6,318 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The talk teaches calm abiding (shamatha) practice, beginning with the importance of a good motivation and dedication of merit. It then explains the nine mental abidings, the six forces and four mental applications, and the faults of sinking and agitation. The talk closes with students’ questions on meditation technique, such as using an object, keeping the eyes open, and visualizing the Buddha.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 3a7082c0-d128-4071-8693-3e574ba439da
Words: 6,314
So initially regarding the generation of the motivation, whether we are effective in our practice of virtuous deeds or not is contingent on the intensity with which we engage in virtuous behavior. Therefore, we engage in virtuous deeds, we must meet and be sure to generate the motivation of compassion of bodhichitta, actualize the deed and complete the deed. And the reason this is extremely important is because the non virtuous deeds we engage in are complete deeds with a strong motivation, a deed and a completion of the deed. And the reason for which it is therefore so important is because if non-virtuous deeds are the most powerful or dominant within our mind stream, they will lead us to lower rebirths in our future life. Whereas if virtuous deeds are dominant or the most powerful within our mind stream, they will lead us to happy rebirths.
Case of non virtuous deeds, no effort whatsoever is needed to give rise to complete deeds. The motivation is present, the actual deed is present and the deed is completed. In the case of non virtuous deeds, it is through a powerful habituation over countless past lives that we engage so easily and so completely into them. On the other hand, the reason for which when we engage in virtuous deeds, we do so in a very fragmented and incomplete way with inadequate motivation, the deed not fully performed and the deed not completed is because of lack of habituation in past lives. And therefore, if in this life we do not put effort at accumulating complete virtuous deeds, since we have a large habituation with non virtuous deeds and they are powerfully present within our mind, there is a great risk that we will be reborn in the lower realms in our next life.
And therefore I hope that during these three days teachings on calm abiding, all of us will put effort in creating complete virtuous deeds with a pure motivation at the beginning, an actual deed in the middle, and a completed deed through dedication at the end. So to do this, it is clear that there will be a little bit of hardship. But when one is trying to achieve a great goal, a little bit of hardship should be no problem. As for those who have preferred to stay at home and to relax, it might seem at first sight as the better option until we realize that not only are their minds probably not at peace, but it is very difficult to say that such a life is a meaningful life. And all those who are extremely wealthy may have some short term happiness.
It is very difficult to see how money is actually going to lead to long-term happiness and it is certain they will experience difficulties at the time of death. Then there is a certain type of person who undergoes no or makes no effort whatsoever and just enjoys the wealth they have living in comfort and at ease. Then there is a sarcastic proverb at Sera Je which is quite effective. Not cloaking oneself with the dharma is comfortable, isn’t it? And the meaning of this proverb is that for until one has died, such a life is comfortable when the time of death comes, discomfort ceases completely.
And therefore, if we can think a little bit about future lives and put effort for them in this life, this will be profoundly meaningful. It is the same thing as accepting suffering such as the suffering of injections or of an operation to rid ourselves of dangerous disease. Whether we are born in the higher or in the lower realms in future lives depends exclusively on whether virtuous deeds or non virtuous deeds are more important in this life. And there may be some doubt regarding the situation of those in whose minds virtuous deeds and non virtuous deeds are of equal force. In that case generally it is the deeds with which one has greater or to which one has greater accustomation or habit which carries the day.
And if the quality of virtuous and non virtuous deeds is the same and the level of habituation to each is the same, it is actually the deeds which have been performed the first which carry the day. And if one has performed non virtuous deeds first, they cause a rebirth into the lower realms. It is rare to be in a situation where virtuous and non virtuous deeds are both of equal strengths and one is equally accustomed to both. And therefore, we can have definite hope that if virtuous deeds are dominant within our mind stream, we will be reborn in the higher realms. And therefore these teachings we are receiving at present on training in concentration and generating śamatha will be of benefit at the time of our death.
If at the time of our death we are able to generate an even slight compassion or sense of love for others, it is definite we will be reborn in the higher realms. And whether this happens or not is contingent on the degree of habituation we have with these mindsets in this life. If we are accustomed to thinking in this way, in this life, we will be able to do so at the time of death. Otherwise, no. And if we do not put such effort in training our minds in love and compassion now, this simply will not happen.
We can see for ourselves that due to the very slightest condition, powerful desire and anger arise with great ease within our minds. This is due to strong habituation in previous lives. This is why I wanted all of us to try to meditate yesterday and practice concentration a bit. It makes very clear the extremely low level we are at since despite the efforts we made, not one of us was more than a ranked beginner in training and concentration. And therefore, if we do actually train in concentration, this training in concentration will accompany us in the future.
Likewise, if we train in love and compassion, eventually they will manifest even within our dreams. Therefore, habituation habit is extremely important. And the arbitration we should engage with is becoming accustomed to virtuous deeds. In the case of non virtuous deeds, we have spent countless past lives becoming accustomed to them. But because at present, have the opportunity to do something different, this is the moment to seize the opportunity.
Ideally, we should generate a motivation of love and compassion. If that is not possible, the middling motivation is one of renunciation from cyclic existence. If that is not possible, at the very least, we should generate the wish to have a higher rebirth. It is critical that our motivation be linked to one of these three motivations. Unfortunately, at present, our motivation tends to be overwhelmingly linked with the happiness of this life which is completely inappropriate.
We should discard this motivation which wishes for happiness and material welfare in this life and instead focus at the very least on attaining happiness in future lives. If we do so, our happiness in this life will naturally and in an ancillary fashion be taken care of. For instance, if we compare on the one hand a yogi who is living in dismal conditions with poor clothing and poor food but who dedicates himself to meditation and the inhabitant of a capital city with the best luxuries the West can afford. In my personal opinion, the yogi who is dedicating himself to happiness will probably be a happier person than the Westerner living in the lap of luxury. And therefore it is critical at the beginning to generate a good motivation.
In addition to this, after generating a good motivation, the actual deed must be performed carefully. For instance, if we recite the 100 deities of Tuśita, the Ganden Hagyama and we recite it in an absent minded fashion with a distracted mind while doing something else, the deed itself will not be complete. For instance, among Tibetans, it is quite common to see that when people attend His Holiness’s teachings, they tend to doze off and therefore actually do not gain any benefit from the teachings. Others of a different disposition spend their time during the teachings chatting of meaningless topics. In either case, they have not gained benefit from the teachings.
Westerners on the other hand in Geshela’s experience have an excellent attitude during his holiness’s teachings. The moment his holiness starts to teach, they sit in meditation posture like this. Now what as to what is actually happening in their minds? That Geshela does not know. Whenever Geshela has seen Westerners going to Tibetan Buddhist temples, he has always been amazed at the posture they adopt.
They all sit like great yogis and realized masters in the meditation posture. But as to what exactly is going on in their minds, Geshela has substantial reservations. Then to meditate, one must know how to meditate. If however, without knowing how to meditate, one adopts such a pose, This amounts to deceitful meditation. I believe that if we train our minds in concentration, then when we wish to give rise to compassion within our mind stream, this training in concentration will be extraordinarily helpful.
And this training in compassion is critically important. And at the end, the dedication of the merits which we have accumulated to all sentient beings attaining a lasting state of happiness after we ourselves attain the state of full enlightenment is critically important. If the merit which we have accumulated is dedicated as a cause to our attainment of full enlightenment, then it will not be extinguished until we attain full enlightenment and it will yield its results until then. If for instance at present we have a good financial situation, this is the result of having practiced generosity in previous lives. If we dedicate our deeds of generosity to attaining full enlightenment as a cause for the attainment of full enlightenment, they will not be exhausted until we attain full enlightenment.
If we therefore dedicate our virtuous deeds of generosity, of ethics, or forbearance to attaining the state of full enlightenment, they will not be exhausted until we attain the state of full enlightenment. However, many favorable results we experience from them. And the example which is traditionally given for this is that if we place a drop of water in the ocean, then until the ocean itself has ceased to exist, we cannot say that the drop of water has ceased to exist. It is therefore extremely important to dedicate to the state the attainment of the state of full enlightenment whatever virtue we accumulate. And then if whatever virtue we have accumulated is accumulated with sound preparation, sound deed, and sound conclusion, then these virtuous deeds become powerful.
If we have accumulated a large number of powerful virtuous deeds, then they will overwhelm whatever non virtuous deeds we may have accumulated and we will be reborn in future lives in the higher realms. And Geshela sincerely hopes that we will all meet in future lives in Adelaide and that we will meet here with better financial situations, better health, and in greater happiness. Or there are numerous fields, Buddha fields, in which one is bereft of suffering. This absence of suffering is temporary and it lasts for the duration of one’s stay in the Buddha field. However, if we are reborn in this world life after life as a human being, we can put great effort at the practice of virtue life after life.
Generally speaking, are two types of higher rebirths. Rebirth as a human being or rebirth as a god or a deity. If one is reborn as a god or a deity, there is very little if any suffering. However, because of that there is very little thought of dharma or religious practice. This is why the practitioners, the great practitioners make prayers to be reborn as human beings.
Precisely because if one is reborn as a human being, one experiences a fair bit of suffering and this suffering acts as a needle impelling us to practice one’s dharma. And we can see this directly in the fact that even here, those who have easy lives and who are well off tend to have no connection to the dharma and not to practice. On the other hand, if within one’s continuum there is some difficulty or some suffering, then one tends to be interested in the dharma. And therefore, we should not be worried about being taking a rebirth in which there may be some short term suffering. And therefore, since this is the second day of the teachings on calm abiding, please dedicate the merits which you will accumulate today through attending these teachings to attaining the state of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings as vast in number as space.
And to do this, one must initially give rise to bodhichitta. In other words, the wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. This must be done through taking a pledge or an oath. And this pledge or this oath in turn arises when one wishes to attain bodhichitta. Therefore, please generate this wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings and meditate on this for one minute.
If we meditate on this, we will generate the supreme motivation from within the three motivations. So calm abiding can be attained through abandoning five faults by means of the eight antidotes. And calm abiding therefore can be attained through clearly identifying at first the five faults as well as the respective antidotes for each of the five thoughts and then applying these antidotes when the five faults arise. The first of these five thoughts is a thought which arises when we apply ourselves to concentration. The second of the five faults arises after our initial application to concentration.
The third fault arises especially during the first, second, and third mental abidings after engaging in calm training in calm abiding. The fourth fault non application of the antidotes occurs when the third fault, in other words, sinking and agitation has occurred and the antidotes to sinking and agitation have not been applied. And the last fault, the intemperate application of the antidotes occurs when neither of the faults of sinking nor agitation is present. Concentration is proceeding well and yet one applies intemperately the antidotes. And through progressively abandoning these five faults, one progresses upwards from the first mental abiding all the way up to the ninth.
This progression occurs through the application of the six forces and the four mental applications. It is therefore important to understand which of the six forces has to be applied at each moment of the progression upwards. Although I have already explained within the context of the nine mental abidings which of the forces and the mental applications are involved, I shall re explain this at present in a concise fashion. And one shall proceed from the first mental abiding all the way up to the ninth mental abiding. The ninth mental abiding is known as setting in meditative equipoise.
It can also simply be known as single pointed concentration. During the eighth mental abiding, the mind has excellent concentration. However, initial effort is required to set it on its object after which it remains indefinitely or for as long as one wish on its object of concentration. During the ninth mental abiding, however, even the slightest amount of effort is not required to set the mind on its object of observation. Instead, it takes up its object of observation and remains on it.
Whereas such a single pointed concentration is a single pointed concentration of the desire realm. When calm abiding is obtained, it is a concentration of the higher realms. And therefore the ninth mental abiding is a concentration which is bereft of effort. Concentration in which the mind effortlessly engages its object of concentration and remains on it can be compared to reciting one’s commitments when one is highly accustomed to them and they just flow naturally. Since this example is only meaningful for those of you who have been reciting commitments for a long time, Geshela will give another example more relevant to the rest of us.
And the example would be if we are accustomed to reciting, then as soon as we start a rosary, we just keep on reciting without thinking about it. Geshela, I hope this is something which is more familiar with to you. He can’t say for sure. But the third example which we suspect will be relevant to everybody is if we are accustomed to gossip and meaningless chatter. Then the moment we meet somebody without any particular forethought, the gossip and the chatter just flows spontaneously out of our mouths, doesn’t And such people are not really terribly interested in whether the other party is actually listening to what they say or not.
There is this constant flow of speech coming out of their mouths. We do have such examples in the monastery. There are some monks who keep talking to you, literally talking at you even when you are writing, it seems to be irrelevant whether you’re listening or not. And this is therefore the criterion for attainment of the ninth mental abiding when the mind naturally and spontaneously enters in concentration without any effort. It’s very simple.
If there is some benefit to listening to what the person says, one should listen to it. And if there isn’t, one shouldn’t listen to it. Is that not the case? Really there’s not an awful lot you can do apart from trying to find means to reduce gently the flow of speech you’re on the receiving end of. Apart from that, there’s very little one can do.
Wouldn’t it be appropriate in such cases to say to such a person, I have actually some work I have to attend to or I’m terribly sorry, I have an appointment I have to go to and try to leave without giving rise to anger. Apart from that, I have no answer for you. And therefore, once one has attained the ninth mental abiding, one has excellent concentration. So this ninth mental abiding is said to be concordant with calm abiding. And it is realized through the force of several familiarization.
So this is the complete explanation of the nine mental abidings and I shall re explain concisely how each of the mental abidings arises in function of each of the six forces and each of the four mental applications. Returning to the first mental abiding, during the first mental abiding, we can place our minds on the object but it cannot stay there continuously. Then in your opinion, have we obtained the first mental abiding or have we not obtained the first mental abiding? Then one can only say that the practice of concentration starts when one has attained the first mental abiding in which the mind is actually set on the object. After that we’re in the preliminaries.
Then you can see it’s rather difficult to ascertain the actual criterion of attaining the first mental abiding. However, once we actually are sure that we have set our mind on the object of observation and in addition, we notice this great increase in conceptual activity of which Geshela spoke yesterday, then we can be sure we have attained the first mental abiding. When we train in concentration, we become aware of the very high level of conceptual activities within our minds. This is one of the criterions of having attained the first mental abiding. It is said in the treatises that the criterion for the first mental abiding is unawareness of the great level of conceptual activity within our mind stream.
And the criterion for the second mental abiding is that there is occasionally conceptual activity and occasionally not. When there is, the conceptions are quite intense. And it is said that the criterion for the third mental abiding, in other words, repeated application is that conceptual activity decreases sharply and for this reason, the treatises say that conceptions are tired. And therefore the difference between the first and the second mental abiding is the continuity of placement of the mind on the object of observation. And the difference between the second and the third mental abiding is the amount of time the mind is distracted from the object of observation During the second mental abiding, it spends a lot of time distracted from its object of observation.
During the third mental abiding, it spends little time distracted from its object of observation. The difference between the third and the fourth mental abiding is that in the third mental abiding, the object of observation can still be lost. One can still forget it. Whereas during the fourth mental abiding, in other words, close placement, the object of observation is no longer lost. It can no longer be forgotten.
The difference between the fourth and the fifth mental abiding is that during the fourth mental abiding, coarse sinking still occurs. During the fifth mental abiding, there is no coarse sinking anymore. The difference between the fifth and the sixth mental abiding is that during the fifth mental abiding, subtle sinking still occurs while during the sixth mental abiding, it is no longer a danger. An additional difference is that during the sixth mental abiding, subtle agitation which was present during the fifth mental abiding is much rarer. The difference between the sixth and the seventh mental abiding is that during the sixth mental abiding, it still, one still has to put some effort to make sure that neither subtle sinking nor subtle agitation occurs or during the seventh mental abiding, close pacification, such effort is no longer required.
During the seventh mental abiding close pacification, there still does exist both subtle sinking and subtle agitation. Whereas during the eighth mental placement, single pointed placement, both subtle sinking and subtle agitation have completely ceased to exist. The difference between the eighth and the ninth mental abiding is that during the eighth mental abiding, some effort is required to set the mind on its object of observation or during the ninth mental abiding setting in meditative equipoise, no effort is required to set the object, the mind on its object of observation. These are the differences between each of the nine stages of mental abiding. To progress on these nine stages of mental abiding, one must apply incrementally these six forces.
The foremost force to be applied during the first mental abiding is the force of hearing. And the reason for which the force of hearing must be applied during the first mental abiding mental placement is because to engage in the first mental abiding mental placement, one must have heard the instructions of the spiritual teacher. Generally speaking, one can present three types of minds. The mind arisen from hearing, thinking, and meditation. The threefold sequence of hearing, thinking, and meditating is extremely important.
And the wisdom arisen from hearing refers to that wisdom which occurs upon having listened to numerous treatises and teachings. And that repeated reflection on the meaning of what was heard is what is known as thinking arisen wisdom arisen from thinking. Therefore, when generating the wisdom arisen from thinking, it is important to rely on numerous lines of reasoning. However, to do this, it is indispensable to have initially heard teachings. Then if one has not received teachings from numerous gurus and virtuous friends, it is not possible to give rise to the wisdom which has arisen from thinking and then one cannot give rise to the wisdom arisen from meditation.
The best if one has a possibility is to actually hear the teachings from the mouth of the spiritual teacher. However, if one is unable to do so, one doesn’t have the time, then it is concordant with that or in keeping with that to read the teachings on the topic. Therefore, it is extremely important initially to generate the wisdom arisen from hearing and after this to analyze critically and in great depth what one has heard, the teachings one has received from one’s guru or one’s spiritual friend. If these teachings are true, if they are in keeping with reality, then in turn one puts them into practice and meditates on them. If they are not true, if they are forced, if they are not in keeping with reality, then one sets them aside and does not practice them.
These are the instructions of Buddha Śākyamūni. Then after carefully analyzing logically and using empirical data whether or not these teachings are in keeping with reason and are true, if we find they are true, then we should meditate on them over and again until the experience of the teachings becomes a direct experience for us in the same way as Geshela says, he’s seeing his own cup of tea. If we just reflect on things based on faith, this direct experience is not accessible to us. It is therefore through analysis and after this through repeated meditation that we can actually hope to perceive things in a naked way in the way they actually are directly. And therefore, meditating on what one has understood through thinking is extremely important.
Therefore, the second mental abiding continuous placement arises through the force of thinking. In other words, it is through thinking over and again on how to train concentration that one is able to reach the second mental abiding. The third and the fourth mental abiding, which are called repeated placement and close placement arise through the force of memory or recollection. Memory or recollection is a specific mental factor whose function is the capacity to prevent forgetting a previously experienced object. And therefore, the third and the fourth mental abidings, which are repeated placement and close placement arise through the force of memory or recollection.
And during the third mental abiding repeated placement, the force of memory must be applied powerfully. Whereas during the fourth mental placement, close placement, it is no longer necessary to apply it powerfully. The fifth and the sixth mental abiding, in other words, taming and pacification occur through the force of vigilance. During the fifth mental abiding, taming, the force of vigilance must be powerful to check whether or not sinking or agitation have arisen. Whereas during the sixth mental abiding, the force of vigilance progressively ceases since this is no longer necessary.
The seventh and eighth mental abiding, in other words, close pacification and single pointedness arise in dependence on the force of enthusiasm. Enthusiasm refers to that delight with which we engage in whichever virtuous object. Then the mistaken mind of delight which engages in non virtue is mistaken enthusiasm, wrong enthusiasm. The very nature of enthusiasm is to be virtuous. Just as the very nature of happiness is to be virtuous.
And therefore, the force of enthusiasm must be powerfully present during the seventh mental abiding close pacification and progressively dwindles during the eighth mental abiding single pointed placement. The ninth mental placement meditative equipoise or equal placement occurs under the power of the force of thorough habituation. Then I explained yesterday in detail the connection between the nine mental abidings and the six forces. I have re explained it today in a more concise fashion. For these six forces to be applied, we need the four mental applications or the four attentions.
The first of these attentions or mental applications is engaging through concentration. This is present during the first two mental abiding. It means one must concentrate powerfully on the object of observation. Then from the third to the seventh mental abiding, during five mental abidings, in other words, the third, the fourth, the fifth, the sixth, and the seventh, one trains relying to relying on interrupted engagement. This is called interrupted engagement because sometimes the mind engages the object, sometimes it does not.
Then during the eighth mental abiding, since the mind no longer can abandon its object, one engages the object through uninterrupted engagement. And during the ninth mental abiding, since effort is no longer necessary to even place the mind on its object of observation, the object is engaged through spontaneous effortless engagement. This is the explanation of the nine mental abidings in terms of the four attentions or the four mental applications. Since during the first two mental engagements, the power of sinking and agitation are extraordinarily strong and one loses repeatedly the object of concentration. No specific attention is dedicated here to sinking and agitation.
And one does not prefer doing these two mental abidings to an uninterrupted engagement for that reason since it is by definition uninterrupted. Instead, one refers during these two mental abidings to engaging through concentration the power of recollection. And from the third to the seventh mental abiding, the power of recollection or memory is solicited less and sinking and agitation become far more evident. Since they are far more evident, albeit occasional, one refers to the attention at this point as interrupted attention. Then during the eighth mental abiding, since even the slightest application of the antidotes guarantees that there will be neither sinking nor agitation, the eighth mental abiding is termed in terms of the four attentions, the uninterrupted attention or mental application.
And then since during the ninth mental abiding even that slight initial effort is unnecessary or unneeded, the ninth mental abiding is known as the spontaneous attention. Then this is a complete presentation of the nine mental abidings. Calm abiding itself occurs after these nine mental abidings. As a result of the nine mental abidings, we shall stop here for today and if you have questions, Geshela will address your questions at present. My first question Ilya is so you described meditative equipoise as concordant with calm abiding.
So that doesn’t mean it is calm abiding. Yes. The ninth mental abiding is not calm abiding. It is similar to calm abiding in its features of focusing continuously on the object. But it is not calm abiding.
Calm abiding arises as a result of it. Even though the ninth mental abiding, abiding in meditative equipoise or placement in equipoise is very similar to calm abiding in that the mind can stay with perfect clarity on its object of observation forever so long as it wishes to do so. It is not calm abiding because it lacks the happiness which is associated with calm abiding, which is known as pliancy. The physical and pliancies which are the characteristic of calm abiding. When one attains calm abiding, one has an extra ordinary feeling of lightness and happiness.
So light that if we were to attain calm abiding at the center, we would feel that we could fly above the cars on the street. I suspect there’d be no need for cars at that point. My second question, is in regards to the first two levels of calm abiding, the first two mental abidings. So we it sounds like we don’t need to worry too much about sinking and agitation that we just need to keep focusing on, placement on the object meditation. Okay.
Okay. Yes. My third question is, could Geshela explain what subtle agitation would be like? When subtle agitation is present, the factor of abiding is present, the factor of clarity is present but the mind or the clarity lacks intensity. So it’s a little bit like the top, holding the top of Geshela’s cup.
The top of Geshela’s cup can be held in two ways, loosely or tightly. If it’s held loosely, it is being held but it could fall. This is subtle sinking. If it is held tightly, it will not fall. That is correct apprehension.
Subtle agitation. In the case of subtle thinking, the mind is focused on the object, doesn’t lose the object but there is a subliminal tendency for the mind to move outwards towards objects of desire. This is what is known as subtle agitation.
It’s a little bit similar to what you see in the winter, at least in Tibet, where the streams are frozen over and are solid on the surface but the water is flowing under the ice. That’s it for me for the minute. Just a quick technical clarification, please, Geshela. I always thought it we we shouldn’t have our eyes completely closed when we meditate. I’m sorry?
I always thought we shouldn’t have our eyes completely as a completely open. Sorry. Uh-huh. No. No.
Completely closed when we meditate. I thought they should just be apart. Uh-huh. And I thought Geshela said yesterday, that’s what I’d like to clarify, please, that when we start placing our mind on the object, we should have our eyes closed. It’s a misunderstanding of what Geshela said yesterday.
The context as you remember was relying on the eye consciousness or the mental consciousness for generating calm abiding. Geshela said you don’t rely on the eye consciousness to generate calm abiding. But first you must observe the object, in this case the bell carefully and then you do not need to look at it anymore. However, you don’t meditate with your eyes closed. So even though you do not observe the object when you are meditating on it, before starting to meditate, you must actually memorize the features of the object and you must look at it carefully.
After that, you do not look at it. Otherwise, if you do not observe initially carefully the shape and the color of the bell and you just start meditating, the bell will not appear clearly. I meditate on the statue of the Buddha from this Gompa at home, but I don’t have a photo of this statue of Buddha Śākyamūni. Should I organise to have a photo so that I can study it more? Because when I meditate at home, I’m relying on memory.
So when I come here, I’m always looking at the statue and not. Depends on the quality of your visualization. If the image of the Buddha appears clearly during your meditation without any doubt, you don’t need a picture. However, if from time to time it is unclear then you definitely should have a picture and whenever it is unclear, you open your eyes and you check before returning to meditation. Frankly, for beginners like ourselves, if we do not have a representation of the object of meditation in front of us to check, our meditations will not be clear.
The object of meditation that I choose is the same. And my question is, should that be the main focus on the altar, the small altar I have at home? Should it actually be or does it not it doesn’t matter that it has to be on the altar because mine isn’t? Then it’s really up to you. If it’s convenient for you, you can set it on your table in front of you and check it from time to time.
Then the moment your meditation is proceeding really well and you don’t need to check it, you can put it on your altar. We have an image that we’ve So you don’t have to meditate on everything which is around the Buddha, you can eliminate that. It’s okay. You can do it either way. Either way.
In terms of studying the object before you let it go, it appropriate to apply Pabongka Rinpoche has a description of how to sit in meditation. So I got that text and then observed the object using that instruction. So it starts with the feet, the hands. So that’s how I studied the object. I looked at the feet and so I built upwards as a way.
You’re speaking of the object or of yourself? No, of the object. I sat in that place but in terms of studying the object before I so I used that small bit of text because I was just looking all over and not knowing because of television probably. So is that okay to do that? It’s conceptuality but I found it more easier to then study the object in a systematic way before I let it go.
However you want to go about it is okay. You can inspect it from the bottom up and back down or in any which way you choose to do. What matters is that it is retained and kept clearly in your mind. Geshela, I’m just wondering whether it’s a distraction when visualizing the image of the Buddha to see the light emanating from from the from the Buddha, or should it just be a bare image? Generally speaking in the Lamrim text, it is taught that one should visualize light around the body of the Buddha.
However, for us who are beginners and who are training in concentration, Geshela feels it is preferable to just visualize the body of the Buddha and have this strong recognition this is the body of the Buddha. He is afraid that if you increase the amount of labour you have to do, it will be difficult to accomplish. Then once we are accustomed to concentration, we can emphasize or expand the visualization. And we will stop here for today, and we have a question session at 01:30 and more questions at the end of the teaching today. Just to say, sorry about the inconvenience with the microphone, but Jill particularly has asked for the benefit of the transcribers because she’s recording the questions.
So for the little bit of inconvenience, thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha field buddhakshetra (Skt); sang gye kyi zhing (Tib)
- In some ways synonymous with pure land, although it can also mean any pure environment, seen as a manifestation of wisdom. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is subtle agitation like in meditation?
With subtle agitation, the factor of abiding is present and the factor of clarity is present, but the clarity lacks intensity. The mind stays focused on the object and does not lose it, but there is a subliminal tendency for the mind to move outwards towards objects of desire. An example is holding the top of a cup, which can be held loosely or tightly. Held loosely, it is held but could fall; this is subtle sinking. Held tightly, it will not fall; that is correct apprehension. Subtle agitation is also like a stream in a Tibetan winter: the surface is frozen solid, but the water is still flowing under the ice.
When we start placing the mind on the object in calm abiding meditation, should the eyes be closed?
No, this is a misunderstanding. The point was that calm abiding is not generated by relying on eye consciousness. First the object, in this case a bell, must be observed carefully, and then there is no need to keep looking at it. However, one does not meditate with the eyes closed. Even though the object is not being looked at during meditation, before starting one must look at it carefully and memorize its features, such as its shape and color. After that, one no longer looks at it. Otherwise, if the shape and color are not observed carefully at the start and one just begins meditating, the bell will not appear clearly.