57 min · 2,420 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 58-minute talk, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen presents a detailed exposition of the Cittamātra (Mind-Only) school’s central doctrine: the Alaya Vijñāna, or storehouse consciousness. He explains why this subtle, stable mental substrate is posited as distinct from the five sense consciousnesses and mental consciousness—both of which cease during sleep and unconsciousness—and why it must bear karmic imprints. Gyaltsen walks through the fourfold structure of the supporting mind-basis-of-all: its objects of observation (outer phenomena, sentient beings, karmic imprints), its aspects (sense objects and organs), its morally neutral nature, and its five omnipresent mental factors. He clarifies Cittamātra’s two subschools: the True Aspectarians (who assert eight collections of consciousness) and the False Aspectarians (who assert six but still affirm that all phenomena are merely mind). The teaching includes extended Q&A on why we cannot access the Alaya Vijñāna at present, how it relates to karma and free will, and what it becomes upon Buddhahood (mirror-like wisdom). Suitable for serious students with some grounding in Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 07032017CITTAMATRA.mp3
UUID: 5940cce3-2e58-4b2a-90ac-0114dd7adc69
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,422
So the Chitamatra school specifically explains in detail the mind bases of all of the Alaya Vijñāna. And the question which arises is what is the purpose or the goal of these teachings on the Alaya Vijñāna. These teachings are propounded to counter the view of both Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika according to which exterior phenomena are merely established on the basis of partless or indivisible particles. Now this viewpoint is not accepted by Chitamatra and it is counter this that it propounds a view of the Alaya Vijñāna. So then do phenomena which are established in division on partless particles exist?
They do appear and they appear as a result of the exhaustion of the karmic imprints which are implanted within the Alaya Vijñāna. Now within the manifold subdivisions of consciousness, As you may know, it will be covered later, consciousness can be subdivided into one collection, six collections, seven, eight, nine collections. The most widely known is the six fold subdivision of consciousness. Where precisely does the Alāyavijñāna fit? So is Alaya Vijñāna included within the five sensory consciousnesses or the consciousnesses of the five gates?
Obviously not because they are not stable consciousnesses and for instance we know that the five sensory consciousnesses cease during deep sleep. Then if Alaya Vijñāna was included within the five sensory consciousnesses, it would cease during the state of deep sleep and as a result exterior form would disappear as well. Then is the mind basis of all the Alaya Vijñāna included within the sixth consciousness, mental consciousness? No. Because mental consciousness as well is interrupted or ceases during both deep sleep sleep and the state of unconsciousness or coma.
Then if the Alaya Vijñāna were included within the mental consciousness, it would within mental consciousness, it would cease to exist during those states. As a result, there would be no ground for the karmic influence it bears and we would have numerous unfortunate consequences. So where precisely do we have to put the Alāyavijñāna? It is an extremely stable mind since it must bear the karmic imprints. And it is for this reason that the Lankavatara sūtra says this foundation is an extremely subtle and difficult one precisely because Alaya Vijñāna is a subtle and difficult mind to understand.
Then each one of us in this room has his or her own Alaya Vijñāna, but we are unable to access it or use it. So I should at present point out since we’re studying Chitamatra that there were two subschools of Chitamatra, the True Aspectarians and the False Aspectarians. The two Aspectarians are the disciples of Acharya Vasubandhu and so forth. They accept an eightfold collection of consciousness, but the False Aspectarians are the disciples of Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti and so forth, and they assert a sixfold subdivision of consciousness. So therefore, what precisely is the Alaya Vijñāna?
It is not the five sensory consciousnesses, and it is not the mental consciousness. Can you say that it is a consciousness? Yes. Because it is included within the eightfold subdivision of consciousnesses. In addition to the Alaya Vijñāna, there is also self grasping, which is technically called the afflicted mind.
So there are numerous commentaries on the root verses of the Saṃgraha, and I’ll translate for you some sections in due course. Pundarika Rinpoche’s commentary, there’s a commentary from Serdogpa, there are numerous commentaries. One of the core debates is on the nature of the Alāyavijñāna and whether to be a Chitamatran, you necessarily must assert an Alāyavijñāna. Now as was mentioned, the False Aspectarians are Chittamatrans which do not assert an Alaya Vijñāna, so it’s a bit awkward. But if one examines, one can find that all Chittamatrans seem to assert something similar to an Alaya Vijñāna which corresponds to their subtle fundamental mind.
So as you know, the Alaya Vijñāna is asserted in Chitamatra to be truly established. And it is precisely hinging on debates of this nature, Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen, in the text on the difficult points of mind basis basis of all on page one of your transcript says, teaching clearly mind, basis of all, the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijnaptimatrata whereas Buddha Śākyamūni in the Lankavatara sūtra teaches that the mind, the basis of all, is both subtle and difficult. The first point to understand is that we can use or utilize the five sensory consciousnesses. And then in addition to these, we can utilize the mental consciousness which is involved in terminological designations on the basis of the sensory consciousness. This is blue, this is green, this is yellow, sorry, and so forth.
But we are completely unable to use these subtle minds such as the mind bases of all. At present, our state is such that if we do not use the sensory consciousnesses, if they are interrupted, we immediately fall asleep. Then we obviously have no capacity to use subtle minds. I suspect the reason for which Ārya Asaṇga asserts in the Mahayanasangraha that the mental consciousness is interrupted in deep sleep or in the state of unconsciousness is precisely because of this relation between the mental consciousness and sensory consciousness.
Otherwise, there’s no real reason for this assertion. Now moving onwards with the presentation of the mind basis of all, there is a twofold subdivision of the mind basis of all into supporting and supported mind basis of all. You have the translation of the root text. Then you should watch it. You should read it.
Page three, stanza two. I assert it within the two definitions and so forth. So this answer reads, I assert that within the two definitions, the definition of basis of all being subdivided into supporting and supported has two aspects. The first verse within the two definitions refers to the two definitions of the mind basis of all and of the afflicted mind. Being subdivided into supporting and supported, this a supporting mind basis of all and the supported mind basis of all.
The supporting mind basis of all is the actual mind basis of all. The supported mind basis of all are the karmic imprints implanted in the mind basis of all. So here in as much as the mind basis of all is a mind, the mind basis of all, which is the foundation, the supporting mind basis of all is subdivided into form, object of observation, aspect, nature, and associates. Now within this fourfold subdivision of the mind basis of all, which is supporting or the supporting mind basis of all, the first subdivision, Object of Observation has three subdivisions. It is subdivided into objects, sentient beings and karmic imprints.
The objects include the five sensory objects, forms, sounds, smells, tastes and tactile sensations. Sentient beings include the sensory consciousnesses and karmic imprints, the variety of karmic imprints including the karmic imprints of the ignorance grasping at itself. Now here obviously when we speak of the sensory consciousnesses, the sensory consciousness qua sensory consciousnesses are not sentient beings. It’s the sensory consciousnesses included within the mental continuum of a sentient being which qualify. The second subdivision of the supporting mind basis of all is aspect.
Aspect can be presented as the five sensory objects as well as the five sense organs. Now the mind basis of all does not ascertain these aspects nor is it able to induce certainty regarding these aspects. It is an inattentive mind. Then please, while Geshela teaches these topics, follow carefully the English translation of the root text On page three, we have the second paragraph, the second stanza. Now regarding the third characteristic of the supporting mind basis of all its nature, its nature is neither virtuous nor non virtuous, it is neutral.
Now the fourth subdivision of the topic, the supporting mind basis of all is the associates or the companions of this mind. These refer to the mental factors associated with it. And five and only five mental factors, the omnipresent five mental factors are always associated with the Alāyavijñāna. These are sensation, discrimination, intention, mental application and contact. The other mental factors such as concentration are never associated with the Alāyavijñāna.
Now in as much as the supporting mind basis of all is a mind, we must be able to posit the four aforementioned components of this mind, its object of observation, its aspect, its nature, and its associates. What is its object of observation? What is its aspect? What is its nature? What is associated with Then the Alaya Vijñāna is present within the mind stream of every single one of us in this room, but we are totally unable to use it at present.
In addition, the Alāyavijñāna has no relation whatsoever with the six collections of consciousness, it is separate from them. Then I would like you at present during a couple of minutes to reflect carefully on these four characteristics of the mind basis of all, its object of observation, its aspect, nature and associates and after this ask your questions. Mhmm. Then please generate the requisite motivation and meditate during a couple of minutes. Then ask your questions at present.
So it’s a very good question. Upon attaining Buddhahood, what does the Alaya Vijñāna become? It becomes the mirror like wisdom from within the five wisdoms. Okay. So this is my doubt.
I I don’t understand the assertion that the Alaya Vijñāna is unable to be accessed by us when the supporting mind, basis of all, has all you know has objects of observation that we obviously are in contact with. We can understand that the mind is neutral, we can understand the associates, we can understand the five sensory objects and five sense organs and that we have inattentive minds. So how come it is said that the Aliyah Vizhnana is a subtle and difficult mind to understand? So it would be odd to say that no one understands the Alaya Vijñāna, but beginners such as ourselves do not even though I have presented to you its fourfold subdivision in terms of object of observation, aspect, nature and associates. Eventually when one gains the realization of what Chitamatran’s call non duality or inner emptiness, then at this point one does indeed gain an understanding of Alāyavijñāna.
But at present we do not have an ascertainment by a valid cognizer of Alaya Vijñāna. Yes, sorry. I was going to ask a similar question, and now I think I’m pretty confused because I don’t understand what you meant when you said we can’t access the at the moment. Because according to, isn’t that the way the mind perceives objects? Isn’t what the way?
Isn’t the what gives rise to the seeds in the gives rise to? So if you are asking who basically is the actor, the actor, excuse me, in the process whereby the sensory consciousness is perceived sense objects, then the actual actor if you investigate is karma. Previously accumulated karma which implants the karmic imprints within the mind basis of all. Karma is a subtle topic. So as I said in Abhidharma, the various worlds arise or are generated from karma.
Then the topic of the ālāyavijñāna abuts eventually to the topic of karma. So do you understand at present that we have five sensory consciousnesses within our mind stream and that the mental consciousness we have is connected to the sensory consciousnesses or not? Good. Very good. Oh, yeah.
Yeah. Uh-huh. My pleasure. Hey, Another another question? Hello, Gesha.
Was just wondering because Cittamātra says that everything exists through exhaustion of I’m what? Everything exists through exhaustion of karmic imprints. So I’m just wondering where does the free will stand? Does that mean, before we actually make a decision because of karmic imprints we have stored in this mind basis of all, that result is predetermined. So that’s not quite what I said, but yours is a good question.
What precisely is the purpose or the import of the Chitamatra view? It is to counter the views of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika who are certain that exterior phenomena are merely or exclusively established on the basis of indivisible particles. Cittamātra says no, exterior phenomena do appear, but they exist as a result of the exhaustion of the karmic imprints implanted within the mind basis of all. But you have to examine carefully because clearly, if everything is a result of karma and karmic imprints, then indeed, there is no freedom. So why do we say that Ārya Asaṇga is a pioneer of the Cittamātra system.
He is a pioneer because he pioneered countering the assertions of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrantikas regarding of exterior phenomena as being constituted of indivisible particles. And to counter this, Asaṇga taught that phenomena occur as the manifestation of the exhaustion of karmic imprints. But this is something we have to examine from our own side. And now that that’s all that has come up. Yep.
Okay. So my question is about the central argument of Chittamatrans is the Alaya Vijñāna. And so with all due respect to Dharmakīrti and other of the False Aspectarians, how on earth do they get to be part of Chitamatra? This is very good. You understood precisely.
There’s food for thought here. Yes, you understood precisely the crux of the argument. Indeed, although Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti are considered to be Chittamatrans and are called false Aspectarian Chittamatrans, they do not accept the existence of an Alaya Vijñāna or of eight collections of consciousness. They accept six collections of consciousness and they also do not accept the existence of three final vehicles. On the other hand, the two Aspectarians which include Vasubandhu and Maitreya, I don’t know the Sanskrit for this one, assert both the existence of the eight collections of consciousness and the existence of three final vehicles.
Now this is something we’d examine in detail because the False Aspectarians still assert that all phenomena are merely of the nature of mind. Okay. Next question. So at present, could you please start discussing by pairs the purpose of the assertion of the Alaya Vijñāna by the Chittamatrans as well as the fourfold division of the presentation of the Alaya Vijñāna into object of observation, aspect, nature, and associates. And this is taught on page three of your good text and also Gyaltsab Je’s commentary pages nine, ten, and the beginning of page 11.
Okay. Thank you. Two, two, three, I think. Two, two, three, three, four, maybe.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Why is the Alaya Vijnana (mind basis of all) described as a subtle mind that is difficult to understand?
It would be odd to say that no one understands the Alaya Vijñāna, but beginners do not understand it, even after being given its fourfold subdivision in terms of object of observation, aspect, nature and associates. Eventually, when one gains the realization of what the Chittamatrins call non-duality or inner emptiness, one does gain an understanding of the Alaya Vijñāna. At present, however, we do not have an ascertainment of it by a valid cognizer.