Four Noble Truths – 2014-04-19 – KR

1 h 41 min · 3,749 words · 19 April 2014

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths - 2014-04-19 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains that meditation on death and impermanence and on the Four Noble Truths leads to the path of the middling scope, where renunciation arises. He then describes the shift to the great scope through replacing self-cherishing with cherishing others, and teaches giving and taking (tonglen) as the practice for generating love and compassion. Students discuss what makes Buddhist teachings uncommon.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 42m

UUID: cc03a14d-f058-4c36-a0b2-9c0a04906485

Date: 2014-04-19

Words: 3,745

Could you do me? Mhmm. You probably have already generated the motivation this morning at 09:00 when you assembled, but we will briefly for a couple seconds or minutes regenerate a motivation reflecting on death and impermanence. The purpose of meditation on death and impermanence is to foster the intention to practice the vast waves of virtue which are necessary for one striving for his or her welfare in future lives, not next year, not next month, not next week, but today. In other words, to cease to procrastinate.

In brief, therefore, the purpose of meditation and death and impermanence is to rapidly engage in the practice of virtue and the abandonment of non virtue and not to defer it out of a sense of forlornness. A couple of seconds. One says that one should meditate, and it is very important to understand clearly what is meant by meditation. There are numerous forms of meditation, broadly speaking, subdivided into concentration meditation and analytical meditation. However, the holy teacher, Khyentse Rinpoche, when he instructed his students over and again said, you must meditate.

In saying this, he hit the crux of the topic. We mentioned yesterday the transition from the practice of the being of the small to that of the middling scope. And indeed, it does rest on an understanding of the four noble truths. As is said in Dharmakirti’s Pramanavarttika, from the four noble truths and impermanence to suffering and from suffering to the realization of selflessness. This stanza is very profound.

The first line from the four noble truths and impermanence to suffering refers to an understanding of the nature of our aggregates, which are contaminated and of the nature of suffering. Now what is very interesting in this stanza is the emphasis on meditation on death and impermanence. One does not meditate on the death and the impermanence of for instance this building, there would be no meaning and no point, and it intimates through not having to meditate on the death and impermanence of this building that one should meditate on the death and the impermanence of something else. What is this something else? It is ourselves.

Then this meditation on the death and the impermanence of one’s own self, of one’s five aggregates, leads eventually to an understanding of the transitory composite, which is animated by karma and affliction. Then one meditates therefore on the death and the impermanence of entities endowed with a mind and not on the death and the impermanence of inanimate entities. Entities endowed with a mind, if they are impermanent, necessarily arise in dependence on causes and conditions, but other causes and conditions which are posited. The cause of a sentient being is its substantial continuum. The conditions of that sentient being are its karma and causality.

Then what determines the time of our own death is precisely our own karma and and afflictions. It is contingent on the karma and afflictions whether or not we die earlier or later. What precisely is karma and klesha connected to? Karma and klesha are connected to ignorance, which has been explained many times, is a mistaken state of mind which misapprehends what does not truly exist from its own side as truly existing from its own side. Independence on this ignorance, the cycles of the 12 limbs are initiated.

So from ignorance arises compositional factors, karma and so forth. It’s a very powerful way of thinking, isn’t it? And this is why it is said in the Dharmakirti’s Pramanavarttika, the contaminated aggregates transmigrating in a samsara of suffering. The understanding which is presented here is that of ignorance giving rise to karma and klesha, karma and the afflictions, which in turn give rise to these aggregates, who therefore are unsuitable and unworthy since they arise from karma and afflictions. This is why Je Tsongkhapa says in these three principles of the path through reflecting over and again on the fact that karma is incontrovertible, counter the attraction to future existences.

Then death and impermanence arise from karma and causality which themselves are rooted in karma. Moving in the opposite direction, karma and causality give rise to these contaminated aggregates, which because of their origin are 40. When one sees the defects of these contaminated aggregates, unavoidably the mind wishing to be freed from samsaric existence arises. Then one is truly a being of the middling scope. Then the uncommon intended teaching, the uncommon intended dharma of the Buddha begins with the path of the being of the middling scope since it is during the path of the middling scope that the view is introduced.

Do you understand? Therefore, the path of the middling scope is the intended teaching, the beginning of the specific teachings of Buddha Shakyamuni, precisely because it encounters the view. An alternate way of thinking about these is to think that the path of the being of this small scope is the foundation of all three scopes. The path of the being of the middling scope is the intended purported specific teaching of Buddha Shakyamuni, and the path of the being of the great scope is the uncommon teaching of Buddha Shakyamuni. And therefore this is why I asked you yesterday what was the mode of proceeding from the path of the being of the small to the path of the being of the middling scope.

So if you understand that the path of the being of the middling scope is the specific intended teaching of the Buddha which differentiates Buddha’s teachings from that of the other dharmas prevalent in India at the period, you will understand how to operate this transition. And we should try to meditate on this for a couple of minutes. It will be very helpful. Then if you have studied somewhat, it is extraordinarily beneficial to engage in these meditations based on an understanding of the 12 limbs of dependent arising and their connection with the Four Noble Truths, and after a couple seconds of such meditation, we should engage in a discussion. So the uncommon teachings of the Buddha begin with the path of the being of the middling scope.

Have you understood this? And if so, what have you understood? I understood that the uncommon teachings were with a great scope not the middling scope as was just said so could we clarify which? Geshe wants answers from you, but. Denis, what Geshe-la is asking you is, have you understood, that the path of the being of the middling scope are the uncommon teachings of the Buddha?

And if you have, what precisely does that mean? I understand it’s where we first have the four noble truths and the Buddha deliberately taught the cause, the cause of suffering first. Because if we don’t realize that these contaminated aggregates do not lead to stable happiness but they lead to suffering, then we won’t look for a way to get out of it. And I think that begins in the being of middling scope, because then we start looking once we realize the cause, then we look for a way to get out permanently of the cycle of existence. My understanding is that the first noble truth is understanding that they’re suffering and that’s in common with most of the other traditions that exist in India.

So at the time there would have been many Vedic traditions which would have sought to aim for higher rebirth as a god. Therefore, the Buddhist teachings are uncommon because they seek to understand the very nature of suffering and to end that suffering. So to end cyclic existence which the other traditions of the time didn’t seek to exceed, they aimed for higher rebirth at the most as a god. Then the Buddha’s teachings aimed to exceed that by understanding that you can end complete cyclic existence and therefore it’s uncommon. As it is, our minds are deeply afflicted and the goal of the small scope is to subdue the mind and direct it towards the intended teaching and the intended teaching is uncommon in that it asserts non existence of a self whereas all other traditions assert a self.

What arose for me is that only by practising virtue and generosity can one enter the middle path. So we’ve experienced suffering and we’ve had realisations around suffering but then only by virtue can we enter the middle path. You do remember Geshela’s question. Right? So there are uncommon features of the Buddhist teachings.

They you might want to write this down actually, you know, because the questions are all over, there are uncommon features of the Buddhist teachings, these uncommon features appear during the path of the being of the middling scope. What are they, and why do they differentiate them from the other traditions? Perhaps the Four Noble Truths are the middle scope. There are to my knowledge no other religions or philosophies that teach the correct Four Noble Truths. There are other philosophies that have a different cause of suffering and so on.

But I feel the Four Noble Truths are the middle scope, they’re not part of the uncommon teaching of the great scope but they’re part of the middle scope. At the core is ignorance and the afflictions of desire and hatred and other negative afflictions. And these propel us through countless rebirths. Overriding this we are basically surrounded by death constantly and we’re either going from we’re just going from one rebirth to the next. And so and this is the background to what I’m saying.

So to go from there the uncommon teachings of the Buddha, the teachings on emptiness and bodhichitta and those are the teachings that help us transcend or get out of samsara which is ruled by the Lord of Death. The uncommon aspect of the teachings is the view realizing emptiness that cuts ignorance at the root which is the equivalent of the cessation of suffering in the four noble truths the practice of the being of the middling scope is the path to cessation of suffering which is within the four noble truths and that links in with the 12 links of dependent origination. I think the other schools taught the lower scope taught the selfness of phenomena but not the selfness of the self. I think that was the major difference. Could you speak louder?

I couldn’t hear. I’m sorry. Okay. I think the the lower scope schools taught the selfness of phenomena, but not the selflessness of self. You’re speaking of the lower scope schools or the beings of the small scope?

Yes, the beings of the small scope. I don’t know. Since I created the causes for ignorance by not attending Geshela’s presentation and teaching on the cycle of existence last year, year before. I haven’t studied this area. Don’t worry.

No worry. Uncommon feature of the path of the being of the middling scope is something I have actually already taught, and it is that probably it is specific to the Buddhist teachings that the contaminated aggregates we have at present are taught to originate from karma. However, this origination does not stop with karma. Instead, Karma, whether virtuous or non virtuous, arises from an ignorance which misapprehends phenomena which are non truly existent to be truly existent. Does this ignorance which gives rise to both virtuous and non virtuous contaminated karma?

The origin of this contaminated karma is the ignorance which misapprehends phenomena which are non truly existent as truly existent. This is the Buddhist specificity, the unicity of Buddhism. None of the other religious traditions teach this. As a result, they are unable to account clearly for karmic operativeness. Then this process of generation of cyclic existence from ignorance is described within the 12 limbs of dependent arising.

At present, we must address the transition from the path of the being of the middling scope to the path of the being of the great scope. The path of the being of the middling scope has been actualized when renunciation or definite emergence which is uncontrived and arises even in the dream state is present, a steady spontaneous wish to be freed from cyclic existence. Then once renunciation has been generated in a fully characterized fashion, one must effect the transition to the great vehicle. What is the mode of transition from the middling to the great vehicle? Then we are all aware of the fact that because of the self cherishing with which we view our contaminated aggregates, unpleasant states of mind such as jealousy, competitiveness, and anger arise.

Then we must examine to find what self cherishing arises from. Self cherishing arises from self grasping, there is somewhat of a similarity between them. At this point, the hearers and the solitary realizers, the Shravakas and the Pratyekabuddhas focus on the elimination of self grasping. Then it is at the level of self cherishing that the differentiation between the lower and the greater vehicle occurs. The hearer and solitary realizer, Arhats, in other words, the Shravaka and Pratyekabuddha Arhats, out of self cherishing, wish for a liberation for themselves without any consideration for others whom they discard.

Such a viewpoint, to be frank, is not that different from the rest of us all the way down to animals who focus on their own happiness, eating their fill and drinking their fill. If one thinks about it somewhat carefully, this is a little bit odd. Then let me give you an example, think about it a bit. If you are surrounded by a large number of people who are dying of thirst, and you yourself in your house with air conditioning drink quietly a cool juice while looking at the people dying of thirst out of the house. Is that strange or not?

Imagine being surrounded by people who are so thirsty that they cannot swallow their own saliva, and for someone to stay in their house or their domain drinking cool juices with the air conditioning on, what would we say of such a person? Not a very nice person. Right? It’s pleasant, isn’t it, to drink a cool juice like that? And if you think of all the others who are dying of thirst, you feel shame, don’t you?

But if you don’t, it’s very pleasant. That’s the way it is. As our holy teacher, Khyentse Rinpoche said, this is the difference between the practitioners of the small and the great scope of the Hinayana and the Mahayana. The Hinayana practitioner is focused on his or her own happiness and considers that of others broadly speaking irrelevant. The Mahayana practitioner is focused on the happiness of all beings.

There is a difference in the breadth of the view. Then if one thinks about it in these terms, the great vehicle teachings are more vast, they are more profound, they are associated with vast waves of blessing, and when one reflects about it about it in this way, become much more literally more tasteful, more inspiring. And therefore, is the difference between the Hinayana and the Mahayana. The hearers and solitary realizers, realizing that the source of self cherishing is self grasping, focus on the elimination of self self grasping without any particular interest in the elimination of self cherishing. They are therefore akin to someone who enjoys a cool drink while others around him are dying of thirst.

The Mahayana practitioner on the other hand understands that all the suffering he or she has experienced since the beginning of psychic existence is precisely due to disregarding and discarding others, and focuses on the elimination of self cherishing. And we can see this type of self cherishing behavior in people who hoard belongings and cherish their houses as a protection above everything else. Shantideva in his Bodhisattvacharyavatara points out that vile self cherishing is our foremost enemy. Nonetheless, it appears to us as our best friend, enticing us through sweet words and so forth. As I said, that one who harms me and who is my foe appears as my best friend.

And therefore, our foremost foe is self cherishing whose force we should understand through numerous lines of reasoning. As is said in the Seven-Point Mind Training, hold one guilty for everything. The one held guilty for everything is self cherishing. As I said in the Guru Puja, through understanding that this literally this epidemic is the root of all suffering, bless me to take the take revenge on self grasping guilty of all. In the context of this stanza, self grasping probably refers to self cherishing.

And as is said further on in the Guru Pooja, through understanding that mother sentient beings are the source of all qualities, bless me to cherish them. It is this process of transition from self cherishing, in other words, egoism, to cherishing others, in other words, altruism, which we should train in. And it is precisely because all of the qualities of the grounds and the paths of the Mahayana arise in dependence on sentient beings that one must recollect their kindness. As is said, the kindness of sentient beings towards us is even greater than that of the Buddhas since it is independence on them that we gain all realizations. In our own case, our practice is almost inverted in this respect.

We make offerings to the Buddhas, but we put no effort in helping other sentient beings. Through numerous reasonings of this type, we can understand that it is through cherishing others, in other words, altruism, that we can attain all of the grounds and paths of the Mahayana. This is why it is said in the sevenfold stanzas of mind training, meditate on the kindness of all. All here refers to all sentient beings. In other words, all beings who at various times have been our parents throughout psychic existence.

And once one has reflected on this over again, whomsoever one meets among these seven or so billion human beings on this earth, one will feel affectionate love for. And then whomsoever one meets, one will feel an affectionate love, an affection, in other words, comparable to that for one’s own parents. At this point, one will have realized the equalization of self and others. Then in this context, we are explaining the generation of bodhichitta by means of the equalization and interchange of self and others. When affectionate love has arisen by this means, this encompasses the practice of the three first stages of the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhichitta, In other words, recollecting the kindness of mother sentient beings, first recognizing mother sentient beings as mother sentient beings, secondly recollecting their kindness, and thirdly wishing to repay this kindness.

Once such an affectionate love arises spontaneously, at this point, one should engage in the practice of giving and taking of tonglen. And the goal of tongle is the generation of great compassion in bodhichitta. This is a risk of you all being sound asleep by now. So at this point, one makes giving and taking the essence of one’s practice. One literally sets it on a lotus.

And initially, one engages in taking. If one is a practitioner of dull acumen, of small capacity in other words, then in the morning when one wakes up, one imagines that one absorbs through one’s breath all the suffering one will encounter oneself in the evening and that it impacts and destroys the self cherishing at our heart. Then at present when we engage in the practice of taking, it is contrived and forced. But once we have generated true affectionate love for others, then just as a parent when he or she sees sees his or her child suffering has a spontaneous wish to take upon himself the suffering of the child, likewise we would have a spontaneous powerful wish to take within ourselves the suffering of others. And therefore, when one visualizes oneself taking upon oneself the suffering of all beings, one trains in compassion, whether it is possible in actuality to take upon oneself the suffering of all beings is another question, but one visualizes this, and then after this one trains in love, and for this one visualizes that with one’s breath as one exhales, one gives everything one owns, one’s possessions, one’s wealth, one’s house, one’s body, one’s roots of virtue to other sentient beings.

Then there are numerous verses regarding the practice of giving and taking in Nagarjuna’s Ratnavali, Shantideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara and the Lama Chöpa, I will not quote them all here. You might wonder for yourself whether such a practice, especially the practice of giving what one owns to other is possible in reality. It is definitely possible in reality, and we have an example in recent history in Tibet, where it is certain that the more than 100 Tibetans who sacrificed themselves, who immolated themselves by fire, practiced this equalization of self and others. This practice is very similar to tonglen since one is taking upon oneself inconceivable suffering, insupportable suffering, the suffering of burning alive, and one is giving one’s body up for the sake of Tibet and of the world. Then one must generate the inner strength to engage in this type of activities, which obviously at present we don’t have.

The moment we start thinking about something like this, we go all wobbly. And then once this practice of giving and taking is fully engaged in, then fully characterized love and compassion will have been generated. And as is said in the Seven-Point Mind Training, engage in the appropriate verbal behavior on the path. In this context, this refers to practice during the periods between the meditative sessions, where one engages in recitation such as a recitation of the famous stanza of the Guru Puja. Bless me to take upon myself all of the sufferings and travails of sentient beings and to give them my roots of virtue and happiness without exception.

Here, stop today. Are you tired? Little bit? And it’s difficult when one has to teach these topics on giving and taking because we don’t really practice them, do we? But even though we haven’t generated them, if we focus on the meditation, on the object of meditation, then through habituation it will arise.

If we could try and keep please keep the talking to outside so that if people want to be quiet in the Gompa. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

chulen
Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top