TBI Recordings

1 h 5 min · 2,699 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 65-minute teaching on the Mind-Only school, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen introduces foundational concepts from Je Tsongkhapa’s Root of the Difficult Points of Mind and Basis-of-All. He establishes why understanding the positing of the person across Buddhist and non-Buddhist philosophical schools is crucial, showing that the distinction between Buddhist and non-Buddhist positions rests not on conduct but on how the person is established. Geshe walks through the basic framework of philosophical systems: result, path, and basis. He then turns to the Mind-Only school specifically, explaining how it identifies the ālaya-vijnana, the mind basis-of-all, as the repository of karmic seeds and imprints, and how this view differs from the earlier Madhyamaka school. The session includes questions from students on consciousness, the relationship between conscious and non-conscious mental states, and the historical development of these schools. Pitched at serious practitioners with some familiarity with Buddhist philosophical categories.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 14022017 Cittamātra.mp3

UUID: a1c25747-ccd4-4778-8559-b923e8d9a193

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,697

So regarding this topic we shall be covering, the root of the difficult points of mind and basis of all which you have as a handout and the auto commentary which I will be turning in next week. These were composed by Je Tsongkhapa and Je Tsongkhapa as you may know lived a short 62, but in those 62 years of life he composed 18 volumes of treatises. It is not so much a number of volumes he composed in his collected works, which matters as the fact that all of these texts were valid authoritative texts and that numerous scholars became his disciples. The majority of Je Tsongkhapa’s treatises were dedicated to Mādhyamika and to deity yoga. Some works were dedicated to the study of the Paramitas and a small number of works to the study of Pramāna Buddhist logic.

He composed a brief treatise on Abhidharma, but it is taught in the Gelug tradition that the great Abhidharma scholar, Scholar, whose great treaties on still exist, relied actually heavily on Je Tsongkhapa, then what exactly this means we do not fully understand and the same is said about Vinaya. And then I do feel that when we present a work of Je Tsongkhapa, it is really bizarre if one doesn’t know when Je Tsongkhapa was born, when Je Tsongkhapa died and how long he lived. So Je Tsongkhapa was born in 1357, this is clear in your text, died in 1419 and lived 62 years of age. Then Je Tsongkhapa was born in present day Amdo in the East Of Tibet and traveled all over Tibet studying with the greatest teachers of his age, Sakya Lamas, Kagyu Lamas and Nyingma Lamas as well. So this treatise, the root of the difficult points of mind and basis of all, is dedicated to the identification of mind basis of all within the eight collections of consciousness.

Now the Cittamātra school of tenets considers that the Alāyavijñāna or the mind basis of all is the instance when one tries to state what the person is. When we speak of persons, this refers both to ourselves and to others. In each case, the standpoint of Chitamatra, the instance is Alāyavijñāna. It is not the case however that one must have become familiarized with tenets to use the term I, we all use in daily language the term I. So the topic of the I is a very strange one because from the moment we wake up in the morning, all of us are focused on our own welfare.

Whether one is a human being or for that matter an animal, we all seek for happiness. Happiness for whom? Happiness for oneself. What is this oneself for which we seek happiness? The I.

Then the existence of I is an experiential given. It is something we all know from experience. However, when we investigate the mode of existence of this I, then things become much more difficult, and this is what the four schools of tenets do. They investigate the mode of existence of the I. Then someone who has not studied tenets, when he or she is asked what is the mode of existence of the I, will probably answer well whatever, I don’t have a clue.

So for those beings who have not yet studied tenets, their life from the moment they wake up in the morning until the moment they fall asleep at night, is a search for happiness for themselves. Then they do not really understand where this I is if you ask them, and will say whatever, I’m not quite sure if it’s in front or behind or where it exists. Those beings who have entered the gateway of tenets then endeavor to identify the mode of existence of this I. Then at present, I would like to ask you to reflect a bit on the meaning, the definition of a person. The definition of a person is to be found in Buddhist texts, but I don’t want to give it to you.

It’s really of no benefit if you just write it down. I’d like you to try to find from your own side the meaning of person. Here it is very beneficial to think along these lines. If we look at the division of the path into the method and the wisdom aspect of the path, then as far as the method aspect of the path is concerned, in other words training in great compassion, in great love, in bodhichitta, but specifically great compassion and great love. Actually, there is no substantial difference between these schools of tenets, and for that matter with non Buddhist religious traditions.

On the other hand, the moment we focus on the issue of the person, what exactly the person is, the mode of existence or establishment of the person, there are major differences. Why is this the case? So this is what I would like you to think about, the distinction between the non Buddhist, Buddhist outsiders, and the Buddhist is posited exclusively in terms of the mode of positing the person. It is not posited in terms of conduct or method. Now why is this the case?

Then I I did want to say to you really from the depths of my mind that what is important to study the Chitamatra view, it is important for you not to waste your time. We have uncommon circumstances here where we have a teacher who can explain the Chitamatra view, and a translator who is a scholar, and who has experience, and who can translate what the teacher says exactly into English. It would be a great pity if you didn’t attend such teachings. Then from your own side, investigate with modern tools how many Buddhist centers there are in the world, and in just how many Buddhist centers in the world have there ever been a presentation of the Chitamatra view in-depth? Now what exactly is a being who enters within the various tenets?

Such a being is called a propounder of tenets, Druptamawa in Tibetan. Now what precisely do we understand by Druptamawa, a propounder of tenets? This can best be explained in terms of basis, path, and result. Now starting with the result, the presentation of the result depends on what? It depends on the presentation of the path.

What in turn does the presentation of the path depend on? It depends on the presentation of the basis. Now what is the meaning here of Druptamawa, probably Siddhantavadi in Sanskrit. A Druptamawa is someone who after this presentation of the result, the path, and the base of his own system, which is established, this is Drupt, the syllable Drupt or Siddh in Sanskrit, asserts that there is nothing beyond this. Ta in Tibetan means boundary, in Sanskrit.

Then the is a propounder of such a position. So for a being to be a propounder of tenets, such a being must propound a result, a path and a base. Then, well this is the meaning of being a propounder of Buddhist tenets. Whether there is necessary necessary entailment. In other words, whether a propounder of Buddhist tenets necessarily propound or a propounder of tenets necessarily propounds all three is a difficult question.

If we take the materialists, the Cārvākas of ancient India, it’s difficult to say they propounded all three. Then if we take scientists and we say that scientists are propounders of tenets, do they propound a basis, path, and result? Perhaps not. Both the Buddhists and the non-Buddhist Tīrthikas, the philosophers of ancient India are propounders of tenets. They propound a base, a path and a result.

In the case of the non Buddhist Tīrthikas, what do they propose as a person? They propose a person who is permanent, literally a person who is a self or an ātman, which is permanent one and independent. So now what would be the definition of a Buddhist propounder of tenets? It would be a person who asserts a personhood which is empty of being permanent one and independent. Now Buddhist proponents of tenets are subdivided into two, Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna, Buddhist proponents of tenets.

Hīnayāna, Buddhist proponents of tenets are Buddhists who accept the existence of exterior objects which are truly established. And propounders of Mahāyāna Buddhist tenets are Buddhists who do not accept the existence of truly established exterior phenomena. Now within the subdivision of proponents of Mahāyāna tenets, we have two schools, Chitamatra and Mādhyamika school. And at present, Geshela will present the Chitamatra school. So last time Geshela explained the first stanza of the root of the difficult points of mind, the basis of all on page one of your text.

The second stanza, I will explain here independence on the utterances of the guru for the sake of healing my memory and teaching clearly mind and basis of all the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijñaptimātrins, teaches both the topic and the purpose of this treatise. So the topic is taught in the last verse of the stanza, the extremely difficult topics of the treatises of the Vijñaptimātrins, and the topics taught are the teachings of the Vijñaptimātrins and specifically And that topic is developed in the third verse, mind and basis of all. Mind here refer refers to afflicted mind. The first part of the third verse teaching clearly indicates that before Je Tsongkhapa’s coming to Tibet, these topics, the explanation of mind basis of all and afflicted mind were not clearly explained. Then the second line is very beautiful, for the sake of healing my memory refers to eliminating forgetfulness within one’s mind.

And the first verse I will explain here, dependence on the utterances of the Guru, clarifies the source of these teachings that was explained last time within the first verse of the text, the wise among the wise, which refers to Ārya Mañjuśrī and to Jetsün Rendawa. The following stanza in the root text after Ārya Nāgārjuna prophesied as upholding the supreme vehicle propounded by the holy speech, spread the supreme vehicle before Asaṇga who fulfilled the prophecies pioneer the system. So here, after Ārya Nāgārjuna, Aryanaga refers to Ārya Nāgārjuna who was prophesied by Buddha Śākyamūni himself as upholding his teachings. After Ārya Nāgārjuna who was prophesied as upholding the supreme vehicle, who spread the supreme vehicle? Ārya Asaṇga did.

So what precisely was the status of Mahāyāna before Ārya Asaṇga spread the Mahāyāna, it was only Mādhyamika and correct your text, it’s a Mādhyamika only, not themselves. You have an early version of my text. This very beautiful text, it is the words of Je Tsongkhapa himself. Then these stanzas which follow are the actual body of the text. In the context of the generation of the motivation, let us now reflect during a couple of minutes on the mode of positing of the person, and the various modes the person is posited in in the different schools.

Mhmm. Would you like to open the playback page one? Page five. So at present Geshela will take a couple short questions, please short, and after this we will have the debate discussion session. The third verse teaching clearly mind and basis of all.

No. The third verse teaching clearly mind and basis of all does not teach that Chitamatra was pioneered after Mādhyamika. It teaches the topic and the purpose of this treatise. So the meaning of these third stanzas beginning with after Aryanaga and ending with the Madhyamikas only, is not that dependent on Cittamātra, it is easier to gain a realization of Mādhyamika and this is why it taught, but instead merely to present a chronology. In other words, after Ārya Nāgārjuna taught Mādhyamika, then Ārya Asaṇga pioneered the Chitamatra system.

It’s very simple, when did Ārya Asaṇga teach the Cittamātra system? It’s perfectly okay to have your own private understanding of these verses. You can do everything. No? But no.

Next question. Please. Generally speaking, yes, Ārya Nāgārjuna came first and Ārya Asaṇga came later. Ārya Nāgārjuna is supposed to have come to this world four hundred years after the Buddha entered Parinirvana and Ārya Asaṇga nine hundred years after the Buddha entered Parinirvana. What do you mean by positive account of the mind?

Is a description of what something of something that exists. Mhmm. What basically I’m I’m really only familiar with. Mhmm. But that is basically pulling out the rug from everything.

It’s emptiness. Emptiness. Emptiness. Emptiness. Emptiness.

So mind is empty, everything is empty. Is there anywhere in any Ārya Nāgārjuna’s writings where he says, this is what mind is, This is what the person is. This is what the sort of things that you find in tenants, the basis, the path, and the result. Does he set those out as that anywhere in his writings? So regarding such a presentation of the mind and specifically bodhichitta, you find this overwhelmingly in Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali, As well as in Bodhichitta Vivarana.

Last week Geshela said that dependent on these attempts to identify what the person is, the various schools of tenets arise. This is my private view on the topic. I would tend to agree with that but does that mean that there’s a debate that there would be other reasons as to why the tenet system should arise other than Geshe-la’s private view? I gather there are other viewpoints, yes. This is not something I have seen clearly in text, but basically dependent on the mode of positing the person, in other words, dependent on the mode of positing the basis in which virtuous and non virtuous seeds are implanted, I feel the schools of tenets arose.

I just wondered if there was a debate in the monasteries that Geshe was alluding to. That’s Yes, naturally. Yes, sure. Of course. What would be contrary, what would be Druptamawa Tawa.

The huge debates about this in the presentation of the object of refutation from the standpoint of the various schools of tenets, starting with the non Buddhist schools all the way up to the Prāsaṇgika school. Very important, know, Very bad. Amazing. Eli, I’m gonna need your help to try and formulate this into a question. It’s something we discussed in study group.

The central claim of Chitamatra is that the karmic seeds and imprints and memories need a stable abode. And so we were talking about the notion of what stability actually means and the first point on that we were talking about was present but not manifest. We were talking about how when in deep sleep you can be woken by a sound so it’s as though the senses aren’t completely ceased. They’re still able to function in the sense that you can be awoken from sleep. And we were wondering if there’s a distinction between in the West there’s what they refer to as conscious and subconscious.

So is it the case that what is manifest it would be considered conscious, as in present to conscious awareness and is non manifest or present but non manifest equivalent to what would be subconscious which is present but not apparent to awareness. Simultaneous, right? Yes, in tantra this is taught, right? The distinction between the coarse and the subtle minds are taught. Okay, next question.

Please. Hīnayāna, Mahāyāna, and Mahāyāna has Cittamātra, Prāsaṇgika and the other one, Mādhyamika, right? Sautrāntika. Is it Sautrāntika? Cittamātra is being practiced by Chinese and Vietnamese a lot.

I wonder is the and the are they developed later or branched off later and practiced only by Tibetan people? No. Not quite. The both the Chitamatra and the Mādhyamika view find their origin in ancient India, but as this text very clearly explains, the Mādhyamika view arose first and the Chitamatra view arose later after. So there’ll be two topics for discussion today.

The first are the instances of the person in the various schools of tenets, starting from the non Buddhist schools of tenets all the way up to Prāsaṇgika, and the second will be the reason for which these instances are given by the various schools. Okay. Place. Place.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
tenet system drubtha(Tib)
A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top