TBI Recordings

1 h 59 min · 3,962 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour teaching on the Bodhicitta Vivarana, Kyabje Rinpoche makes motivation the foundation of all practice. He distinguishes three levels: bodhicitta (placing all sentient beings above yourself), liberation from saṃsāra, and good future rebirth. Using vivid examples—a mare grieving her dead colt, birds laboring to feed their young—he argues that animals possess genuine consciousness and deserve compassion. He maps a daily structure: generate a pure intention upon waking; work with loving-kindness; examine your conduct in the evening and purify missteps through confession and meditation on emptiness. The same practice yields radically different results depending on motivation alone, illustrated through four people reciting guru yoga with four entirely different intentions. For newcomers to Mahāyāna Buddhism and serious practitioners.

File metadata (for organising)

File: BV 19 May.mp3

UUID: fb810e7f-e059-4c0b-8eaf-7233655f305a

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,958

To both listen and to explain Dharma teachings, the motivation is capital. And generally speaking, there are three categories of motivation, the supreme, the middling, and the lower motivation. The supreme motivation is the motivation of bodhicitta. This motivation of bodhicitta is a motivation to place all sentient beings as vast as as space in a state of unalloyed enlightenment through thinking that all we ourselves are but one. Sentient beings are infinite in number, and therefore, they are infinitely more important than we are.

And in addition, there is not a single sentient being of whom we can say that he or she has not been a father or a mother in past lives. And parents who naturally spontaneously extend infinite kindness to their offspring are in turn entitled to are in turn entitled to receive this kindness back, not to return the kindness of one’s parents, of mother sentient beings from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna is base, vile, and debased. Therefore, we must engage in practice for the benefit of others. Generally speaking, there are two types of benefit, worldly benefit or benefit from the standpoint of one’s worldly situation and benefit for Dharma. Worldly benefit is at best transient and unsatisfactory, but benefit from the standpoint of dharma is durable.

Therefore, this is what we should strive for. What are the three benefits of dharma? The first benefit is a contingent or short term benefit. The second benefit is the benefit of eliminating suffering, and the third benefit is a benefit of placing beings in an infinite state of happiness. And therefore, we should meditate on eliminating all of our faults and perfecting all of our qualities, thinking that even though at present, I wish to free all sentient beings from suffering and the causes of suffering and to place them in a state in which they have happiness and the causes of happiness.

I am unable to do so. Therefore, from my own side, I must strive for the sake of mother sentient beings for the state of full enlightenment, which is a great enlightenment, which combines the attainment of all qualities and the elimination of all objects of abandonment. And with this as a motivation, we should meditate. And we should therefore take the resolution to train in both the conventional and the ultimate bodhicitta, which are expounded in this great treatise, the Bodhicitta Vivarana, the conventional bodhicitta, which enables us to attain an infinite amount of merit as well as the ultimate bodhicitta. And therefore, will meditate for one or two minutes on generating this motivation, and then Rinpoche will start his teaching.

Then we will move onwards a bit to page 52 of your English commentary and stanza 76 of the root text on page 24. The root text reads results desired and undesired in good or evil states within this world. All these derive from actions, good or ill, that have been done to other beings. So here, the two categories of conditions are the happy and the unfortunate states within this world of ours. These are happy rebirths and unfortunate or miserable rebirths.

These are the result which is either desired in the case of happy rebirths or feared in the case of evil rebirths. And these results in turn derived from what is explained in the third verse of stanza 76. They derive from actions good or ill. Good actions here refer to deeds which are performed through love and empathy, and these give rise to happiness in future lives. And ill deeds refer to deeds which are performed with the intention of harming others or deeds of violence and wrath, and these give rise to suffering in future lives.

And then moving onwards to verse 77 on page 52. The peerless state of Buddhahood is gained by taking the support of beings. Here, actually, the state of omniscience of infinite Buddhahood arises only in dependence on others. By taking the support of beings, what wonder is it then that there’s no heavenly, no human joy, no state of Brahma, Indra, or Shiva, or any guardian deity of the world enjoyed in all the three realms of existence that was not engendered through desire for being’s goods. Here, Brahma, Indra, Shiva referred to referred to happy rebirths.

All of these happy rebirths can only arise as a result of performing kind deeds towards sentient beings and specifically as a result of the morality of protecting others and helping others. And it’s in dependence on these that even worldly happy results arise. And then moving onwards, all the different kinds of pain that beings suffer, the hells, as animals or hungry ghosts, all these result from harming beings. So as far as what is unwished for, what is of the nature of suffering, Lobsang says, this arises exclusively and only through harming others. And therefore, sentient beings, beings in general, are a field for the attainment of full enlightenment.

All of the qualities of the hearers, of the solitary realizers, of the bodhisattvas, all the qualities of the fully enlightened Buddhas arise in dependence on sentient beings. So sentient beings can really be compared to the field in which a skillful farmer, for instance, would plant seed, which in turn would give rise to sprouts. In the same way as at the worldly level, happiness is contingent on the productivity of fields and the yield when attains from crops. Good crops give rise to happiness and difficult crops or poor crops give rise to suffering. Likewise, it is from the field of sentient beings that all of the qualities such as faith, conviction, and so forth arise.

And therefore, we must endeavor to use sentient beings as a field of accumulation of merit and through relying on sentient beings, through helping sentient beings to perform both our own welfare and that of others. If we engage in practice without reflecting on the welfare of sentient beings, irrespective of what we practice, whether it the practice itself is called Mahāyāna Dharma or not, it becomes a Hīnayāna practice, a lower vehicle practice. Any practice engaged in with egotism through self-cherishing becomes thereby a lower vehicle practice. It is only practice engaged in through cherishing others for the welfare of others, which becomes practice of the great vehicles. So when we harm other beings, we harm ourselves.

When we help other beings, we help ourselves. In the self same way as a mother loves her only child, in the very self same way we should love sentient beings. And the Buddha’s affection for sentient beings is millions of times greater than that of a mother for her only child. So if we harm others, then it is very difficult to see how the Buddhas could feel close to us.

And at present, we will briefly cover the essential meaning of the presentation of outer interdependence. The text gives a very detailed commentary, which is a bit complicated, and Rinpoche will summarize this. So a distinction is here clearly clearly made between outer and inner interdependence. And to understand this, we must understand the difference between outer and inner phenomena. Outer phenomena are phenomena which are without feeling, which are not held by feeling.

In other words, which are mindless. These are, for instance, stones, vegetables, or various inanimate objects. They do not have pleasurable or unpleasant feelings. Interior phenomena, on the other hand, are those phenomena which are subsumed by feeling, which are subsumed by consciousness, and these include sentient beings such as fish, dogs, horses, and so forth. Generally speaking, feelings are subdivided into three categories, pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant feelings.

Pleasant feelings such as the pleasant feeling which arises when we are eating a good meal are the product of virtue, whereas unpleasant feelings such as the suffering of hunger are the direct result of non virtue. All feeling is necessarily a consciousness. So wherever feeling is present, consciousness is necessarily present. And all sentient beings of the six realms, both the happy and the unfortunate realms, have feelings. They experience the feelings of heat and cold, for instance, in the upper realms.

And in the lower realms as well, they experience great feelings of suffering. We should become very clear on the fact that even animals have not only feelings, but consciousness. For instance, we can see very clearly that in the behavior of a dog, a dog is trying to be happy. He searches for happiness, and he will search for those who help him, and he will bite, for instance, those who harm him. He is in this respect a mother sentient being for us.

He is a being who is searching for happiness just as us. He not only searches for happiness, but he protects his offspring. Rinpoche gave also the example of a mare which will protect her colts and which will suffer from great grief if one of the colts dies. Insects for that matter, Rinpoche says, also cherish their children, their offspring, and they do understand that the eggs they lay will eventually give rise to their offspring. Birds go to great effort to feed their chicks, actually, partially ingesting insects and then regurgitating them in their chicks mouth.

Every single animal for that matter puts tremendous effort in protecting its offspring and will defend its offspring often at the cost of its own life even if it is unable to protect them. So animals, for instance, manifest very clearly through biting and so forth, the presence of feelings and of mind within them. And we ourselves, if we reflect on our behavior as human beings, beings who inflict violence, who inflict death, who inflict suffering on others, we ourselves must modify our behavior because it is very clear that this is a result of non virtue. And therefore, at present, we are blessed with all of the conditions to practice Dharma correctly, and we should generate a good motivation for this. We have actually an excellent body on which we can practice.

And having received both Sūtra and Tantric teachings, we can hope to attain full enlightenment within this very life. We have, moreover, in this country of Australia, all of the conditions to practice. There are no interferences at all in the process of teaching of Dharma, unlike the situation in Tibet where it is very difficult to receive Dharma teachings. Then, in addition to this, we have established, a powerful connection with the Mahāyāna tradition, the great vehicle tradition.

Most definitely, we must have accumulated a lot of virtuous karma in past lives for this connection to be created. On the basis of this, we can attain the state of full enlightenment in this very life. And therefore, it is our responsibility to strive not just for ourselves, but for all beings and to give a hand, for instance, to the animals and to the animal realm. We ourselves have wisdom. We have a good body.

We can practice truly. In this life, we can attain the ultimate goal, but the ultimate goal we should attain for the sake of others. None of us wants suffering, and all of us want to be happiness want happiness. However, the happiness which we want is not the happiness of this life. This life itself is very short, and it’s very transient.

The practice, Dharma practice, which is practice for this life, for the sake of this life, is not Dharma. It is just worldly Dharma. It is meaningless. Dharma begins with the next life. And this is the basis on which we must must practice since the happiness we want is a long term happiness over many lives, not the ephemeral happiness of just this life.

This is these are the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni, our teacher. If we practice in this way, later, we will be happy. Otherwise, we will be empty handed. And as you will know, if you go on a vacation empty handed, then you are in difficulty. So at the end of this life, we have to leave everything behind.

However many great teachers we have had, we will have to leave them behind. We will have to leave our parents behind. We will have to leave our friends and even our very body behind. Only the mind goes on to the next life. And it goes on accompanied by whatever virtuous or non virtuous karma it has created.

If the virtuous side of the mind is greater, then it moves towards happiness. And if the non virtuous side is greater, it moves towards suffering. And therefore, one of Atisha’s students asked Atisha, what Atisha teacher is the boundary between Dharma and worldly deeds? And Atisha answered, the boundary between Dharma and worldly deeds is happiness. What Atisha meant is that worldly deeds are exclusively focused on the welfare of this life and do not begin to create happiness for future lives, whereas dharma begins from future lives onwards and is focused on the happiness of future lives.

So worldly activities can establish happiness in this life, but they are of no use whatsoever to create happiness in future lives. Dharma, on the other hand, begins to create happiness in future lives. And for this reason, one engages in practices such as a practice of ethics and so forth. So our goal must be to try to attain happiness in future lives. And for this, we engage in the practices of the being of small scope, which focuses mainly on happiness in future lives, and for instance, rely or meditate on the reliance of the spiritual teacher, on karma and causality, on death and impermanence, and so forth.

Striving then to attain a good rebirth, a human rebirth in future lives, we engage in the threefold practices of ethics, of forbearance, and of training in generosity, engaging thereby in the practice of the being of small scope. There is, however, a higher level of practice, which is the practice of the being of middling scope who understands that all of the cycle of lives is permeated with suffering, that there is no happiness in the slightest within the cycle of lives and who strives for freedom and liberation from cyclic existence. One who with the motivation of attaining liberation from cyclic existence meditates on the four noble truths on the 12 links of dependent origination and so forth is practicing at the practicing at the level of the being of middling scope. As for the being of great scope, this is a being who instead of practicing for himself alone, understanding that such practice is base and vile, strives instead to practice for all other beings and to attain the great enlightenment, full enlightenment for the benefit of others. All practice we engage in with this motivation, by that motivation alone becomes a great vehicle practice.

So for instance, if we meditate on karma and causality with that motivation, then even though the object of meditation karma and causality is the same as that of the practitioner of middling scope, it becomes great vehicle Dharma through the motivation. The teachers of the Lam Rim tradition used to give a famous example. They would give the example of four persons attending a long life puja, a guru yoga recitation. And the first of these recites the Lama Chöpa, the guru yoga, with the motivation of leading all sentient beings to full enlightenment. The second recites this with the motivation of being free from the suffering of cyclic existence.

The third recites the guru yoga with a wish to be free from lower rebirth. And the fourth recites a Guru Yoga thinking of the food which will be given to him and the money being handed out. These four beings in turn accrue four different results. The first being reciting Guru Yoga for the sake of all sentient beings is practicing the Mahāyāna. The second being who is reciting it to be free from cyclic existence is practicing the Hīnayāna, to be free from the cycle of lives.

The third has also good motivation. He is trying to be free from the suffering of the lower realms. As to the fourth, his recitation of the Guru Yoga is actually a cause for being reborn in the lower realms.

And therefore, motivation is fundamental in the initiation of any venture. And for us, when we rise in the mornings, we should reflect carefully and think the happy realms, happy rebirths are the result of virtue, and and unhappy rebirths are the result of nonvirtue. It is up to me to make this human life of mine meaningful or to waste it. And then we can generate one of three motivations upon rising in the morning. The highest is a motivation wishing to place all sentient beings in a state free of suffering and of the causes of suffering, in a state endowed with happiness and the causes of happiness.

If we’re not able to generate such a motivation, we generate the second best motivation, a motivation wishing to be ourselves free of the endless sufferings of the cycle of lives. And if we’re not able to create this motivation, we generate the third and lowest motivation, a motivation to be at least to have at least happiness in future lives. Then we rise. And at this point, we engage in whatever devotions one should engage in, we choose to engage in in the morning, offering prostrations, making offerings, making prayers with this motivation. And then after this thinking to practice Dharma, I must have the material facilities, we go off to work.

And we try to do our work in goodness with a mind which is loving and kind. And upon returning home from work, we should examine all day, and we should examine whether we have behaved in keeping with our motivation generated in the morning or not. If we have been behaved in keeping with our motivation, then our work has been meaningful, and we should rejoice and generate happiness within our mind stream. If on the other hand, our motivation has slipped and we have misbehaved, then we should purify whatever we have done through reciting Vajrasattva mantras, confession, the confession sūtra, through generating bodhicitta and meditating on emptiness. Finally, we should dedicate all of the merits accumulated during the day to attaining the state of full enlightenment for the benefit of others.

In this way, a human life is made meaningful. So if we practice in this way today, and then we practice tomorrow, and every single day after tomorrow, eventually, we will have practiced our whole life in this way. Do you understand? And therefore, reflecting that we need a means to be freed from the lower rebirths and from cyclic existence in general, and that the means is the triple gem, the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha. We should entrust ourselves to the triple gem and follow the advice, the instructions of the triple gem, which are first and foremost to abandon, to give up the 10 non virtuous deeds and to practice the 10 virtuous deeds.

And then in dependence on our spiritual teacher and whichever Yidam we practice, we should generate virtuous states of mind, understanding that from white minds in turn arise white karma. White minds here refer to the minds of love and of bodhicitta. And from dark evil minds arise non virtuous karma, and then engage in whatever practice of whichever scope of being we can practice, practices of the smaller middling or greater scope, trying to meditate as best we can on bodhicitta and on the view of emptiness so as to implant karmic imprints. For us, it would be difficult to hope for any realizations in this matter because we have not practiced well in past lives. We do not have those karmic imprints.

But in the present life, we can implant karmic imprints to obtain those realizations in the future in the same way as a farmer plants seeds in a field hoping for a large crop. So it is through such daily and incremental practice that we can hope eventually to improve. Okay. And this life is short, Rinpoche says, so take good care of yourselves, protect your health, try to put your minds in peace, and try to live in harmony with each other. There will be no harmony in your lives if you cannot practice forbearance and empathy, compassion for each other.

Practicing in this way, we will reach quietly our goal. And then when we speak of interdependence, what is meant by interdependence is the causal chain. You understand this in your practice. When you ring a bell, the sound arises from this. There are causes which give rise to the color of hair or to baldness.

These are all direct results of past causes. And through meditating on dependent origination, one will eventually gain understanding of emptiness. Without realization of emptiness, there is no freedom from the cycle of lives. This is the shared teaching of the Buddha of Nāgārjuna and Tsongkhapa. So this is a very core element.

And without freedom from the cycle of lives, there can be no freedom from suffering. So this is something that you understand at present. Rinpoche has given a lot of explanations on this. Generally speaking, there are two forms of love. There is self love, and there is love for others.

First, you have to love yourself before you can hope to love others. Otherwise, if you have no self love, which is says your love for others is not gonna be very stable. So we have a present finished the teachings on the Bodhicitta Vivarana, which His Holiness the Dalai Lama asked to give. And he, from his side, feels he has derived great benefits from giving these teachings. He hopes they have been of benefit to you, and he would like to ask you to meditate on their meaning.

It has now been three years since Rinpoche was last in India, and he will be going to India with your translator to give or to complete a vast cycle of teachings on Lam Rim, which is extremely rare. And Rinpoche would like to ask you in the meantime to be happy here in Adelaide and to practice well. And in addition, for young Australians, who are Dharma students, will be going to Sera Je to study. One has already been ordained and has gone, and Rinpoche hopes that everything will turn out for the best for him and that he will be of great benefit to Australia. Three are yet to go, and this is how what makes a human life truly meaningful.

The Tibetan term for being ordained is rab jung. In English, we would translate it as going forth. Rab in Tibetan means supreme. Is going forth. So this is the supreme way of making a human life meaningful through striving for authentic liberation from the suffering of cyclic existence, abandoning the 10 non virtues, and practicing the 10 virtues.

One should all we should all pray that they do well in their studies and in their ordination. And when one becomes ordained, one is striving to benefit both the teachings and beings. And Rinpoche hopes that these young Australians who are being ordained will be of benefit to Australia in the future.

Thank you. Thank you. It was a tradition of yore in Tibet for the teachers to recite the beginning of the text having finished it to create a dependent origination of its being taught again. Okay. Take care.

Take care very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
six realms
The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
yidam ishtadevata (Skt)
Literally, "mind-bound." One's own personal, main - or, as Lama Yeshe used to say, favorite - deity for tantric practice. The deity with which a practitioner has the strongest connection. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top