53 min · 2,422 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 53-minute exploration of Cittamātra philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen unpacks why the doctrine of the mind-only school presents such notoriously difficult terrain. He begins with past and future lives—a topic that immediately stakes the Cittamātra view against ancient materialist objections and anchors the need for a mental continuum. From there he moves to the central puzzle: if the mind-only school rejects external objects independent of consciousness, what carries karmic imprints from life to life? The mental consciousness cannot, since it lapses during sleep and coma. Enter the ālaya-vijnana (the all-basis consciousness)—a subtle, morally neutral receptacle that stores the seeds of experience. Geshe walks through the ālaya-vijnana’s defining properties (neutral, non-discriminating, continuously present), illustrates the doctrine with the classic dream analogy (an elephant appears to the dream-mind; no actual elephant fills the room), and touches on the boundaries of this consciousness—when it engages and ceases. He stresses that monasteries spend six months on this topic through memorisation, debate, and textual study, yet understanding remains hard-won. A moving story of the master Asaṇga, who persevered through twelve years of retreat by witnessing a drop of water slowly carve stone, punctuates the talk: transformation takes time. Aimed at practitioners with some grounding in Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 060616 Cittamātra.mp3
UUID: b182d5ad-9d38-402d-94de-4064697baa8c
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,420
So in the root text of Jñānagarbha’s difficult points of mind and basis of all, the second stanzas, last two verses teaching clearly mind and basis of all, the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijñaptimātratā clearly specifies that the teachings of Chitamatra are difficult and this refers mainly to the teachings on the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all and the Klishtamanas or the afflicted mind. So why is this the case? This is a case because the presentation of other minds such as great compassion, bodhichitta, or for that matter, ethics, concentration and wisdom, in every case hinges on a similar mode of assertion. Whereas here, the topic abuts immediately on the issue of past and future lives. So this is a case because the topic of past and future lives connects directly with that of causality.
Now as you know, the materialists of ancient India, the Lokayatas or the Cārvākas did not accept the existence of past and future lives. And once one delves into the topic of past and future lives, then the issue of a mental continuum extending from life to life arises. Then here, past and future lives refers to one’s own past and future lives, in other words, to one’s own mental continuum extending from past to future lives. Now, once one has set down the foundation of an existence of past and future lives, the question of what reincarnates arises. And this is the person, and the issue of the characteristics of the person arises.
Is a person permanent or impermanent? A majority of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, the Tīrthikas, the Mu stegs pas asserted that the person was permanent. All four Buddhist schools of tenets accept that the person is impermanent. They differ, however, in their mode of positing the person. Do they identify the person as one of the five aggregates or do they proceed differently?
So, apart from the Chittamatrans asserting the existence of eight collections of consciousness, a majority of the other schools of tenets assert or accept that the person is the mental consciousness. The Chittamatran’s asserting eight collections of consciousness however say that the person cannot be the mental consciousness. So the Chitta Matarans, which assert eight collections of consciousness, say that the mental consciousness cannot be the person because the mental consciousness is not continually present. It is absent during deep sleep as well as during states of coma or unconsciousness. And therefore, the mental consciousness cannot function as a base within which the virtuous, non virtuous or neutral karmic imprints are suffused.
So this is the reason for which the Chittamatrans asserting eight collections of consciousness propound the existence of the ālaya vijnana. So these Chittamatrans assert that the karmic imprints require a stable base, the virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints require a stable base for themselves. And this is so because as was explained many times, the mind only or Chitamatra school asserts that there are no exterior objects independent of consciousness, that all objects, all forms are of the nature of consciousness and occur within the dawning of karmic imprints in the And therefore, Chittamatrans assert that there are no exterior objects which do not depend on consciousness that all objects such as form and so forth are of the nature of consciousness. In this regard, an example is given which is a very helpful example, is the example of a dream. So let us imagine that we are dreaming of an elephant.
Then apart from the appearance of the elephant to consciousness, there is no elephant because if there actually were an elephant, we would need to have the space for the elephant in the room. So you received a handout last week, a Sangha similes for the non existence of exterior objects from the Mahāyānasamgraha, the compendium of the Mahāyāna. And the example of dreams is given at the beginning of that text. This is drawn or rooted in Buddha Śākyamūni sūtra, the sūtra Unraveling the Intent. So this is a very helpful example because what is being asserted is that apart from the appearance of an elephant to the dream consciousness dreaming of an elephant, there is no elephant.
Likewise, Chitamatra asserts that apart from the appearance of the aspect of objects to consciousness as a result of the dawning of karmic imprints within the Alaya Vijñāna, there is no exterior object. Likewise, the example of a reflection is given if we look at the reflection of our face in a mirror, then apart from that reflection in the mirror, there is no face in the mirror. So here we should rely however on this example of the dream and returning to a dream elephant. Clearly a dream elephant is not a fully characterized elephant because otherwise it would have to fit in the room. Now when we apply the example of the dream to the world which we perceive, things get a bit more awkward.
If we take the table in front of Geshela for instance, then this table clearly is constituted of parts, it has been made. To say that it merely the appearance to consciousness seems delicate. This doubt does arise indeed. The answer given is that for those who accept the Chitamatra view, this is indeed how things appear and Chitamatra was taught largely for the sake of presenting karma and causality, teaching that all phenomena of the nature of mere mind. Now at present we have reached in the root text the presentation of the nature of the Alaya Vijñāna, and this appears in the verse on Page four towards the middle of Page four, because it is neutral and not clear, definitely the five contact and so forth.
Now apart from the term mind only in Alaya Vijñāna and Chitamatra, actually what is important for us is that they are referring to a subtle mind. So here in the stanza, which was quoted because it is neutral and not clear, neutral refers to the fact that the associates or perhaps if you prefer the parts of the are neither virtuous nor non virtuous. So today probably we will finish the presentation of the mind basis of all or the Alaya Vijñāna and it behooves us to try to understand or identify what the nature of the Alaya Vijñāna is. So it is precisely because the mind basis of all is neutral and not clear that the five object determining mental factors are necessarily present and these are aspiration, then belief, memory, concentration and wisdom. So it is precisely because the Alaya Vijñāna is neutral and not clear that these five are not present.
And precisely for this reason, apart from the five omnipresent mental factors, none other mental factors are present. So which aspects of the first omnipresent mental factor of sensation are present, then neither pleasant nor unpleasant suffering sensations are present, only equanimous sensations are present, neutral sensations. And this is why the final verse of that stanza says, sensation is intermediate because it is neither suffering nor pleasure, it is neutral. So the following stanza, because it is connected with the self basis of all provides an etymology for the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all. In brief, when we refer to the ignorance grasping at a self in the context of Chitamatra, this ignorance views the Alaya Vijñāna as self, because it is the basis within which the karmic imprints are suffused.
And at present, the very elegant verses on the boundaries of the Alaya Vijñāna, the engaging and countering of the Alaya Vijñāna. Now clearly, Alāyavijñāna cannot be traced back in time, it is beginningless, but the question is when does it engage and when does it counter, what are its boundaries? Then it would be ideal if you understood the totality of this presentation of Alaya Vijñāna’s engagement and countering, but even if that is not possible, if you understand 50 or 60%, then that is quite good nonetheless. Then the topic of the Alaya Vijñāna, the mind basis of all is a difficult topic. In the monasteries, three full months are dedicated to its studies with daily or perhaps every two days textual classes in Buddhist philosophy, as well as hours and hours of debate every night, and one will have memorized the text, and even with all of this it is difficult to understand the topic, And for yourselves obviously, how much more so.
So the main difficulties of the Chitamatra system of tenets are the teachings regarding the mind basis of all the Alaya Vijñāna, and the teachings regarding the Klishtamanas, the afflicted mind. Then the teachings regarding non duality, they come later as a result of this. And don’t be discouraged, actually we cover the Alaya Vijñāna at Sera during something more like six months than three months. Yes, six months, exactly. And you need mental fortitude, a bone in the heart literally, because clearly at the monasteries, one debates on this in the mornings and one debates on this in the evenings, and some even have several textual classes a day.
So we have to put effort. So what we need is what Gyalse Ngülchu compared to a perseverance similar to the flow of a great river, which flows uninterruptedly. So then this topic of past and future lives enables us to understand the importance of karmic imprints and how they are implanted. And this is what is explained very clearly in Chitamatra. Then there is a marvelous example from the life of Ārya Asaṇga, as you know Asaṇga realized Maitreya, he had a direct vision of Maitreya and to attain this vision, he went into a long retreat.
But after three years, he had no experience whatsoever of Maitreya and with great discouragement, he abandoned his retreat and started returning to the world. And on his way back, he saw that a drop of water falling from a cliff had worn a hole in the rock at its base. And seeing this, he regained enthusiasm and returned to his retreat. Now you can imagine how long it takes for a drop of water to wear a hole in a piece of rock, it takes millions of years, Yet, this is reality. Then if it is the case that a drop of water can wear its way into stone and basically make a hole, how much more so for our minds.
And therefore, we should have fortitude and resolve and there’s a passage in Bodhicharyavatara to the effect, there are actually numerous passages. Then if we have time, we should not waste this time, but we should study, and eventually over time, we will accumulate this knowledge. It will not happen quickly. In our cases, we have been afflicted or we have been affected by the afflictions since beginningless time. We will not be able to eliminate them rapidly.
We have to proceed slowly. It will take time. And then the most important is to understand the thoughts of the afflictions epitomized by anger. So at present the issue of the engagement and the countering of the Alaya Vijñāna is covered in only two verses. It engages the continuum uninterruptedly until remainderless nirvana and Vajra-like.
Upon the abandonment of the body since at that point countered or abandoned at the level of the tenth ground upon the attainment in other words, cessation of the continuum of an arhat, and Vajra-like refers to the tenth ground. To try to ascertain what you understand at present about the Alaya Vijñāna, the basis of all which is supported and this referring to the Alaya Vijñāna, what’s the nature of the Alaya The mind holds all the karmic imprints which dawn. Another? Subdivided into two, the supporting basis of all and the supported basis of all, that’s the subject of moralizing. What does that mean? Not moralizing.
It is neutral, neither virtuous nor tainted and does not discriminate. This and this. Then this sort of statement will not be easy to make. We will and? I would have searched anything into that container and they carry from life to life.
It is an instance of the person. You really have to speak about an instance of the person. The object of observation and the aspect of the Alaya Vijñāna and specifically the fourfolds. So stable support, since all five sensory consciousnesses cease at the level of sensory consciousnesses cannot be the mental consciousness. It cannot be the mental conscious what is.
So if I ask you the very basic question, the easy question, can the Alaya Vijñāna Because they are not a stable base for the suffusion of the karmic imprints, Were the Alaya Vijñāna not present, since they might it must exist during sleep, there would be no sleep. Because when one wakes up, one has memory of the day before, therefore have some sort of a receptacle for them to arise. Mhmm. They call you not the Alzheimer’s, but it’s a continuity of the person. You’ve been mindful.
So you’ve changed. I’ve I’ve qualified from counter example is also very easy to and Alzheimer’s. A lot of that is to do with has no relation with the brain. Right? Nor can it be the mental consciousness, It therefore must be something else.
Please open the playbook, page one. So within the five aggregates other compositional factors and consciousness. The mind basis of all. Have time for two questions. Wondering what the difference is between insertion that the is passes from life to life.
So so the I’m asking about the difference. Like they say, it’s separate. I mean, the idea of it as a receptor consciousness, which is the instance of the person. Then whether it’s present or not Is the the aliyah we were told tonight the Alaya Vijñāna engages the mental component need an aspirational wish to get it going. And then part two So your second question is a good one.
Your first question is broadly speaking unrelated. There is a mental consciousness which is of similar type with the Alaya Vijñāna. Mhmm. Would have to have an aspiration, they’re unrelated. Alaya, how do you pronounce it?
Vijñāna. Vijñāna is not clear. What what did Geshela mean by? Through training, it becomes clear. And upon becoming fully clear at the level of full enlightenment, I think beyond.
Have you questioned, Steven? Yes. Announcements. Soup, $6 at 05:30. And the
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object-determining mental factors vishayapratiniyama-chaitta (Skt); sem jung yul nge (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany all virtuous minds and their function is to ascertain the object. There are five: aspiration, belief, mindfulness, stabilization, and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.