1 h 36 min · 3,843 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that impermanence means momentary change, not only destruction, and that composite phenomena, including consciousness, have no first beginning, which supports past and future lives. It covers how causes and conditions (potentiating, substantial, and cooperative) increase or decrease bodhicitta and afflictions. Questions follow on whether consciousness can end and whether separate consciousnesses blend.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 36m
UUID: d7485654-4e09-4438-a809-d7c0d494ba3e
Words: 3,839
Mhmm. So at present, we will, as usual, meditate during during a couple of minutes. And before meditating, let us check our minds. And if our minds are virtuous, then let us be delighted. And if they are not, then we have to find a means make them virtuous once again.
So here, one should engage in an overview meditation on what one has done, especially what one has done during the weekend and maybe the days before this one on Tuesday. And if one has engaged in non virtuous deeds, then one should purify them through the application of the four antidotes, the four forces. Then this is a very, very nice way of proceeding. One should look at one’s deeds and enumerate the non virtuous deeds one has done. And if one has engaged in virtuous deeds, then rejoice.
Then if one is ordained, then one must purify broken secondary vows every fifteen days in or. Then if one is not ordained, ideally, one should confess and purify one’s faults every morning. Yeah. I wish. This is a form of analytical meditation.
As you know, there are two types of meditations, analytical and concentration or fixative meditation. Then here, it is important to see one’s faults as faults. And once one has seen one’s faults as faults to generate repentance. Let us now meditate during a couple of minutes. Mhmm.
And so I want to ask you what you meditated upon. I would point out it is rather strange that to meditate is a verb, whereas meditation is a noun. And we would never say, for instance, that a table is meditation. But we do hear things like emptiness is meditation, bodhicitta is meditation, and so forth. Do you remember?
Do you remember? So if the table is not gonna be meditation, then there are not many reasons for which impermanence would be meditation. Impermanence is not meditation, what exactly do you meditate upon? Maybe there’s no topic of meditation. Do you understand?
You see, we all talk about meditation, but we say casually that emptiness is meditation, bodhicitta is meditation, compassion, definite emergence are meditation, but we don’t say table is meditation. Then if we take the case of impermanence by now, we should all have a clear sense of what impermanence is. Impermanence is a moment It is moment by moment destruction. And when we meditate on impermanence, we are not looking on some type of exterior object. We are reflecting on the meaning of this.
Then there are multiple ways of proceeding. As you know, one can focus either on exterior objects or on interior mental objects. So when we speak of impermanence, we are referring to change, and there are two modes of change. There is progressive upward improvement, and there is also progressive downward deterioration and degeneration. I like, you know, talk about tomato.
Tomato. Tomato. Tomato. Tomato. I really like tomato.
Oh, really? Okay. Also like tomato. Okay. Tomato.
Oh, yeah. A different I know. Tomato. I said to Gishna, in The US, it’s tomato. Over here, it’s tomato.
So if we take tomatoes, tomatoes are impermanent phenomenon. They become. Then there are two modes of becoming. They can improve or they can deteriorate. In either case, becoming is contingent on conditions.
If the conditions are not present, there is no becoming.
So when tomatoes are planted in a field, for the tomatoes tomatoes to increase in size, conditions are required. If these conditions are not gathered, then the tomato does not increase in size nor does it for that matter decrease in size. Without these cooperative conditions, the tomato remains of one substance of similar type? It is a substantial cause which merely continues in time. Just just for example, you know, So what precisely are these conditions for the tomatoes to grow?
Conditions such as water, manure, warmth, light, and so forth are necessary. Likewise, for the tomatoes to eventually be destroyed, to degenerate, other conditions such as, for instance, being cast in the fire are necessary. All exterior material phenomena are similar to tomatoes without exceptions. They need conditions to improve or deteriorate. So let us now take interior phenomena such as, for instance, bodhicitta.
Bodhicitta does not increase by itself. For bodhicitta to increase, conditions other than bodhicitta are indispensable. So this is probably something you know at present for bodhicitta to increase. Conditions are required. What are these conditions?
So great compassion is therefore necessary for bodhicitta to increase, but so is for that matter the wisdom realizing emptiness. Mhmm. So for bodhicitta to degenerate and to be destroyed, what is required? What He’s anger. Yeah.
What are the conditions for bodhicitta to degenerate? So bodhicitta by itself neither increases nor decreases. Decreases. Conditions are required. So the conditions for increase have been given.
What are the conditions for decrease? No. No veggies. Excuse me. I don’t understand what you’re saying.
So bodhicitta neither increases nor degenerates or dwindles by itself. Conditions are required for both. In the case of increase, bodhicitta requires conditions which are concordant with it, in other words, with great compassion. For Bodhicitta to degenerate, it requires a condition which is discordant with it, and self cherishing is the antidote, if you wish, the opposite of Bodhicitta. Therefore, self cherishing increases, bodhicitta decreases.
So it is a mistake to believe that impermanence always means the destruction of the continuum. This is only coarse impermanence. Actually, there are two aspects to impermanence or becoming. You have a becoming, which is an enhancement, an evolution, an improvement, and you have a becoming, a degeneration, a destruction. Therefore, impermanence refers to momentary destruction or momentariness.
However, when we speak of impermanence casually, we seem always to refer to the destruction of the continuum to degeneration. This is not the case. There are two forms of becoming. We have becoming, which is improvement, and we have becoming, which is degeneration. So in the case of impermanence, therefore, impermanence does not always refer to a process of disintegration ending with destruction.
Now the question we should address is, as far as impermanent phenomena are concerned, do they all have an end or not? The answer is, broadly speaking, yes. Do they all have a beginning or not? From that standpoint, the answer is, broadly speaking, no. So once one understands clearly that impermanent phenomena such as consciousness have no limit to their beginning, then this is very powerful to gain an understanding of the existence of past lives.
And once one understands the existence of past lives, then the existence of future lives is fairly self evident. So this whole issue of past and future lives is extremely important. So there are a variety of impermanent phenomena. The question at present is, do all have a final end or not? Certainly, for form, the first category of impermanent phenomena, most forms have an end.
For instance, if we take the table in front of Geshe-la, if this table is put in the fire, which is not the case, then this table will be destroyed. And therefore, for coarse forms, we can posit an end of that entity. Then as far as mind or consciousness is concerned, is there a final end to mind or consciousness? It is very difficult to posit something like that. It would create numerous problems.
So if we take consciousness, we can see that at times, it is virtuous. At times, it is neutral. And then it turns into a non virtuous mind, then it comes back to neutrality. But actually, there is no end. So there are numerous levels of consciousness, coarser and more subtle, and it is a subtle consciousnesses which transmigrate.
Now if one were to assert that there was an end to the continuum of consciousness, then this actually would be illogical. There are no logical reasons for this. And as says in his essence of eloquence on the interpretable and the definitive, a person which accepts tenets which are at odds with reason is not a person which is a valid cognizer. Then we have to understand that while we ourselves are present, we also contain within ourselves a continuum of consciousness. And this continuum of consciousness is endless.
Endless. It is because this continuum of consciousness is endless that there are future lives. And once we understand this, we can understand that even if in this life we are unable through the practice of virtue to attain liberation or full enlightenment over time in future lives, this will happen. Otherwise, if one does not believe in the furtherance of the continuum and believes that it is severed as death as a string is cut, then isn’t this a source of great fear?
Then for every one of us in this room knows that he or she will necessarily die, we are all profoundly convinced that we will need a very long life. This is a clear case of grasping at one’s own permanence. Then if one is convinced of the existence of future lives, the process of death becomes a very smooth, a very peaceful process. Because as one dies, one thinks of the virtue one has accumulated, and then one can generate the feeling that one will be reborn in a higher realm. Otherwise, death is a source of great fear.
Then here, it is one’s own past and future lives which matter, and these are positively dependent on one’s own mental continuum. Then as you know, Buddha Śākyamūni taught in his sutras the existence of three categories of conditions, immutable conditions, potentiating conditions. Impermanent conditions. Then these were developed by Ārya Asaṇga in his works. And Asaṇga points out that immutable conditions refer to conditions such as the creation of this world by God, by Ishwara, whose mind is said to be immutable.
Impermanent conditions refers to the fact that all composite phenomena are in and of themselves impermanent. Potentiating conditions refers to the fact that phenomena can only give rise to other phenomena of a similar type with themselves and cannot give rise to phenomena of a discordant type. Now there’s a lot of food for thought here. So of these three, the most important for us is potentiating condition. Once we understand that every phenomenon can only arise from another phenomenon which is of similar type with itself, we can understand why all composite phenomena cannot have a first beginning.
If they had a first beginning, let us say if this table had a first beginning, then there would be a point before which this table would have no cause. Now this table is a thing. It is an effect thing. As such, it necessarily has a cause. If we take this table, we can trace it back in time to the wood which constitutes a table and further back to an indefinite stream of substances without beginning.
So these are the rationales for which there is no first beginning for composite phenomena. If there were, there would be numerous logical contradictions. Then if we take ourselves, we as persons are on the basis of our continuum of consciousness. And these this is the reason or these are the reasons for which this continuum of consciousness is said to have no first beginning. Then if we were to say, for instance, that our own continuum of consciousness is substantial cause was the continuum of consciousnesses of our two parents, then there would be numerous logical contradictions as I explained last time.
Then if we take the conception if we take the consciousness at the very instant of our own conception, then that consciousness is neither permanent nor is it causeless. It actually has a cause, a substantial cause, which is of a similar type to it, and this leads us directly to previous lives. So this is the reason for which as we move backwards in time from the time of our own conception, there are limitless previous lives. Some of them were lives in the higher realms and some lives in the lower realms. So what I would like you to reflect upon is the fact that all composite phenomena have no first beginning.
There is no boundary to the beginning of composite phenomena and this therefore applies to the continuum of consciousness, is which beginningless. Once we understand this, then it is possible to explain generating bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold causal instruction. Once we understand through these explanations the existence of past lives, then it becomes, for instance, very easy to understand the origin of the afflictions within our own mind stream at the level of the past shared with the being of the middling scope. It also becomes much easier to understand the process of generation of bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold causal instruction at the level of the path of the being of the great scope. Then, to be frank with you, the foundation of the is an understanding of past and future lives.
It is very difficult to explain the Lam Rim without this as a foundation. However, it is quite awkward when we are asked just how precisely do past and future lives exist, Why are they there? To be completely unable to give an answer. So this short commentary was given for this reason. And that’s why if someone challenges you and says what or who precisely was your previous life, and you’re stumped for an answer.
Or if they ask you, well, what precisely is your substantial cause? And you say, well, my parents, then really that’s quite an embarrassment. So at present, in the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect on the fact that all composite phenomena are beginningless. Some of them have an end, as well as the purpose and the mode of existence of impermanence. And if we do so, then this will give rise to meaningful questions.
Okay. Let us meditate it. Yeah. Please open the page one. You know, page one b, two b, four.
And also page five, another six, monthly opening. Last one and then three. So even though we have finished presenting the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope, nonetheless, the notions of causality of substantial cause of cooperative condition and of continuum of the same type were not presented in great detail. And through presenting these notions, it then becomes much easier to understand how the afflictions within our mind stream arise, and since they are impermanent and arise from substantial causes and cooperative conditions, how to counter them. Otherwise, we face the danger of thinking that they cannot be eliminated.
Normally, we do the practice of confession and restraint before going to sleep. But if we forget, then we do it in the morning. This is a question from a couple of weeks ago. Geshe la taught that Bodhicitta, without its object of observation being sentient beings, the would disappear at the end of that, but if there are still my question is if there are still the objects of observation being sent to sentient beings are present, but they’ve all attained full enlightenment, what would happen to the bodhicitta of them? There’s a lot of debates about this in the second volume of Paths and Grounds of Perfection Mhmm.
About what happens when all sentient beings attain full enlightenment. When all sentient beings attain full enlightenment, there’s no sentient beings. Therefore, there is no great compassion. Then what precisely exists is debated. So what I would encourage you to do is to focus on improving your own mind, and this is a long and painstaking process.
It does not happen rapidly like taking a book within one’s hand, but it is something which exists, which does occur over time. Maybe your doubt, Ilya, is that there is a degeneration of bodhicitta at the time when all sentient beings have attained full enlightenment, and that’s not the case. Mhmm. Bodhicitta merely ceases to exist because its object no longer exists. It does not generate.
Big different. You know? Yeah. Got it. Many different.
Thank god. Yep. Next question. So if you ask questions, things will become clearer. Yeah.
Very important. You know? I like I like to answer. You know? Matthew.
Ilya, why is it at odds with reason that consciousness has an end? So the way to look at it is as follows. The continuum of consciousness is an impermanent phenomenon, and therefore, both to improve and to disappear, it requires conditions other than itself. Then if we were to say that the continuum of consciousness can disappear, we would have to posit conditions which can cause this disappearance, and there aren’t any we can posit. For this reason, this view is said to be at odds with reasoning.
Geshe la, when you talk about consciousness, you talk about it as if each consciousness is an individual thing that continues throughout time in that there are many, many consciousnesses in each of us. It has just one consciousness in our continuum, sort of much like if you have a bag of marbles, you can distinguish between each marble. Why is it that consciousness is understood as discrete entities rather than consciousness being understood as, for example, something like water, where you can put two glasses of water into a bowl and that you still have the same amount of water. You still have water that is has always has always been there all throughout time and will continue to be there throughout time. But that as you you can have a larger or smaller amount of water rather than there being individual if you put two marbles in a bowl, you still only have two marbles.
If you put two cups of water in a bowl, you have a larger amount of water. Why is it that consciousness is Why is the nature of consciousness so that it is individual items rather than like water? Where is it? It’s a sort of substance. You speak Geshe la’s doubt is the one I had when I was listening to you.
Are you talking of individual consciousnesses of different people? Yes. Or are you talking of individual consciousnesses within one mind stream? Individual consciousnesses of different people.
That’s a very straightforward answer. The reason for which Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen’s continuum and my mental continuum are different is because right now, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen does not know what I think, and right now, I do not know what he thinks. So these are two different mental continuums. They do not blend. So the reason for which there is such a difference is because consciousness is unobstructive.
Now if we take the example you gave of water in a bowl, we first pour one glass of water in the bowl and then another, then precisely because these two are formed, we are actually at the end of the process unable to distinguish which comes from which. That if consciousness is mixed or blended, then Gesheera would understand right now my thoughts, and I would understand right now his thoughts. Perhaps at the time of transmigration, consciousness is not contained within a body. It says, what is it about the nature of consciousness that keeps individual consciousnesses separate at the time that they transmigrate rather than being able to suppose I’m trying to get some idea of what is the nature of consciousness, and I’m speaking from a person who has spent most of their life in scientific environment. So in a scientific environment, you have some things that are individual objects and some things that are a substance.
I’m trying to understand I’m trying to get to some understanding of the nature of consciousness and whether When water is being held in two separate glasses, then the water doesn’t mix and end So Keshe la’s explanation that Geshe la doesn’t understand Illya’s thoughts, and Ilya doesn’t understand, isn’t aware of Geshe la’s thoughts. That could be explained by, at that time, consciousness being contained within two separate vessels. Is consciousness able to mix during transmigration? And if not, what is it about consciousness that keeps consciousness as separate? So the reason for which the consciousness of Bardo beings do not blend or mix is exactly the same as the reason Gesheera gave previously.
The crux here is that consciousness is not matter. It is not form. It is not something which can be perceived by the senses. If the consciousnesses of Bardo beings blended, we would become all one and the same. You’re welcome.
So yours are good doubts. Do keep in mind the subdivision of impermanent phenomena into forms, consciousnesses, and non associated compositional phenomena. Then these three are different. And if forms and consciousnesses were one and the same, then indeed, as you say, consciousnesses could become one. That’s not the case.
And then we have to investigate the nature of consciousness. Could it be, because the the continuum is separate because each continuum is not of similar type to the other. So substantial causes have to be of similar type to continue. Yes. Definitely, you can say that these are different mental continuums because their substantial causes are different.
I want to clarify something, There are conjoined twins. They share brains. Mhmm. One brain. Mhmm.
And, you know, all of them. But, clearly, this is two consciousnesses, isn’t it, to continue? Right? And do they blend? Do they blend?
Mhmm. Yes. So those for those cases where you have children with one brain, one heart, then the continuum of consciousness is different. Mhmm. Got it.
They are born from the fertilized ovum of one set of parents, but the continuance of consciousness are not the same. These are two persons. Two separate persons. Two Two two persons. They they have the same karma, and they share the same brain, and they’re doing the same?
No. You can’t say they have the same They have the same brain. Yes. Not the same. Well, in the case of the five aggregates, they would all be different, wouldn’t they?
The form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness. The mind is one of the the the composition excuse me. The brain is one of the same. Okay. Just one question.
You are family. No? What do Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika posit as the cessation of consciousness at the time of liberation? So it’s a good doubt. The schools which assert this include one of the Chitamatra subschools, and they assert that since to be reborn in cyclic existence, you need the cooperative condition of the afflictions.
And since for an arhat the afflictions have been extinguished, then there can be no rebirth in cyclic existence. Therefore, they state that the consciousness is severed. Okay. Thank you. Good good question.
But I will check, you know, also. Check. Check. Check. Check.
Check. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What happens to bodhicitta once all sentient beings have attained full enlightenment and there are no beings left to benefit?
This is debated at length in the second volume of Paths and Grounds of Perfection. When all sentient beings attain full enlightenment, there are no sentient beings, so there is no great compassion. What precisely exists then is debated. The advice is to focus on improving one's own mind, which is a long and painstaking process. It does not happen quickly, like taking a book in one's hand, but it does occur over time. Bodhicitta does not degenerate when all sentient beings are enlightened. It merely ceases to exist because its object no longer exists, and it does not generate. These are very different.
Why is it said to be at odds with reason that the continuum of consciousness could come to an end?
The continuum of consciousness is an impermanent phenomenon. Because it is impermanent, both for it to improve and for it to disappear, it requires conditions other than itself. So if one claims that the continuum of consciousness can disappear, one must be able to posit conditions that could cause that disappearance. No such conditions can be posited. For this reason, the view that consciousness has an end is said to be at odds with reasoning.