1 h 44 min · 2,759 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this extended 104-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores a central paradox of Mind-Only (Cittamātra) philosophy through the lens of possession and the nature of the mind-basis-of-all (ālaya-vijnana). Building on stanza 25 of his root text—which states that one base cannot support two ālaya-vijnanas—Geshe-la walks through the problem: when a deity or spirit possesses a person, does the possessed individual retain their ālaya-vijnana? If so, there would be two ālaya-vijnanas on one base, contradicting the foundational doctrine. The teaching unfolds as both lecture and Socratic debate, with Geshe-la pressing students to articulate their position on possession, multiple personality disorder, and remote control of consciousness. He clarifies that possession is not a double consciousness but the ripening of karmic imprints, while the possessed person’s ālaya-vijnana remains dormant, uninterrupted until enlightenment. The session builds towards a subtle resolution: how identity and continuum relate when one mind-basis persists but many personalities can manifest.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 15082017 CITTAMATRA.mp3
UUID: a00415b1-357f-451f-bee5-721dedb7972a
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,759
So there are numerous subdivisions of imprints and explaining all of them in detail doesn’t have a lot of purpose. But last time, Geshela covered the presentation in stanza 21 verse two of common and uncommon imprints. So generally speaking it is said that uncommon imprints are imprints which establish the essence, in other words sentient beings, and common imprints are imprints which establish the vessel, in other words the environment. So, let us first take uncommon karmic imprints. In other words, the karmic imprints which establish sentient beings or the essence.
An example of such karmic imprints would be, for instance, when oneself tastes something sweet, and as a result of tasting something sweet, a sensation of happiness arises within one’s mind. That sensation of happiness is the maturation of an uncommon karmic imprint. A virtuous one. So if we analyze further, let us take the case of a very pleasant meal. Then the condition for this very pleasant meal is an exterior collection of tastes and so forth, but the cause of the experience of this pleasant meal is the maturation of a karmic imprint.
Otherwise, we would find it difficult to give an instance of uncommon karmic imprints. Now regarding the common karmic imprints of the vessel, the vessel here is none other than this world of us, what is known as Jambudvipa in Sanskrit, but the common karmic imprints are the general imprints accumulated by all human beings, for instance, which give rise to the experience of this world. Now we can see this in particular with different environments, which are the products of different common karmic imprints, for instance, the various continents. Generally, count them as five, but there are various ways of cutting them up to eight in the Tibetan tradition. In any case, life on these continents, in their cities, in their capitals, the conditions, all this is a product of karmic imprints.
Now within some of these continents, there are capital cities within which people have remarkable circumstances for both living and study. They have often a marvelous level of education, and all of this is the result of the common imprint. It’s not the result of something so much in this life, but of previous karma of the person. Then this environment would be the result of that common karmic imprint. Likewise, we can see the opposite in some areas which are very poor and where circumstances are very hard.
Some families have all the requisite conditions they need, ideal conditions even, whatever they engage in is successful, and this is a result of karma. And as you said, somewhat further in our text on stanza 25, since on one base, two bases of all there would be, they are not distinct. So here, obviously, what is being said is that if there were two bases of all on one base, in other words in the continuum of one sentient being, then they could not be distinct. So we can see this with the sensory consciousnesses, which are all different from each other. For that matter, with the six collections of consciousness, there is only one mental consciousness.
And if we accept eight collections of consciousnesses, then there is only one mind basis of all. There cannot be two minds basis of all. So therefore, what is taught explicitly in numerous Buddhist texts is that within one mental continuum, there can only be one mind basis of all, one ālaya vijnana. There cannot be two different ālaya vijnanas. Then if this is the case, let us consider the situation of someone who has attained the first ground, for instance.
On the first ground, such a being can emanate, let us say, 100 emanations. Do each of these emanations have their own mind basis of all? Yes. Then are these mind basis of all one or different with the mind basis of all of the emanator? So let us therefore consider the case of this first grounder who has emanated 100 emanations.
Each of these emanations is a person or a being. Therefore, each emanation has his or her own mind basis of all or ālaya vijnana. Are these ālaya vijnanas one or different with the mental continuum of the emanator? Are they one or different with each other as well, in your opinion? Do you understand?
I’m going to go for the different. The different is The case of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama being an emanation of Chenrezig. That Chenrezig could send out lots of different emanations and that His Holiness would be one. And he has such a distinct personality that it’s hard to imagine that Chenrezig would be exactly the same as His Holiness. And the other?
Then this occurs obviously when the mind is more subtle, it probably is one of the attainments which occurs when one attains calm abiding for the first time. Now let us consider another situation, that of possession. You know what possession is? So let us take the case of possession, for instance, by a spirit or a ghost. Then Are the Alaya Vijnanas one or separate?
So as you know or may know in Tibetan Buddhism, there are cases of persons who are the receptacle of deities. They are said to be like the cushion, if you wish, in which a deity descends. When the deity descends, that person’s personality is completely gone, and when the deity leaves, it returns. The same thing is said to occur in cases of possession by ghosts or spirits. What happens to Alayavijnanas?
I would say in that case Do you understand what possession means? You understand that during possession, the possessed person’s personality is completely absent. It’s completely gone. So in cases of possession by spirits, His Holiness has said that the spirits in question are generally pretas, or in the preta category. The personality of the person who is possessed is completely evacuated.
It’s not there. You understand that? Yeah, yeah, okay, but basically it’s not there. So we do agree based on the scriptural material we’ve been working with that in the continuum of one sentient being, there can only be one mind basis of all, there cannot be two minds basis of all. So you need a rationale for the existence of two minds basis of all, there isn’t.
So let us take the case of hero. If a spirit enters hero’s body, then at that point, how many Alayavijnanas are there? Is there only one Alāyavijñāna or are there two Alayavijnanas? Has to be two because here was Aria Vajnana, it has to stay there, it’s not going anywhere. And then there’s also the Alāyavijñāna of the spirit, right?
The spirit. So there are two Alayavijnanas. And Buddhist texts are explicit in their assertion that there cannot be two Alayavijnanas within two Alayavijnanas within the continuum of one being. So, yep. I do not understand what the problem is because if you have two beings which are inside hero’s body, where is the issue?
There’s still two beings, just that they’re taking possession of a body. Yes indeed, there’s two minds within one body and that is directly if there are two Alayavijnanas within one body, that’s directly contradictory with the statement that there cannot be two Alayavijnanas within one base. But the base of the spirit is not hero. Otherwise, if it was, then spirit would not exist without hero, which clearly is not the case because it existed before hero. No.
What is being said is not that the base of the deity or the ghost or the spirit is hero, but that the support in which the deity has descended, that is a base which is hero. Hero therefore is a base. And we are not saying that hero is the base of the deity, if hero was the base of the deity, there’d be no reason for the possession. Do you understand? This case.
So set possession aside, imagine we’re talking of multiple personality disorder. So multiple personality disorder is understood as possession in most of the traditional cultures in the world, in Buddhism, in Christianity, etcetera. What are we dealing with as far as the Alāyavijñāna is concerned in multiple personality disorder? Geshe-la says obviously this difference of personality is the justification for possession. So once hero is possessed by a deity or another personality manifests in hero, then the first personality is totally gone.
Do you understand? Okay. That is alright. So I guess I’m just gonna debate with you. First we have to understand the situation we’re dealing with.
Greg? Amy? I was wondering if the deities whilst it’s in the the person’s body whether or not that has any bearing on that person’s Alāyavijñāna, whether or not there’s the deity takes over and does various activities, whether the karma of those activities is now burdening the other person. So if a spirit possesses hero or a deity descends in hero, in other words, in a case of multiple personality disorder of which hero is the victim, then even though all of hero’s consciousnesses have ceased, we do agree that the ālāyavijñāna of hero is still there. You remember that we studied that the ālaya vijnana is uninterrupted until full enlightenment.
So we agree therefore that until one attains full enlightenment, the ālaya vijnana is continually present as a consciousness. Then let us assume hero hero has not attained full enlightenment. His ālaya vijnana must be continually present. Is it present therefore when he is possessed? Then it follows that on the base of hero, there are two ālaya vijnanas because there is hero’s own ālaya vijnana and there is the ālaya vijnana of the spirit possessing hero.
The possession is not another ālaya vijnana, it is the ripening of karmic imprints. The possession. Does such a thing exist? So in your opinion, what’s happening? Possession exists, Geshela says.
In dharma, this is a very common occurrence. Possession is provoked, you have the supports who are possessed by the gods and they give prophecies and oracles and so forth. At least you have to understand. This is something one can observe. So just as we have different personalities with different karma in different lives.
There’s no question about karma here. We’re not talking about karma. All Geshela wants from you is the answer to the question. Is or are two Alayavijnanas in hero’s mindstream or not? At that point.
We cannot use the ālaya vijnana at all. Then how can it be taken possession of? We can’t use the ālaya vijnana at all, how could we? In which case, when we talk about a possession, it’s not possession of the But who is talking, you are talking about that. We aren’t.
Okay. Is a subtle mind. How could it be seized or held? So when in Cittamātra, one refers to the ālaya vijnana, actually this is the fundamental mind which is referred to in tantra, the terminology is different. We have no access and no use of such a mind.
We have no connection with the ālaya vijnana. When in Tibetan when one says possession, one says the god descends, When the god descends or the spirit descends, this has no link at all to the ālāyavijñāna. So when one is possessed by a spirit or a deity, then all one’s sensory and mental consciousnesses cease, and the deity or the spirit takes control of the body and does whatever it wants with the body. So Geshela is saying then based on this analysis, it follows there are two Alaya Vijnanas within hero’s continuum of consciousness. Are there or aren’t there?
I think there are. Agreed. Yeah, the deity that’s possessing or the spirit that’s possessing already has a base before it goes into hero. It has a very subtle base before it goes into hero. Base means mind, base is evolved, right?
No. It means body. So you are saying there are two mind bases of all. And other? So you’re in direct contradiction with the stanza since on one base, two bases of all they would be there not distinct.
Firstly, I think there’s a difference between being possessed and actually having multiple personalities in my thought. They’re not the same thing. So what I’m thinking is the mind as thing is actually inhabited by two but yet one is dormant being the original hero. It’s like when you’re in deep sleep or something. Okay.
This is my self investigation and analysis of myself. And it seems like just this one ālaya vijnana. There’s no two. But hero appears dependent on the situation and dependent on the motivation also. And that’s all those source is from within arising from the one Alaya Vijñāna.
There’s not two Alaya Vijnanas, that’s mine. You said souls. So you’re saying that in case of possession, there is one ālaya vijnana. So come on, let’s get your answers. I think there’s only one.
I think, I don’t know if it’s an appropriate example, but when you’re on the hypnosis, you are not at all present, but there was someone of a different continuum that is able to manipulate you remotely, so through either verbal suggestion or otherwise. So it seems to follow to me that you can have two beings of a different continuum where one is able to remotely control another. You’re saying two. So there’s two bases and two mind bases of all, but one is remotely controlling the other. Don’t know if that would be through the power of clairvoyance or something of that nature, but the spirit wouldn’t have that.
I say there is only one Alaya Vijñāna. And as we die, then this base is not the Alaya Vijñāna. So when if the if the base is possessed, then the Alaya Vijñāna goes into the Alaya Vijñāna waiting room. So I don’t know if there’s a if there’s a space where we can go to you. I just wonder if if we can die if we die and and our Alea Vidjana continues separate from this base, there must be a A waiting room.
A waiting room. Okay. Can the the Alaya Vijñāna I guess I’m asking, can the Alaya Vijñāna of the being that is possessed take a Bardo body in the time of possession? So what Geshela would like you to think about is therefore what happens in a case of possession when the the god or the deity descends. What happens specifically to the ālaya vijnana of the possessed person?
So says in stanza 25 of his root text, since on one base, two bases of all there would be, they are not distinct. That there cannot be two ālaya vijnanas on one base. But when Hiro, let us say, is possessed, then Hiro’s Alāyavijñāna is there and the possessing spirit has an Alāyavijñāna too. So we would have two Alayavijnanas, wouldn’t we? So therefore, let us now reflect during a couple minutes on this debate.
On the one hand, in stanza 25, Jetsunpa says that there cannot be two Aliyah Vijnanas on one base. On the other hand, it seems clear in cases of possession that there have to be two ālaya vijnanas on one base. Mhmm. It’s a bit difficult as a topic. Mhmm.
Open the playbook, page one. So Cittamātrins say that the mind basis of all is the instance of the person. So if we say that hero is possessed by a spirit or a deity then we’re still saying hero is possessed. We’re not saying that hero has disappeared. Yes?
Yes? Geshe was waiting for a question. Would that be correct? At the time of possession Hiro’s mind has ceased, the mental consciousness has ceased, it’s gone. Then in Hiro’s body or however you wish to put it, the deity or the spirit is present and does whatever it wants with Hiro’s body.
So Geshela would like you tonight to debate therefore the following topic. When a deity or a spirit descends in hero, possesses hero, then hero’s ālaya vijnana remains, it is still present. Mhmm. But in addition, there is also the ālaya vijnana of the possessing spirit. Then there are two but this seems to be in direct contradiction with stanza 25, since on one base, two bases of all there would be, they are not distinct.
What is being said is that on one, the base of one person, you never get two ālaya vijnanas.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Jambudvipa Rose-apple Land; dzam bu ling (Tib)
- Of the four continents surrounding Mount Meru in Buddhist cosmology, this is the southern continent where human beings live. The other three continents are Godaniya in the west; Kuru in the north and Videha in the east. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.