1 h 10 min · 3,292 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 70-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen provides a detailed exploration of Cittamātra, the Buddhist school asserting that all phenomena are of the nature of mind. Drawing on Je Tsongkhapa’s commentarial framework, he systematically examines the mind basis of all (Alaya Vijñāna) through four analytical lenses: its object of observation, the aspect it apprehends, its nature, and its associated mental factors. Central to the session is the question of how a table, perceived simultaneously by multiple observers, can be of the nature of consciousness—addressing the paradox that each person perceives a distinct aspect while all seemingly perceive the same object. Geshe-la illustrates the Cittamātra position through the example of a pleasing house, which appears beautiful to its owner but not to others, arguing that this subjective appearance proves objects arise from karmic imprints in the mind rather than existing externally. He distinguishes Cittamātra from Sautrāntika and Vaibhāṣika schools, defends the necessity of mediated aspects against “naked perception,” and closes with extended Q&A in which students probe the logical implications: whether indivisible particles exist, how one table becomes twenty in a room of twenty observers, and whether analysing a table as mind causes it to become non-obstructive. Aimed at serious students already familiar with Tibetan Buddhist philosophical debate.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 16052017cittamatra.mp3
UUID: d99333ca-45da-43a9-83f8-6b2ad291fdd7
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,300
Mhmm. So as you remember, the root text regarding the mind basis of all, Je Tsongkhapa’s root text is subdivided into four sections. A presentation of the object of observation of the mind basis of all, of its aspect, of its nature and of its associates. So regarding the first subdivision, the object of observation of the Alaya Vijñāna, this has broadly speaking already been presented. It is the five sensory organs and the five sensory objects.
The second topic, the aspect which appears to the Alaya Vijñāna is a difficult topic. We shall enter into it quietly and the two final topics, the nature, in other words the meaning if you prefer, and the associates of the Alaya Vijñāna will be explained later on. If at present I were to explain the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna, I doubt that you would be able to retain it. Therefore, we shall enter in detail into the object of observation, the aspect, the nature and the associates, in other words, five omnipresent mental factors linked with the Alaya Vijñāna and then later on the definition will become clear. So as you remember, regarding the object of observation of the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all, we said that the five sense organs and the five sense objects appeared to the mind basis of all or the Alaya Vijñāna of beings of the two lower of the three realms, the desire realm and the form realm, but did not appear to the Alaya Vijñāna of beings of the formless realm.
Now in your root text at present, page three, second paragraph from the bottom, you have the following stanza. In the lower as well, should all beings and environments appear to the basis of all of one sentient being, the hells would appear as well to a God of the form realm. So in the stanza, in the lower refers either to a being of the desire or of the form realm and if we were to take the case of one sentient being, let us say a human being, myself, the issue which is being raised is whether all beings and environments appear to my own Alaya Vijñāna, my basis of all or not. Now if they did appear to my own basis of all, then the hell realms, the sufferings of the hell realms, their difficulties would also appear to my own Alaya Vijñāna, and if that was so, since that is only possible through the awakening of a karmic imprint within my own Alaya Vijñāna, then that will be present. So in Je Tsongkhapa’s auto-commentary on Page 16, the example which is given is that of a being of the form realm, but the same lines of reasoning apply to beings of the other realms.
If the hell realms were to appear, then their karmic imprints would have awakened. And the converse is also true for beings of the hell realms for instance, If all beings and environment appeared to the Alaya Vijñāna of the being of the hell realm, then clearly the experiences of the higher realms would appear to such a being and naturally this would occur as a result of the awakening of karmic imprints within the mind basis of all of that being. As is said, should this be the case, there would be the thought of the distance appearing to the ordinary and this means that there would be the thought of very distant objects appearing to the Alaya Vijñāna of ordinary beings. And this leads us directly to the final stanza at the bottom of Page three, directly sense organs, entities, the beginning of Page four, indirectly whatever can appear as objects of its six collections is also posited as object of the basis of all. But we shall set this aside for the time being and proceed gradually through the root text.
So, if to a being such as ourselves, the appearances of the Hell Realms occurred, then since the only way these appearances could occur is through appearing to the Alaya Vijñāna and to appear to the Alaya Vijñāna, it is necessary that a karmic imprint giving rise to these be present and awaken within the Alaya Vijñāna, then we would experience these Hell Realm experiences. So the issue which is being addressed here is the mode of appearance of phenomena to the Alaya Vijñāna and this mode of appearance is one in which phenomena can only appear through the dawning or the manifestation of a karmic imprints, in this case the karmic imprint of a hell realm. Now regarding the Cittamātra view, as you know Chittamatrans are sometimes called Vijnaptivadins or propounders of pure consciousness or consciousness alone. And in this respect, Buddha Śākyamūni says in the Lankavatara Sūtra, the descent into Lanka sūtra, As to exterior phenomena, all there is, is the appearance of your consciousness. And Je Tsongkhapa adds in his root text on mind and basis of all in the middle of page three, since apart from appearing as form to consciousness outside, nothing exists.
So, here in keeping with the passage from sūtra, there are no exterior appearances, there is only your mind appearing as exterior. What is clearly taught is that for every given phenomenon, for instance, the table in front of Geshe-la, we have a substantial cause which is a karmic imprints within the Alaya Vijñāna, which gives rise simultaneously to the object and to the subject. In the case of the table, the object is the table itself and the subject is the visual consciousness perceiving the table. So think about it the following way. The table which appears to the visual consciousness is of the nature of consciousness.
Then, when you ask why it is of the nature of consciousness, then that calls for examination. So, here let us remember the example I gave last time, which is the perception of this table by Chris and then by myself. Let us assume that when Chris perceives this table, he perceives it as unpleasant. He perceives its color and so forth as unsatisfactory. From my standpoint on the other hand, when I perceive this table, I perceive it as pleasing.
Then, those two perceptions are private. So let us take the example of one’s lodging, whether it is a house, a unit or whatsoever. Then one’s lodging appears as very pleasing to oneself. It however does not appear as very pleasing to others. This appearance as very pleasing to oneself is an appearance at the time of examination and analysis.
Now, if it was the case that this was established exteriorly, then it would appear as such to all persons without exception, yet it does not. It does exist however. This pleasant beautiful house, it is useful, yet it is not established from the outside. And here, when we try to explain this, what is taught is that this pleasing house, which is the object and the visual consciousness perceiving it, is the subject, arise from one substantial cause which is the karmic imprint implanted in the mind basis of all. So here if we inquire whether subject and object, in other words the pleasing house and the visual consciousness perceiving the house are established sequentially or simultaneously, they are established simultaneously.
There is no reason to say they are established sequentially. If we were to say that they are established sequentially, we would fall back into the Sautrāntika view, according to which there is a pleasing house out there, which is perceived by the visual consciousness and therefore the visual consciousness arises dependent on it. So here, the reason for which this pleasing house which appears to the visual consciousness is of one nature with the visual consciousness perceiving it, and is not prior to the visual consciousness perceiving it, is because it is part of the substantial continuum of this visual consciousness, and it arises out of a karmic imprint in the Alaya Vijñāna, which is its substantial cause. There is therefore no reason to say it is not of one nature with the consciousness perceiving it. This is asking about how tomatoes will I don’t know.
So let us take the example of a tomato which gives rise to two tomatoes. Then that one tomato is the substantial cause of those two tomatoes. Those two tomatoes arise from that one tomato and therefore abide with the nature of tomato. So this one tomato acts as substantial cause to give rise to two tomatoes. And therefore, in keeping with this example, the visual consciousness perceiving a pleasant house, and the pleasant house perceived by a visual consciousness, in as much as they arise out of one single karmic seed within the mind basis of all can be said to be of one substantial continuum and by extension can be said to be of one nature.
So a major doubt which could arise here is it is very strange to assert that table is the nature of consciousness since after all, tables arise as a result of a lot of work and effort in manufacturing them. So here, we are not saying that the table does not exist, the table does exist. However, if I ask you why do you say the table exists, all you can say is the table exists because it appears to my visual consciousness. Therefore, it is appearance to visual consciousness which is the criterion for the existence of table, and appearance is a topic we have to enter in in-depth. Otherwise, we might say what a strange viewpoint this one which says that tables and houses or buildings are the nature of mind since after all, it calls for a lot of work to erect a building or to construct a table.
So the Vaibhāṣikas probably do not accept the concept of aspect. Let us set Sautrantikas aside for the time being, Cittamātra’s have the understanding of aspect which was explained. So the Vaibhāṣikas do not assert the existence of an aspect of phenomena such as table and so forth for the following reason. They say that when we perceive a table by means of the visual consciousness, if an aspect of the table appeared to the visual consciousness, then there would be an aspect between the table itself and the visual consciousness, and you would have three entities. Therefore the Vaibhāṣikas assert that instead of being mediated by an aspect when it appears to the visual consciousness, a table appears nakedly to the visual consciousness.
The Cittamātra however assert the existence of an aspect in keeping with the verse of the Triṃśikā of Vasubandhu which says the aspect is cognized or not cognized and they assert that when a table appears to the visual consciousness, what appears is the aspect of the table and this is the table. If the Chittamatrans did not assert the existence of such an aspect, then their position would be similar to that of the Sautrantikas for instance. So Cittamātra asserts that what appears to the visual consciousness perceiving table is the aspect of table and both are the result of the karmic imprint giving rise to this awakening within the mind basis of all. So, the question which arises is, according to the Chittamatrans, the table which appears to the visual consciousness perceiving it form or not. It is form.
Is it a table or not? This is more delicate. For instance, if I take the case of Hiro, when Geshe-la looks at Hiro’s body, Hiro’s body which appears to Geshe-la’s visual consciousness, is it Hero’s body or not? If it is Hero’s body, things become very delicate. Because if that aspect of hero’s body which appears to my visual consciousness were hero’s body, then my visual consciousness, my consciousness would become of one substance with Hiro’s body and then Hiro’s body would be part of my continuum.
So, in this context I was planning on explaining today non duality, which is the view of Cittamātra, but I think I will do that next time. Let us at present meditate during a couple of minutes on the nature of consciousness and the awakening of karmic imprints. Please open the page one. We will cite one b, two, three, four, and also page five. Number six, mandala offering, first one and three.
So in brief, the Chittamatras assert that all phenomena, all things, all objects depend on the mind, and these aspects which appear to the mind, they assert to be of the nature of mind. In brief according to Cittamātra, this table can only be posited in terms of the consciousness which perceives it. Apart from this, what table can we posit? And as a result, this table is said to be of the nature of the consciousness perceiving it, to the difference of the Sautrāntika view according to which there is a table out there, in dependence on which the visual consciousness perceiving it arises, and this table out there is constituted of indivisible particles. Then at present, Geshe-la will take a couple questions.
Are you ready? Okay. Thank you, Geshe-la. Do do partless particles exist at all for the Cittamātra? Even if they are not the basis on which external objects appear to exist, do they exist at all?
No, indivisible particles do not exist for Cittamātra. This is the core element of their assertion of non duality, which is specifically to counter the view of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrantikas, according to which there are exterior indivisible particles. Okay. Was meditating on the five aggregates a few days ago, and it kind of thumped me in the chest, which was very painful, to, realize that. And I was thinking, what do you do once that’s happened?
What’s happened? Once you’ve stepped on your ego. Get to worry. Is it a question? Sorry?
Is it a question? Yeah. What what do you what do you do? Because it’s a bit shocking. Mhmm.
So how do you kind of where do you go from there? I mean, I’m not in a monastery. I don’t have great resources. Mhmm. I just did something rather radical, and and it’s not a bad thing.
It’s it’s a shift in perception, but it’s quite shocking, and I I guess I wasn’t prepared for that. So the most important thing at present is to study and specifically to study the Four Noble Truths, the path shared with the being of the middling and the great scope, because it is through transforming our own minds that we will reap our own rewards. Geshe-la, how is it that an aspect of table appears to my visual consciousness and to everybody else’s visual consciousnesses? It is simultaneous. Simultaneously, we all perceive an aspect of table.
However, when one examines to see whether the aspect of table appearing to your mind is beautiful or not and that appearing to another’s mind is pleasant or unpleasant, then the situation changes. That’s why I use the indefinite article, an aspect of table appears. Yes? Yes. Why what is the meaning of the indefinite article here?
Well, it means that to me, there is an aspect of table that appears to me, and there’s a different aspect of table that appears simultaneously to everybody else or to other people. How is it that at the same time there is an aspect of table that appears simultaneously to me and to everybody else? Yes, the appearance to others depends on how they think of it. Discussing a point during study group and we may have reached the wrong conclusion, so I want to clarify it. Hopefully I’ve formulated this well enough.
If an obstructive object such as a table is thoroughly analyzed by a wisdom realizing it to be of the nature of the mind, does it for that individual alone? You’ve got to speak up and clear, I Okay. Don’t catch If an obstructive object such as a table is thoroughly analyzed by the wisdom realizing it to be of the nature of mind, does it for that individual alone cease to be obstructive? So this is something we have to think about. If it were to become unobstructive, and I think about not sure 100%, probably, but not 100%.
We were thinking about the cities and the Burmese, if this is how it manifests. Yes, probably unobstructive. It’s a good question, the distinction between obstructive and obstructive. According to Cittamātra, are there more than one table? You say this one.
You speak of this table right because everyone agrees I’m with many saying that table. Actually in the world you know different tables but you say this one. I did. I’m saying that table and about 15 people in here or 20 people. So there’s 20 tables according to Cittamātra.
So this is something which has to be examined. In this temple we have some 20 people, each one perceives this table by means of his or her visual consciousness. If the table perceived by the visual consciousness is a table, then 20 tables. So this we have to examine very carefully where exactly is this table, is it within our consciousness, is it somehow on the table here? Take an example, Chris has a $100, right?
Aussie dollars. So Chris has, let’s assume, $100 bill, and the 20 of us are ogling his $100 bill, then there’s $2,000 in the picture, isn’t it? So Chris, you keep a 100 and the rest of us we share So there’s $2,000 20 people looking each at 100 So thousand you are very happy you know. So these are the debates we engage in in the monastery. Then, if we were to say that for instance, Chris had these $2,000, and that would be very strange, wouldn’t it?
And yeah? Geshe-la, if I heard correctly, you thought that Hero’s body is one with visual one with the nature of mind, but not one with your mental continuum. Is that correct? Not quite, no. So I’ve got that slightly wrong but the question is if it’s not one with your if close, if it’s one with your mental continuum, with which mental continuum of which mind is it the nature of?
So Hiro’s body is of one nature with Geshe-la’s visual consciousness when Geshe-la is observing Hiro’s body. Then the question is, is that body of hero observed by Geshe-la’s visual consciousness, hero’s body or not? If that body observed by Geshe-la’s visual consciousness is of one nature, or is Hiro’s body, then Hiro’s body becomes one with Geshe-la’s mental continuum. Does tonight we’ve been talking about when the visual consciousness perceives the form. Does this change the argument at all if one is thinking of the form from memory?
That’s a good question. So it is principally the sensory consciousnesses which are at issue here and we said that the table when perceived by the visual consciousness is of one nature with that visual consciousness perceiving it. Now as far as memory is concerned, it’s a conceptual mind as opposed to the sense consciousnesses which are non conceptual. So when memory thinks of the table, actually it is that appearance of the table to the visual consciousness which is the cause eventually of the memory thinking of it. So there’s no particular issue here.
In that respect, the table is a meaning generality for that conceptual mind. So so the topic for discussion tonight is the following. Cittamātra asserts that table when it is perceived by the visual consciousness is of one nature or of one substance with that visual consciousness. Please debate this topic. Yeah, please.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do partless (indivisible) particles exist at all according to the Cittamātra school?
No, indivisible particles do not exist for the Cittamātra. Their denial of them is the core element of their assertion of nonduality. This assertion is made specifically to counter the view of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrantika, who hold that there are exterior indivisible particles.