Rinpoche’s Story

1 h 50 min · 4,209 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 111-minute teaching, Ilia S. Durovic explores the philosophical foundations of Buddhist liberation through the lens of dependent origination and the three doors of liberation. He begins with the critical mental foundation for receiving teachings: cultivating bodhicitta, the wish to benefit all beings. He then works through the Buddhist concept of emptiness using vivid examples—a seed growing into a sprout and crop; a chariot examined part by part; chariots, people, and tables understood as mere nominal imputations. The core focus is the four criteria that validate whether a conventional phenomenon truly exists: valid establishment of the basis of imputation, recognition by ordinary consciousness, non-contradiction with valid cognition, and non-harm from ultimate analysis. Durovic illustrates these criteria with stories of appointment (a monk chosen as chant master, a candidate elected prime minister) and reflects on how names and conceptual designation confer reality on things. He closes by encouraging students to engage actively with the material through doubt, questioning, and peer discussion, with the hope that Australia might develop a large lay Buddhist community as Tibet and India did.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0128.mp3

UUID: 188b324b-ac60-464a-93f2-a2fbe760f08a

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,195

So generally speaking, if even one being alone listens to the teachings with a mind of bodhicitta, the benefit is inconceivable. So this is a sort of mind we have to generate to listen to teachings. And then we will meditate for one or two minutes on generating this motivation. Please be aware of the fact that if you can generate a motivation of bodhicitta to listen to teachings on emptiness, then you will actually be ascertaining emptiness with the mind of bodhicitta and will therefore be uniting at the Paramita level the method and wisdom aspects of the path. In other words, you will have a complete practice.

And this mind of bodhicitta is a mind which wishes to benefit all beings, which are far more important than ourselves and place them in a state of unalloyed bliss bereft of all suffering. And rooted in the awareness that we ourselves are completely unable to do this at present, we then listen to teachings on emptiness and meditate on teachings on emptiness to reach a state where we can do so. Page one. One b. If you’re not familiar with it, then it’s negative.

The As I said in one of the root texts, the teaching, emptiness, it is by means of emptiness, peace, and the absence of signs that the nature of phenomena is to be construed. And it is through understanding the infinite suffering of beings and of cyclic existence in general that the Buddha, through countless sutras and through teachings which are later on used by the great teachers relying on them through scripture and reasoning, expounded the meaning of emptiness.

And generally speaking, these so called three doors of liberation, which are emptiness, signlessness, and nonproduction. So I made a mistake in translation. It’s not lack of peace. It’s nonproduction. The three doors of liberation are the gateway to liberation.

They are actually the means whereby we are freed from the afflictions and the delusions. These three doors to liberation can best be understood using the example of the process of germination of a seed. A seed when planted in the earth gives rise to a sprout and eventually to crops. Now if we take the central element here, which is the sprout, the nature of the sprout is not to be truly established. It is actually empty of true establishment.

Its cause, which is the seed and those conditions associated with the seed such as water and manure are also empty of true establishment. They are actually marked by signlessness. They have the signlessness of lack of true establishment. Likewise, the result of the sprout, which is the crop, which is called the result which is aspired to, or the matured result one is striving for, is also empty of true establishment. So all three elements here, the cause, which is the seed, the middling entity, the sprout which is the result of the seed which in turn becomes itself the cause of the crop, all three are marked by lack of true existence.

All three, therefore, can be said to be characterized by the three doors of liberation. In other words, all three are empty, are signless, and are unproduced, nonproduced. It is therefore capital for us to gain definite ascertainment of the three doors of liberation if we wish to attain liberation. For that matter, it is very clear that the Hīnayāna practitioners, insofar as they gain realization of emptiness, necessarily also gain realization of the three doors of liberation. And as Śāntideva said, the seven limbs are necessary.

Now which seven limbs are referred to here? The first six of the seven are the six perfections of which the five initial ones which are generosity, morality, patience, enthusiasm, and concentration are the preliminaries for the practice of the sixth one, which is wisdom. Now for generally speaking, one can say that the five first perfections are indispensable for the attainment of full enlightenment In as much as there is no full enlightenment without the perfection of wisdom, then these five first perfections must first act as preliminaries for the perfection of wisdom. And generally speaking, these five first first perfections are part of the means component of practice, which leads to the realization of the wisdom component of practice, which is emptiness. Now that emptiness must be realized by means of an uncommon mind, which is a valid cognizer.

And this valid cognizer realizes emptiness, generally speaking, in dependence on seven different types of reasonings, which include the diamond sliver reasoning, the king of reasonings, which explains the dependent origination, and various other reasonings. These seven reasonings can, however, be subsumed into five. And Je Tsongkhapa himself, before he had realized emptiness, received instructions regarding the view directly from Mañjuśrī and repeatedly said to Mañjuśrī, I simply do not understand what you are saying. And again and again, try to understand the meaning of Mañjuśrī’s word. And Mañjuśrī said to Je Tsongkhapa at this point, fear not.

Keep my words in mind and engage in the uncommon training to eliminate obstructions to understanding emptiness, which is first accumulate merit, secondly, cleanse all defilements, thirdly, see the guru as inseparable from your yidam and finally, make heartfelt prayers to realize emptiness. In dependence on these, Je Tsongkhapa eventually gained full realization of emptiness. Now if this was so difficult for a great being like Je Tsongkhapa, how much more difficult is it for us who have no familiarity whatsoever with emptiness? Therefore, it is very important for us to gain this familiarity and to implant karmic imprints within our mind stream regarding emptiness because these karmic imprints eventually will lead us to full enlightenment. So Mañjuśrī said to Je Tsongkhapa, teaching such beings in Tibet in the fourteenth century is of little or no benefit.

Go forth in the wilderness and live as a hermit. And through meditating on the nature of things, you will benefit yourself and others. And Je Tsongkhapa, at this point, abandoned all his disciples and went and lived as a hermit meditating on the view, engaging in the practices Ārya Mañjuśrī told him to engage in. In so doing, he was able to realize the view, and through realizing the view was of benefit both to himself and to others. So we ourselves must take the example of and generate strong faith, strong conviction within our minds, make strong prayers that we can eventually realize the view, and in dependence on this, it will happen in due course.

So returning to the root text of the three principles of the path and the stanza which has commented, one who sees the infallible cause and effect of all phenomena in saṃsāra and nirvana and destroys all false perceptions has entered the path that pleases the Buddha. Now I glossed this a couple lessons ago as to be understood in the light of the syllogism. The subject, all phenomena in saṃsāra and Nirvāṇa Nirvāṇa are necessarily empty of true existence because of being dependent arisings. And when the in the subject of this syllogism, it is said, the subject all phenomena of cyclic existence and Nirvāṇa. This subject refers to the fact that all phenomena without exception can either be included within saṃsāra or Nirvāṇa.

Therefore, every phenomenon without exception can be said to be non truly existent or lacking true existence because of being a dependent arising or because of being a dependent origination. As Ārya Nāgārjuna said, that which is not a dependent arising is not a phenomenon for all phenomena can be said to be dependent arising. All phenomena can be said to be dependent arising because some are dependent arising because of depending on causes, others are dependent arisings because of depending on parts, and others yet again are said to be interdependent or dependent arisings because of being connected to the relation of imputer and imputed phenomena. Therefore, all phenomena without exception can be said to lack true existence.

And interdependence and true establishment can be said to be totally contradictory. That which is interdependent or that which is which is a dependent origination is that which arises or which depends on another. On the other hand, that which is truly existent, which is a true existent is that which does not depend in the slightest on another, which does not depend therefore on causes, on parts, or on the relation between imputer and imputed phenomena. In other words, a dependent origination, an interdependent phenomena is a phenomena which is linked, which depends on other others, whereas a truly established phenomena is totally autonomous. These are incompatible and contradictory in the same way as hot and cold can be said to be totally incompatible and mutually contradictory.

As said, nature is nondependent and thereby causeless. Interdependence, on the other hand, is necessarily dependent. What Je Tsongkhapa meant in this quote by nature is true establishment, and by non dependent, he referred to non dependence on causes and on conditions. Now such a truly established nature which is non dependent on causes and on conditions is naturally a non causal phenomenon. It does not arise from causes.

On the other hand, all phenomena are to be understood as being dependent arising precisely because they arise in dependence on causes, on parts, and on the mutual relation between imputer and imputed phenomena. The non dependent phenomenon does not exist. If we reflect, we will see clearly that should true establishment exist, should, in other words, independent phenomena exist, then necessarily karma and causality, cause and effect would no longer exist. It is quite obvious that should that be the case, there would be phenomena which exist impermanent phenomena which exist independently of causes, and this cannot be the case because there are no such impermanent phenomena which do not arise in dependence on causes. If that were the case, then seeds would no longer exist, children would no longer exist, cyclic existence would no longer exist, Buddhas, dharmas, and Sangha for that matter, which are all dependent arising, would automatically cease to exist.

And therefore, to put an end to this cycle of cyclic existence, it is capital to negate true establishment, to negate true existence. In so doing, we can put an end not merely to the cycle of lives, but to the suffering which is associated with them. Otherwise, this is not possible. This is why all the great traditions of Tibet, the Sakya, the Kagyu, the Nyingma traditions, all strive for realization of emptiness. And the Buddha himself in many sutras gave the example of a chariot and its components to lead one to understand emptiness.

Perhaps, Rinpoche says, because in those days, there weren’t many cars around. And if we take the example of a chariot, then we look at the constituents of a chariot. We have the wheel of the chariot. We have the body of the chariot. We have the main beam which connects the chariot to the horse, and we can clearly understand that there is no chariot independently of its parts.

Now the same thing can be said about a being which arises a person in other words, which arises in dependence on its five or its four aggregates. It is in dependence on the basis of imputation of the five or the four aggregates through the imputation by means of name and conception that a being arises. There is no being independently of these bases of imputation. Likewise, if the bases of imputation ceases to exist, in other words, if the five aggregates or the four aggregates no longer exist, it is no longer possible to impute a being on that basis. A being or a person therefore exists merely as a nominal or a conceptual imputation on the basis of the basis of imputation of that.

And this is the same thing for chariots, which are mere nominal imputations on their parts. For individualist persons, such as someone, let’s say, called Choga in Tibetan, who would only be an existent or an imputation in dependence on his five aggregates. Same thing for a girl who would only be an imputation on the basis of her five aggregates. Tables, for that matter, which are imputed on the basis of their parts. Houses, which are likewise imputed on the basis of their parts.

Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, which are imputed on the basis of their aggregates, and even cakes, Rinpoche says, could perhaps be seen as imputations on the basis of a cake’s aggregates.

And then one might wonder if all phenomena mere nominal and conceptual imputations, what prevents us from imputing anything on the basis of anything else, which would naturally lead to the collapse of all conventional knowledge, and what would prevent us from calling a goat man or anything. Actually, there are clear criteria for the validity of imputations, and these criteria are threefold. The first criterion is that the basis of imputation must be ascertained by a valid cognizer. The second criterion is that the imputed phenomena must be renowned to a conventional or worldly consciousness. And the third criterion is that the imputed phenomenon on the basis of imputation must not be harmed by a worldly valid cognizer.

To give an example of this, For example, let us imagine that one sees a stone in the distance, and this stone looks somewhat like a human being, and one mistakenly thinks that is a human being. Then when one comes up closer, one realizes that it’s not a human being. Now that realization that it is not a human being is a case of the imputation being harmed by the third criteria not being fulfilled by the fact that the basis of imputation is not established by valid cognition. And therefore, it is in dependence on the collection of the five of the four aggregates that a person can be imputed. And that imputation of a person on such a basis of imputation is validated or is established by a valid cognizer.

For instance, in dependence on the aggregates of Tashi, we can impute as a an imputation. And on the basis of the aggregates of our friend Nick, we can impute to the person Nick. So the first criterion for validity of conventional phenomena is that the basis of imputation be established by a valid cognizer and we have covered that with respect to the aggregates, which are the basis of imputation of a person, but this is not sufficient. The second criterion, as Rinpoche explained, is that it must be renowned to a conventional worldly consciousness. And for instance, if one were to impute the name of someone to the aggregates, This name must be something which is accepted by the people who know this person.

So if one were to say, for instance, on the basis of the aggregates of Lobsang that this is Lobsang, the environment of Lobsang will acknowledge this. It is reputed at a worldly level. And if I were to say it is Tashi, the environment of Tashi would acknowledge that the name Tashi can be imputed on the basis of the collection of the aggregates of Tashi. This, however, is not sufficient. A third criteria validity for conventional phenomena has to be fulfilled.

These imputed phenomena cannot be harmed by a worldly or conventional valid cognizer. And what is meant by this is that these worldly phenomena must be realized by a conventional or worldly cognizer, which inquires whether they exist in the way they are imputed to exist. So if they are realized by such a worldly valid cognizer, then one can say that they are not harmed by a worldly valid cognizer. If they are not realized by a worldly or conventional valid cognizer, then we can say that they are harmed by such a worldly or valid cognizer. To give an instance of phenomena which would satisfy the first two criteria for conventional existence, but not the third, the widespread belief in countries like India, for instance, that the world is created by Vishnu or by Īśvara or by Ganesh or by Brahma is a belief which would actually satisfy the second criteria.

It is widely accepted in the society of the people of a given area. But it does not satisfy the third criteria because it is harmed by valid cognition. It is harmed by valid cognition because through analysis using a valid cognizer, can clearly establish that the world is not created by Vishnu, Shiva, Ganesh, or Brahma, but instead arises through the power of causality, and specifically, that the world is a product of mind. Specifically, the product of virtuous minds, which lead to happiness, and non virtuous minds, which lead to suffering. And in addition to these three criteria, there is a fourth criteria, which is specific to the Madhyamaka tradition, which is that whichever phenomena is imputed cannot be harmed by an ultimate cognizer.

Now this is a specific view to the Madhyamaka tradition since the other lower traditions from the Vaibhāṣika upwards all accept the existence of truly established phenomena of one type or the other. And for this reason, the two lower traditions in particular, the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika are called as the are called the proponents of the existence of entities because they believe in the existence of true establishment. On the other hand, the lower of the two schools of Madhyamaka, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, where they do not accept the existence of true establishment, do consider, however, that phenomena are established by their own characteristics. It’s only the Prāsaṇgika school which considers that none of these is valid. For all the Madhyamaka schools in general, both Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika phenomena are said to lack true establishment because they are interdependent, because they are dependent originations.

However

Because of his skill in means in teaching beings who were very attracted to the view of true existence, Buddha taught the lower schools, and Buddha taught that some phenomena were truly established so as not to induce dismay in beings who were attracted to this view, who might otherwise thinking that phenomena did not exist at all, give up all practice of ethics and karma and causality. So through believing in the existence of truly existent phenomena, these beings would then engage happily in the practices of virtue leading to joy and in the practices or in the abstention of non virtue, thus avoiding suffering. But generally speaking, in the scale of schools, we start with the lowest school, the Vaibhāṣika school, which was taught for trainees of very dull faculties and move upwards with an ever greater refinement of the view through the Sautrāntika, Cittamātra, and ultimately the Madhyamaka school. If Buddha himself had taught the Madhyamaka view to the practitioners of the lower schools, he would have made them dizzy and disturb them profoundly. And Rinpoche, which he gives as an example of this the process of nomination of a chant master in a Tibetan monastery.

So it was not in the Tibetan tradition to praise someone and say, you have a nice voice or you recite well. However, based on those qualities, the abbot of the monastery would choose a monk and would nominate him chant master or Lama Umze. Now before he was nominated chant master, he may have had those qualities, but the name, chant master, was not projected or imputed on him, and he was not known as such irrespective of his good voice and his capacities to recite. However, as soon as the abbot appointed him as chant master, then to all he was understood to be the chant master, and not only did all understand him to be the chant master, but he himself became quite aware of the fact that he was a chant master. Therefore, on the basis of that basis of imputation, which is the aggregates of this person, his good voice, his capacity to recite, the name chant master is imputed.

Likewise, in the West nowadays, if we look at the process of election of a prime minister, before the election of the prime minister, the candidates suitable candidates postulate for the position, and then they are examined. Now while they’re being examined, they’re not recognized as prime ministers. And then the voting process occurs. If the vote goes in their favor, then after the vote, the term prime minister is imputed or is projected on the collection of aggregates of the person. Now if we take the case of a candidate who is running for the position of prime minister before he is elected, this candidate who is running for the position of prime minister has all the qualifications to become a prime minister.

But until election time, the name prime minister is not imputed upon him and is not recognized by the community. Therefore, he has, until that point, none of the powers or the capacities of a prime minister. So which he says, let us take the example of Mark, for instance, who is a very big man now. Now let us look back to the period when Mark was a tiny baby in the arms of his mother, crying desperately and looking up at his mother. And this was before the time his mother had given Mark the name Mark.

He was just a little creature. And at that point, his mother says, you are Mark. And from that point on, he becomes Mark for her. So it’s not as if the name Mark is there from his side, she puts the name Mark on him. There is tremendous power, Rinpoche says, in this process of naming, of putting the name on phenomena.

It invests them with the capacity to act. So if Mark was a truly established phenomenon, Rinpoche says, then at the very instant of birth, he would turn to his mother and say, I am Mark. in that case, Mark’s mother would have no work at all to do. So it is not the case that phenomena from their own side are truly established or express themselves. It is the case that from our own side, we impute, we project through name and conception these characteristics on phenomena.

If there was such a thing as a truly established phenomena, then from its own side, it will be bearing its own name. It could be performing its own activity. No such thing exists. And therefore, says it is important for us to understand clearly these three plus one, these four criteria for the establishment of conventional phenomena. The first is that the basis of establishment is validly established.

In other words, that when we examine the basis of establishment, we can see that it is an existent. The second is that the imputed phenomena is renowned to a conventional to conventional worldly consciousness, which Rinpoche explained. The third is that the imputed phenomena is not harmed by a valid cognizer. And finally, that the phenomenon in question, this is the fourth point, is not harmed by under ultimate analysis by a mind of ultimate analysis. So if all four of these criteria are fulfilled, then we can say that this conventional phenomenon is an existent.

If all four of these criteria are not fulfilled, then we can probably say that it is a nonexistent. So Rinpoche says, regarding the initial plans we had made that there would be four teaching sessions followed by a fifth question session where you would discuss with each other, what did you think, all of you, of that fifth session? Did things go well? Good. So Rinpoche says that since things seem to have gone quite well, we have the project of continuing and expanding this way of proceeding so that you don’t just attend passively teachings, but engage the material.

And he encourages you you to think about these things and to give rise to doubts in your mind so that you can benefit from this. So Rinpoche says that, therefore, what we should try to do is attend the teachings and then reflect on the meaning of the teachings and try to give rise to doubts, interrogations, questions within our mind, talk privately with each other. And then Rinpoche says, we have good instructors. There is Geshe la and there is your translator, and they will be able to answer carefully the doubts which you give rise to.

So just as in Tibet in days of yore when Buddhism was introduced, the Sakya, Kagyu, and Nyingma traditions had many lay practitioners who first studied carefully then meditated, and then many of them became ordained. And as generations passed on, the number of ordained increased. Likewise, Rinpoche makes strong prayers, the same thing would happen in Australia. So, Robert, I hope that in the future in Australia, there will be a very large sangha. So says laypeople can attain liberation.

There were many, many such cases in India, and there were many such cases in Tibet. So lay people can here in Australia attain liberation too. Sorry. I have a few alarms here.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
three doors go sum (Tib)
Body, speech and mind. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top