TBI Recordings

59 min · 2,787 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the philosophical foundations of Cittamātra Buddhism’s unique presentation of consciousness in this 59-minute teaching. Rather than accepting the six collections of consciousness standard across Buddhist schools, Cittamātra asserts two additional subtle minds: the ālaya vijnana (mind basis of all) and the afflicted mind, each serving a precise soteriological purpose. He walks students through the definition of the afflicted mind from Tsongkhapa’s root text, examining its four defining characteristics: its object (the mind basis of all apprehended as truly established); its aspect (grasping at a self); its nature (neutral, neither virtuous nor non-virtuous); and its nine associated mental factors (the five omnipresent factors plus desire, pride, ignorance, and the afflicted view). The teaching includes careful analysis of why the ālaya vijnana cannot carry afflictions while the afflicted mind must, probing the relationship between subtle and coarse consciousness through examples of childhood development, sleep, death, and the student’s own mental experience. Pitched at practitioners already familiar with Buddhist philosophical debate.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 12092017Cittamatra.mp3

UUID: 54aef3de-4972-466b-817f-87208d845f8b

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,785

So whereas all schools of tenets teach six collections of consciousness in addition, the Cittamātra school teaches two complementary collections of consciousness, the afflicted mind and the consciousness or mind basis of all. It is important to understand the purpose and the necessity of these two consciousnesses for Chitamatra. So since generally speaking, all schools of tenets apart from Chitamatra assert six collections of consciousness and for that matter, it would seem that the scientific community would be comfortable with that as well. But Cittamātra asserts two additional collections of consciousness, the mind basis of all and the afflicted mind. It’s important to understand why, what the purpose of this is.

So within the four schools of tenets, it is Sautrāntika and Cittamātra which devote a considerable amount of explanation to awareness. In other words, to mind and mental factors. On the other hand, Vaibhāṣika, and for that matter, Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, do not devote a lot of attention to this topic. And this is specifically the case in the works of Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti for Sautrāntika and Asaṇga and Vasubandhu for Cittamātra. Now Prāsaṇgika devotes very little to this.

For instance, Prāsaṇgika asserts that all valid cognizers are necessarily subsequent cognizers. So generally speaking, the six or the eight collection of consciousnesses are overwhelmingly main minds. Little is said about mental factors even though mental factors such as the 51 mental factors are very important. Now there are numerous subdivisions of mental factors. For instance, there’s a presentation of mental factors specific to Vinaya.

Then next year, if circumstances allow and there are no major interferences, Geshela hopes to be able to present first a summarized presentation of Lorig, in other words, topic of awareness, and specifically mind and mental factors, and then link it with the topic of Buddha lineage or Buddha nature. Since this year we will have covered the Cittamātra representation of consciousness. So Geshela had taught Lorig for one year at TBI and had hoped it had stayed in your mind, but it seems wiser to represent it next year again in a summarized fashion over one month. The reason for this is because at present we still have the translator Lobsang Dorje and therefore the circumstances are good for this. Then you seem to be unaware of the fact that things are impermanent and times are hard.

So what is the rationale for the explanation of the eight fold collections of consciousness? It is a distinction between coarseness and subtlety. Specifically, the six consciousnesses, the five sensory consciousness and the mental consciousness are obviously coarse. We know in daily life that they cease. Buddhist texts say they cease, but in reality, this means that they stop to exist at certain moments.

Then, one must postulate subtler consciousnesses. In other words, the seventh collection of consciousness, the afflicted mind, and the eighth, the ālaya vijnana. Whether or not these collections of consciousness are of a similar or different nature filled from the preceding ones is something which must be examined. Now, Svatāntrika Mādhyamika does not explain subtle consciousnesses. It explains mainly the mental consciousness.

What happens when the mental consciousness becomes ever more subtle is an open question. Eventually, it would lead to something of the nature of the ālaya vijnana. Now the alia vijnana itself is simply posited as the basis, and once this has been set, then one can naturally deduce the existence of the kliṣṭamanas. So as minds become more subtle eventually, we arrive at the ālaya vijnana or the mind basis of all, which has five associates. As you remember, the five omnipresent mental factors starting with contact sensation and so forth.

Then if we analyze the afflicted mind, the in addition to these five omnipresent mental factors, it has four additional ones, which are desire, pride, ignorance and the afflicted view. So once one has abstracted from the six coarse consciousnesses, one is left with something subtle, which can be posited as the self, and this is the mind basis of all. And it is precisely at this point that one sees that there is an apprehension of this mind basis of all as truly established and this leads us to an understanding of the afflicted mind. Now the ālaya vijnana, as you remember, has only five associates, five accompanying mental factors. It is not accompanied by afflictions such as desire and so forth.

If it were, then we would not be able to use it, but it is not. If it were, it would become something like the mental consciousness, which is indeed or can be accompanied by mental factors such as desire and so forth. As Dharmakīrti says the afflictions are adventitious. The nature of the mind is clear light. Now here when Dharmakīrti says adventitious in Tibetan, he does not say that the afflictions are adventitious because they are impermanent.

That is trivial. He is asserting something very different, and that leads precisely to the existence of such subtle minds as the ālaya vijnana or the kliṣṭamanas. Likewise, in the Tathāgatagarbha Sutras, it is said, mind does not enter into mind. Its nature is a clear light. Now there are numerous interpretations of these two verses.

The meaning is that the afflictions are adventitious and do not infuse or suffuse the nature of the mind which is clear light. Then since the root text of Je Tsongkhapa and the commentary are translated in English, yes, I would like to encourage you to peruse them carefully and think about them. So in the root text of Je Tsongkhapa, the definition of the afflicted mind is on page five and six of today’s handout. It is in four plus two verses, stanza 32 onwards. The definition of the afflicted mind is a matured component of the basis of all and with the view of the self obscured but neutral with only nine: contact desire and so forth.

And stanza 33 had a period of equipoise on cessation, finally the powerful ones, the arhats. So please focus on the stanzas. Geshela will comment them. It will be quite straightforward. So here, stanza 32, the definition of the afflicted mind.

Afflicted mind is our topic. So definition here is definition, the characteristics or the nature of the afflicted mind. On page six with the view of the self. The view of the self refers to the fact that the afflicted minds apprehends its object, the mind basis of all as self established. Then in on page six, the term obscured in the first verse is a difficult one to understand.

Normally, obscurations refer to the obscurations to liberation and the obscurations to omniscience. However, here, if that were the meaning of obscured as referring to the afflicted mind, then how can we explain that the afflicted mind becomes the wisdom of equality at the level of full enlightenment? So normally, obscurations are subdivided into two. The obscurations to liberation and the obscurations to full omniscience. Now the obscurations to liberation prevent one from attaining liberation.

If that was a meaning here, then how could they prevent one from attaining enlightenment? So what’s your opinion on this topic? On the one hand, kliṣṭamanas proceeds until full enlightenment. On the other hand, it is said to be obscured. So doesn’t matter, just think about it.

But in Je Tsongkhapa’s auto-commentary and the passages were distributed today, you will find that Je Tsongkhapa points out that obscured here refers to the four latter mental factors associated with the afflicted mind. In other words, desire, pride, ignorance, and the afflicted view, which obstruct, in other words, prevent one from attaining liberation. Now on page six, the final term of the first verse is neutral. Neutral here first means stable, but more importantly, it means that this mind which becomes virtuous. This mind here refers to the ālaya vijnana and the kliṣṭamanas which both become virtuous at the level of full enlightenment until that point are neutral.

So the reason for which the afflicted mind is neutral is similar to the reason for which the ālaya vijnana is neutral. If the afflicted mind were not neutral, but let us say virtuous, and at that point, anger become became manifest, how would it be possible for simultaneously a virtuous and a non virtuous mind to be present in the same mind stream? It’s not possible. The same line of reasoning applies to demonstrate that the afflicted mind could not be non virtuous. If it were non virtuous, how would it be possible for a virtuous mind to become manifest at the same time?

Therefore, the afflicted mind is necessarily neutral. So here, one must analyze very carefully the mode of arrival of virtuous and non virtuous minds. What causes and conditions both virtuous and non virtuous minds depend upon to arise. To see, for instance, whether in the continuum of a dog, it is possible for a virtuous mind to be present. And if so, what would be its mode of existence?

Are there virtuous minds within the mind stream of a dog or not? So let’s start with the beginnings. What is the nature of a virtuous mind? Please explain and then on that basis, we’ll check whether they exist in the mind stream of a dog or not. So what’s the nature of virtuous mind?

I would say the nature of a virtuous mind is a mind oriented towards liberation or enlightenment. Obviously, non existent in the mind of a dog, right? Then obviously dogs can never have virtuous minds. Under those circumstances, no. I hope this virtue could extend to compassion.

Compassion. Compassion. Just for example, you know. Give you examples, right? What is the nature, what is the meaning of your choice?

We will try to identify today what virtuous minds are and what non virtuous minds are. Otherwise, how can you answer the question, is a virtuous mind present in your own mind stream? So and the term neutral in the first verse, obviously, is directly linked to the issues of what is virtuous and non virtuous since a neutral mind is average is neither virtuous nor non virtuous. Now, here, Geshela has presented the object of observation of the, which is the alia vijnana, and the aspect of this object of observation, which is that kliṣṭamanas apprehends the ālaya vijnana as established as a self. And the final line of stanza 32, with only nine: contact, desire, and so forth.

Here, contact refers to the five omnipresent mental factors which are also associated with the mind basis of all. In other words, contact, sensation, discrimination, mental application, and intention. And desire and so forth refers to the four afflictions, which are additionally present as associated with the, which are desire, pride, ignorance and the afflicted view. So when we’re speaking of the afflicted view here, it is the view of the disintegrating composite. So within the fourfold division of this topic, which is the object of observation, the aspect, the nature, and the associates, the final verse presents the associates.

There are only nine mental factors associated with the kliṣṭamanas, and you should be able to give them. So at present, you should be able to understand clearly the differences between the mind basis of all and the afflicted mind. The mind basis of all and the afflicted mind have different objects of observation. They have different aspects. Now both are neutral.

However, only the afflicted mind is said to be obscured. The mind basis of all is not said to be obscured. And whereas the mind basis of all has only five associates, the afflicted mind has an additional four associates. And here it is important to analyze carefully why there would be another four associates. So whereas it is self evident that the mind basis of all must have the five omnipresent factors, contact and so forth.

Because without these, a mind cannot operate as a mind. The question is, why does the mind basis of all not have the four additional mental factors which the afflicted mind has? For instance, why does it have desire? So ālāyavijñāna does not have desire as a mental factor. The afflicted mind does.

Why? The afflicted mind has desire as a mental factor because it is a quality of desiring for our self, so that this itself desires for itself. I believe Geshela pointed out previously that the ālaya vijnana, the nature of the mind is clear light. That the nature of the mind is clear light and therefore it cannot have desire and ignorance etcetera as part of it. The ālaya vijnana does not apprehend its object whereas the kliṣṭamanas does apprehend an object and therefore has an object to desire for.

This is very good. All of the reasons you gave were sound ones. So if desire was associated with the ālaya vijnana, then perhaps we would be able to use it. But the ālaya vijnana is a mind we cannot use. Then in the case of the afflicted mind, since desire is associated to it, we have to analyze whether it is a mind which we can or cannot use.

We can see clearly that as we move upwards from very subtle minds to coarser minds, eventually afflictions such as desire and so forth appear. And this fits with our experience growing up. As it were children, no one has strong experiences of anger or remembers them. Then later on there’s a lot. So if we take an infant aged one or two months of age, then any thoughts of anger like that present?

Probably not. Then later on, as years pass, they do appear. Then the same thing is true in the death process. In the death process, the coarse levels of mind progressively disappear and subtler and subtler levels of mind manifest. This is the same thing as in the sleep process in which coarse levels of mind disappear and subtle minds become manifest.

And in turn, when we wake up, it’s the opposite. The subtle minds are covered by the coarse minds. So this is a very helpful way of explaining things. Now, you do understand the similarities and differences between the mind basis of all on the one hand and the afflicted mind on the other hand, don’t you? Whether we can use the afflicted mind or not, that is open to question.

But in brief, the afflicted mind is the subtle grasping at a self. Now Chitamatra does not use this term subtle grasping at a self, but they say afflicted mind, but that’s the meaning. This is an absolutely marvelous topic and then let us at present meditate during a couple of minutes on stanza 32, the definition of the afflicted mind and its characteristics, and then we will have the recitation of the prayers. Open to page one. So what instance can you give of a virtuous mind?

Give an example. One who could avoid in 10 virtuous actions and avoid 10 non virtuous actions. Excuse me, I don’t understand you. Can you repeat? 10 virtuous actions?

10 virtuous actions. It’s strange to give us instance of a virtuous mind to turn virtuous actions. The instance of a virtuous mind. Example. Example.

Of a virtuous mind. Okay. Okay. Another. You gotta be able to give me a sense of virtuous mind.

Very strange. I’m thinking compassion is a virtuous mind. Your thinking must be. Really? Not necessary.

Okay. Okay. The subject great compassion, why is it a virtuous mind? Can you say? You explain It’s a virtuous mind because we’re actually thinking of the welfare of others.

Okay. So what example can you give a non virtuous mind? So why is anger non virtuous? Does it? Produces suffering.

There’s many reasons. So we have to give examples here of virtuous minds on the one hand and non virtuous minds on the other hand. And then in dependence on reasons we can understand why they are virtuous and non virtuous. So the afflicted mind is not a non virtuous mind, right? That’s what you should be thinking about, right?

It’s non virtuous because it’s present all the time. It’s non virtuous because it’s present all the time. At times, virtuous and virtuous minds are also present. And so it cannot be neither virtuous nor non virtuous. So it has to be neutral.

So what Geshela would like you to do is based on the stanza, stanza 32, which gives the nature, the definition of the afflicted mind, Examine its nature and definition and analyze whether it’s virtuous, non virtuous or neutral. Okay. Please for discussion.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top