5,142 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The talk completes the teaching on the first two noble truths, origin and suffering, linking them to the twelve links and cyclic existence. It covers impermanence, the root afflictions (desire, anger, pride, doubt, ignorance) and how to counter them, then the noble truths of cessation and path. A question session on self-grasping follows, and the talk closes with advice to train in compassion and bodhichitta to prepare for death.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 92399cd0-b5f0-481f-bbe5-3bc086413814
Words: 5,138
If you just recite the shortened amount that I think that’s enough. Page nine, just the first verse, and we’ll just say it rather than sing it. So we have finished explaining the two first noble truths, the noble truth of the origin of suffering and the noble truth of suffering. The Noble Truth of the Origin of Suffering includes six of the causal links of the 12 links, and the Noble Truth of Suffering includes six of the resulting links from within the 12 links. It is in dependence on the sequential unfolding of the six causal links that one experiences the sequential unfolding of the six resulting links and thereby cyclic existence.
The six resulting links range from the first, the link of birth to the last, the link of aging and dying. And these six links, the resulting links ranging from the link of birth to the link of aging and death are posited as the truth of suffering. In dependence on this presentation of the noble truth of the origin of suffering and the noble truth of suffering, the Buddha taught the four features of each of these noble truths. These four noble truths, these four features of the, noble truths are impermanence, suffering, emptiness of a self and selflessness of persons. The first of these four features is impermanence.
Impermanence refers to the instantaneous very essence of phenomena, the fact that phenomena change instant by instant. All phenomena which arise in dependence on causes and conditions change instant by instant in dependence on causes and conditions. And there are two forms of such transitoriness, coarse and subtle transitoriness. Instances, of course, transitoriness or coarse impermanence are, for instance, the death of a human being, which the continuum is severed, or, for instance, the completion of a house at which point a new house has come into being. All things without exception, all in Tibetan change instant by instant.
There is no thing which does not change instant by instant. It is through a constant process of change that we have reached our present condition after being born from our mother’s womb. And for that matter, this dharma teaching, which we have come to attend, dies or disintegrates today. For instance, the assembly this morning which gathered to listen to the teachings at present no longer exists. Likewise, the good lunch we all had and the joyful talk in the main room at present no longer exists.
Likewise, you’re waiting for me and doing the recitations at the beginning of the teaching are all over and have disappeared. Likewise, the instant when I first sat on the cushion and started speaking has also disappeared. Likewise, within the second hour of teaching, the first hour of teaching has disintegrated and disappeared. Within the second minute of teaching, the first minute has disintegrated and disappeared. Thinking in this way, we can understand that at the time of the second second, whatever existed during the first second has already been destroyed.
Then analyzing in this way, we can say that this see that this is true for all beings, all persons. And it is said in Buddhist scriptures that the shortest interval of time, which can be posited, is a fraction of the interval of time in which a strong person snaps his fingers. Clearly, this has to be someone who is both strong and healthy. If someone who is weak and debilitated snaps their fingers, then this might take quite a bit of time. Between the moment in which we close our eyes and reopen the wall blinking, a short interval of time will have lapsed.
Then you can see that these are very small instance of time which we can observe. In your opinion, are there smaller ones than this? These are only the shortest instance of time which we can see unaided. How would you identify them? How small were they?
You remember? So that’s not what Geshela is talking about. You’re talking about the measurement of time by machines or instruments. He wants to know with your own body as ordinary beings, is this the smallest interval of time which can be measured or not? Otherwise, if one starts dividing, then clearly some Buddhist texts posit the one sixty-fourth interval of the time for snapping one’s finger as one of the smaller instance of time.
This is a discussion of what the smallest intervals of time would be. That’s not what we’re talking about here. What we’re talking about here is what the smallest interval of time we as an ordinary being can create, can cause or can create. So Geshela is asking you if an ordinary being can create a shorter interval of time than the one he creates through snapping his fingers or blinking. So in the Buddhist scriptures, the smallest interval of time which an ordinary being can create by his own means is given in this way.
Definitely, definitely. One can observe much shorter intervals of time. The question is, however, which ones can one create? So in the Buddhist scriptures, is said that the shortest interval of time which an ordinary being can observe is one sixty fourth of the time needed for a by a strong person to snap his fingers. However, it is clear that scientists have measured far shorter intervals of time since then.
These subtle states have changed in the same way as within one minute there are sixty seconds, great practitioners inspected how many intervals they could notice in the time it took to snap one’s fingers and they found 64. No, 64 in the time it takes to snap one’s fingers. Well, are the explanations in the treatises on Abhidharma. It is clear at present that one has to develop the explanations regarding the shortest intervals of time given in science such as the speed of light and so forth. And therefore, all composite phenomena change instant by instant, in dependence on their causes and conditions.
Then the instance which are defined, as you can see, can be extraordinarily small. And therefore, our body, but also our objects of experience change instant by instant. They are not stable in the slightest. So what is our fault or our defect? It is that we see ourselves as eternal and permanent.
This is the apprehension at per the apprehension of permanence. And to counter this apprehension of permanence and to relinquish it, one must reflect on the transitoriness of one’s body and one’s aggregates. Likewise, we see our body as clean in nature, and this is at odds with its true nature, which is unclean since arisen from unclean substances. The biological causes of our body are the semen and the egg of our parents, which are unclean substances. Likewise, the main component of our body is blood and flesh, which are likewise unclean substances.
Finally, the foremost causes of our body are contaminated karma and affliction, which are likewise unclean. Through meditating on the unclean and filthy nature of the body, we can counter, we can relinquish the apprehension of the body as clean. Likewise, we have a strong sense of our bodies existing independently of any other factor. And it is through meditating on the fact that our body arises in dependence on other factors, other causes and conditions, that we can counter the apprehension of our bodies not existing independently, not existing independently of other factors and conditions. Likewise, we view the contaminated feelings of happiness within our body as happiness.
They are not happiness but suffering. Then through meditating in this way on the impermanence, suffering, emptiness of a self of other objects and selflessness of persons which characterizes our body, we will able we will be able to counter attachment to it. Through seeing the numerous faults of this suffering physical aggregate of ours, we will eliminate all attachment to it. Through meditating, therefore, on these four features of our body, its impermanence, its suffering nature, its emptiness and its selflessness, we will be able to eliminate attachment to it. And this is an introduction to our understanding the aggregates as objects of abandonment as what is to be abandoned.
If we are not separate from these aggregates which are of the nature of suffering, we will be unable to be separated from suffering. And to relinquish or to abandon these aggregates which are of the nature of suffering, we must eliminate their root. The foremost root of these is the afflictions which are a truth of origin. So we can see that the aggregates of this life have as their main cause karma, which is a truth of origin. Karma, which is a truth of origin, has as its main cause the afflictions which are a truth of origin.
And Geshela has endeavored to explain clearly how this occurs over the last two days. And therefore, since the abandonment of these aggregates which are of the nature of suffering encounters the abandonment of the afflictions, which are its cause, we must find a means to abandon these afflictions. While there are numerous subdivisions of the afflictions, which are a truth of origin, nonetheless, they are not of the nature or they do not dwell in the nature of the mind. These aggregates do not stain the very nature of the mind. These afflictions do not stain the very nature of the mind.
In the same same way as when water is polluted, that pollution does not affect the very nature of water and it can be removed from the water. Likewise, the afflictions do not dwell in the very nature of the mind, and therefore, when one applies the antidotes to the afflictions, it is possible to separate the afflictions from the mind. For this reason, the affliction the afflictive obstructions are called adventitious obstructions. Then these afflictions include the six root afflictions Geshela spoke about this morning. The first of these is desire.
Desire is similar to seeing someone who is evil as good. Just as when we see someone who has evil plans within his heart but is laughing cheerful and friendly on the outside. Likewise, desire, causes suffering both for others and for oneself, arises through superimputation on a basis which seems agreeable. It is an attraction to an object with a limited attractivity and which superimposes or imputes on this object attractiveness far in excess to its actual attractiveness. Then through enhancing artificially the attractiveness of the object, eventually desire troubles the mind.
And then in turn, when something harms or affects an object which we have over evaluated through desire, then as a result of this, envy, jealousy, and anger arise towards whatever harms the object of desire. The cause of envy, jealousy, and anger is generally desire. For instance, if we have a lot of desire or lust for another person and a third party chats up to that person, Then as a result of that, tremendous jealousy and envy will arise within our minds, and this will cause great mental suffering. And therefore, it is in dependence on one’s powerful lust, one’s powerful desire that the friendly talk and laughter of another person to the object of one’s desire causes great suffering within one’s own mind. Likewise, rooted in one’s powerful desire or attachment for another person, should that person be on the receiving end of a beating, harsh words, discrimination, then immediately anger, powerful anger arises within our mind.
Then you can see clearly that this mental turbulence, this mental suffering, this mental unhappiness we experience is rooted in desire. And therefore, the means to eliminate desire is to focus on the faults of desire, to focus on the faults of the object of desire, seeing the object of desire as dirty, unappealing and unattractive. Then when we see it as dirty, unappealing and unattractive, our very way of looking at it changes. And therefore, even though there is only one person who is being observed, we can see that the the mode of apprehension of the mind which apprehends this person with powerful lust, and the mode of apprehension of the mind which apprehends this person without lust are completely different. And since desire is such a treacherous enemy, the moment it arises within our mind, we must expel it from our mind.
Now regarding anger, anger can be experienced both towards sentient beings and towards non sentient entities. Anger arises when our mind is unhappy and is troubled. And this mental unhappiness, this mental discomfort arises mainly because of one’s mental fancies, one’s mental imaginings. What are these mistaken imaginings? They are thoughts along the lines of so and so harmed me in the past, so and so is harming me now, so and so is planning on harming me in the future.
Or through thinking so and so is going so and so harmed my friend in the past. So and so is harming my friend at present. So and so will harm my friend in the future. Or through thinking so and so has helped my in the past, so and so is helping my foe in the present, so and so will help my foe in the future. And therefore, this unhappy and troubled mind arises when one’s expectations are not satisfied.
Then when such an unhappy mind arises and increases in its power, eventually we experience anger towards another. In brief, the nature of anger is a mind which wishes to harm another person. When such anger arises, one experiences great mental suffering. Anger is the worst affliction from within all afflictions. Anger has the power to destroy all of the previously accumulated roots of virtue.
And it can prevent new roots of virtue from being accumulated. It also can cause great suffering at present preventing us from enjoying the taste of food or sleeping. When great anger arises in brief, the pain can be as sharp as if someone was stabbing us in the breast with a dagger. When such anger arises, one’s entire expression and one’s face change completely. Let alone being unhappy oneself, we make all those around us unhappy.
Then one is face to face with questions from one’s friends and relatives. What exactly is going on? What are you thinking about? What’s happening? And when you answer nothing is wrong with me, nobody is convinced because their face is like this.
And therefore, anger profoundly harms us. And when anger arises forcefully in the mind, one wishes to grasp a stick or a stone and inflict pain on others. Or whatever one usually uses for this. And then with powerful anger in the mind, whatever one is holding in one’s hand becomes a weapon. So, Wal, there is much to be said on the thoughts of anger.
I will stop here. Pride, literally in Tibetan, I am the king, is that affliction which greatly overestimates whatever small qualities we might have. So when one is proud, one is observing the rest of mankind as from a high mountain. Then when one is on top of a high mountain, oneself is high up and everyone else is tiny down below. Then with great pride, none is good but oneself.
None is careful in one’s work but oneself. None has any qualities but oneself. All are beneath oneself. When pride arises, one depreciates others. And therefore, there is a Tibetan proverb which says, on the proud hill, the rain of the qualities does not remain.
Such a person has faith and veneration for none and listens to none. Even if his or her guru were to give him instructions, there would be no point. And therefore, if one is proud and arrogant, the water of qualities will not dwell within oneself. The fourth affliction is afflicted doubt. This refers to a doubt which wonders, for instance, whether a karma and causality exist or not.
Generally speaking, there are two types of doubt, afflicted doubt and beneficial doubt. The doubt which doubts whether past and future lives exist, which doubts whether karma and causality exists, which doubts whether there is a state of full enlightenment is an extraordinarily harmful type of doubt. Then the doubt which wonders after having planted the seed, is it going to ripen or not and give a sprout? That is a beneficial doubt. Now for those of you who are attending these teachings and who are wondering whether these teachings are of benefit for the future or not, such a doubt is actually a beneficial doubt.
Likewise, the doubt which wonders what exactly is Geshela explaining, is this accurate or not, is a beneficial doubt. So the doubt which is to be abandoned is afflicted doubt. Then ignorance is the worst of all. Ignorance refers to that benightedness which does not understand the actual mode of existence of phenomena and of objects of knowledge. The fundamental root, the fundamental origin of desire, of anger, and so forth is ignorance.
It is through not understanding the actual way in which things exist, the actual mode of existence of phenomena, that ignorance gives rise to desire and to anger. And therefore, ignorance is an extraordinarily grave thought. Nonetheless, this affliction has one great quality. And the quality of afflictions is that if we do not befriend them but we apply the antidote, they can be isolated, separated from the mind. And it is precisely because we have been under their influence until the present day from beginningless time that we are in our present state of affairs.
It is because they have deceived us and we have been under the influence until now that we have experienced suffering so far. So we have seen their force today. Therefore, from today onwards, we should be separate from the afflictions and turn away from them. And therefore, whenever the afflictions arise within our minds, we should apply the antidotes. And therefore, when the afflictions arise in our minds, how should we approach or how should we handle them?
If desire arises, we should think of the ugliness and the filthiness of the object desired. And if we better take filthiness and the dirtiness of the object which gives rise to desire, in the short term, we can reduce desire for that object. When anger arises, we should either think that in this life we used to have good relations with the person towards whom we feel angry at present, or in previous lives we had good relations, and this will lead to a reduction in the anger. Then in the case of pride, pride arises through the exaltation of some very small qualities. There are some who have such proclivities for pride that merely because they have a beautiful voice, they become proud.
Then one way to eliminate it is to reflect on the multiple subdivisions into five aggregates, 12 sources and 18 constituents, which can get very complicated. And as a result, one’s pride will abate. And therefore, if one wishes to eliminate or to dispel doubt and ignorance, This can only be done through an antidote, which is an understanding of the actual mode of existence of phenomena. Geshela apologizes. He’s gonna drink some water.
There are two means of dispelling the afflictions from our minds. The first is a means of dispelling them in the short term through applying antidotes which cause them to abate, but they can reappear later. The second involves applying antidotes in such a way that they can never appear again. They have been permanently abandoned. Now specifically, if one merely tries to counter attachment to the sense objects such as form, sounds, smells, taste, and tactile sensations through reflecting on their faults, This is a technique, of the antidotes which is shared with non Buddhist practitioners.
And this is a technique we engage in through our limited capacities reflecting on the thoughts of whatever object of attraction we encounter. However, even though one can abandon, one can eliminate the afflictions in the short term in this way, it is not a permanent elimination. Once the afflictions encounter an object which is conducive to them, they will appear again. Non Buddhist practitioners are unable to abandon permanently the afflictions. They can merely cause them to abate in their intensity, and when they encounter the conditions for them to arise again, unfortunately, the afflictions do arise.
Since the root of all of the afflictions is none other than the grasping at a self of persons, it is that self of persons which is to be abandoned. And to abandon the grasping at a self of persons, one must counter it with a mind which is its direct opposite. This is the apprehension of a non self of persons. This apprehension of a non self of persons will cause the elimination of the grasping at a self of persons. When one has understood that the conceived object of the grasping at a self of persons does not exist through, for instance, the direct realization of the selflessness of persons, then one will have attained the noble truth of the path.
And the Noble Truth of the Path is subdivided into two, an uninterrupted path which is the actual antidote to the afflictions and a path of release which is the permanent abandonment of the afflictions. The uninterrupted path within the Noble Truth of the Path is that component of the path which expels, for instance, a thief from the house. Then after all of the afflictions have been abandoned, that abandonment, that cessation of the afflictions is known as the noble truth of cessation. The noble truth of cessation is that pacification, which pacifies all afflictions, that elimination which eliminates all afflictions known as the noble truth of cessation. And therefore, the complete pacification and elimination of the first two noble truths, the noble truth of origin and suffering, is none other than than the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of cessation, which is actualized by the third noble truth, the noble truth of the path.
And therefore, pacifying one’s mind through eliminating all afflictions at the beginning is akin to expelling a thief from one’s house. Then once one has enacted the the noble truth of the path, in other words, once one has expelled the thief from the house, there is another path which is simultaneous with the noble truth of cessation which one attains. It is the path of release. It is said that once one has attained the noble truth of cessation, which is equivalent to a path of release, this is akin after having expelled the thief from the house to close the doors and lock them up. And then at this point, whatever objects of abandonment have been abandoned can no longer arise again.
Then the afflictions have been permanently abandoned. Then once one has abandoned permanently all the afflictions which are to be abandoned, one has attained liberation. And therefore, if one puts effort at the beginning, one will be able to prevent the afflictions from manifesting. And then over time, one will be able not merely to do this, but actually to abandon them, to eliminate them permanently. And since the root of all of the afflictions is ignorance, once one has applied the antidote to ignorance and has abandoned ignorance as a byproduct, one will have abandoned all of the afflictions.
Then having abandoned all the afflictions without exception, no type of suffering can arise anymore. Then forget the nine types of suffering, no type of suffering can arise. So Geshela has completed his presentation of the four noble truths and within the six root afflictions, he has presented the afflictions which are not related to the view since he doesn’t feel there’s great benefit in talking about the afflictions related to the view in a Buddhist center basically. Then Geshela will be open to your questions for about what he talked about today during the next twenty five minutes. If the view that we have of self is so fundamentally flawed, how did that mind come into existence in the first place?
Then Geshela will give you a clear explanation. So when we are speaking of self grasping or the grasping of the apprehension of a self of persons, we are not talking about the mind which thinks I am a person, I am a being, or which thinks I. What is referred to by the apprehension of a self, of persons, is that mind which thinks that this I is not dependent, related, or contingent on the parts of the body, on the aggregates and so forth, but is completely independent of them. For instance, when we call out to someone and say, when we call out the name, what appears to the conceptual mind thinking of is a which exists independently of the five aggregates of Trashi. It is that Trashi existing independently of the five aggregates of Trashi which is the grasping at self of Trashi.
So while Trashi arises in dependence on his aggregates, there is no Trashi which is of a separate nature from the aggregates. Likewise, when beings examine themselves, this I which they feel exists powerfully within themselves is an I which is an owner of the aggregates, which has power over the aggregates, which is different from the aggregates. It is this I towards which egoism or self cherishing arises, then on who which on whose basis desire and the other afflictions arise. The apprehension of a self existing person apprehends a self as solid as the bell Geshela is holding. Then it is in dependence on apprehending such a solid self that on this basis self cherishing or egoism arises, then pride, desire and so forth.
If we discard this self, this inherently existing self, all of these disappear as well. Now the I, which exists in reality, is not the I which we are refuting when we refute the existence of a self of persons. So part of the problem comes from the fact that we have a an I which exists and an I which does not exist, and we use the same name I for both. The I which exists is the eye which, independent on the aggregates, walks, sits, and so forth. Geshela spoke earlier on about meditating on love, compassion, and bodhichitta, and that what is being referred to is generating them mentally within our mind stream.
Is this I mean, when I attempt to meditate on, say, love, I, you know, get an actual physical feeling of it of the emotion of love. Is this is what is this what Geshe is referring to when he talks about that mental generation of of love and compassion? Yes. One must, in other words, generate love within one’s mind stream. There are probably no more questions.
And Geshela would like to conclude by saying that during the last two days, he was extraordinarily happy to be able to talk with you of the four noble truths. He tried to give an introduction to the mode of ingress into cyclic existence principally through the noble truth of the origin of suffering, which is karma and affliction, and the mode of egress out of cyclic existence principally through the noble truth of the path. And he sincerely hopes this has been of some benefit to you. When Buddha Śākyamūni taught the 12 links of interdependent origination, he also taught extensively about anguish, about suffering, and about the intermediate state. However, later on, the great pandits in India and Tibet, they taught the 12 links of dependent arising, did not add the Buddha’s teachings on anguish, suffering and the intermediate state.
And the reason for which it is appropriate not to talk after presentation of the 12 links of anguish, suffering, the intermediate state and mental discomfort is because while it is true that if one does not practice correctly at the time of death, these are experiences one will encounter. It is also true that if one practices correctly, one will not experience these experiences at the time of death. And this is why I myself did not explain these to you when I explained the 12 links since we gathered here how to learn to practice and I am convinced that at the time of death you yourselves will be able to practice. It is certain if one practices well from one’s own side that at the time of death, one will not experience suffering, anguish, and so forth. And you remember that Geshela recounted what happened to a Geshe from Amdo.
She killed a great monastery in the East of Tibet who had been sentenced to death by the Chinese by firing squad. When this geyshe was executed, because of his regular and consistent practice, he had no fear. And he said to his executioner, give me five minutes before shooting. And during these five minutes, he recited the famous stanza from the Lama Chöpa, from the Guru Puja, which reads as follows. Bless me, most compassionate guru, that I be able to take upon myself the sins, obstructions, and afflictions of all mother sentient beings without exception, and that I be able to give to others all my merit and virtue without exception.
After saying this, he said to his executioner, shoot. And because he died in such excellent, an excellent frame of mind, there was no fear whatsoever. And therefore, let us all please practice this training in love, compassion, and bodhichitta because in this way, at the time of our death, there will be no difficulty whatsoever. Because to say I don’t really like all this talk about past and future lives will be of no benefit. Because death will certainly come for all of us without exception, and when she comes, we do not know.
Therefore, we should prepare for her. And therefore, thinking in this way, please practice. Thank you very much. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So turn to turn to page nine, and we will be doing offering a body, speech, and mind by singing the mandala offering on verse eight. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you.
Yeah. Yeah. Can we come around and just leave space here? Then you can sit, make it yourself yourself organized, you know, not, you know, cover each other. Okay?
Block each other. Yeah. You can yeah. That’s right there. You can come.
Two people here. Thank you to all the hard work behind the scenes in the kitchen. Chris and And Carol. And Mandy. And Lily.
And Chris and Cook. Lily Bell. And for everybody that has helped in any possible way. Thank you so much. Thank you very much.
Probably.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.