4,248 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. Continues a teaching on the practice of the being of the small scope, centred on meditation on death and impermanence, including the three roots of death meditation. It links this to karma, renunciation and the transition to the path of the being of the middling scope, and to the aggregates as the basis of imputation of the self. Audience questions are answered throughout.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: b913614c-9102-4412-be10-f48a9d30c86b
Words: 4,244
Have a good lunch? Yes. Good. Alright. Then, if one has time as much as is possible, when one gets up in the morning, one should meditate on the stages of the practice of the being of the small scope, specifically on death and impermanence.
And then if one has commitments to recite, whether it is Yamāntaka, Vajrayoginī or Guhyasamāja for that matter, then it is very helpful for one’s mind if one memorizes one’s commitments as much as is possible. Then as this is highest yoga tantra, it is difficult for us to understand the complete meaning. Otherwise, if you don’t meditate a bit on the practice of the being of a small scope, generates some motivation. When you recite your commitments, you’ll be racing through the text, checking your watch all the time. You know how to read, you know how to read this type of material.
We have talked about it a bit. This will be very beneficial. At the beginning when you think about it, it is quite difficult. But if you go over it again and again, it is really beneficial. Then once one has meditated correctly on death and impermanence, and here we are talking of course impermanence, as a result of these meditations one’s desires will decrease and one’s contentment would increase.
So the decrease in desire and the increase in contentment, one will be able to think effectively about karma and causality, and as a result, one will engage in the practice of virtue and one will be able to abandon non virtue. Then as a result of these reflections on karma and causality, we will protect the law, the law of the dharma and the law of the land. And then, if we’re abiding by the law of the land, then all of us as human beings will progressively extend our view to this whole world of ours. Then, once something like this happens, you have no work left to do. Right?
And once the law is respected like this on a global scale, then there is no need for police. There’s no need for disciplinarians in the monasteries, for those to take care of the elderly and whatnot. And then one’s own happiness, the happiness of others, the happiness of this life and the happiness of future lives will all occur. There’s a Tibetan in this expression in this respect, excellences for here and thereafter, here refers to this life, chi, thereafter refers to future life, so in dependence on good behavior in this life, one can expect excellences in future lives. Then it is said in Buddhist scriptures that every single sentient being has the Buddha type, sometimes called the Buddha nature.
Then if we reflect on this we can see how the teachings could spread throughout the entire world, but it would take a lot of time. So this is what I wanted to present regarding the practice of the being of the small scope. And if you have questions regarding the practice of the being of the small scope, I will take them now. Do we really need to have all the lights on? It makes it quite hot, doesn’t it?
I don’t need light. Pardon? No thanks. Yeah honey? I’m wondering about the power of prayer.
Now in the Christian tradition, as most many of us here probably been brought up with Christian I must ask you to speak louder, yes. Many of us have been brought up in the Christian tradition and the power of prayer is encouraged. Earlier during question time you made some mention of whispering into the ear of a dying dog but that doesn’t have any effect whatsoever. So is the power of prayer seen more as a benefit to the person doing the praying to put them into a conducive mind? Then there are two types of prayers, there are general prayers and dedications.
Dedications would be for instance to dedicate the merit one has accumulated for the sake of a goal such as the attainment of full enlightenment. In the case of prayers, it is a bit complicated. Basically, the substantial cause which is being dedicated can indeed be of benefit in some cases. Chris? I have a question from the teaching this morning but it’s not specifically about the small scope.
Is that okay for me to ask that? The line was mentioned at the beginning of the text for the seven stanzas of mind training. It starts with when envied by others, which sounded very beautiful. Was just wondering if Geshela could elaborate on that. The stanza reads, when others out of envy or spite berate or abuse me, may I accept their criticism without rejoinder.
This is a very powerful practice which comes into its place within the equalization and interchange of self and others. When Geshela speaks about meditation on death and dying can he expand on whether we just need to stick to considering our own death because in my practice when I consider imminent deaths from people that are close to me it generates sadness I’m not entirely sure I understand what sadness actually is and I’d like to avoid it but I’m not sure if this is possible. Initially, one should focus on one’s own death and impermanence, and when a strong sense of one’s own death and impermanence has been generated, if one then meditates on the death and impermanence of others, according to Buddhist scriptures, this is the gateway to compassion for them. Initially therefore, one should focus on one’s own death. And when a strong sense of this has arisen, one can extend this realization to others.
As is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, what hope does one have to help others when one cannot even begin to help oneself? Hi Geshela, my question relates a little bit to the lineage and to the particular text that you’re relying on. As I understand it the seven point mind training, the author is Geshe Chekawa. There’s a few different editions such as Togmeh Zangpo and Pabongka Rinpoche. So two questions the first is who or what edition are you teaching from today?
And the second question I just wanted to clarify who Serlingpa was who had the lineage of Nāgārjuna, Asaṇga, Maitreya and Śāntideva. Is that Atisha’s Guru Serlingpa? I thought so. So I just have the first question then. Then the root text is obviously Geshe Chekawa’s Sevenfold Mind Training.
And I initially relied on Pabongka Rinpoche’s commentary, but then also developed my own analysis of the text. I have one more question and it’s probably a premature question but it’s to do with the ordering. I remember when Geshela taught the 37 practices of the bodhisattva by Togme Zangpo talked about and dependent arising or realization of dependent arising or emptiness or something like that giving rise to bodhichitta and I noticed that Togme Zangpo puts the ultimate awakening mind verse first whereas Geshe Chekawa puts it last. May be too premature to ask this but I was just wondering if Geshe could comment on that. There are many reasons, but if I were to explain them out, I’m afraid we would run out of time.
Can you open the windows? A little bit dark. Yeah, yeah, and another? Another, yeah. In a nutshell, most of the great Indian Śāstras, the great Indian commentaries explain ultimate bodhichitta first and conventional bodhichitta afterwards, because their intended trainees are trainees of sharp acumen, for which this is the best means of explanation.
The Lamrim treatises all the way from Lamrim Chemo, Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the path, back to its source, Atisha’s Bodhipathapradīpa, the lamp for the path, all explain conventional bodhichitta first and ultimate bodhichitta afterwards, because their intended trainees are trainees of dull acumen. Thank you. So minister Dalai Lama mentioned that a general presentation of the Buddhist teachings is one in which ultimate bodhichitta is presented first and conventional bodhichitta is presented after, but specific presentation for individual trainees is one in which conventional bodhichitta is presented first and ultimate bodhichitta is presented afterwards. He mentioned this in this year’s or last year’s teaching. He mentioned this during the teachings at Sera at the end of last year in 2013.
Chris behind you, Richard. Geshela, I’m asking about meditation on death as part of the small scope practice. Is this Geshela’s point of view, in terms of assistance in the practice, in the meditation on death, There’s the certainty of death. There’s the fact that death can occur at any age and at any time and there’s meditating on the different modes of death. Is there also as part of this practice within the small scope meditating on the process of death or other are the other things to be meditating on as part of meditation on death?
The main meditation on death is meditation on the three roots, in other words, the certainty of death, the uncertainty of the time of death, and the fact that at the time of death apart from dharma nothing is of benefit, then apart from this there obviously are other methods of meditation on death. As Je Tsongkhapa says regarding mind training, if definiteness regarding death and impermanence does not occur, even when one is sleeping, then it will not be possible to engage consistently in the practice of virtue. In a nutshell, if the recollection or the thought of death does not occur, the recollection of virtue will not occur. Even should it occur, it will be contaminated with the affairs of this life. Geshele, is there benefit in studying and practising karma and causality with the death meditation to add force to practice that there is a consequence of not working quickly on death?
There is definite benefit in meditating on death and impermanence and karma and causality within one meditative session, because they benefit each other. As is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the path, this human rebirth is rare and life is short, therefore counter the attractions of this life. Therefore, the meditations on the precious human rebirth are not circumscribed to the path of the being of the small scope, but usher the other paths. This is explicitly mentioned by Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche in his commentary on the three principles of the path. A lot of our discussions today on death and impermanence, we talk about the suffering and the regret that people go through at the time of death.
What if someone that dies suddenly doesn’t have that opportunity to experience that regret or in the case where someone is highly medicated how does that affect one’s process of death? It’s difficult to say. Those who had some type of connection with the Buddhist teachings, with the dharma, might have such thoughts at the time of their death. As for the others, probably just fear. Then someone who dies suddenly in this way will have a great fear, which arises from the sensation of abandoning his body and everything being left behind him.
Clearly, if we are dealing with a person who has engaged in dharma practice well, then there may be a sensation of happiness and rejoicing at the thought of the virtue accumulated and the good rebirth which will be obtained. Dharma begins with the next life. Therefore the benefits of dharma at the time of death are definite in this matter, because we are reassured regarding future lives. Geshela with my past associations with the Theravada tradition when we did meditations on death we often got told to reflect on the body parts and to the grossness of the body even to the pus and the feces and so is this useful to do as a death meditation? By grossness you mean filth, right?
The filth, yes. These are very beneficial practices. One can for instance meditate on the four characteristics of our body, which is that it is impermanent suffering, selfless and empty as well. Geluk is not the only tradition out there, right? It is the same.
The basis of the Theravada and the Mahāyāna are identical. It is the Four Noble Truths and the 37 limbs of enlightenment. 37 limbs of enlightenment. I have heard of a practice called Chod I’ve never received any instructions on how to engage in it nor have I received instructions that I should engage in it. Is it a very dangerous practice?
Is it something that you should be quite wary of? So the practice of Chod, in other words of cutting or severing, is an extremely beneficial practice which is designed to counter self cherishing and grasping at the self through offering one’s aggregates. Geschla offered an instruction at last Wednesday’s teaching of breathing three through the right three through the left and three through both nostrils. What I’ve done is I’ve used three through the right three through the left breathed exactly as he’s instructed but used the three roots of meditation on death inevitability of death the uncertainty of the time of death and the fact that nothing but Dharma will help I’ve just independently decided this. Is this an appropriate practice to do or not?
Yes, I think because in the practice of the nine cycles of breathing one focuses on the flow of breath outward and inwards, and this flow is indeed impermanent, that you could reflect on this basis on impermanence. Therefore could I also reflect on rather than a breath meditation the thought of each breath is is one breath closer to my death? Yes, definitely. There’s some sort of a connection, isn’t there? There are, I heard of a few monks that as part of their daily routine they take off any ornaments or any items that they may have at nighttime in case they die during their sleep.
And that’s as a casual reminder to them or a constant reminder to them of the impermanence they have. What kind of peripheral things could we adopt in our lives that could be used to augment that practice? The best practice between meditative sessions if you want to foster your recollection of death and impermanence is a constant abandonment of non virtue and practice of virtue while recollecting death. This fosters as well a sense of karma and causality. Then in dependence on this, your understanding of karma and causality will arise.
Alright. And are you tight? Little bit? Really? Then, since we have now generated within our mind stream the path of the being of the small scope, we will set it aside and we can be called from now on beings of the small scope.
REPRESENTATIVE:] Beings of the small scope. Aloha has become a being of the small scope. Then having completed the practice of the being of the small scope, there is no definiteness, there is no certainty that one will engage in the practice of the being of the middling scope, since there are many practitioners who remain all along on the path of the being of the small scope. However in our case, since our goal is the Mahāyāna practice, we must effect this transition to the practice of the being of the middling scope. How do you propose to effect this transition and why?
Think for yourselves. Then I was joking previously when I said we have finished the practice of the being of the small scope. Since I have no idea if there is any one of us who has actually engaged in the practice of the being of the small scope and is a fully characterized practitioner of the small scope. You have to check for yourselves within yourselves. Yeah, so just joking, you know.
So we have to now reflect on how to operate this transition from the being of the small scope to the being of the middle scope. Now when we speak of Lamrim or the stages of the path, we are speaking of stages which are incremental, how do we pass from one stage to the other. In your cases, you have received numerous teachings on Lamrim, you are highly familiar with it. Therefore, it is very helpful to think of these terms and you should ask yourself, how do these transitions occur? Why does one pass to the practice of the being of the middling scope?
Then let us say we have completed the practices of the being of the small scope, and we are at the point of entering the practice of the being of the middling scope, how does this happen and why? What is the relationship? And please, one answer, one answer per person. Just one answer. So I’m thinking is that once we’ve achieved the small scope practices that we gain liberation and then within that liberation we witness the suffering of others and because we have achieved liberation then we are able to show others Which liberation?
Of suffering of death and impermanence and of the aggregates of this bodily life. I’m not sure of the words. One. Just one end here. Also, just one.
Chondrus. Yes. Renunciation. In short. I’ve not been getting any of these answers right, but I’m not discouraged.
Perhaps one deepens one’s reflection on impermanence to subtle impermanence and then one deepens one’s reflection on karma and causality to come to understand dependent arising and perhaps deepens one’s investigation of the cause of suffering and then based on those three thoughts, the subtle impermanence, dependent arising, one decides to cut the root of existence, that being ignorance. Is it having become aware of your certainty of your own death that you developed compassion for others who are in the same situation that others will certainly die. Alright, enough. I was asking you why having reached the end of the practice of the being of the small scope, one entered the practice of the being of the middling scope. All of you seem to be discarding, literally kicking away the practice of the being of the small scope, that’s not the case, right?
You should take it with you. So one must reflect by oneself then study text and blend the reflection in the study. The best is when the authentic states which are described in the texts are states which we encounter with our minds. And therefore, why does a Lam Rim practitioner enter into practice of the being of the middling scope? Our hope during our practice of the being of the small scope is to attain a stable state of happiness.
This cannot be attained by the practice of the being of the small scope. Then I ask you these questions so that when an answer is provided, it remains stably within your minds. As Nāgārjuna says in his Ratnāvali, from non virtue, suffering and lower rebirth, whereas from virtue, happiness and happy future rebirth. We need a stable form of happiness, in other words nirvana, the transcendence of our plight. In our cases we can see that our bodies follow our minds, our minds follow delusions, and delusions follow ignorance.
Then if our bodies are under the sway of our minds, our minds are under the sway of afflictions, and afflictions are under the sway of both self cherishing and grasping at a self, which themselves are under the sway of ignorance, none of this can lead to stable happiness. Then one must understand that there is no stable happiness based on contaminated aggregates like the ones we have. In other words, saṃsāra or the Tibetan term for saṃsāra korwa, which means literally the wheel. And on this basis, one generates a wish to be freed, to be liberated from these aggregates, these contaminated aggregates. As Je Tsongkhapa says in the foundation of all good qualities, the root of all suffering is birth.
Understanding this, we try to eliminate the contaminated aggregates which are the root of all suffering. Indeed, it is to feed these contaminated aggregates that we eat, that we fill our stomachs, it is to protect these contaminated aggregates that we go to all the trouble to get a house and so forth. So this is something we have to examine for ourselves and generate conviction for ourselves. Likewise, as is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s Song of Realization, without striving at understanding the thoughts of the truth of suffering, one will not generate the mind striving for liberation. As is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, practice contentment through covering yourself with the minimum and eating the least.
And therefore, one should train in contentment and as is said, if one practices contentment, one will experience great benefit. And as I said in the Lama Chöpa, having abandoned the perception of this prison of cyclic existence as akin to a pleasure grove, One in turn seeing one’s aggregates as the root of suffering will generate the wish to be freed from them. Then seeing one’s contaminated aggregates as the root of suffering, one will ask from what causes and conditions they arise. One will then see that they arise from the noble truth of the origin of suffering. In other words, from self cherishing and grasping at a self and will endeavor to counter these.
And when such a wish to be freed from one’s contaminated aggregates arrives spontaneously even in the dream state, one will have generated renunciation. As is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the Path, when through repeated habituation, the mind wishing for liberation from cyclic existence arises spontaneously even in the dream state, at that point uncontrived renunciation will have been born. It is also of great benefit to view one’s contaminated aggregates as a field within which all of the delusions such as envy, competitiveness, jealousy, and so forth arise through the cooperative condition of self cherishing. When such an authentic practice has been generated, then one will have gained the realization of renunciation or the path of the being of middling scope. Then, once one has generated within one’s mind stream an uncontrived path of the being of the small scope, one can probably say that attachment to things has been countered.
In keeping with the verse in Je Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the path through recollecting the precious human rebirth and the shortness of one’s lifespan, turn away from the vanities of this life. And in keeping with the following two verses of this stanza, through recollecting karma and causality over and again, turn away from the vanities or the figments of future lives. Here, the vanity or the figments of future lives refer among others to our aggregates. In other words, in this process, one turns away from one’s aggregates. If we divide craving, craving can be subdivided into two, craving for exterior phenomena and craving for interior phenomena.
Craving for exterior phenomena, in other words things, is eliminated during the path of the being of the small scope. Craving for interior phenomena, in other words, our aggregates, is eliminated during the path of the being of the middling scope. In this context, in the practice of the being of the small scope, one is speaking not of countering the vanities or the figments which one is attached to, but the attachment or the predilection one has for these. It is not a case of casting away everything one owns. When during the practice of the being of the small scope, one is able to counter powerfully the apprehension of one’s own permanence, one is countering the apprehension of the permanence of one’s aggregates, and in so doing, one’s understanding and eventually realization of impermanence will be fostered.
This enables one eventually to understand the impermanence of persons, since persons are imputations which are engaged in on the basis of the aggregates, which are their basis of imputation. When we meditate on death and impermanence, we are meditating on the transitoriness of the aggregates, which are the basis of imputation of the self. We are not actually meditating on the emptiness of permanence, oneness, and independence of the person imputed on that. Right? In my case, many years ago my hair was black, but now it is in majority white.
Then when old friends meet me, they tell me my goodness, you have grown grown old, most of your hair is white. And therefore, if in the context of such meditations, one reflects carefully on the basis of imputation, which are the aggregates, then it is extremely beneficial for oneself. Otherwise, if one sets the aggregates on one side and oneself on another side, and one considers the emptiness of a permanent unitary and independent person autonomously, it’s a very different state of affairs. Then to take my own example, when my aggregate of form engages in the activity of eating, people say Geshela is eating, When my aggregate of form engages in the activity of drinking, people say is drinking, and they impute these activities upon myself. Sorry.
I was thinking that he was four thirty, see, he was going straight through. We’ve been going on for more than one hour, haven’t we? So it is therefore important to understand that there is an understanding of the emptiness of the person as a permanent one and independent at the level of the path of the being of the small scope. Then I will take questions tomorrow.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- chöd chö (Tib)
- A tantric practice aimed at destroying self-grasping, where the practitioner visualizes dissecting and distributing the parts of the ordinary body to spirits and other beings as a feast offering. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.