TBI Recordings – 14092016Lamrim 3

1 h 39 min · 4,373 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 14092016Lamrim 3
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains bodhicitta as a mind with a twin aspiration, for the sake of others and for full enlightenment, and distinguishes aspiring from engaging bodhicitta. It also distinguishes great love, great compassion, the great resolve and bodhicitta by their objects of observation and aspects. A question and answer session follows on related points, including the six perfections and emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: bbe06020-4f8e-4a28-b70e-8c1ab74818fb

Words: 4,369

Yeah. As I said in my prayers, generating the mind is for the sake of others to strive for full enlightenment. These two verses offer a definition of Bodhicitta, which is a mind with a twin aspiration. One aspires for the sake of others to full enlightenment, thereby fulfilling both one’s own welfare and that of others. So one must know and understand the definition or the meaning of bodhicitta.

And if one doesn’t know or understand its definition or its meaning, then it is impossible to practice. An example will make this clear. If we’re going downtown, let’s say, to Downtown Adelaide with as go to go to a large shopping center, we have to have the directions. If our directions are not accurate, we will waste a lot of time in the process and may not get there at all. Likewise, when one speaks of meditating on bodhicitta, it is meaningless to say, I meditate on bodhicitta without having a clue what bodhicitta is all about.

Or if one is going to visit a family, one needs to have their precise address. Otherwise, if one doesn’t have their address and one wanders around the hills in one’s car, one can get lost. One waste a lot of time. Mhmm. One might even have an accident.

Likewise, when it comes to a topic like bodhicitta, before meditating, we must understand the meaning of bodhicitta as well as the meaning of all of the components of the method aspect of the path. Also, instance, if one thinks one is meditating on bodhicitta, but in reality, one is not meditating on bodhicitta, but on compassion. Then obviously, is a virtuous state of mind. But when one gains some type of experience, one will think, I have gained an experience of bodhicitta, whereas one hasn’t gained an experience of bodhicitta at all, one has merely gained an experience of compassion. For this reason, it is extremely important when one studies to understand the object of observation, the aspect of the state of mind considered, and so forth.

So bodhicitta is therefore a mind with a twin aspiration, a double aspiration. The first aspiration is for the sake of others. The second is for the sake of full enlightenment or if you prefer for one’s own sake. Bodhicitta is a mind with these two aspirations conjoined. Then if one is able to clearly distinguish between Bodhicitta and compassion or distinguish clearly between compassion and love or distinguish clearly between the great resolve and compassion, then when one meditates, things will proceed as they should.

Then if we were to look at the definition of Bodhicitta in the great treatises, it is a very long definition, which is actually difficult to memorize. But if we focus on the meaning, this is the meaning. So I would like to make it clear here that understanding the meaning of bodhicitta and having generated bodhicitta within one’s mind stream are two totally different things. One must understand the body meaning of bodhicitta first to generate bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, but this generation of bodhicitta within one’s mind stream involves a transformation of the mind through repeated habituation at which point bodhicitta arises in a spontaneous and uncontrived fashion. In this respect, the generation of bodhicitta is different from training the mind in focusing on emptiness since emptiness is an external object.

So the object of observation of conventional bodhicitta is full and utter enlightenment, and its aspect is the same. It is also full and utter enlightenment for bodhicitta, the object of observation, and the aspect are the same. So here, when we refer to the object of observation of bodhicitta as full and utter enlightenment, this is its object of attainment. Now if we were to ask how does one identify full and utter enlightenment, What would be your answer? What is full and utter enlightenment?

No. It’s okay. I ask you to give your answer. So what is full and natural enlightenment? Yes?

Yes. Eliminating all faults eliminated, actualizing all qualities. So then we have said that the object of observation, in other words, the object of attainment of Bodhicitta is full and utter enlightenment. So what is full and utter enlightenment? Is Buddha Śākyamūni full and utter enlightenment?

All the same. The same. How do you think we could attain the state? How could we become Buddha Śākyamūni? Buddha Shakimuni is dead.

It’s passed. So if I ask you what the object of observation or the object of attainment of bodhicitta, full and utter enlightenment is, then if you give the state of Buddha Śākyamūni as an answer, that is obviously inappropriate because Buddha Śākyamūni is long gone, long past. Then we have a different continuum from that of Buddha Śākyamūni. So he’s He is past.

Our enlightenment is future. Past and future do not meet. Do you understand? Okay. So what’s your answer?

What do you give? So our object of attainment is our own minds becoming fully enlightened through study, through practice over a long period of time. Our mind will transform, all faults will be eliminated, all qualities will be actualized, and eventually, our own mind will become fully enlightened. Therefore, the object of act of attainment is the manifestation of our own enlightenment. Then, however much we purify our mind, it improves.

This continual process of purification leads us to our object of attainment, full enlightenment.

So this is what the object of attainment of Bodhicitta is for enlightenment. And here, there is a lot of food for thought in trying to distinguish between bodhicitta on the one hand and the Mahāyāna refuge on the other hand. As you know, there are several forms of refuge, The refuge of the being of the small, middling, and great scope. Now Bodhicitta is subdivided into two, aspiring and engaging Bodhicitta, and the distinction is best understood through an example. Let us imagine we plan to go to Adelaide.

Then for so long as we are planning to go, but have not started to go, we’re actually not going to get to Adelaide. In addition to planning to go to Adelaide, we must also start to move to walk towards Adelaide. So the planning to go to Adelaide is aspiring bodhicitta, and the actual motion towards Adelaide is engaging bodhicitta. Aspiring bodhicitta is a mind which wishes for full and utter enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, but it does not yet engage in the activities to obtain that state. That happens when one generates engaging bodhicitta, and at this point, one trains in the six perfections.

So moving from the object of attainment, full and utter enlightenment down to its causes. Its cause is a bodhicitta. And as was explained, bodhicitta has both an object of observation and aspect which are one and the same. They are full and utter enlightenment. The cause of bodhicitta, the immediate cause is the great resolve.

The great resolve is the state of mind which motivated by great compassion, which cannot stand the suffering which sentient beings experience, thinks in addition, I will free them. And this state of mind has an object of observation, which is bodhicitta, and it has an aspect, and its aspect is none other but the resolve, I will free them. Now what is the cause, the uncommon cause of the great resolve? It is called specifically the substantial cause of great resolve. The substantial cause of great resolve is great compassion.

What is great compassion? Great compassion is that state of mind which observing all sentient beings thinks why should they not be freed from suffering. It therefore has as object all sentient beings and as aspect why should they not be freed from suffering? Then perhaps at present, none of us is experiencing physical suffering, the suffering of heat or cold, but we definitely do experience mental suffering, and we must be able to identify it. Then one must establish a distinction between great compassion on the one hand and mere compassion on the other hand.

So mere compassion exists within our mind stream. It is manifest towards friends, relatives, teachers, and so forth. And it manifests occasionally when we experience it, but sometimes it does not manifest as well. What is the specific cause of great compassion? The specific cause of great compassion is great love, which is that state of mind which is or has as object of observation or sentient beings and has as aspect an affectionate concern for all sentient beings, a an affection for sentient beings.

Now the more powerful the generation of this great love, the more powerful in turn the generation of great compassion. Now we have both mere love and mere compassion within our mind streams. For instance, we have mere love, ordinary love for our relatives, for our children, and so forth. This love is a biased or a partial love, just as there are a biased or a partial compassion. So when we reflect on the advantages on the object of observation and the aspect of love, then a powerful sense how extraordinary love is arises within our mind stream.

This is an understanding of mere love. Then reference was made previously to immeasurable love, compassion, joy, and equanimity. We shall not develop these further here because their controlling condition, in other words, indispensable preliminary condition is the attainment of calm abiding, and that would leave us to lead us to far field. So quickly at present, answer. What is the difference between great love and great compassion?

Give reasons. Those are the words. Yes. What is it meaning? Others.

What’s the difference between love great love and great compassion? The Please. Advice. I’d like to translate what Geshe-la has said first. So the meaning, please, not the words.

Yes. Natalie? Yeah. Yes. That’s pretty much it.

What’s missing is on contract. So we do have within our mind this affection, but it’s a biased affection for others. So we have to extend it to all beings. Then we have affectionate love for our father, for our mother, for relatives. What we have to do is to extend this affectionate love to all beings.

This is great love. What is the difference between great compassion and the great resolve? What is the difference? The determination even if I myself do must do this alone to engage in the acts to attain the full enlightenment in the sake of awesome joy.

What’s the difference? The difference that used to draw was between the idea that I’m going to go for it, but I’ve got a lot of friends with me. And the idea of I will go for it even if I have no assistance at all from anyone. Okay. What is the difference between great compassion and So before we go before we go there, what is the meaning of conventional bodhicitta?

Mori? Then conventional bodhicitta and great compassion are different. What is the difference between them? Okay. Another?

So broadly speaking, all of you have understood the difference, but you have been drifting around the precise answer I wanted. The difference between great compassion and bodhicitta is a difference of object of observation and aspect. The object of observation of great compassion is all sentient beings and its aspect is the wish may be the may they be free of suffering. The object of observation of Bodhicitta is full and utter enlightenment, and its aspect is also full and utter enlightenment. Therefore, the objects of observation and aspects are different, and therefore they are different.

Then if we set aside the aspects, just the objects of the observation are different. The object of observation of great compassion is all sentient beings, and the object of observation of Bodhicitta is is is fully nurtured enlightenment. All you have to do is say the objects of observation object. Let’s see. One is high, one is low.

It takes four words in Tibetan. The me the object of observation is different, and you drift on and on with two definitions, and no one understands anything. So this is a very simple way of presenting things. They are different because the objects of observation are different. Or in other cases, they might be different because one is a cause and the other is an effect.

You might think the great compassion and conventional bodhicitta are different because great compassion is a substantial cause of conventional bodhicitta. Without great compassion, there cannot be a conventional bodhicitta. Then I would suspect a helpful way of thinking about this is to reflect on the fact that the object of observation of great compassion, of great love, and of the great resolve are identical. They differ in aspect. Whereas the object of observation of great compassion, of great love, and of the great resolve is different from the object of observation of So at the great debates during examinations, if someone asks you what the definition of great compassion is, then indeed you go on and give the definition of great compassion is this is this subject.

But if someone asks you what the difference of great compassion and bodhicitta is and you give instead the definition of the one and the other, it is not false. But that is not what’s being asked from you. So it is therefore extremely important to be able to distinguish clearly great love, great compassion, the great resolve, and bodhicitta. And once one has done this, then in the context of setting the motivation, one should take all sentient beings as object of observation and with the wish of benefiting all sentient beings, generate the resolve to study and practice the Lam Rim. Please open the paper, page one.

[Please open the text and recite.]

So as was mentioned, the bodhicitta is subdivided into two, aspiring and engaging bodhicitta. And in brief, aspiring bodhicitta is that bodhicitta which is generated but does not actually engage in the path towards attaining full enlightenment. Whereas engaging bodhicitta is that bodhicitta which engages in this path. So aspiring bodhicitta is aspiring towards the means, whereas engaging bodhicitta is engaging in the means. Aspiring bodhicitta is of the nature of a mere prayer, whereas engaging bodhicitta engages in the practice.

So then So engaging bodhicitta, therefore, engages in the means to attain full enlightenment, and the means here can either be presented in terms of the two collections, the collection of wisdom and of merit or in terms of method and wisdom. Then this specifically refers to the practice of the six perfections. The four first perfections, the perfection of generosity, ethics, forbearance, and enthusiasm are included within the means aspect of the path, whereas the latter two, concentration and wisdom, are included in the wisdom aspect of the path. So therefore, engaging bodhicitta is a bodhicitta which engages in the practice of these six perfections starting with the perfection of generosity. Now the perfection of generosity could be defined as giving something to others.

So excuse me. This was just generosity, not the perfection of generosity. Now the perfection of generosity is this activity of generosity engaged in motivated by, at best, uncontrived bodhicitta, alternatively, contrived bodhicitta, and at the very least, a motivation or an understanding of the motivation of bodhicitta. So we have proceed incrementally in a presentation of the six perfections presenting both their nature and their aspect. If we take the perfection of generosity, it is subdivided into three.

The generosity of giving material objects, the generosity of giving fearlessness, and that of giving dharma. So once we generate this motivation, which should be at least an understanding of bodhicitta, then whichever form of generosity we engage in, whether it is the giving of material things, the giving of fearlessness or that of dharma, it becomes a practice of the Mahāyāna. And when we refer to giving material things, it doesn’t have to be a large donation. Something very small is still adequate. Chocolate is okay.

We eat a lot of chocolate, don’t we? Very popular, you know, in Australia. So So to engage in generosity, the opposite of generosity must be absent. The opposite of generosity is avarice or stinginess. And then such a practice of generosity is not as such the perfection of generosity.

In addition, we need the motivation of bodhicitta. So these the perfection of generosity and so forth will be presented gradually. These are very beautiful topics. At present, I will take your questions, please. Concise and clear questions, only one question per person.

And after you have finished, if there are no questions left, you can ask a second question. Yes, Sheila. I am mildly confused. Might be more than mildly confused. At the beginning of the teaching, if I heard correctly, and I might not have, I understood that that generating the mind striving for full enlightenment for the sake of others had two aspects, was described as having two aspects, that it was for the sake of others, and that it was for full enlightenment, and that included oneself.

So it was in essence for the two purposes. Okay? But later on, the object of observation and the aspects were described as identical. Could he could Geshe la, please, clarify? So indeed, bodhicitta is a mind which has two or twin aspirations.

The first is for the sake of others, and the second is to attain one’s own will. In other words, full and utter enlightenment. But this is not the same thing as bodhicitta having the same object of observation and aspect. Bodhicitta has the same object of observation and aspect, is full and utter enlightenment. But when we speak of the two aspirations of Bodhicitta, they are in a causal relation with each other.

For the sake of others is the aspiration, which arises from great compassion whose object of observation is all sentient beings, whereas one’s own goal that is, the result. Mhmm. So aspiration is not aspect. Yes. Aspiration aspect are different.

Okay. Yep. Thank you. Mhmm. So the aspect is something which the object has.

The aspiration is from the side of the actor or the agent. Michel, could I clarify something, please? You said the first four perfections fall under the method aspect and the last two under the wisdom aspect. But in liberation, in the palm of your hand, it says the first five fall under method and the last, the sixth only, is the wisdom aspect. So is this something that is debated or contentious?

You must be wrong. You must be thinking of enthusiasm, which indeed can either be included in the method or the wisdom aspect of the path. Because concentration and wisdom are both included in the wisdom aspect of the path. This is explicit in the Abhisamayālamkāra. You check.

I will finish it. You check for yourself, and I’ll check myself. It is strange to include concentration within the wisdom aspect of the path. Something that Within the method aspect of the path. Excuse me.

Strange. Include I didn’t tell them. Have we finished it? Okay. I think I misheard something as well regarding the objective observation of the great resolve.

First, I thought Geshe la said that it’s Bodhicitta, and then said that it was identical to that of great compassion and great love, which would be all sentient beings. So Geshe la clarify that. The object of observation of great resolve is all sentient beings. It’s the same. Thank you.

How does bodhicitta relate to the four Buddha bodies? So the four bodies are the object of observation of Bodhicitta. Mhmm. The Nirmala kaya, the Sambhogakaya, and the two dharmakayas. On Natalie.

In relation to the perfection of generosity, I was wondering if Geshe la could speak a little bit more about the fearlessness, which is one of the three possibilities of generosity and conviction of generosity.

I will explain quietly and in detail later on the various aspects of the six perfections. What I’d like to take as questions at present are questions regarding great love, great compassion, the great resolve, and bodhicitta. So the topic of the six perfect six perfections is something which will be addressed later. Its foundation or its basis, what we are talking about now, which is great love, great compassion, the great resolve in bodhichitta. Marker?

What is the distinction between definite emergence and full and utter enlightenment? I was always also going to ask the distinction between definite emergence, the third noble truth, the fourth seal, and full and utter enlightenment because I thought that they were all synonymous. Definite emergence. The third noble truth. The fourth seal, Nirvāṇa is peace, and full and utter enlightenment.

So definite emergence is the mind of consciousness. So the mind of definite emergence is an actor, an agent. It’s a mind Mhmm. A consciousness. Then there is a close relation between the object of observation of the mind of definite emergence, the object of observation of bodhicitta, and so forth.

Those are objects. So the mind of definite emergence is the mind striving for liberation. Mhmm. I might need to explain this question, but in brief, it is, can we realize the meaning of Bodhicitta without understanding the meaning of emptiness? And I ask that because if the object of observation of conventional Bodhicitta is full enlightenment, to understand full enlightenment, do not do we not need a realization of emptiness?

Yes. Definitely. It’s definitely possible for someone who has not understood the meaning of the emptiness to generate fully characterized bodhicitta within his mindstream. Because a being who has entered the path of the Mahāyāna and who is at the level of the first path of accumulation will have a an uncontrived realization of bodhicitta, but does not necessarily have a realization of emptiness. This will necessarily arise at the very latest at the level of the middling path, the path of preparation.

And the same is true for the Hīnayāna path. To enter the Hīnayāna path, one needs an uncontrived definite emergence. One does not need a realization of emptiness. So as says in his three principles of the path, once the mind striving for liberation arises day and night, at that point, definite emergence would have been well generated. This is a perfectly clear definition.

Another. Just another point of clarification. What is the difference between a definition and a meaning? They are quite similar. When one asks what’s the what the meaning of of is, but it’s asking for the definition of conventional.

Then, obviously, when in debate, someone asks what’s the definition of and then you start giving the definition which is found in the text that is not necessarily connected to the meaning. It is the meaning which counts. Mhmm. Yeah, Nick. Geshe la, you said that bodhicitta is the development of all good qualities within the mind.

I’m just wondering how that relates to Buddha nature. So there is a close relation between bodhicitta and lineage or what the Chinese called Buddha nature. Now we can posit lineage either the mind or the of the mind. Bodhicitta arises through the development of the mind. Thank you.

There seems to be so many bodhicittas. And with the aspiring and engaging bodhicitta, which one of those is conventional bodhicitta, or are they both conventional bodhicitta? Vishal had mentioned about six perfections. Do I hear correctly it’s a perfect generosity? What’s the difference between the perfect and the general term generosity?

So the difference between the perfection of generosity and generosity is one of motivation. For the perfection of generosity to occur, one must engage in generosity motivated by Bodhicitta. Generosity alone is just the wish to give something to another person without being affected by avarice or stinginess. Just one one question. Sorry, Geshe la.

I think I missed it. You asked us for the definition of full enlightenment, and a few of us said the state of Buddhahood, which apparently wasn’t right, but I missed what the definition was. Could you repeat the deaf your definition of full enlightenment? Fully enlightened and the state of Buddhahood are similar and the same thing. Mhmm.

Mhmm. Hi, Geshe. Hi, Geshe. I just wanna ask them to follow-up Andrew’s question before. How does I don’t understand why someone who doesn’t understand a can sort of develop a bodhicitta as referred to full in full enlightenment.

Because he just said it’s a quality of Buddhahood. Although somebody doesn’t understand the interdependence would and would actually develop this full enlightenment state. Thank you. You are asking how someone who does not understand interdependence can understand what? Can develop?

What is it? Independence. Right? One can definitely generate bodhicitta without having understood subtle emptiness. In addition to the fact that one is the wisdom aspect of the past and the other is the method aspect of the path, there’s a big difference between great compassion and Bodhicitta, let’s say, the one side and the wisdom realizing emptiness on the other.

Great compassion and bodhicitta are a mind which is transformed towards others, whereas the wisdom realizing emptiness arises through the analysis of an object. So your question regarding interdependence is a question regarding emptiness. And this is the wisdom aspect of the path. Then bodhicitta and great compassion are part of the method component of the path. We have a lot of rain.

So if you ask too many questions, we’re gonna have complications. Just one question, please. Geshe la, is one possible definition of full enlightenment a mind from which all knowledge obscurations and their imprints have been eliminated? No. It would not be an appropriate definition because Buddha Buddha is not necessarily consciousness.

Mhmm. Your definition would be appropriate for omniscience. Mhmm. Omniscience. Mhmm.

Thank you. Mhmm. So we shall call it a day or a night, perhaps. Okay. Thank you.

Okay. I would like to announce a few thing. Initiation is come empowerment’s coming up on twenty fourth, and there is no Tuesday teaching next week, the the week before the retreat. But there will be

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
kaya ku (Tib)
Buddha-body or holy body. A body of an enlightened being. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

If bodhicitta has twin aspirations, how can its object of observation and aspect be described as identical? How do aspiration and aspect differ?

Bodhicitta is a mind with two, or twin, aspirations. The first is for the sake of others, and the second is to attain one's own goal, full and utter enlightenment. This is not the same as saying bodhicitta has the same object of observation and aspect, which is full and utter enlightenment. The two aspirations stand in a causal relation to each other. The aspiration for the sake of others arises from great compassion, whose object of observation is all sentient beings. One's own goal is the result. So aspiration is not aspect; they are different. The aspect is something which the object has, whereas the aspiration comes from the side of the actor or agent.

Is it possible to realize bodhicitta without first understanding the meaning of emptiness?

Yes, it is definitely possible for someone who has not understood emptiness to generate fully characterized bodhicitta in their mindstream. A being who has entered the Mahāyāna path and is at the first level, the path of accumulation, can have an uncontrived realization of bodhicitta without necessarily realizing emptiness. A realization of emptiness will necessarily arise at the very latest at the middling path, the path of preparation. The same holds for the Hīnayāna path. Entering it requires an uncontrived definite emergence, not a realization of emptiness.

What is the difference between the perfection of generosity and generosity in the general sense?

The difference lies in motivation. For generosity to become the perfection of generosity, one must engage in it motivated by Bodhicitta. Generosity on its own is simply the wish to give something to another person without being affected by avarice or stinginess. So ordinary generosity is giving free of miserliness, while the perfection of generosity is that same giving when it is done with the Bodhicitta motivation.

Scroll to Top