1 h 28 min · 4,454 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 88-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche addresses the critical gap between studying Buddhist texts and actually transforming the mind through meditation. He outlines the three-stage path of realization: minds arising from hearing, thinking, and meditation, using impermanence as a primary example. He shows how analytical meditation on impermanence can ripen into stable realization that persists even in dreams, and contrasts this with teachings on compassion and bodhicitta, which require direct emotional generation. Through extended Q&A, he offers practical guidance on meditation structure, the role of preliminaries, and working with obstacles like distraction. The session closes with commentary on Langri Tangpa’s Eight Verses on Mind Training, emphasizing cherishing others as the bodhisattva path. For practitioners already familiar with the Lamrim.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 8 Verses (D1S2 – KR.mp3
UUID: e87ccea5-e8f8-441e-b933-dec37513b2d3
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Sun Radiance – Thought Transformation
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,448
But chai sometimes. North Carolina, normal, sometimes you know. I like coffee. Coffee every afternoon at 3PM, then I have coffee. Just no sugar.
Coffee, black black coffee and milk. Black coffee. Yeah. White coffee. Why?
White coffee. Black coffee. Black coffee and milk. Okay. If I, you know, drink coffee, then I but I but I how do you say?
But I can sleep, you know? No worries. Somebody said if you you get coffee then you can’t sleep. But no worry for me, why? She can drink coffee during the day.
Doesn’t have She says, yeah, the same, you know, your wife and I are same. I’m not saying anything. Good, good chai. I like it. This time I like.
So here meditation, gom in Tibetan means that one must appropriate the topic which one has heard. One must make it a thing of one’s mind, one with one’s mind. A disciple of Haribhādra, the author of a commentary on the Abhisamayālamkāra, who was known under the name of master Tseshey said that meditation means to turn the topic into one’s mind, to make it into one’s mind. For some of you may be new, I think almost all of you long time students who have received teachings on the path shared with beings of the small, middling and great scope. As Buddha Śākyamūni said, what I have taught you should listen to and put into practice, otherwise you will be similar to a patient who hoards medicine without ever ingesting it.
The meaning of this stanza is that Buddha taught everything there was to be taught on these topics before departing, and it is entirely up to us after receiving these teachings to put them in practice or not. If we don’t put them in practice, we will be similar to a patient, someone who is sick, who holds medicines, but never ever takes them. And as Je Tsongkhapa said, although the quote is somewhat different, the intent of the quote is the same. One who has received many teachings, but abandons the Dharma clearly indicates thereby that the Śāstras, in other words the commentaries, have not dawned as oral instructions to his mind. Therefore, put in practice what you have heard.
And the meaning of this quote is that if one abandons the teachings, and abandoning the teachings means here to abandon practice, there are numerous forms of abandonment. After having received many teachings, it is a sign of not having interiorized the teachings. Or as Pabongka Rinpoche said, the meaning is once again similar, one should combine what is heard, and this here means what one has studied with what one has experienced, which here refers to one’s reflections on the topic. I think a few, you know, light can you turn off? Yeah.
And fine. Nice. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
And also another thing, you can turn on. Okay. Okay. Okay. Yep.
Chris, just relax. I’m fine. Thank you. No problem. And I’ll say, I think you can.
Okay, thank you. Cool and dark is very good for sleeping. So please do keep in mind these quotes of Pabongka Rinpoche, of Je Tsongkhapa and the quote of Buddha Śākyamūni, and I remember the last time I visited Khensur Rinpoche, Rinpoche said meditate. Then this is also advice his holiness has given. This morning, Geshe-la explained clearly the meaning of meditation.
That’s the way it is. The way it is. That is? That is the way it is. Is the way it is.
So this is what meditation is, and then there are numerous objects of observation. One can meditate on bodhicitta, on compassion, on impermanence, and so forth. So the potency of meditation is a potency to transform our minds, and to give you an example, let us take someone who has meditated on the path shared with the being of the small scope, then when that person deep down, not just verbally, not just mere talk, but deep down feels this life has no substance, no essence, then that is a result of meditation. Then this is the result of meditation, however, obviously, it is difficult for the mind to stay in that state. And for instance, if one meditates on patience, and that which is discordant with patience progressively dwindles.
If one were to meditate on impermanence, then grasping at the permanence of things would progressively dwindle as well. So let us take an example which will make it evident. Let us take sexual desire for a person, a man or a woman, then the more we reflect on the attractiveness of that person, the greater the sexual desire. In other words, the mind is transformed through those reflections. Then let us take another example that of one’s enemies, whether you have great or small enemies, then as you start reflecting on how your enemies have offended and insulted you, and the reasons for which they have done this, and you think over and again, your anger increases evermore, your hatred increases evermore until you’re literally shaking in your seat with anger.
And sometimes we see this in families, you know, two people are living quietly together and somehow for no reason it seems this starts, right? This is why it is said in the Lamrim that meditation has a potency to transform the mind’s outlook either on objects of desire or pleasant or unpleasant objects. Now when we attempt to meditate on impermanence, we need a topic or a base for this meditation. If we take the stand in front of Geshe-la, then obviously you all are aware that there is such a stand, and we might say it is impermanent verbally, but when we try to justify its impermanence through reasoning, things get difficult. Then when we reflect through numerous lines of reasoning on the impermanence of this table, this amounts to analytical meditation.
Now if we compare on the one hand meditating, let us say on compassion or bodhicitta, and meditating on impermanence on the other hand, there is a big difference. When we meditate on bodhicitta or compassion, even though we understand in detail the meaning of bodhicitta or compassion, that does not mean that they arise within our mind stream. Do you understand? Do you still remember the meaning of great compassion which Geshe-la covered last year? It was presented here.
Yeah. Forgot here. Do you remember? Do you remember? Sorry?
Between aspirations. No, it’s bodhicitta, you know. So here in a nutshell, when one understands the meaning of great compassion or bodhicitta, one will not by that alone have generated great compassion or bodhicitta within one’s continuum. Whereas when one understands impermanence by means of a valid cognizer, which determines it, one will have generated the realization of impermanence within one’s continuum. It’s therefore not sufficient to understand the meaning of bodhicitta or great compassion.
One must transform one’s mind in the nature of bodhicitta and great compassion to have generated them. So once one has generated the realization which realizes impermanence within one’s mind stream, one has understood impermanence. So to meditate on a topic, let us say on impermanence, at the least one must understand the topic. So if one wishes to meditate on the impermanence of the table, one must understand impermanence through relying on numerous treatises. So here, it is through initially generating a mind arisen from hearing regarding impermanence, and a mind arisen from thinking regarding impermanence that eventually one can give rise to a mind arisen from meditation regarding impermanence.
Once one has generated a mind arisen from meditation regarding impermanence, then that realization of impermanence remains stably within one’s mind for one’s life. The characteristic of minds arisen from meditation is that they are stable over and against minds not arisen from meditation, which are not stable. Therefore, once one has generated a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence, then one’s mental outlook is durably and permanently transformed. As a result, the opposite of the realization of impermanence, which is grasping at the permanence of phenomena, would probably no longer occur. So, and probably at this point, we would experience the realization of impermanence in the dream state.
This is a characteristic too of minds arisen from meditation. Of course, I do understand. This is the meaning of generating great compassion or bodhicitta within one’s mind stream. Once they are generated, they are there stably, we never forget them. So it is not easy to generate a mind arisen from meditation.
This is why Je Tsongkhapa in the final verses of the three principles of the path says, having in this way understood these three principles of the path, retire in solitude and put effort or exertion to accomplish your final goal. And this is also taught in one other short prayer of Je Tsongkhapa’s. We have your questions. If you have questions, please ask them. And based on your questions, I will understand your mental outlook.
I can’t figure it out looking at your faces. So what exactly would make you happy? Presentations on impermanence, presentations on great compassion, presentations on bodhicitta, and then once I understand, then I will present them. Please don’t confuse great compassion and bodhicitta. They are different.
Great compassion is the cause of bodhicitta. Okay. Would an appropriate approach be to assign, for example, one of the seven topics of the small scope for each day of the week? Yes. It would be a very good system.
You would meditate for instance on one day on identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, and a couple days later on death and impermanence through the reasons given for this. So for instance, when you meditate on death and impermanence, you would resolve to meditate on the ninefold meditation on death and impermanence and not to get scattered out towards other topics. Okay. I’m not I’m not sure if I understood correctly, but when you said that when you when you have understood the meaning of impermanence correctly, then that’s and doing that with a mind arising from meditation, then that’s the same as realizing impermanence. But that’s different to understanding great compassion and bodhicitta.
It’s not enough to just simply understand the concept of those, that you need to be able to feel them or you need to be able to experience that feeling? Is that I’m not So when one wishes to generate great compassion or bodhicitta within one’s mind stream, it is not sufficient to have understood the meaning of great compassion and bodhicitta. One must turn one’s mind into great compassion or bodhicitta. However, as far as impermanence is concerned, when one wishes to gain a realization of impermanence within one’s mind stream, all one has to do is understand fully impermanence. Thank you.
If I was to practice for an hour by starting with the mindfulness of breath to calm the mind and then the rest of the hour focus on a topic, one of the seven meditations. Would that be an appropriate practice for an hour? Yes, it is however not necessary to practice mindfulness of breath before meditating on one of these topics. It is only necessary if your mind is wandering to a non virtuous topic. Otherwise, if your mind is not, you can engage directly in meditation on the Lamrim topic.
So when meditating on one of the seven topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it is best to meditate on that topic in an incremental fashion. Alternatively, if you’re experienced, you can focus on one topic. Mhmm. Sometimes during the day if I’ve been studying and I become really interested and focused on a particular topic and I go and sit to meditate on that topic, is it necessary first to go through the preliminaries? I might have already done the preliminaries at the beginning of the day.
Which preliminaries? The points cleaning the altar, the offerings, prostrations and so on. Yes. It would be good actually if you have because these preliminaries are means of accumulating merit and purifying non virtue. If you have time before engaging in meditation, it would be good to do so.
Because you are a nun. I think you have to examine because you’re a nun. So because you are a nun, the standard is higher unlike the others and therefore by definition you have time, so you should engage in the preliminaries in detail before meditating. Yeah. Exactly you have time unlike nobody, you know.
Sometimes if you have time, it’s correct. Okay. Yeah, now more time, you know. What are you doing? What are you trying?
Okay, come. You can ask anything. You mentioned the dream state about halfway through and I missed the connection. Would you mind speaking a bit more about that? So when one has generated an experience of the impermanence of a table, in other words, one has realized the impermanence of a table, this is an extremely powerful and stable state of mind, and at that point, probably, the mind grasping at the permanence of the table can no longer arise.
Now this powerful stable experience of the impermanence of phenomena will be present at all times, and therefore will be present during the dream state as well, and one’s mind in the dream state will be mixed with this experience. So what is meant by saying that it is mixed with the dream state is that whatever you see in the dream state, you would be aware of as impermanent in the dream state. How would a mind of impermanence appear in the dream state? So when you would in your dreams see your car or your house, you would see them with full awareness that they are not stable. This is not the same thing as ordinary dreaming.
Many things, you understand. You understand. Because in an ordinary dream, when pleasant things happen we are happy and when unpleasant things happen we cry. That’s an ordinary dream. Because an ordinary dream is one in which we subscribe or we believe in what we see in the dream, in the objects of observation. Once one has generated minds arisen from meditation, one views a dream as a dream.
Beyond. What are the characteristics of a mind arisen from thinking? So if we take for instance the mind arisen from thinking which realizes the impermanence of a table, such a mind has a cause which is the mind arisen from hearing, which has studied numerous treatises on impermanence. In dependence on these treatises in turn, one reflects on the characteristics of the table. And once one has generated a valid cognizer which determines that this table is impermanent, at that point one has generated a mind arisen from thinking focused on the impermanence of table.
So arisen from thinking, Samjung in Tibetan can be developed in Tibetan to sampa lé jungwa. sampa is thought, lé is from, jungwa is arisen. Arisen from thinking. Here thinking refers to the process of repeated analysis. Once this repeated analysis has led to fruition, one has generated a valid cognizer, which is focused on the object.
Can I ask a question that came out of the Lamrim and your discussion earlier this week? So I want to ask a question about the nature of mind. Okay. Alright. Okay.
You okay with tea? I think it’s Don’t you say that the mind is permanent, Geshe-la is going to be very angry again. It’s a very important point, this one. Then the Vaibhāṣikas have a particular presentation, but Geshe-la will cover that tomorrow when there’s a moment. My question is that I think you said it was the Jonangpa position that says that the mind is permanent and I wondered how that is different from the position that says Jonang, Geshe-la said.
Sorry? Jonangpa’s view. Jonangpa. Jonangpa. Not Shentong. Not Shentong.
The co-position. And I was wondering how that was different from the position that says the nature of mind is emptiness and emptiness is permanent. So Jonangpas say that the ālaya vijnana is truly established, then this is not what Je Tsongkhapa says. Je Tsongkhapa says that the ālaya vijnana if it exists is not truly established. Okay.
Earlier, you were talking about the relationship between memory and distraction, and my memory seems to be atrophied due to strong distraction which is probably a result of weak ethics. And so my question relates to purification practices. I guess what would you recommend for a neurotic borderline scatterbrain like myself? So if you take a topic such as impermanence, to be able to remember in a stable fashion everything you have studied on impermanence. Really, the best way is to discuss about it with others and to analyze it in great detail.
In our experience, in Geshe-la’s experience at the monastery, it is largely through debate in the debate courtyard that whatever was studied remained stably and durably in the mind through repeated debate and analysis. And you have to sleep well, right? Then however many hours of sleep you might need, whether it’s seven, eight or nine hours, you should sleep just that many hours, because at present our minds depend heavily on the brain, and when the brain is fatigued, then nothing stays in the mind. And have a relaxed mind. You have to but you need, you must relax the mind.
It’s interesting, the must Okay. So when you study, it is important not to allow scattering to occur, to let your mind wander all over. Instead, you should focus on whatever you’re studying. So I guess the question was if there are if there are obstructions to that focus, which need to be purified. I guess without going into details about what they are, it’s hard for you to say.
But in your observation of Western students, if you want to keep it general, what would be the most potent or practical purification practices? The first step with interferences of this nature is to think about their defects or their faults repeatedly. When you think about their defects or their faults repeatedly, then you will be able to counter them, otherwise it will not happen. Geshe-la believes that the majority of you do not drink. Then if you were to drink, you should drink very little beer, because it is when you reflect on the faults and the problems of drinking beer that in turn the mindset which thinks I really don’t want to drink a lot, because there’ll be complications arises.
Otherwise, it doesn’t. So as Je Tsongkhapa says in his Lines of Experience, if one does not strive at understanding the thoughts of the truths of origin and suffering, how could one generate the mind striving for liberation? Here, one must reflect on the faults of these two first truths. As Rinpoche said, without reflecting on the defects, how can you generate the wish to be freed from them? As Āryadeva says in his Chatuhshataka, without sadness with cyclic existence, how can the mind striving for liberation arise?
And sadness with cyclic existence means being aware of the faults of samsaric existence. Then I suspect in your case, you are not aware of these defects. Then there’s no wish to be sure. Geshe-la, I just want to ask you on the Vajrasattva purification. Your recommendation is quite different, not quite different, a bit different to some other lamas who recommend prescribed practices like Vajrasattva practice.
I’m just wondering, for someone with limited time, like half an hour or twenty minutes a day, do you recommend practice Vajrasattva as opposed to going through each of the points, meditating on seven points of small scope? So Vajrasattva Mantra is a tantric practice, and you’re comparing a tantric practice and the practice of the being of the small scope. The way you should proceed is you should recite Vajrasattva mantra and when you have time in addition you should also meditate on the seven topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Then you have just told us that you don’t have time, so Geshe-la doesn’t know what to say, but really if you have time, the best is to study. It is through study that your mind will improve.
Through faith and folding your hands like this, it is difficult for the mind to improve. As is said, not through enthusiasm alone, but in conjunction with wisdom. So here enthusiasm alone is insufficient. One must engage in training in wisdom. These are instructions, advice.
The wisdom being a realization of selflessness. Whenever I say wisdom, you think it is the wisdom realizing selflessness. No. It is the various forms of wisdom. For instance, when you reflect on impermanence, if you analyze using reason, the reasons which phenomena are impermanent, that is wisdom.
Wisdom is analysis. Would Geshe-la be able to tell us a little bit more about this wonderful Geshe Langri Tangpa and a little bit more about the context of how he came to compose the eight verses of mind training. I’m sorry. I don’t know a lot about that life. Okay, sorry.
I’m sorry. Any other questions? Just going back to I think it was part of Mark’s answer to Mark’s question. Geshe-la mentioned about having debate and people to discuss the topic with. I think most of us don’t have that around unless we’re at the center.
I tend to sort of throw myself into books on similar topics or trying to stay on topic or books on Buddhism. So is that okay? Is that one way of keeping things in mind? Yes, most definitely. However, I would not say that there is no possibility to engage in such discussion in the West.
Certainly, if you come to TBI, we have the discussion group on Tuesdays, you can speak with people at the center of these topics, you can send emails to knowledgeable students and discuss about these topics. Then if none of this is possible, do indeed read, but reading is not enough. You must think about it. And also you can call him. If you want to ask me about impermanence, you’re more than welcome.
If you want to ask I’ll give you my number if you want to ask, you’ve asked meaningful questions, not about momos and prostrations and all that, something weighty. Okay. Are you tired? Little bit. Little tiny.
Okay. So we have in the last couple hours reflected since this morning on the meaning of the Mahāyāna and we have accumulated vast waves of virtue, then we should rejoice in this. So at present in Langri Tangpa’s root text, second verse, whenever, wherever, and whomsoever I befriend, I will behold myself as the basis of all, and from the depths of my thoughts may I always uphold cherishing others as supreme. And the meaning of this stanza is rather difficult. So in the first verse, whoever and whomsoever I befriend, whomsoever refers to whomsoever one meets, whether this is someone who is high up in society or low down, then whomsoever we befriend, it is helpful to see ourselves as somewhat smaller, humbler than them.
The last two verses from the depths of my thoughts, may I always uphold cherishing others as supreme. We cherish others as supreme because it is in dependence on others that we are able to generate great compassion and bodhicitta. So to practice in keeping with this stanza is difficult, but our goal must be to do so at a basic level, at the level of the foundation of our mind. Then if on the other hand, whenever we meet others, we keep thinking none is greater than I, who is my equal, then it is very difficult to generate any type of altruism. And this is a way of thinking, a way of looking at things mentally in dependence on which altruism arises.
It’s very pleasant and one ends up with a very happy mind. And here, may I always uphold cherishing others as supreme, the final verse of the stanza teaches cherishing others as a means of countering self-cherishing. And the first verse, wherever and whomsoever I befriend, probably teaches the qualities of cherishing others, whereas the second verse, I will behold myself as the basest of all, probably teaches the faults of self-cherishing. And then, if we recite these verses from time to time, as this is the core practice of the sons of the conquerors, the bodhisattvas, then there will be no unhappiness, no depression in our mind. Instead, we will be happy and exalted.
Then one should not say, this is the practice of Bodhisattvas, how can one like me ever hope to do this? Bodhisattvas also had to start somewhere. So these two stanzas covered the presentation of bodhicitta and also of great compassion. And from tomorrow onwards, I will cover the presentation of impermanence and so forth. Then today, we were not able to present things in a systematic sequence.
I had to draw from various different directions, but as of tomorrow onwards, we will be presenting our own system. It’ll be very sequential. Then today when you depart for your homes, it will be good if you try to keep your minds focused in a virtuous direction and keep that in mind for the next two and a half days. Otherwise, once you’re gone, to start thinking about this is a bit odd. So therefore, ideally, you would keep your mind focused in a virtuous direction for the rest of your lives, but this is rather difficult and therefore we will start with two days and a half, and if you could tomorrow bring the questions and the doubts you had from today, then you will improve, otherwise what way is there to improve one’s mind?
The harder your questions, the happier I am. When you ask difficult questions, I wonder does he or she understand or not. Then through looking into this, all of us improve, our general understanding improves. At the end of this class, what is there, Chris? Is there meditation after this class?
What is the program? I don’t have the program. Finish English. English. So you are a little bit happy.
Okay. So if you have the opportunity and you do now, you should try to recollect these topics by yourself. This is the time and then we can head out quietly. She will probably live far away. I think then, okay.
The Mandala offering on page nine, just the first verse. Okay. Well done.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is it appropriate to assign one of the seven topics of the small scope to each day of the week for daily meditation?
Yes, this would be a very good system. For instance, one day could be spent meditating on identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, and a couple of days later on death and impermanence through the reasons given for it. When meditating on death and impermanence, the practitioner would resolve to meditate on the ninefold meditation on death and impermanence and not to get scattered out towards other topics.
What are the characteristics of a mind arisen from thinking, and how is it generated?
Take the mind arisen from thinking that realizes the impermanence of a table. Its cause is the mind arisen from hearing, which has studied numerous treatises on impermanence. In dependence on these treatises, one reflects on the characteristics of the table. Once one has generated a valid cognizer that determines the table is impermanent, one has generated a mind arisen from thinking focused on the table's impermanence. The Tibetan term, sampa lé jungwa, means 'arisen from thought': sampa is thought and jungwa is arisen. Here thinking refers to the process of repeated analysis. When this repeated analysis reaches fruition, one has generated a valid cognizer focused on the object.