enable us to abandon this view of the decay with the degenerating composite and specifically taught the view of emptiness without which there is no possible liberation from cyclic existence. And for this reason, Nāgārjuna says, I prostrate to the being which taught emptiness.

Generally speaking, there are multiple subdivisions or presentations of emptiness. Emptiness can be presented in terms of twenty, eighteen, four or two different subdivisions. And when one compares the subdivisions emptiness, these are actually limited in number if one compares them with for instance, the subdivisions present in the presentation of the other paramitas. For instance, the subdivisions into 10 paths, into 10 grounds, into five paths and so forth. However, even though in terms of divisions, the presentation of emptiness is not that difficult.

It is very difficult to understand in terms of its meaning, and for this reason it is explained again and again. Śāntideva said, all of the Buddha’s teachings are merely branches of the teaching on wisdom. And therefore, the Buddha’s teachings are to be understood as an introduction to the Buddha’s teachings on wisdom. All of the Buddhist teachings can actually be understood as means leading one to realize emptiness. So all of the other antidotes we might try to consume, whether it is medicine or whether we make forceful prayers will in no way be of help to lead us to liberation.

It is only through hearing, thinking, and meditating about emptiness that we can hope for liberation. And said, those with little merit cannot realize emptiness, but merely through doubting cyclic existence is torn to shreds. Merit here refers to a large accumulation of virtuous karma, and without a large accumulation of virtuous karma, indeed realization of emptiness is not possible. However, the doubt Nāgārjuna refers to in the second verse of this stanza is actually doubt erring towards the factual from within the three fold division of doubt into doubt erring towards the factual, equal doubt and doubt erring towards the non factual. And this doubt erring towards the factual is doubt erring towards the factual regarding emptiness.

The state of mind which wonders, well after all perhaps indeed all phenomena are not the way they appear to be. Perhaps indeed they are empty. This doubt alone is enough, it is said, to tear existence, and existence here refers to cyclic existence to shreds. So, even one who does not have merit, if he is able to generate such a doubt, is able to cause the foundations of cyclic existence to totter. And then we will pass on to Ngawang Rapsal’s commentary on page 39 of your English translation.

The middle of the page, such a mode of abiding is separate from the path of logical utterances, since it never occurs within the four logical possibilities established by a logical mind. So the logical utterances here, Rinpoche says, refer to those sophists who or dialecticians who analyzed phenomena in the light of four possibilities affirming, violating the law of the excluded middle that phenomena were neither existent nor non existent nor both existent and non existent, nor neither existent nor non existent. So those who held such sophistic positions could not in any way hope to gain any understanding of emptiness. And that these positions were widely held can be seen by the verse in taking the dharmakaya on the path within the lam-me sādhana of Yamāntaka, which refers specifically to being free from the four possibilities of eternalism, nihilism and so forth. Now, there is one way to understand this verse correctly, which is to understand the extreme of eternalism or the extreme of existence as the extreme of inherent existence, and the extreme of non existence as the extreme of complete non existence.

But it would seem that at the time when this verse was composed, the great Sakya master masters held a position which was much more in keeping with that of the dialecticians which considered that none of the four logical possibilities were established. And specifically, it would seem that the Sakya position prevalent before Je Tsongkhapa’s time was one which refuted mainly the extreme of existence, but does not seem to have refuted the extreme of non existence. The fortressy position which refuted one of the two extremes. And Je Tsongkhapa himself was for the first time, the one who clearly formulated a refutation of both extremes. The extreme of existence or the extreme of permanence, which is the extreme asserting the true existence of all phenomena, and the extreme of nihilism or the extreme of negation, affirming the complete non existence of all phenomena.

This is completely in keeping with Tsongkhapa. Since Tsongkhapa is one who rejects both of the extremes. And in a famous verse in Ratnāvali, Nāgārjuna says, from the standpoint of those having the view of self and other within the context of a mind of bodhicitta as firm as Mount Meru. Wisdom is the abandonment of both extremes. Both extremes which are explicitly mentioned in this verse of the Ratnāvali refer to the two extremes of existence and non existence.

And therefore, Nāgārjuna clearly teaches a path which is the middle way between the two extremes. So Rinpoche says, the great Yamāntaka yogi who transmitted the lineage to Tibet, Lotsawa, was probably a Sakya master and he seems to have composed this passage on taking the dharmakaya on the taking death on the path for the dharmakaya, which speaks of eliminating the four extremes. So there is considerable debate between the Sakya tradition and the Geluk tradition on this matter. Since the Sakya say, Lhatsawa himself said that one should eliminate all four extremes, and you, the Geluk, seem to speak of only eliminating two of these. And when we refer to ultimate bodhicitta in this text, it can be understood as the main mind in meditative equipoise on emptiness within the mental continuum of a Mahāyāna, ārya being.

This is a sufficient understanding or a sufficient explanation of ultimate bodhicitta. And ultimate bodhicitta in this context has also to be understood in terms of the two fold subdivision of Mahāyāna. ārya beings into bodhisattva ārya beings and Buddha ārya beings. So in every single case, we have to postulate one ultimate bodhicitta which corresponds to that within the mind stream of Bodhisattva Aryas and one which occurs within the mind stream of Buddha Ārya beings. Now in the context of the explanation in this text of how to meditate on emptiness, emptiness is compared to space.

This is an example which is given to enable one to understand emptiness. Space is traditionally defined as a mere absence of obstructive contact And as such is what is called a non affirming negative. In other words, it is a phenomenon which is a mere negation and in no way implies anything else than the mere absence of obstructive contact. Likewise, emptiness is compared to space because it is a non affirming negative, which merely negates its object of negation. Its object of negation is true existence, inherent existence, and so forth.

And, Rinpoche will jump some of the passages on page Tibetan three sixty six. So we’ll pass to the English translation page 40, the middle, which is meditated upon emptiness, is the object of meditation of ultimate bodhicitta has five features. Now generally speaking, Rinpoche says, the mode of presentation of the Guhyasamāja tantra and the Pāramitāyāna tantra, the Pāramitāyāna in this respect are different. The Guhyasamāja tantra teaches the wisdom realizing emptiness explicitly and teaches emptiness itself implicitly. For the Pāramitāyāna proceeds in exactly the opposite way.

Teaching emptiness explicitly and teaching the wisdom realizing emptiness implicitly. And in the context of the debates here on page 40 of your English text, the thrust of the debates is the misunderstanding the Cittamātra practitioners have of those sutras in which Buddha teaches a basis of all. A kunshi or ālāyavijñāna. The cittamatra’s mistake this as a mind basis of all, and this is clearly explained by Ngawang Rapsal as referring not to the mind basis of all, but referring to emptiness. As is said here, as all phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana arise from within a nature of emptiness, it is the foundation of phenomena.

So because emptiness is the foundation of phenomena, phenomena in turn exist. Where emptiness not to exist, then neither karma, nor causality, nor for that matter, past and future lives, nor liberation, nor enlightenment could exist. On the other hand, the existence of emptiness enables all of these phenomena to exist. For this reason, emptiness is the basis of all. And therefore, that we just meditate upon emptiness, which is the object of meditation of ultimate bodhicitta, has five features.

As all phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana arise from within the nature of emptiness, it is the foundation of phenomena. So as Rinpoche explained, if emptiness were not to exist, then the true establishment of phenomena would be averted. And if phenomena were truly established, then it would be impossible for karma and causality to exist, for past and future lives to exist, for liberation or for enlightenment to exist. So it is in non existence of the true establishment of phenomena or emptiness which enables karma and causality and so forth to exist. And the second feature, since they are not experienced as inherently existing from the very beginning, they are primordially peaceful.

So when it is said that phenomena are primordially peaceful, peaceful here refers to their absence of inherent existence. And therefore, the primordial peacefulness of phenomena means that from the very beginning, phenomena are not inherently existing, and are not truly established. It’s not the case, Rinpoche says, that at the very beginning phenomena somehow were truly or inherently established, and after that they ceased to be truly or inherently established. In exactly the same way as for instance fire, which is hot in its nature from its very inception, continues to be hot until the end. On the surf same way as molasses, which are sweet from their moment of appearance until their moment of extinction.

Likewise, phenomena from their very inception until their end lack inherent existence. And the following reason is that since they are not found under analysis by an analytical reasoning, they are akin to a mirage. So here, all phenomena actually are unfindable under ultimate analysis. And therefore, they are said to be akin to a mirage. A mirage or an illusion, also in which he says, of phenomena which appear to exist in a certain way, and yet do not exist in the way they appear in the case of an illusion.

For instance, the illusionist under the power of mantra in ancient India would cause on a basis of pebbles and twigs, horses and elephants to appear. Now if one analyzed carefully, one could clearly see that neither the shape of a pebble or a twig, nor its color for that matter corresponded to the shape or the color of a horse or an elephant. And this would be self evident for someone whose senses were not affected by the power of mantra, the power of spells. But for someone whose senses were affected by this, these would appear as horses and elephants. And the following feature by meditating on the non existence of a basis of true establishment, existence in its root, the apprehension of true existence, as well as its seeds and so forth are destroyed.

So here the basis of true establishment actually refers to an object which is truly established. Such objects which are truly established do not exist. And, finally, Rinpoche subdivides the fifth outline in your translation into two. And the last part becomes the fifth outline through meditating the very root of existence, which is the apprehension of true existence, as well as its seeds are completely destroyed. So existence here refers to cyclic existence.

And therefore, since under ultimate analytical investigation, no self can be found, the doubt which quite legitimately arises is is it the case that there is no self at all? And this is not the case. All the self, which is an object of negation itself does not exist and does not exist in the slightest. The self which is the actor of the karmic drama, the self which is impelled by past karma and experiences the fruition of karma exists and exists fully. So in this respect, His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said that Buddhists should help their scientific counterpart since scientists, when they engage in careful examination of the human body, for instance, find no trace of a self and quite easily succumb to the extreme of nihilism.

The Buddhist help to the scientific community would be to clarify the distinction between that self, which is an object of negation and which is refuted, And that self which exists merely nominally, which is a mere nominal and conceptual imputation, and which itself does exist. Such a self is actually the self which acts, the self which moves, the self which accumulates karma and experiences the fruition of karma, the self which transmigrates in the cycle of lives. And even though it exists only as a mere nominal and conceptual imputation, it nonetheless does exist. So for the Buddhists to help foster the understanding of the existence of such a self in the scientific community, Buddhists should deepen their own understanding of science. And therefore, it is said in one of the Madhyamaka texts, all phenomena are empty in as much as they lack inherent establishment.

It is precisely this emptiness, this lack of inherent establishment which enables phenomena to function, which actually enables activity. And for this reason it is said in the uncommon presentation of the extreme of permanence and of nihilism in the three principles of the path that full causality is incontrovertible. It is through appearance that the extreme of existence is dispelled, and it is through emptiness that the extreme of non existence is dispelled. Appearance here refers to karma and causality. So it is a sound understanding of karma and causality which actually dispels the extreme of existence.

And it is a sound understanding of emptiness which dispels the extreme of non existence. That existence which is refuted in this context is that existence which does not depend on causes and conditions. And the uncommon presentation in the three principles of the path by emptiness refutes the extreme of existence can only be understood fully when we understand that emptiness is not a non existent. And therefore, the English translation emptiness, Rinpoche says, is a very poor translation. Emptiness actually exists.

It is non it is the inherent existence of phenomena itself which does not exist. So that very existence of emptiness is what enables everything to occur, specifically all of the causal chain. And for this reason, and this reason alone, one can say that it is through the view realizing emptiness that the extreme of nihilism is eliminated and specifically that all of the interferences are eliminated. The foremost interference is to be understood as the apprehension of the true existence of phenomena. So to put things in a nutshell, Rinpoche says, emptiness exists.

The inherent establishment of phenomena does not exist. And this is the key thrust of the Prāsaṇgika school. It is a point which none of the lower schools from the Vaibhāṣika to the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka has ever understood. And, without understanding the ultimate presentation of emptiness, which is a presentation of emptiness in keeping with the Prāsaṇgika view, there is neither liberation nor full enlightenment. So, this is a presentation of emptiness we must understand.

This is a very difficult view of emptiness to understand. And therefore, Mañjuśrī instructed Je Tsongkhapa to prepare himself to understand it through increasing the accumulation of merit, through eliminating all of the mental contaminations and defilements. And if one relies upon a tutelary deity, to see one’s spiritual teacher as completely inseparable from the tutelary deity. And then in dependence on these three preliminary trainings to engage in the threefold activities of hearing, thinking, and meditating on emptiness, and again and again through forceful analysis to clarify the issue. And the reason for which we cannot gain realization of emptiness is because of the degree of the karmic defilements present within our mind stream.

We can become aware of this if we reflect at the number of non virtues which we have accumulated in this very life, and then if we think of the number of sins which we have accumulated in this life, and we look back on former lives which are infinite in number, and think that in every single one of them we have accumulated a similar amount of sins, then we can conceive how overwhelming the total karmic obstructions are. And these prevent us therefore from gaining direct realization of emptiness. Hence, we should first purify the karmic obstructions and the defilements within our mind. And then, in addition to this, we need to request the blessings of the spiritual teacher, specifically the teacher who teaches us about emptiness. The same way as a crop will not sprout without sunlight.

In the same same way, even if we have the requisite karmic imprints within our mind to realize emptiness, without the blessing of the teacher they will not mature. Therefore, this blessing is indispensable. All of us have the requisite seeds within our mind to attain full enlightenment. This is known as the Buddha lineage or sometimes as the Buddha nature. And this just has to be brought to maturation to lead us to the state of full enlightenment.

So the time has passed and Rinpoche will grant us five minutes for questions specifically on emptiness since it’s a difficult topic. So the misunderstanding of the Chittamatras is that in those passages in sūtra where Buddha speaks of an ālaya, of a basis of all, they understand this ālaya as being only present within sentient beings, and as being the foundation on which virtuous, non virtuous, and neutral karmic imprints are implanted. So the Cittamātra temptation arises because the Chitamatras want to postulate a firm foundation on which karmic imprints can be set out. And neither main minds nor mental factors can function in this way. And therefore, they postulate a mind basis of all, which is their instance of a person.

He’s hampered by the fact he doesn’t speak your language. You’d have to figure this one out. As Buddha himself said, the delight caused by the blossoming of flowers, various flowers in a field, as well as dwellings scattered left and right, all of these are mere conceptual imputations. In other words, whether the delight caused by the flowers is the delight caused by red, yellow or blue flowers, whether the house is seen in the fields are to the left or to the right, every single one of them exists merely as a conceptual imputation from the side of the mind perceiving them. There is nothing from the side of the phenomenon which establishes the phenomenon.

And this Rinpoche says is a direct quotation, a direct teaching of the Buddha. Likewise regarding the mind, when one speaks of the activity of the mind, one is actually referring to the mental continuum. The mental continuum here refers to the subsequent instance of mind. And if we take the very first instance of mind, that very first instance of mind is an instance of destruction at the very instant it arises. And the second instance of mind which follows it, as well as the relation between these two instance of mind is what constitutes the mental continuum.

This mental continuum as well is a mere conceptual imputation. And if we take the instance of the subsequent instance of a mental continuum, at the end of the first instant of the mental continuum, the second instant of the mental continuum arises Without a mind which designates the second instant of the mental continuum as a second instant of the mental continuum, there is no such thing as a second instant of the mental continuum. It is through the kindness of conceptual imputation that your mind exists. There’s a big difference between the self, which is the object of refutation, and the self which travels from lives to lives. So the self which is an object of refutation, which is an inherently existing self, does not exist in the slightest.

It is completely non existing. However, the self which travels from life to life, which is a mere nominal imputation, that definitely exists. Tsongkhapa said that if the which is an object of refutation occurred with an object of knowledge, then it could in no way be refuted. Therefore, it is necessarily a non object of knowledge. And the self which travels from life to life, the self which experiences, all the things Rinpoche was talking about, being hot, being cold, having a hand, having a foot, having friends, or not having friends.

My friend, my house. Does that answer your question? So if we examine Joe and we try to find the essence of Jonas, then, he says, where is Joe? Joe is not in Joe’s head. Joe is not in Joe’s hands.

Joe is not in Joe’s feet. So when Joe experiences something, what is it which experiences something? When Joe says he is cold, who is experiencing the cold? So, the root of your being here is something called karma, and it is in dependence on seeds planted in a past life, akin to seeds planted in a field that when they matured, you came to be with us here today. Robert just says, you’ve blossomed like a sprout.

Okay. Roberto, thank you very much. He thinks you have asked very good questions and he hope you understood his answers. So regarding the question you asked last time about the difference between the dharmakaya and emptiness, and which he would like to point out that the dharmakaya exists only within the mental continuum of a Buddha, and emptiness exists in all phenomena.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top