6,756 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. A teacher answers student questions about how to help others, the Four Noble Truths, the difference between physical and mental suffering, and the three sufferings. He argues that true help depends on first purifying oneself through calm abiding, and that suffering must be examined and tested against reality. He encourages listeners to check the Buddhist teachings for themselves.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 9e94b846-466e-468d-bbb1-797509e7e2b5
Words: 6,752
There’s always one. Elliot, can you comment on what the 18 non Buddhist teachings were that the teachers did? I don’t know them all. They would have included, I mean, to answer your question, give some background about the period because it’s a really interesting period. It’s a period which I’ve called the Gangetic period because it’s a period in India which corresponds to the great explosion of philosophy in ancient Greece.
It’s certainly the most period, most fertile period in Indian history, broadly speaking from the seventh to the fourth century BC centered around the Ganges Basin. And you have wandering ascetics who correspond to the philosophers of ancient Greece teaching every single conceivable system thought. Some teach that there is a self, an Ātman. We speak of a self, we mean the soul or an Ātman in the in the Christian sense of the term. Some teach that there is no self as the Buddha.
Some teach that there is no past lives and no future lives. Some, like the Indian philosopher, Sanjaya Belatthiputta, teach that one can know nothing. He was a skeptic before his age. Then of these 18, the Buddha eventually stood out. And I think the main contemporary rival of the Buddha was the founder of the Jain tradition, Mahavira, who is considered in the early Buddhist texts with a lot of respect and esteem.
The main difference between Mahavira and the Buddha is that the Buddha taught selflessness and Mahavira taught the existence of a self. The Buddha, however, has only contempt for the so called Lokāyata teachers, one of whom was counted among the 18. I forget his, exact name. It was Gosala. He was a potter by birth.
Then he taught that the universe was infinite, had no beginning and no end, that there were no past and future lives, good deeds had no meaning nor did any evil deeds have any meaning. And according to Gosala, everything was subject to astrological determinism. So it’s in that world that the Buddha appeared. I hope that answers your question. Just one about priorities, really, Elya.
Geshela mentioned that we should or not focus on eliminating suffering in this life for ourselves, but focus on eliminating suffering in future lives. And that makes sense, I can see, because ultimately, if you’re striving for enlightenment, it’s not totally selfish. But to what extent I have a problem if I have to turn away from eliminating the suffering of fellow human beings now if I can do something? Well, if you can help others, clearly, you should. I think, however, as Westerners, we have very unrealistic, a very unrealistic assessment of our true capacity to help help others.
If you take Australia, you have a welfare state. In a welfare state, the government is proactive in helping others. It is very debatable whether welfare in Australia truly and sincerely helps people. The motivation is excellent. But in Australia, as in The UK, when large swathes of the population end up living from month to month on benefits, does this actually increase the interior qualities of the person or not?
Now this is completely motivated by I think quite an altruistic wish to help others. Then when I was in India, I saw many NGOs, who were act which were active in India trying to help others. I think overall, and I can say this certainly for India, is based on direct experience, their work was of limited benefit at best in many cases meaningless. And I think the Buddhist understanding of helping others is very different from our very proactive Western understanding. The Buddhist understanding is that we can truly help others when we have helped ourselves up to a certain point.
Now Atisha defines that point in the Bodhipathapradīpa as having calm abiding. Because with calm abiding, there are some uncommon mental capacities which enable us to actually identify exactly the problems of others. Otherwise, for instance, if I let’s say this is more case in The US than in Australia. If I gave money to a homeless person who asked for it, I had no means of knowing with my limited capacities whether this helped or did not help the homeless person. If the homeless person was alcoholic, it harmed the homeless person because the money would go to alcohol or perhaps drugs.
If the homeless person was hungry and used it for food, it helped the homeless person. So from a Buddhist standpoint, we start by training ourselves because it’s only when we ourselves have purified ourselves up to a certain level that we can effectively help others. Then obviously that doesn’t mean we don’t help others in the short and now. But you can see all of you know the damage which charity and welfare does. In Australia, I think the damage welfare does is a taboo topic, but I see it among the students of the center.
I really see it. People who have become dependent on welfare are fragileized psychologically. They do not perform in their studies. They do not perform in their practice. Now true help, true charity starts by helping others to stand on their own feet.
And that calls for a very, very sound understanding of the other person’s situation, their needs and their capacities, which we don’t have. I’m sorry. I hope this is not too provocative. I never know if I can talk about these topics in Australia or not. Does it answer your question?
Yeah. I think so. It clarifies it. So the our focus really should still be on eliminating suffering and future life. In the Mahāyāna context, we practice to help others.
But we are fully aware of our own limitations in helping others. We want to, but we all know that the road to hell is paved with good intentions. We know this very well. Yes. Are there other questions?
I do have a couple of questions, Ilya. The first one would be about Tuśita and that Geshela was saying that the gods didn’t want Buddha Śākyamūni to come down and deal with us barbarians. That feels like a fairly selfish attitude from the gods. Can you talk a little bit about that situation? The gods are selfish, so are we.
Right? I mean, which one of us wanted Khensur Rinpoche to go back to India where he’s of much better benefit than in Australia? The gods are beings like us. Then whether we accept they exist or not, that’s another issue. But from a Buddhist standpoint, they really do.
Some of these are beings with bodies, more subtle than ours, much more subtle. Others are pure mind. Then their capacities are far more advanced than anything we can imagine. These are beings who can in an instant of concentration, apprehend the nature of thousands, many, perhaps tens of thousands of particle. Some of these beings never even leave the higher Jnanas.
They have not a single conceptual thought. But those in Tuśita, I think, fully valued the Buddhist teachings and felt that the Buddha would be of no benefit on earth. Then Buddha Śākyamūni, which is who is the force of the universal eliminations, took the uncommon vow to help those none of the other Buddhas could help. And that is said to be those of us here. There are teachers nowadays who do the same thing.
I I personally have always felt that Khensur Rinpoche was in that category of teacher. And in that sense, of my 11 teachers, he is perhaps unique. Rinpoche has an uncommon focus on those for whom all the other teachers have given up. I’ve seen this many times. And from my own side, it gave me a lot of faith in Rinpoche because when I first met some of Rinpoche students, I thought, good gods.
You know? Who is Rinpoche sending us? You know? And then I realized Rinpoche had seen things nobody else had seen. Rinpoche sent some people to be ordained whom I thought didn’t have a chance in hell.
And they turned out very well. So I think Buddha Śākyamūni is a bit in that, or has to be understood in that perspective. Then what are your other questions? Well, I also was really interested in, the fact that the four noble truths can be taught in two main ways. And I hadn’t come across the cause and effect presentation and I was quite fascinated about that.
And I was wondering whether the reason that Rinpoche, sorry, Geshela is teaching us the straightforward practice way is because you use the cause and effect for different types of minds. Not really. There are two reasons for teaching the practice presentation. First, it is the one the Buddha himself taught. The Buddha taught the noble truth of suffering, the noble truth of origin, the noble truth of cessation, and the noble truth of the path to cessation in this sequence.
And the question which arises is why such an unnatural sequence? From the effect to the cause, from the effect to the cause. And the reason is simply because it’s the psychologically natural sequence. So that is why Buddha taught it in this way. That’s why Geshela is teaching it too.
For us, if we think carefully of the Four Noble Truths, we can see that there is a series of benchmarks or a series of stages we have to pass through. The first is the hardest for Westerners to accept that our situation is suffering. I think, especially if one is accustomed to a very comfortable life in Australia or in the West in general, is extremely difficult unless one understands really what suffering means. And here, it’s very helpful as Gesher did to make a distinction between physical and mental suffering or as my teacher, the late Khensur Rinpoche did, between pain and suffering. Pain is a physical experience.
If I pinch myself, there is pain. Suffering is the mental response to that. If my mind is profoundly attached to my body, this slight pinching of my arm will cause an extremely powerful response of suffering. And we all know people who can’t stand a mosquito bite. If my mind is not attached at all to my body, even a burn will cause pain, but the mind is not going to respond with suffering, with mental suffering.
So once one understands that there’s a difference between pain and suffering, well, that depends — called nyepa and dukngal. Then one starts to come close to the first noble truth. And then after that, the second noble truth is very difficult for us because you cannot accept the second noble truth without accepting the existence of past and future lives. For doesn’t accept the second the existence of past and future lives, one does not accept that past karma and past afflictions can cause suffering in this life. Then I think for me, the hardest is the third noble truth.
To accept that there is an a cessation of suffering. A cessation doesn’t just mean that you put an end to suffering. It means that suffering can never come back. It has been uprooted like a weed from the very root. It will never grow back.
That calls for lot of analysis. His Holiness emphasizes this point a lot. And then the fourth noble truth is pretty evident. Does that answer your question? Yes, please.
Am I on the right track in contemplating with regard to the cessation of suffering that I’ve sort of rephrased my question to Geshela earlier in the week, that it is consciousness and met compositional factors of the five aggregates that do the imputing. That do what? That do the action of imputing the self. Is it a combination, not necessarily an equal measure, of compositional factors and consciousness that commit the action of imputing the self? That’s very debatable.
You’d have to analyze it school by school. If you are speaking of an imputation of the self in a theoretical context, then clearly can only be consciousness. Otherwise, you’d have to analyze. You’d have to analyze. Is there a topic worthy of analyzing?
Well, it’s very difficult because I think it would depend on each school. It would depend on each school. For instance, if desire, desire is a mental factor within a compositional factors. Then can desire impute the existence of a self or not? Clearly when one desires an object, the mind desiring the object reifies that object.
To say that there is no imputation of the self is strange. You know? Desire can be both conceptual and non conceptual. Both are present. There could be both conceptual and non conceptual imputations of the self.
I think it’s a difficult question. The best way to approach it would be to study the tenet systems of each of the schools moving up from the lower to the top, you know, and then you’d have to enter into a very careful study of logic. So Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen will be teaching logic here, when he returns. You have another question. Perhaps I can ask a question really while people are thinking.
The cause for the material body, the sperm and the egg, said to, be unclean substances. Is that, because they are of a previous body which is contaminated by karma and delusions? Because the sperm and the egg wouldn’t be inherently unclean? Nothing is inherently unclean, but it’s clear that if you see menstrual blood on the floor, it’s not the most inspiring of sites. Then we have a natural reaction of revulsion towards these substances.
And the goal in mentioning that they are unclean is to point out that the human body is unclean. Then the uncleanness of the human body is, one of the great taboo topics in the West. We spend our days in the shower trying to forget how unclean the human body is. Then, it’s an argument I think or an issue best addressed not theoretically but practically. So those of you who want to have a sense of the nature of the human body, stop washing, stop shaving, stop applying makeup.
If you dye your hair, stop dyeing your hair, and I don’t ask you to do that for one month, I think one week is enough. Your family may decide not to hang out with you anymore. So the human body is basically a very dirty affair. Shantideva contrasts a wooden statue with the human body, and the contrast is striking. If you have a a nice wooden statue, it remains clean, perhaps a bit dusty after years, but clean indefinitely.
The human body without count constant maintenance is is a revolting thing. And the the substances, whether it’s snot, earwax, saliva, semen, blood, feces, is is quite disgusting. It’s interesting that there’s I know someone, a Romanian doctor in Switzerland. He’s not a Buddhist at all. This is someone who does a lot of autopsies.
He’s actually a forensic pathologist. And he said to a friend of mine who is a priest, you know, the body is only attractive until you cut it open, at which point it is disgusting. This is a non Buddhist speaking. So do you have other questions? Yes, please.
Nearly the West has a lot of ways distracting you from physical suffering and from mental suffering. So the next best thing is only a shop away and you can buy material happiness very quickly. In order to progress along the Four Noble Truths, understanding the First Noble Truth is important. How can we in the West get a better grasp for that First Noble Truth? What’s a practical study that we can undertake on a day to day basis that can help us understand mental suffering better?
I think most of us, have come in contact with Buddhism precisely because we have exhausted the possibilities for material happiness. Then I personally think that a Westerner cannot become a sincere Buddhist until he has tried out he or she has tried out materialism. So I would say go for the money, go for the fun, and see whether it answers your ultimate questions. Because it’s only after you have found it doesn’t that you’ll be open to something else. Then I was one of the lucky few who was extremely wealthy, could do what I wanted with my life.
And therefore, I had the boat. I had the secondary residence. I had the primary residence. My main goal was not paying taxes. So I traveled so as not to pay taxes.
You know? And the big preoccupation every day was what restaurant do I eat in? You know? Then I was very lucky because I’ve always had a strong theoretical interest in other things. So it just became very clear to me that this had no no substance.
Right? But I think you’ve got to try it. You know? If a part of you is really convinced that money is gonna make you happy, then your commitment is never gonna be strong enough. You’ve got you’ve got to have the money.
You’ve got to have the goodies the West provides. Right? The money, the status, the girls, whatever. And then you’ll see that really it’s nothing. And one can understand at that point the process of superimposition.
Superimposition means putting something which is unrealistic on the basis of something which already exists. Right? It’s not that money is useless. Money is useful. We need money.
But money is over appreciated for what it can do. I can speak from direct experience in this matter that in the big big crisis in life, money stops to function. So I was in India, in two or three when, we were at the at the edge of war with Pakistan, you know. Everyone fled the monastery. Then if you had money, you couldn’t do anything with it.
You wanted an airline ticket, you couldn’t get an airline ticket in India with money because nobody was selling. Money ceased to have value. Then I think the next great goal for Westerners is relationships. Right? People spend their life running from one fantasized relationship to another until they realize they’re old.
Right? At which point, at some at some point, they may run after but everyone else is running away from them. Right? And at this point, the person suddenly realizes that perhaps this was waste of time, but they lack the energy at this point to do anything else. So I think for Westerners, first explore carefully, or first we have to explore carefully our own culture and become truly convinced that it is an essenceless culture.
There’s nothing inside. And then at that point, the big realization, which is something which Asia has lost and we are trying to discover, is that happiness starts here. So I had that experience when I was in Dharamsala many, many years ago. I was a young Westerner. It’s very good family.
I had twisted my father’s arm to let me go to India to study Tibetan Buddhism at 19. There was this huge back sack filled with things, you know, I thought I needed, many books as a matter of fact, you know, staggered into upper Dharamsala and McLeod Ganj. And I saw this Indian ascetic. I’ve never seen him before nor after. He must have been well in his seventies.
He just had a loincloth, a stick in a bag, nothing else. And he was absolutely radiant. And there I was staggering under the weight of my possessions and definitely not radiant at all, you know, very hot and bothered. Then I looked at him and I thought, my goodness, you see. Here I am 19.
I have everything. There he is in his seventies, a beggar in India, where being a beggar means you have nothing. Right? And he is radiant, and I am not. And that means that his road to happiness is a road which leads to results.
Mine doesn’t. He wasn’t a Buddhist or anything, but all of the Indian tradition and to a degree, the Christian, Muslim, Jewish religious traditions are all traditions which say that this life isn’t the end it all. And we live in a world which is saying that. So I think to understand the noble truth of suffering and then the remaining noble truth, first, we have to be profoundly convinced that happiness in the here and now is not really meaningful. It’s a very long answer, but does it it answer your question?
It does. I have a more wife than they’re happy. It does. Well, you have to find a compromise. I have a very understanding wife.
Then those of you who don’t, you have to try to explain. There other questions? Ilya, I was curious about Geshela’s comment about when he went into Tibet and the need to encourage the Tibetans to listen to the teachings as opposed to the group today. And just wondering if you could comment on that. Well, we talked about it several times at the center.
Basically, for us, because we are in a spiritual wasteland, we project much of our spiritual expectations abroad, in this case, on the Tibetans. And Tibet is a particularly apt support of projection because, basically, it was a very spiritual society, but also frankly, it doesn’t exist anymore. So one can say what one wants. Now the relation the actual relation of Tibetans to Tibetan Buddhism is one of profound faith. But in some senses, it’s not that different from our relation to Christianity in the West a couple of centuries ago.
People went to church because if you didn’t go to church, you basically got into trouble. Not perhaps legal trouble, but you were looked down upon in society. You were unreliable. People wouldn’t do business with you. They wouldn’t let their children marry with your children.
There were some massive social pressures on, you know, being a part of the religious establishment. Then when a teacher like Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen comes to Tibet, if you’re in the village and you don’t go to these teachings, you’re a bad Tibetan, Perhaps even a friend of the Chinese. This has a big impact on your life. So people go because they feel they have to go. Then, if people go when they feel they have to go, the heart isn’t there.
And I’m not quite sure they benefit a lot. So in the West, one of the big advantages we have is that people come sincerely. Every one of you could do something else with your time. You are here, so the motivation is quite sincere. With Asians, it’s much more complicated.
You go because everyone is going, because you have to go. It wouldn’t look good. Every young Thai man becomes a monk for some three months of his life. I have not noticed a great impact on their behavior in Thailand. Then when I was in Dharamsala, if his holiness teaches, you have to go if you’re Tibetan.
It’s it’s nonnegotiable. Dharamsala empties. And I never forget, I once had to leave the teaching for something and I saw this young Tibetan boy, maybe 22, 23, who hadn’t gone to the teaching and who was desperately puffing on a cigarette, I think he was really trying to be very bad. But he looked terribly worried about the whole thing. Then, I mean, this is, you know, a very messy motivation.
Right? I’m not sure there’s any benefit for anyone in that. Now does that answer your question? Thank you for taking questions, Ilya. I’m interested in the distinction that Buddhism makes between mental suffering and physical suffering.
Because here in the West, it seems science is doing its best to combine the two and say that, you know, everything rests on the brain. So do you know the, like, a description of the difference, or or is that something that that is not focused Well, you have to keep in mind that, the Western approach to science is built on a certain model. The model is the equation or the identification of the brain and the mind. They are one. Therefore, all suffering is basically physical suffering for Western psychiatrists and biologists.
Then I think in the last two years at the center, we’ve tried to present a series of I think rather strong arguments in favor of the fact that there is a mind apart from the brain. That when the brain ceases to exist, there is something which remains, which may not be the coarse mind, which we are using right now to communicate, but a more subtle level of mind. Then I’ve drawn on on data basically from psychiatry, from linguistics, from physics, from neurobiology, from parapsychology, even from evolutionary biology to show that there is a case, and I think a strong case to be made. Once you accept the existence of such a mind, then the question is what sort of suffering can that mind experience? And for instance, being conflicted would be a typical case.
If the person has conflictual motivations, wants to do two things at the same time, cannot decide, it’s a source of great suffering. I mentioned a couple of weeks ago the case of dissociative identity disorder. And I think I showed you the data which shows that it is very, very seldom cured. It’s quite interesting to hear psychiatrists recognizing that it is not cured. And I was just reading recently, a very interesting article by Patrick McNamara, who is an American neurobiologist, Who considers that one has to basically separate what he calls possession from dissociative identity disorder and schizophrenia.
And, points out that in cases of possession there is no evidence, generally speaking, before nor after the possession of mental disorder. Then all of this seems to indicate there is a mind independent of the body and this mind can experience suffering. This mind’s reaction to physical suffering is what we in the Buddhist tradition are trying to learn to control. An arhat, for instance, experiences physical suffering, pain. If an arhat walks on a thorn, the pain is there, but there is no mental suffering.
The two are separated. For example, if someone believes they are being pursued and becomes paranoid, they believe that they’re in danger, but there is no actual danger, that would be purely mental suffering. Whereas if someone was chasing them, would they also be considered to be an aspect of physical suffering present? What if they’re running naturally? They’re running.
But the physical suffering would just be from the running, the exertion, the no? Most of the suffering we see in the centers in the West because people come because they are suffering. Otherwise, most people wouldn’t push the door. Come from mental suffering or people at the end of their lives. And suddenly, are no answers.
All their lifelong, they have evacuated the big questions. Then they reach the end of their life. And suddenly, the question is, why did I live? And more fundamentally, where am I going? And the person has no answer.
So it’s all all of us are doing well that we have to put effort towards this. Then I’ll be glad to take other questions. Otherwise, perhaps I can ask you some questions. What would you prefer? Please, please.
I would appreciate if you could just talk a little bit more on the third it’s the the actual pain, and then it is, you know, discovering all the time that, oh, that that money doesn’t make me happy either. So those three different kinds of realization and and then, you know, nothing really makes me happy. Could could you just at least at at that of suffering, I think, is what you’re talking about. Yeah. Yes.
That’s a very interesting question. Well, the suffering of suffering, there is not much to say. You have both physical and mental suffering of suffering. We all know what it is. I think the great Indian philosopher, Āryadeva, put it beautifully when he said the poor suffer in their body and the rich suffer in their minds.
When I was in India, I saw physical suffering, but honestly, very little mental suffering. Westerners who go to India always comment on how happy people are. Then here, I have seen a tremendous amount of mental suffering. And I remember I was very annoyed once with a general Western attitude to things and I went to Jado Rinpoche, a very, very fine monk, the former abbot of Namgyal monastery, very close to his holiness. And I said to him, Rinpoche, I just find it very difficult to handle Westerners because here are all these Indians who have the best reasons in the world to be unhappy, and they’re quite cheerful.
And here are all these Western students who have pensions or money coming in, who are in good health, and who invent themselves problems. And Rinpoche hit the nail on the head. He said, it’s the same thing. And it is the same thing. It’s a manifestation of this propensity to suffering we have.
Now in India, obviously, it’s covered up by physical suffering. With people who are dying because they lack medical treatments, very common, you know, who die of slow starvation, it’s very common even now. It’s just the person just starves over the years, you know, Just enough to stay alive, but not enough to build immune resistance, you know. Here in the West, the minds have become very twisted, you know. And we see this every day more and more, don’t we, with crimes which beggar the imagination.
This is from mental suffering. The second category of suffering, the suffering of change, much more difficult to understand. It’s basic it amounts to saying that what we call happiness is just the level of suffering dropping under a certain threshold. This really very striking. If we had time, I would do a little experiment with you, but I think we’re short of time.
Do it at home. You just you can sit in a chair. You put a watch in front of yourself and you must absolutely motionless without blinking your eyes or moving for five minutes. Five minutes is not a lot of time. Right?
You just stare at the watch. And you can take my word for it. Those five minutes are gonna last hours. You’re gonna notice itches, pains, cramps. You cannot move.
So the itch starts, you just let the itch grow and grow. You’ll be surprised how far an itch can grow. Then cramps, you know, as your back will start cramping, then your head will start itching, then you’ll have a desperate urge to blink, don’t blink. All you’re allowed to do is to breathe. Now at the end of those five minutes, what you will have noticed is that there is a tremendous amount of constant suffering which is under the threshold of attention.
And the moment this is what one learns through insight meditation. The moment you engage in insight in Satipatthana meditation, this becomes very obvious. Right? You become in Satipatthana, all you’re doing is lowering the threshold. Right?
Through paying attention, you’re lowering the threshold of suffering. And the first realization you get in Sattipattana meditation is the nature of suffering. That it’s not the case that we are suffering from time to time when, let’s say, a child’s baseball hits our thigh. But that baseball hitting our thigh is just above the threshold of attention and it registers. The moment we basically become more focused, more aware of what is going on, suffering is uninterrupted and what we call happiness is just a decrease of suffering.
You are hungry, you haven’t really become aware of it, but it’s there in the background, you eat and you feel full and that is a source of happiness. Likewise with physical happiness. Likewise with mental happiness. So there’s not a single case of happiness which cannot be understood as a reduction of suffering. Not just understood, if you practice yourself, if you look at yourself in Sattipattana, you will see this.
Then obviously if that’s the case, that second type of happiness is not stable, right? Because you’ve basically merely reduced a certain level of suffering which is going to come back. And the third level of suffering or pervasive suffering is what the noble truth of suffering really refers to. That is the fact that we have bodies and minds which are prone to suffering. Now we take this for granted, but it’s not the case.
If you accept the existence of disincarnate entities like the gods of the formless realms, you could always see that a god whose mind is in the fourth jnana, for instance, would have no overt suffering, would he? If something like that exists, it’s quite quite something. And this god would stay in this k in this state for eons. The problem is eventually one is reborn out of that. So those are the three sufferings.
The first one is easy to understand, the suffering of suffering. And within that, one has to understand that for us the biggest threat is mental suffering. The second, the suffering of change, I think really can only be understood through mindfulness. It’s a big advantage of mindfulness, just small mindfulness practice for oneself at home. And the third is our propensity to suffering.
Then if you have no more questions, maybe I can ask you one or two questions. 02:30. Yeah. We stop at 02:15. It’s the last desperate attempt to stay.
What’s the biggest source of suffering in your lives? You don’t have to answer me. You can keep it private, but think about it for yourselves, each one for yourself, nowadays. Is it bodily suffering? Is it mental suffering?
What’s the biggest source of suffering? And then ask yourself, what can I do to durably eliminate that? Is there something I can do or not? But you have to be fundamental in your analysis. Your greatest suffering might be your wrinkles, but that is old age, isn’t it?
And there’s something one can do about old age. Then if one’s greatest suffering is disease, that’s part of medicine. But if medicine can’t do anything about it, then what? And if one’s greatest suffering is mental, and we have quite a few cases, then most certainly before coming here, have been to see psychiatrists, psychologists, therapists, counselors. Have they helped durably?
Temporarily help probably is possible, but durably. Then what I would like to propose to you is that we try to leave aside everything we know for these two days and see if what the Buddhists say makes sense. Doesn’t have to make sense, but we see if it makes sense. If it’s true that mental suffering is the main suffering, then that you have to check for yourself. Is it true that between physical and mental suffering, when my body suffers, it’s my mental response which is more important than my bodily one, then I should look for mental responses.
If that is true, does it make more sense to address mental suffering by drugs? Legal or illegal, from a Buddhist standpoint it’s the same thing. That includes alcohol, tobacco, marijuana, whatever whatever you use, psychotropics, anxiolytics, or to counter the mind by the mind. And the Buddhist response to counter the mind by the mind. If it makes sense to counter the mind by the mind, do I know how to?
And am I doing it? If I know how to and I’m not doing it, I’m wasting my time. And then, the very big question is, is it possible that there is a permanent end to mental suffering of all types? So until you have answered yes to that question, your practice, I think will be very weak. Once one has answered yes to that question, one is unstoppable.
That there is a true end to suffering, it’s possible to put an end to it. It’s very difficult to be convinced that it’s possible not just to reduce it like desire arises, you apply the antidote, it abates but then it will arise again. But is it possible to eliminate it durably for good? If that is possible, that’s a conviction we have to have. Then we should try to find the means to do so, so in not to find this means depending on our own partial sympathies.
Oh, I rather like the idea that there is a soul, so I think that’s what I’ll go for. Or I rather like the idea that there isn’t one, so that’s what I’m gonna go for. Instead, we have to ask ourselves, what is there which really could eliminate suffering from the root? It’s not a trivial question. Right?
Is it true what the Buddhists say that only meditation on selflessness can eliminate suffering from the root or not? And for that we have to check. Are we truly selfless or not? If you have any doubts in that respect, you haven’t started to travel on the Buddhist path. Because the question in our practice is that our practice must be in harmony or in agreement with reality.
There’s no point in practicing something which is false. You know, if you’re buying a house, the first thing you want to do is to get a true evaluation of the house because you’re gonna pay for it. And you’re very careful getting that true evaluation. Then in terms of one’s mental practice, it’s the same thing. Be hard nosed about it.
Be as hard nosed about the Buddhist teachings as you are about money, about your health, about a mortgage. Is what the Buddhists say true? And if it is, what am I gonna do about it? And if it is not true, they’ll walk away. Right?
Life is short. Go have fun. Alright? What are you doing here? And those are the questions you have to ask yourself.
It makes a difference only to yourself, to nobody else. A Buddhist path is one in which we are very alone. If we change our minds, we benefit. If we don’t change our minds, as Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen was was saying to me today, we’re prostrating to the teacher, why bother, right? I mean, what’s the point of all the ritual?
So be very hard nosed, examine. We’re very fortunate Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen to have someone who gives a strong analytical presentation. You know? And your goal is not to convince yourself against reality, but to see whether what the Buddhists say is true or not. And for this, you should rely on all the tools at your disposal.
There’s a lot of scientific data proving reincarnation. You should read that. Then there’s a lot of data proving the existence of disincarnate spirits. You should study it. Then you should ask yourself, if reincarnation exists, is it true that karma exists as well?
The two can be independent. Right? They have reincarnation and no karma. And if it is true that karma operates, that what you do in a past life affects your happiness in the future life, and you have data in Stevenson, read Stevenson’s reincarnation of biology, then you have to ask yourself, then me, what am I going to do about this? You want to find a way to be freed from this and you have to find a true way.
Life is short. Ancient India dedicated, I think we can say, two thousand five hundred years of its history to finding these answers. Everyone agreed on the basics. The Buddhists, the Hindus, the Jains, the Sikhs, everyone agreed, we reincarnate. Everyone agrees there is karma.
Everyone agrees virtue leads to happiness, non virtue leads to unhappiness. Everyone, except the which are minority group. Everyone disagrees about the solution, the remedy because it is important, because people are trying to find ultimate answers. So you owe it to yourselves to try to find ultimate answers. Then that’s all I wanted to do.
I wanted to bring up these issues with you. It’s less a question than a suggestion for reflection. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.