7,033 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. The teacher introduces the Four Noble Truths, the first teaching of the Buddha, explaining how to listen with a good motivation and a sharp mind. He then presents the truths in the order of practice using the analogy of disease, diagnosis, cause, cure and medicine, and describes the three sufferings and the importance of future lives.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: dfe71c9a-0182-4689-a099-eb1ca3633707
Words: 7,029
So Geshela, I would first and foremost like to express his personal gratitude to the center for creating the opportunity for such teachings on the Four Noble Truths. This is an extraordinary opportunity. The very heart of Buddhist practice, the very essence of Buddhist practice is the Four Noble Truths. Therefore, this is most important. Normally, when one presents the Four Noble Truths, one presents them in terms of four subdivisions.
And these include the way to listen to the teachings, the motivation for listening to the teachings, what fully characterized teachings are, and finally, an actual presentation of the Four Noble Truths. So regarding the first, one should listen to teachings with a happy mean and a delighted mind, taking every single word of the teachings to heart. Then Geshela feels that you have excellent attitude towards the teachings since he notices that your faces are happy, which should reflect a happy mind. But he would also ask to like to ask you to all take notes as quite a few of you do already. As Geshela mentioned previously, he traveled to Tibet last year, and taught extensively throughout Eastern Tibet in Kham.
And, the audience is different from here since many of the Tibetans who are there do not fully understand what is taught nor do they analyze what is taught. On the other hand, you are yourself different from this because you attend the teachings out of a profound wish to receive the teachings and Geshela is delighted by this. And therefore, even though normally one explains the need for enthusiasm in attending the teachings, Geshela feels it is unnecessary here and he will not elaborate. Then secondly, the characteristics of the trainee receiving the teachings. As Āryadeva says, one who attends teachings must be of sharp faculties with a good mind and focused on the speech of the teachings.
The first faculty or the first feature refers to the fact that whoever attends the teachings must not be under the influence of desire or anger and must pacify his or her mind. Otherwise, if the mind is under the influence of desire or of anger, then it does not remain focused on the teachings and the teachings do not lead to any results. An alternative interpretation of this first characteristic is that one does not favor some viewpoints over other viewpoints in terms of one’s personal bias or in terms of one’s personal prejudices. However, it is perfectly appropriate to examine using analysis what is taught to see whether what is taught corresponds with reality or not, is or is not. For instance, many of the non Buddhist Indian practitioners, the tirthikas, assert the existence of an ātman or a self.
Then if from the very inception the Buddha had taught them selflessness, this could have caused tremendous difficulties for them. And therefore, please examine what Geshela says from the beginning using reasoning and analysis to see whether it fits or not. There is no certainty that everything which Geshela teaches is correct. And actually, it is a wrong view or a mistaken understanding to assume that everything which is taught is correct, ipso facto. And therefore, when Geshela has explained the teachings with sharp faculties, the first criteria, please examine these teachings.
Buddha Śākyamūni said to his disciples, what I have teach you, you must examine through reasoning. And if it is appropriate and fits, then accept it. If it is not appropriate and does not fit, then reject it. It is incorrect to accept my teachings because you see me as a teacher. This is what is meant by the first criterion mentioned by Āryadeva, one of sharp faculties.
Then the second criterion, is intelligence or being endowed with wisdom, refers to the capacity to distinguish between faults and qualities between what is to be practiced and to be abandoned. Geshela trusts that all of you have such a wisdom which can discriminate between what is to be practiced and to be abandoned. I have some experience of the uncommon systems of teachings in the West. Then perhaps I should speak from experience here. Present.
I have many students at Sera Je, but from within them I have had three Western students. The first was Ilya. However, even though all of the students receive the same teachings, the way they investigate the teachings is different. Then to take the example of Ilya’s class, Ilya’s Ilya was the best in his class in investigating the teachings. And he has practiced extraordinarily well basing his practice on his own analysis of the teachings.
Even though he was extremely wealthy and who could have gone anywhere in the world, nonetheless, he chose to study the dharma and did so intensely. Well, before I came to the center, Khensur Rinpoche said to me, Ilya was extraordinarily kind towards the center and has been of tremendous benefit to the center as a translator and in all capacities. Then Rinpoche said to Geshela, Ilya is a true yogi of yogis. Then Geshela had a second Western student, Jampa Sherab, a monk from New Zealand. Even though he is in a very large class of approximately 180, he is the first among the first in that class.
And he has done extraordinarily well in his Buddhist studies. And we have finally one new arrival, Jampa Kedrup, a young Australian from this center. He is studying at present Lorig and Tarig, Buddhist psychology and Buddhist logic, and is doing exceptionally well and is moving towards becoming the first in the class. This western style of study, Geshe has seen, involves analyzing each word, word by word, and seeing what its meaning is and what its benefit is. So, Geshela, trust that you yourselves will study intensively in the same way.
The third feature mentioned by Āryadeva is that one should strive for the teachings. Geshela is convinced that you have striving for the teachings. And he is sure of this because even though this is a vacation, it is a weekend in the West and you could very well go and have fun outside, go for walks or whatever. You have nonetheless put the effort to come to the center for these teachings. And frankly, such effort put at the teachings is the true vacation.
In dependence on such effort put into teachings, for long the mind will be happy. I have seen that the pleasure or the happiness of staying at home or going to the restaurant is a pleasure of short duration and power. We can see that when one stays alone because numerous conceptions, numerous fancies arise in the mind, suffering arises in dependence on these fancies. On the other hand, when one goes for walks, if one sees a pleasant object, then desire arises within the mind. Whereas when one sees unpleasant or hurtful objects, anger arises in the mind, therefore the afflictions arise.
Therefore, there is no point during one’s breaks, one’s time off either to stay at home or to go for walks outside. However, if during these teachings we understand correctly the mode of ingress or entry into cyclic existence and the mode of egress or exit from cyclic existence and find the means for ourselves to exit cyclic existence, we will reap tremendous benefit. I don’t consider a vacation in which one is relaxed as a good vacation. Then I will tell you a small story His Holiness the Dalai Lama recounted. Once upon a time, an older monk had two disciples, and they never took a day off and kept working and studying.
Then they said to the older monk because they were rather tired of the endless work they had to do, when can we hope for a vacation again? And older monks said to them, right now it’s not possible. Then one day they were walking outside and they saw a dead man’s body being carried along the street. And they asked the older monk, what precisely is that, And the older monks said to them, he’s going on a vacation. A couple of friends and myself went to see Kensurinpoche for oral instructions before going on a Vajrayoginī retreat.
Then Rinpoche looked at them fiercely and said, you must meditate. You must meditate intensively. Are you able to meditate? Then jokingly, I said to Gin, well, Gin, apart from Tuesdays, which are the day off at the monastery, I have no opportunity, so I do it on Tuesdays. Khensur Rinpoche answered him directly, there is no such Buddhist practice only engaged in on Tuesdays.
And therefore, if one practices whenever one has a free moment, some time off, there is tremendous benefit. And Geshela can see through your coming here today, your tremendous striving. These are the characteristics of one who should listen to the teachings. If one listens to the teachings with these three characteristics, there will definitely be benefit for this life and for future lives. Then the third of the four features is motivation.
There are three types of motivation, the superior, the middling and the least. The least of the motivations which is indispensable is refuge. In dependence on the motivation of refuge, the virtue we accumulate will later on mature as we birth as a god or a human. The middling motivation is renunciation or definite emergence. Whatever we do which is held or which is engaged in with this motivation leads as a result to the attainment later on of liberation.
The greatest motivation is the motivation of compassion or bodhichitta. Whatever is engaged in independence on such a motivation leads ultimately to the attainment of full enlightenment. It is said that a bodhisattva in one day of meditation on the view of emptiness achieves more than Shravakas or hearers or Pratyekabuddhas or solitary realizers in eons of meditation. The reason for this is that a bodhisattva’s meditation on emptiness is motivated by bodhichitta, whereas the motivation of a Śrāvaka or a Pratyekabuddha meditating on emptiness is not bodhichitta. And therefore, even if we recite one single Om Mani Padme Hung with the motivation of compassion or bodhichitta, that will lead to the attainment of full enlightenment.
Whatever dharma we engage in, whether it turns out to be pure or impure dharma depends on the motivation. Likewise, all virtue, bodily virtue or physical virtue we engage in turns into virtue independence on the motivation. And therefore, for these teachings today on the Four Noble Truths, let us make sure that our motivation is imbued with bodhichitta and compassion. And for this to happen, we must generate within our own mental continuum both bodhichitta and compassion. It’s not appropriate to put bodhichitta and compassion far away and then to say, well, I’m meditating on bodhichitta and compassion.
There is no other means of meditation on great compassion, bodhichitta or śamatha, calm abiding, than to generate them within our own minds. How should we proceed? We should think that all beings without exception wish to abandon suffering and that we should therefore strive to help them to abandon suffering. And then let alone giving rise to a wish to free all sentient beings from suffering. As this wish becomes ever more powerful, eventually the determination, I shall free all sentient beings from suffering arises.
And then as this intensifies, it turns into a determination which pledges, I alone will free all sentient beings from suffering. At this point, the realization dawns upon ourselves, I don’t have this power at present. And then one wonders who has this capacity, one who has abandoned all faults and who has realized all qualities, in other words, the Buddha. And at this point thinking, may all sentient beings be freed from suffering when the determination I shall do so arises and one thinks I myself will attain the state of full enlightenment to do so, one takes the out the oath for this. When that oath I shall attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings is fully taken, one speaks of the attainment of bodhichitta.
Then after this, uncontrived spontaneous bodhichitta arises in the mind. Such a mind arises day and night spontaneously within the mind stream without outputting any effort to generate it. It arises by its own force. At this point, when such a mind of bodhichitta arises naturally and spontaneously, we have entered the Mahāyāna, the great vehicle. And therefore at present, let us let us generate for one minute the motivation of bodhichitta with which we will, engage in these teachings on the four noble truths to attain full enlightenment.
As Buddha Śākyamūni said in a famous stanza, Engage not in even the slightest sin. Practice virtue fully. Tame your mind. These are the teachings of the Buddha. Specifically, we are taught to engage in the practices of three trainings.
Likewise, the Buddha said, I do not dispel the sufferings of beings with my hand nor do I wash sins with water, nor do I give transmissions through blessings. It is through teaching suchness that I benefit beings. The Buddha, therefore, does not dispel the sufferings of beings with his hand. Buddha attained full enlightenment for the sake of dispelling the suffering of all beings. However, even though this is the case, the Buddha has no other means to dispel the sufferings of beings than to teach them the dharma.
If it was possible to dispel the sufferings of beings with his hand or to cleanse the sufferings of beings with water as one cleanses a filthy vessel with water, certainly the Buddha would have done so. And therefore, the only way for the Buddha to dispel the suffering is to teach them to abandon sin and to engage into virtue and thereby to lead them to reaping a good crop. And fundamental to these teachings of abandoning sin and engaging virtue are the presentation of the four noble truths by the Buddha. The Buddha was staying in Ganden Chökhör, one of the sub realms of Tuśita, teaching sentient beings. And it is there that he took the oath or the pledge to benefit the sentient beings of this world of ours.
And it is there that he formed the project to manifest in our world. However, the gods of Tuśita asked the Buddha not to manifest in our world, saying there will be no benefit in your manifesting in this world since the beings in this world are of a coarse and rough disposition and are under the sway of the 18 tirthika teachers, the 18 non Buddhist teachers. However, Buddha answered to this, it is precisely for those rough and uncouth beings of this world under the sway of the 18 tirthika teachers that I will go. He said, since this is my goal, I definitely will go. However, you will not be bereft of a teacher in Tuśita.
My substitute or my regent, Ārya Maitreya, will after my departure manifest in Tuśita wearing a tiara or a crown and will teach. And therefore, the Buddha descended from Tuśita to manifest in this world, and his first deed was to be conceived within the womb of his mother, Queen Maya. And after being born immaculately from the right side of his mother, Queen Maya, Buddha manifested numerous deeds, including the deeds of youth such as consorting with his wives and so forth. He was called Shendag Drolo because of his uncommon skill at worldly sports. However, on one of his excursions out of the palace, he came in contact for the first time with the suffering of death.
On another excursion through another gate, he saw the suffering of sickness in other beings. And exiting his palace through each of the four gates, he in turn saw over time the four sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death. And finally, leaving the palace again, he saw a Geelong, a Bikshu, wearing the yellow robes. And upon inquiring who this Bikshu was, who such a being was, was told he was a disciple of one of the Buddhas. And then thinking of the great amount of merit accrued by one who has gone forth, who has become ordained, he developed a profound wish to become ordained.
However, the king and the queen, king Shuddhodana, his father, and queen Maya were opposed to his project of being ordained and forbid him from doing it, locking off the gates of the palace. Their reasoning was that if their son, which means the fully accomplished youth became ordained it would sever the royal lineage and put an end to the dynasty. However, from the standpoint of a fully accomplished youth, Shendag Drolo, he had no desire whatsoever for his status as a prince and saw it merely as spittle in the dust out of his profound renunciation. However, because of the efforts made by his parents, it was very difficult for Shendag Drolo to become ordained. Then with the help of Indra and of Brahma, all of his entourage and the guards which were guarding him fell asleep.
And thanks to this, the young Siddhartha was able to escape and to become ordained. And then after becoming ordained, Siddhartha for six years engaged in tremendous asceticism. And after those six years manifested the state of full enlightenment. After attaining full enlightenment for one full week, the Buddha gave no teachings whatsoever. Even though he had at the period his five followers, the nadag, nonetheless, because they had lacked faith in him at the beginning, they had become somewhat distant from each other.
He had the lack of faith in him was a lack of faith before he attained full enlightenment. However, after attaining full enlightenment, when he met again with the five followers, they became close once again. And when the five followers approached the Buddha who had attained enlightenment, even though from their side, they wanted to show a certain distance or even contempt for him, they were unable to do so and spontaneously manifested veneration. And this faith which arose spontaneously in them upon seeing Buddha Śākyamūni turned into veneration and they beseeched teachings. The first teaching the Buddha gave was a teaching on the four noble truths.
The very first teaching the Buddha gave in our world was a teaching on the four noble truths. And therefore, the essence of the Buddhist teachings, the most fundamental practice are the four noble truths. The main audience for this first teaching on the four noble truths was the Circle of the Five Followers. During these two days, we will cover the first teaching of the Buddha, the teaching on the four noble truths. There are two stages in the presentation of the four noble truths.
These two stages in the presentation of these two manners of presenting the Four Noble Truths are in terms of the cause and effect relationship and in terms of how to practice. If one presents the Four Noble Truths in terms of causality or cause and effect, there are two subdivisions. The first subdivision is the subdivision of the second noble truth, the noble truth of origination at the level of the cause being the cause of the first noble truth and noble truth of suffering. And the second subdivision presents the noble truth of the path at the level of the cause being the cause of the noble truth of cessation at the level of the effect. Through understanding the first subdivision and how the noble truth of origin gives rise to the noble truth of suffering, we understand the mode of ingress of all sentient beings into cyclic existence.
Through the second subdivision and understanding how the noble truth of the path, the fourth noble truth, through its force gives rise to the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. We understand the means for all sentient beings to turn away and to relinquish cyclic existence. And therefore, the Four Noble Truths present both the means by which sentient beings enter cyclic existence and dwell in it and the means for sentient beings to find escape or liberation from cyclic existence. And therefore, if the Four Noble Truths are presented in terms of cause and effect or causality, then first one presents the Second Noble Truth, Noble Truth of Origin, then the First Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of Suffering, then the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path, then the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. On the other hand, if the four noble truths are presented in terms of practice, the second subdivision, Then the first one presents the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering.
Then the second noble truth of the origin of suffering. Then the third noble truth of cessation. And then the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path. And therefore, from the standpoint of causality, the truth of origin comes first and the truth of suffering comes second, whereas from the standpoint of practice, the truth of suffering comes first and the truth of origin comes second. Likewise, for the two last truths from the standpoint of causality, the truth of the path comes first and the truth of cessation comes second.
Whereas from the standpoint of practice, the truth of cessation comes first and the truth of the path comes second. The reason for which the noble truth of origin is presented first in the noble truth of suffering second within the context of a causal presentation is because within a causal presentation, the noble truth of origin is the cause of the noble truth of suffering. The reason for which within a causal presentation, the noble truth of the path is presented third and the noble truth of cessation fourth, is because it is in dependence on the noble truth of the path which is the application of the antidotes to the afflictions that the noble truth of the cessation which is the elimination of the afflictions occurs. And therefore, since the noble truth of the path entailing the application of the antidotes to the afflictions gives rise to the noble truth of cessation. It is this sequence which is adopted for a causal presentation.
However, here we will mainly explain the four noble truths in terms of their sequence for practice. And in this sequence for practice, the first noble truth to be explained is a noble truth of suffering. After understanding the noble truth of suffering, one investigates whether or not suffering has a cause and if it has a cause, whether this cause is permanent or not. This leads to an understanding of the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Then investigating carefully whether the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering can actually be eliminated or not.
When one generates the conviction that the noble truth of the origin of suffering can be eliminated, one starts to understand the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. And then investigating what the means are for abandoning the two first noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering, one finds that the means to do so is the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path. So if we were to give an example for the two first truths, the example for the noble truth of suffering would be disease and the example for the noble truth of the origin of suffering would be the exterior conditions giving rise to disease. The example for the third noble truth of cessation will be the pacification of the disease or healing from the disease. And the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path, is the medicine to be taken.
And we will now present how one engages in the Four Noble Truths. So let us take one sick person, a patient who is seriously ill. What is necessary for this patient to be healed? Geshela would like to ask you, what does a sick person need to be healed? Initially, to be healed from a disease, you actually have to have a diagnostic of your disease.
Is it necessary If you are experiencing the results of a disease, the first step to be healed is to ascertain or to have a diagnostic of what the disease is. And in our cases, we have been experiencing suffering for beginningless lives. So the very first step is to ascertain what precisely we are suffering from. Then once we have done this, what is important in the second place is to understand or ascertain what the causes and the conditions for this disease or this suffering are. Then thirdly, we have to investigate whether our disease is curable or incurable.
And therefore at the leg, returning back a bit at the level of the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering, taking our metaphor of the disease. We are investigating what exterior causes and conditions the disease arises from. Likewise, one must investigate what causes and conditions suffering arises from. And therefore, the, third noble truth, in this metaphor is the investigation of whether or not the disease we are suffering one from is curable or not. Likewise, one must investigate whether the cause of suffering which is the noble truth of origin, which is twofold comprising karma and afflictions can be eliminated or not.
If we ascertain that it can be eliminated, then we become convinced of the existence of the Noble Truth of cessation, the third Noble Truth. And therefore, pursuing with our metaphor of the disease, understanding the nature of the disease we suffer from and understanding the causes of this disease and having ascertained that this disease can be healed, we now turn to try to find a treatment for the disease. That means for pacifying or healing the disease is the Fourth Noble Truth. And therefore, as was said from the very beginning, to rely on medicine is inappropriate. The viewpoint given is not mistaken.
It’s just a very rapid one. So Gesheera was trying to explain how to do things slowly and carefully. Then Heather’s approach was much more lightning fast. However, whether one goes quickly or slowly, the point of arrival is the same. There is no contradiction between these two explanations.
And therefore, understanding that the path for the pacification of the noble truth of the origin, which is karma and affliction exists. This is a presentation of the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path. In brief, the first noble truth of suffering is similar to a disease. The noble truth of the origin, which is the cause of suffering, is similar to the causes giving rise to a disease. The Noble Truth of Cessation is similar to healing from the disease.
And the Noble Truth of the Path is similar to the medication which will heal one from the disease. So there is no doubt that if we rely correctly on the path within the noble truth of the path, we will be able to eliminate all suffering. In the same way as if we treat a disease with the appropriate medicine, we are sure to heal it. So this is the example one should rely upon. And since in our example of the disease one must have a sound diagnostic of the disease, likewise in the presentation of the four noble truths, one must identify clearly the first noble truth of suffering.
Then even though Geshela will be explaining the noble truth of suffering, he would like you to give rise to happiness within your minds while he speaks of suffering. Otherwise, it’s gonna be very uncomfortable for all of us. Otherwise, if Geshela talks about suffering and you are in great mental suffering today, then this is a waste of a vacation, isn’t it? And there is reason for such a feeling of happiness to arise because when one explains clearly the nature of suffering, one is opening the gateway to the elimination of suffering. We have been accustomed to suffering since beginningless time, and therefore the slightest pretext, the slightest condition is sufficient to give rise at once to suffering.
So one must understand clearly what suffering is to be able to discard it. We all know that suffering arises easily within our minds when we are at rest. And for that matter, suffering arises just as easily when we are going on a walk. We have to put no effort whatsoever for suffering to arise. And we can see that suffering arises almost spontaneously from the slightest pretext, the slightest cause without having to put any effort into causing it to arise.
Exactly the opposite is true of happiness. We can see, for instance, that when we gather at the center for teachings, we make offerings and so forth. We are doing this actually hoping to be happy. But this very easily gives rise to suffering. We can see, for instance, that to remain in this world, we need the basic necessities of food and clothing.
And we undergo tremendous hardship for this, trying to get food and clothing, earning money, worrying about whether we will get it or not, whether we will get good food and good clothing. Then when we have a bit of wealth being worried that it will be stolen from us. In other words, it gives rise to a tremendous amount of mental suffering. And this mind which worries about our food, our victuals, our necessities going to waste or being stolen is always present, isn’t it? And therefore, although we are trying to have a sensation or an experience of happiness through accumulating money for food and for clothing, this is actually the cause of great suffering, isn’t it?
Then even if through the great effort we all make to earn a lot of money to be happy, we do finally earn a lot of money and become wealthy, you yourselves can reflect on how much happiness that money has given you. However much money you may have, you can only eat the same amount of rice and vegetables as anyone else, can’t you? Then one monk with a sharp tongue once said, really, it’s not surprising we don’t bother to have any money because poor as we are, we eat rice and vegetables. Then the president of The United States, however wealthy he may be, can’t eat more rice and vegetables than we can. And then when one has accumulated a lot of money, great suffering arises from the fancies we entertain such as going on distant trips and so forth.
And finally, at the time of death, tremendous suffering arises because the person who has worked so hard to accumulate wealth is unable to let his or her money go. So even though we may think that happiness arises from being very wealthy and having a lot of money, it is actually very difficult to be happy with money. A westerner, Geshela is not quite sure of his nationality, requested an audience with His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. And this was an immensely wealthy man, who asked His Holiness, I am hugely wealthy. I am of excellent birth.
Nothing is wrong with me, and yet I am always in a state of inner unhappiness and unease. Why is this the case? Then His Holiness gave him some very specific advice regarding Buddhadharma. And then the next time he met with His Holiness, he said to His Holiness that this advice had been extraordinarily beneficial and that his mind had become calm, happy and peaceful. So don’t think that if you train in renunciation from cyclic existence, you will end up, worthless.
You still have to engage in, some activity to be able to afford your food, your house, your rent and so forth. However, it is very important whenever you have free time to put effort in meditating on Buddhadharma. And therefore, I shall start speaking about suffering. Generally speaking, there’s two types of sufferings, physical and mental suffering. Likewise, there are the opposites of these, which are physical and mental happiness.
So our goal is to counter physical and mental suffering and to give rise to physical and mental happiness. When we realize physical happiness, automatically physical suffering will disappear. When we realize mental happiness, automatically mental suffering will disappear. Physical and mental happiness on the one side and physical and mental suffering on the other side have the same relationship as hot and cold water. Where hot water is present, cold water cannot be present.
Where cold water is present, hot water cannot be present. There is no great difficulty in eliminating physical suffering since it can be done through food, through wealth, through medicine and so forth. For that matter, even when physical suffering is present, is possible to dispel it through one’s way of thinking. In the same way as it’s not very difficult to eliminate physical suffering, there’s no great mystery in how to attain physical happiness. It remains, however, unstable.
Therefore, I won’t say anything to you today about eliminating physical suffering and gaining physical happiness. What is really important is eliminating mental suffering and gaining mental happiness. It’s very difficult for physical means such as taking medicine, receiving shots or being operated to have any impact on mental happiness. For instance, one sees cases of people undergoing mental suffering who rely on medicine, tranquilizers or drugs to control their mental suffering. But this cannot eliminate the mental suffering durably.
It remains a very short term and contingent means to address the problem. Mental suffering arises from our way of thinking. Therefore, the foremost way to eliminate mental suffering is to change our way of thinking. So we will investigate what are the means to eliminate mental suffering and what are the means to give rise to mental happiness. Generally speaking, there are three types of suffering.
The first is the suffering of suffering. These are, for instance, the suffering of experiencing cold or heat or for that matter disease. Since most of the suffering of suffering is related to physical suffering, it is not difficult to eliminate. For instance, if we have a headache or a stomachache, it’s just a matter of taking the right medicine. Such a suffering is very small.
It’s small. However, it is important for us to reflect on the second suffering, the suffering of change. What is a suffering of suffering? It is all the contaminated happiness which arises, for instance, through eating food or through drinking. For instance, when we first buy a new house, we have a great feeling of happiness upon buying the new house.
But this feeling of happiness is not happiness. In its very nature, it’s suffering. However, after having bought our new house when we move in, over time, the new house, which was clean, spick and span, starts to become dirty. There are repairs which have to be done. It progressively starts to change into decay and our attitude towards it shifts.
At first, when we buy the house, the bigger it is, the happier we are. Then the first day we have to clean it, that feeling changes rather abruptly. And then the bigger it is, the more unhappy we are. Frankly, both for living in and for buying, Geshela thinks a smaller house is better. The It is exactly the opposite we see.
With time, the true nature of suffering becomes obvious. If they were true suffering, then these causes which give rise to happiness, then these causes which give rise to true happiness should lead to an ever greater increase in happiness. We see it as exactly the opposite. Therefore, let alone not being happiness, they are suffering. For this reason, they are called the suffering of change.
The third subdivision of suffering is known as all pervasive suffering. This refers to our body, our feelings, or our consciousness. All of these, our body, our feelings, our consciousness have arisen from their causes, which are contaminated karma and afflictions. Therefore, this body has arisen independence on causes and conditions which are contaminated, karma and afflictions. In addition, our body’s substantial cause is none other than the semen of the father and the egg of the mother.
So independence on these impure or unclean causes, such a body is the basis in turn for the arising of numerous afflictions such as desire and anger. And therefore, for so long as we have not abandoned these impure aggregates, which are the result of the karma and affliction within our mind stream, we have no hope to attain lasting happiness. And therefore, these very aggregates comprised within our continuum, these five aggregates are of the nature of suffering. This is known as all pervasive suffering. These are the three sufferings.
There are two approaches to eliminating suffering. Eliminating suffering within this life and being happy within this life or eliminating suffering within future lives and being happy within future lives. Not a lot of thought should be dedicated to being happy within this life. Much thought should be dedicated to being happy from the next life onwards. Trying to be happy in this life and to eliminate suffering in this life is something animals engage in.
We can think we are superior to animals. We are human beings, the supreme rebirth from within the six rebirths. We are human beings, and our rebirth, the human rebirth is considered the best among the six possible rebirths because of our natural propensity for wisdom, for analytical capacities. And therefore, it is perfectly okay not to put a lot of thought into this life’s happiness. And it’s perfectly okay for animals to be focused on this life.
This life. And the reason we should focus on future lives and not this life is simply because of the extraordinary duration of future lives. And then thinking on the durable happiness of future lives, in turn we are able to engage in virtuous practices of dharma. And then through engaging in virtuous behavior in this life, focused on future lives, as a side effect of this virtuous behavior, we will eliminate fear and worry in this life thinking because of this virtuous behavior, I will gain happy rebirths in the future and we will be happy in this life too. And therefore, through practicing in this way focusing on future lives, in the next life we will get a human rebirth which is even better than this one.
So there is such a thing as a materialist viewpoint. This is not the one espoused here. The Indian materialists believed that there was no such thing as past and future lives or karma and causality. The reason they advanced was that they couldn’t see it. And they said if there was such a thing as past and future lives, then when someone died, he would be born again.
And the example they gave for this was that if one if it was true that they were past and future lives, then if one sowed a seed of barley, one would get seeds of barley in return and not sprouts. And if one sowed seeds of wheat, one will get seeds of wheat but not sprouts of wheat. So in your opinion, this example of the Indian materialist, is it a good one? Is it convincing? No.
However, it is quite true that if one does sow seeds of barley, one will get sprouts of barley. And therefore, it is quite true that if there is such a thing as past and future lives, then if one dies as a human being, one is necessarily reborn as another being. Likewise, when one sows one seed of barley, down the line it is not one seed of barley one reaps, but numerous seeds of barley. And we can see for ourselves that when we sow one seed of barley, the seeds of barley which we eventually reap from the new crop which has arisen are not perfectly identical in shape or in color with the initially sowed seed of barley. Likewise, the materialist critique of the theory of rebirth that if a human being was reborn, he would have to be perfectly identical in number and in qualities with the previous rebirth of force.
And we can clearly see that for instance, things which are produced from a factory are never perfectly identical. So from my personal viewpoint, this example of the materialist is not good at all. And the further example of the materialists, which is that even without having sowed a seed of barley, you would still reap a seed of barley is also incorrect. What one can say is that after one death as a sentient being, another rebirth as a sentient being does occur. And therefore within the two viewpoints that there are past and future lives and that there are not past and future lives, the first viewpoint has both more reasons in its favor and more empirical data.
And the second viewpoint has unconvincing reasons in its favor such as the fact I do not see past and future lives. Then to think that if there were no past and future lives, our lives would be easier is mistaken since if there were no past and future lives, then we would experience tremendous suffering at the time of death. And if therefore generating conviction in the existence of past and future lives, we at present prepare for our own death, Then at the time of our own death, our death will be peaceful, and we will get a human rebirth even better than the present one. And therefore in this life, it is important to think about death and impermanence, to think about abandoning the non virtues and practicing the virtues. Then it is the end of the morning session.
Ilya will take questions this afternoon from 01:30 onwards.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
- tirthika mu teg pa (Tib)
- An outer being, a proponent of a non-Buddhist system of beliefs with tenets that assert either eternalism or nihilism, views which bind them to samsara. Also known as an outsider, one who adheres to an outsider doctrine. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.