TBI Recordings – 01-140418 1329

6,915 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. A Q&A session in which the teacher answers questions on taking the essence of a precious human life, the Lamrim scopes of practice, and meditation on death and impermanence. He stresses reasoning about past and future lives, daily practice, and beginning with the small-scope path, and notes that death tends to bring regret and fear. Some answers draw on the speaker’s own experiences with dying people.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: b1e2fdec-bc42-4d19-a03c-0ad9126ee7f5

Words: 6,911

Can I be delighted to take your questions and answer as best I can? Please. Okay, I guess this has to do with the small scope talking about identifying the precious human rebirth and it said take only the essence of this Wonder if you could say something about what that really means like what the essence is? And I have a second question which may be related it’s what is the five degenerations but probably the most important question is about the essence. It’s an excellent question Taking the essence of this life is basically, to put it rather bluntly, exactly the opposite of what we do.

So our main focus is this life, then if we if our focus is this life, then it is certain we’re not taking the essence of this life. Taking the essence of this life in the outline of the Lamrim includes all the paths of the three beings, the path of the being of the small, middling, great scope, because each of these paths involves taking the essence of a human rebirth in a meaningful way. If you practice as a being of the small scope, you are definitely taking the essence of this life in a meaningful way. If you are able to practice as a being of the middling scope, that is even more remarkable. And if you are able to practice as a being of the great scope that is exceptional but if one’s focus is this life then it is definite one has not taken the essence of this life Definite.

Then, to give you an idea of how difficult all of this is, I know very few fully characterized beings of the small scope. In the monasteries I don’t know a lot. In the centers I don’t know any. A fully characterized being of the small scope will practice the 10 Jewels of the Kadampa tradition. And if you read the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition, it reads a bit like a slap in the face.

Nobody practices that. Then a being of the middling scope, one of my very best friends at Sera Je, he’s a former disciplinarian of the monastery, Geshe Geshe Gawa, an old monk, real buksa Geshe, he said to me once, and this shows you how difficult these practices are, I wish I could practice as a being of the middling scope and become an arhat, but I don’t have the capacity to do so. Therefore, our claims to practice Samarayana are just that: they are claims. We’re training our minds in this direction, but to say anything more than that would be unrealistic. The five degenerations, I’m not sure I can remember them all, I’ll try.

The degeneration of the beings, a degeneration of the lifespan, a degeneration of the age, a degeneration of the afflictions. And the fifth one I have a doubt, excuse me. But you can find them in good Buddhist dictionaries, or in the index of Pabongka Rinpoche for sure. Do you have other questions? Yes, Sam, please.

Beyond the need to understand karma and causality. When I look at it to understand that death is imminent and is going to happen it requires a consequence for dying in order to give force to practice. So when I hear and when we discuss a lot about the focus on meditation sorry, meditation on death and impermanence, I wonder if that needs to be mixed also with a bit of an understanding of the consequence of dying. In the absence of that, it becomes an imminent death. And I think a lot of people get confused, including myself, that everything’s going to be Okay when we die.

And that in some cases we don’t fully comprehend as Ribur Rinpoche says, the magnitude of the poor karma, good karma that we create and the magnitude of the bad karma we create? I sincerely hope everything will be okay for you. I have seen a fair number of people die in my life and in most cases it is not okay. Didn’t there’s not a lot one can say. My father said something to me once which had stuck in my mind.

He was a very famous cancerologist, very much on the cutting edge of cancer research. Therefore, he only handled terminal cases, experimental cases, so pretty much by definition people who were referred to him would die. He was a bit of a doctor of the old school. He said, I never allow one of my patients die alone if I could be present. And then he said, you know, he was not a religious man at all.

His religion was science. He said, I have never seen a good man have a bad death. I have never seen a bad man have a good death. This is interesting. This is someone who is really speaking from experience.

Saw not like in my case, I saw ten, fifteen people die. He saw thousands. Thousands and thousands, just, you know, they would ring him up, know, so and so is terminal, can you come? That’s food for thought, isn’t it? A meditation on death and impermanence, there’s several ways to go about it.

I think one of the big problems as Westerners we have is that we have no contact with death at all. Some of us like Chris do, and you can see how remarkable Chris practice Chris’s practice has become as a result of this. Then one thing we can do is to try to find a job in an environment where we deal with death. You can volunteer I don’t know if there are volunteers in palliative care, Chris, but if there are, this is definitely something I would highly encourage you to do. You can train to work in a morgue, which is what I wanted to do when I was a novice monk.

It’s extremely beneficial for the mind to wash their bodies, you know, to clean up the filth, you know. It’ll be much more beneficial for your minds than hours spent sitting cross legged with some nebulous and abstract idea of death. And then once it’s become something real, death is something real, the second step, which is often missed when one meditates on death, whether one uses the Lamrim meditation of the three roots and the nine reasons or visualizing one’s own death, is to connect it to yourself. You can meditate for hours on death in the abstract, it’s always somebody else who is dying. It has to connect with us.

The first step is to really understand what death is, and I think for that as Westerners you have to use some pretty forceful techniques, you know, find a job, volunteer someplace to link it to your mind. The second step is to realize this is happening to me, and the clock is ticking as Geshela explained this morning. Then at that point you will want to have answers. Whether your answer is Buddhism or not that’s another question. That I cannot tell you.

It does not have to be Buddhism. Christianity, with the initial I were talking and I were talking over lunch, Christianity is incredibly beneficial for the mind. I think for a majority of simple people Christianity is easier than Buddhism, but for the thinking person there are some substantial problems with the Christian message. Buddhism is a demanding tradition, so those are the two steps as I see them Sam. The first is to actually gain some sort of direct experience, because we know in the centers that the people who have had a direct connection with death are unstoppable.

They’re the ones you never have to try to advise or counsel, they come to you for some instructions, but they want the answers and like a sword they only cut in one direction does that help a bit you have other questions Lady behind you, Chris, I think. This is a little bit of an obscure question but it relates to the witnessing of death and dying. I did ask this question of another ordained at one time and she wasn’t able to give me an answer. I live in a very rural area and I see the death and dying constantly of animals in particular. And it makes me wonder when we talk about living in a place that’s beautiful or that this indicates your karma.

If you’re living in a desert then that’s the result of your karma. I’m living in a beautiful place but I’m witnessing death constantly. What does that say about my karma? In my opinion that you have excellent karma. In my opinion that you have excellent karma.

Suffering is good and happiness is bad for spiritual practice. It’s as simple as that. People come to the center because they are suffering. If they were not suffering they would not be here. People who are happy never devote one thought to spiritual practice, especially in the West where everything is taken care of.

Then, Śāntideva said the one benefit of suffering is that it leads us to practice. It is true, in terms of spiritual practice a moderate amount of suffering or seeing suffering is of tremendous benefit and therefore it’s very much your good fortune that you live in an area where you see death and it causes you to think People who live in wealthy countries like this one, who are reborn in wealthy countries like this one, where death is actually the last taboo really, are experiencing the result of tremendous good fortune indeed, but this tremendous good fortune is leading, probably, to a fall in the lower realms. His Holiness put it very bluntly this year at Sera. He said, Yes, some at the monastery have had the good karma to be reborn as human beings and to choose to come here and become bhikshus. And then, later on, as a result of their behavior, they fall in the lower realms.

So you can see that even being reborn as a human being and becoming a monk, who is trying to eradicate non virtue, is not sufficient. Those who break their vows are reborn in the lower realms. In your case I think it’s very good, it’s a very good combination. You have a human rebirth, hopefully enough comfort and good health to be able to practice, but you do not forget what is happening. It’s very helpful.

Do you have other questions? Please, Safo. I wondered what you thought of you would think of this in meditation on impermanence and death it’s crucial my experience has been it’s crucial to have relied on the spiritual teacher because meditation on impermanence and death for example in my experience immediately takes me back to meditating on the torture of the bodhisattva Jesus not consciously but death equals torture for some for some from certain Christian traditions not consciously I don’t consciously do that but death equals torture and that’s not necessarily the case but it does increase terror but there’s something about so much terror that I don’t take refuge I forget to take refuge really quickly. So and I think that’s because I’m really weak around relying on the spiritual teacher as a prerequisite to meditation on permanence and death impermanence and death which is what the Lamrim instructs. So I wondered what you or anyone else, would think of that.

Undeniably relying on the spiritual teacher is the foundation of the path, there is no question about that. However, I suspect perhaps it is more the understanding of what happens before this life and after this life which has not fully penetrated. Because if you have a profound conviction, ideally a valid, inferentially valid cognizer, but at least a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives, once you become convinced that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death nothing but spiritual practice helps. The very next step is what do I do about it? Then, if you are paralyzed by fear when you meditate on this, obviously this is of no particular benefit, it may even be harmful, but I think it is not relying on the spiritual teacher which will help, because Buddhism is not a faith based practice.

There were two types of disciples for which the Buddha taught. The ideal disciple is a disciple of sharper acumen who understands through reasoning. Now this has to be our goal. And then, if the disciple is unable to understand through reasoning, through logic, and through experience, then the second lower category of disciple is a disciple who relies on faith. But faith is not a solid basis for practice, as we see with our Christian friends.

I mean, however much faith one may have in the saving power of Jesus, how many Christians do we know who, when faced with the tragedies of life, lose faith? Right? Faith is not a valid cognizer, to put it in terms of logic. Faith is indispensable at the beginning to get us started. Without faith nobody would even come to the center or study.

But for Westerners who are not raised as Buddhists, who have no particular connection with Buddhism, but who are generally speaking quite well educated, one can hope to practice in keeping with the superior category of disciple. In other words, practice based on reasoning. Therefore, in your case, the first step would be to study in detail the evidence for the existence of past and future lives, and there is a lot. Take Stevenson’s works, if those are a little bit too difficult, they were simplified works by Jim Tucker and others on the topic, and study them and try to understand the reasonings which are presented by Geshela demonstrating the existence of past lives, if these are reasonings you’re comfortable with, and try to generate a conviction that if the past lives existed, if past lives exist logically, so should future lives. From that point on, death, instead of becoming this terrifying abyss, becomes a door we go through to we do not know where, and the question we must answer immediately and all of us will feel the need to answer it is to where?

And then obviously do I have some control or do I have no control? Then if I have no control, then we just relax. No point in coming to this center. Right? I mean, you could spend your Easter weekend with your family on the beach.

If we have some control, you have to ask yourself of all the great religions which basically say we have some control, which is right? You cannot go through life without asking that question rather bluntly. When you buy a house, you don’t buy a house casually relying on just anyone’s advice on financial matters. So with the great religions all basically assert there is something after death, all say what we do in this life affects what comes after death, all say that basically if we behave well things will work out well, and if we don’t behave well, things will not work out well. So far there’s a consensus, and I would put it to you, it’s a huge consensus.

It’s a consensus of 20, maybe 30 centuries of human history, and of some very, very profound and often spiritually inclined people. Then you have to choose at a certain point. Does that go towards answering your question? Start by looking at the data. We are very lucky in 2014 there is data.

It’s tedious, I know. Put the lamrim aside, take Stevenson’s works, take Jim Tucker, take this material until you suddenly generate a certainty. Yes. I came from somewhere, I am going somewhere, it’s gonna happen not once but over and again. And at that point, the totality of the Lamrim connects with your mind.

Otherwise it remains up here. You have other questions? Richard, please. At the of death, whether you are reborn in the higher or lower realms, what will happen to us after death will already have been determined. We know what we have done and what we have abstained from.

We know what our mind has been filled with. Therefore, it has been decided. I suppose I want some sort of a comment on that. That’s obviously what Geshe-la has said. And going back to Sappho, suppose you’re being brought up as a Catholic and those thoughts of deathbed conversions and sudden transformations that can occur.

This, as a statement at least, appears to be some sort of a denial of that. That transformation at least of the mind is not something that can happen as death is fast approaching. Well, would put it to you, it happens almost systematically, if anything. Most of the people I have been with at the time of death have experienced great regret. Great regret.

Great regret. And great fear. All the more so because basically Chris can tell you much more than I can about this, but at the time of death, you know, death is basically a big embarrassment for the medical profession. It is seen as a sign of failure instead of the way things are. It is astonishing if you’re in a hospital that at the time of the death of a patient, there literally is nobody.

It’s quite amazing. You know, I remember hunting for doctors and nurses and just thinking, it’s interesting, like, they just vanished, you know. Deathbed conversions, you see, there is a fundamental difference in outlook between Buddhism and Christianity, but there is a large stream of commonality. Obviously, in the Christian tradition you are basically saved by faith in Jesus Christ, so faith at the last instant before dying is powerful enough through the salvific virtues of Jesus, who is a God man, to save you. Buddhists, I’m afraid, are much more realistic about the process.

If at the time of death there is tremendous regret about the non virtues committed, this is a very powerful virtuous state of mind. It purifies a lot. But it goes hand in hand with great mental disturbance. I’ve never seen a case where this was not the case. Then this, in turn, can lead at the time of death to the maturation of afflictions within the mind stream.

This can precipitate a non virtuous rebirth. The fear, the anger, the attachment to one’s relatives triggers whatever is most powerful in the mind stream. Then once one is reborn as a non human, let’s say as a dog, basically it’s over. I mean, would love to do something for our dogs, but there is absolutely nothing I can do. Then it’s very sweet and pious to recite Manis in their ear, But as a friend of mine who is a very good Geshe said, since they don’t understand a word, I’m not quite sure what the benefit is.

Once the human rebirth is over, or I’d say the higher rebirth, then unless at some distant point in the future a virtuous karmic imprint matures, we will remain stuck in the lower realms. So for that reason from a Buddhist standpoint it is now where the going is good that we should practice. Because you see, and in this matter I think Buddhism is profoundly realistic. What you have trained in while the going is good is what you will fall back upon when the going is bad. Okay?

So now we are not under pressure. In Australia we certainly are not under pressure. We have the leisure to attend teachings, we have the leisure to meditate. Now is the time to put effort because whatever the future of Australia may be, it is guaranteed that our individual future will be death. It’s guaranteed.

And then at the time of death, suppressive pressure will be huge. I don’t think you can even imagine how great it is. Not only your mental pressure, but the physical pain, and more importantly, the pain and the pressure due to the emotions of those around you, your relatives, who will be crying, who will be upset, who infect you with their own fear. At this point, if you have practiced regularly, which means basically every day for ten, fifteen, twenty, twenty five years, you can fall back onto this and you will function pretty much on autopilot, hopefully. If you haven’t, it’s very unrealistic to expect that suddenly at that point you will be able to meditate on something such as altruism, which would really help.

It’s very difficult. And then, you know, obviously, it is always said one should show the dying person a picture of their teacher. Clearly, one has to have had faith in a strong connection with one’s teacher in this life for that to be of any benefit. As is always said, the relation between the teacher and the student is that of the hook and the ring. The hook of compassion of the teacher seizes the ring of faith in the mind of the student.

Obviously, if there’s no ring, the hook of compassion obviously will try to seize, but there’s nothing to hold. So it’s now that effort has to be put. I hope that answers your question, Richard. I think there’s a big difference in this respect between Buddhism and Christianity, and one has to see where it comes from. Thank you for that.

I suppose the other surprise perhaps of the pronouncement was the use of the word decided, the word determined is an understandable one, but decided suggests that there’s somebody making a decision. Yeah, yeah, that’s what Krishna said. I guess it’s us. And in in Tibetan, the we translate to decide in English. It’s much blunder.

It means to cut the string. Who cut the string? We did. I mean, each one of us has his or her knife behind him or her. We all know what we did.

Right? Every one of us. There’s a lot of garbage. We all know what we didn’t do. Then there’s not a lot of time.

You know, people tend to come to Buddhist centers when the time is counted. Then there is enough time because Westerners tend to have decent old ages, but we can’t procrastinate too much more. We have to think, what am I going to do? Realistically, what am I going to do for myself? How am I going to do this on a daily basis?

Not from time to time with great emotion and enthusiasm for two or three days, but every day, like a clock. Tibetans always say, One’s practice should be like a great river flowing. A great river flows without obstruction continuously, every day, whether the sun shines or it rains, the river flows. That is how our practice should be. Then all of us are alone, you are alone, I am alone.

I cannot take your non virtues upon myself, nor could you take my non virtues. I would love to give you my merits, I can’t. So if you have accumulated merit, things will work out well. If you have accumulated merit and purified non virtue, even better. If you haven’t, then I can guarantee things will not work out well.

You can see even in one life, if you have a bit of life experience, you can see cases of karma maturing towards the old age of a person. They start out the golden child, there’s not many cases like that, born with a silver spoon in their mouth and they waste the opportunities and behave badly. And then suddenly it’s as if the fountain of good luck is closed. And you read this on the face of the person. The face becomes dark, wrinkled, the hair turn white.

It depends on the face turns black. And then bad luck after bad luck after bad luck. One stroke of bad luck happens coincidentally to everybody. But if you lose your job and you get cancer and you divorce and at the same time you’re depressed, then clearly that’s a little bit more bad luck than should be expected statistically. That is a sign of the exhaustion of merit.

The good karma which impelled this life is over. Then at that point, you better hurry, right? You’re running out of gas. Merit is gas, propelling the car of life. Then, when you’re running out of gas, you must accumulate more merit, if you can.

If you don’t believe in this, okay? Then you don’t do anything, you know? And you see this with people. You see this with people. I’ve seen this many times, you know.

Especially towards the end of the life, with these which are karmically heavy. Right? Like, a classic I saw quite often is abortion. Right? Abortion from Buddhist standpoint is a karmically heavy deed because one is basically it’s a deed of killing, killing a human being.

It is one’s own child, so there’s a close link, the deed the being is powerless, the deed is even heavier, and then especially in late abortions it is a very barbarous procedure, you know. Then I know knew at least two cases of women who had abortions, and later on in life, you know, and there seems to be no obvious medical connection, they got cancer of the womb. Then one was a Buddhist scholar, a student of Geoffrey Hopkins, she was extremely distressed by this because she viewed this as a connection, a karmic connection. I cannot say for sure whether it is or not, but this is how karmic connections would mature. You know, I’ve also seen many cases now of people breaking tantric vows and commitments who basically suffer from mental disturbances later on in life.

Many times I’ve seen this. Late people in Sangha, actually interestingly quite a few Sangha, you know. Then what can you do, you know? And the person always, when the mental problems arise, often full scale mental problems, know, schizophrenia. Then the person realizes something is going on and I remember one Australian nun, she came to see Kensur Rinpoche but she got a lot of vows and commitments, she had broken the lot basically, because she took too much.

This is very common. She asked me to translate for her and I said, What do you want to ask? And she said, I’ve broken all my commitments. I want Rinpoche to give me some new initiations so I have new commitments. I said, I I I will not translate for you.

I will have no no hand in this one. You broke your old commitments, you want to take new ones which you will not keep, I will not do that. We purify your old commitments and we talk. Because at a certain point as a translator you are karmically associated with these things, you know? So you see in one life, karma maturing.

Then, do you have other questions? We have fifteen minutes. Natalie, please. One of the things from the teaching this morning that I found particularly interesting, well all of it was, but this one popped out a bit and hopefully I got it down properly, that I understood that this age is difficult, it’s difficult to develop the middling scope in this degenerate time, but it’s actually in a way easier to develop the great scope. I found that quite fascinating.

It is. bodhichitta is compared to what we knew in the West in the old days as the philosophical stone. The Indians called it the elixir. I think of immortality, it was the alchemists believed that there was a stone in the West or liquid in India which transformed everything into gold. Now, obviously, it doesn’t exist, but bodhichitta is like that because bodhichitta transforms everything into virtue and the highest of virtues.

Then if one lives, let’s say, in our age, which from a Buddhist standpoint is profoundly degenerate, since most, I think, Westerners, perhaps a very large proportion of materialists, believe neither in the pre existence of the mind nor its existence after death. Most basically subscribe to an extreme form of biologism which identifies us with animals and basically glorifies desire and aggressivity, then in such an age to practice as a being of small scope is very difficult. How can you practice virtue? And to strive as a being of middling scope to escape from cyclic existence through countering desire, which everyone sees as the best of things, and anger, which everyone thinks gives you strength. You can see in the popular media the glorification of desire and anger, is extremely difficult.

But a bodhisattva dedicates himself or herself exclusively to others. Then, as Geshela mentioned this morning, when a bodhisattva sees these powerful afflictions arising, the bodhisattva immediately wishes to help others. The greater the suffering of others, the greater the bodhisattva’s wish to help. Then, from the standpoint of such a practitioner, the greater the afflictions in the outside world, the greater the merit he or she accumulates. It’s an uncommon feature of bodhichitta.

Does that answer your question? I have been really struck in today’s teaching and also on Wednesday night about the emphasis that Geshela has been placing on developing the small scope And I have to say it’s the first time I’ve really heard that emphasis in a teaching connected to the Lam Rim and that’s possibly because I haven’t really heard the teachings very well in the past but I really have been struck at the emphasis. And so obviously I’m really working to develop as a being of the small scope. But to develop, so if in the degenerate age which is going to continue, what will happen with this if we’re developing on the path from low to middling to great? What happens with that middling part in this degenerate time in terms of ability to progress on the path?

Difficult, right? There’s a distinction all of us must really understand regarding the Lamrim. It’s a distinction between the practice of the being of the small scope and the practice shared with the being of the small scope. It’s a very big distinction. It’s the same distinction as there is between someone who says, I’m flying to Perth, and someone who says, I’m flying to Paris via Perth.

The one is going on a small trip, the other is going on an international trip. Both are passing through Perth. Both have to fly from Adelaide to Perth first. So the practice of the being of the small scope begins and stops with the small scope. I’d say it’s a practice of 99% of sincere Asian Buddhists, who sincerely believe in past and future lives, are convinced of the efficacy of merit, and do everything in their power to improve their lot in future lives.

It is the minimum to be called a Buddhist. Alright? In our case, I think it is absent for many of our students at the center, and it is something we should train in. But we should train in it with the idea that it is a passage on the road to the Mahāyāna, on the road to Paris, if you wish. Everyone wants to go to Paris, right?

So I’m not sure if he wants to go to Perth, but everyone wants to go to Paris, so I took Paris as an example, that if I had told you it was on the road to, I don’t know, Alice Springs, you might not be enthusiastic. But do you do you see the difference? And the being of small scope, true being of small scope, is an exceptional practitioner. I mean, if you think of the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition, the four firsts, the Reliances, a true being of the small scope focuses his mind on the dharma, his or her mind on the dharma. Then he focuses the dharma on poverty as a beggar.

He focuses poverty on death, and he focuses death on death alone in a cave. Who do you know who practices like that? Here, do you know anybody? Right? I don’t know anybody.

In the monasteries, I know very few people who practice like this. And those are only the four first Reliences and the four first Topics, you know, and that’s a being of small scope. Middling scope, there’s nobody here who practices like that. Practitioners of the middling scope, all ordained. If you’re serious practitioner of the middling scope, by definition you ordained.

Because the main discipline for the practitioner of the middling scope is ordination, full ordination. And then for the practitioners of the great scope, then the basis of discipline varies. Ideally, it is ordination. If ordination is not possible, then because the great scope focuses on helping others, there is some latitude towards practicing as a lay person. But our focus in terms of our practice, in my private opinion, should be the practice of the being of the small scope.

And it’s what I have seen personally at TBI, what really helps a student are teachings on death and impermanence, and that is where there’s a big response, because this really is what benefits the minds of the student, those are the core teachings of the beings of the small scope, and then you have three other teachings of the being of the small scope, the suffering of the lower realms, the general and specific features of Karma, and refuge. Then in terms of one’s own practice you have to check for yourself where your mind is, so I mentioned this several times here. Present the totality or Geshela presents the totality of the Lamrim, But then we have to see where we stand on the scale, and that sometimes our teacher can tell us if we are very close to our teacher, otherwise it’s for us to assess our mind very realistically, And we should practice what corresponds to our level, not because one is preventing you from practicing great and exalted things, but because that is what will really help. I have lost track over the years of the number of students practicing Mahāmudrā and Dzogchen who no longer are Buddhists.

I have lost track. You know, here at the center, well know, easily 80 or 90% of the people who attended the teachings in 2007 are no longer coming to the center. They had bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, commitments, acceptance of Khensur Rinpoche as a teacher. Where are these people? So it’s clear that they were simply not ready for that level of teaching.

Then there are karmic imprints which mature in the future, will hopefully be helpful to them, but the truth of the matter is it’s a practice of the being of the small scope. Daily meditation on death and impermanence, then once that has been assimilated, to start to meditate on the suffering of the lower realms, and for this we have to be convinced they exist. So there there are a lot of arguments, you can find that in Stevenson, showing that the lower realms exist. And once you are convinced of this, then to start thinking about karma. A life spending this is a life well spent, You know, if in one life you manage to complete most of the meditations of the being of the small scope and to generate refuge as a rock, at your death, you are fine.

You are fine. Then in the next life you practice as a being of the middling scope, maybe that takes a couple of lives. It doesn’t happen at once. And ten, fifteen lives from now you enter the Mahāyāna. That is the way forwards.

Then people who are in a hurry, they never accomplish anything. This is true in finance, this is also true in one’s practice. Do you have any other questions? Yes, Saffron. At one point during Geshela’s teaching, you said something translating what Geshela said about at the time of death somebody utters holy Moses.

Sorry, I mistranslated. No, I no, didn’t know how to translate. In Tibetan when you want to say you are horrified, say, aka, then I really didn’t have a clue how you would say this in English. If I say, aka, you’re going to look at me as if I’ve come from the planet Mars. So I say what my mother says, but that doesn’t mean anything to you obviously.

No, no that’s not my question, that wasn’t my question. My question is amongst us there was laughter at that point and at the point you said you know you shouldn’t be laughing and something about this isn’t this isn’t I’m a part of it too so it’s not it’s not meant as anything other than an opportunity for us to consider personally what what did my laughter mean? Not like individually because it’s something about when there’s meditation on impermanence and death I can get into humour really quickly. Some of the best jokes are about death right but that’s not what we’re doing here so it’s like there’s something that happens collectively maybe I don’t know I think what just I’m noticing is what what’s I’m not sure everyone understands. I think this is a very I’m not fault finding, I’m just trying to observe.

This is a very good question, I thought about it and I thought about it over lunch because I was hearing you all laughing in the room there, you know. Then it’s a sign of one thing, which is that you haven’t integrated the practice, right? Because take my word for it, if you actually meditate correctly on this, you will be close to tears. Right? It is said that the criterion for realization of death and impermanence is that you want to jump off your cushion with horror.

When you have actually an experience in meditation, that’s what happens. Then I’ve seen many students at the center, you know, when they themselves lose someone who is close to them, they lose a pet, or they have that conversation with a doctor, right? I’ve seen this a couple times now and the usually cheerful student comes in and they don’t have to say anything. One knows just looking at their face that they are in a state of extreme shock, because they are faced with their own demise or that of someone they are close to. That is a sign of realization, and nobody had that today.

That’s a given, right? But you have the words, and hopefully if you think over the words, at some point in your lives, when these experiences arise, and it’s a given. It’ll be very nice if they didn’t arise, it’s a given, you would experience them. At that point the words and the meaning will connect. I had a very good friend, and I’ll stop with that because we have little time, who was a doctor in France, and she was finishing her internship at the big medical hospital in Paris, and they had a lady who was terminal with cancer.

She have been very beautiful. So eventually they had to had to strap her down. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen that in hospitals. They used leather belts, maybe in Australia you have synthetics now, because out of horror at her condition she would roll out of bed and she could no longer walk, but she would crawl in the hallway and obviously she would tear all of the, you know, transfusion and needles and all that out of her arm, you know, and they would find her crawling in the hallway and basically had to drag her back to her bed. Now, this is the sort of thing you should be thinking about, right?

Because it is going to happen to you personally. It’ll happen to me, it’ll happen to you. How you respond depends on what you do with your mind now. You don’t do anything? Okay.

As Geshela says, you have decided. You know, then we get a lot of this, you know, it’s constant at the center, telephone calls, proceed with Geshe Yamāntaka puja, now it’s Geshe Jampagese, to go to the hospital at the last minute to see somebody. There’s really no point, you know. And they go, you know, I used to visit dying people in the hospital with a friend who was a Christian priest. We sort of teamed up, he and I, you know.

And one does almost no good on a deathbed. Either the person has something inside ones themselves, in which case one is useless, or they have nothing, in which case one cannot help. So it’s up to ourselves to try to create something what it’s possible. And then I think we must break for tea, you know, but try try to make sure that these teachings don’t all stay up here and here, you know. Try to bring them down here and here, you know, to change, you know, that’s a good.

Otherwise, just to know what the Buddhist say, it’s a waste of time, waste of time. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
chulen
Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
dzogchen
Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
five degenerations
The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top