5,478 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The talk explains the second noble truth, the origin of suffering, through the twelve links of interdependent origination, focusing on the six causal links: ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness, craving, taking and existence. It describes how karmic potencies ripen at death according to the mind then arising, and how this leads to rebirth. It stresses training in virtuous states of mind and cutting ignorance as the root.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 2b8c7651-1a0f-447f-98a5-0dc4e9e7973b
Words: 5,474
So we just do the short the first verse of the Mandala offering on page five, verse six. In keeping with the injunction, you shall learn the state or the crux of suffering. I have tried to explain this morning in as many details as possible the nature of suffering. And I have used the metaphor of disease. We all know that when disease occurs, we experience great suffering and as a result, we must first identify the disease and find the means to cure it.
Likewise, we do not wish to experience suffering and wish to be cured from suffering. For this, we must understand the nature of suffering and the means to be healed of it. Let alone being suffering freed from the suffering of this life, it is from the suffering of life after life that we should wish to be freed. And for this, we must understand the causes and conditions which give rise to suffering and specifically to suffering from the next life onwards. And this leads us to the second topic, the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
Any impermanent phenomenon, any composite phenomenon can only arise in dependence on causes and conditions. There are no composite phenomena which do not arise in dependence on causes and conditions. Whatever suffering we experience arises in dependence on the concatenation of a very large number of causes and conditions. Likewise, whatever happiness we experience arises in dependence on the concatenation of a large number of causes and conditions. And we have actually experienced suffering really from the time of conception onwards until the present day.
If we do not at present identify clearly the cause of this suffering, we will continue to experience suffering life after life indefinitely. If we explain suffering from the standpoint of the 12 links, then it is summarized within six of the links. The 12 links of interdependent origination can be explained in terms of six causal links and six resulting links. The six links of interdependent origination which are causal are subsumed within the second noble truth and noble truth of the origin of suffering. Whereas the six resulting links from within the 12 links are subsumed within the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering.
These six resulting links arise from the six causal links. And through understanding how these 12 links are interrelated, we will understand the process of ingress of sentient beings into cyclic existence. And therefore, it is important to understand the mode of ingress within the Four Noble Truths, the mode of cessation, likewise the mode of ingress within the 12 links and the modes of cessation or exiting the 12 links. I believe that it is because of the extreme importance of the Four Noble Truths that it was the first teaching which Buddha Śākyamūni gave to his disciples. And it is when one develops the process which leads from the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering, to the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering, that this leads to the 12 links.
We transmigrate in cyclic existence under the power of the 12 links. And therefore it would seem extremely important to understand this precisely. Most of the introductions, which His Holiness the Dalai Lama gives to Buddhadharma are done in the light of the Four Noble Truths and the 12 links. And therefore I hope sincerely that you will try to understand as much as you can the Four Noble Truths and the 12 Links. Tenzin told Geshe-la that on Mondays, they are at the center an introduction to Buddhism.
And there will be great benefit if during this period you put effort at trying to understand the Four Noble Truths and the 12 links since this will be greatly beneficial in the future for others. Then I will explain the 12 links as best and as clearly as I can. Please put effort from your side. I will first explain the six causal links then the six resulting links. The causal links are subdivided into two, the impelling causal links and the resulting causal links.
The first of the impelling causal links is the link of afflicted ignorance. And the comma which is a karma which arises in dependence on such afflicted ignorance is the second of these three first links, the link of compositional factors. And the second instant of such a karma relies on a base. The base for such karma is the link of consciousness. It is independence on these three links, In other words, afflicted ignorance compositional factors and the first instance of consciousness which are the impelling causal links that we are able in a future life to take rebirth.
For instance, our present body is the result of such three links in the past. And therefore, the root cause of our present aggregates and body is the first link afflicted ignorance. Ignorance in Tibetan Marikpa and Nescience in Tibetan Mashepa both refer to a non knowledge of the actual state of beings of phenomena. And such an ignorance, such a nescience gives rise to our non apprehension of the illusion like nature of phenomena. Through our non understanding of the illusion like nature of phenomena, in turn, numerous mistaken fancies and conception arise within our mind.
And through the superimpositions or the imputations due to such mistaken minds, in turn, desire arises towards attractive objects and hatred arises towards unattractive objects. For instance, in the case of desire, desire is a superimposition or an imputation on the basis of a slightly attractive phenomena which desire sees as hugely attractive. Affliction. These afflictions must be seen as enemies, as foes to be defeated. However, desire is particularly problematical because desire seems to be a friend, a valued friend.
And it is then very difficult to eradicate desire since it keeps on increasing. Likewise, afflictions can arise which think this object doesn’t exist in the slightest. The other afflictions do not trouble us as much as this one. It is motivated by the ignorance which does not apprehend the illusion like nature of phenomena that in turn the afflictions such as desire and so forth arise. And in turn, it is motivated by desire, for instance, a desire for meat that one eventually commits a non virtue of killing another being or motivated by the desire for wealth that one commits a non virtue of stealing.
And it is therefore in dependence on desire which values unduly an object which is only slightly attractive that one engages in physical and verbal non virtues such as killing other beings or trying to harm them using mantra for instance. And therefore, through desire for the flesh of another being or their skins, one accumulates the non virtues of body and speech. And one refers here to the accumulation of karma, literally the accumulation of action, because in the future, as a result of this, one will experience the maturation of this action. There are three possible causes of coma. The first is the result excuse me, three possible results of karma.
The first is result concordant with the cause. The second is the result of maturation. And the third is the environmental result. For instance, through slaying sentient beings in this life, in future lives, the maturation we will experience will be to have a short life. A second result is that in future lives, through having slayed beings in this life, we will delight in killing beings.
For instance, in society, we know of people who enjoy killing other beings tremendously, who delight in this. And this is a result concordant with the cause or similar to the cause of having killed beings in previous lives. Likewise, we see in human society people who live only a short life and die early. This is the result of maturation of having killed others in previous lives. And therefore, if we ourselves and future lives, we wish to have a long life and wish not to enjoy ourselves killing others, it is at present in this life that we should train in seeing the force of killing.
The abandonment of killing other beings, of harming the life of other beings is that virtuous deed of abandoning killing. And if at present through understanding by extension the force of the remaining 10 non virtues, we can engage in the virtuous deed of abandoning each of these 10 non virtues, then in future lives, things will go well for us. We unfortunately do not have the time for Geshe-la to present in detail all 10 non virtuous deeds. He has presented the non virtuous deed of killing and allows you to extend or to generalize this to the remaining nine non virtuous deeds. We engage in any of the 10 non virtuous deeds, killing, stealing and so forth through the power of this benightedness which ignores the true mode of existence of phenomena.
Whichever virtuous and non virtuous deed we accumulate, we accumulate under the power of this ignorance. Therefore, it’s extremely important to eliminate ignorance. That which is responsible for our ignoring the status of all phenomena is ignorance. In my own case, the fact that I do not understand English well is the fault of ignorance. Should I wish to understand English well, progressively studying English over the years, I would dispel my benightedness with respect to English.
Ignorance is like a fog which covers objects. When fog covers objects, we don’t see them clearly. But when we clear the fog away, when the fog is cleared away, then we can see the objects clearly. Likewise, when ignorance is dispelled, we can see clearly. And therefore that nations, that ignorance we refer to here is one which ignores numerous or misunderstands numerous phenomena.
The ignorance which does not understand the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena is called the apprehension of a self of persons and the apprehension of a self of phenomena. And therefore, to dispel that ignorance which is benighted with respect to the selflessness of phenomena and the selflessness of persons, we must train in a wisdom which understands that there is a selflessness of phenomena and a selflessness of persons. When one understands well these two selflessnesses, the ignorance which misunderstands them is eliminated. In the same way as if one understands clearly a specific object of knowledge, the ignorance regarding that object of knowledge is destroyed. The knowledge of the mode of existence of a phenomenon is the antidote to the ignorance which misunderstands the mode of existence of a phenomenon.
In our minds at present, this ignorance, this non knowledge is very present. Its antidote is weak or non existent. And because of this ignorance which does not understand the mode of existence of phenomena, we accumulate a large amount of non virtuous karma. This karma, which is accumulated in this way, makes it possible for us to be reborn in the future. Therefore, the second instant of the karma which is accrued is deposited or placed within our consciousness.
Even though the karma itself has ceased to exist, its potency is implanted within our mind stream. Just as you all know that garlic is very odorous and if you put a clove of garlic with other foods, then even after you throw the clove of garlic away, the remaining foods will smell of garlic. And when the is performed, even though the karma itself, the deed itself has ceased to exist, its potency remains in our mind just like the smell of garlic, and it can mature at the time of death. There are numerous such types of karmic potencies within our minds. These may be virtuous karmic potencies or non virtuous karmic potencies.
For instance, if in this life we engage in extensive virtuous conduct, the potency of those virtuous deeds remains within our mind stream. Likewise, if we engage extensively in non virtuous conduct, the potency of those non virtuous deeds remains also within our mind stream. This is a case in our example just for this life, but it is not just this life one talks about, it is since beginningless lives that we have accumulated both virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints which remain in our mind. At the time of our death, these karmic potencies will actually be actualized or will be led to maturation through the power of craving. The first manifestation of that desire is called craving.
That craving is a desire which does not wish to be separated from our body of this life. Independence on this limb of craving, the karmic potency within our mind stream matures a bit. For instance, if after planting a seed, we water it and we pour some liquid manure on it, then the seed will mature, will ripen a little bit. This is what happens to the karmic potencies under the influence of the link of craving. And which of these karmic potencies which is present within our mind matures at the time of death depends on our mindset or the way we are thinking in the death process.
Therefore, which virtuous karmic potency or non virtuous karmic potency starts to mature at the time of our death depends or is contingent on which virtuous or non virtuous mind is generated within our mind stream at that moment. And therefore, even though we have a large number of virtuous and non virtuous karmic potencies within our mind stream, what is determinant is the mindset, the attitude at the time of death, which determines which of these will mature. And therefore, to prepare for this moment, it is important at present to train in virtuous states of mind. For instance, due to our boundless previous habituation to non virtuous set states of mind, it calls for no effort whatsoever to give rise to a non virtuous state of mind at present, doesn’t it? And therefore, if at present when we are hale and hearty, we do not train in virtuous states of mind, there is a very great risk that non virtuous states of mind will manifest at the death time.
However, if at present we train in virtuous states of mind, there is no doubt that we will be able to generate them at the time of our death and through generating them it is a virtuous karmic potency present within our mind stream which will come to fruition, then there is no doubt we will be reborn in the higher realms. I have a story for you. Then there was once upon a time a butcher who had accumulated a tremendous amount of non virtue throughout his life through slaughtering a large number of animals. However, at the time of his death, great remorse arose in his mind stream at the thought of the non virtue he had accumulated. Then he found himself unable to die as a result.
Then a yogi realized the situation. Then the yogi from his side thought, I have practiced virtue extensively in this life. This poor butcher cannot leave, but I from my side definitely can. Then he himself fell to the ground, hit his head, and died at once. Then the yogi, because of the pride which arose in his practice, wanting to show off, was able to die at once.
And therefore it is independence on whether or not we have trained in virtuous states of mind at present in this life that at the time of our death we will be able or not to generate a virtuous state of mind. This is why in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, when someone is in agony, someone stands next to him and whispers in his ear the names of the Buddhas, of his gurus and so forth. And this is because as a result of hearing, however indistinctly, the names of the Buddhas and of his teachers, virtuous states of mind will arise during agony. Then since this is probably not possible here, it is from our own side that at present we must become accustomed to virtuous states of mind. For instance, if at present we train in virtuous states of mind, then at the time of death it will be quite straightforward to give rise to a virtuous state of mind.
And therefore, habituation is very important. We can see for ourselves that if we are accustomed to working at whatever during the day, eventually we would actually dream about that in the night proceeding. Most of the dreams we have are the result of our way of thinking and of our habituations. For this reason, it is extraordinarily important from today onwards to give up non virtuous deeds and to train in virtuous deeds. And it is extremely important not to procrastinate saying I will tomorrow, I will after tomorrow, because death and impermanence will catch up with us.
And therefore please from today onwards thinking, may I attain a good rebirth the next time around, practice in training at virtuous states of mind and engage in virtue. We take the case of those of us in this room, probably none of us will be around in sixty years’ time. And we all understand that sixty years passed quickly day after day and year after year. And thinking about this, we will be uncomfortable at the idea of deferring our practice for even one day. Death is certain for all of us.
The time of death is completely uncertain. Not one of us can say, Tomorrow I will be alive. This is why practicing dharma today is important. When the breath which we have exhaled can no longer be drawn back in, at that instant we are dead. Sometimes, I am, rather worried when I go to sleep because, before falling asleep I think tomorrow morning if the breath does not, come back in, it will be over for me.
Therefore, meditation on death and impermanence is extremely important. One of the, Sera Je Geshes went on a pilgrimage to Tibet recently and visited one of his relatives. Then they had a bowl of Tibetan soup of tupa in the evening and went to bed. The next morning, the relative got up, but the Geshe did not. He was dead.
It is definite that death and impermanence will come. And we have no way of knowing for whom it will come earlier and for whom it will come later. Then, to be polite, I will say it must come for me first. And if we reflect this way on death and impermanence and train in this way in virtue, then when we go to bed at night, whether we wake up in the morning or not makes no difference to us. And training in this way, in this very life, in generosity, we will as a result of this generosity experience great prosperity in future lives.
Training in forbearance, we will have a beautiful body and will meet teachers easily and we will eventually get a rebirth which is far superior to the present one. And therefore, the first factor which initiates the maturation of the karmic potency within the mind stream is the fourth of the six causal links, the link of craving. However, once that maturation has been initiated by the link of craving, the link which leads to the full maturation of the karmic imprint is the link of taking. This link is actually desire. The link of taking the force of the causal links is desire for the body of the next life.
This causes the full maturation of the karma. And at this point when the comma has fully matured, the comma can be said to have fully matured. So these last three links are called the three ripening links. So the three last links of the causal links are first the link of craving, then the link of taking and finally the link of existence. The link of craving is a link which initiates the maturation of the karmic potency through attachment to one’s body at the time of death.
The link of taking leads to the full maturation of the karmic potency through attachment to the body of the next life and the link of existence completes the process. These are the three ripening links from within the six causal links. These last three links are called the realizing links because they realize the aggregates of a future life. These are the six causal links. Then once these three resulting links, the links of craving, taking and existence have manifested, they will have been able to lead to fruition either virtuous or non virtuous karmas.
If at the time of death it is a virtuous state of mind which is actualized, then a virtuous comma will be brought to maturation. If it is a non virtuous state of mind which is actualized, a non virtuous karmic potency would have been brought to maturation. Then, in dependence on these six causal links, one will have died and been reborn, and karma will have been led to maturation. Then in the next life, there are four types of beings. These are oviparous births, mammalian births, births from heat and moisture, and births from miraculous powers.
In the case of a miraculous birth, the rebirth is instantaneous. Instances of miraculous rebirth would be, for instance, rebirths in the hell realms or rebirths as gods. However, pretas have two different types of rebirths. Some are born from the womb, in other words have mammalian rebirths, some experience miraculous rebirths. Oviparous rebirth or rebirth from eggs occurs when the egg has been fertilized and then the embryo grows within the egg until it breaks the egg open.
Finally, there is a fourth rebirth, which is not mammalian, oviparous or miraculous rebirth. It is rebirth from heat and moisture. Rebirth from the womb of one’s mother is mammalian rebirth. Most of us all of us have experienced All of us have experienced mammalian rebirth from the wombs of our mothers. Otherwise, Geshela says, if I say most, it means some of you have had miraculous rebirths.
I have no way of knowing whether all of you know their mothers. For both, oviparion and mammalian rebirth, one needs, parents, father and mother. Parents, genitals are not necessary for miraculous rebirth or for rebirth from heat and moisture. So we take rebirth in this way through one of the four modes of rebirth. Now within the death process at the end of this life, the heat from our body can leave from the top downwards.
Now when the heat has left the body and the capacities of our sense organs have decreased, this is a sign of the subtle death. It is said that when the heat leaves the body from the bottom up, this is a sign of rebirth in a higher realm. However, when the heat leaves from the crown downwards to the feet, it’s a sign of rebirth in a lower realm. And therefore in the Tibetan tradition, it is said that when one handles a body, one should handle the body from the lower parts first and never from the top. And in so doing, the heat is supposed to move upwards towards the head causing a rebirth in the higher realms.
But Geshe-la isn’t quite sure about this. Then after the sense faculties have shut down and the heat has left the body, let us say from the bottom upwards and from the crown to the heart, all that is left is some heat at the level of the heart. This is a case because when conception entered the embryo, it entered the embryo at the level of what later would become the heart. Likewise, when it leaves the embryo, it leaves the embryo from the level of the heart. And it is taught in the Buddhist texts that consciousness remains at the heart for up to three days.
Therefore, in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, we do not incinerate bodies for at least three days. If one were to incinerate the body before these three days passed and consciousness was still present at the heart, there is a risk of committing murder. However, in the case of yogis, even though the breath has stopped, consciousness may remain at the heart for twenty days, sometimes even for one month. There are cases of such holy beings in which consciousness remains at the heart for one full month. Geshela told me I have personally direct experience of this.
One of the monks in Geshe-la’s compound, Gendun Tsering, who was a hidden yogi, spent eighteen days in the death meditation with consciousness at the heart. Such beings do exist. Then it is only when consciousness leaves the heart that one can say that true death has occurred. Then after consciousness has left the heart, the being becomes what is known as a being of the intermediate state, a Bardo being. If one is in the next rebirth to be reborn as a human being, one does not immediately take a human form.
That state between the end of this life and the beginning of the next life, which is known as the intermediate state or the Bardo state, is one in which the being has its own body. Such a Bardo being, a being of the intermediate state, dies once a week. The being the body of a Bardo being is an extremely subtle form of matter which we cannot perceive. It is said that the body of a Bardo being is not stopped by obstructions such as walls, ceilings and so forth, but passes straight through them. However, such a Bardo being cannot remain for more than seven weeks, forty nine days in the bardo.
And the Bardo being will die at the end of each seven day interval, at the end of each week, until it takes rebirth in a new body. Normally, the rebirth to the new body happens within the first two weeks. If such a being is to be reborn as a mammalian, then the bardo being enters into the, fertilized ovum, fertilized by spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. At the time of conception, the consciousness enters into the fertilized embryo and a link is created between the fertilized embryo, which is matter which derives from the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum, the eggs of the mother, and the consciousness. This link is a karmic link which is traced back to the death of the being in the previous life.
Then the embryo grows progressively. At the beginning, the fertilized embryo is very smooth. Then there are five stages of development which I will not even attempt to translate. The first is known as merbuma. And then the embryo grows progressively becoming larger and firmer until eventually the premises of arms and legs as well as a head appear.
And then within less than ten months, the child to be is born from the womb of the mother. Then a human being is born. Dear Geshe-la, I would like to ask you whether you have understood fairly well his explanation of how the six causal links, in other words, within these three first impelling links which give rise to the accumulation of karma and the last three completing or realizing links which lead to the maturation of karma lead after the death of the person to their rebirth as a new being. And then relying on this body, we should try to move upwards. So after being reborn from our mother’s womb, growing over the years, we have reached our present state.
So the substantial cause of our present body is the union of the father’s spermatozoa and the mother’s egg. So for those of us who are ordained, thinking about how we are born is a powerful way to counter desire. All of us are equal in having desire. There is no difference in between any one of us in this matter. However, there is a difference in whether we apply the antidotes or not.
For instance, if one is male and one has lust for a female, for a woman, when one thinks that her body is actually born from literally sperm and blood, in other words, the spermatozoa and the egg, then one thinks to oneself, how can I desire this body? Desire appears when on the basis of an attractive object, conceptions are imputed which emphasize its attractiveness. The more conceptions are imputed emphasizing its attractiveness, the greater the desire until it becomes infinite. All of us are the same in having desire for such objects and therefore in your case, when desire appears in your mind for an object or for a person, you should analyze carefully this object or this person thinking what is there actually in this which is attractive and if you proceed in this way, you will be able to eliminate desire. Then if desire causes problems to your mind, please act in this way.
So what our body is actually the result of the substantial cause of the spermatozoa and the egg of the mother? Our minds are the result of a previous mind, which is its substantial cause. So the substantial cause of the first instant of consciousness which enters into the fertilized egg at conception is the last instant of the mind of the being in the intermediate state. And the cause of the mind of the Bardo being is the mind at the time of death of the previous being. It is through the last three links, the resulting causal links, that the link is made between the mind of the being at the time of death in the previous life and the mind of the bardo being.
And these three last resulting links, in other words craving, taking and existence are present within the mind of one’s previous rebirth. And this in turn is set in the mind by the three first links. And the karma which impel this is the second of these links, the compositional link, which in this case is called impelling karma. And the motivation which generates this impelling karma within the second link of compositional factors, which can be virtuous or non virtuous is a motivation of ignorance of the first link. Then the presentation is And therefore we can see that our present bodies, our present existence when it is traced backwards is rooted in ignorance.
Therefore, to eliminate the process of rebirth, to eliminate cyclic existence, we must eliminate the first link which is ignorance. Just as if we have a leak in the ceiling, it is that leak which has to be patched and no other point. There is no benefit in patching another point. So I have explained to you the process of ingress in cyclic existence. These are the stages of entry into cyclic existence.
These are the stages of taking rebirth. These are the six links from the first link of ignorance in a previous life to rebirth in the present life. And then the future path for us is the perpetuation of this process of the links. In our cases, we have a limitless accumulation of the three first links within our mind of ignorance, compositional factor, and consciousness in which karmic imprints have been implanted over countless lives. It is the death process which is critical for deciding which of these karmic imprints matures.
So our hope is to give rise to a virtuous state of mind within the death process so that a virtuous karmic potency matures and leads us to a happy rebirth. So we will stop here for today. Geshe-la has explained the first of the six links, the causal links. He will explain tomorrow the six of the resulting six resulting links starting with the link of birth and ending with the link of aging and death. And then the means to put an end to this process of ingress in cyclic existence, is exemplified by the 12 links, are none other than the two last truths, the noble truth of cessation and the path, which will be explained tomorrow.
Do you want to make the recitations? So as I was saying earlier, we will be having afternoon tea and then we will complete today’s proceedings to have some time to rest up and contemplate and then see you again here at 09:00 for another wonderful meditation on the same topic by the way. It’s a wonderful warm up with Jampa Gyaltsen for the teachings meditation on the four noble truths at 09:00. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- possessed result
- One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.