2,019 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. Responds to students’ questions about a drawing of the stages of calm abiding meditation, stressing that texts and teachers come before illustrations. It explains vigilance as a means of catching lapsed memory, and says calm abiding is hard to attain and depends on pure ethics and prerequisites.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: f6a5ccd0-bfbb-4455-b1a8-6ff44713edaf
Words: 2,015
Knowledge for salvation is profoundly Christian. Right? God is unspeakable, inexpressible. You find it in the in the monotheisms, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. And therefore, all the monotheisms in their essence are anti intellectual.
And you find it’s very deeply rooted in the western mind, this idea. The moment you look into spirituality, you don’t study, you don’t think, you bliss out. It’s a very western idea. Then it is it is alien to Buddhist thought. It is alien and to Indian thought in general.
Indian thought in general. Do have other questions? I have two questions, Ilya. The first one in terms of the picture is at the end when the monk is riding the elephant with the sword in his hand, just before then, it’s like the path splits in two. Is that because some people then go off to nirvana?
And he’s coming back to It’s possible. Like a Bodhisattva? I have translated the totality of the Tibetan text. Nothing is said about that. Oh.
Then that is sort of up to the artist. You know? You could view it as a two paths, the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna. Yeah. That’s one possibility.
You could also view it as the various possible objects of insight, mundane and super mundane. That’s also possible. I’ve read no commentary about it. Probably not. Is it the path which splits?
Right? Yeah. So does that mean that there’s nothing written about it or that there may be something written that hasn’t been translated? Or that that’s just either of the two. But you have to keep in mind something, which is why Geshe-la did not want to present this himself.
In the Tibetan tradition, you rely on texts. Then the drawing by definition is made by someone else than a teacher. So the understanding of the draftsman is very limited. When I showed this to Geshela, the first question he asked was, who drew this? How experienced and learned is he?
Then I said, well, it’s under the auspices of the Central Tibetan Institute in Sarnath. He also translated the Bhāvanākrama. I don’t if he did the drawing but he supervised it. Probably it’s good. But the drawing comes second to the explanations you get from your teachers.
That’s why I only presented here to just enable you to settle things in your mind because it’s a lot of material otherwise. If there’s something which is contradictory between the teachings you receive and the drawing, then it’s a drawing which is at fault. Clearly. My second question is about vigilance. I thought I have been using vigilance in my own meditation at home.
But according to this, vigilance really only comes in at level five. And I am definitely not at level five mental abiding. So what am I doing if I think I’m doing using vigilance? You’re using it, but you are not using it at the level you will use it at during the fifth mental abiding simply because at the level we are at, the vigilance we are using is not so much struggling against sinking and agitation. What we are using is memory to try to avoid losing the object of meditation, Vigilance checks whether the memory loses the object of meditation.
So if you lose the object of meditation, it is just much more basic than sinking or agitation. Sinking or agitation means in the case of sinking, the object of meditation becomes a bit less clear. In the case of agitation, you’ll see, for instance, the object of meditation can actually start to shake a little bit, you know. That’s a sign of the beginning of agitation. Then at that point, you’re using vigilance.
But when you’re basically meditating on the image of the Buddha and suddenly you realize that you’ve been thinking of something else for the last five seconds, we’re not even talking of vigilance. We’re talking of lapsed memory. You know? So in our cases, I think probably we do not fully understand what vigilance is. Probably.
Does that answer your question? For the time being. K. That’s a good question. So what I have no personal contact with the artist.
But the flames at the end of the path might represent one of two things. First, the fact that the flames of desire diminish as we progress up on calm abiding simply mean that when we practice calm abiding, desire manifests less. So that does not mean it’s eliminated. It simply means that it manifests less because the mind is more subdued. Calm abiding alone cannot eliminate desire.
Then this is what might be meant by the flames at the end of the path. Alternatively, these flames might be the flames of wisdom. Then as I said, I showed you the drawing to help you to visualize things. Don’t rely on the drawing too much. I know that it’s it’s tempting and it’s easier, but we should rely on the text, you know.
Then I think Ishur’s explanations are remarkably clear. So I I honestly don’t know, therefore. Could be. Could be. But does a drawing help to set things down?
Many of you have seen it already once at least. Then you see one thing we have to understand is obviously in our cases some of us are here, some of us are down here. It’s sort of very theoretical all of this. Then the explanations on the prerequisites calm abiding are quite humbling in the sense that frankly it’s the only way to get calm abiding. If one doesn’t have the six prerequisites it doesn’t happen.
If one does have the six prerequisites then frankly, it depends on one’s ethics. So I have known at least two of the top Western Buddhist scholars and now teachers try to get calm abiding and both failed. And both were students of my own root teacher. You know? They went to retreat in Dhamsala, both failed after six months.
They never got it. You know? So it’s not that easy to get. You know? Well, Well, the teachings are given really to show the way to increase one’s concentration.
I think that’s realistic. It’s realistic to try to go from the first to the second level of mental abiding. The third is quite something. Not everyone gets the third. And once you have the fourth, you are a meditator, you know.
Then if one doesn’t go into retreat with the conditions which are described and is an open ended retreat, unless there are extraordinarily powerful karmic imprints from past lives, and I have heard of such cases, it simply doesn’t happen. I have heard that Tibetan doctors can identify people who have predispositions for calm abiding. At least they say so. I don’t know this for a fact, but there’s a difference in the way the winds flow into channels. You know?
It’s not easy to get. And someone who actually has calm abiding, the people in front of you hear this quite a lot because calm abiding is taught a lot now in the West. I don’t know of a single westerner who has it. I know quite a few who claim. Then the moment you ask them to show you their practice, you realize they don’t have it because when someone enters calm abiding, they become like a rock or a block of wood.
Everything stops. They’re insensitive to pain. There is no breath one can notice. They can stay in meditation for days on ends. It’s open ended.
You know? Then whatever paranormal powers they wish to have, they get at once. You know? So it’s difficult to get. Sorry.
Safer, you were first. It was with Geshe Rabten. I mentioned that you have a good memory. Geshe Rabten had calm abiding. It was recognized by His the Dalai Lama, and he had been in retreat in Dharamsala.
Then His Holiness asked him to teach calm abiding to meditators in the mountains above Dharamsala, which he did for many years. And then really on order of his holiness, like, Khensur Rabgye Sherab Gyatso had really no interest whatsoever in coming to the West. He was sent to Switzerland. He created, at the period, the best Buddhist study center in the world, in the West. And he eventually got cancer when my father was treating him.
And we, had to go to a neurologist to check whether there was metastases of the liver cancer to the spine. And in those days, the way it was done was that they would actually pass an electrical current through the spine and check responses of the nerves on an oscilloscope. I suppose it’s done in a much more sophisticated way nowadays. But to do this they had to put the person under anesthesia. Then for the Tibetans anesthesia amounts to using drugs.
So when the doctor explained this, had to translate for Geshe Geshe Raptan refused. And the doctor was very, very contemptuous of us. It was extremely unpleasant experience. Then he didn’t want to have anything to do with us. But Geshe Rabten said to him to just do what he had to do in very blunt Tibetan terms.
He literally said to me, tell the witch doctor to do what he has to do. And then I insisted and the doctor had to sign a waiver, you know. And then he did these tests which involved placing very large needles inside Geshe Rabten’s spine. But before this, Geshe Raptan entered into meditation, and I had never seen him enter in calm abiding before. He never showed this to us, but I was his translator, and I was privileged to see this.
And, I’ve never seen this happen to a human being. He became like a block of stone, literally like a block of stone. There was no breath. There was no movement. You had a dead body in front of you.
Well, we weren’t poking him. My apologies. You know? Then the doctor panicked, and he thought Geshe Rabten had just had a heart attack or was dying. And I said to the doctor, he’s he’s, you know, one of the meditation teachers of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, then you can just do what you have to do, you know.
And then the doctor finished his tests and I could really see Geshe Raptan had pre programmed the lengths of calm abiding because he asked the doctor about this before. Then the doctor finished the test and we had to wait. And then Geshe Rabten came out of this and the doctor said to me, he said, I have never seen this. This is medically impossible. There’s no control over this.
And he became a Buddhist as a result. So calm abiding is this, you know. Then frankly, it is mainly the domain of monks. It is possible for lay people to get calm abiding but one needs pure ethics. If there is no ethics, there can be no calm abiding simply because ethics is controlling the outward waywardness of the mind.
If it is not controlled, it’s not possible to control more subtle aspects. Then a lay person with lay vows, someone who is fully ordained, someone who has good ethics and who has the conditions can gain calm abiding. Unsurprisingly, in the Theravada countries where the emphasis on ethics is very strong, there are cases, I know of one case of a Burmese girl, a lay girl. She went to it wasn’t U Pandita’s center in Yangon, but one of the related centers and it was in a little bit more than three months she got calm abiding. And there are very powerful karmic imprints, number one.
Number two, very pure ethics for sure, you know. She had lay vows for the duration. Then it’s possible. Then I think we have to stop for today. My apologies for cutting it a bit short.
We have to dismantle all the material before the class. I hope this has been of some help. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pandita khäpa (Tib)
- Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.