1 h 7 min · 3,449 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 68-minute commentary on Cittamātra philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen unpacks stanza 34 of a root text by examining the relationship between the afflicted mind, the mind basis of all, and the path to enlightenment. He walks through a precise logical analysis using the concept of logical possibilities, determining how many valid coexistence patterns exist between these two mental states across different levels of spiritual attainment. The teaching then pivots to exploring the doctrine that afflictions do not disappear but transform into wisdom at enlightenment, using anger and bodhicitta as concrete examples. Central to the discussion is the definition of what it means for something to be abandoned—not erasure, but the elimination of certain mental factors. He concludes with two debated topics: whether anger and other afflictions necessarily transform into enlightened wisdom, and the precise relationship between antidotes and objects of abandonment. Pitched at serious practitioners with prior study of Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 17102017 Cittamātra.mp3
UUID: fd31830b-e3fe-44f7-9f3a-157da46b2fb3
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,453
So in your root text, stanza 34 on page six, even where the apprehension of the person, which is the afflicted mind is negated, because its mere type exists and because the potency to generate the apprehension of phenomena has not been negated, both defects, the absence of mental consciousness and attaining equality are abandoned at a remove. So here, as Geshe-la explained last time, once one attains a state of an Arhat or one is on these three pure grounds, since the afflicted mind is abandoned, one might think that one incurs a defect of abandoning or eliminating the mental consciousness and of attaining the wisdom of equality. Then if one attain the wisdom of equality, one would have attained full enlightenment. Then in the final two verses of the stanza, both defects, the absence of mental consciousness and attaining equality, are abandoned at a remove, what is taught is the two defects which are to be abandoned. Now the reason for which even though the and Bodhisattvas in the three pure grounds, the eighth, ninth, and tenth ground, although they have abandoned the afflicted mind, do not incur the thought of the disappearance of the mental consciousness or attaining full enlightenment at that point, is because once they have attained that point, even though grasping at the self of persons has been eliminated, nonetheless grasping at the self of phenomena has not, and as a result, the mental consciousness is still present and they have still not attained the wisdom of equality.
So the reason for which the opponent believes that upon the attainment of either arhathood for a hearer or a Pratyekabuddha, or the attainment of the three pure grounds of a bodhisattva, this fault is incurred, is because he or she believes that upon attaining these states, not only is self grasping abandoned, but all its seeds are abandoned as well. So the logical tool Geshe-la explained last time, which is known as in Tibetan, which we have translated in English as logical possibilities. Etymologically in Tibetan means the end, the juncture, or the boundary. When one speaks of the mtha’ between two phenomena, we’re saying that beyond this something does not exist. Whereas, before this something does exist.
So in other words, the moves or the logical possibilities mean boundaries. This term is widely used in sa lam, in grounds and paths. And when we speak of two phenomena having three or four logical possibilities, in other words, three or four moves, this is very closely related to whether one phenomena necessarily entails or pervades the other or not. So as you remember last time, Geshe-la brought up the issue of how many logical possibilities there were between the afflicted mind and the mind basis of all. Were there three or four moves, or three or four logical possibilities?
And as we saw, there are only three logical possibilities. So when one examines them, one examines if when the afflicted mind exists, there’s a case in which afflict afflicted mind exists and the mind basis of all does not exist. A case in which the mind basis of all exists and the afflicted mind does not exist, and so forth. So there are only three logical possibilities between the afflicted mind and the mind basis of all. There are not four.
Now what are these three logical possibilities? There is both afflicted mind and the Alaya Vijñāna present. There is The Alaya Vijñāna present and no afflicted mind. And there is a situation where neither is present. Mhmm.
So obviously, give examples. Right? So they are both present in the continuum of ordinary beings. There are not four logical possibilities. No.
Is not. So which one is missing? The one that is missing is you can’t have, excuse me, the afflicted mind without That exists. Right? Okay.
Great. No. You you cannot you cannot so the afflicted mind cannot be present without the alaya vijnana. So you need the alaya vijnana present. In other words, yes, in other words, the logical possibility of the afflicted mind existing and the ālaya vijnana not existing does not exist.
In other words, the logical possibility of the afflicted mind existing and the mind basis of all not existing does not exist. Because in the continuum of a given being when the afflicted mind exists, the ālaya vijnana necessarily must exist. Do you understand? Yes. So or logical possibility has etymologically in Tibetan the meaning of the end or the boundary.
In other words, that beyond which something does not exist, but before which something does exist. So in other words, the mind basis of all and the afflicted mind, there are only three logical possibilities. Then could you give those three logical possibilities? Both, neither, and a mind in which the ālaya vijnana exists, but the afflicted mind does not exist. Please give the three logical possibilities.
All of you. I’m an example of a case where both exist. Uh-huh. The case where the ālaya vijnana exists but the afflicted mind does not is in the meditative equipoise or the first instant of meditative equipoise which is a direct insight into emptiness. The example where neither exists is in the meditative equipoise of an arhat or powerful one.
Uh-huh. Qualify that with the meditative equipoise on cessation. I need to qualify that. And there’s no example of the fourth case. So in other words, a logical possibility or a mtha’ in which the afflicted mind exists, but the ālaya vijnana does not exist, does not exist.
Do you understand? So Geshe-la said that a person or an instance in which the afflicted mind exists but the ālaya vijnana does not exist, does not exist. Why? What’s the reason? For there to be an afflicted mind, it necessarily has an object, that object is necessarily the ālaya vijnana.
And the second instance I could give is that the Allaya, the Klistamanas is a depositor and it would necessarily need something to deposit into and so if the ālaya vijnana is not present, it cannot function as a depositor. So the three logical possibilities between the afflicted mind and the ālaya vijnana are a being which has both is an ordinary being like ourselves. A being which has neither would be a bodhisattva on the pure grounds engaged in a meditative equipoise on cessation, and a being who has an ālaya vijnana but no afflicted mind would be an Arhat or Ārya being with ālaya vijnana but no afflicted mind, engaged in meditative equipoise on emptiness. So therefore in the continuum of an Ārya being on the first instance of the path of seeing and this can be either a hearer, a solitary realizer, or a bodhisattva ārya being, the afflicted mind does not exist. Now the reason for which the afflicted mind does not exist is because emptiness is perceived directly at this moment.
Therefore, one can formulate the logical consequence. It follows that in the mind of the subject, and now you’re being on the first instance of the path of seeing, the afflicted mind does not exist because emptiness is realized directly. Then in this consequence, the reason implies the predicate. In other words, if emptiness is realized directly, then it is necessarily the case that the afflicted mind does not exist. Do you understand?
So this must be understood in terms of reasons. In the mental continuum of a being who is realizing emptiness directly, there is no afflicted mind. However, in the mental continuum of that being, when that being is not realizing emptiness directly, the afflicted mind exists. It’s a bit odd, but that’s the way it is. So in addition, there are four logical possibilities between, on the one hand, the existence of the six collections of consciousness, and on the other hand, either the afflicted mind or the mind basis of all.
In other words, there are four logical possibilities between the six collections of consciousness and the afflicted mind, and there are four logical possibilities between the six collections of consciousness and the mind basis of all. Do you understand? Chris, could you please? So Chris, could you please give the full logical possibility? So Chris, could you please give the four logical possibilities between the six collections of consciousness and the afflicted mind?
Geshe-la said you don’t have to give examples. So the afflicted mind with the six collections of consciousness would be one. And then there’s the afflicted mind without the six collections. The six collections without the afflicted mind. And neither. Sure. 100%. And Natalie? Great.
Sorry. Do you understand me here? Yes, I do. Not sort of really ready to sort of give examples though. Not yet, we don’t know.
Okay, good. So Geshe would like to give you some simple examples for training. How many moves between being an Australian human being and being a human being? Being Australian human and being a human being in general. That’s easy, right?
So how many moves are there? That’s easy, right? One. Just one. Everyone is Australian.
So how many how many logical possibilities are there? You said three. Yeah, you said just three. Okay, okay, that’s okay. And other?
Two. Just two. Okay. You say three. Okay.
That is okay. And other? So you can only give one answer and not change it. Right? Yeah.
Just two. Just two. Okay. And Chris spoke already. Chris, really?
Not sure. There’s only three moves, Three logical possibilities. There aren’t four. So you go through them one by one. The way you do it is you go through all four one by one and you check if something exists or not.
Is there a logical possibility which is both an Australian and a human being? Is there a logical possibility which is an Australian but not a human being? No. Right? Is there a logical possibility which is a human being but not an Australian?
Yes. Is there a logical possibility which is neither a human being nor an Australian? Yes. Yeah. Right.
So What do you mean, Myra? Do you understand? Yes, yes, yes. And other? You have to be able to give the moves.
So before you give instances, could you give the list of the four moves, the four logical possibilities in general? In general, something which is both. Neither. Neither. So what you have to be able to list quickly is something which is both, something which is the one and not the other, the other and not the one and neither.
Do you understand? So you don’t have to give examples at first, but you have to know the sequence of the formulas, the list of the formulas, then you check. Right? Can you show me? You can list them in whatever sequence you want, but the form was the sequence of four are the four which exist including whether one is an Australian and not a human being or a human being and not an Australian.
So in general, how many moves, how many logical possibilities are there? Four. Four. Okay. Could you list those four, please?
So give it in terms of Australians and human beings. Yeah. Okay. So what example can you give of a human being which is not an Australian? Okay.
So what instance can you give of something which is both? Or someone which is both? So what is the move or the logical possibility which is neither an Australian nor a human being? Ilya’s dog. So what instance can you give of someone who’s an Australian but not a human being?
See that was where I Really? It’s a wombat. So why? Because they’re native to Australia. They’re not found anywhere else.
It is very controversial, but aboriginal people of Australia are still considered flora and fauna under the constitution. So you were saying there are four logical possibilities. Yes. I’m asking, no. I’m asking, yes.
This house is Australian? Why? It’s not a human being. It’s in Australia and nowhere else. It’s not possible to be Australian and not be a human being because the definition of an Australian is an Australian citizen who holds a passport.
So in Geshe-la’s private opinion, to be an Australian, you have to be a human being. Because when one says Tibetan, a Tibetan, one refers also to a human being. No one says a yak is a Tibetan. No. It’s funny.
Very funny. Very strange, you know. You understood, did you? About the mtha’s. Right?
So you understand the difference between three and four logical possibilities. So please give the four logical possibilities between the six collections of consciousness and the afflicted mind? So an ordinary being has both the six collections of, sorry, collection of consciousness and the afflicted mind. Ordinary being has both. A being on the path of seeing in meditative equipoise does not have an afflicted mind but does have the six collections.
So neither would be on the pure grounds on a meditative equipoise on cessation. And on the pure grounds, you can have no, there’s no afflicted mind. So this is not an meditative equipoise. On the pure grounds there’s no afflicted mind but you can still have the six collections. So therefore, on the doubt which is addressed in stanza 34 is the following.
On these three pure grounds, since the afflicted mind has been abandoned, one has attained the wisdom of equality. Therefore, one would have attained full enlightenment. Now, here, one has to explain the topics of the object of abandonment and the antidote. The afflicted mind is the object of abandonment, and the antidote is the wisdom realizing selflessness. How precisely does the wisdom realizing selflessness, the antidote, counter the object of abandonment, the afflicted mind?
So the wisdom realizing emptiness is said to be the antidote to its object of abandonment, which is grasping at the self of persons. Why is wisdom realizing emptiness said to be the antidote in Buddhist scriptures, and grasping at the self of persons said to be about the object of abandonment? Why is grasping at the self of persons never said to be the antidote to the wisdom realizing emptiness? So for instance, if we take hot and cold or fire and water, then if you pour water on fire, you put the fire out. If you put fire under water, the water evaporates.
Depends on their respective ratios and relationships. But when it comes to the relation between the wisdom realizing selflessness and the ignorance which grasps at a self of persons, why is the one always called an antidote and the other always called an object of abandonment? Because emptiness is, emptiness is primordial, it’s reality. Whereas the grasping of itself is adventitious and secondary. So Geshe was not quite sure what you mean by adventitious here.
The emptiness which is the object of the wisdom realizing emptiness is in accordance with reality. Now when we speak of grasping at a self of persons, grasping at a self of persons is a consciousness. Therefore, it exists. It is it is its object which does not exist. You have to distinguish between object and consciousness apprehending the object.
So the reason for which the grasping at a self of persons and the wisdom of realizing emptiness entertain a relationship of object of abandonment to antidote, is because their objects, their respective objects are antithetical or discordant. The object of the grasping at a self of persons is a self of persons that is discordant or antithetical with the object of the wisdom realizing emptiness, which is emptiness. So one has a basis, the other does not. The basis means reality. Let’s take an easy example.
Let us take the grasping at permanence which apprehends the permanence of the table versus the mind apprehending the impermanence of the table. Do you understand? So between these two, the grasping at permanence which apprehends the permanence of the table, and the apprehension of the impermanence of the table, which is the object of abandonment and which is the antidote. The object to be abandoned is the grasping at the permanence of the table and the antidote is the wisdom that realizes the impermanence of the table. So we say that the apprehension which grasps the impermanence of the table is an antidote, and that the grasping at permanence, apprehending the permanence of the table is an object of abandonment.
One in other words is the antidote, the other is the object of abandonment. Their mutual relation is similar to that which Geshe-la evoked earlier for emptiness. So if we take the grasping at permanence, which apprehends the permanence of the table table, the reason for which it is an object of abandonment is because its own object, which is this permanence of the table, is not something which is in contact with reality. On the other on the other hand, the wisdom which realizes the impermanence of the table has an object which is in contact with reality. So here one must understand clearly through reasoning why the table is impermanent and not permanent and generate a conviction in this.
To understand, So let us try to apply this. Is bodhicitta the antidote to anger or not? Is anger the object of abandonment of bodhicitta or not? So if you’re going to say that bodhicitta is the antidote to to anger, you have to give a good reason for this. Why?
Okay, so the development of bodhicitta is to develop love and compassion towards all sentient beings. And if you have anger in your mind towards another or other sentient beings, that is the opposite to bodhicitta in your mind stream. So that is why I say that bodhicitta is an antidote to anger. Just adding because anger harms other beings. So that is it for antidotes and objects of abandonment.
You do understand that the afflicted mind proceeds to full enlightenment, do you understand? So the afflicted mind therefore proceeds to full enlightenment and becomes the wisdom of equality. The alaya vijnana as we saw proceeds to full enlightenment and becomes the mirror like wisdom. Does anger proceed to full enlightenment? Proceed.
Proceed. To go in other words. I’m going to argue yes because if you don’t understand the experience of anger, then what reason would you have to develop bodhicitta and to develop the antidote to that in your mind stream? Because if you haven’t got anger you wouldn’t need to develop it. So yes, in that respect it does proceed to enlightenment.
So you’re saying anger becomes enlightened? So is there an enlightenment of anger or not? Do all the afflictions exemplified by anger, all the other afflictions become or attain eventually enlightenment, do they become in other words enlightened wisdoms or not? You lost the debate. So if you’re going to say that anger does not reach full enlightenment or that this this mindset of anger does not become enlightened, what’s the reason?
Anyway, quick quick. I would say that it does reach enlightenment, that all the afflictions reach enlightenment. Really? So the afflictions are not objects of abandonment. Just like the Sorry?
They become transformed. So it’s a difficult one, but as far as the afflicted mind is concerned, the afflicted mind reaches full enlightenment and becomes the wisdom of equality. Then why do we say that the afflicted mind is abandoned? When we say that the afflicted mind is abandoned, what is being said is that within the nine mental factors associated with the afflicted mind, the four last ones are abandoned. So let us meditate on this during a couple of minutes, and then we will have the recitations.
Page one. So now during the discussion session, Geshe-la would like you to discuss two topics. The first is, as we saw, both the afflicted mind and the mind basis of all proceed until full and utter enlightenment. Then if this is so, especially if the afflicted mind proceeds until full and utter enlightenment, do or do not anger, and therefore the other afflictions do the same. The second topic is relationship between antidotes and objects of abandonment.
Some of you said that bodhicitta is the antidote to anger. Then if bodhicitta is the antidote to anger, the same line of reasoning means that bodhicitta is the antidote to every affliction. If that is the case, what is the point of the wisdom realizing emptiness? Okay. Then please if you could discuss by pairs, if it’s not possible by pairs, by groups of three.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.