1 h 34 min · 4,055 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching continues the presentation of grounds and paths, explaining entry into the path (uncontrived definite emergence) for hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas. It discusses how the path of the Mahayana differs in requiring great compassion and bodhicitta, and compares the objects of meditation, abandonment and attainment across tenet systems, including conceptual imputation. Questions from the audience on innate ignorance, afflictions after definite emergence and the basis of imputation are also addressed.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 35m
UUID: d5d95199-3373-495f-8e38-92bea1b4fc21
Words: 4,051
Mhmm. So broadly speaking, we have finished the presentation of the five paths of grounds and paths, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and normal learning. And at present, the time has come to present the three vehicles that of the, hearers solitary realizers and bodhisattvas. So, here, a path or a path to liberation are synonymous, and we define a path as the generation of an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Now what precisely is an uncontrived thought of definite emergence?
An uncontrived thought of definite emergence arises once one has reflected with sadness on the miseries of cyclic existence. So here, having entered the path refers, in other words, to having generated an uncontrived mind of definite emergence, which is a mind which reflects with sadness on the miseries of cyclic existence. And at this point, one is said to have entered the path to liberation, to have entered the path, or to have entered the gateway to liberation. So to be counted as having entered the ranks of the Mahāyāna or not is contingent on whether bodhicitta has been generated within one’s mind stream or not, uncontrived bodhicitta. Likewise, once one has generated an uncontrived definite emergence within one’s mind stream, one has entered the path to liberation.
So just as to enter the path of the Mahāyāna, one must have no relation with the four elements of the path to liberation. Likewise, to enter the path leading to liberation, one must have generated an uncontrived mind of definite emergence, which is not mixed with any attraction for the miseries of cyclic existence. Should that mind be mixed with an attraction for the miseries of cyclic existence, one will not have entered the path to liberation. So, to have generated a noncontrived mind of definite emergence, it is not sufficient, to have generated a mind which, experiences no admixture with the attraction for the miseries of cyclic existence in the slightest. But in addition, such a mind must be a stable mind.
Should that mind not be a stable mind, but at times be a mind, which experiences no attraction for the marvelous, of psychic existence and at other times a mind which experiences such attraction, then this is not the generation of uncontrived definite emergence. Generating a a mind an uncontrived mind of definite emergence means entering the path. Persons who enter the path are generally speaking threefold, hearers, solitary realizers, or bodhisattvas. Now there is no necessary entailment between having entered the path and being necessarily one of these three beings, but we shall set that aside. Once one has entered the path, the category of these three beings one falls within depends on one’s object of observation, the liberation one strives for.
In other words, one’s object of attainment. So therefore, as was already explained, the category of person one falls in, the vehicle one falls in, is contingent on the motivation underlying the aspiration for the liberation one is striving for, whether it is liberation or full enlightenment. And to take an example within this temple of ours, if we were to check our motivation, then I would like to think that all of us wish to enter the path of the Mahāyāna. Let me take an example, in, our society. When one enters school, one has, multiple, levels of education, primary school, secondary school, university, and everything is contingent on one’s motivation.
Perhaps not in primary school, but certainly later on by the time of secondary school, one studies with a goal, with an object of observation in mind. One might study to become a professor or a doctor or to work in a factory. Then the goal one achieves is contingent on one’s motivation. It is the same thing when one enters the path. Australia’s primary school which starts speaking.
Right? You start in primary school. Probably in kindergarten, the children have no particular motivation apart from playing. But definitely, by primary school or secondary school, they wouldn’t be going to school without such a motivation. And this motivation determines how they proceed.
Then for us, most in this temple have received teachings on the Lam Rim, and we need a motivation. Then what precisely is our object of observation, our goal? If it is full enlightenment, then probably one can say one has Likewise, for, beings who have yet to enter the path, there are those who motivated by the wish to become arhats, strive, and these would be hearers. And there are also those, and it’s a little bit awkward, the so called solitary realizers or Pratyeka Buddhas who aim for full enlightenment for their own sake alone and who study the four noble truths with this as a motivation.
So as was mentioned previously, when someone who is striving to attain the state of an arhat for his own sake alone generates a definite emergence which, wishes to abandon the afflictive obstructions, klesha varana, or wishes to abandon psychic existence. At that point, I think one can say that such a being has entered the vehicle of the hearers. So once such a being has entered the path of a hearer, he or she will have entered the will have entered the path of accumulation. At the point where such a being generates an insight which is focused on emptiness, he or she would have entered the path of preparation. At the point when such a being generates for the first time the direct perception of emptiness, he or she would have entered the path of seeing.
When that being reenters into a direct perception of emptiness, he or she would have entered the path of meditation. Then the same thing holds for Pratyaka Buddhas or solitary realizers, the process of progression with the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing meditation until one attains the path of normal learning is the same. Is unnecessary to explain it in detail. So, as far as the path, or the vehicle of the Mahāyāna is concerned, things are somewhat more complicated. Initially, one generates an aspiration, which wishes for the attainment of a liberation, which is full and utter enlightenment. And when eventually uncontrived definite emergence arises within one’s mind stream, at that point, things get a bit delicate, and this calls for analysis.
So, probably, all of us in this room, have, generated a wish which wishes or strives to attain full and utter enlightenment for the sake of others. Now on the basis of that wish, when eventually, one day, we give rise to uncontrived definite emergence, in your opinion, have we entered Mhmm. Have we entered the Mahāyāna or not? Yes. Yes.
Oh, really? Really? Oh, yes. And you have to think. No.
There is grounds for analysis here. Yeah. What do you think? I agree with the answers. I I think if you start motivation that you want to achieve the.
You haven’t entered the, have you? No. You here in this room. Oh. No.
You haven’t entered the Mahāyāna, have you? Okay. Really? Oh. Good.
You have. Very good. You are. I should prostrate, but my apologies. I’m a bit impaired.
I think you didn’t understand Gesheera’s question. But the question is this. We all agree that if your goal is fully not for enlightenment for the sake of others at present, that is not enough to say you have entered the Mahāyāna. Right? Now if independence on that through your practice eventually someday, you generate uncontrived definite emergence, Have you at that point entered the Mahāyāna or not?
So, basically, Geshe la was saying to Jampa Kedrup, the doubt, and it’s one which is, debated in the monasteries is the following. There is basically, no doubt regarding the fact that someone who wishes to enter the, Śrāvakayāna or the Pratyaka Buddhayana and who generates, independence on that initial motivation, uncontrived definite emergence, will enter those paths at the moment he has generated uncontrived definite emergence. There is a doubt for someone who wishes to enter the Mahāyāna and who independence on his practice generates uncontrived definite emergence. What path has he entered? So the, this is the doubt.
Then, Jampa asserts that there is something called Mahāyāna definite emergence. Geshiva asked him what precisely Mahāyāna definite emergence was. And Gesheva then said, the problem is that, basically, once one has generated uncontrived definite emergence through meditation on the four noble truths, one has definitely entered some path, but precisely which one? If one says that one has directly entered the Mahāyāna, it’s very awkward because initially to generate bodhicitta, one must train great compassion, independence on the sevenfold cause and effect instruction or the equalization and interchange of self and others, and that hasn’t yet occurred. Do you understand?
So there’s a lot of food for thought here because it is clear on the basis of Lam Rim that one must initially generate uncontrived definite emergence before being able to generate bodhicitta. So for someone who has generated uncontrived definite emergence with an underlying motivation of wishing to attain full and utter enlightenment, has that person entered or not the Mahāyāna? This is very much the doubt. Then, it is partly this doubt which the definition of a path in the technical definition in grounds and paths, a path upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, wishes to address, but we will set that aside for the time being. So you do understand that numerous causes and conditions are required to be able to enter the Mahāyāna.
First and foremost, one must generate great compassion and independence on that supreme resolve. And the boundary for the entry of the Mahāyāna is a generation of a stable experience of Bodhicitta, which arises independence on two causes, great compassion and the supreme resolve. So now, obviously, if we look at the definition of a which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, it would be very awkward if one once one had generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence alone, one was not said to have entered a path. Then what precisely the meaning is of the sapience upheld by the uncontrived thought of definite emergence is something which calls for analysis. Clearly, once one has generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence within one’s mind stream, probably all one’s deeds and thoughts would be virtuous because they are upheld or they are suffused by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence.
Mhmm. So we have begun today’s presentation of entry into the path of the Mahāyāna.
So we definitely do need a motivation, and therefore, we shall generate a motivation striving for as an object of observation for full enlightenment for the sake of others and reflect also on the mode of ingress in the path of hearers or the vehicle of hearers and the mode of ingress in that of solitary realizers. Let us generate this motivation. Page one. Page five. So now regarding the presentation of the three vehicles from the standpoint of the object of meditation, the object of abandonment, and the object of attainment, the object of meditation of hearers, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka is the same.
Mhmm. It is emptiness. Then the object of abandonment are different. The objects of abandonment of hearers and solitary realizers are afflictive obstructions, and the object of abandonment of Bodhisattvas is the obstructions to omniscience. The objects of attainment are different.
The object of attainment for a a hearer is the state of an. For a solitary realizer, it is full enlightenment for one’s own sake. And for a bodhisattva, it is full enlightenment for the sake of others. So, from the standpoint of prasangika Madhyamaka, the object of meditation of all three vehicles is, the same. It is that emptiness which is dependent arising.
Now it is very helpful to present, the object of meditation of abandonment and of attainment from the standpoint of the four schools of tenets. The two lower schools of tenets, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, and the two higher schools of tenets, Chitamatra and Madhyamaka. So for hearers and solitary realizers, all four schools of of tenets assert the same object of meditation, the four noble truths. And, the two lower schools of tenets assert that the object of abandonment is the afflictive obstructions. And we could say for the higher schools of tenets that the object of abandonment is asserted to be those obstruct obstructions which are not the obstructions to omniscience.
The object of attainment is the same. Now from the standpoint of the objects of observation So the, objects of observation according to Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka are different for, the hearer vehicle, the Pratyaka Buddha vehicle, and the Bodhisattva vehicle. Now from the standpoint of Chitamatra, the object of meditation of hearers and solitary realizers is the same. It is the selflessness of persons. The object of abandonment is the same.
It is afflictive obstructions, but the objects of attainment are different. For hearers, it is the state of liberation for one’s own sake. And for solitary realizers, it is the state of Buddhahood for one’s own sake. For as previously, the objects of attainment are what were explained, but the objects of meditation are different. The object of meditation of hearers is the selflessness of persons.
The object of meditation of Prateka Buddhas is nonduality, and the object of meditation of bodhisattvas is emptiness. As to the object of abandonment, it is also different. The object of abandonment of hearers is afflictive obstructions. The object of abandonment of solitary realizers are the coarse obstructions to omniscience, and the object of abandonment of bodhisattvas are the subtle obstructions to omniscience. So for Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, as you know, all phenomena are mere conceptual imputations, nothing more, or mere conceptual imputations.
Then, Jampa Kedrup, since you are studying these topics, it is very beneficial for yourself to reflect on the mode of conceptual imputation. Little is said about conceptual imputation in Vaibhāṣika, but what are the differences between the modes of conceptual imputation as taught in Sattrantika, Chitamatra, Svatantrika, and Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka? Don’t worry if you’re getting a little bit dizzy. I will just mention this, and it’ll hopefully stay. So the understanding of conceptual imputation is that the only phenomena which are conceptually imputed are permanent phenomena.
Things, in other words, impermanent phenomena, are not conceptually imputed because they are established in terms of their own uncommon mode of abiding.
So as for Chitamatra, in Chitamatra, it is no longer the case that no permanent phenomenon is or it is no longer the case that all permanent phenomena are conceptually imputed since emptiness is a permanent phenomenon, but it is not a conceptual imputation. Because according to Chitamatra, it is truly established just as other powered phenomena. In other words, impermanent phenomena. Now why is it the case that emptiness is truly established? Simply because according to Chitamatra, it exists from the very beginning.
And in as much as it exists from the very beginning, it is said to be truly established. So why, according to Chitamatra, would space be said to be a mere conceptual imputation? Because space is not established as its own mode of abiding from the beginning. And why is this the case? Because space is imputed on a basis of imputation, which is the intermediate area.
This intermediate area can be said to be established, on the basis of its own mode of abiding, but it is on its basis that space is imputed. For this reason, space is a mere conceptual imputation. Now, the doubt which arises is that, the understanding of space in Chitamatra as not being established by its own characteristics at as being a mere conceptual imputation and as not being established in terms of its own uncommon mode of abiding is identical to the object of negation within Prasangika Madhyamika. This doubt is a misunderstanding of the differences between the two schools. Because when Prasanika Madhyamica asserts that space is not established by its own characteristics, It does not assert that space is imputed on a basis of imputation, which is established in terms of its own uncommon mode of abiding as in Chitamatra.
It asserts instead that there is nothing which is findable from the standpoint of the object of imputation. The Svatantika Madhyamica system is a complex and awkward one. Indeed, in Svatantika Madhyamica text and monastic textbooks, it is asserted that for Satanika Madhyamaka, all phenomena are mere conceptual imputations. At the same time, Satanika Madhyamaka asserts that all phenomena are established from their own side and are established by their own characteristics. And when one inquires what the conception is which does the imputing in Svatantika Madhyamaka, it is said to be a conceptuality, which is not contaminated by, the tenet of true existence.
Okay. She just says it is rather difficult to explain. So this is mainly for Jampa Kedrup usage. Mhmm. Is, I suppose, an idiosyncratic system.
Then if you have questions, please ask your questions. I just have a quick question. If, the removal of the obstructions to omniscience, thus becoming a fully enlightened being, a Buddha, how can such a being exist for their own sake? So war, this is the goal of solitary realizers. Whether they attain it or not is another question.
They seem to attain a state with the similitude of the 32 major and the 80 minor marks. This is why there is a difference between the duration for the attainment of the object of attainment for hearers and solitary realizers. Hearers must train for one hundred eons. There’s there’s a lot of debates about solitary realizers, rhinoceros type solitary realizers, the social and the asocial solitary realizers and socials. Is the hearer is like a lay person?
Generally speaking, the overwhelming majority of hearers are bhikshus, fully ordained monks, but there is no definiteness. It’s not necessarily the case. So after someone has attained uncontrived thought of definite emergence, can they engage in nonvirtuous acts? And if yes, how is that possible given that they’re constantly in that one state of constantly striving for liberation? It’s a very good question.
Indeed, once someone has generated uncontrived definite emergence within their mind stream, they nonetheless can commit non virtuous deeds. They can give rise briefly to anger. Mhmm. What allows them to do that, like, that their mindset of constantly striving. As in they have this mindset like the way I look at it is I have this filter going on, so everything that they’re interpreting is actually through a filter of a striving for liberation.
Therefore, what allows them to commit or to actually enter or to become angry? That’s okay. That’s okay. You’re not thinking. You think you’re not sleeping.
You’re thinking. Then the beings who generate definite emergence sleep sometimes, don’t they? So then at what point does the accumulation of nonvirtuous deeds stop? It stops at the level of the path of preparation onwards. With Chitamatra, Geshe la mentioned that they believe that emptiness is, permanent because it has existed from the beginning.
So do they believe or accept in beginningless time? No. They don’t they don’t accept beginningless time. Beginninglessness means something without a beginning. Right?
Chitamatra asserts that things which are formed are beginningless. Beginninglessly established. I’m a little confused. I thought once, you reached uncontrived definite emergence, which would be liberation, that you would be beyond the afflictions. You would be beyond the afflictions?
Yeah. So you asked a similar question previously. Do not confuse definite emergence and liberation. Definite emergence is a motivation striving for a goal, an object of observation. The goal is liberation.
Excuse me, let me give an example to make this clear. When we’re studying in school, one studies with a goal in mind. And even though one has a goal in mind, one hasn’t achieved that goal yet. Could you please distinguish between innate ignorance from the ignorance abandoned upon entry into the path of seeing? Innate ignorance from what?
Distinguish between innate ignorance Yeah. From the ignorance abandoned upon entry into the path of seeing. So generally speaking, in, the monastic manuals, it is asserted that the abandonment, the ignorance, which is abandoned at the level of the path of seeing, is that assertion of the existence of a self of persons, due to tenets or in a mind which is contaminated by tenets. Now here, what is not said is that these are, evil tenets. Then, innate ignorance is present within our all our mind streams.
It is this ignorance which causes us, to perceive all phenomena, whether they are material or nonmaterial, as, being established from their own side, as appearing as being established from their own side, and as existing as they appear. I don’t recall well, actually, put this other way. Could Geshe-la talk about the path of no more learning? I could, please later, I will
No. No. No. It’s no hurry. You know?
So, today, we covered the mode of ingress in the path of hearers and solitary realizers and started to talk about the mode of ingress in the path of the Mahāyāna. This is something which we are focused upon, and therefore, we should listen about. Then, Jampa Kedrup, it will be very beneficial for yourself to reflect on the mode of arising of the various systems of tenets. For instance, the, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika system of tenets are rooted in the first turning of the wheel of the law. Whereas the Prāsaṇgika system of tenet, is rooted in the second turning of the wheel of the law, which it takes as literal.
The Chitamatra system of tenets is rooted in the final turning of the wheel of the law and specifically the Samdhinirmochana Sūtra, the Sūtra of the Unraveling of the Intent. But the Svatantika Madhyamaka system is an odd system because, even though it is rooted in the second turning of the wheel of the law, it does not accept, all of the sutras of the second turning of the wheel of the law as literal. For instance, the, heart sūtra is not accepted as literal. Does Kedrup have a question? Question was regarding the understanding of phenomena not being established from their own side.
Then if phenomena are not established from their own side, the mere conceptual imputation, what is the basis of imputation. If we take the case of a vase, part of the definition of a vase is what is bulbous. Then is bulbous the basis the of imputation of a vase or not? And Geshe-la said he’s, just taking this one on the fly. He’s a bit winging it, but in his opinion, it is not because the, imputed phenomenon is subsequent to the basis of imputation.
Then do we really want to assert that vase is subsequent to what is bulbous? So the way one would debate about it is with a person, as an instance. So in the case of Jabba Kedrup, the person Jampa Kedrup is an imputed phenomenon on a basis of imputation, which are the aggregates. Therefore, the imputation arises after the basis of imputation. No?
And in the Chittamatra system, question is, is the basis of imputation and the are the basis of imputation and the imputed phenomenon such as bulbous and vase simultaneous or not. Numerous quotes about this, which distinguish between the way things appear to, persons and the way they are in reality, and one must reflect on this by oneself. Okay. And, I think you have question. Just following up that question, I just wonder if the basis of imputation for everybody is different.
All of us have the same basis of imputation, which are the five aggregates, the form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factor, and consciousness aggregates. Nonetheless, there are different modes of imputation of the I on this basis of imputation. If one meditates, there is one mode of imputation. Reflection: I have meditated well. If one is studying a text, there’s another mode of imputation.
I am studying this text. How was that? No problem. We will start covering this quietly, next time. So we shall stop here for tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
- The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.