5,663 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The teaching explains the obstacles of sinking and agitation in calm abiding meditation, and the vigilance and antidotes used against them. It then goes through the nine mental abidings (mental placement up to single-pointed application), linking them to the six forces and four mental applications, and ends with question and answer on enthusiasm, perfections, and time needed to progress. The session ends with the teacher planning to explain the ninth abiding the next day.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 6dc3e068-3e38-4bc8-8d67-ca45f0ea8fb1
Words: 5,659
So within the five obstacles to generating concentration, the two first ones, which are laziness and forgetting the instruction, have been explained. And then within the actual process of training and concentration, the two obstacles we are explaining now are sinking and agitation. In turn, sinking is subdivided into two, coarse and subtle sinking. Coarse sinking is a mental factor which is present when the object of observation is stable and in addition there is some slight clarity with respect to the object of observation. So when coarse sinking is present, the factor of abiding, the factor of stability is present within the mind with respect to the object.
In other words, object is stable. And in addition, there is some clarity, but the object is not truly clear. Subtle sinking, on the other hand, occurs when both the factor of abiding and the factor of clarity are present with respect to the object of observation. In other words, the object is both stable and clear but there is a certain lack of intensity in the strength of the mode of apprehension of the object. During subtle sinking, the factors of the components of both abiding and of clarity are present with respect to the object.
However, there is a lack of intensity in the mode of apprehension of the object. Therefore, subtle sinking is remarkably similar to concentration. Both coarse and subtle sinkings are major obstacles to the attainment of concentration. However, abandoning subtle sinking is much harder than abandoning coarse sinking. Subtle sinking is a state in which the factor or the component of abiding and the component of clarity are both present with respect to the object but there is a slight slackening of the intensity of the engagement of the object by the mind.
This is what is called subtle sinking. And therefore when the factor of stability with respect to the object increases at the expense of the factor of clarity, there is a risk of subtle sinking developing. The mind must therefore engage the object not only with clarity but with a clarity endowed with a certain intensity. And to prevent subtle sinking from arising, one must increase the elevation or the intensity of the mind. When we speak of intensity within the context of the mode of apprehension of the object during meditation, it can be understood in terms of the example of holding a rosary or a tea bowl.
We can hold a rosary or a tea bowl with or without a certain amount of strength or intensity. When we hold the bowl tightly within our hand, this is similar to the factors of abiding and of clarity having intensity. When we hold the bowl loosely, slackly within our hands, this is similar to the factors of abiding and clarity lacking intensity. It is very difficult to explain the issue of the intensity of the factor of abiding and clarity verbally. It is something which one must gain an understanding of through experience.
It cannot really be explained without direct experience. And it is not from the standpoint of the object that we speak of the factor of clarity or the factor of limpidity, it is from the standpoint of the mind which apprehends the object. And the faults of the lack of clarity in the mode of apprehension of the object are that this lack of clarity is actually linked to both coarse and subtle sinking. One must therefore understand that concentration and subtle sinking are similar in that both have factors of abiding and factors of clarity which are identical. And it is therefore very difficult to differentiate concentration from subtle sinking.
When one meditates with subtle sinking, it actually will happen for the breath to stop moving through the nostrils and for the mind to be focused single pointedly on the object. And this is why many practitioners of old in Tibet called subtle sinking supreme meditation. What is therefore the difference between subtle sinking and concentration? Subtle sinking is bereft of the intensity associated with the factor of clarity. This lack of intensity is the feature of subtle sinking.
On the other hand, good concentration has intensity and this factor of intensity in good concentration increases as one continues to meditate. And moving onwards, I shall at present explain agitation. Agitation is said to be that outwards movement, that outwards distraction of the mind away from the object of concentration due to desire. For instance, if we saw a movie or a show and after seeing the movie or the show, were to engage in our meditative practice and recollected very forcefully and clearly this movie and this show, the outward movement of the mind away from its object of meditation is called agitation. So agitation is therefore that outward movement of the mind away from its object of meditation which is caused by desire and which leads to a distraction of the mind from the object of meditation.
Scattering and agitation are remarkably similar. The main difference is that scattering refers to an outward movement of the mind towards for instance recollected enemies or foes. Whereas agitation is an outward movement of the mind due to desire. When we engage in meditation on samadhi, it is mainly desire which arises, scattering arises only occasionally. When we meditate and train in concentration, it is mainly agitation which is an outward dispersion or distraction of the mind due to desire which occurs.
Scattering towards a recollected enemy or scattering upon recollecting virtuous deeds we have engaged in is much rarer. Therefore, it is said that it is agitation which is the main foe in this context. Agitation is of two types, coarse and subtle agitation. Of course, agitation occurs when the mind actually loses the object of concentration and is scattered outwards or is dispersed outwards due to desire. The result of coarse agitation is that the mind loses the object just as through forgetfulness.
Subtle agitation on the other hand is a subliminal manifestation of agitation which leads to a tendency towards outwards dispersion of the mind and dispersion towards pleasurable objects. Subtle agitation is therefore a subliminal manifestation of agitation not dissimilar to the way water can flow under ice. And therefore, both coarse and subtle agitations are big foes in the training and concentration. The means to relinquish both sinking and agitation is the training in vigilance. However, in fact, vigilance is merely the mental factor which is aware of the existence or non existence of sinking and of agitation.
It cannot be said to be the actual direct antidote of either sinking or agitation. Just as during military operations, we send out spies to inform us of the advance of enemy troops. Likewise, the function of vigilance is to be a wisdom which understands whether or not sinking or agitation are present. And we can see how vigilance can counter the advance of sinking and agitation just as a spy to informing his superiors of the presence of enemy troops can actually be said to counter the advance of enemy troops. We must therefore rely on the antidote to sinking and agitation.
Otherwise, if one does not rely on vigilance which acts as a sentinel guarding one against sinking and agitation, one’s concentration will be faulty. However, it is not necessary to rely constantly during the practice of concentration on vigilance. On the other hand, if one does not rely at all on vigilance, the other extreme, then both sinking and agitation will occur. And we will be in the situation of learning that a thief has broken into our house and fled with our belongings after it is all over. And therefore, it is when sinking and agitation are approaching that one must become aware of the fact.
On the other hand, when neither sinking nor agitation is approaching, vigilance has no work to do. The fourth of the five faults is the non application of the antidote when sinking or agitation are present. In this situation with vigilance standing guard as a sentinel, the moment one sees sinking or agitation beginning, one must apply the antidotes. And the seventh antidote within the eight antidotes is that antidote which is an application of the appropriate antidote to either sinking or agitation as soon as one becomes aware that they are on the point of arising. And this is identical or similar to the situation in which the army’s spies have informed the military that the enemy is approaching and the military immediately counters the enemy approach with the requisite troops.
And the fifth fault is the fault of undue or intemperate application. This occurs in a situation in which neither agitation nor sinking are present and yet the antidotes are applied intemperately. When neither sinking nor agitation are present, the mind must be placed in equanimity. And that equanimity is the eighth antidote. Whereas the application of antidotes when they are not required is the fifth of the five faults.
It is not possible to sever the continuum of sinking or agitation before the eighth mental abiding. Since it is not possible to sever the continuum of sinking and agitation before the eighth mental abiding, at present we must consistently apply the antidotes to both sinking and agitation. It is at the point where one is free of both sinking and agitation. In other words, after the eighth mental abiding that it is possible to loosen or to relax one’s vigilance and the application of the antidotes. So this is the explanation of the five faults and their respective eight antidotes.
And therefore when one trains in concentration, these five faults will arise and one must be aware of precisely which antidote to apply to each of the five faults. I have explained the six prerequisites for the obtaining of calm abiding as well as the five faults and the eight antidotes, all that is left to explain is the nine mental abidings. And therefore, since obtaining calm abiding occurs when one progresses through the nine mental abidings, I shall explain them one by one. To attain calm abiding, we must have a clear experience of the nine mental abidings, the nine mental levels, and therefore they must be understood clearly. The first of the nine mental abiding is mental placement.
During mental placement, even though the mind can be placed on the object, it cannot remain continuously on the object. And when we start training in concentration after having chosen whichever object of observation we choose to meditate upon, we find that even though we are able to place our mind on this object, we are unable to retain it on this object continually. When we have attained the first mental abiding, mental placement, we will have the impression that we are experiencing an explosion in conceptuality and that there is much more conceptual agitation than there used to be before. This is not the case. What has happened however is that for the first time we are noticing the normal state of conceptual agitation we experience.
And therefore, at present, please adopt the correct posture for meditation and focus on your chosen object of observation for one minute to see whether or not this happens. And your goal is to inspect whether or not the mind can stay on your chosen object of observation, whether or not there seems to be much conceptual activity or not and whether or not the mind can stay on the object of observation continually. So here we are obviously referring to a visualization of the object of meditation and not to looking at an object of meditation with your eyes. So let us try this out for one minute. Did your mind stay on the object, or did it wander all around?
Stayed on the object and the conceptuality that came up was related to the object. So the mind must be focused on the object of observation to the exclusion of everything else. If that does not happen, we are not at the level of the first mental abiding. But in my case, my mind went nearly to the plane I could have been flying upon. Just, wanna clarify something.
Last time we had, calm abiding teachings, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen asked everyone if they could clearly visualise the image. I personally can usually visualise the image quite clearly. There are a couple that say that they have almost no ability to visualise this image. Now when you were talking about this subtle sinking and having in the last couple of months, for the first time in my life, not been able to visualise an image, not because I had been practising too much meditation but because I was physically not so well, my question is an inability to, visualise an image, is that probably indicative of a subtle sinking? Or could a person be meditating on calm abiding quite correctly but still not be able to, visualize an image?
I know that’s a very long and convoluted question. But I will summarize your question with your permission for. Then if the object of observation does not appear, the very basis of meditation is absent. You are not meditating. Then there is a risk if one meditates without any object appearing to the mind that this becomes similar to the practice of the Chinese who said you should meditate without anything appearing to the mind.
Basically, the only benefit of that practice is eliminating the occasional harmful conceptions which might appear in the mind but otherwise there is no mental improvement whatsoever. In talking to the particular person who could have almost no visual image, she said she was quite able to do very lengthy meditations on breath and seemed to be able to keep up some concentration of the breath for quite a long time. So she seems to have had some object. But I know I’m talking about someone else, so it’s very difficult. But what does Geshe-la think about that?
Okay. So the practice of mindfulness of breath Satipatthana is beneficial for those who have very high levels of mental conceptuality. It enables them to lower the level of mental agitation and conceptuality by counting the breath. However, to attain calm abiding on that basis of mindfulness of the breathing is extremely difficult. So we are therefore ranked beginners since in my case, Geshe-la says, if I analyze carefully, I probably am unable to place my mind on the object for more than one second.
However, I have little experience in the training in concentration. My main activity is as a professor of Buddhist philosophy teaching the great Buddhist treatises. However, I sincerely hope there are among you those who can actually spend minutes, maybe even longer on the object of meditation undisturbed. And therefore, those like me must just study these texts and explain them and hope to gain experience. The clear advantage of these practices is that once we have developed some ability, some stability, once our mind is focused on the object, whatever virtuous deeds we engage in, we can engage in over a long period of time.
And for instance, if we meditate on a compassion which wishes to free sentient beings from suffering, once we have concentration, we are able to meditate on such a compassion continuously for a long period of time. And concentration counters the distracted nature of the mind which leads it to wander outwards to objects of desire and so forth. And this prevents, this distracted nature of the mind prevents the mind from focusing Lojong single pointedly on compassion for instance. And in that case, our meditation on compassion or bodhichitta is akin to a little butter fly fluttering around with no stability. It is difficult to achieve a lot.
Just on that point, can I ask therefore Geshe-la’s understanding of Bodhichitta and compassion is vast? So that’s obviously coming about through analytical meditation. And given what Geshe-la was saying before about not having time to practise calm abiding, is that an example for us that we should be spending more time on the texts and on the topics, knowing that meditation is actually a very advanced practice. Within meditation there are two types of meditation, analytical meditation and concentration meditation. Whatever meditation you choose to privilege, initially it is critical to study carefully and then analyze in great depth your object of meditation, your topic of meditation.
Only then should one engage in concentration meditation. Then there is great benefit in the practice. And therefore returning to the first of the nine mental abidings, mental placement. During mental placement all we are able to put the mind on the object of meditation, the object of meditation. It does not dwell there for long or continuously.
In addition, a second feature of this level is that we have the impression of a dramatic increase in conceptual activity. There is no such dramatic increase in conceptual activity. This is simply the sign that for the first time we are identifying pre existing conceptual activity and this is a valid cognizer and is an excellent understanding to have had. We can understand this clearly through an example. When we dwell like this at ease, there are no particular afflictions which normally are present within our minds.
Whereas the moment we put our minds under pressure, it is astonishing the amount of afflictions which appear suddenly. In reality, what happens is that in one case, the mind is unexamined and in the other case, the mind is examined. The amount of afflictions in both cases is basically the same. Then this is the first mental abiding. I shall progress to the second.
During the second mental abiding continuous placement, in addition to the mind being placed on the object, it can dwell there for a very short period of time. There are numerous different definitions of duration. The standard criterion for having attained the second level of mental abiding continuous placement is that the mind can remain continuously placed on the object of observation for the time it takes to recite one full rosary of At this point sometimes there are more conceptions, sometimes there is less conceptual activity. One of the features of the second level of training in calm abiding is that the conceptions are more intense. Each of the nine mental abidings is attained through the practice of one of the six forces.
Therefore, I shall at present explain the connection between the nine mental abidings and the six forces. Since the transition from the first to the second mental abiding occurs through understanding the instructions of the teacher, the first mental abiding is intimately connected with the force of hearing. In turn, since during the second mental abiding one’s own efforts at being focused continually on the object predominate, it is said that the second mental abiding is established through the force of thinking. In addition, during the first two mental abidings, it is said that the level of conceptuality is extremely high and specifically that both sinking and agitation are actively present. Therefore, two first mental abidings are known also within the four mental applications as engaging through concentration.
So within the four applications, the first application, the first mental application is known as engaging through concentration. In other words, engaging through force ful concentration. And this is predominant during the first two mental abidings, the mental application and continuous application. And therefore, since the first mental abiding mental application is actualized through hearing the instructions of the teacher, it is intensively or closely connected with the force of hearing. Whereas since the second is actualized through one’s own effort, it is closely connected with the force of thinking.
And the four mental applications are applied at key points of the training in the nine mental abidings, specifically the first mental application engaging through concentration is applied during the first two mental abidings. The third, mental abiding, is known as repeated application. It’s often mistakenly translated in English as patchy application. This means that even though the mind loses its object of observation, it is again and again repeatedly brought back to the object of observation. And the criterion for the attainment of repeated application, the third mental abiding, is that the mind can stay on the object of observation for the duration it takes to recite one mani and as soon as the mind loses its object of observation, it is brought back and reapplied to its object of observation.
And it is said to be similar to placing a piece of cloth on another piece of cloth. And therefore during the first two as well as the third mental abiding, distraction is a powerful force which tends to scatter or disperse the mind outwards. However, during the first mental abiding, the period of time the mind spends away from the object of observation is far greater. During the third mental abiding, the period of time the mind spends away from the object of observation is smaller. And the third mental abiding is the mental abiding during which the force of memory or recollection is enhanced.
The fourth mental abiding is close application. It is called close application because as the force of memory or recollection has increased, the mind is placed closer to its object of observation. The criterion for having attained the fourth mental abiding close placement is that the mind no longer loses the object of observation. And since it is at the level of the fourth mental abiding that the mind no longer loses the object of observation, it is insuperably superior to the first three levels of mental abiding. However, even though at the level of the fourth mental abiding close placement, the mind no longer loses the object of observation.
Nonetheless, it remains strongly afflicted by both sinking and agitation and the antidotes there too must be applied. And therefore, the third and fourth mental abiding, repeated application and repeated placement and close placement both require the force of memory or recollection. The application of the force of memory must be particularly forceful during the first, during the third mental abiding patched or repeated placement. However, it will be lesser during the fourth mental abiding and it leads to the conclusion of the fourth mental abiding. The fifth mental abiding is taming.
Taming. Taming. Taming, subduing. Taming. Taming.
During the fifth mental level, taming, the subtle sinking which was latent during the fourth mental level, the fourth mental abiding becomes evident. And therefore it is during the fifth mental abiding that vigilance plays its most important role as a sentinel trying to ascertain whether or not subtle sinking is present or not. And therefore, although coarse sinking and agitation could occur during the fourth mental abiding, they can no longer occur during the fifth mental abiding. And therefore the difference between the fourth and the fifth mental abiding is the presence or the absence of coarse sinking, and agitation. The sixth mental abiding is pacification.
And during the sixth mental abiding pacification, as a result of the intensification of the mind during the fifth mental abiding, struggling against subtle sinking. During the sixth mental abiding, subtle agitation can be noticed. And therefore, vigilance acting as a sentinel during the sixth mental abiding must check whether or not subtle agitation is present. If it is present, the antidotes must be applied. And therefore the difference between the fifth and the sixth mental abiding is that during the fifth mental abiding, subtle sinking occurs whereas during the sixth mental abiding, subtle sinking can no longer occur.
And therefore, the fifth and the sixth mental abiding are established by the force of vigilance from within the six forces. And therefore, the force of vigilance initiates the fifth mental abiding, taming, and leads to completion the sixth mental abiding pacification. And the seventh mental abiding in turn is close pacification. As a result of the completion of the force of memory or recollection during the seventh mental abiding, it is difficult for either sinking or agitation to occur. And even though it is difficult for sinking or agitation to occur during the seventh mental training, through training in the force of enthusiasm, one actually starts to abandon them.
And therefore, the boundary or the criterion for having attained the seventh mental abiding is the presence or the absence of doubt regarding the existence or not of subtle sinking and subtle agitation. During the sixth mental abiding, there is still doubt regarding whether or not subtle sinking or agitation is present or not. During the seventh mental abiding, there is no such doubt anymore. And therefore even though during the seventh mental abiding there is no longer any doubt regarding the presence or the absence of subtle sinking and subtle agitation. Until then, one has been unable to abandon them and the force of enthusiasm is necessary to abandon And therefore, or during the fifth and sixth mental abiding, there is considerable doubt within the practitioner whether or not subtle sinking and agitation are present or not during the seventh mental abiding there is no such doubt.
Until the seventh mental abiding, the force of enthusiasm is unable to incinerate, to burn away whatever traces of sinking and agitation might be left. The five mental abidings from the third to the seventh mental abiding, in other words, third, fourth, fifth, sixth and seventh mental abiding are mental abiding during which it is possible for both sinking and agitation to interrupt the concentration and therefore these are called from within the four mental applications interrupted engagements. And therefore the interval between the third and the seventh mental abiding since it can be explicitly affected by sinking and agitation is said to be that in which there is interrupted engagement. The eighth mental abiding is single pointed application. During the eighth mental abiding, after an initial slight effort of memory, it is possible for the mind to remain uninterruptedly on the object of meditation without being in the slightest affected by sinking or agitation.
And since during the eighth mental abiding, all sinking and agitation has been completely abandoned. It is no longer necessary to rely on vigilance. And since during the eighth mental abiding with a slight initial effort, the mind can remain in concentration on the object of observation indefinitely. The eighth mental abiding is called from within the four mental applications, the uninterrupted mental application. And therefore it is possible during the eighth mental abiding with a slight initial effort to remain indefinitely on the object of observation.
As a result, this is called a state of uninterrupted application or engagement. This is called the state of uninterrupted engagement. Both the seventh and the eighth mental abiding are realized through the power of the force of enthusiasm. While the seventh mental abiding is actualized through an intense force of enthusiasm, the eighth mental abiding is completed through the continuation of the application of the force of enthusiasm. Then I have explained all of the nine abidings up to the end of the eighth.
I shall explain the ninth mental abiding tomorrow. I can see you would have some difficulties if I were to explain the ninth today as Then if you are tired, the chances of applying concentration will be limited. I shall stop here for today and we’ll take your questions if you have any. Yes. Thank you, Geshela.
I was just wondering whether the force of enthusiasm has any relationship to the joyous effort, one of the six perfections. So the force of enthusiasm is the steady increase in enthusiasm, whereas the perfection of enthusiasm is only attained at the level of full enlightenment and cooperates in the practice of all other virtues. However, are differences in the presentations of the perfections according to the schools of tenets. For the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School, the perfections are only present at the level of full enlightenment whereas for the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School, the perfections are present both at the level of non full enlightenment and at the level of full enlightenment. Thank you, Geshela.
Just a few questions. Moving up the levels, does the time taken just vary according to individuals? That’s one. Secondly, if you attain a certain level, can you drop back again and have to sort of climb up again? And three, the object of observation, if it when you’re focusing on it, if it changes slightly, the color or moves slightly, is that a lack of concentration?
So regarding your third question, the object of observation itself naturally being impermanent will change over time But this doesn’t concern us. The visualized object of observation must remain the same as when we initially memorized it, if you wish. Then moving backwards from the third to the second question, whatever mental abiding we may have attained as long as we continue to meditate regularly we will not fall from that level. However, if we completely give up meditation then irrespective of the level of meditative attainment we may have attained in the training and calm abiding, we can degenerate. And then regarding your first question, the time it takes to attain calm abiding.
If one is able to practice exactly in accordance within with the great scriptures there is no doubt that one will obtain calm abiding within six months. If that is not the case much depends on the amount of effort we put. Sorry, Eliot. Could I just clarify the last the first question? Thank you.
It was more to move between the levels. Does the amount of time between each level vary according to the individual or is it six weeks on each level? So there is no definiteness regarding the time it takes to progress from one mental abiding to the next. It depends first on the object of observation chosen and the obstructions which arise with respect to that specific object of observation. And secondly, it depends on the amount of effort which is consented by the practitioner.
Clearly if you meditate a couple of minutes each day, it’ll take a couple of years to go from one mental abiding to the next. Geshela believes that if you practice intensively concentration, you will definitely benefit from it since there is strong scientific evidence that the practice of concentration leads to a stabilization of the moods which in turn leads to a stabilization of the blood pressure and this can only be of benefit to the brain. And there is considerable evidence as well that if one is choleric and one allows anger to arise frequently, this leads to the release in the bloodstream of substances which are harmful to one’s physical health. Then Geshela sincerely hopes that if you practice concentration and if you try to train your mind in love and compassion as a side effect, your health will benefit. He believes that will be the case.
He cannot say that definitely since he is not a doctor. You can see this clearly with the case of this patient who was terminally ill with cancer who asked Geshela for advice at the hospital. He was extremely distressed when he asked for advice and yet Geshela feels that as a result of the advice Geshela was able to give him, his outlook changed and you all noticed when he came to the teachings here a couple days ago that his face was completely different and much more at peace. So there is definitely physical benefits to this mental training. Okay.
Yeah, yeah, yes. Then the next time Geshela comes, maybe India will have no work to do. Yeah. Yeah. Do you have any special questions?
If a practitioner with strong, renunciation of bodhichitta surely would be would have an advantage, as far as vigilance or, well, especially enthusiasm. Uh-huh. Would that be correct? I got the first part of your question, not the second part. Versus somebody who is just training calm abiding on, say, the horn of a cow, surely in comparison to developing shinne with bodhichitta, that person would have the Mahāyāna practitioner would have an advantage given the mental factors of vigilance and enthusiasm.
Wouldn’t that help bodhichitta help the enthusiasm? I’m sorry. I don’t understand the question. Compared to someone who is training to develop shinne on the horn of a cow Yeah. Would a Mahāyāna practitioner have an edge training in shiné with bodhichitta as an object?
Not as the object, but with that quality. With the motivation of bodhichitta? Yes. There would be no difference in or no big difference in the time necessary to obtain calm abiding for two practitioners, one who is a non Buddhist generating on the horn of a cow with the horn of a cow as an object and the other with the motivation of bodhichitta. However, there would be a huge difference in terms of the amount of merit accumulated and in terms of the benefits accrued.
The non Buddhist practitioner who is training in calm abiding on the horn of an ox would derive no particular benefit from this apart from gaining calm abiding in this life. It would neither act as a cause for liberation nor as a cause for full enlightenment. However, the Mahāyāna practitioner motivated by bodhichitta meditating on let’s say the same horn of a cow would see this become the cause of attaining full enlightenment. I guess that I would like to stop here for today. There’ll be a short break, and then we will finish with just fifteen minutes with Ja Potenzin to settle our minds before we leave.
So rather than, you know, a full three quarters of an hour. So you’re welcome to come back in a few minutes.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Should we spend more time studying texts and topics, given that meditation is a very advanced practice?
Meditation comes in two types: analytical meditation and concentration meditation. Whichever type you choose to emphasize, you should first study your object of meditation, your topic of meditation, carefully, and then analyze it in great depth. Only after that should you engage in concentration meditation. When the practice is built on this preparation, there is great benefit in it.
How does the force of enthusiasm relate to the perfection of enthusiasm (joyous effort), one of the six perfections?
The force of enthusiasm is the steady increase in enthusiasm. The perfection of enthusiasm, by contrast, is only attained at the level of full enlightenment, and it cooperates in the practice of all the other virtues. The presentation of the perfections differs according to the schools of tenets. For the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School, the perfections are present only at the level of full enlightenment. For the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School, the perfections are present both at the level of non-full enlightenment and at the level of full enlightenment.