1 h 54 min · 5,655 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 114-minute teaching from a two-and-a-half-day retreat on the Eight Verses of Mind Training, His Holiness the Dalai Lama guides students through the foundational path of small scope (renunciation and karma), the middling scope (great compassion), and the great scope (bodhicitta). He opens by examining meditation on death and impermanence—specifically the three roots that death is certain, its timing unknown, and only Dharma practice helps at death. He then walks through how to progress from these basics to understanding the six root afflictions (desire, anger, ignorance, pride, doubt, afflicted view) and why eliminating them leads to lasting mental happiness. A central theme is bodhicitta: the uncontrived aspiration to free all beings from suffering and to achieve enlightenment for their sake. He illustrates this through the example of His Holiness himself, who through practicing the Lamrim eventually generated such compassion and has spent his life benefiting countless beings. The teaching culminates in exploring substantial causes and cooperative conditions, using practical examples (potatoes, vases, parents) to clarify how phenomena arise in dependence on conditions. Pitched at committed retreat participants with some prior Buddhist study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 8 Verses (D2S1.mp3
UUID: 956cc62a-5908-407f-9dcd-a8bf7e458fb0
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Sun Radiance – Thought Transformation
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~5,650
Mhmm. You have good dreams. Good dream, I think. Because So since we engaged in this short retreat lasting two and a half days focused on virtue and the abstention from non virtue, that is why I ask you whether you have had good dreams because normally you should have a good dream.
Last night or this morning. Sorry? Traffic. Something wrong with the. When one stays in retreat, especially if one abides by the rules of the retreat, then definitely one will have very good dreams because one is fulfilling the wills of one’s spiritual teacher.
So this is the best of possible activities. So if we focus on what was taught yesterday, in other words, on how to meditate, then we will get a very pure, very clear, and a very swift understanding of it. As Pabongka in the 37 Practices of the Bodhisattva says, upon waking with a pure mind, this is a an advice on how one should proceed in the morning. Then, obviously, if one has not slept well, it is difficult for these dreams to come. So yesterday, among your questions, Maggie asked how to meditate on the path shared with the being of the small scope.
And the way one should proceed is that one should group the four first of the seven topics of meditation. In other words, one should group meditations on identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, its importance and its rarity, as well as the fourth meditation on death and impermanence, and use this to then engage in the topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope. So these are the conditions for meditation on the path shared with the being of the small scope, and then one proceeds incrementally to that shared with the being of the middling and eventually the great scope. So if we take at present the fourth topic of meditation on death and impermanence, and we meditate on it in terms of these three roots that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, nothing is of benefit but practice of Dharma. Then here, the first of these three roots is self evident.
We all know that our death is certain that we will die. Yet under the influence of, grasping at our own permanence, when we have reached, for instance, the age of 50, we are looking forward to living until 80 or 90. And we accumulate, obviously, under the influence of this mind grasping at permanence, all the requisites, to live that long, which interferes very greatly with our practice. Then, at the age of 90, we are convinced that we will live to the age of 100. This is once again the influence of the mind grasping at permanence.
In my own case, I am over 50. And when I don’t think carefully about things casually, I assume that as long as I mind my health and eat good fresh food, I can look forward to living until my mid seventies or even older. Now, this is clearly self grasping at work, grasping at permanence at work. And under the influence of this, then we say, I will study next week. I will meditate next month and so forth.
And the most powerful counter to grasping at permanence is the second root, which is realization of the uncertainty of the time of death. Then, in this context, a piece of advice or instruction is given. Have contentment regarding your desires because tomorrow you might be a corpse. And this is very powerful piece of advice. Because we do not know what tomorrow will be made of, then we should be satisfied with what we have.
This is the, advice of, older monks, and it is something, which has been, the source of considerable reflection. So it is something we ought to take on board. And regarding the remainder of the path shared with the being of the small scope, after meditating on death and impermanence, if we ask ourselves what possible rebirths there are, there are only two rebirths, higher and lower rebirths. And if we check for the causes of this, we find within our mind stream that there are only non-virtuous karmic imprints. Then in our own case, the odds of a lower rebirth is very high.
As a result, we look for we seek for protection from this, and this protection is afforded by the triple gem and specifically the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni. Mhmm. Which teachings? The teachings on causality. This is how one proceeds.
So here, we have reached the topic of causality, and this is the core of the practice of the being of the small scope. By causality, one refers specifically here to abstaining from the 10 non-virtues. So practice here means knowing both what one should abstain from and what one should practice. And this issue of causality is an extremely important one because imagine what our world would be like if everyone in this world believed in karma and causality and lived accordingly. Then there would be no need for a police force.
There’d be no need for the military. There’d be no need for guns or weapons of any type. These people would live in peace and harmony. Karma and causality is the interior law, which prevents us from behaving like beasts. In a world without any belief in karma and causality, men are animals.
Imagine if you wish, in this community, if no one believed in karma and causality and there were a pile of dollar bills on Geshe-la’s table. Yeah. Then if you believe in karma and causality, you will say, I I cannot take that because if I take that, you know, I will accrue non virtuous karma, and I myself will suffer in this in the future. But otherwise, if you don’t believe it, obviously, you will grab the money and put it in your pocket. This is therefore the importance of an ethics which abstains from the 10 non virtues.
And yesterday, Mark had asked how to foster the strength of one’s memory. Then one of the best means to do this is precisely a careful practice of ethics. Otherwise, if, one doesn’t behave ethically and one is always subject to desire and anger, traveling around by night and so forth, then obviously, one’s capacities are going to dwindle. So
Yesterday, Natalie asked me about the biography of, Geshe Langri Thangpa. And, I would like to suggest to Natalie to consult the great lama, mister Googler. And if you enter Langri Thangpa, you will have the biography of Langri Thangpa, which will come out. I was going to Google, but I didn’t do that. But I did find the brochure that’s in the handout and has a Google description.
Google. You know, you can search Google route, and they’re like, do want to add some more edge? There’s everything on Google. Yes. Do you understand Google?
Oh, yes. I do, Geshe-la. Okay. It’s become very easy these days, hasn’t it? So understanding the path shared with a being of the small scope is quite easy.
Practicing is something else, and that is what we have to focus on. Now we should move upwards to the path of the middling and especially of the great scope and meditate on it. So yesterday, when I asked you to give me the meaning of meditation, no one seemed to be able to do so. Therefore, I would like to ask you to memorize the definition of meditation given by Je Tsongkhapa in the Lamrim Chenmo. Meditation is protecting the aspect of appearance of a virtuous object of meditation after focusing on it repeatedly.
Do you understand? Can you repeat? Yes. You can just, you know, memories, please. Can you repeat it by memory?
Very. You know? But in the Tibetan, Mhmm. I can do that. Say in Tibetan, you know.
So if you could all, like Andy, memorize this definition of meditation, then it would be very helpful, and you repeat it and think about the meaning so that one knows what one is doing, who meditates. So here, the definition mentions a virtuous object. And as was mentioned yesterday, a virtuous object is one apprehended with a virtuous mind. But the moment we try to go beyond a verbal statement of what a virtuous mind in is and try to understand the meaning, things become difficult. What do you think is a virtuous mind?
And What is a virtuous mind? So today, we’ll proceed in this fashion. I’ll ask you questions, and then we’ll meditate. Then I’ll ask you some more questions. If I only present things formally, the benefit is very limited.
So I’ll explain a little bit, then ask you a question, a little exam, then some meditation. Okay. Can you? The aspiration to become enlightened? A mind that is free of the afflictions.
In the context of meditation, I would say a mind that’s not under the sway of a of an affliction at that particular time. A mind that wishes not to harm but to benefit others. A relaxed mind. Mind that has assimilated the objects of concentration during meditation, so the objects of virtue have been assimilated into the mind stream. Yeah.
Yeah. Another. Okay. That’s very good. All of you have been thinking about things.
But the foremost is the motivation. There are numerous types of virtuous minds, bodhicitta, great compassion, renunciation, definite emergence, and so forth. But what is critical or fundamental to define a virtuous mind is the motivation in the backdrop of that mind. If the motivation in the backdrop is to benefit others, then it is a virtuous mind. If the motivation in the backdrop is to escape cyclic existence for one’s own purposes, that is also a virtuous mind.
Then a mind which is focused on future lives and beyond is a virtuous mind. Likewise, as Anila said, a mind which is focused on liberation is also a virtuous mind. So when a virtuous state of mind arises, then one’s mind is at peace and happy. Then, obviously, when one’s a nonvirtuous state arises, one’s mind is uptight, one’s face is uptight and dark. Definite emergence.
Emergence. Said renunciation, but different. So regarding the thought of definite emergence, this thought has two components. The first is a heartfelt understanding of the faults of cyclic existence and the afflictions, and the second is a desire to be freed from these. Then, the thought of definite emergence and the wish for renunciation, for liberation are synonymous.
Do you understand? I mean, you, mean, you think you you you some. So what is the meaning of the thought of definite emergence? Alright. Do you understand?
Okay. Question. Do you understand? Okay. When you don’t answer, I assume you don’t understand.
Right? So one thing which you have to understand is that when one says that one should meditate on definite emergence, on great compassion, or on bodhicitta, it is not the case that the object of this meditation is definite emergence. When one meditates on definite emergence, actually, one meditates on the faults of cyclic existence and the afflictions to generate definite emergence. However, when one meditates an impermanence, impermanence is the object on which one meditates. So at present, we are relaxed and at peace because our minds are probably virtuous.
However, if we were to ask whether the state will be a lasting one, then obviously not. Our minds would be troubled. Now what precisely troubles our mind? What eliminates mental peace and happiness? It is the afflictions.
So, here, it is important then to meditate on the faults of the afflictions, understanding that the afflictions disturb mental peace and happiness, and then seek for a means to eliminate the afflictions. So we all understand what the afflictions are, and we all understand that if there are no afflictions, then our minds are at peace. The question which arises is, is it possible to completely eliminate the afflictions or not? Then we can see that our mind can be improved. Our mind can be improved indefinitely as much as we want.
So in the case of the mind, we can see that the mind can be improved indefinitely. The improvement of the mind is measureless, infinite. On the other hand, if we look at physical satisfaction, we can see that it is finite. It is measured because, for instance, if we take food, then if we eat too much, we suffer. We become fat.
You must be eating a measured amount. You must eat a measured amount.
So we can see that as far as physical happiness is concerned, physical happiness is finite. And as a result, if we do not practice contentment, then we will experience suffering as a result of this. On the other hand, mental happiness is potentially measureless, infinite. What is it which interferes with mental happiness? The afflictions, and specifically the six root afflictions, desire, anger, ignorance, pride, afflicted doubt, and the afflicted view.
Afflicted view. Afflicted? View. So there is a distinction you should make here between the afflicted view, which is a term I used for in Tibetan and wrong view for in Tibetan. These are different.
It’s better to include the afflicted view within these six root afflictions. So, Geshe la, asked me to present the six root afflictions to you during the question and answer session this afternoon. Otherwise, we will waste a lot of time. Defined the afflictions as mental factors which have the capacity to induce an inappropriate state of mind. Here, the root of all the afflictions is the ignorance grasping at a self.
Therefore, if we target this root and sever it, all the afflictions disappear. Then when you ask what exactly the afflictions arise from, one has to introduce the topics of substantial cause and cooperative condition, which we will be covering later. So let us at present meditate on definite emergence. First, understanding that we want mental peace, and we understand its value and what interferes or obstructs mental peace are the afflictions. So we know that temporarily, we can cause a cessation of the afflictions, but what we wish is to cause a permanent abandonment of the afflictions, which will lead us to a permanent state of happiness.
And then thinking in this way on the fault of the afflictions, let us meditate on definite emergence during a couple of minutes. Are you thinking or are you sleepy? Come on, Kurt. So once one wishes to be freed from the cyclic existence or the afflictions which bind us, then at that point, one is striving for one’s own liberation. That is definite emergence.
When that is extended to others, it becomes great compassion. The difference between great compassion and definite emergence is in terms of the object of observation. The object of observation of definite emergence is oneself, that of great compassion is others. The aspect is the same. Keep this in mind.
So one must understand here what the aspect is. It is what one does with the mind focused on the object of observation, which is the wish to free from suffering. So what is the meaning of great compassion? The meaning of great compassion is an uncontrived mind which wishes to free all sentient beings as great in number as space from suffering. Pointed out, this adjective uncontrived and uncontrived mind or uncontrived awareness is extremely important.
This means that it is a mind which arises spontaneously. So here, this wish to eliminate suffering is characteristic both of a great compassion and of a definite emergence. Now, we know that suffering can be presented in terms of physical and mental suffering or alternatively, in terms of these three types of suffering, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and all pervasive suffering. But setting that aside, if we look at a twofold subdivision, mental suffering for certain arises from the afflictions. But this is something we can see.
Then we ourselves as Buddhists understand that the afflictions can be caused to dwindle, and we know how to do this with a repeated application of the antidotes. Non Buddhists, in other words, most of the people in this world are completely oblivious to this. If you were to ask them, they would say the afflictions are just the state of nature, the way things are. Nothing can be done about it. And as a result, situation becomes more and more uncontrollable.
And we can see in our world at present that precisely because the afflictions are not seen as faults and there’s no means to eliminate them, then under the power of anger, under the power of envy, under the power of competitiveness, the problems increase more. Each day, there is more which is going on. So then we can see that the world would be a marvelous place if everyone was freed of the afflictions. We would all live in peace and harmony. And when we generate that state of mind thinking, if only
All beings were, freed of the afflictions and of suffering. At that point, we have generated, great compassion. Then, once one has generated great compassion, one has entered the path of the being of the great scope. This is therefore how one passes from the path shared with a being of the middling scope to the path of the being of the great scope. Numerous techniques are taught in the eight verses of mind training to counter or reduce the afflictions, then to eliminate them completely is difficult, but certainly it is possible for us to reduce them.
Do you understand? Do you understand the meaning of great compassion? Yes. Yes. Can you repeat?
Can you repeat the meaning? Yeah. Yeah. I’ve been trying to wish to free all sentient beings from suffering. Yes.
Uncontrived here is very important. Uncontrived is extremely important because both hearers and Pratyekabuddhas have the wish for all sentient beings without exception to be freed of suffering and the causes of suffering. They just do not have the uncontrived wish for them to be freed of suffering and the causes of suffering because it is not something they meditate upon. How could they not have, however, the thought itself in general? So to be precise, one would have to say that once great compassion is generated, one has entered not the path of the great vehicle, but the cycle of dharmas of the great vehicle, then this is not something which hearers or Pratyekabuddhas have done.
Let us meditate at present during a couple of minutes on great compassion. So here oh, sorry. Okay. Are you here? You’re I know.
I have. Yes. So here, once one has generated great compassion in this way no. Excuse me. Once one generates a compassion which thinks, why should beings not be freed of suffering, understanding that suffering is rooted in the afflictions?
At that point, it is necessary to engage in the requisite activities to help beings. And once one engages in these activities, eventually, becomes a being such as Buddha Śākyamūni or such as his holiness, the Dalai Lama for that matter, who is able to benefit countless numbers of beings. For instance, when his holiness gives the Kālacakra initiation in Bodh Gaya, hundreds of thousands of people attend. Then those 100 thousands of people in turn help millions of others. At the beginning, his holiness, the Dalai Lama, was a being like us.
It is through the practice of Lamrim that his holiness, the Dalai Lama, eventually reached the level he is at, training over time in the Lam Rim until he generated great compassion and then bodhicitta, and then started working for the welfare of all beings. And this is what we should do too following his example. Something you can do. Yeah. Then can you do it in this life?
That is not definite. But here, we have to think of past and future lives. And then even if we are unable to do it in this life, once we start thinking in this way and aiming for this, just how happy will we be? There’s a a verse in the just about this, the happiness is causes. When we say, I will be the protector of millions of beings, I will generate the great resolve to help beings.
At present, let us meditate during a couple of minutes on generating such a bodhicitta, and then we will recite the various prayers. Page one. One b.
So at present, in the Eight Verses of Mind Training, the third stanza, in all conduct, I will investigate my continuum. And as soon as the afflictions arise, since acting so would be inappropriate for self and others, may I oppose them face to face with forceful methods? So in the third stanza, the first line in all conduct, I will investigate my continuum, conduct refers to behavior in daily life, such as walking, standing, sleeping, and so forth. And here, I will investigate my continue means to check one’s continuum for the afflictions as they were described by Asaṇga in his Abhidharmasamuccaya, the definition of the afflictions which Geshe la gave. And as soon, in other words, at once, when the afflictions arise, since acting so would be inappropriate for self and others, may I oppose them face to face with forceful methods?
Since at present, we are under the sway of affliction, as anger, then as soon as they arise, we must counter them forcefully, energetically. Me take the example of anger. All of us have generated anger numerous times in the past within our minds, So we should try to understand the nature of anger, the aspect of anger, how anger manifests, the object of anger, which is typically someone with whom we are in disagreement, and understand how to counter it. Then in a dharma center like this one, for instance, when one does work for the center of volunteers, one should reflect beforehand on the thoughts of anger. And then when anger arises in the context of one’s activities here, one should apply the antidotes where you have the force to do so.
The fourth stanza of the eight verses of mind training, when beholding sentient beings of an evil nature, fiercely oppressed by sins and suffering, just as discovering a treasure of jewels, may I uphold cherishing the rare ones. It is here that one should engage in in the practice of giving and taking. So in this sense, when beholding sentient beings of an evil nature, fiercely oppressed by sin and suffering, the suffering referred to is probably suffering which can spread from one being to another and perhaps alludes to leprosy, which is quite prevalent in Tibet. Then when we encounter a leper, then fear arises because we could ourselves catch that disease. At this point, we should view such a being as a treasure of jewels, in other words, just as a diamond, because they are most rare.
Then it is at this point that we should engage in the practice of giving and taking in conjunction with breath, visualizing that one takes the suffering of certain beings upon oneself. It matures upon oneself, and one gives one’s own happiness and virtue to them. And in the context of training of the equalization of self and others, leprosy is mentioned as one of the diseases which can be cured in this way. So this has been so far a concise presentation of the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the path of the being of the great scope, then if one were to develop it, it would become very expansive. Extensive.
Extensive. Okay. Then regarding the meaning of bodhicitta, this has been covered previously. As you remember, it is a special mind endowed with the twin aspirations. So here, what are these two aspirations?
The first is an aspiration for the welfare of sentient beings. This is of the nature of great compassion and is the cause of bodhicitta. The second is the actual nature of bodhicitta. It is an aspiration for full and utter enlightenment. Then whether bodhicitta itself is a main mind or a mental factor is another topic altogether.
So what’s the meaning of bodhicitta? So this leads us quite naturally to the topic of causality and the presentation of substantial causes and cooperative conditions. The first aspiration is of the nature of a great compassion. It is therefore a cause of bodhicitta. It is not a substantial cause.
In other words, it’s not a special cause. It is a common cause. bodhicitta is a mind which arises in dependence on causes and conditions. It’s extremely important to reflect in terms of causes and conditions. Now generally speaking, causes refer to the substantial cause, and conditions refer not to the substantial cause, but to cooperative causes or conditions.
So let’s talk about the substantial causes at present. Do you like? Yes. It or them. What?
So as you remember, the definition of a substantial cause is producer which generates a later phenomenon of similar type to it. And therefore, as we said, a substantial cause is producer which is related to a later phenomenon similar in type to itself, and all composite phenomena without exception have both substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Therefore, here, when one says that all composite phenomena have causes and conditions, causes refer specifically to substantial causes and conditions to cooperative conditions. It is not the case that every composite phenomenon is necessarily substantial cause or a cooperative condition. Tomato, Now if we take the example of rice or, let us say, potatoes, then point a tooth.
Potato. Then potatoes are composite phenomena. Therefore, they have both substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Both are required for a potato to arise. Then if those were not required, you would see something very strange in stores where potatoes alone, which are substantial cause, would be what do they do?
They don’t blossom. They sprout. Would be sprouting. So potatoes or tomatoes are therefore substantial causes, but they need cooperative conditions such as water, manure, sunlight, and so forth to sprout and so forth. And if these are absent, this doesn’t happen.
Then if on the other hand, in addition to the substantial cause, a potato, the cooperative conditions, which are water, manure, heat and so forth are present. Then the former potato will sprout and give rise to a latter potato, which is its substantial result. And the former potato is the substantial cause of the latter potato, because the latter potato is produced by the former potato and is of a similar type, in other words, a similar substance to the former potato.
To be letter. And the example of the table in front of Geshe-la should make this clearer. This table is the substantial result of a past substantial cause, which is the past table. This past table has given rise to the present table. So the present table is part of the table substantial continuum.
At the time of the present table, this past table no longer exists. Why precisely it no longer exists is something we must investigate. So here, why is it the case that the substantial cause is no longer existent at the time of the substantial effect? Because the substantial cause has become that of which it is the substantial effect. Therefore, at the time of the substantial effect, the substantial cause does not exist.
If it were to exist, it would not be a substantial cause, but a cooperative condition, and this becomes very clear in the example of our parents. At present, many of us still have our parents still alive. Therefore, our parents cannot be our substantial cause, because if they were our substantial cause, they would not exist when we exist. Instead, our parents are our cooperative condition. Do you know?
Yes. It’s a very good example of this one. Some of you seem to have thought that parents were of substantial cause, then this is evidently not the case. Because if parents were our substantial cause, then at the time when we exist, our parents would not exist. Instead, parents are a substantial parents are a cooperative condition.
Then as was said, every composite phenomenon necessarily has both substantial causes and cooperative conditions, so we have to posit substantial causes for ourselves, which are different from our parents. In the case of our parents, we go for walks with our parents and so forth. So they are not a substantial cause. I’m just do you understand? Yes.
Really? For sure. Okay. So what are your doubts? What do have to understand?
About substantial cause and cooperative condition. I didn’t think that a substantial cause necessarily was no longer existent. I thought it changed because what I’ve read off an example I said a few weeks ago is that clay is the substantial cause of a clay pot. But when you make a clay pot, even if you paint it and and what’s the word, you know, put it Glaze it or put it in a fire. The clay is still And with the table, I would have said that the substantial cause in my ignorance is the tree, the wood, which changes and gives rise to the table, but the wood is still there.
What’s the problem? Well, Okay. If you have a doubt, it has to be short and concise. Okay. Not speech.
Sorry, Elliot. But I was trying to explain that that that that my doubt is that I didn’t think that the substantial cause was no longer existent when it gave rise to the effect? So in the example of the table that’s why Yeah. Yeah. You you can.
Yeah. Let us make it very simple. Let us take a vase and look at the instance of a vase. The first instant, the second instant, the third instant. The first instant of the vase is the substantial cause of the second instant of the vase, right?
There’s one continuum, the second instant of a vase is of a similar type to the first instant of the vase, the first instant of the vase produces the second instant of the vase. Right? So the first instant of the vase is the substantial cause of the second instant of the vase. Correct? Or not?
Enough claim. Correct? Yes. At the time of the second instant of the vase, the first instant of the vase does not exist. Correct or not?
Correct? Yes or no? Yes. So this is this is Yes. Okay.
So that is what is meant by a substantial cause. So then why did they give the example of clay being a substantial cause of the clay pot? Your side, Geshe la is suggesting that you reflect very carefully and you rely on texts, not just think by yourself. If you think by yourself alone, it would not be of great benefit. We have go, you know, lunch.
So, Geshe-la, we have to go to lunch, you know. Geshe-la, I would like to know, do you agree or not that all composite phenomena necessarily have a substantial cause and a cooperative condition? So if you don’t agree, we go for a cup of coffee. But if you agree, then we can talk. You lost your registration already.
Mhmm. Okay. Thank you, Carlos. Thank you. So I just translated your doubt for Geshe-la about the clay pot.
No. There’s. So the problem with the reasoning you gave for the clay vase is it’s not precise. You’re talking of clay in general or the clay of the vase. The moment you narrow things down in terms of instance, your doubts disappear.
Instant. You understand. Care in this instance. The moment you understand the what instant of what is the cause of what? Okay.
By instant, when you say instant, then I understand. When we say that clay is the substantial cause of clay vase, we are not saying that clay in general is a substantial cause of a clay vase. We are saying that the clay which was used to make the vase is a substantial cause of a clay vase. Sorry. That’s exactly how I understood it.
But this particular clay of the clay vase is used to make the clay, but you said that substantial cause no longer exists. So it still exists. Because the is is joking. He’s lesson to us. He says, because that clay is empty, you know, when it is turned into a vase, it is no longer clay.
That was. You’re you’re locking up a heap of clay which is turned into a vase. That heap of clay does not exist when the vase exists. Do you understand that? Oh, yes.
Yeah. It’s no longer a heap of clay. It’s no longer a heap of clay. Right? A lump.
Right? Okay. Correct. 100%? So, Geshe-la would like to avoid difficulties, so he’s gonna drop the topic.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Let’s after lunch, you know, we have more time.
You know? So So it is important here to understand carefully what substantial causes are. Otherwise, major doubts will arise. I explained, Kristen, your doubt about the table, which is the same as your doubt about the vase. So after lunch, we will address the issue of consciousness and how the existence of a substantial continuum of consciousness can establish the existence of past and future lives.
So I think we will skip the topic of clay and silver vases, which is not terribly relevant. Just for example. Just an example. Yeah. Okay.
Lunch is ready. You know?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.