1 h 10 min · 3,422 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 71-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen provides a detailed explanation of the Alaya Vijñāna, the subtle eighth consciousness central to Cittamātra philosophy, within the context of a structured study group. He begins by presenting the classical definition: an extremely stable continuum, neutral and unstained, infused by karmic imprints. Geshe explores why the Alaya Vijñāna persists continuously—present during waking, dreaming, and sleep—and contrasts it with other consciousnesses that come and go. He then addresses the philosophical puzzle of how something can be both impermanent (disintegrating moment by moment, as all consciousnesses must be) and yet described as extremely stable. The teaching includes extensive Socratic dialogue with students about dream consciousness as a non-conceptual mental awareness, the boundaries of the Alaya Vijñāna (lasting until Buddhahood), and whether it transforms into mirror-like wisdom or ceases entirely. The session clarifies that the mirror-like wisdom is not the Alaya Vijñāna itself because wisdom is virtuous while the basis mind is neutral, and wisdom holds no karmic imprints while the Alaya Vijñāna does. The teaching is pitched at practitioners already familiar with Buddhist tenet systems and requires sustained attention to subtle ontological distinctions.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 20062017cittamatra.mp3
UUID: b4bf9232-fcb8-48e5-9e97-152af2759126
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Cittamātra
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,415
So at present, regarding the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna, Geshela will give the definition in keeping with commentary, which was sent to those of you who are interested, the translation of Joe Wilson. I’ll retranslate the definition myself. The definition of the Alaya Vijñāna is an extremely stable main mind which is neutral and unstained and is posited partially as being the basis infused by the karmic imprints. Now this definition has three components. The first is extremely stable continuum.
The second is infused by the karmic imprints and the third is unstained and neutral. So this is an appropriate definition for the Alaya Vijñāna as given by Guntang Rinpoche and as mentioned, it has three components. So there are two newcomers tonight. Then for yourselves, the topic of the mind basis of all of the Alaya Vijñāna will not be easy. It is a rather difficult topic and we have been studying it for quite a while, but over time, if you attend regularly, you will understand much better.
So, here within the four systems of Buddhist tenets, the tenets system which is being explained is a Chitamatra or mind only system. Now within Guntang Rinpoche’s commentary, the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna has three subsidiary points. The first is it is an extremely stable continuum. The second is that it is the base of infusion or the infused base of the karmic imprints. And the third is it is a consciousness, which is unstained and neutral.
So regarding the first characteristic of the Alaya Vijñāna, an extremely stable continuum. This becomes evident when one understands that the Alaya Vijñāna is always present. It is present when sensory consciousnesses are present. It is present when sensory consciousnesses are absent in deep sleep or in a coma. It is also present when the remaining six consciousnesses are absent.
For this reason, it is said to be an extremely stable continuum. Continuum here refers to the continuum of the Alaya Vijñāna itself. Then the second characteristic is that it has become the base infused by the karmic imprints. And this means that it is the ground of infusion of the karmic imprints. And the third characteristic is that it is a main mind which is unstained and neutral.
Now here, unstained means it is unstained by both obstructions, the afflictive obstructions or Kleshaavarana, and the obstructions to omniscience or Jñeyāvarana. Neutral means that it is neither virtuous nor non virtuous. And main mind means that it’s a main mind from within main minds and mental factors. So now regarding the boundaries of the the Alāyavijñāna exists from the point before entering the path all the way up to for Mahāyāna beings to make it simple to the end of the continuum of the Bodhisattva. In other words, the very last instant of the tenth ground.
Now, for Hīnayāna practitioners, in as much as this school accepts the existence of three final vehicles, the Alaya Vijñāna exists all the way up to make it simple again to the end of the continuum of an arhat in whose mind a non abiding nirvana has been generated. It is important to understand that within the four schools of tenets, the Chitamatra school asserts and teaches the subtle most form of consciousness from the standpoint of the Sūtrayāna, the Alāyavijñāna. Neither the Sautrantikas nor the Vaibhāṣikas assert the existence of Alāyavijñāna, nor do for that matter, the twofold subdivisions of Mādhyamika, the Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. On the other hand, from the standpoint of the object, undeniably, the view taught in Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika is the subtle most view. So this distinction between subtlety of object and subject is a very important one to make.
Then I must say it is really remarkable that most of you attend very regularly these teachings and almost never miss except due to work obligations. As a result, you can derive great benefit from such teachings, and we are very fortunate to have a remarkable translator who makes the effort to be continually present. Such material is very difficult to translate in English, I believe, This is a rare opportunity. So I would like to say that it is exceptionally rare to get teachings on Chitamatra in the West. You are very fortunate.
While in Tibetan, there are numerous remarkable teachers and teachings on Chitamatra. In English, it is exceptional. And when I say you are fortunate, you’re obviously not fortunate from this from a monetary standpoint, but fortunate from the standpoint of your mental development. The mode of teaching adopted here is identical to that in the great monasteries. Geshela explains the topic, asks questions from those who attend and answers their doubts.
So in logic, the classical example given for a mental consciousness which is non conceptual within the mind stream of ordinary beings is dream consciousness, which is considered by Lorig to be non-conceptual. So among yourselves, I am sure the majority have had clear dreams at one point or another. Now the question is, what are these dreams? Obviously, these dreams are not sensory consciousnesses. They are mental consciousness, but what type of mental consciousness is the question?
The reason for which this doubt arises is that if we say that the dream consciousness is a mental consciousness, in other words falls into sixth category of consciousnesses, Then, as it is a subtle consciousness, just how precisely can this be? So, the reason for the awkwardness of this stance is because the mental consciousness is considered to follow upon the sensory consciousnesses. No sensory consciousness, then no input into the mental consciousness. And if this is the case, then where exactly does the dream consciousness fit in? It is certainly not the seventh consciousness, the afflicted mind, nor the eighth consciousness, the Alaya Vijñāna.
They tell us the case, do you understand? So clearly in dreams, we can recollect or be influenced by past events, but there are also very clear dreams which are pre cognitive during which we see future events and if we take careful note of these dreams, then sometimes we find that these events come to pass. In other words, this dream consciousness is a very subtle consciousness. So if I ask you, is the dream consciousness the mind basis of all, what do you answer? Why?
No? Why? The dream consciousness exists, that’s self evident. Yeah. Right?
Because the mind basis of all exists all the time but the dream consciousness doesn’t exist during the daytime. It is interrupted. So now within ordinary beings, the minds of ordinary beings, let’s set aside advanced practitioners. Non conceptual consciousnesses can be divided into two. Sensory non conceptual consciousnesses and mental non conceptual consciousnesses.
And Lorig, minds and awarenesses gives as example of mental non conceptual consciousnesses, the dream consciousness. Now precisely because Lorig gives as example of non conceptual mental consciousnesses, the dream consciousness, that means that it is not self evident and calls for careful analysis. This is based on experience. So if I ask you at present, is the mind basis of all permanent or impermanent? What do you say?
Good. So after impermanence, is it? It’s permanent until the tenth ground then it becomes impermanent, right? That’s interesting. Interesting.
So here it is clearly stated in the definition that it is an extremely stable continuum, which, as Geshela explained, lasts until the last instant of the tenth ground. However, Buddhist treatises teach that all consciousnesses are impermanent phenomena, and impermanent here means that they disintegrate instant by instant. So what precisely does this mean? So indeed Alaya Vijñāna must be impermanent and disintegrate instant by instant. But what is this mode of disintegration instant by instant?
So it is self evident that the sensory consciousnesses and the mental consciousness are impermanent and change instant by instant that we can see firsthand. Then the Alaya Vijñāna obviously is impermanent too and changes instant by instant and disintegrates instant by instant. But how it disintegrates is the problem. Then what Tenzin Drolkar said that somehow the Alaya Vijñāna is permanent until the tenth ground and becomes impermanent at the end of the tenth ground begs the question, just how does it become impermanent? It’s very good however to think in those terms.
It is permanent to the tenth ground. So if we say that the Alaya Vijñāna is impermanent, then from the standpoint of the three times, obviously we’re not talking of the past here, but as far as the future is concerned, how could it become impermanent when it had not been? And obviously, present impermanence is what we have to try to understand. So this is the Jonangpa view in Tibet, right. It is a heretic view according to which the Alaya Vijñāna is identified with the Buddha nature and is permanent.
It’s identical with Hinduism in many respects. So this is the view of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, which asserted the existence of a self or an ātman, which is obviously not our body, that would be a ridiculous view, but which is the very, very subtle consciousness and it is asserted to be permanent one and independent. The Alaya Vijñāna is impermanent, right? It is inappropriate to say it’s permanent. But it is very helpful to think about how it exists and helpful to generate doubts, you’re allowed to generate doubts.
So the way to reflect on the Alaya Vijñāna is and its boundaries is given in stanza 16 of Jetsunpa’s root text. It engages the continuum uninterruptedly until remainderless and Vajra like, page four of your root text. So here, the term remainderless refers to the remainderless nirvana of a Hīnayāna practitioner and Vajra like refers to the end of the continuum of the end of the tenth ground of a Mahāyāna practitioner. Now here when it is said that the Alaya Vijñāna lasts until the last instant of the tenth ground. It is in other words countered at the last instant of the tenth ground.
And what is meant here by countered? Do in Tibetan. The meaning is that for the Mahāyāna characteristics of the Aliyavijnana such as the fact that it is neutral and unstained are countered. However, in the case of the Hīnayāna, since the Hīnayāna asserts three final excuse me, since Chitamatra asserts three final vehicles, what is meant is that the continuum is severed, the Alāyavijñāna ceases to exist. So the Alaya Vijñāna therefore continues until the attainment of full enlightenment and at that point it becomes the mirror like wisdom.
Then whether the Alaya Vijñāna is the mirror like wisdom or not is something we have to examine. Yes or no? So here when I ask you this sort of question, you have to immediately check the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna and ask yourself whether, in this case, a mirror like wisdom satisfies the definition or not. This is how he always taught us to examine these questions. He said, check the definition, check whether there is necessary entailment or not.
It’s an important piece of advice. So therefore the Alaya Vijñāna exists until the attainment of the state of an Ārya Buddha. And the question which is to be addressed is whether the mirror like wisdom which it turns into is the Alaya Vijñāna or not, and it’s addressed in terms of consequences. It follows that the mirror like wisdom is the Aliyah Vijñāna or it follows that the mirror like wisdom is not the Alaya Vijñāna because in both cases, a reason must be advanced. Yes or no?
So is mirror like wisdom the ālaya vijnana or not? I’m asking you what it is and what it isn’t. I think the answer is yes because Because I was under the impression that the sixth sense, the sixth consciousness is actually, is the one converted into pure light enlightenment. Into what? Sorry, Sixth, sixth consciousness is the one becoming enlightened once you actually become the Buddha.
But I don’t think that’s the case. And then definitely the sensory consciousnesses are not. When you become a Buddha, they are not the one actually becoming enlightened, tending to realized wisdom. So if you rule them out one by one, you are left with mind basis of all which will be converted into a pure light wisdom when you become Buddha. I’m asking you whether the mirror like wisdom is the or not?
I would say no. And that’s because it relates to the karmic imprints because with my very limited knowledge of what happens at the full and enlightenment, I imagine that karmic imprints are really not something that occur. Buddha could do no no karmic imprints. Yes. It’s okay.
This is just a guess in terms of Yes or no? No. Because You guys are really bad at answering questions. You know that. You’re just fishing So for the answer is no because Alaya Vijñāna is neutral and the Buddha is in the nature of compassion.
That’s okay. Good. Yes. You can pass it. Yeah.
In other words, the Alaya Vijnana must be a neutral mind. Okay. Okay. That’s okay. Mhmm.
I think yes. I think yes because pure light wisdom it is mutual because it’s free of attachments. So I’m thinking it is the same nature as Alaya Vijñāna. It still holds the karmic imprints. It is extremely stable.
I would like to say no and suggest that the Alaya Vijnana is the substantial cause of the mirror like wisdom. Yes. Yes. That’s a good answer. I was thinking as well, I imagine with Buddhahood you don’t transmigrate like the Alaya Vijñāna does.
Yes, it’s good, good idea. I think you read something on book, is it? Oh, good. Good. Good.
And Can you ask some? Another. Another. Awesome. Do the Buddhas have karmic imprints?
I from I can’t remember the name of the sūtra. One day, Buddha actually suffered from a headache. And Ānanda was asking why you actually suffered from a headache and Buddha answers that because in all my previous lives I was a village boy which I hit, or actually hit a fish on the head for three times, that’s why I suffered from my headache. So if Buddha doesn’t have the karmic imprints, where does the suffering come from? So, from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna, not all statements in sūtra are literal.
Then Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika consider that all statements in the sūtra they accept are literal. From the standpoint of these two schools, that statement of Buddha would refer to physical suffering, which Buddha would still experience, but obviously there would be from the standpoint of these two schools, no mental suffering. Such passages from sūtra exist. Okay. So now from the standpoint of Buddhist texts, the reason for which the mirror like wisdom is not the Alaya Vijñāna is twofold.
Generally speaking, indeed, the continuum of the Alaya Vijñāna continues until the last instant of the tenth ground and then transforms into the mirror like wisdom. The mirror like wisdom is not the Alaya Vijñāna, First, because the Alaya Vijñāna is neutral according to the definition and the mirror like wisdom is not neutral, it is virtuous. And secondly, because the Alaya Vijñāna is the basis infused by the karmic imprints and the mirror like wisdom is not because at full enlightenment there are no karmic imprints. Then let us at present meditate during a couple minutes on the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna to deepen our understanding. Preview page one one b.
Page five, number six, verse one and the three. So at present, what is the definition of the mind basis of all the Alaya Vijñāna? Quick. Quick. Quick.
Please. This is what we came up with last week. Mark, Shane, and myself. The Alaya Vijñāna is a stable neutral consciousness infused with karmic imprints posited as the person who transmigrates. Good.
Good. Good. An extremely stable continuum infused by the karmic imprints, unstained and neutral. So we have finished the presentation of the Alaya Vijñāna basis of all and next week Geshela will begin presenting the supported basis of all, in other words, the seeds and the karmic imprints, their mode of infusion and so forth. Then we will examine how the karmic imprints are infused, are they infused by the coarse mental consciousness, what they are infused in the aliyah viznana, how they awaken within the aliyah viznana and so forth.
Geshela would like to thank you for your good answers to his questions on Alaya Vijñāna. You answered well. You were able to give good definitions. Thank you. Mhmm.
And then I have your question. Few question, you know. Yeah. Quick, please. Geshela said last week that the person doesn’t exist primordially.
If the mind basis of all is substantially existent which is what Geshela also said last week, does this mean that it exists primordially? According to Chitamatra, the mind basis of all is truly established and the mind basis of what exists primordially. So if the person, if the mind basis of all is an instant of the person, then it would follow that the person would also exist primordially which is what Geshela said it doesn’t. Yeah, yeah, that’s okay. Yes, you could say that in Tibetan.
Really? I’m just trying to reconcile it too. Because in Chitamatra, all composite phenomena are said to be truly established. Quick, quick, quick. Quick, quick, quick.
Another go. Why Could you Could you energy? Yeah. How can the mind basis of all be described as a stable base for the karmic imprints, but at the same time be disintegrating moment by moment? So now in the definition when we say that the continuum is extremely stable, what this means is that this continuum is not at times a consciousness, at times a karmic imprint, at times something else.
It is continually a consciousness. This is what’s being said. Geshela, I just want to ask you, as as you progress on the path to enlightenment, is the progress along the way? So I reformulated your question to make it clearer. What I asked is the case was, is it the case that the Alāyavijñāna develops qualities along the path in the same way ordinary consciousnesses?
And that is not the case. The Alaya Vijnana remains, excuse me, neutral until the attainment of full full enlightenment at which point it becomes the mirror like wisdom. So when we say being is, in becoming a first ground Bodhisattva, which part of consciousness actually changed? Which part of consciousness actually becomes the first ground Bodhisattva? So what improves as you progress on the path is the mental consciousness.
That is what obtains the first ground. The Alaya Vijñāna you let be, it does not change. I just really find it really hard to understand. You sort of have this sudden change when you reach full enlightenment in terms of from an Alaya Vijñāna point of view, you sort of, you don’t, you become stable or sort of stable, and then when you reach fully enlightened, become a fully enlightened being, you sort of all of a sudden it just changes. To me that just, for our family is really hard to understand.
So can you explain further, please? So this is a very good question. There are numerous doubts about this. It is indeed the case that the Alaya Vijñāna remains neutral until the last instant of the tenth ground and then becomes a mirror like wisdom, but there is no precise explanation of how this happens in sūtra. In tantra there is.
Okay, quick. Oh, origin. Yep. Trying to understand how the Alaya Vijñāna changes from moment to moment. Is it on the basis that it comprises the ground on which karmic imprints are infused and that because these are the infusion occurs from moment to moment, therefore that ground is changed from moment to moment, and therefore, the Alaya Vijñāna does.
Yes. It is the principal reason on the basis of which we can say that the Alaya Vijñāna is impermanent, otherwise there’s no particular reason to assert this. Okay, thank you. So very good. At present discussion or debate, please debate the definition of the Alaya Vijñāna which Geshela gave tonight.
And you understand that the Alaya Vijñāna is impermanent, but please discuss why it is impermanent and why some people might think it is permanent. Okay. Please quick, no time you know. So we have no time, please.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- non-abiding nirvana apratisthitanirvana (Skt); mi nä pä nyang dä (Tib)
- According to the Prasangika school, this is the nirvana of a buddha, free from both samsara and the nirvana of a Hinayana arhat; one of the three types of nirvana, or liberation... LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
- The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Which part of consciousness actually becomes the first ground Bodhisattva?
The mental consciousness is what improves as one progresses on the path, and it is the mental consciousness that obtains the first ground. The Alaya Vijñāna, by contrast, is simply left as it is, because it does not change.