1 h 33 min · 4,166 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches how to prepare for death by generating a conviction in past and future lives based on reasoning, and by training the mind in virtue daily so that death occurs in a virtuous state of mind. It covers morning and evening mental practices, reflecting on the inevitability of death, and abandoning the ten non-virtues. The session ends with a question and answer period on resulting refuge, the intermediate state, and terminal lucidity.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 34m
UUID: 16710751-57b9-4a91-9ed8-7115b882abdd
Words: 4,162
In all of the experiences, the difficulties which we share, setting aside animals as human beings are indeed difficult to experience. And people have different types of difficulties. Some have difficulties in their practice. Some have others difficulties, but this is a shared experience. Take care.
Don’t worry. You know? No And, specifically, death is something which we all experience. If we abandon the afflictions, then we abandon death, specifically death which arises from the afflictions. Then all of the hardship we undergo in this world, we undergo to try to obtain some type of happiness.
But the foremost hardship is obviously death and the fear of death. Then our main focus must try to be to eliminate death and the fear of death. Now, our goal, therefore, has to be to, eliminate or to reduce suffering at the time of death and specifically, mental suffering. And in this respect, a belief, but not just a mere belief — a conviction rooted in reasoning — in the existence of past and future lives, specifically future lives, since death ushers future lives is of great benefit. To generate such a conviction, dharma is extraordinarily helpful.
Then, without a focus on the after death, dharma is probably pretty much useless. Now here, there is a tremendous difference between believing in future lives based on some type of nebulous faith and a conviction in the existence of future lives, which is based on reasoning. Once one has such a conviction based on reasoning and experience, then the purpose, the goal of dharma becomes clear since dharma is of benefit from the next life onwards. Then, obviously, if one does not believe in future lives, just why precisely is on practicing dharma? Now is the time to prepare.
Now is the time to become accustomed to these notions. To fancy that one will be able to do this preparation at the time of death is to be delusional. That will be very difficult. It takes a long time of habit and preparation. Of course, Then please listen carefully.
There’s probably nothing in this presentation which any one of you will be unable to understand, and I will explain naturally as best I can. Clearly, the hardship we experience in this life can only be dispelled by ourselves and ourselves alone. Now as we have explained many times, what proceeds to future lives is the subtle mind. In other words, the subtle mental continuum. The coarse aggregates which we have at present, they are left behind.
There is a profound difference between a vague and nebulous faith in past and future lives and a conviction which is rooted in reasoning. Once we have generated a conviction rooted in reasoning, even if we encounter someone and this happens frequently, who says there’s no such thing as past and future lives. You’re just matter. When it’s over, it’s over. If all we have is a conviction based in faith, our conviction will waver.
If it is based in reasoning, it will not waver. This is a great difference. There is a profound difference between an ordinary nebulous conviction and a conviction based in reasoning in the existence of past and future lives. And as said, generate a conviction in the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni rooted in reason and logic. Such a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, which relies on reasoning, is similar to take an example with, the state of falling asleep.
We experience no particular fear when we fall asleep because we are profoundly convinced that we will wake up the next day in the morning. So there is really no difference between deep sleep and death. In deep sleep, we are totally oblivious to environment just as in the death state. And after deep sleep, we wake up the next day. We actually know for a fact that before falling asleep, we make plans for the next day in all certainty that the next day we will proceed with our lives.
So death can indeed be compared with sleep for that matter. The, death meditations, are linked with the meditations engaged in certain levels of the sleep state, but this is very advanced for us at present. So this is evident when we reflect on the fact that after falling asleep, the next day, we wake up. And whatever plans or projects we made the previous day, actually, we engage in the following day. Now these plans, these projects, these memories, if you prefer these karmic imprints or seeds, where do they dwell?
They dwell within the subtle mind. There is therefore a tremendous difference at the time of death in having a conviction in the existence of past and future lives which relies on reasoning. And it is therefore something which we must try to generate. And in this context, obviously, at the time of death, if faith is present, this is very helpful since faith is a virtuous state of mind, a virtuous mental factor. So when we reflect on death, the following issues come to mind.
First, there is not a single person who will not die. And for that matter, from the very instant of birth onwards, we are dying. The death process has been initiated. And when we think about it in these terms, then we can generate faith in Buddha Śākyamūni who taught this precisely and taught that we would die. Then there is no benefit whatsoever in believing naively that somehow we are exempt from the rule and will not die.
Very easy. You know?
Thinking in this way is very helpful. In doing like this, then we can gradually eliminate the hardship we would experience at the time of death. And here, the, third root of the meditation on death that at the time of death, only dharma is of benefit is extraordinarily beneficial. However, there is no point in saying this to a dying person. They will not be able to change their attitude independence on this.
It is now at present where we have the opportunity that we have to change our outlook. Do you understand? Generating such a motivation in the morning when one wakes up is extraordinarily beneficial. One should think, will endeavor to keep my body and mind, hale so that I can study and practice. Then with this mindset, we will benefit ourselves.
This is easy. The only difficult aspect about it is that we keep procrastinating and deferring and figuring that we’ll do tomorrow what we could do today, next week, next month, next year. And as Gungthang Rinpoche says in his marvelous poem, then it’s all over. As the lines of the poem read, during the first twenty years, one says, I will be doing. I will be doing.
Then during the next twenty years, one says, I have started. I have started. And then from age 60 onwards, it’s finished. Right? And one says, it’s over.
Yeah. This poem exists in English, A poem on old age.. We have it somewhere at the bookstore. So when one gets up in the morning, then, I want you to have a bit of courage and get up at once and not stagger back to bed. And then, one should and all of us have that.
Take ten or fifteen minutes and reflect on how one wishes to make this human life into something meaningful. And for instance, reflect on bodhicitta and so forth. All of us have received countless teachings on these topics. Now, here, all of us are human beings. Therefore, we have both the capacity to do this, and we are able to think.
It is up to us to take the resolve to do so. And therefore, in the morning, after waking up, since the mind is inordinately clear, we should use those ten, fifteen minutes to reflect, for instance, on the benefits of bodhicitta. And at the end of that period, we should generate the motivation, ideally, to benefit others during the rest of this day. But if that is not possible, then at the very least, we should generate the motivation not to harm others. Now in this respect, there is a very big difference between generating this motivation freely from deep within oneself and generating it because someone on the outside hectores us to do so and says, you must generate this motivation.
For instance, when, strong anger arises within our minds, there’s a very great difference if we, from our own side, understanding the faults of anger, restrain it forcefully. Then, it is said, the afflictions, just as horses, are subdued through forceful means. Here, one must subdue the afflictions with forcefulness. Or as it says in the Eight Verses of Mind Training, view self grasping as the foremost enemy and subdue the afflictions forcefully. And therefore, ideally, we, wake up in the morning, we should generate, a motivation to benefit others or to cherish others and at the very least not to harm them.
And if we don’t have time, generating such a clear motivation is of great benefit in eliminating hardship. And then every day has an end. And therefore, in the evening before going to sleep, we should analyze our behavior during the day. And if overall, we have behaved in a virtuous way, then we should rejoice. And if we have engaged in nonvirtuous deeds, then we should generate a strong sense of repentance and restraint and resolve not to engage in these deeds again.
And this, I suspect, amounts to a form of confession. Now this calls for no particular hardship. It is a mental operation unlike physical or verbal, activities which may involve some hardship. And this is what is called a good and meaningful human life. Then, it is entirely up to you whether you choose to behave in this way or not.
Broadly speaking, as westerners from the age of 20 onwards, you have been completely independent and you have done what you wanted. Then, obviously, with Tibetans, says one has much more control. And if they’re naughty, one just gives them a good beating. Right? So, obviously, you know, with the spread of the ideas of independence in the world, a lot of things have become very difficult for you and maybe are no longer possible.
In the monasteries, the elder monks have a lot of input in the training of the young monks, and then it is possible to lead them very far. For yourselves, it will be difficult. And, here, it is therefore at present that we must prepare for the time of our own death so that our death be easy. And as is said in the third reason of the meditation on death and impermanence, at the time of death, only dharma is of benefit because, obviously, at the time of death, you cannot take any of your material possessions with you. Then, clearly, when you say that at the time of death only dharma is of benefit, that means that you have to prepare before and become habituated to dharma for a long time.
To practice dharma for the first time at the time of death doesn’t work well. Then, obviously, one, tries not to die from a devastating and harsh disease, and therefore, one has to be mindful of one’s health during this life so that one can die slowly and peacefully and that whatever virtuous maturing karma one has accumulated in previous lives can be led to fruition. And here when one says that at the time of death, dharma alone is of benefit. The manner in which dharma is of benefit at that time is through reducing powerful attachment to objects and vanities of this life. Now this does not happen instantaneously.
It is over the duration of one’s life as one reduces the attachment to exterior things and reflects that they really have no substance and no essence, then at the time of death, death will be easy. Do you understand? So when one says turn away from the vanities of this life, this doesn’t mean throw everything out of the window, but it actually refers to reducing one’s attachment to things. And in the West, we attach to some, whereas for instance, Tibetans might be attached to others. Then through reducing this gradually at the time of death, there will be no fear.
Do you understand?
So it is at present that we should begin to prepare in this way. And, there is fundamentally no difference between turning away from the vanities of this life and turning towards future lives. Both are dharma. Dharma begins with the next life. This is a distinction between the world and dharma.
Dharma begins with the next life. The world is this life. Mhmm. This is how Atisha just differentiated them. And here, this topic of past and future lives is extremely important because it ushers a notion of our mental continuum, which is like a path traveling from past to future lives.
So here, one must therefore generate a conviction based on reasoning in causality, and one must, on this basis, generate a conviction based in re in reasoning in the three supremes or the triple gem. For instance, one takes refuge in the Sanga gem, through generating through reasoning the conviction that the Sanga gem has protected themselves from the afflictions and therefore can protect us from the afflictions as well. Therefore, our goal must be to die in a virtuous state of mind as opposed to dying in a non virtuous state of mind exemplified by anger, and the difference is self evident. Someone who is in a virtuous state of mind is at peace. Someone who is in a non virtuous state of mind such as anger has an inflamed and angry face and does not control himself.
And here, we should rely on the advice imparted by our teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, and restrain from engaging in the 10 non virtuous deeds. If we can practice his ethics of protection of the 10 non virtuous deeds, we will then be able to die in a virtuous frame of mind. So at the level of the past shared with the being of the small scope and refers to the abandonment of causality, this is the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. Then ideally, one would, generate virtuous states of mind 100% of the time. But, since that is difficult, if one can do so most of the time, 60 or 70% of the time, then at the time of one’s death, one will die in a virtuous frame of mind.
And, obviously, there are a numerous variety of modes of death. People die for various reasons due to accidents and the upheaval of the elements and so forth, but this virtuous state of mind can be maintained. And in Australia, people die of a variety of reasons. Car accidents are one. Some unfortunately get devoured get devoured by sharks in the ocean, then it’s difficult to generate a virtuous state of mind at that moment.
And here, one must meditate over and again to generate this conviction grounded in reasoning in the existence of past and future lives. Not only does this or can this do no harm at all, it can only benefit. And therefore, since these are Mahāyāna teachings that is at present, generate the appropriate motivation and meditate during a couple minutes on past and future lives. Over to prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four.
Also page five, number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. Page five. Morning.
Drawing So what was covered today is the totality of the path shared with the being of the small scope in a simple and easy to way easy to understand way. And if one wishes to practice it, one can. The object of attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope is a higher rebirth in future lives, and the cause for such a higher rebirth is generating a virtuous state of mind at the time of one’s death. To be able to generate such a state of mind at the time of one’s death, one must train in generating these minds throughout one’s life. This is what the path is.
And one of the interferences to generating a virtuous state of mind at the time of time of death is acute disease, then this is to be avoided. We have the favorable conditions at present to ensure this does not hap happen. We have everything we need in our hands. Now the next step is to abandon death, and death is not a thing which can be discarded. To abandon it, one must abandon its cause, which is the ignorance grasping at a self.
Now there are numerous ways of countering this ignorance according to the various schools of tenets. But once one has abandoned it, one has attained the state of an arhat. Some schools of tenets teach that the mental continuum of the arhat is severed upon its death, others do not. What we can all practice at present is the path shared with the being of the small scope. This is accessible to us.
It is not difficult. Then to practice the path shared with the being of the middling scope, we must abandon ignorance. And for this, we must understand emptiness. And this calls for a numerous study a deep study of the numerous stages. Then, the time for the teaching is over.
At present, Geshe la would like to take your questions. We were had a a discussion group before the teachings tonight, And a question that arose was relating to last week’s teachings about resulting refuge. And Geshe la said that it occurs at the point when one’s continuum becomes the object of refuge, in this case, Buddha Śākyamūni. And we don’t really understand at what point does that actually happen. So regarding causal refuge, which is the one which concerns us at present, causal refuge means that we take refuge in something which is of a different substantial continuum than ourselves.
In this case, the advice of Buddha Śākyamūni as well as Buddha Śākyamūni himself who engaged in this advice. Now in the case of effect refuge or the resulting refuge, this occurs when, after engaging in hearing and thinking on, for instance, the four noble truths, and generating a valid cognizer in dependence on thinking, one then tries to generate the wisdom arisen from meditation focused on the four noble truths. And through repeated familiarization with this, eventually, one reaches the state of the first ground, the path of seeing. At this point, one’s own qualities become one’s own refuge since they protect us from the lower rebirth. Do you understand?
So the resulting refuge means that we ourselves develop ourselves. If a being cultivates virtue in their life and dies with a virtuous mind, then that virtuous mind would condition their rebirth in the Bardo state. Is that right? We get reborn as a Bardo being between lives? So there is no reference to virtuous minds as far as the intermediate state or the is concerned.
If the mind of death and there are here discussions about numerous levels of the minds of death, but if the mind of death in general can be turned into a virtuous mind, then we will, in the next life, get the physical base of a higher rebirth. And in the intermediate state, we will get an intermediate state body, which, for instance, corresponds to that state of a human body, let’s say. Intermediate state. Can experiences in the intermediates in the Bardo influence a future rebirth? No.
Probably not. Once one has attained the intermediate state of a human being, then a majority of such are reborn as human beings and would not be reborn, let’s say, as animals. Okay. And last questions? Geshe-la, earlier on you said deep sleep and death were very similar in the sense that the plans we make before we go to sleep, we access when we wake up.
The memories that children who recall previous lives have, have they been accessed in a similar fashion? Yes. It’s very similar. Just as the child who remembers past life experiences in this life remembers them because he implanted very powerful karmic imprints in a previous life. Likewise, when we wake up, we remember whatever projects we made before falling asleep.
However, I gave this example to illustrate the importance of generating a conviction based on reasoning in the existence of past and future lives, which enables us to die at ease in confidence that we will be reborn in a future life just as when we fall asleep, we fall asleep with the certainty of awakening the next day. But let us set aside the issues of memories of past lives because these hinge on one’s own experience. And instead, let us try to generate a conviction based on reasoning in the existence of past and future lives. Geshe-la said that whatever maturing karma arises from past lives can be led to fruition. What does Geshe-la mean by leading it to fruition, and what is the best way to do that?
So when one speaks of the maturation of virtuous karmic imprints, that maturation is simply happiness. The result is happiness. So here what happens is that the virtuous karmic imprints which are infused in one’s mind are led to maturation by virtuous states of mind at the time of death, and one actually has a substantial cause present at this point for a future happy rebirth. Yeah. First, I think, Susie then said after you.
Given the is there any case of practitioner that got dementia? And, you know, at the time of death, will they remember or is, you know, so that they can practice the virtuous state of mind so that they can go beyond, you know, in in, into the death? Difficult. If one is not accustomed, it’s difficult. Without stable experience, it’s difficult.
One needs also a stable faith in the triple gem, in karma and causality and so forth. So, I gave Chris some articles, on terminal lucidity, which cover just what you’re talking about. And I was mentioning these to Geshe. I tell you first what I mentioned to Geshe and then his answer. These studies were made, by psychiatrists of people with Alzheimer’s or schizophrenia, who had Alzheimer’s, for instance, for more than twenty years and were totally incoherent.
They didn’t know their name. They were incontinent and so forth. And a couple of minutes before death, their minds became extraordinarily clear. They remembered their names. They remembered their family, members.
And since many of them had been very devout Christians, they recited Christian prayers before dying. And Geshe la said that this definitely is something which happens, but it is only possible if the person has had previous habituation. Otherwise, without habituation, it’s not possible. It is indispensable in these cases to have strong habituation. Without habituation, this is impossible.
Then if one has strong habituation, even if the mind is disturbed for a very long period of time, it is possible at the time of death through the power of that habituation to take powerful refuge. About that mind just before death and to have a virtuous mind just before death or at death. Geshe said that it’s helpful to have faith, is a virtuous state of mind. What specifically would be that state of mind? Would it be recollecting one’s spiritual teacher or recollecting Buddha Śākyamūni, are those the kind of things that Geshe was referring to when he says a virtuous state of mind?
Definitely one spiritual teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, or especially recollecting Amitābha, or Avalokiteśvara. You wanna just sorry. And would it maybe would reciting mantra be, you know, would that would that do? People could die. Right?
So when you die, it’s very difficult to recite. Yeah. If you can, you’re not dying yet. Here, Geshe-la, when he is speaking of the mind of the death state, he’s not talking of the coarse minds of the death state. At that time, you’re not dead.
He’s talking of the subtle minds when you are basically physically inactive. So in, in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, there is an account of some of the dissolution, the stages of the death process, then it is very beneficial to engage in this at a level of the past shared with the being of the small scope, which is our level. Yeah. I think stop here tonight. I think okay.
Thank you. So this is where I think Mhmm. Yeah. Yeah. There are some rugs, yak wool rugs in the back.
Shores. Thank you. And as being modeled by Jill here.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.