Rinpoche’s Story – 2018-05-01 – 20180501Lineage – KR

1 h 35 min · 3,853 words · 1 May 2018

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story - 2018-05-01 - 20180501Lineage - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaching on Buddha lineage (gotra) and the presentations of lineage in the Vaibhashika, Sautrantika and Cittamatra tenet schools, focusing on why the lower schools speak of arya lineage and the three final vehicles. Covers the Vinaya sutra verses on contentment and the three characteristics of naturally abiding lineage in Cittamatra. The second part discusses the meaning of sentient being versus living being, with questions from students.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 36m

UUID: 426f9a9f-e355-4b74-8ec7-aa0314227b06

Date: 2018-05-01

Words: 3,849

So we will start today with the topic of Buddha lineage or more generally lineage, sometimes called Buddha nature in English. And this topic of lineage has four different presentations in keeping with the four different schools of tenets by Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra and Mādhyamika. So here, when one refers to Buddha lineage, Buddha Gothra in Sanskrit, this is something which refers to a future state, a development. Now in ordinary worldly affairs, when we speak for instance of the lineage of a king, this refers to someone who is of kingly origin. Lineage of an animal, this is an animal.

Lineage of a human being, a human being. The three lower schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra do not use the term Buddha lineage. They refer to ārya lineage. It is only at the level of Mādhyamika that the term Buddha lineage is referred to. Geshe-la will explain later the reason for which these three lower schools only refer to ārya lineage.

So Geshe-la had thought that he would initially explain the concept in the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika schools and then as best as possible explain this concept in Cittamātra and Mādhyamika. Mhmm. So the meaning of lineage or the explanation of lineage in Vaibhāṣika is as given in your handout. I hope you all have it. I’m supposed to print this out for today.

That virtuous nondesirous mental factor of the continuum of sentient beings which is a substantial cause of the realizations of an ārya which are its result. Have you received them? So I sent them yesterday or before yesterday. Well, then so we’ve changed the system because there’s a lot of problems with the handouts which are unpaid and everything. So basically from now on, they’ll be emailed to you and you have to print them out yourselves.

It reduces the burden on the center of the financial loss. So this is the definition as given in general explanation of the perfections. So I will repeat the definition slowly so you can take it down. That virtuous, non desirous mental factor of the continuum of sentient beings, which is the substantial cause of the realizations of an ārya which are its result. Alright.

Have we done? So I repeat rapidly that virtuous non desirous mental factor of the continuum of sentient beings, which is the substantial cause of the realizations of an ārya which are its result. Alright. Actually, in Vaibhāṣika, this is a definition of ārya lineage. So the lineage of an ārya, and not the definition of the lineage of a Buddha.

Now in this definition, the results are the realizations of an ārya. The realizations of an ārya here refer to the path of an ārya being. And in the beginning of the definition, the terms non desirous mental factor refer to the mental factor of contentment. So now in your opinion, in the definition which Geshe-la gave of lineage in Vaibhāṣika, that virtuous, non desirous mental factor of the continuum of sentient beings, which is a substantial cause of the realizations of an ārya, which are its result, why does the definition say which is a substantial causes of the realization of an ārya and does not say which are the substantial causes of the realizations of a Buddha? Why is the term ārya used for Vaibhāṣikas?

In your opinion. Vaibhāṣika being a lower vehicle only does not attain full enlightenment of a Buddha. They attain the enlightenment of arhathood. And other Other answers? Because you’re only seeking liberation or enlightenment for themselves and not for the benefit of all sentient beings.

You said is good because indeed the Hīnayāna schools do not recognize the perfection of wisdom Sutras and the Mahāyāna Sutras in general as Sutras, therefore, as utterances of the Buddha. So generally speaking they recognize the utterances of the Buddha but they do not recognize the Mahāyāna Sutras. So Geshe-la can see from the way you are thinking that you have been studying and things are starting to take. It’s a little clearer in my head. It’s not perfect.

But the contentment which is an abandonment of the thirst for objects of desire can only act as a cause for the realizations of an ārya being. But cannot act as a cause for the realizations of a Buddha. Okay. So please do not be confused, Geshe-la. I noticed in all your answers that you seem to assume that Vaibashikas are necessarily lower vehicle practitioners.

This is false. Someone who is a propounder of Vaibhāṣika tenets is a propounder of lower vehicle tenets. That does not mean that that person is necessarily a lower vehicle being. There are bodhisattvas who are propounders of lower vehicle So as you remember, Geshe-la drilled you extensively on the moves, logical possibilities last year. And there are four moves or four logical possibilities between Hīnayāna beings and propounders of Hīnayāna tenets.

There are beings who are both Hīnayāna beings, in other words Hīnayāna by motivation and propounders of Hīnayāna tenets. There are those who are Hīnayāna beings but not propounders of Hīnayāna tenets. There are those who are propounders of Hīnayāna tenets but not Hīnayāna beings and there are neither. Then the same thing is true about Mahāyāna beings and Mahāyāna propounders of tenets. There are four logical possibilities.

So Geshe-la suspects you understand. So the reason for which to answer Geshe-la’s question to you, the term Buddha is not used in the definition, but ārya is because Vaibhāṣika asserts three final vehicles. Therefore, for Vaibhāṣika, not all beings necessarily have the Buddha lineage. That is the answer. Do you understand?

Do you get it? You understand what three final vehicles means? No. Sorry. I don’t.

So the meaning of three final vehicles is as follows. If we take for instance a hearer Arhat, then a hearer Arhat has attained the state of hearer arhathood and will never ever enter the Mahāyāna. Upon the death of that hearer Arhat, his mental continuum is severed, ceases to exist. The same thing is true for Pratyeka, Pratyeka Buddha, that is the meaning of three final vehicles. Do you understand?

So there’s oh, we get got two vehicles there, the hearer Arhat and the Pratyeka Buddha. What’s the other one? So what therefore one should say in answer to Geshe-la’s question is, Vaibhāṣikas do not accept that all sentient beings have the Buddha lineage or the Buddha nature because the hearer and solitary realizer, experience severance of their mental continuum where they cease to exist at the time of their death. Then, therefore, they never can or will attain full and utter utter enlightenment. Then in Mādhyamika, all sentient beings have the Buddha nature because Mādhyamika does not accept the severance of the continuum.

So this is the definition of ārya lineage. I want you to say ārya nature instead of buddha nature in Vaibhāṣika. And Vaibhāṣika gives a marvelous example of ārya nature in the Vinaya sūtra, which reads as follows. Contentment with poor vestments is the lineage of an ārya. Contentment with bad alms is the lineage of an ārya.

Contentment with mediocre bedding is a lineage of an ārya. Delight in abandonments and meditation is a lineage of an ārya. So in this stanza of the Vinaya sūtra, vestments refers to clothing. Then bedding refers not just to bedding but one sits where one lives and so forth. And alms refer to food, what one eats.

And the term in Tibetan means mediocre, something which is just barely acceptable. Then it is out of lack of contentment that we experience hardship in this world. Contentment is what fosters happiness. Now in this fourfold example of the ārya lineage according to Baibhashika, the first three examples, in other words, contentment with vestments, with alms, and with bedding generates the Aryan lineage indirectly. And the final example in the last verse that joy or delight in abandonments and meditation is the ārya lineage directly generates the ārya lineage.

Then as to the three first examples, contentment with vestments alms and bedding, it is not mere contentment, which is referred to here, but stable, firm contentment. As a result, this necessarily implies that one has obtained the path shared with the being of the small scope. As to the final instance, delight or joy in abandonments and meditation, this implies that one has attained the path of the being of the middling scope and has generated fully characterized definite emergence. So the paths are taught completely within these four verses. So these verses, therefore, teach definite emergence, not just ordinary or mere definite emergence, but fully characterized definite emergence, which is the cause of the attainment of the state of an.

An So we have to include the totality of our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni’s teachings within the Lamrim. Otherwise, it is very very strange if the Lamrim is set on one side and the great treatises, the study of the Paramita, of Pramānavārttika, of Mādhyamika, Vinaya and so forth are set on the other side and they have no relation whatsoever. And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says in his song of realization referring to the Lamrim, the innermost essence of all of the sutras. Now these three first verses in the stanza of the Vinaya sūtra, in other words, contentment regarding vestments, alms, and bedding, refer to practicing contentment with respect to exterior object. So initially, our main desire or lust is a lust for exterior objects.

And as a result of practicing contentment towards these three first topics, in other words, vestments, food, and bedding, in turn, one relinquishes craving for the mind. As to the final verse of this stanza, joy or delight in abandonment and meditation is a lineage of an ārya. It acts as an antidote to grasping both at the mind and at the body. Then you understand clearly that in Vaibhāṣika, according to Vaibhāṣika, the ārya lineage is not present in the mind stream of all sentient beings. It is certainly not present from the beginning in the mind stream of all sentient beings.

It must be developed. And among the many divisions of Vaibhāṣika, the Kashmiri Vaibhāṣikas say that ārya lineage is not present in the mind of all sentient beings, but must be trained in by hearing, thinking, and meditating. Whereas other Vaibhāṣikas say that even though one has not trained in hearing, meditate thinking, and meditating, some sentient beings through habituation in previous lives have the ārya lineage already in this life. In brief, in Vaibhāṣika, the ārya lineage refers to the thought of definite emergence. Once one has generated a stable thought of definite emergence, one has definitely generated the path shared with the being of the small scope.

Now regarding the Buddha lineage lineage in Sautrāntika, there is not a lot. The definition which is given is in your handout. You can please give your names to Mark if you haven’t received the handouts and he will send them to you by email. The potency of the seed of uncontaminated mind of the continuum of sentient beings. This is very similar to the definition in Cittamātra.

Now as to the definition of lineage in Cittamātra, Cittamātra asserts that lineage has three characteristics. And in Cittamātra, the lineage which is referred to is known as rang bzhin gnas rigs, the naturally abiding lineage. Its definition is given as follows. It is the transmission of sentient beings, beginning this continuum from one life to the other, the attainment of thusness, the seed of the uncontaminated mind upon the sixth inner locus, the mental locus. So Geshe-la will now focus on Buddha lineage in Cittamātra during a couple of weeks and therefore we have to try to understand this definition.

So what is therefore the meaning of naturally abiding lineage in Cittamātra? Guiding quick quick. Naturally abiding. Is it that it is always present? So is it the Alaya Vijñāna?

Should I give you the definition just now? Right? Yeah. Yeah. I’d repeat the definition slowly.

Try to take it down in notes. Chitamatrans assert as lineage the transmission of sentient beings beginningless continuum, from one life to the other, the attainment of thusness, the seed of the uncontaminated mind upon the sixth inner locus, the mental locus. Do you know? Do you understand? Just read what you wrote.

We know that it’s written down, right? Transmission of sentient beings beginningless continuum from one life to another. The attainment of thusness, the seed of the uncon uncontaminated mind on the sixth on the locus of the sixth. No. Upon the sixth inner locus, comma, the mental locus.

So this in Cittamātra is asserted to be the naturally abiding lineage. It would be good if you could remember this because we will be covering this material repeatedly. So Cittamātra asserts that the naturally abiding lineage has three characteristics, as Geshe-la said. The first is taught in the first part of the definition. It is transmitted from as a beginningless continuum from one life to the other.

Its second characteristic is the attainment of thusness. This refers to an effortless natural presence within the continuum of sentient beings from the beginning. And the third characteristic of the naturally abiding lineage in Cittamātra is the final part of the definition. It is the seed of the uncontaminated mind upon the sixth inner locus, the mental locus. Now this part of the definition applies only to Cittamātrins asserting six mental six consciousnesses.

The Cittamātrins who assert eight consciousnesses state that it abides in the Alaya Vijñāna. Have you understood these three characteristics? So the last one is the seed of the uncontaminated mind upon the sixth inner locus, the mental locus. So what are these three characteristics? So it’s the transmission of sentient beings beginningless continuum from one life to another or to the other.

The attainment of thusness and the That’s right, the seed of the uncontaminated mind upon the sixth inner locus, the mental locus. Please keep these three characteristics in mind. So Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra are similar in referring to an ārya lineage. This is explicit in Vaibhāṣika and implicit in the definitions in Sautrāntika and Cittamātra the term seed of the uncontaminated mind refers to an ārya lineage on ārya path. So the procedure is similar in Vaibhāṣika.

The reason for which the lineage is said to be the substantial cause of the attainment of an ārya is simply because hearer solitary realizers and hearer and solitary realizer experience the severance of their continuum. So the reason is the same. So do you understand why in Cittamātra reference is made not to Buddha lineage but to ārya lineage? I have done before. Finished.

So as Geshe-la was saying in Vaibhāṣika, reference is made to Buddha lineage. Instead, one refers to ārya lineage. Now, the reason which is given for this, the reason one does not refer to Buddha lineage but to ārya lineage is the same which is applied in Cittamātra. So what is this Because the mental continuum is severed at death. So it is only those beings who have attained the state of an Arhat who at the time of their death experience the severance of their continuum and therefore can never attain the state of Buddha.

Because Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika and Cittamātra all accept three final vehicles. They accept a final hearer vehicle, a final solitary realizer vehicle and a final bodhisattva So the Cittamātra teachings on naturally abiding lineage are found mainly in Asaṇga’s works in the Mahāyāna Sutralankara and the Bodhisattvabhūmi So let us at present generate a good motivation and engage in the recitations. Page one. So there is an important difference between ārya lineage in Vaibhāṣika and in Cittamātra which we have to understand. In Vaibhāṣika, ārya lineage is an attainment which is obtained through study and which acts as a substantial cause for the attainments of an ārya being.

On the other hand, in Cittamātra, ārya lineage, naturally abiding lineage is a lineage which all sentient beings have naturally since beginningless time. So here, one must think carefully on what is meant by the term sentient beings. So in Buddhist scriptures, sentient beings include the beings of the higher and the lower realms. And the higher realms are beings such as ourselves and the divine beings, the gods, and the lower realms are the lower realms. And Buddhist scriptures refer to all sentient beings.

Now what exactly is meant by sentient beings? The Tibetan term means literally with mind. And once we identify that, then we can understand what naturally abiding lineage is. How do you understand the term sentient beings? What does it mean for you?

Because sentient being is like being that got feelings. In that case, what is sensation? What are feelings? So let’s take another case, another example. How do we differentiate sentient beings from matter?

What’s the difference? Buddhist texts are suffused or filled with references to sentient beings left and right, and we just say sentient beings. But what exactly do we mean by a sentient being? A being that has consciousness. I think maybe a sentient being is a mind which has not attained to the path of no more learning or a being with a mind that that is Not attained what?

Attained to the path of no more learning. Path of? Path of no more learning. In other words, know the Buddha. Okay.

And I think I’m. I thought sentient being is also you experience suffering and happiness? We are sentient beings. Yeah. We are sentient beings.

Why? Why are we sentient beings? So when you are in deep sleep, do you have an active mind or not? Not to my knowledge. You wouldn’t be a sentient being at that time.

So the same So now the doubt, very precise doubt, Geshe-la would like to ask you is, what is the difference between a sentient being and a living being? What is the difference between sentience or consciousness and being alive? Is it the same thing or not? We ex as being a sentient being, we experience pleasant by by being a a sentient being, we experience pleasant and unpleasantness. Experiences?

All sentient beings have consciousness but not all sentient beings are living beings. For example a Bardo being you wouldn’t describe as a living being but they have consciousness. So how do you identify life? So how do you identify life? I gave many conferences at CBI on this topic.

Have completely forgotten. Life is something that maintains its internal order. So there’s a lot of food here for analysis between the distinction between conscious or sentient being and living being. I define living beings as something that functions according to type. Functions according to Functions according to its whatever type of living being it is.

Living being or certain being? Being. Being. Being. Literally with life in particular.

So the Tibetan term chain means with living literally. We were saying there are many thermodynamic and electrochemical processes that don’t involve sentience in any way. And the difference between a living being and a sentient being would be that a sentient being is aware that it’s living. So Abhidharma says that life is that which depends either on warmth, in other words, energy or consciousness. So let us therefore reflect on the meaning of sentient being, the meaning of living being, and the difference or not between the two.

Do you have questions today? The central being, just now we talked about, is the consciousness, right? Is Like you can, they got brain to function? Then we ourselves are sentient beings. We have brains, but it’s certainly not the case that all sentient beings have brains.

The definition from Abhidharma about life that which depends on energy seems a bit limited because when I turn the electricity on, put the fan on, the fan depends on energy but I wouldn’t call it a living, whereas a tree I would. So in other words, I just don’t quite get that definition of life. Tree is a living being, a sentient being for you. Okay. So there is.

He is a living beings. Why? They grow. That’s not enough, right? We say that’s alive and then if it’s cut, then we say that’s dead.

It has a life force. What’s the difference with a crystal? Crystals grow. Maybe some would say there’s there’s a line. Every living being have a feeling and can interact with other.

This is sent If it is a living being, right? So are you able to make a difference between conscious beings and living beings or not? Sentient beings and living beings, can you make a difference or not? I was just thinking about the last answer I gave and that it was incorrect because I said it’s aware that it’s alive but obviously when we’re asleep we’re not aware that we’re alive. So I was just thinking now that the difference may well be that a sentient being is the locus of karmic imprints whereas a living being is not.

Geshe-la, if not all sentient beings have brains where their consciousness is residing, the smaller sentient beings like insects that only have nervous systems and then cellular organisms, where is their consciousness? Do fish have brains or not? They have nervous systems but is there an actual brain? Dolphins have brains but they’re not. They’re not fish, they’re mammals But fish.

Fish with skeletons do have nodes that operate but I can’t remember exactly how many types of cells are in them. So Geshe-la was asking about dolphins. I said dolphins have brains, but they’re mammals. They’re not fish. They said, why do they have brains?

I think what Geshe-la is asking is what is there in the environment of the dolphin which makes the brain necessary? Are we still on dolphins? I think to rephrase my earlier question was what is the minimum amount of DNA required for sentience to reside in it? Just one question, please here. Can you pass?

I had a conversation with Jampa Nams quite some time ago about what the Abhidharma thought about the smallest life forms and I think that he said that probably according to Abidharma, the cells need to be at least two in number. What do you think, Geshe-la? Do you think the cell needs to be two in number? For what? In order for it to be a sentient being.

Okay. So we should stop here for today. Thank you. So this went very well. If you can formulate the distinction between life and consciousness, you will be able to formulate the distinction between a living being and a conscious being or a sentient being.

Geshe-la knows of cases of people who are mentally dead and yet physically alive. That these are living being, but these are not sentient or conscious beings. So for such a person, that person is alive, but the consciousness has ceased. He’s gone. Okay.

Mhmm. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top