1 h 25 min · 3,683 words · 24 June 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher reviews the path of the small scope, explaining that grasping at permanence and attachment to this life’s pleasures obstruct mental happiness from the Lamrim. He teaches meditation on death and impermanence as the main antidote, and discusses turning away from the vanities of this life toward future lives. The talk ends with questions on the 10 non-virtues, desire, and happiness.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 25m
UUID: 7a8c0198-06b0-4205-b1ee-200b0a6ad398
Date: 2015-06-24
Words: 3,679
So it has been, one month or so, during which, we have not received Lamrim teachings. And during this period, we were busy doing other things. So it is quite possible that the topics have slipped a bit from our minds. Therefore, I would like to reenter into these topics by covering again shortly the foundations such as the path of the being of the small scope. So when we refer at the beginning of the teachings to generating the motivation, in Tibetan.
This is only necessary if our mind is not dwelling at that point in a virtuous state. If it is already dwelling in a virtuous state, it is unnecessary. Only necessary if the mind is in a state of affliction. So if one’s mind has not fallen under the sway of the afflictions, it is unnecessary to generate any particular motivation. One just remains in that state.
Then in this context, when we refer to generating the motivation, this is said in context or in reference to the person or the trainee. This person or this trainee is a beginner. This is often why the statement generate the motivation sounds so odd, so strange. So the term in Tibetan means to make, to do. Then is uncontrived.
Is contrived. So we want to initially generate a contrived motivation. And this is difficult for us. When we get up in the morning, we get up preoccupied with food and clothing. So to focus our mind on anything virtuous is difficult.
And then, much of our day is focused on our family or our children if we have children again, generating something virtuous in the mind is difficult. For this reason, we are told to generate a virtuous motivation. To focus one’s mind during an hour or an hour and a half on teach ings such as this one to bring one’s mind in a virtuous direction in a world of incredible busyness in a major city like this one, this is very difficult indeed. If one’s mind is dwelling in a virtuous state, there is nothing in particular to do. If on the other hand, it is not, then one should generate a virtuous motivation.
When we say to generate a motivation, this doesn’t mean to just sink into some sort of torpor. Instead, we have to find a method, a means to generate the wanted motivation. It does not have to be any one specific motivation. There is a variety of motivations for a variety of persons. Whatever deed a living being, in other words a person engages in, that person engages in those deeds for the sake of happiness.
It is therefore critically important to identify what happiness is. Happiness in Tibetan is the key. The first syllable or bliss is subdivided into two, physical and mental bliss or happiness. And it is important to be able to differentiate these two without mixing them together. In this life, all of the deeds which we engage in, we engage in for our physical happiness.
When we refer to physical happiness, we refer to the happiness which is a sensation of the visual sense, a happy sensation of the auditory sense, of the olfactory, of the gustatory, and of the tactile sense. This is something everyone in this room knows. For instance, tactile bliss, tactile sensation is extremely important, isn’t it? Then I would like to begin by saying that the Lamrim has no relation whatsoever to happiness of the five senses, none whatsoever. And yet this is what we are obsessed with.
This is something I cannot talk about, something I do not know to talk about, and something I will not talk about. Now when, we see a pleasing object with the visual consciousness, a sensation of happiness is induced in the visual consciousness. And in dependence on the sensation of happiness in the visual consciousness, a fleeting sensation of happiness arises in the mental consciousness. This is true. But this sensation of happiness in the mental consciousness is not stable.
It is not stable because the happiness in the visual consciousness depends on an exterior object and is itself unstable and transitory. Do you understand? Really? That’s good. Now in the context of Lamrim, the happinesses which we wish to generate are, those which arrive from the activities of hearing, the activities of thinking, and the activities of meditation.
Happiness arisen from these three is definitely mental happiness. For this happiness which arises through hearing the Lamrim to occur is difficult for us because were it to occur, it would mean we have understood something of the essence of the heart of the Lamrim. Mhmm. Now in the context of the path of the being of the small scope, what acts as an obstacle to this happiness which arises from the Lamrim? None other than grasping at permanence and specifically the afflictions which are induced by grasping at permanence act as an obstacle to giving rise to the happiness arisen from the Lamrim in the context of the path of the being of the small scope.
What do we mean here by grasping at permanence? We mean grasp a grasping at permanence which sees ourselves as permanent. It is when we fall under the sway of this that the afflictions induced by this arise. What is this grasping at our own permanence? It is clear to everyone in this room that none of us here can say with 100% certainty, tomorrow, I will still be of the living.
Nor can we say, in a year or so, I will still be of the living. Yet, because of the grasping at permanence within our minds, we behave as if it was definite that tomorrow we would still be of the living, that in one week, one month, one year, we would still be of the living. So let us think carefully. Is there any sound reason which enables us to conclude that it is 100% certain, definite, that tomorrow we will be among the living. There is no reason which enables us to conclude this.
And yet, we are convinced that we will be among the living tomorrow, not convinced by one mind, but by numerous minds. And we see that those who have reached 20 years of age are totally convinced that they will live until 40. Those who have lived 40 years of age are convinced they shall live until 60. Those who have reached 60 are sure they will make it to 70, and at 70, they are definite, they will reach 80. By the time they reach 100, they believe they will reach 200.
This is the arrogance of beings like us who are part of the realm of desire and who are insatiable. It’s characteristic of the realm of desire. And all of us are convinced that we live a long time, thanks to our health in the gym. But this has nothing to do with reality. We lead a long life due to the potency, from previous karma which has impelled this life.
When that potency ceases, we die. Then ideally, we should combine that potency with a well maintained health and then it is definitely will stay a long time. Under this way of grasping at permanence, are convinced that we will lead an extremely long life. Convinced of this in turn, we start trying to accumulate all the food, the clothing, the garb, the bedding, the houses, the cars, the money, which we need for such a long life, and in dependence on this, in turn afflictions arise. Then it is perfectly appropriate to accumulate what you need until your hopeful lifespan of 90 or 100.
But what we see is that people accumulate vast amounts in excess of that which they have no possibility to ever use. Under the sway of grasping at one’s own permanence, in turn, the afflictions arise and these cause us to be extraordinarily small, petty, and narrow minded, focused exclusively on the happiness which visual or objects auditory objects and as with sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations can induce. So it is not the houses, the cars, and the possessions, which are the cause of the afflictions, the great craving and desire within our mind stream for these objects. Instead, it is precisely grasping at our own permanence within our own mind stream, which is a cause of this lust and this craving. Its antidote is meditation on death and impermanence.
And therefore, the foremost means to counter this powerful grasping at one’s own permanence is repeated meditation on death and impermanence. So, the way therefore to counter this craving for the five sense objects, sights, sounds, smells, tastes and tactile sensations, is through repeated meditation on death and impermanence. So that we reach the point where however vast the offerings which are made to us, no desire whatsoever arises within our mind when this is done. At this point in keeping with Je Tsongkhapa three principles of the path in which it is said, so reflecting on the fact that leisure and opportunity are scarce and fleeting, turn away from the vanities of this life, we will have turned away from the vanities of this life. Once one has countered attachment to the enjoyments of this life, one will turn towards future lives and strive from between the two possible future rebirths, happy and unhappy future rebirths for a happy rebirth.
And specifically, through taking refuge and through meditating on causality, one will strive for a special rebirth of leisure and endowment. Generally speaking, within the seven topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope, the three first connected with a rebirth of leisure and endowment. In other words, identifying a rebirth of leisure endowment and endowment, reflecting on its great meaning and reflecting on its rarity are shared with the paths of all being beings of the three scopes. There are four cycles of meditation, which are specific to the path of the being of the small scope. They are meditation on death and impermanence, meditation on meditation on death and impermanence on the suffering of the lower realms, taking refuge, and on causality.
Once one has meditated on these topics of the being of the small scope, if one is not ready to relinquish engaging in an ethics of the abandonment of the non virtues and relinquishing performing any of the non virtues even at the cost of one’s own life, then one would not have gained the realizations of the being of the small scope. Then how should one proceed? One should focus on happiness in future lives, but it is very difficult to do this at the expense of happiness in this life, and therefore one should strive for excellent happiness, which is not only happiness in this life, but also happiness in future lives. So how should one proceed? One should find the right measure.
For instance, one needs a house, but one’s house should neither be too big because it is unmanageable nor too small because it is insufficient for us. Just the right size. Likewise, in Australia, we need cars. Cars are the equivalent of our shoes. But one’s car should not be too big nor too small.
And therefore, if we take a car, the car should be of a convenient size, neither too big nor too small. In that way, will use it, and in that way, our mind will be content with it. So instead of investing ourselves totally in physical happiness the way we do, we should reflect on mental happiness and try to focus on mental happiness. At present, many of us literally prostrate at the feet of physical happiness. It is not the case that our body is unimportant.
As Śāntideva says, you shall get it this one time, Therefore, put it to good use. However, our body is the mount of our mind, and therefore, we should use our body to give our mind the opportunities it requires and to enable our mind to develop higher and higher. Then eventually when the mind is led to its full completion, but this is something which is far removed for us and therefore let us focus on the here and now. Then from within the twin subdivision of physical and mental happiness, we should focus on mental happiness and within mental happiness, the mental happiness which has arisen from the Lamrim. Anyway.
Anyway, what we should do is use the Lamrim as a means to give advice to our own mind. Now, I mentioned grasping at permanence. Within the context of the path of the being of the small scope, there are numerous individual objects of abandonment. But the foremost, the main one is grasping at one’s permanence which apprehends the permanence of oneself. And the way to counter this this is none other than meditation on death and impermanence.
Let us therefore generate such a motivation for a couple of minutes. So as is said, through countering the vanities of this life, one is a practitioner of the small scope and through countering attachment to all lives, one becomes a practitioner of the middling scope. Within the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope, there are four which are specific to the being of the small scope. These are meditation on death and impermanence, on the sufferings of the lower realms, on refuge, and on causality. However, the question is, which among these acts as specifically as a counter to the vanities of this life?
And more importantly, what is the boundary before the next step. So this is important because while for the being of the middling scope. It is said that it is countering the vanities of all lives, which generates the mind striving for liberation. For the being of the small scope, it is countering the vanities of this life, which leads to relinquishing this life and focusing on future lives. So the question is what precisely among the four topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope is the foremost counter to attachment of this life, to this life.
These three principles of the path intimates that it is the inseparable meditation on the importance, rarity and of this rebirth of leisure and endowment and on death and impermanence which counters attachment to this life. I personally feel that it is taking meditation on death and impermanence as a principle meditation with meditation on the suffering of the lower realms as a subsidiary meditation. It seems to me that it is taking meditation on death and impermanence as the foremost practice with meditation on the suffering of the lower realms as subsidiary, which acts as the antidote to attachment to the vanities of this life. Since by the time we reach the following two topics of meditation, which are refuge and causality, it is clear that the focus on future lives must be present. Therefore, relinquishing attachment to the vanities of this life must have occurred before this.
Then this is something we have to find out for ourselves in the context of our own meditation to find which topic of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope is the specific antidote to attachment to the vanities of this life. Once one has countered attachment to the vanities of this life, and by vanities of this life, one means the aspects of this life. In other words, exterior physical objects. At this point, the mind which is focused on exterior physical objects will turn inwards and will no longer be distracted by exterior physical objects. So once the mind is no longer focused on exterior physical objects and has relinquished the vanities of this life, It has begun to turn inwards and at this point, one can focus on those mental states which arise in dependence on the minds having focused on exterior objects.
In other words, the afflictions. Trying to subdue the afflictions, one will enter in the path of the being of the middling scope. So we shall stop here. Otherwise, as there is a lot to cover, we will become tired. And at present, if you have good questions, I will take a couple questions.
Please, we would like concise and clear questions. Please hold the microphone to your when you please hold the microphone to your chin. Geshe-la, should we try to dispel the 10 non virtues before practicing the middle scope? Should we try to what, the 10 non virtues? Dispel them or gain mastery over them.
So to practice a fully characterized path of the being of the, middling scope, probably one would have to dispel the 10 non virtuous deeds. Whether it was actually possible to abandon the 10 non virtuous deeds at that level is another question altogether. It is far from clear that that will be possible. Also, it is perfectly possible to meditate on topics of the path of the being of the middling scope such as the four noble truths, without having dispelled the 10 non virtuous deeds. Your doubt is a very legitimate one.
You probably wonder, is it possible to study and practice the path of the being of the middling scope without having initially abandoned the 10 non virtues, which are the focus of the path of the being of the small scope. But what one does initially is one studies the totality of the paths or of the beings of the three scopes. And then once one has studied everything, then one begins practicing following the sequence of hearing, thinking, and meditating. Is it person? Yes.
Sound of sometimes, yeah, afraid. Oh. Because because at that time, I was by myself here. But now understand. Yeah.
Yeah. And then you. And question. Think that’s it feels like it’s almost impossible to understand the depths of it. I guess you’ll talk a little bit more about that, the depths of you know, it seems impossible to really understand the depths of desire in our realm.
This is a very private or personal viewpoint. This is the way you look at things. It is not the case for all beings, even in the realm of desire, that desire cannot be countered. I’m not sure that I that was my question. I think my question was that we can sort of say, oh, you know, we need to get rid of desire.
We need to counter desire. But just thinking about it lately, I’ve been thinking that desire is very complex in our realm. And that’s what I was wondering if Geshe-la could speak about that. So all of us in this world wish for happiness. And when I say that in this world, some beings are able to counter desire in reality, I should say human beings are able to counter desire since in the realm of desire, only humans are able to do this.
And this happens through understanding that the physical objects of desire which we strive for are unable to satisfy us. We are profoundly intimately convinced that these objects can provide the measureless, the infinite satisfaction we strive for, and yet this is impossible. Once we understand this, then by itself desire will dwindle. But this is not something which happens easily. It is not something which happens just through thinking about it.
One must study, one must reflect, and one must meditate. Otherwise, it does not happen. Exactly. Exactly. Then more understand.
More understand. Yes. Hello, everyone. I’m sort of new to, tonight’s sort of readings, but I was just trying to grasp the main concept. And I just wanted to ask Geshe-la to elaborate a bit more on so the way I sort of interpreted was that, yes, a lot of us in Western society see happiness and we’re bombarded with, you know, happiness is a like a physical state.
We get satisfaction with our senses, and there might be products, all those things of desire. Yet so if we are to then look at happiness from a mental state is and I understand the process, yes, we need to meditate so we maybe detach ourselves from that physical thinking. But is there a process that we can look at as far as looking at compassion and finding happiness from maybe serving others, finding forgiveness even in ourselves and our desires to help us achieve that. So I wanted to explore that with Geshe-la, if that’s okay. What you say is most definitely true.
Tonight, we were presenting the foundations of the teaching, which is the path of the being of the small scope. What you are referring to is the path of the being of the great scope, the Mahāyāna. But the foundation of the path of the being of the great scope is first the path of the being of the small scope, in in other words, turning away from the vanities of this life, then the path of the being of the middling of scope, turning away from the vanities of all lives, and then one enters the Mahāyāna. So the authentic realizations of the path of the being of the great scope, as Śāntideva says, are extraordinary. What greater is there than this uncontrived realization of bodhicitta?
Yeah. And then another question, please. No more time. Just five minutes. Can I ask a second question?
Alright. It’s not problem. When you I just wanted to clarify. When you talked about the vanities of this life, did Geshe-la say that they are that it that they are exterior physical objects? Not exactly.
The five physical objects, sights, sounds, smells, tastes and tactile sensations are that which is desired by the mind. It is that the desire which is the vanities of this life. And turning away from these objects leads to an interiorization of the mind. Well, we shall stop here for tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do we need to abandon the ten nonvirtues before practicing the path of the being of the middling scope?
To practice a fully characterized path of the middling scope, one would probably have to dispel the ten nonvirtuous deeds. Whether it is actually possible to abandon them at that level is another question, and it is far from clear that it will be possible. It is also perfectly possible to meditate on middling-scope topics, such as the four noble truths, without having dispelled the ten nonvirtues. The doubt is a legitimate one. Initially, one studies the totality of the paths of the beings of all three scopes. Once everything has been studied, one begins practicing in the sequence of hearing, thinking and meditating.
Are the vanities of this life the exterior physical objects themselves?
Not exactly. The five physical objects (sights, sounds, smells, tastes and tactile sensations) are what the mind desires. It is the desire itself that is the vanities of this life, not the objects. Turning away from these objects leads to an interiorization of the mind.