TBI Recordings

1 h 7 min · 3,117 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 67-minute teaching on Cittamātra (Mind-Only) philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the relationship between karma and karmic imprints, and how imprints are infused into the mind basis of all (ālaya vijnana). He begins by distinguishing between the accumulation of virtuous and non-virtuous karma and their connection to the 12 limbs of dependent origination, then moves into the central question: how does a completed deed become a stored potency that will ripen later as experience? Using examples of killing and anger, Geshe clarifies that the “faulty component” of a motivation—a non-associated compositional phenomenon—lodges in the subtle mind as an imprint when the seven consciousnesses approach cessation. He illustrates this with the image of garlic or onion: the smell remains even after the object is removed. The teaching culminates in a difficult extension: how virtuous imprints, especially uncontrived bodhicitta, are infused when the bodhisattva’s consciousness does not cease. The talk includes extensive Q&A in which students test these concepts against the four divisions of completed karma and other technical frameworks. Pitched at serious practitioners with grounding in Tibetan Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 11072017Cittamatra.mp3

UUID: 87b546ca-4a62-4903-948e-3992d2e16446

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,116

So one makes a distinction between the supporting and the supported basis of all and karmic imprints of the supported basis of all. So most probably the karmic imprints which supported by the basis of all or the seeds which are supported by the basis of all are one and the same. So please focus single pointedly at present. The important point is that these karmic imprints in general can be subdivided into virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints. Now the topic of karmic imprints is directly related to that of karma and causality in the mode of accumulation thereof.

Now this is presented succinctly at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, specifically in the context of the ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues. It is presented much more extensively at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope where it is presented mainly in terms of the two first truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering or in a more extensive form in terms of the 12 limbs of dependent origination. Now this is of great benefit for one’s own practice. And therefore, this topic of the karmic imprints is directly linked with that of the accumulation of karma presented both in a succinct form in the path shared with the being of the small scope and more extensively in the path shared with the being of the middling scope, specifically within the 12 limbs. Now specifically the three first of the 12 limbs are dedicated to the accumulation of karma and the third limb consciousness is the base of infusion of karma.

So this topic of the 12 limbs of dependent origination has been explained many times in-depth at TBI. It will be covered again during the long October weekend in October. If you have the time, it will be very beneficial for you to come. You will then understand the mode of accumulation of karma. Then to enter into this topic in a little bit more deep detail, the third of the 12 limbs, the limb of consciousness would be the mind basis of all of the ālaya vijnana in those schools of tenets which accept the existence of the ālaya vijnana and would be the mental consciousness in the others.

Now here, regarding the karmic imprints or if you prefer the seeds or for that matter, the supported mind basis of all, before explaining karmic imprints, it is necessary to explain the karma whereby or by which they are accumulated. Otherwise, it would be quite odd if one started initially by explaining the vasanas, the vasanas without explaining the karma first. One must therefore explain the origin of both virtuous and non virtuous seeds or imprints. And when one endeavors to explain their origin, one abuts on the concept of karma. So if we for instance take the case of virtuous karmic imprints, then virtuous karmic imprints have an origin which is to be traced in virtuous karma.

Now likewise, non virtuous karmic imprints in as much as they have an origin are related or linked to non virtuous karma. Now for instance, if we take the case of contaminated karma, then it’s unfolding for instance to gain a human rebirth after being a human being would follow the accumulation of the requisite karma. So listen carefully and you will not confuse these topics. So let us take the karma of killing. Let us assume that one human being wishes to kill another human being.

Then that first human being generates the motivation to kill that other human being using whatever means are at his disposal. For instance, it might be a gun, it might be a sword, it might be using drugs or whatever. Then once the other human being dies, there is an element in the motivation of killing which is evil, and that element is what turns into the karmic imprint. Understand? So to repeat, if one human being wishes to kill another human being and generates the motivation to kill that human other human being, then irrespective of the causes and conditions used to deprive that other person of their life, once the other party is deprived of their life, the motivation within the mind of the murderer becomes something which is known as the manifest base, And this manifest base, if you prefer, is an evil or a defective component of the motivation, which becomes the karmic imprint of murder.

It’s probably okay, right? Do you understand? Many person? Now in other words, once one has decided to deprive another person of their life and motivated by that decision, one deprives them of their life, then that manifest or direct base which becomes the karmic imprints is present. This is a defective or evil component of that intention.

That is not to say that that that karmic imprint itself is the mind basis of all. It is not. However, its relation can be said to be similar to that of an onion and its odor. It is when we cut the onion open that the odor manifests. So Khensur Rinpoche used the example of the onion and that’s why Geshe-la would like to use it.

Now here, once the karma has been actually established, Is that karma itself the imprint? No, it is not. Is that imprint the mind basis of all? No, it is not either. So once that karma or that deed of killing has been accumulated, then a component of that karma, which is the karmic imprint, the potency, or if you prefer the imprint, dhikpa in Tibetan, that is what will mature in a future life as suffering.

So here what is important is to understand that this imprint subsists as a component of the karma. It is not related to the mind basis of all. This is a difficult topic which you will not understand at once. One must think about it over and again and then understanding will dawn. So even for those who are good scholars, this topic of how karma is accumulated or how imprints infuse the base of infusion, the mind bases of all, is a difficult topic which one does not understand quickly.

Therefore, don’t rush. Take your time. So here, one is talking about the mind and what is related to the mind, not about form or matter, then this is much more difficult and one must study texts and try to relate them to one’s understanding. So here, therefore, what is infused in the base of infusion is the seed which is the component of the non virtuous karmic imprint. Now, if we wish to present this in terms of the 12 limbs, the base of infusion would be the third limb, either the alia vijnana for the schools which accept it, or the mental consciousness for the schools which do not.

And the karmic imprints would be the second limb, the limb of compositional factors. So now within the schools of tenets which accept only six collections of consciousness and don’t accept the ālaya vijnana, let us take this Svatāntrika Mādhyamika school. So for this Svatāntrika Mādhyamika school, the base of infusion, the third limb, would be the mental consciousness. Now if we take the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school, then the base of infusion is the mere I. But for that matter, the infuser is also the mere I.

So now if we return to our example of murder or killing, then obviously the motivation to murder or to kill is not continually present. So it is after the deed of killing has been performed that a component of that motivation becomes the karmic imprint, and this dwells in the mental continuum or the mind basis of all. The same thing is evident if we take the case of anger. No one is angered continually. Having given rise to anger within our mind stream, a potency is generated and that potency is of the nature of the karmic imprint.

So this example of anger is a very helpful one. Once anger has been generated in our mind stream, at some point, it ceases and we return to a state of peacefulness. However, the fault of having generated anger does not disappear. This fault or this sin needs a support to subsist. Likewise, with virtuous states of mind, virtuous states of mind are not permanent.

When the virtuous state of mind disappears, the virtue which it gave rise to needs a base of infusion, a support. So the same can be said of the example of the onion which Rinpoche gave, has a strong smell and when you throw it out of the vase which contained it, smell remains. Or for that matter with garlic. The smell of a clove of garlic is within the clove. It is when we open the clove of garlic that it is released.

And therefore, returning to our example of killing or murder. Once the intention of killing has been generated, the deed of killing has been performed, then that ceases to exist and as it approaches the end of its existence, its potency must subsist somewhere. The question is, where? And therefore, as the deed dwindles, as is said in stanza 17, as it is manifestly oriented towards ceasing, at that point, the potency or the imprint infuses or is placed. Infuses or is placed in what?

In the mind basis of all. And this is therefore the meaning of Stanza 17. So infusing the supported, the seed basis of all, when the basis infused is manifestly oriented towards ceasing, a potency has been placed. So here, what infuses what infuses are these seven collections of consciousness. What is infused?

What is infused is the mind basis of all. It is when those seven collections of consciousness are manifestly oriented towards ceasing. In other words, when they have dwindled that at that point, the potency of the karma which has been accrued, which is the karmic imprint, is implanted or infused in the mind basis of all. And therefore, in the two last verses of this stanza, manifestly oriented towards ceasing, a potency has been placed as the seven collections of consciousness which are the infusers are manifestly oriented towards ceasing. In other words, as they dwindle and approach the point of disappearance.

At that point, the faulty component or the potency is actually implanted in the mind basis of all. The substantial continuum of these six consciousnesses transforms into a non associated compositional phenomena, which is imprint infused in the mind basis of all. And therefore to repeat, as the seven collections of consciousness, the infuser dwindle and as their own potency weakens, they approach a point where the faulty component which is present turns into a non associated compositional phenomenon, which is the karmic imprints. Then this is infused in the subtle mind which in Cittamātra is the alaya vijnana or the mind basis of all. To give an example, it’s the same thing as infusing a piece of paper with gasoline or oil.

Then as long as the piece of paper is there, the gasoline or the oil is there. When it is eliminated, so are they. So to use Rinpoche’s example of garlic or onion, when we have garlic in a room, then the smell of garlic is present, but when we take the garlic and throw it out, the smell remains. Likewise, even though the karma of killing has been ceased, nonetheless its faulty component remains. This is how the imprints or the seeds are completed or perfected in the mind basis of all.

Then if you reflect on this stanza in the root text on the mind basis of all, it will foster or enhance your understanding. Now, once one has attained the path of accumulation, one has generated uncontrived bodhicitta, and it would be very strange if the continuum of this uncontrived bodhicitta was severed. So how exactly are the virtuous imprints infused independency on bodhicitta? So here, as you remember, the model of infusion of karmic imprints in Cittamātra is that upon the cessation of the seven collections of consciousness as they approach manifest cessation, the karmic imprint is infused. However, if we take the case of a bodhisattva on the first ground, we cannot say that bodhicitta ceases for the karmic imprints to be infused.

So what precisely is happening? This is a very delicate topic. So here in the analysis of the process of accumulation of karma, the question to be asked is whether the accumulator and the experience of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma are necessarily manifest or not. So at present, let us meditate during a couple of minutes on this topic. And if doubts arise in your meditation, write them down.

Obviously, it’s ideal if you have enough concentration to remember them, but otherwise write them down. Okay. For few minutes, please. Please open the paper, page one. We recite one verse with bodhicitta.

Then Geshe-la, we will only take a couple of questions now, please. One question per person and you don’t have to all ask questions, otherwise we’ll waste a lot of time. I’m just trying to reconcile in my mind the four aspects of a completed karma, that is the object, the intention, the act and the completion. The intention being divided into the discriminating motive and the delusion or affliction. Geshe-la said that the motivation was the manifest base which is a defective component.

It’s a defective component of the motivation. How does that fit with the motivation and the affliction in the four divisions of a completed karma? In other words, is the delusion the defective element of the motivation whereas the way Geshe-la presented it was that it’s actually a component of the motivation itself. Don’t know if that makes sense. Chris, you have to summarize that.

You’re going to have to summarize. Okay. So the defective element of the manifest base is the was the motivation that Michel was talking about that turns into the imprint. I’ll transfer as you speak. So given the four divisions of of completed karma, Two aspects of the second that is the intention is motivation and delusion.

The other one being the discrimination. So the motive, is Geshe-la conflating motivation and delusion? General motivation and affliction are not identical. However, in the context of the karma of killing, yes. Yes, that would fit.

Thank you. From now on what I will do because sometimes I simply don’t understand what you’re saying is I will translate simultaneously. Then you’re responsible for what’s understood on the other end. Geshe says you will not understand immediately, so we have to take a lot of questions. This is not an easy topic.

It is one which calls for a lot of investigation. I’m having trouble understanding the faulty component. And so last week you taught, it is the faulty component of anger which leaves an imprint. This to me implies that there are other components to anger. What are these?

So here, the faulty component of anger refers in the context of anger to the same thing as the qualities of a virtuous mind in the context of virtue. It is the defective aspect of anger. It is the sin, if you wish. So I was telling Geshe, your doubt seems to arise from the fact that when we say component of anger, this implies that there are other components. Then the term cha in Tibetan is just a way of formulating things.

It means a defective anger if you prefer. So the example of garlic or the onion makes this very clear. Garlic or onions have a very strong smell, but we would never say that they are their smell. Likewise, anger has a faulty component but we would never say it is that faulty component. The way I’m understanding it is that when the mental factor of anger arises, it is what accompanies it is a non associated compositional phenomenon which is a potency and then when that consciousness which is anger, a mental factor ceases, the potency is what remains and is then implanted as a seed into the ālaya vijnana.

So I’m wanting to confirm if that is a correct Yes, that’s exactly it. So this potency accompanies anger, but it is not anger, then as anger disappears, this potency must remain somewhere. Where does it remain? In the mind basis of all. Okay, so it seems like a similarly, the mental factors arise out of a main mind, they accompany a main mind, but they are not the main mind.

And when they cease, the main mind is abiding and continues. So we can in a similar way think of a mental factor arises, it is accompanied by a potency and when that mental factor ceases, the potency continues. Broadly speaking, yes, but there is a fault in your analysis which is that not all of the infusers are necessarily mental factors. There are also main minds which can infuse karmic imprints into the basis of all. Now the reason for this is we find a passage in the text which refer to the infusers as these seven collections of consciousness and associates.

And associates refer to the mental factors. Seven collections of consciousness themselves are main minds. Now clearly, the mind basis of all itself cannot be an infuser because it is uninterrupted. So at present, Geshe-la, I would like to ask you to discuss the mode of accumulation of karma and the mode of infusion of karmic imprints in the mind basis of all. And to discuss this carefully as was taught so that you understand the basics.

Otherwise, later on, when doubts are presented, you will get very confused. Also regarding the groups, Geshe-la would like to ask you to stop having the big groups you have been having. You should have groups of two or three people for the maximum. Otherwise, when you have large groups, a couple say stay in the group and never say anything and there’s no benefit at all. And please ask your translator questions as he passes through.

Then next week things will become clearer. This is a very difficult topic, the mode of implantation of karmic imprints in the ālaya vijnana. In the monasteries, it’s debated for months to clarify the doubts. Then there’s no hope, obviously, to clarify all the doubts in one evening. So we need mental courage.

Okay. Please. Please. Please.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

When the teaching speaks of the 'faulty component' of anger, does this mean anger has other components? What are they?

The question assumes that speaking of a component of anger implies other components, but this comes from the wording. The faulty component of anger refers to the defective aspect of anger, the 'sin' if you wish, in the same way that the qualities of a virtuous mind relate to virtue. The Tibetan term cha is just a way of formulating things, and it can be understood as a defective anger. Garlic and onions show this: they have a very strong smell, but we would never say they are their smell. Likewise, anger has a faulty component, but we would never say anger is that faulty component.

Scroll to Top