1 h 9 min · 3,309 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 69-minute session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen offers a systematic commentary on the ālaya-vijnana, or mind-basis-of-all, drawing from Tsongkhapa’s presentation in Cittamātra Buddhist philosophy. He structures the teaching around four subdivisions of the ālaya-vijnana — object of observation, aspect, nature, and associates — focusing here on the object of observation. The core doctrinal point concerns why sense organs and sensory objects appear to the ālaya-vijnana of beings in the desire and form realms, but not to that of formless-realm beings. Geshe-la works through key verses from the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra and walks students carefully through Tsongkhapa’s logical analysis: he explains how karmic imprints planted in the mind-basis-of-all ripen to produce both sensory consciousnesses and their objects, and shows why a formless-realm being could not possess sense organs or sense-objects without contradicting the fundamental characteristics of that realm. The session includes extended Q&A exploring how the ālaya-vijnana apprehends without ascertaining, and whether emptiness appears to advanced practitioners in formless meditation. Pitched at serious practitioners with prior Buddhist study or Cittamātra initiation.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 11042017cittamatra.mp3
UUID: fa3fb3be-7a88-4070-9b8c-953a61b2dbf1
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,307
Mhmm. So first, the handout you received is the extension of Khensur Rinpoche’s commentary on the material we cover. And then Geshela says regarding the topic of the Alaya Vijñāna, which we are studying in the Tsongkhapa’s treatise. The way to proceed is to study the four subdivisions of the Alaya Vajnana, which are the object of observation, the aspect, the nature, and the associates. At present, what is being presented is the object of observation.
The remaining three subdivisions would be presented in sequence. So at present, what is being explained within the fourfold topics of the Alāyavijñāna is a topic of the object of observation. Now regarding the definition of the Alāyavijñāna, this will be presented later within the third of the fourfold subdivision. As you remember, we have object of observation aspect nature within the nature subdivision. So in a sense, the Alāyavijñāna is the principal uncommon feature within the eightfold presentation of consciousness specific to some Cittamātra schools, it is important for you to know the source, the initial source of this, which is to be found in a shloka, a stanza of the Saṃdhinirmocana Sūtra beginning with the lines, the base of maturation.
And on the this stanza, Ārya Asaṇga and the other great Cittamātra scholars have drawn. So please take the root text of Je Tsongkhapa, the Root of the Difficult Points of Mind Basis of All, page three. The second paragraph below one one one four. Were this not so, a formless one would not have gone beyond the discrimination of form, and it would ensue that it would be on a ground endowed with form. Since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists.
So obviously, I work on the assumption that you have understood the meaning of the previous stanza on which this hinges. Now the first verse of this stanza, were this not so, a formless one, is to be understood as follows. A formless one refers to a being of the formless realm from within the three realms, the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm. Now, the crux of this stanza is that a being of the formless realm would become a being of the form realm if this were true. So the first words of the first verse, were this not so, refer to the points made in the previous stanza, as to both apprehended factors of basis of all, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses and are imputed terminologically by the sixth, they are determined in both realms, which mean that in both realms, the two lower realms, the realm of desire and of form, phenomena are apprehended by the five sensory consciousnesses, and thereafter, there is a mental imputation which proceeds.
This only occurs in the two lower realms, the desire and the form realm. It does not occur in the formless realm. Were this so? Other stanza goes on. So the words were this not so, in the stanza we are studying, you do understand refer to the fact that the previous stanza states that phenomena appear to the five sense consciousnesses, and are imputed by the mental consciousness only for of beings of the desire in the form realm.
Do you understand the meaning of the previous stanza that we covered last time? What does it means? To understand? Okay. That’s exactly it, and there is a meaning of the previous stanza we studied as to both apprehended factors and basis of all, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses and are imputed terminologically by the sixth, they are determined in both realms.
So it is critical to understand this, we must understand the meaning of these two stanzas, and on this basis we can proceed. And at that point, we can investigate the mode of exhaustion of the karmic imprints, give rise respectively to the sense organs and to the experienced sense objects for beings of the two lower realms. Then this is the crux of what is being explained here. So on the one hand, this is really quite a fantastic presentation. On the other hand, it is quite odd.
What is being said, as you remember, as was stated in the text, is that to Alayavijnanas of the desire and the form realm, both sensory organs and sense objects appear, but they do not appear to Alayavijnanas of the formless realms. Then why is this the case? This you have to understand. So here, you must understand that it is not the case that it is somehow forbidden for sense organs and sense objects to appear to the Alaya Vijnanas of the formless realms, and it is allowed for them to appear to the Alaya Vijnanas of the desire and the form realms. Chitamatras, just like Vaibhāṣikas, Sautrantikas, and so forth, as propounders of tenets, accept and rely on logic.
Therefore it is not a case of things being forbidden or allowed, and somehow maybe the law of the state would forbid objects and sense organs from appearing to the Alaya Vijñāna of the formless realm. The question is more, why is this not possible? So this is what one means by studying, literally looking at text in Tibetan. One must analyze a topic and reflect on it. Now as far as the desire realm, all of us in this room are beings of the desire realm, and therefore, what is being stated is that both sense objects and sense organs appear to our ālaya vijnanas.
This is also the case for beings of the form realm, which is a higher realm, but not higher physically, higher mentally than ours, in which certain aspects of form do appear. However, for beings in the formless realm, which is a realm yet higher, nothing neither sense organs nor sense objects appears to the ālaya Vajnana. Then it would be ideal if you could memorize all of this text, root of mind and basis of all of Je Tsongkhapa, but if you are unable to do so, I would ask you to at least memorize these two stanzas below one one one four, the one starting with as to both, and the one starting with were this not so. This is not difficult to do. Then you can reflect on the meaning, which is given in the commentaries.
The first is, do you understand the meaning of the first stanza as to both apprehended factors etcetera. Do you understand? What it means? What does it mean? It’s more accurate to say that within the objects of appearance of the Alaya Vajnana of the desire and the form realm, there are both sense objects and sense organs.
But that these are absent within the appearing objects of the Alaya Vajnana of the formless realm. So the way to look at it is as follows. Whatever appears to the sensory consciousnesses of a being of the desire or the form realm necessarily appears to the ālaya vijnana of that being, and whatever appears to these sensory consciousnesses is also on the receiving end of a process of imputation by the mental consciousness of that being, which also appears to the Alaya Vijñāna of that being. In addition, whatever appears to the Aliyah Vajnana of that being, appears to the sensory consciousnesses or to the mental consciousness of that being. So you have a process of to-ing and fro-ing between these groups of consciousnesses.
However, none of this is true for the Alaya Vajnana of the being of the formless realm. Why is this the case? Now, please memorize the fourfold division of the topics of the Alaya Vijñāna, the object of observation, the aspect, the nature and the associates. So within these four, which is being explained now? So in the stanza, which is being commented, were this not so, a formless one would not have gone beyond the discrimination of form.
These two verses refer to the fact that if it were not the case that the objects of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna were restricted to sense organs and sense objects within the two lower realms alone, and if this occurred in the formless realm as well, then such a being of the formless realm would become a being of the form of the desire realm, and the syllogism is as follows. The subject, a being of the formless realm, it follows that it is a being of one of the realms in direct form, because form appears to its Alaya Vijñāna. And this is the case because the two final verses of this stanza, since appearing since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists, can be understood as follows. Consciousness here can simply be understood as referring to the five sensory consciousnesses, and apart from the appearance of form to those five sensory consciousnesses due to the extinction of the karmic imprint in the Alaya Vijñāna, there is no form. For this to occur, it is necessary for the sensory consciousnesses to exist.
For the sensory consciousnesses to exist, sense organs are required, which would mean that the being of the formless realm would have sense organs. Do you understand? So the meaning of these two important lines at the end of the stanza, since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists, is as follows. Consciousness, as was said, refers to the five sensory consciousnesses, and the appearance of form as form to these sensory consciousnesses occurs when a karmic imprint implanted within the Alaya Vijñāna reaches its exhaustion and gives rise simultaneously both to the sensory consciousness perceiving the object and to the object perceived. The meaning of this stanza since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists.
And therefore here, according to Cittamātra, there are only two tenable views, Either one asserts in keeping with Vaibhāṣika and Sautrandika that exterior phenomena are established as being constituted of or indivisible particles, but this is a viewpoint which faces a large scale refutation based on logic. And when refuted, according to Chitamatra, the only tenable viewpoint is their own viewpoint, according to which exterior excuse me, phenomena do exist, but they exist only as manifestations of the mind within. So here there is no rush, no hurry, this is not something which we will be able to understand rapidly. We will not understand easily or rapidly that the condition for exterior phenomena arises in dependence on karmic imprints implanted in the mind basis of all or the Aliyah Vajnana, and that these karmic imprints in turn arise in dependence on a previous consciousness. An example will make this clear, in the self same way, if as if when we look at the light of a lamp, an oil lamp, that light which is necessary to read a text, or for that matter the light of a window, needs to have a source, an origin.
Likewise, when we investigate phenomena, it is in dependence on the arising of a sensory consciousness from the extinction of a karmic imprint within the Aliyah Vajnana that in turn the condition of the exterior appearance of a form occurs. And now in dependence on the appearance of an object to a sensory consciousness due to the extinction of a karmic imprint implanted in the Alaya Vijñāna, a sensation will arise. This can be a pleasant sensation, an unpleasant sensation. We will set neutral sensations aside. If it is a pleasant sensation which arises as a result of the appearance of this object, this pleasant sensation itself is the result of a virtuous karmic imprint deposited in the mind basis of all previously.
Now what we do have to reflect carefully upon is that according to Cittamātra, the Alāyavijñāna of a being in the formless realm has no object of appearance, and in this respect, Chitamatra is different from the other schools. It does not assert necessarily the existence of either an object of observation or an object of appearance for consciousnesses. In the case of the Alaya Vijñāna itself, it proceeds due to previous virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints. Let us therefore at present meditate on these topics during a couple of minutes, after that we will engage in the requisite recitations, and then you can ask your questions. So here some explanations of sensory consciousnesses are required.
If we take the case of the gustatory consciousness, for instance, then whatever the type of water we try to ingest, whether it is sweet, salty, bitter, sour water, We can posit as the sensory consciousness experiencing that taste. We can posit the sensory consciousness experiencing that taste as the gustatory consciousness. Now here, one really should make a distinction between gustatory consciousness and gustatory organ as well, but that is complicated. So the same would be true for the olfactory consciousness or the tactile consciousness, and here it is important to understand that these sensory consciousnesses are unable to perform the type of mental designation, this is short, this is long, and so forth, which the mental consciousness performs. If we were able to exclude mental consciousnesses, then we would be able to isolate sensory consciousnesses.
If it was possible either through drugs or through instrumentation to cause a cessation of mental activity, of the mental consciousness, we would be able to isolate sensory consciousness. At present, we find this difficult to do because we blend them with mental consciousness. So if you take visual consciousness for instance, visual consciousness experiences only color and form. If you close your eyes, you can see there is no such experience. Do you have questions?
Then here, this is a process of interiorization. As we interiorize, bring the minds back inwards, and start developing our mind and focusing it, eventually we reach a level of concentration known as calm abiding. When we continue beyond calm abiding, and basically our mind ceases entirely to rely on exterior physical objects, then at that point, we can say we have probably become a being of the formless realm. You see, for instance, some of us may have had the experiences of deities or gods spirits, but these are still not beings of the formless realm. So I’ve just got a question that sort of follows on from Hiro’s question.
Just firstly, just to clarify that formless being could actually appear as a human, sentient being? No. No. Never. No.
Alright. Because I didn’t think they did, but then the sound the answer sounded like they could look human. So all of us are living in this world known as Jambudvipa. This is a physical world. Then according to Buddhist cosmology, there is a form realm above this, and the formless realms are not material, but they would exist theoretically above this.
One enters the formless realms through ever higher levels of Samādhi or concentration. Yes. So my actual question was, what are what would be examples of objects that appear to the Alaya Vijñāna of the formless realm being? There is no such thing. There are no appearances to the Alaya Vijñāna of a formless realm being.
No worry. Don’t worry. You can can cause you. I am very confused. Why are Probably because I wasn’t here last week and I’m sorry.
I was under the impression that the ālaya vajnana, the mind basis of all, apprehends nothing. That all of the mental factors within it are non manifest, and that it doesn’t it doesn’t act like a cognizing consciousness at all. If that is the case, if if if that is the case, then how do things appear to it? So for the Alaya Vajnana, the being of the formless realm, there’s no object of appearance. As to the object of observation, that’s another question.
In our cases, in other beings of the desire realm, the Alaya Vajnana has an object of appearance, an appearing objects. So the the Alaya Vajnana actually apprehends an object. Are you talking of the of former strength? Yeah. No.
I’m talking about just general. The of our mind apprehends its object. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
So it does apprehend. So so you think it knowledge. Yeah. Yeah. Yes.
Yes. Yes. Yeah. So our Aliyah Vajrayāna apprehends, then the issue of the Alaya Vijñāna of a formless realm’s being, this is a critical point for Chitamatra, nothing appears to it. So I said to Geshela, I think your doubt is that because the Alaya Vijñāna is an inattentive mind, in other words, a mind to which phenomena appear, but is not apprehended, it cannot apprehend its object.
I said, I think that’s your doubt. Yes, that is. So the Alaya Vijñāna is a mind in which its object appears, but which does not ascertain its object. So they arise, but they but they’re not apprehended. You mean Yeah.
Yes. Yes. Yes. If you want to say they don’t apprehend, it’s okay. It the technical term is it’s not apprehend it is not apprehended by a valid cognizer.
Mhmm. Right. Okay. Good. So could one then say that the Alaya Vijñāna is a support for the consciousnesses for the sensory consciousness and the mental consciousness?
Yes. Mhmm. Basically. Yes. I thought pleasant sensations ultimately led to desire and craving and the afflictions.
So why does Chitamatra say they arise from the virtuous Yes, indeed. From a virtuous karmic imprints, pleasant sensations arise, and here we refer to contaminated pleasant sensations, and from contaminated pleasant sensations, the afflictions can arise. So contaminated pleasant sensations. To which of the eight consciousnesses does suffering appear, and what is the mode by which did they appear or it appears? Are you talking of the experience or the appearance of suffering?
The experience of suffering arises principally in dependence on the sensory consciousnesses. I just want to clarify whether the schools above and below Chitamatra say that the objects appear to be in the formless realm. So a formless being is a being into beings phenomena do appear. When you talk of the of a being of the formless realm, then according to Chitamatra, nothing appears to it. This is an uncommon Cittamātra position.
Yep. According to Cittamātra, is the mind basis of all accessible to those doing tantric practice? Prior Is the mind accessible to those doing tantric practice prior to Buddhahood being reached? The experience of non duality, in other words, the experience of the subtle winds and drops would be one you would have according to Chitamatra. Okay, another question?
No, okay. Okay. So just going back to the formless realm, the that being who is in the formless realm is in deep Samādhi meditating on emptiness. So surely, that object of observation, emptiness, has to appear to that being’s Alaya Vijñāna. That’s my doubt.
It’s a good doubt. I would first point out that it is not the case that all beings of the formless realms are in meditative equipoise and emptiness, far from that. There are however beings of the formless realms which are first-grounders, who would therefore be in meditative equipoise on emptiness. However, emptiness is not an appearing object nor does it appear to the Alaya Vijñāna. Okay.
So the topic for discussion today is the following, As has been explained, the object of appearance of beings of the desire and the form realm includes both sense organs and sensory objects. It is not necessarily either sense organs or sensory objects. I assume you understand that. And the object there is no object of appearance of beings in the formless realm. Then today, why there is no object of appearance to the Alaya Vijñāna of beings in the formless realm.
Okay. Thank you. . I think just 4. Please.
Quick. Quick. Not have time. More time.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Jambudvipa Rose-apple Land; dzam bu ling (Tib)
- Of the four continents surrounding Mount Meru in Buddhist cosmology, this is the southern continent where human beings live. The other three continents are Godaniya in the west; Kuru in the north and Videha in the east. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Can a being from the formless realm appear as a human, sentient being in our world?
No, never. We all live in this world, known as Jambudvipa, which is a physical world. According to Buddhist cosmology, there is a form realm above this one, and above that are the formless realms. The formless realms are not material, though they would exist theoretically above this world. One enters the formless realms through ever higher levels of Samādhi, or concentration.
If a formless-realm being is in meditative equipoise on emptiness, must emptiness as the object of observation appear to that being's Alaya Vijñāna?
It is a good doubt. First, not all beings of the formless realms are in meditative equipoise on emptiness, far from it. There are, however, beings in the formless realms who are first-grounders, and these would be in meditative equipoise on emptiness. Even so, emptiness is not an appearing object, and it does not appear to the Alaya Vijñāna.