13,180 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The talk continues an earlier session on the first two Noble Truths, teaching suffering in three divisions (suffering of suffering, of change, and all-pervasive) and the six-fold division of cyclic existence’s sufferings, with reflection on death and impermanence. It explains karma and afflictions as the origin of suffering and outlines the Noble Truth of the Path. A question session follows on death, mindfulness practice and meditation on death.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: cd5a3fe1-cd97-46ab-8c1e-75e12463396f
Words: 13,176
Just before we commence the second part of our session, there were a couple of apologies, Susan St. Clair and Anne Hamilton Bruce. And just thank you for your kind donation of $5 for members and $8 for non members. Thank you. The great French philosopher Pascal said, All the tragedy of man comes from the fact he cannot stay alone in a room.
I was thinking of that during the break. Think of the place talking and gossip plays in our lives. What is its function? Its function is to prevent us from looking inwards. So when we look inwards, obviously, the state of affairs is worrisome.
We can see the suffering we talked about. We can see perhaps even the causes of suffering. Then distraction is a means of not thinking a lot of suffering. To all this is society of distraction. I think perhaps never in history except perhaps in the latter days of the Roman Empire did distraction and pleasure play such a role as a means of removing ourselves from ourselves?
That is what Pascal said. And by the way, Pascal was a very great Christian philosopher. So you can see that in many respects, the great religions in their core assessment of the human condition agree. They disagree in the solutions, but in the core assessment they agree. We were talking about the noble truth of suffering and we have covered the first presentation of the noble truth of Suffering in permanence.
Then I would like to cover with you the second feature of the Noble Truth of Suffering, which is suffering itself. Then there is both much and little to say about suffering. Much because the modalities of suffering are almost infinite, little because it’s an experience we have all had in one sense or another. But it is very helpful to break down suffering into its divisions and to reflect on them individually. I think for us as beginners, the most helpful meditations are meditation on impermanence and death on the one hand and on suffering on the other hand.
This is what transforms the mind. Everything else is an indulgence. Then from the Buddhist standpoint, suffering is subdivided into three and you can see here that the Buddhist understanding of suffering is far broader than the meaning given to the term nowadays. We have the suffering of suffering, which is what we would call suffering, the suffering of a cancer, the mind’s response to a cancer. Then the suffering of change is what we call pleasure.
The sweetness of the cookies we had during the break is a suffering of change. And we will talk about this shortly. And finally all pervasive suffering is actually life, Existence. Life or existence is actually suffering. Now this seems like a very shocking statement.
It is this which is actually intended by the first noble truth. The first noble truth of suffering is simply the statement that all life is suffering. Then we have to qualify it, but I won’t qualify it at once. Think of the fact that we have a tradition which is asserting that all life, existence as existence is suffering. You can see how alien this is.
And obviously it has to be qualified because what is being said is that contaminated life is suffering. In other words, the contaminated aggregates are suffering. But all we encounter is life with contaminated aggregates. Basically when we say life, this is what we refer to. So the Buddhist statement is a very shocking one and I think we should not discard the shocking component.
We should not pass it on to silence nor deny it. We should let it rise within ourselves and see is this true or not? Is it true that every living being’s existence is one of suffering? This is what we shall be talking about briefly. But first, I want to talk a little bit more of the second category of suffering, the suffering of change because this is the most problematic.
This is what all of us in this room call pleasure. And what are the pleasures we experience in daily life? I would say we acknowledge the three first categories of pleasure, animal pleasures, sexuality, food, urination, defecation. In other words, basically the control or the release of the orifices of the body. These are directly connected with the limbic neuropleasure centers.
Then the higher levels of pleasure are social pleasures. What you enjoyed in the foyer a couple minutes ago, conversation, grooming, it feels good. You’ve had a hard time in here, You go out, you relax, the mind relaxes, one talks of everything but the topic doesn’t run. And then one come back and once again when one comes in here, it also feels rather good because there’s change, isn’t there? Then an even higher level of pleasure is intellectual pleasures.
Elevated forms of pleasure, music, art, the pleasure of mathematics. I used to I’m a mathematician and physicist by training. And the highest pleasures, the pleasures of meditative equipoise which we do not know. These are pleasures the meditators experience. The great meditators of ancient India.
These are the most addictive pleasures a living being can experience. Often confused with liberation. So what is the Buddhist understanding of suffering, neutral experience and pleasure? From the Buddhist template as you remember we said there are three categories or three subdivisions of suffering. Suffering of suffering of change and all pervasive suffering.
If we look at a chart with the intensity of painful stimuli in ordinate and time in abscissa, as the intensity of painful stimuli rises we experience the suffering of suffering. If someone were to put a match on your skin, a lit match, as this lit match stays there the intensity of the pain increases. This is the experience of the suffering of suffering. As the cancer grows inside the body and presses on the other organs, the intensity of the pain increases. This is the suffering of suffering.
Then there is, if you are lucky, a plateau at which suffering is stable, you will experience something that can be a neutral sensation. The increase has ceased. After this, there may be a decrease. The match is removed from the skin. Cold water is put on the skin.
The temperature of the skin starts dropping. This decrease in suffering is experienced as great happiness. What you have in reality is only a decrease in suffering. Then eventually the skin regains its more or less normal temperature and you have a neutral sensation or low grade suffering. And then you may have another experience of suffering in which, let us say, someone pinches you ever harder.
These examples are simpler than the examples of disease. Again, the suffering of suffering increases and you experience the suffering of suffering very acutely and eventually the person stops squeezing harder, the squeeze remains stable and you reach a plateau. And progressively the pain fades and you have a neutral sensation until the person releases the pinch and you experience happiness. This is a course presentation, but you can see that the totality of the experience from the Buddhist standpoint is called all pervasive suffering because it is merely the varieties of the intensity of pain, of suffering. The sharper the increase, the speed of the increase, in other words, you see the tangent in mathematics.
The greater the suffering of suffering, the sharper the decrease, the greater the happiness. What I haven’t factored in here is the threshold of attention or the pain threshold. So anything beneath your pain threshold will be experienced as neutral. Anything above it will be experienced either as pain, neutral experiences or pleasure. So you see that the pain beneath the threshold of attention is not noticed consciously.
The moment pain arises above it, the totality of this experience where pain is increasing over time is qualified by the mind as pain or suffering. The plateau here is a neutral experience and the sharp decrease is a pleasurable experience. Then the pain keeps on decreasing but this is below the threshold of attention, you have a neutral experience. Once again the increase of the pain above the threshold of attention is called the suffering of suffering. The plateau is neutral and the sharp decrease is pleasure.
Now you can see that the modulation of the threshold of attention will determine how much pain you experience. So it’s a common experience for practitioners of Satipatthana, of insight meditation. When you engage in insight meditation, you’re focusing on the experience of the breath and on training in mindfulness. As you train in mindfulness, your threshold of attention increases and you notice absolutely everything. Eventually, what do you notice?
You notice the totality of an extraordinarily painful experience, the experience of being alive. It can only be born because of the very high threshold which eliminates vast swathes of this experience. We have filters which simply eliminate the overwhelming majority of the painful experiences which we experience continually. And this becomes obvious and that’s why I was very happy to be able to quote my favorite philosopher Pascal. This becomes very obvious when you try to sit alone in a room.
Try to sit alone in a room with no stimuli, just on a chair, comfortable enough room. What happens? You become more and more mindful of your inner experience. As you become more and more mindful of your inner experience, you get a very strong sense of discomfort. You will notice that you seem to be itching everywhere.
You may get get cramps you weren’t aware of, your scalp is itching, your ear is itching, your throat is sore, Suddenly it is too hot, too cold, there is a draft, there isn’t a draft. In every single case, these were experiences below the threshold of attention which have suddenly come into consciousness. So the main benefit for us, from my personal standpoint of mindfulness meditation, is to lead to the experimental verification of the three seals or the three marks as it’s called in Theravada Buddhism, impermanence, suffering and selflessness. Because westerners are much more accessible to this, to experimental verification than to reason for various cultural reasons, it’s extraordinarily helpful. If you just engage in Sattipattana meditation, the basics of Buddhism will become evident to you.
You will see that you are living in a state of physical and mental suffering which you are only able to become oblivious to through distraction, hence the popularity of a foyer. And that the moment one increases one’s attention and one’s vigilance, the whole state of affairs becomes quite painful. Then the impermanence of the experience becomes obvious. Painful experiences flashing in and out of the mind stream constantly and finally the selflessness of the experience becomes obvious. So this is what is alluded to by Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen and his definition of the noble truth of suffering.
These are actually the three marks grouped into four. Impermanent suffering and the last two marks would be grouped as one in the Theravada tradition. Theravada does not accept the emptiness of exterior objects. Then this Buddhist understanding of suffering and specifically of the decrease in suffering as pleasure accounts for all happiness, even refined happinesses such as listening to Bach’s Goldberg variations. Music can be explained as the pleasure generated by the transition from discordance to harmony and back.
The discordance is suffering. It is painful. It is disharmonious. If you strike a discordant chord, it’s actually unpleasant to listen to. And the transition from discordance to harmony is simply a reduction of suffering.
Likewise, for all of the so called elevated aesthetic experiences. Then I shall not talk about the selflessness of phenomena. It takes us too far in these introductory conferences, but I will talk briefly of the selflessness of persons, which is the fourth feature of the noble truth of suffering. And all the Buddhist schools consider that persons are selfless because they are empty of permanence, in other words stability, unity and independence. Now if you examine your own experiences of attachment to persons, this may be family members, children, partners or your experience of animosity towards persons.
Once again, for some people it’s even family members, partners, children or, you know, your adversaries in life. You would find that in every single case, the person you love or the person you hate seems to be permanent, they haven’t changed since they have harmed you twenty five years ago. One, they never had any doubts about what they were doing to you. This is a single pointed enemy who has come into existence to hurt you and is independent of any exterior circumstance. This person was not influenced by their own family, by their own culture, perhaps by disease.
This is a single stable unitary enemy or a single stable unitary loved one. Now you can see when it is put in these terms that looking at things in this way sounds like mental disease, doesn’t it? I mean, if I were to describe this about someone who has just been arrested, you would say the poor man, right? He needs help. But if you examine your mind, you will see that this is how we function.
Then for this reason, the fact that persons are perceived as not empty of permanent unity and independence becomes one of the main factors of suffering. Us. It’s a main factor of all human relations which are basically, from a Buddhist standpoint, entirely of the nature of suffering. Of the suffering of suffering with the increase in pain, suffering of separation from a partner, from a child. Of the suffering of change, decrease of suffering, you were alone, you were in a relationship.
The suffering of being alone decreases and your happiness increases until the problems start. You didn’t have a child, you wanted a child. The suffering of not having a child peaks. This is social suffering in many cases. The way others see one for not having children, sometimes envy for other people’s children.
Then one has a child and there’s a sharp decrease of the suffering experience as intense happiness and then the problems associated with having a child come. So for us it is very important to analyze our experiences of happiness in terms of a decrease of suffering. And once you analyze in these terms, they lose any glamour they might have had. Now what are the varieties of suffering? These subdivisions of the varieties of suffering are really for sake of meditation.
Traditionally, suffering is subdivided to the general and the specific sufferings of cyclic existence, in other words, the cycle of reincarnations. And I shall not be talking of the specific sufferings. I talked about them in the context of the presentation on the lower realms. But I shall talk about the three main subdivisions of the general sufferings of cyclic existence. We have an eight fold, a six fold and a three fold subdivision.
Then you will find as you meditate upon them that one of the subdivisions will be more helpful for you than another. For myself it is a six fold subdivision which is particularly helpful for my mind stream. For yourself it might be another one. The eight fold subdivision focuses mainly on human experience. Human experience of suffering involves the suffering of birth, which is largely controlled nowadays through pain killers.
But if you can imagine what giving birth without a pain killer would be like, you have an idea of horrific suffering which might end easily with death for the mother, the child, or both. The suffering of aging. A great Tibetan yogi once said that we can only bear aging because it happens gradually. If it were to happen all of a sudden, the suffering would be unbearable. The suffering of sickness, which in the West is largely hidden.
We have basically overcome acute diseases and the chronic diseases and terminal diseases tend to be hidden away in hospitals, in palliative care centers and so forth. One of the very helpful things you can do for your own mental training is to visit people in hospitals. I cannot recommend this too highly. I think your entire outlook on life will change. And finally, the experience of death which once again for most westerners occurs in the aseptic halls of hospitals with the family frequently absent.
Then four profoundly human experiences, encountering what is unpleasant, not encountering what is pleasant, not getting what one wants and the suffering of the five aggregates. If we enter into them in detail, suffering of birth is I think rather aptly symbolized by this bird flying out of a tunnel, the tunnel of the womb. Consciousness comes into this life but if you want to read an extraordinarily powerful account of the suffering of birth, read Chandragomin’s account of the suffering of birth. It’s haunting because Chandragomin lived around the sixth century and his description of the suffering of birth is a description of someone who actually seems to have remembered the event. I find it very difficult to understand as an outsider how it is possible to give such an accurate description of what must have happened.
But this suffering is terrifying for the child and the child is born crying and screaming. Children are not born with happy grins on their face. And movies to the contrary, mothers generally, unless they have an epidural, are not terribly happy during a pregnancy and a delivery. The suffering of aging is one we have become sharply attuned to in the West. Perhaps the greatest fear Westerners have is to suffer from Alzheimer’s disease in their old age and to progressively become ever more impotent and ever more confused with the nagging worry whether or not they will actually be in the future enough money to take care of them so that they do not die in a state of complete humiliation.
As you know, with Alzheimer’s disease, in its extreme form, the consciousness of time shrinks. I know of cases where the person’s time span awareness is five minutes and shrinking. Then such a person lives within a time frame of five minutes. What happened seven minutes ago does not exist for this person. With all the problems you can imagine.
Sickness I think is a suffering we understand mainly in the light of cancer, which is, probably the disease afflicting the largest proportion of Westerners, above fifty. Certainly the chronic disease. I’ve done many cases of brain cancer, cancer of the liver. These are radiographs of a tumor in the brain. It is a particularly difficult way to go as one loses progressively control over all one’s bodily functions.
This is not something which is far removed from us. I am showing these to try to make you reflect on what every single one of us in this room will experience. We have experienced the suffering of birth. Thank heavens, we forgot it. The suffering of aging, we are experiencing and some of us will experience very sharply quite soon.
The suffering of sickness, I can guarantee you will experience. It is a given. I cannot say which form. I can guarantee you will experience. And we can only hope for the blessing that the sickness be short and not too painful, not too humiliating, not too degrading.
And the final suffering is a suffering of death. Depending on our death, we may just be opened up by a forensic pathologist for examination. This is a human being’s body. What we glorify so much is none other than this. A rib cage with a big mess inside.
Now these are things we should meditate upon because these are powerful counters to attachment. The exhorted meditations we are interested in, they are of almost no benefit for a mind stream. This is a benefit. If you keep a picture like this on your altar, your mind will change. When I was at the monastery, I lived just next to the charnel ground of the monastery.
Then we didn’t have enough we couldn’t bury the bodies because of the dogs, and we didn’t have enough wood to burn them. Wood is a luxury in India. So we would burn the bodies with gasoline, you know. It’s a time consuming process, but gasoline was cheaper than wood. Then we could not keep the bodies for more than two or three days because of the heat.
And I remember processions passing in front of my room with the body wrapped up in a sheet, a monk who had died. It was quite a common occurrence. And there is a stench which is quite once you have smelt it once, you know what it is. It’s a very pretend particular Swedish revolting stench, the stench of a human body in a state of decay. And it would be carried to the funeral site.
Whatever paper we had, cardboard, would be laid on the body and then gasoline would be on it and the body would be lit. And it smelled exactly like one of your Australian barbecues. And I remember that it was a constant struggle to keep that idea out of my mind. It smelled actually very appetizing. Then I would go to meditate there after the installation was complete.
There was very little left, some bone fragments. And I took one of the bones and put it on my altar. Then I felt that was a true object of refuge. Much more helpful for my mind than countless Buddhist statues and texts and all that. This one bone of a monk I must have known, you know, not a lot because, you know, once you burn them with gasoline and and carbon, there’s not a lot left.
That was very helpful for my mind. I looked at it every morning when I got up, every night. Then some of my Tibetan friends, they said this might bring bad luck. Said, it can bring bad luck. So for yourselves, if you are here to try to help yourself which I hope is the case, this is what helps the mind.
The rest, it depends very much on one’s outlook. If one’s outlook is wrong, all this is just Tibetan, Asian folklore. I know His Holiness can be extremely sharp about this. If it benefits your mind, then it becomes dharma. It’s being dharma or not depends on your mind and I think for westerners because our minds are very coarse, the sledgehammer of photos like this or the picture of the grave of one of your fathers or mothers is much more helpful for the mind.
This brings down attachment to this life, brings a concern for future lives. Then the fifth suffering is encountering the unpleasant. Australians seem remarkably oblivious to the idea that unpleasantness might ever occur on these shores. This is a picture of a family in Sydney which was evicted during the great depression. These experiences do occur.
They may even occur in this country. Then before these experiences occur, one’s mind should be prepared. This reduces the suffering. Then apart from encountering the unpleasant, which may be an eviction, not encountering the pleasant is about as damaging. This is supposedly true picture of a bride which was jilted at the altar.
We expected to experience the pleasant of a marriage and experienced abandonment. It is of these experiences that our lives are made. Not getting what one wants is often the case with one’s children, whom one invests so much into only to find that they fail satisfying every single one of the dreams of their parents. In this country you have free education so your parents can only afford to be so bitter. But in countries where education is not free and where the parents may have spent in The States in the range of 400 to $500,000 on the education of a child up to a BA, this is a very bitter experience indeed.
It’s an experience of complete disillusionment with what had been the source of one’s hope and in some countries, one’s only guarantee for retirement. Once again, in Australia, you are sheltered from that problem. But in most of Southeast Asia, in Africa, in South America, one’s children is one’s pension. You get a state pension at 65, 67. In most of the world, if one’s children turn bad, one ends up poor and on the street.
And finally, the suffering of the five aggregates. This is a diagram of a human head after dissection. One of the five aggregates, the form aggregate. The beauty which we aspire to so much, the beauty which we admire in movie stars and singers is just this. As a friend of mine, a very good western monk, Australian actually, excellent monk, in his sixties in India, told me once, the beauty of a woman’s face is one millimeter of skin, which separates us from absolute horror.
That is a beautiful face. It’s one millimeter of epidermis. Then the six fold division of suffering which is I find very beneficial for my own mind and I hope you will find it for yours. Suffering is understood and this refers more to the general suffering of cyclic existence in terms of the fault of uncertainty, uncertainty, the fault of insatiability, the fault of dying not once but over and over and over again, life after life after life and the fault of being conceived and being born over and again, The fault of falling from the high to the low over and again and the fault of being alone. There is nothing particularly surprising if anyone of you have experienced these sufferings.
These sufferings are part and parcel of the package. Now if we cover them individually, just in the last ten years, we have had a very clear experience of the uncertainty of cyclic existence. These are a series of key events which happened in the last ten years which have affected us all. September 11, I was at Sera Monastery when this happened. My brother in law’s brother worked in the top office of the World Trade Center.
He was going to work that day. He is a very nice chap but a bit of a party goer. The night before, I may have told this story already I think, he had been drinking very heavily. Then he decided not to go to work the next day but America being America, if you don’t go to work, you may find a pink slip on your your desk the following day. So he figured it was safer to go to work or be it late.
And as he was going to his office, he saw this. He’s a stockbroker. You can see him on in this PC. If you want your financial news, you know, you’re on Valacho. Everyone he knew in the office died.
There were no survivors. He himself, he was I think 24 years old when this happened. All his hair turned white in a matter of weeks and he lost it in a couple months. He’s completely bored. He was completely changed by the event.
And I think it’s a very good example of the uncertainty of cyclic existence. Then this was the tsunami which hit all of Southeast Asia. I was in Bangalore when this happened. I was supposed to go to Sri Lanka as as a monk. Then that very morning, turned on the television to see that much of the coast of Sri Lanka had been hit by the tsunami and I had to cancel my trip.
As you know, some three hundred thousand people were killed in a matter of hours. This is the global financial crash in 08/02/2008. It’s the first year after I came to Australia. I came here first in two zero seven. I remember everyone was giddy with the peak of the mining boom, the stock market was peaking, money was flushed, you know.
I was invited to the restaurant by a group of students here. I think every single one of them now is, if not bankrupt, in great difficulty financially. Not one of them comes to the center in six years. And just a matter of weeks later after I had arrived here, I remember watching on television the crash. My family was protected.
I I had seen it coming. We were in bonds. We did very well from the crash financially. And I watched this and I thought, you see, this is what happens from greed, from debt, lust for money, you know. And all of us now live on the consequences of this crash.
But five years later, our lives are different. Even in Australia, is becoming necessary to curtail the benefits. All our lives will be affected. And this is the earthquake in China, which as you know, killed thousands and thousands of people. The monks participated in the rescue effort.
All this happened in ten years. It’s a very short period of time. We don’t think too much about it because our attention span is very short. But this is the situation we are dealing with. The second suffering is a suffering of insatiability.
Never being satisfied. One had a small apartment, but one really figures one should have a house. Someone gets a mortgage to buy a house with apartment, because it’s the only way one can get a mortgage. If two have a job, then hopefully the bank will accept to lend enough. Then one outgrows that house because one has children.
So one stretches one’s resources even more with the help of perhaps one’s parents, one’s relatives to buy a very fancy house. Then unfortunately, one divorces. The bank reassesses a mortgage if one is unfortunate, repossesses a house and one ends up up where one had started. Twenty years of a human life have been wasted. In the suffering of dying over and again, this is a case I presented at TBI of a young Sri Lankan who remembered murdering his ex wife and who remembered several of his past lives.
A clear case, very clear case. The suffering of being conceived over and again the case of a young Turkish boy, Semih Tutusmus whom I presented here also or which I presented here also. A young boy who remembered being murdered in a previous life and who get physical deformities concordant with the assassination. He was shot in the right ear and the right ear, you know, was deformed in disperse. He identified the murderer, could not forget murderer, kept trying to take revenge on him as a little boy.
Then the fifth suffering falling from the high to the low, we have seen many cases. This is perhaps one of the most famous, Bernie Madoff, the infamous financier who bankrupted himself in a large number of charitable organizations, who went from being an up and striving stockbroker to one of the most respected figures of The US financial establishment to a prisoner in a minimal security jail with no future. You have many such cases in Australia. You probably know cases yourselves. A human life is made of these cycles.
But from a Buddhist standpoint, these cycles extend not only over one life but over many lives. In one life, one might be, let us say, a wealthy American. In the next life, it might be Africa, one is reborn in a poor family. In the following life, one might even have an animal rebirth. And the sixth suffering, the suffering of being alone, perhaps the greatest fear of most westerners in our age.
A great probability I would say, the light of the divorce rate which is above fifty percent. Then the combination of being alone, of being sick, and possibly of being poor is very difficult to handle. So when we speak of the sufferings of cyclic existence, this is what we are speaking about. And these are symbolized by the diagram of the six realms of cyclic existence. The god realm, the demigods, the I can’t really quite see from here, my apologies.
The god realm, the demigods, the humans, the animals, the pretas and the heroines, all engulfed by the mouth of the Lord of death. In other words, the totality of cyclic existence is controlled by death. Whatever rebirth one has, it is a given one will die, that rebirth will end. Therefore, wrong engagements of the noble truth of suffering. In other words, four wrong views, if you wish, regarding the noble truth of suffering.
Seeing the contaminated aggregates, in other words, this body and our mind as clean, happy, permanent and having a self. I think if you reflect a little bit on the examples which are given, you can see that this is obviously not the case. The body is not clean even though most materialists believe it is and great effort goes in keeping the body clean. The daily regimen of showers we undergo in the West is basically for the sake. Then the body is seen and the mind is seen as happy.
This creates actually tremendous unhappiness in those who have become aware that their mind or their body is not terribly happy and who feel they are misfits, where this is a normal state of affairs. The mind and the body are seen as permanent. This is the case of most of the schools of philosophy of ancient India. Whereas as I said, through meditation it is evident that the mind and the body change continually. And finally, we are seen as having a self.
In this respect, Buddhism is unique among the world’s great religions in teaching selflessness. Simply because the existence of a self is at odds with both experience and reason. So having covered in great detail the first noble truth, suffering, our mode of existence, the question which arises is where does this suffering come from? And it is here that the Buddha’s uncommon response begins. The source of this suffering is not in this life.
The source of this suffering like this river can be traced back and further back into the mountains, life after life in the past. There are causes we do not even begin to be aware of. Now you might say this is a philosophical position, one of many but I believe there is strong evidence supporting it and this evidence has largely been accumulated by the division of perceptual studies, used to be called personality studies at the University of Virginia under the aegis of the late doctor Stevenson and at present Kim Tucker, who have collected a large number of cases of children who spontaneously recollect past lives and within those cases a certain number of cases which are verified. In other words, where the data of the children provided was checked. Now if we break down doctor Stevenson’s cases, Stevenson has an excess of two thousand five hundred cases of children with past life memories and of these, it’s much more than nine hundred, more than a thousand actually verified cases nowadays.
These verified cases are cases where the child made statements regarding the name of his previous parents, the name of his family members, where he lived, what he did and most importantly how he died. This seems to be what remains in the mind and this was verified by Stevenson and his team. Of these eight hundred ninety five cases, there are some sixty five exceptional cases in which the autopsy of the previous rebirth was traced by Stevenson. The cause of death was identified and this was compared with birthmarks on the body of the child. I’ve presented some of these cases at TBI.
These are extraordinarily powerful cases because it’s very difficult to see how something like this could be forged. And within these eight sixty five cases, Stevenson identifies what he calls his 35 best cases for which from his standpoint as chair of the department of psychiatry at the University of Virginia, there is really no other sensible explanation. So these make a very strong case for the existence of past and future lives. From my standpoint, they come close to being a proof. If one denies the existence of past and future lives, then one must address Stevenson’s research and provide other explanations.
They however do not demonstrate the existence of karma and causality. They hint at it. Now I would like to give three cases which illustrate the noble truth of the origin of suffering, where suffering in this life comes from. Because this life we can’t do anything about. It’s basically finished.
The causes for this life were accumulated in the previous life. All we can do is fine tune things in this life. But if we understand the causes of suffering in this life, then while we are still alive, we can change things for the next lives. That is in our control and that is what the Buddhists call dharma. To do this, we must understand how what the Buddhists call karma, in other words, deeds in this life operate and how these deeds carry over to future lives.
So the three cases I want to present are first the case of Semih Tutusmus, which I mentioned previously. This young Turkish boy who was seen as you can see with micro born with microtia of the right ear. The right ear was greatly diminished. The left ear was perfectly normal and was facial hemiplegia. In other words, the right side of the face was underdeveloped and stunted in comparison with the left side of the face.
Now this young Turkish boy actually clearly recollected the town in which he lived in, in a previous life. His name, his wife’s name, his murderer’s name, how he was murdered, shot in the right ear, what happened, the shot and pellets embedded actually in the right ear in the skull with part of the skull blown away. And these are the features of the life of this young boy as gathered by Stevenson. At three years of age, barely walking, he went to the village where he used to live in a previous life. He evinced very strong attachment to his ex wife and great jealousy towards her new husband at three years of age.
A profound hater hatred for the man who had murdered him in a previous life, which led him to plot this man’s murder from approximately the age of six until the age of 18. Then as you saw, he has some physical marks. The right ear is deformed. The right ear which was shot as you know. The head, you can clearly see the hemifacial dysplasia.
All of this is concordant with the wounds which caused death. I did not include Stevenson’s diagram or drawing of these wounds based on an autopsy report. I showed it here previously. The second case regarding the noble truth of the origin of sufferings I would like to present is a case of a young American boy, a very strong case regarding reincarnation, young James Leininger. A very strong case because the child was born in Louisiana, in the Deep South, in a Baptist family.
The father is very successful businessman. He had absolutely no interest whatsoever in reincarnation and an active member of the Baptist community. So the family had a vested interest in the child’s not having any past life memories. This was a big problem for both parents and for the father’s business interests. Unfortunately, the child started having uncontrollable nightmares in which he kicked upwards while in bed, while shouting plane on fire little man was out.
This started around the age of three and as soon as he could draw, he started making these drawings of a plane with his name James, but the number three nobody could explain and something coming out from the front of the back of the plane. He had clear memories of friends in a previous life and of their names And eventually, his father was so disturbed by the development that for the peace of the family and he suspected his son’s sanity, he decided to disprove these fantasies. And he investigated the data his son provided. He eventually was able to track down people who had borne the name his son remembered. It turned out they had served on an aircraft carrier called the Natoma in the Pacific and remembered the young man whom this boy remembered to be.
This is little James Leininger with one of his remembered friends from a past life, Jack Lawson, his best friend. When he met him at the Natoma Bay Convention of survivors of the Natoma Bay, I think the child’s face says everything. There’s not you don’t have to add an awful lot, you know. And this is a picture of James Huston junior, the child’s previous incarnation with his corsair on the natoma. It was not known initially that corsairs took off from the natoma.
It’s something which the child’s father was actually able to establish. And surprisingly enough, the little boy knew a number of technical features of the Corsair airplane such as that it tended to veer to the left on takeoff, which were completely unknown and which are confirmed. This is a picture of the Natoma Bay, the aircraft carrier on which the young boy James Leininger’s previous incarnation served. And this is an analysis of the case. James Leininger was born in 1998.
As a child, he loved planes, repeatedly drew planes under anti aircraft fire over water. He said as a child the Japanese had shot his plane. He had repetitive nightmares up to once a day in which he tried to kick his way out while saying little man can’t get out. Every March 3, the child would enter into a state of depression. He identified the aircraft carrier Natoma by name and fourth of the plane, the Corsairs, that they veered to the left at takeoff as well.
He identified by name and recognized Jack Lawson among a group of older people forty, fifty years later after the event. And very strikingly, he called his toy soldiers, his GI Joes as we call them in The States, Leon, Walter and Billy who were three friends in his previous life, all of whom were killed before he died. These are the features of the previous life. Navy pilot shot down over Iwo Jima, could not extricate from the plane, died on 03/03/1945 which corresponds to the grief on March 3, served on the Natoma, flew pilots, his best friend was Jack Lawson, his dead friends were Leon, Walter and Billy. Leon Peeler, Walter Connor and Billy Devlin.
And this is a clear case illustrating the suffering, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. The karma from previous lives being carried over into this life. The recollection of the death from previous lives and the grief causing depression in this life. This is the third case I would like to present to you. The case of a young Sri Lankan who became ordained at the age of 16 as a result of his memories.
He remembered one previous rebirth as an infant, a baby who died one hour after birth. Then he remembered a rebirth as a rabbit, as a hare which was shot and before this a rebirth as a Sri Lankan, Ananda Mahapalita, who was a hunter which is actually a taboo activity in Sri Lanka, a traditional Buddhist country and before that an unclear life as a dental mechanic. Now if you look at the pattern of this life, the pattern indicates some type of causal connection. It does not establish existence of karma but it hints at it. You have Ananda Mahapalita who was a meat eater and a hunter, probably hunting rabbits, who was reborn as a rabbit which eats grass and is short.
He explicitly remembers being short. These are two memories he had. Of this life, we know nothing but in this life, the young child is spontaneously a vegetarian and through the recollection from these lives becomes ordained. Now what is striking is without this hare’s life, we would not understand what the correlation is between the second life and this life because in the second life, Ananda Mahapalita was a meat eater. So you get a sense here of how the lives are intertwined.
And this leads to give his definition of the noble truth of the origin of suffering. A truth which is characterized by cause, origin, utter generation and condition. And the big question from the Buddhist standpoint is what are the causes? Because if we can understand this causal process which leads from here to here, then we who are here gain control over what comes after. Otherwise we cannot.
Number two of the origin of suffering is subdivided into two, karma and afflictions. Karma is the result of past deeds. Afflictions are negative states of mind which cause karma to mature into a rebirth or an experience, especially at the time of death. Karma is subdivided into three. Meritorious karma, in other words, good karma, non meritorious karma, and immutable karma generated through meditation.
Now meritorious and non meritorious karma can lead to a full rebirth or to experiences within a life. Immutable karma can only lead to rebirth as a non material being which we know as a god of the formless realms. More important however than karma are the afflictions because whether we purify the karma or not, if we can prevent the afflictions from arising, especially at death but throughout life, karma does not mature. So karma is, it could be akin to a lot of dry seeds scattered in the ground, let’s say chili seeds, you don’t want them to sprout in a in a wheat field. You just make sure it never rains.
Then you may have as many chili seeds as you want. It’s irrelevant. They’re not going to wreck your wheat crop because it will not rain. Whenever there’s a cloud, you shoot it down with one of those nice rockets people use at least in much of Asia. And therefore identifying the afflictions is very important.
To identify them, to know that what affliction is an affliction and how to counter it. There are six root afflictions and 20 secondary afflictions. I won’t cover the 20 secondary afflictions. Hopefully, will be covered at TBI, at some point next year. But the six root afflictions concern us.
They are desire, anger, pride, ignorance, afflicted doubt, in other words not just doubt about something irrelevant, but doubt regarding the Buddhist viewpoint and afflicted view, in other words a viewpoint which is contradictory with the Buddhist teachings. In every single case, these afflictions can lead to the maturation of past non virtuous karma. When they do, it is too late to change the experience, which is why Buddhism does not believe in the power of prayer to change experiences. Our experiences are individual experiences, product of our own past karma, led to maturation by our own afflictions and we and we alone must experience them. What we experience now, we sowed in the past.
If we wish not to experience in the future, then we must avoid sowing anything further now, purify the non virtuous karma as much as possible and try to prevent the afflictions from arising. If we do that, it is guaranteed that things will improve for us. Then there are four wrong engagements of the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Suffering can be seen as causeless. I think this is a dominant viewpoint nowadays certainly in the West.
It’s just a tragedy of life. A child is born deformed, there’s no reason. Somebody gets cancer, there’s no reason. Somebody is hit by a car, there’s no reason. Somebody wins a lottery there’s no reason.
Then it leads to a tremendous sense of powerlessness. One is on the receiving end of destiny. From the Buddhist standpoint, this is a wrong view. Suffering is not causeless, it has a cause which can be identified. Or suffering is seen as having only one cause which is also very common western viewpoint.
You see this for instance, let’s say, someone who is well, actually to the left or to the right both say suffering is due to lack of money. This is very common. It’s just a matter of redistributing the money or gaining the money. If you’re left wing, you want to redistribute the money. If you’re right wing, you want to gain the money.
In either case, money is seen as the palliative. Then suffering can be seen as created to having displeased God. This is a view of the monotheism. Judaism, Christianity, Islam. It is the will of God which cannot be fathomed.
Suffering can be seen as permanent in nature but only changing occasionally. This is a view of some western pessimists like the Romanian author Cioran or Yonesco. Then in every single case, the Buddhist message is a balanced message. Against those who say that suffering is causeless, Buddhism says suffering has a cause. Its cause can be traced in past lives and can be obviated.
So even though suffering does exist, there is hope to eliminate suffering. And this hope to eliminate suffering enables one to attain the cessation of suffering, the goal of every practicing Buddhist, which occurs when the afflictions which lead to the maturation of karma have been destroyed. Then the four features of the cessation of suffering are cessation, peace, blissfulness and renunciation. And there are four wrong engagements of the noble truth of cessation. The noble truth of cessation can be seen as totally non existent, which I would say is the view point not just of materialism but probably of all of the theistic religions.
Or it may be seen as a partial liberation. You are freed of some of the afflictions but not all of them. Or a plentiful liberation but only of some features of suffering, or even a temporary liberation. Suffering ceases but then returns. The conviction in the existence of the noble truth of cessation is probably the most difficult conviction to generate when one studies the four noble truths.
It’s quite easy to understand the noble truth of suffering. Then much of the data Stevenson provides enables one to understand the noble truth of the origin of suffering. But that it is actually possible to permanently eliminate the afflictions from the mind stream so that they never ever return, that is difficult to understand. Once one has understood that, it is the only possible goal one can have. We’re not talking of a temporary abatement of the afflictions.
Desire, anger, ignorance, pride disappear to never ever return. They are extirpated from the mind. And this occurs to the noble truth of the path. This is a picture of Ajahn Buddhadasa, a very great departed Thai monk, very close to the Mahāyāna. The noble truth of the excuse me, noble truth of the path, it’s a mistake here, has four features.
Path, knowledge, realization and deliverance. This is the way to free oneself from suffering. And I shall not enter into it in detail here. It is the focus of the totality of the teachings at TBI. So it is years and years of study will engage us in to understand the fine points of the path.
It is not easy but it is the only road forwards. It’s a road we ourselves must travel alone. Whether we travel it or not decides whether or not we shall be free of suffering. No one can travel it for us. There is no God, there is no one to pray to, there is no one who can help us.
The enlightened beings teach. They teach the road they travel. Buddha Śākyamūni said, I do not dispel, I do not wash the stains of the mind with water nor do I impart my blessings with my hand nor do I dispel sufferings with the wave of the hand. I dispel sufferings through teaching emptiness. This is the very essence of the Buddhist teachings.
The Noble Truth of the Path is subdivided into three depending on one’s goal. If one’s goal is one’s own liberation, one can either follow the path of hearers or solitary realizers. The difference is that hearers have teachers, solitary realizers do not. They are born in a life without a teacher, practice alone, through past powerful habituation and it is said like rhinoceros in the wild gained liberation alone. When we say they gained liberation, we mean that they have attained a certain noble truth, the noble truth of cessation.
And to do this, they generate the motivation to aim for liberation, which is renunciation or definite emergence. This motivation can only be generated if one has understood the two first noble truths. If one has understood the noble truth of suffering and the cause of suffering, then and only then can one generate renunciation. If one does not believe that life is suffering, if one does not believe that the suffering has a cause and can be eliminated, one cannot generate renunciation. Therefore meditation on the first two noble truths is the gateway to generating renunciation.
But it is also the gateway to generating bodhichitta because it is reflecting on the fact that all without exception are like us in experiencing the first two noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering. And that they are not alien to us, They are intimately connected over countless lives. That we generate a sense of responsibility for them and wish to free them as well from the two first noble truths. And this enlarged renunciation is what we call bodhichitta. There can be no bodhichitta without renunciation.
There can be no renunciation without a realization of the two first noble truths. And a conviction in the existence of the two last noble truths. Because if one did not believe in the existence of the noble truth of cessation or the noble truth of the path, one would not make any effort. There would be no point. And then the path in turn, each of these three subdivisions, excuse me, of the path.
The path of the hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas. The two striving for their own freedom from suffering and the bodhisattvas striving to free all from suffering. Each is subdivided into five then I should enter very briefly into a presentation of this because it is a bit removed from our topic. We have the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and normal learning for each of these three vehicles. So the path of hearer has five paths.
The path of solitary realizers has five paths. The path of bodhisattvas has five paths. They differ in terms of their motivation. The motivation of one who enters on the five paths of the hearers or solitary realizers is definite emergence. The motivation of one who enters on the five paths of the Bodhisattva path is bodhichitta.
And the turning point in every single one of the sequences of five paths is the path of seeing. It is at the path of seeing that one gains a non conceptual experience of the emptiness which corresponds to one’s vehicle. So during the path of accumulation, one tries to attain calm abiding. Attained it, one will have entered the path of preparation and at this point, with calm abiding, one meditates on emptiness. Eventually one is able to unite calm abiding in insight.
At this point, one has a non conceptual experience of emptiness. Throughout the path of preparation one has a conceptual experience of emptiness. When one gains this non conceptual direct perception of emptiness, one enters the path of seeing, one at that moment becomes an ārya being. Then one progresses upwards through the path of seeing and the path of meditation purifying one’s mind to continually meditating on emptiness within calm abiding. Until one attains, if one is a hearer or a solitary realizer, liberation, which is called the path of normal learning.
And if one is a Bodhisattva full enlightenment. This is the noble truth of the path. We have three types of practitioners on three broad paths subdivided into two, depending on whether they are focusing on their own liberation or that of others. The first path subdivided in function of whether they rely on a teacher or not. Within each path, it is indispensable to travel on five, we could say, sub paths.
The main subdivision occurs at the level of the path of seeing. The level of the path of seeing one gains non conceptual direct insight and emptiness. The two paths before this, the path of accumulation and preparation prepare for this. The two paths after this, the path of meditation and normal learning, are a process of continued purification of the mind. And finally, there are four wrong engagements regarding the noble truth of the path.
Four wrong views if you wish regarding the noble truth of the path. It can be seen as non existent. This is I would say the dominant viewpoint of materialism. There is no such thing, why bother to try? Or one can think that wisdom is not necessary for it.
This is a viewpoint of all the monotheisms. It is not given to man to know. It is a viewpoint of many of the Indian darshanas which do not subscribe to the view of selflessness. Some teach one must meditate on a self. Others, the bhakti traditions teach that it is through devotion to Krishna, to Rama, that one is able to the blessing of the god to gain liberation.
In each case, it is considered that the wisdom realizing selflessness is unnecessary. A majority of Indian schools consider that liberation arises through concentration alone. This is a viewpoint of Samkhya, Yoga, Vedanta and Jain, where the bliss of Samādhi is confused with liberation. Such a bliss from a Buddhist template merely leads to rebirth as a god of the formless realm. And one is reborn after thousands and thousands of eons back as some ordinary sentient being.
And finally, that such a path which totally eliminates suffering does not exist, which is a viewpoint of materialism. There may be paths which partially eliminates suffering. It may be possible to reduce desire, to reduce anger. I would say this is broadly the viewpoint of those psychiatrists who use mindfulness in the context of psychiatry. They use it to reduce the suffering of the person.
They do not subscribe to the notion of the existence of a noble truth of the past. Then after a somewhat difficult Buddhist presentation, I wanted to end with the words of a very great Islamic mystic, Rumi, a Sufi mystic. Then we will wait a bit because some of you are still writing. But I think it encapsulates a core insight of all of the great religious traditions. That suffering, if it is a motor for spiritual progression, is not evil but is actually extraordinarily helpful.
And Ohmi says, the wound is the place where the light enters you. It is very close to a beautiful verse of Śāntideva in which Śāntideva says that it is actually through suffering that one engages in practice. I have completed this presentation for today. Thank you very much and we have time for questions if you have any questions. No.
I mean, it is possible to accumulate merit. And I mean, Alzheimer’s is a long drawn out process. A simple meditations could be engaged in. It is clear that as Alzheimer progress is in, one has to use much simpler approaches such as the recitation of mantra. In my mother’s case, we are very lucky.
My mother is 92 now. She has no Alzheimer’s but she has the reduced concentration of an older person. Then she finds it difficult to listen to teachings anymore so I have given her mantras to recite and I encourage her to listen. She can no longer read with any facility. Listen to little bits of teachings, nothing very difficult.
But it is more the mind is powerful and the body is strong that one has to engage in practice. Then as the years pass by, the odds pile up against one. I think a lot of people would see suffering at death differently and would say with medication, palliative care, coming to the point of hearing others say, I’ve now completed my life happily and I’m happy to go. That seems to be comments that are thrown around. You know, that it’s not such suffering at the point of death.
I’m just wondering on your comment or response to that. There’s two different things. Physical suffering, I think Western medicine does a remarkable job of taking care of. Why turn elsewhere? Mental suffering, I mean, we have to ask specialists in palliative care like Chris.
The experiences I’ve had is that most deaths are not easy. And this sort of happy acceptance is something you read about in the papers, in the movies, which people buy into because, to put it quite bluntly, very few people visit their relatives when they’re in the hospital. I mean, was quite struck, at the number of either very old patients or dying patients who would ask me either to contact their relatives for them or whether I knew their relatives. And I’ll never forget once, my a very old friend of mine is a Christian monk. We used to go together to old people’s homes.
And this old lady, quite advanced case of Alzheimer’s, came to me and she said, do you live in Lausanne? I said, yes. And she said, do you know my son? She she gave me this very generic name. And I said, well she said, you must know him.
And I said, sort of. Yes. It’s very embarrassing really because there’s a real demand from the side of the person. And then she said, will you tell him to come to visit me? I won’t bother him.
What I’ve seen is that, you know. Then I’ve been with a couple of people through the death process. The only death I have seen which have been easy have been the deaths of some Tibetan Gesheus. I know several monks who had bad deaths, very difficult deaths. My father had a very difficult death.
I’d say if you’re interested in these topics, you should gain your own experience because there’s a huge vested interest in sweeping the problem under the carpet. Our entire society is built on the ignorance of suffering and death. Every one of us in this room is going to stop functioning as a good economic cog once we realize that what is proposed to us does not work. And this is why people tend to turn towards spirituality as they grow older when they become suspicious that perhaps it’s not quite what they were told. Does that go towards answering your question?
Yeah. I think so. And I think you’re right. We’re we’re brought up in a movie world, you know, and told stories and seeing things that are not reality. Don’t die as in the movies, you know.
I mean, the first thing which happens when a human being dies is that all of these fingers open. Know? People die in an ocean of fecal matter in urine. If there’s anything in the bladder, it comes out. And if you’re in a hospital, at least when I was visiting people, the first thing which is done when someone’s heart has stopped is to plunge the sphincters with cotton or whatever, you know.
The deaths are not easy and the deaths are alone. The final stages, I don’t know nowadays, Chris, how it goes, but in Switzerland through the eighties and nineties in the final moments, there would be nobody. Hospital staff would disappear, quote unquote, out of decency, you know. The families were overwhelmed by what was happening, you know. And there would be a big bustle once the person was dead.
Then there were things to do but the western mind is attuned to doing. There are situations where one can’t do anything. And there’s a sore need, I don’t know in Australia but in Europe, there’s a sore need for people to visit the sick, to talk to the sick. If you want to help others and to help yourselves, it’s a very good thing to do. Volunteer, be at the disposal in a totally non religious context.
The last thing people who are on their death need is proselytism. So if you from your side can just be a presence, you know, then one’s outlook on death changes a lot. Because the Lamrim really, in these matters, is very close, in my opinion, to the true state of affairs. We die alone. Yes.
Are there other questions? Yes. So my question is about the mindfulness meditation movement at large. Often we hear that by practising mindfulness and being aware of our bodies, our breath that we’re developing a different relationship to our pain. Perhaps developing more acceptance in relation to our pain.
And so people are encouraged to do these long periods of mindfulness where, you know, over time they experience more peace and happiness. That approach seems in some ways at odds with what you mentioned which is that where to, I guess, act in certain ways so that in future lives, suffering will be alleviated. I wondered what what you had to say on that. Yes. I mean, there’s been a very active movement of instrumentalization of mindfulness by John Kabat Zinn by a series of of often very well intentioned psychiatrists.
We had an old friend of mine, Graham Meadows, who gave two talks here over the symposium on this. Then I think the comments I made then are comments I would stand by. These techniques of meditation were not designed for that. Because they were not designed for that, they may or may not have. They were designed with a very different goal in mind.
They were designed to bring us in touch with the actual way in which our mind functions. There were three marks, suffering impermanence and selflessness. They weren’t designed to reduce suffering at all. And, if one has experience in mindfulness meditation, I think the first thing one notices when one starts meditating is very quickly a great increase in suffering. This is like a consensus.
I did some mindfulness when I was younger. I have many friends in Thailand who have engaged in mindfulness practice. Describe then they practice it quite intensively. It’s in the temple, on the floor. They describe pain which skyrockets and extreme difficulty in keeping the mind focused on pain.
Then I think it’s very good that these techniques have helped to reduce pain. I’m not quite sure how because it’s not the goal. What would reduce the experience of pain would be training in śamatha. Then single pointed concentration, the mind is drawn inwards, focused on an object, then the sense consciousness is abate. Then, yes, there will be a reduction in pain.
I think the one thing where we do we do have a moral responsibility is to be very clear that obviously we have we have no control if people choose to use Buddhist techniques of meditation for something else. It is set right designed in the public domain. But we have a moral responsibility to be very clear that these techniques were not designed for this. There may be major side effects and that this is not something we in any way condone. For instance, generally speaking, all the Buddhist techniques of meditation are designed for people who are in good mental health.
They are not designed for people who have mental problems. People who have mental problems should address these problems by other means first. The reason being that in the case of calm abiding for instance, you’re developing very intense powers of concentration. If the person has any predisposition towards mental instability, calm abiding can actually trigger this. Then, I used to counsel people who came to a Buddhist center in Switzerland when I was young.
I remember at least one one very clear case of a young man practicing insight meditation, Satipatthana, who ran into very big problems. He came to the center and I encouraged him to completely stop any type of Buddhist practice and referred him to a psychiatrist because the insight practice was harming his mental well-being. This was a young man, very repressed, medical student, considerable problems with sexuality and whenever these sexual images arose within his mind, he would just press them forcefully. It’s actually not really how one practices insight. And as a result of this, a constant stream tension arose in him and he came he was quite distraught.
Then my feeling is if all the great Buddhist teachers, I think it is unanimity, say that the Buddhist meditation technique should be practiced under the guidance of an experienced teacher, there is a reason for this. We come from an overly cerebral culture in which there is this idea that everything can be learned from books. It’s a bookish culture. For some things, you must have experience and you must learn from someone who has been there, who has traveled the path, who knows what the pitfalls are. This is the case in the Theravada tradition.
Theravadans practice insight under the guidance of an elder who is experienced and they meet with him daily to report their meditative experience. This is the case in the Zen Buddhist tradition. This is the case in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. Then obviously, should people choose not to do this, have no control, but at least we have a moral responsibility to warn them. Because I’ve been present in countless cases, really countless of young westerners who drew some meditative technique from a book, applied it under nobody’s guidance, got into big trouble, and came to one of my teachers asking for help.
I mean, we had one who was sitting on a window ledge going in and out of the window. She thought she was a bird. Then she was interned. Another when I was in India, she was doing some sort of Tantric practice with no guidance. She had sort of devised the thing herself.
Then she had uncontrolled experiences. She came to a Nyingma lama, I know of, for help. So I think we have a moral responsibility to warn the students. I see even here. I’m very surprised sometimes when students ask questions, it’s not about your question, which is a good question.
But and I ask them what their meditative practice is. They describe something we have never taught here and often something nobody ever taught. And when one asks them what they’re practicing, they say, oh, I made it up. Then as said, you may end up with realizations nobody has ever had before nor will ever have after. The mind is a delicate affair.
You don’t want to play with it. So it’s a long answer to your question, but all this to say, generally speaking, I think it is marvelous that these techniques have some applicability. From my standpoint, I don’t understand how mindfulness can reduce pain but I’m willing to take it on board. I can see how calm abiding could and I think we must be very clear in our warnings that they were not designed for this. It’s a bit like using a lawn mower to cut somebody’s hair.
If you’re careful, you’ll get away with it. But if you’re not careful, heaven knows what will happen. Do you have any other questions? Is contemplation on death the best antidote for distraction and laziness? For all?
Distraction and laziness. Yes. I think for us, meditation on death is the best practice period. Because it is the antidote to all the problems at the level we’re at now, which is obsession with this life. It is only when meditation on death has really been interiorized that one can move upwards to more advanced meditations.
Nothing is more beneficial than meditation on death. The Buddha says in the Mahaparinirvana sūtra, just as a footprint of an elephant is the greatest of all footprints, likewise meditation on death and impermanence is the greatest of all meditations. Simply because it is not only of great benefit but there are no risks. If you take meditation on emptiness, there are considerable risks of misunderstanding emptiness. I think if one has not studied, there is basically a certainty of misunderstanding But with meditation on death and impermanence, there’s only benefits for the mind and there’s no risk in misunderstanding.
Does that answer your question? Ilya, I’m just wondering, referring to your last quote, how we can, I guess, use suffering in a way that’s constructive on the path as opposed to responding to it in a way that perpetuates unconstructive habits? Well, the first thing is obviously awareness of suffering. And then awareness of suffering can lead to depression if one thinks that the suffering cannot be eliminated. So one must understand that this suffering has causes.
And that’s really the noble truth of the origin of suffering. That I think one can deepen one’s understanding of through studying these cases of reincarnation. One sees that the experiences of these children in their present life come from a distant past. They’re not random. Then if they have causes, they can also be eliminated.
That gives hope. It’s up to us to find the strategies to do so. Those are karmic strategies. I don’t know if that answers your question, does it? In part, I guess it sounds like you’re saying awareness of process is In a nutshell, broaden the scope of your mind.
If the mind is focused on oneself and oneself suffering, the situation becomes very difficult. If you broaden the scope to all your lives, the situation becomes much easier. If you think of others, the situation becomes even easier. There’s a lot of data which really confirms that from cognitive psychologists that altruism, training an altruism reduces the experience of suffering in the person who was training an altruism. So this really corroborates basic Buddhist teachings.
Let’s say one takes a given source of suffering in this life. Let us say for instance cancer. Let’s imagine I had, let’s say cancer of the lungs, what my father had. And all I believed in was this life and that this cancer was random or even worse due to my own smoking, then the suffering would be very great. If in addition I believe that after death there was nothing, the suffering would be terrifying.
I’m going from something to absence, to nonexistence. However, once I understand that this life is just like one one bead on this rosary. And the consciousness, the red thread, goes in the past into numerous beads, my past lives, past bodies, and in the future into numerous beads, then the suffering is reduced. There is survival after death. It may not be a soul which transmigrates, but the mind transmigrates.
Then when I understand that the sufferings in this life are the product of whatever I did, let’s say, four lives from now, but that in this life I have control, I can change my behavior and my outlook so that in the next life, which for me let’s say is not more than thirty forty years away, maybe less twenty years away. For some of you it may be ten fifteen years away. In the next life, things will improve. That gives hope. Then the cancer becomes quite manageable.
There’s obviously physical suffering that Western medicine does a very good job of. There’s no need to look elsewhere. And the mental suffering is greatly reduced. And then if one meditates on suffering, it’s profoundly liberating. If you meditate in the fact that there’s nothing particularly abnormal about this suffering, I have died life after life after life.
After all, we all have to die of something. In my case, in this life it was cancer. The next life it may be a heart attack. Then I will be reborn life after life after life. All these lives are the same.
They all have the same basket of suffering with a different distribution of the sufferings. Once outlook changes completely, then at this point, your priority is within your basket to have more goodies and less chubbies, right? And then eventually you realize that the basket is the problem, right? And you want no baskets, no lives. But I think the conviction in the existence of past and future lives and that must be based on experiment.
Westerners, it does not work if one uses the great lines of reasoning from Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika. It must be based on Stevenson’s work, the data. A conviction in past and future lives, conviction in karma and causality give hope. And then it’s up to oneself to do the work but it’s manageable. In your case, you were young.
You have a fairly large number of years in front of you. It is something which can be done. You can inflect The Tibetans say to know your past life How does this one run? To know who you were in a past life, look at your body in this life. To know who you will be in a future life, look at your mind in this life.
So our body in this life is due to the work of someone else in the past life and all of us basically is being quite good. Then where we will be reborn, we can also check-in our minds. We look in our minds. If the mind is improving, then probably a good rebirth. Then we must understand how karma operates, try to avoid afflictions at the time of death, a positive frame of mind, a generous frame of mind, a religious frame of mind.
Then the rebirth will be good. And then the rest we have no control. Physical disease, mental disease, no control. I think we’re running quite late, so my apologies. Thank you.
Those of you who are interested, there is a reading list outside I believe if you want to pursue some readings.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
- Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How can we use suffering constructively on the path, rather than reacting in ways that reinforce unhelpful habits?
Begin with awareness of suffering. Awareness can lead to depression if suffering seems impossible to eliminate, so one must understand that it has causes, which are not random. If it has causes, it can be eliminated, and that gives hope. Then it is up to us to find the karmic strategies. In short, broaden the scope of the mind. Focusing on oneself makes suffering very difficult; considering all one's lives makes it easier, and thinking of others easier still. Cancer, for example, becomes manageable when seen as one bead on a rosary, the result of past actions, with the power to change one's behavior and outlook now so that the next life improves.