TBI Recordings

54 min · 2,230 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 54-minute talk on Cittamātra philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the subtle distinction between karma that propels continued rebirth in saṃsāra and virtue or non-virtue that does not. He begins by explaining the fourfold classification of seeds from classical Buddhist texts, then focuses on the key practical question: does all the virtue and non-virtue we ordinary beings accumulate necessarily become karma that compels future rebirth, or not? Drawing on Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo, Geshe-la shows that virtue motivated by genuine rejection of saṃsāra does not become propelling karma because it aims at liberation, not cyclic existence. He then raises a profound counterpoint: while ārya beings (those with direct insight into emptiness) accumulate no propelling karma, Buddhist texts say they can accumulate negative actions without those becoming propelling—a puzzle the teacher invites students to examine carefully through meditation and discussion.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 08082017cittamatra.mp3

UUID: df205efe-3ed9-4a77-8c61-fac9165aa276

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,226

Now within the division of seeds, we have at present in the root text that which is taught in the following stanzas, the four aspects of seed, the common, the uncommon, those with sensation, and those without. In brief, this division of seeds can be subdivided into two common and uncommon seeds. Common seeds are the seeds which we share, which infuse our mind basis of our all and create the exterior realm of the environment. And the second subdivision of seeds, the uncommon seeds referred to in stanza 21 are those seeds which create the essence. In other words, sentient beings, as you remember, there is a subdivision of the universe into the vessel of the environment and the essence of sentient beings.

In addition, this first reason is presented in terms of seeds which are endowed with sensation in the last verse of stanza 21 those without sensation. Seeds which are endowed with sensation refer to those seeds of sentient beings. And regarding examples for the seeds without sensation, the last verse of stanza 21, These are the common seeds which are accumulated by persons, in other words, sentient beings, and create or establish the universe which they commonly perceive. So here, in this fourfold subdivision of seeds in stanza 21, the two first subdivision is synonymous with the subdivision in the two last. Specifically, common seeds, in other words, the first subdivision is synonymous with the fourth, seeds without sensation, and uncommon seeds are synonymous with the third, seeds with sensation.

Now, topic of seed is a very profound one in which one could enter in great detail if one had time, but what really is important is the threefold subdivision of seeds presented last Tuesday in Stanza 20. Moreover, the three imprints of manifest verbalization of the views of the self and of the limbs of existence, especially the seeds of the limbs of existence. Now the imprints of the limbs of existence, the third in the threefold division in stanza 20 refer to the imprints which give rise to an impelling karma, impelling cyclic existence, and this therefore refer to imprints, which give rise to virtuous and non virtuous rebirths. Now here, the imprints of the limbs of existence which impel cyclic existence are of particular concern to us here. And one topic which Geshe-la would like to address is in our own cases, in the virtue and the non virtue which we accumulate.

Can we say that all the virtue and non virtue which we accumulate becomes or necessarily is imprints which impel the limbs of existence or not? So in other words, in your opinion, the virtuous and sinful karma which we have accumulated, both the virtuous ones which are present within our mind stream and the non virtuous ones which are present within our mind stream as well, do they all become imprints of the limbs of existence or not? So in our own cases, we are all ordinary beings. Geshe-la cannot say for us, but for himself, certainly, he is an ordinary being. And the question which is being asked is, is all of the virtuous and non virtuous karma which we ordinary beings accumulate necessarily does it necessarily give rise to imprints of the limbs of existence which impel cyclic existence or not?

This topic is both important and profound. I would say no, all the karma we create is part of the So what counter example do you give? You found something, you know. You have to give a counter example. Okay.

If I I’m gonna start talking about that. It’s not just a matter of what you think. If I am to get angry because I stubbed my toe Mhmm. That anger will arise in my mind and create a karmic imprint. Uh-huh.

But that karmic imprint is not strong enough to lead to a future life. This is what has to be examined. Okay. So the way to look at it is as follows. In our mind stream, there is virtuous karma.

Now within that virtuous karma, there is impelling virtuous karma which will impel a future happy rebirth. It is previous impelling virtuous karma which led us to where we are now. So in our mind stream, there is virtuous karma arisen from engaging in generosity, from protecting ethics, from practicing forbearance. There is contaminated virtuous karma. So the question here is, in our mind stream, is there something which is virtuous karma, but which is not impelling virtuous karma?

And here, the distinction between contaminated and non contaminated karma hinges on the motivation. What is motivated by the ignorance grasping at a self is contaminated. What is not is not. So Geshe-la is asking you, is all virtuous karma in our mind stream impelling virtuous karma or not? If not, why?

And the counter example? For example, please. Someone who finds finding enlightenment or goes to a pure land. Sorry? Someone who goes to a pure land.

It’s good there’s rationale to your answer. The problem is that it’s far from clear that there is virtuous karma leading to rebirth in a pure land in our mind stream. Because Buddhist texts say that virtuous karma leading to rebirth in a pure land is necessarily uncontaminated. In other words, only exists in the mind stream of an ārya being, which we are not. Obviously Geshe-la’s explanations are overwhelmingly presented from the standpoint of sūtra.

Now, the example, which Geshe-la was asking you for is actually given in Lamrim Chenmo, in which Je Tsongkhapa says that actually if one reflects repeatedly on the faults of cyclic existence, eventually a very profound rejection of cyclic existence arises within one’s mind, and this turns into an aspiration for liberation. Now that motivation enables us to accumulate large amounts of virtuous karma, which Je Tsongkhapa says, is not impelling virtuous karma because it does not lead to rebirth in cyclic existence. Existence. Do you understand? Likewise, another counter example is the following.

If one were to investigate selflessness repeatedly without realizing selflessness by means of a valid cognizer, just repeated investigation. Then the mental factors which are similar to that wisdom, which is investigating selflessness are said not to be karmas which give which are impelling karmas. So you therefore understand that in our mind stream, there is virtuous karma which is not impelling virtuous karma. Specifically, all the virtuous karma which arises out of a motivation striving for liberation, obviously cannot be impelling karma because striving for liberation and impelling karma are contradictory. So says very explicitly in that when through repeatedly investigating the faults of cyclic existence, the marvels of saṃsāra, in other words, the qualities of cyclic existence hold no longer any attraction for us.

We accumulate vast collections of merit, and that is what Je Tsongkhapa is alluding to. These become the causes for liberation, and becoming the causes for liberation, they cannot be the causes for cyclic existence. And now perhaps you understand better what is necessary for something to be an impelling karma, impelling cyclic existence, the conditions which are required. Do you understand? What are the conditions required for something to be impelling karma?

Motivation founded in the ignorance grasping at a self. So it’s obvious that as we start to reflect on the faults of cyclic existence indirectly within our mind stream, the ignorance grasping at a self decreases. So in other words, impelling karma exists only within the mind stream of ordinary beings. It does not exist within the mind stream of ārya beings. And you probably understand now, after last time’s explanations, what an ārya being is.

An ārya being is a being on the path of seeing or the path of meditation. The path of seeing is a path on which one sees directly emptiness as it is, as if one were to see it with one’s eyes. And the path of meditation is the path during which one applies the antidote to innate grasping at a self. So here, the boundaries for the accumulation of impelling karma range from being an ordinary being all the way up to just before the attainment of the state of an ārya being. However, Lamrim Chemo says that even though ārya beings do not accumulate impelling karma, ārya beings do accumulate non virtuous karma.

Why? Certainly for ourselves, accumulating non virtuous karma would mean accumulating impelling karma, probably. But Lamrim Chenmo says that Ārya beings accumulate non virtuous karma, or can accumulate non virtuous karma without accumulating impelling karma. Do you understand? Everyone?

You understand that ārya beings can accumulate non virtuous karma, but do never accumulate impelling karma. Alright, alright, everyone. So you do understand the basic statement here, which is that ārya beings can accumulate non virtue even though they cannot accumulate impelling karma. Now they’re not accumulating impelling karma is well known. It is said in Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakośa of Vasubandhu, he who sees the truth is no longer impelled.

However, says that Ārya beings do accumulate non virtuous karma. How do they accumulate non virtuous karma? Is it possible for an ārya being to generate non virtuous karma through the wrong view? Perhaps they have a nihilist view, so they’re still focusing on emptiness, but they’re tending towards nihilism. So we have to reflect on this carefully.

It is said that aryas accumulate or can accumulate non virtuous karma. How? And that non virtuous karma never becomes impelling non virtuous karma. Through self-cherishing. For an ārya being, an ārya being can accumulate the non virtuous karma of killing someone but with the motivation of protecting others rather than being a self grasping motivation.

So it’s for each of you to think about. So here, what is being said is that if an ārya being can accumulate non virtuous karma, and that non virtuous karma is not impelling karma, then that non virtuous karma cannot be motivated by the ignorance grasping at a self. So it is not non virtuous karma motivated by ignorance. So obviously, what you should think about is if such an Ārya being can accumulate non virtuous karma, which is not impelling karma, can such a being accumulate the karma of killing at all? Let us now meditate during a couple minutes on the following topic.

First, the mode of accumulation of impelling karma. And second, the fact that it is said that Ārya beings accumulate or can accumulate non virtuous karma, but never accumulate impelling karma. Then if this is so, can the non virtuous karma an Ārya being accumulate include the karma of killing another human being. If it does include such karma, that would mean that the karma of killing another human being would not be impelling negative karma, which is very odd. Okay.

Please open the prayer page one. So here therefore, for impelling karma to be accumulated, it necessarily must be accumulated motivated by an ignorance grasping at a self. It is motivated by the ignorance grasping at a self that impelling karma is accumulated. Now regarding the accumulation of both contaminated and uncontaminated virtuous and non virtuous karma, both are accumulated in dependence on a core motivation of ignorance grasping at a self. When it is said that non virtue can be accumulated by an ārya, this is evidently not impelling karma.

Therefore, it is not accumulated under the influence of the ignorance grasping at a self. Then, how then is it possible to give an example of this non virtuous karma in the mind stream of an Ārya being? If we say that the non virtuous karma of killing is present within the mind stream of an Ārya being, killing a human being, then to kill a human being, the motivation of anger is probably necessarily present. Then if anger is present, how can we say that ignorance grasping at a self is not present? Just one question please.

There is the story of one of Buddha’s previous lives, Buddha Śākyamūni’s previous lives when he was an Ārya Bodhisattva and he was on a boat I think and there was a very bad man and he decided he had to kill him because he knew that the man’s motivation was to kill an enormous number of the people, if not all of the people on the boat. So he killed him, but he was a bodhisattva at that point. It’s difficult to give examples of non virtuous karma which are not impelling non virtuous karma. And regarding the example Natalie gave, we have to examine whether at that period, Buddha was an Ārya being or not. Okay.

Okay. Okay. That’s okay. So during the discussion session, Geshe-la, I would like you to analyze the following topic. As was taught for karma to be impelling karma, it necessarily must be motivated by, the ignorance grasping at a self.

Now, it is said that in the mindstream of an ārya being, there is the accumulation of non virtuous karma, which is not impelling karma. And, Geshe-la, I would like you to discuss how this is possible, and can one say that in the mind stream of an ārya being, the karma of murder can be accumulated or not? So please, no more than, not more than four, preferably three or two groups of three or two. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top