6,274 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. A teacher, responding to students’ questions in a calm abiding (shamatha) session, explains that a coarse appearance of the object must arise before training can proceed, and describes vigilance as a mental sentinel that detects agitation and sinking. He covers how to correct a mind that is too tight or too loose, and explains physical and mental pliancies as the criterion for attaining calm abiding and distinguishes it from insight. He also recommends reading Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo on calm abiding and taking notes.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: a9e24e87-dd05-4d26-979c-f85066e07304
Words: 6,270
So I can tell you, you’ll be making the news at Sera Je. This was a big topic over lunch with Geshe-la. He just looked at me. He said, they really don’t see anything. It’s not possible.
He said, why? I don’t know. Oh, I’m sorry. So the problem you see is if you don’t see anything, I mean, if not even a coarse aspect appears, you’re not on the first level of training in calm abiding. So the first step before anything else is for something to appear because otherwise, there’s nothing to work with.
Then why things don’t appear? We talked about it a lot over lunch. I think a lot has to do with the lack of training and memory of Westerners. I mean, that’s happened in my lifetime. There’s been a rejection of any type of memorization.
So Westerners have weak memories. Then, there’s a general feeling that it’s also connected with alcohol usage and the extraordinary prevalence of drugs in our societies. I have friends who taught meditation, nuns, western nuns, who taught meditation in Dharamsala in the Burmese tradition, and they had to adapt their meditation, teaching techniques because they found that the, people who came basically had overwhelmingly used drugs and they were not able to identify subtle objects, of meditation. So that’s something we have to work with. Before we start with your questions, did you think of the question I asked you yesterday?
And do you have any answers? I will then. If you didn’t if you don’t remember the question, you didn’t think about it. I think you’re having a Okay. Then the question yes.
Yeah. Yeah. That’s exactly what I was hoping you would be you would be thinking about. I mean, as Je Tsongkhapa describes the experience of calm abiding, it has the features of clarity, stability, non conceptuality, and bliss. Then if we think of because we have to account for the mystical experiences in the non Buddhist traditions.
These are very sincere, often extraordinarily holy practitioners who have powerful life transformative experiences and they call these experiences of union with God. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, we can’t just dismiss all this with the flick of the wrist. We have to try to understand what this is. And my personal suspicion is that these are experiences of calm abiding or even higher levels of concentration which are interpreted within the theological framework of non-Buddhist traditions, where there is no way to account for meditation or concentration. Then indeed, we have Meister Eckhart, has a non conceptual experience of God.
We have Saint Paul is a famous case in point on the the road to Damascus who collapses and has an experience which he says is unspeakable. The unspeakability is a very clear sign of Samādhi, you know. Then you could mention the Muslim mystic Al-Hallaj in the Sufi tradition, Persian mystic. Much more recently, we could think of Ramakrishna, the great Indian mystic of Calcutta. What makes Ramakrishna’s case very interesting for us is that Ramakrishna lived at the end of the middle end of the nineteenth century, and he his case was investigated medically.
And the doctor investigating Ramakrishna during Ramakrishna’s Samadhis found that Ramakrishna’s heart had stopped. It was impossible with a stethoscope, which is what they had at the period, to find the trace of a heartbeat. And then the description he gave is exactly the same we find in Lamrim Chenmo, a blissful, clear, non-conceptual experience, which he thought was an experience of union with Ishwara in the form of kali. So I think this enables us to have a much more sympathetic vision of the mystical experiences in other religions and to understand something which is a big problem when Westerners start speaking about Buddhism, which is an obsession with ineffability, with what is unspeakable. Every direct meditative experience is unspeakable.
There’s nothing particularly holy about it. If you have, for instance, a Samādhi, you cannot convey the experience to another verbally. But that Samādhi in and of itself is not necessarily particularly holy. If you have a samadhi on emptiness that cannot that experience cannot be conveyed to others, but that is not something just particularly holy. It is the nature of any samadhi to be nonconceptional and unspeakable.
And that’s what I wanted to to mention. Then do you have questions from your side? Yes, Well, the five objects of desire which are represented here by the fruit and I’m not sure I can identify them all but the fabric, right, And so forth. These are the objects of visual desire, beautiful forms, beautiful sounds, beautiful smells, beautiful tastes, and beautiful sensations. No.
It’s a mirror. So the first step when we train our mind in concentration is to prevent our mind from going out to these objects. Then each of us is different in this respect. Our sensory focus defend differs from person to person. Right?
Certainly, in the human species, among men at least, the visual sense is dominant. With animals such as dogs, it’s the olfactory sense which is dominant. Then generally speaking, with regard to sensory attachment, probably tactile sense. Sexuality is tactile, isn’t it? It’s a dominant attachment of human beings.
Perhaps followed by taste. Perhaps followed by taste. Then this is what we have to struggle against at the beginning. This attachment to the senses because that takes the mind out every time. So that that is what these five objects of desire represent.
Agitation is of the nature of desire as Geshe-la explained. So when we meditate, we’re trying to keep our focus on the object of meditation. And if agitation arises, typically it arises because of an object of desire. It might be the restaurant you’re planning to go to, the concert you’re planning to go to, these are different objects of desire. From a Buddhist standpoint, they’re all the same in terms of their capacity to disrupt the mind.
We have to bring the mind back. Does that answer your question? Do you have other questions? What what what the extravagance of the monks? I honestly don’t know.
Don’t I don’t know. Could be. Could be. I don’t know. I honestly don’t know.
Nothing is said. So you could. Why not? It would be a good idea, but that is more a practice connected with the seven-limb puja, with taking refuge in the merit field, and so forth. Why not?
Nothing is said in the texts. Nothing is said. These are pure concentration practices. You could, as Geshela explained, as well practice them with the horns of a goat. But there are big advantages to practicing it with a Buddha’s image.
Do have other questions? Yes. Then that’s an interference to your usage such as supportive meditation. Then there’s two ways to handle it. The first is not to use a visualized representation of the Buddha, but just to actually rely on a statue and try to see that statue.
The alternative is to use another meditation support because those conceptions are going to interfere with your attainment of śamatha. Then what historians say about historical influences, I am much more skeptical than you are for a very simple reason. They weren’t there and neither was anyone of us. And I have studied actually Indian art and the sources of the statue. And what is actually very striking is how speculative the whole thing is.
For instance, it struck me recently. There’s a lot of talk about the lateness of the tantras. You know? And this is like a dogma among western Buddhologists. Tantras appear in the eighth century.
They are a sign of the decay of the Buddhist tradition, heavy influence of local Indian religion. You’ve heard all this. You’ve probably been through this. You know? Then if you look at the data, it actually flies in the face of the data.
Artistic data, first, have tantric depictions, let’s say depictions of Hayagrīva, which are traced back to the second century. We have depictions of Yamāntaka which are traced back to the first century, both in India and in China. Then we have texts with clear attributions to scholars who lived in the second century such as Nāgārjuna with tantric allusions. The bodhichitta Vivarana is very famous in this respect. It’s a huge embarrassment for western scholars because the bodhichitta Vivarana is obviously a text of Nāgārjuna.
The style in Sanskrit is the same. The topics are the same. The totality of the Indian and Tibetan tradition consider it’s a text of Nāgārjuna. Yet, he starts by quoting the Buddha śamatha Kantra and he quotes it verbatim. And his entire release of gloss on this.
If Nāgārjuna lived in the second century according to Western scholarship and broadly speaking Tibetan scholarship, how is he quoting the Guhya Samaja, which according to Western scholars appears at the earliest in the eighth century? What’s happening? The result is that the Bodhicitta Vivarana is evacuated by Western Buddhist scholars. If you look at Potter’s Encyclopedia of Indian philosophy, it’s not included within Nāgārjuna’s works for no reason. The leading Danish scholar, Christian Lindtner, who’s not a Buddhist, he’s a Sanskrit scholar, a Tibetan scholar, has gone out and over on a limb professionally with his career, he said, this is actually work on Nāgārjuna’s.
So I put it to you that what Western Buddhist scholars think they know about the genesis of Buddhism is perhaps not as certain as we think. You know? But why he was maybe a scholar from the other way, you know, instead of going from West Indies We don’t know. We don’t know. I mean, some things are established like the toga, for instance, the influence of the Greek toga on Gandharan art and from Gandharan art into Chinese.
It’s not that established. Now the major and minor marks are actually much more ancient than Greek or Roman influences because they are the marks of a great being in India. Then whether these marks of a great being influenced the Buddhist depictions of a great being or the other way around, We don’t know. But you’ll be in trouble if you’re trying to accumulate the merit to get these marks and you don’t believe in their existence. Right?
So I’m not quite sure how you’re gonna do that because it said the Ushnishya is one of the major marks. And I should point out that Tibetan masters assess students based on the beginning of the presence of such marks. There is an art of physiognomy which is never talked about but which is used. For instance, long ears are the sign of having listened to a lot of teachings. The presence of certain hairs, of protrusions on the body, so forth.
But Westerners don’t accept this, so we just can leave let it aside. What are your other questions? Yes, please. Yes. Yes.
I’m I’m delighted you’re asking that question because that’s really what I’d like to focus upon. Because everything else is so much further down the line. If nothing appears to the mind, we are not actually on the first level of calm abiding practice. There’s actually nothing to practice, basically. Then I wanted to ask all of you a couple of questions, and you’re free to answer them or not.
The first question I wanted to ask you is do you dream? Who who doesn’t dream? Do you dream? Who doesn’t dream? You don’t dream.
You don’t remember them. You don’t. Who dreams in color? Pretty much everybody who dreams dreams in color. How vivid are your dreams?
Three d. Who has who has vivid to three d dreams? Okay. Then you have good mental imagery. So if the dreams are not vivid, it’s a sign of very deep sleep.
You know? Then it may or may may not be a sign of good mental imagery but if you have clear vivid dreams, you know that mental imagery you have. Then it’s just and this is mental imagery. These are images appearing in the dreams. Now if you think back of your dreams, that sort of image is what you want to have when you practice calm abiding.
It’s nothing different from that. Some of you seem to have struggled with the idea of a mental image. That’s it. I mean, you can see I have very vivid dreams. You can see very clearly something.
I mean I mean, sometimes you can even try reading texts right in dreams. It doesn’t work very well, but you can try. Then that is what we’re trying to develop in the context of calm abiding, but when we’re awake and not a fleeting transit one, a stable one. So all of you have that. But I think perhaps the problem is lack of familiarity with the object, number one.
And then perhaps the standards are too high as Sappho was saying. At the beginning, if you get a rough shape of Buddha Śākyamūni, that’s enough. And then you have to check the object after your session. You don’t check it during the session. No?
But during your after your five minutes are over, you check it, you fresh it up again, then you return to it. Then clearly, if you have no capacity to do this, when you practice your Tantric Sadanas, you are not practicing them. Right? I mean, there’s actually no visualization. How can you visualize yourself as a deity if you can’t even visualize Buddha Śākyamūni in space?
Right? It’s not possible. So it is something which is really important. And then once that appears you are on the first level, then you follow the traditional training. Then you really have to give up alcohol.
If this is something you want to do, alcohol and drugs, tobacco for health reasons, but alcohol and drugs have to go. You have other questions? Sure. The problem with the guru as an object for developing is that he changes. You want an object which does not change.
Otherwise, you’re gonna suddenly start to have doubts. Should I visualize my teacher as he was when I first met him or ten years after? And for us, developing Shine takes a long time. You want an object which doesn’t change. I think you’re right.
Most Western students are beginners. The karmic imprints are not strong. There’s not a lot of faith, frankly, in the Buddha. Then people don’t really see why they would visualize his image either. There’s not a lot of mental commitment.
Yasmin, what is your question? Not not really. I mean, these are just these are ways of speaking. I mean, obviously, you’re not seeing the object with your visual consciousness. So visual consciousness is used to acquire the features of the object and then it’s shut off.
The only reason we keep our eyes half open is for some type of light to keep us awake. That means it’s a big problem in the beginning of the practice. Then when we say that the object is sixty sixty to 80 centimeters in front, if you try to meditate, you will find that doesn’t mean a lot. You don’t have a sense of distance, you have a sense of size. And the size, it’s up to you to find the perfect size and that depends on the nature of your mind.
If you have a very, let’s say, if some of you have a very dull mind, you want a small object. If you have on the other hand a very agitated mind, you want a bigger object. Does that help you? Yes, please. Sure.
Sure. I mean, it’s a matter of familiarity. The thing is you must use a support, an actual picture and you really have to be able to see it with clarity. Why not? Why not?
I mean, you do want to be able to see it in three dimensions, you say, if you can, but why not? Why not? There’s a lot of neurological evidence that actually pattern and picture recognition can be performed by one single neuron, the so called grandmother neurons, when they are trained. This is established in the last ten to fifteen years. Then you need familiarity.
Perhaps the familiarity with this representation of the Buddha isn’t there. But for all the importance of his holiness to Dalai Lama, I mean, the founder of our tradition is Buddha Śākyamūni. I think we have to be familiar with Buddha Śākyamūni. I mean, Buddha Śākyamūni is a fourth universal teacher. You know?
You know? And do you have other questions? Yes, please. With pleasure. It is actually conscience.
So the Tibetan we’re we’re sort of stuck because there’s no exact English cognate. Right? The Tibetan term is means to know. Is a continued. It means knowing.
Vigilance is just knowing, the process of knowing. It’s a part of the mind which is knowing what is happening. More you’re focused on your object. Then the Tibetans often compare it to a sentinel. And I think that’s a very good way to look at it.
I don’t know. It’s probably none of you have been in the army, but you may have seen movies of about sentinels. Then a sentinel is at a low level of awareness all the time. But should something happen immediately his awareness increases and the next question is who is at the feet of the fort? Friend or foe?
Now that’s exactly what vigilance does. Vigilance is a mental sentinel, a mental guard. It is there in the background when it is not needed. It’s a fraction of the mind which is involved, like maybe 95% is concentrating on the image. At the beginning, it will be less.
At the beginning, vigilance has to be quite heavy because at the beginning the mind is all over. Let’s say maybe 30%. And that part of the mind is looking what’s happening. Then as long as the main mind is focused on the object, that part of the mind doesn’t do anything. But the moment the main mind goes off, what that part of the mind has to do is to figure what’s happening.
Is it going off through agitation or through sinking? If it’s going off through agitation, what you see is that you’re thinking of something else. That’s what agitation means. You’re thinking of whatever. That something else is always an object of desire.
So then that vigilance tells you what to do to bring the mind back. Alright. As Geshe and I explained, meditate on something depressing and that brings the mind back inwards and refocus it on the object of meditation. Then if the vigilance decides, the sentinel decides that instead of the foe having a bow, let’s say, he has a spear, it is, let us say, sinking. Having ascertained its sinking, then the first step for vigilance is to apply the antidote to sinking, just to bring the mind back up.
And you can visualize light. It’s a simple way to do it. It’s a bit powerful, but it’s simple. You can meditate on the precious human rebirth, not longer. I mean, just I have a precious human rebirth like Mila Reppa should be enough, you know.
It brings the mind up immediately. And then you reapply the mind on the object of meditation. Then at the beginning, this takes a lot of time. So what you will find is that there is a very big lag between the moment when agitation or sinking arise and the moment where vigilance becomes aware of this. A big lag in meditation means two to three seconds.
This is huge. Two to three seconds when you speak of mental process is gigantic. So by the time vigilance becomes aware of what’s happening, you are way out somewhere on your vacation in Bali, you know, and you’re no longer even meditating. As you train in this process, vigilance kicks in much faster. The lag becomes shorter, shorter, shorter.
Eventually, what happens is that vigilance senses that agitation or sinking are going to arise and preempts. When that happens on physical concentration, It senses the the fretfulness of agitation, the frost of agitation, and it senses the beginning of the torpor which indicates sinking. And at that point, you are probably at least at the fourth level, At least. Maybe fifth. And does that does that help a bit?
Okay. Then you have to look inside yourselves. Right? I mean, really, best approach to this is to read first Je Tsongkhapa carefully. It’s not a novel.
In other words, you take the section on calm abiding. It’s what? Sixty, eighty pages in English. Read it carefully with pen in hand. I don’t know who among you reads with pen in hand.
It’s a good habit. Read with pen in hand, underline, take notes. Nobody ever said it’s forbidden to take notes in dharma texts. If they’re on dharma, it’s not only a fault, it’s a quality. Rinpoche takes notes in his texts.
Then you can find what the problems are. Then you go back, study what you have underlined, think about it, apply it in your practice. When there are problems in your practice, go back to Je Tsongkhapa. That is what we the reason I’m not pushing Lamrim for sectarian reasons, but what Je Tsongkhapa did is he drew the totality of the Indian tradition. And you don’t want to have to go to Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi, the stages of the hearers, and Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, let alone Bhāvaviveka’s Heart of the Middle Way, some of which are not transiting.
You have all the key quotes in the Great Lamrim. If the greater Lamrim is too much for you, you have the middle one without the quotes. For this sort of practice, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is insufficient. It was not written for this. It was written to complement Lamrim Chenmo in those sections where Lamrim Chenmo had not entered into details.
Then on insight and on calm abiding, Je Tsongkhapa entered into tremendous detail because there were lot of problems with both of these topics in Tibet at the time. I know the passage. It’s in Tibetan. Non forgetfulness. What is that in Tibetan?
What? B R G E D G e D space m e D. Then I I look forward to seeing you at the next intensive. Why not? Why not?
No. This I’m I’m very glad you are you are that careful. That is the right approach because these terms are actually very meaningful terms. Then I have tried in my translations to stick very, very close to the Tibetan. Then I I feel that this is a good translation, the the translation of Lamrim Chenmo, but it is too casual.
What you mentioned yesterday, mindfulness for recollection. You can see in English that mindfulness on the one hand and recollection or memory on the other hand evoke very different things for you. Right? What we are when we are training in, we are not training in mindfulness. We’re not speaking of the mindfulness of the object of meditation.
We’re speaking of the memory of the object of it. You must remember it. And it’s very helpful to translate that because we see that one of the problems we have with is lack of memory. It’s a Western problem. Do have other questions?
Well, do you hear with your eyes or ears? With your ears. So anything you do to foster your hearing is what matters. I think then moving to the left or to the right to see, that’s perfectly okay. You are focusing on hearing.
Then I think it is excellent that you take notes. And I think those of you who don’t take notes are missing out big time unless you have total recall, which I think is dubious. Because if you don’t have notes, how are you going to remember in three weeks’ time what was said? Then what would have been the point of coming? Right?
You could have stayed at home and read a book. You would have derived more benefit. Those of you who go to university or even some of you teach, I believe, I think you’re quite terrified if your students don’t take notes. Right? I mean, it’s a very bad sign.
If the student is staring into space like that, then chances are that nothing is gonna be retained. So Rinpoche has heavily emphasized taking notes. Do take notes. And then there may come a point where your memory is powerful enough to retain without notes. But that takes time.
That takes time. It’s a hearing function. You’re training concentration on hearing at that point, not concentration on sight. Do you have other questions? I think what will help a lot for those of you who have a hard time visualizing is to keep in mind two experiences where I’m sure you’re able to visualize.
The first is a dream state, and the second is I think everyone in this room has been infatuated. Then I don’t know if you haven’t been infatuated if you missed out or if you’re one of the lucky few. That’s up to you to decide. That’s up to you to decide. But if you were infatuated, you agree with me that the image of whoever you were infatuated with is almost always there.
So I was telling Yishin over lunch and I think it’s true. It’s not an example which is given because our teachers are monastics. It’s not really appropriate. But as a layperson, I can give it. We are perfectly accustomed to practice both analytical and concentration meditation.
But we practice them we practice them every day, but on objects of desire. Right? You know how to do it perfectly well. You’re just doing it on the wrong things. Now it may be a person you infatuated with or the latest Holden, but in every single case, the first thing you do, maybe not a Holden, but whatever I don’t know what Australian’s like as cars.
Let’s say Mercedes maybe. Let’s say Mercedes. Right? First thing you do before you buy a Mercedes is you start convincing yourself that you can’t live without one. Right?
It’s the first step. You have to take on a lot of debt. So you read about a Mercedes. That’s what you do. Right?
You read about it, then you start thinking about it. The more you think about it, the more irresistible getting a Mercedes becomes. This is analytical meditation. Now once you have reached a certain point, you don’t you don’t read anymore about the Mercedes. It appears.
Right? It’s there. Then you engage in concentration meditation. Now in the process of generation of desire or hatred, like in my father’s culture, it was hatred which was dominant, not desire. It’s a culture of of revenge, you know.
People engage the same process. When you generate powerful desire, you analyze for exalting the qualities of the object and eventually you focus on it. Then when you’re generating tremendous hatred, you know, like, my my grandfather married at 14, my grandmother who is 11, to put an end to a blood feud which had lasted a hundred twenty years. Nobody knew why the two families were fighting, but they generated hatred in the same way. They meditated on the thoughts of the enemy again and again and again and again until the enemy became this object of utter loathsomeness, and then they focused on it single pointedly.
So if you look at how your minds work in the wrong way, you can draw on that to make them work in the right way. The process is correct. Analysis followed by focus. If the object is wrong and the object is being apprehended wrongly. It’s being apprehended as having in the case of desire qualities which actually are not there.
And in the case of hatred, thoughts which actually are not there. So if you want to practice meditation, just draw on that. If you have strong desire, I think most people in Australia have strong desire. It’s a culture of desire here. Then look at how your mind worked when you were younger.
You were on the beach, you know, whatever. You get infatuated with someone, then you build up mentally this process. Take that and extend it to an object of meditation. It works very well. I think it’s a very good idea.
You have very good lives of the Buddha. How accurate they are is another question. But Thich Nhat Hanh, I’m told which is very nice. I have not read it, but I’m told it’s very nice. There is a French scholar.
I don’t know if it’s translated in English. It’s called following in the steps of the Buddha. Very, very nice. Have you heard of it? Very nice.
Relying on history. That’s very good. That is very good. Get the references from Anita. That’s very good.
And if you have the opportunity to go on a pilgrimage to Bodhgaya and to Bihar, I think I mean, I I’m in an embarrassing situation. I’ve never had the time to go with the studies and all that, but I think you would benefit greatly to see where the Buddha lived, what the Buddha did. And then obviously if you have time to read a bit the the Pali Canon. Right? The Pali Canon are certainly the historical texts we have.
We know that any debate attributed to the Buddha. You sense a Buddha’s personality through these texts. Then it’s a very endearing personality. And then when you look at the statue of Buddha Śākyamūni, it’s no longer something cold and distant. When you visualize the Buddha, you have a particular feeling.
No. No. But it helps a lot to have it because you you want to do the practice. In this practice, no emotions should arise. Well, I mean, it’s not it’s not wrong, but it it interferes with the concentration.
In the context of, for instance, offering the seven nymph puja, then those emotions are very helpful. But when you are training in concentration, even what are basically positive emotions which arise are interference. They are distraction. Your goal is concentration. Like, when you’re concentrating on the image of the Buddha, if you start thinking about bodhichitta, it is an interference.
I mean, this is not your focus. Do you have other questions? There’s a big well, we would say distraction because agitation is considered a part of desire. Desire is an affliction. These emotions are not afflictions.
Afflictions. I mean, it’s actually veneration for the Buddha. But they interfere with the process of concentration. Turning it down and, you know, just focusing on the image. Sham Shamatha is very boring.
Training in Shamatha is is quite dull. It’s not something exciting. You’re focusing on the image and you’re just bringing your mind back again and again and again until the flow is established. And then you use it for something else. Breathe in the back.
Calm the mind. Calm the mind. The mind is too high. You have two concepts which are introduced in the concept in the context of calm abiding. Your mind which is too high and too low.
Mind is too high. It’s too tight. Like, if you play a musical instrument, let’s say, cello or guitar, the string is too tight, it won’t sound right. You loosen the string. That’s agitation.
You bring your mind down. String is too loose, it won’t sound right. You tighten the string. Right? So if there’s a lot of emotion, the mind’s too tight.
You know? Bring it down. The goal is to be on the image. If on the other hand, there’s a lot of sinking like this, the image will be very stable, you’ll see. Not terribly clear, but very stable.
And you bring the mind up. Now someone you ask actually regarding clarity, you said it’s an individual concept. How do we define clearly clarity? Fundamentally, everything here is individual because it depends of the tenor of our minds. Each one of us is different in terms of temperament.
What is clear for one will not be clear for the other. Yes, please. It’s not mentioned in the six collections. Then, obviously, you would want to do it. I certainly would want to do it.
However, the main preliminary for calm abiding is ethics. That is the most important preliminary and the main outer factor in the West where we have safe conditions is the absence of noise. And by absence of noise, we don’t mean a relative absence of noise. The moment you really start practicing concentration, a finger snap is enough to disrupt it. Then you need a very quiet environment.
Now that we have ear plugs and ear muffs, I think they are ideal for training in concentration. You should. Yes. But when we start, that’s not the case. Normally, you have good concentration, then you don’t notice noise at all, but the problem is getting to that point.
Depends how good your vigilance is. If you have really, really good vigilance, which is always shining the spotlight on the mind meditating, you will see how the slightest point the mind goes out. Until you reach a level of who actually had a pistol blank fired by his ear and there was no neurological response to the sound, which is considered impossible in neurology. To reach of that level, you need to eliminate noise in the back. So he obviously has that level.
Right? There’s no debate. He was tested. He was anonymous. And, obviously, somebody leaked the name.
You know? And that’s a meditator. And that’s a meditator. But we have to get there. Right?
Then you have other questions. Yes. Pliancies. Yes. What would you like to know?
Geshe-la, let me talk about it this afternoon. Basically, pliancies mean that in the case of bodily pliancy, the body is serviceable. The body can do what you want it to do. It doesn’t mean you’re flexible. Flexible.
Right? And in the case of mental pliancy that the mind is servicing, they are accompanied by a very, very strong sensation of bliss, which fades over time as one becomes accustomed to the appliances. Then in Tibet, there was a very big problem which came from the confusion of the bliss generated by the pliancies with the bliss of the of tantric practice. Then they are unrelated, completely unrelated even though both arise from certain activities involving the winds. The pliences generated by calm, the pliancies generated by meditation are the criterion for having attained calm abiding.
So once physical and mental pliences which are a result of concentration have arisen, you have attained calm abiding. Until then, you are still on the ninth level, you have not attained calm abiding. That blissful sensation has some particular physical signs which preceded, specifically a sensation of great heaviness on the top of the skull inside the brain, a sensation of heaviness in the brain actually. And this sensation of heaviness is a portent of the arising of physical pliancy, a sign. It’s not something which is unpleasant, but it’s a sign of particular activities of the winds.
Then physical pliancy induces mental pliancy, which is a result of the serviceability of the winds. Then where it is important to understand the pliancies is that it is thanks to them that we can posit a difference between calm abiding and insight. Calm abiding is a concentration meditation which is qualified by appliances which have arisen from concentration. Insight is an analytical meditation which is qualified by appliances which have arisen from analysis. Same sensation.
Same sensation. Although I have never heard of the presence of the signs of brain heaviness in the brain before the insight pliancy. This is very important distinction because the doubt which arises is, let us assume that you take emptiness as the object on which you develop calm abiding. When you attain calm abiding based on emptiness with the pliancies, physical and mental pliancies, have you at the same time attained insight? The answer is no.
You have a mind which is single pointedly focused on emptiness just as it could be single pointedly focused on anything else. A statue of the Buddha, a chair, the horns, of a cow, let us say. The pliancies have arisen, you have a fully qualified calm abiding on emptiness. You don’t have insight. How do you generate insight?
Within that calm abiding, your mind engages in analysis. And that analysis, that small stream of analysis, which is going on, eventually gives rise to physical and mental and the bliss connected with them. When that arises, you have perfected insight. So the pliancies are very important criteria. It’s a very good question because there are a lot of doubts in Tibet about this.
Attaining the ninth level does not mean you’ve attained calm abiding. You must have the pliancies on top of that and meditating using calm abiding on emptiness is not vipaśyanā on emptiness. If analysis is not involved, you are not engaged in the practice of vipaśyanā and if pliancy which has arisen from analysis has not appeared, then you have not attained vipaśyanā. And then I think we do have to stop. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- merit field tshogzhing (Tib)
- Or field of accumulation. The visualized or actual holy beings in relation to whom one accumulates merit by going for refuge, making offerings and so forth, and to whom one prays or makes requests for special purposes. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.