Rinpoche’s Story

2 h 1 min · 5,007 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 121-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche moves from foundational ethics to advanced philosophy. He begins with the Buddha’s core instruction—abandon non-virtue, practice virtue, tame your mind—emphasizing that even one minute of abstaining from a harmful action accumulates real merit, especially in our age when practitioners are rare. The mind is the root of all virtue and suffering; Rinpoche uses the metaphor of taming a wild horse to show how antidotes gradually reduce afflictions like desire and anger. He then teaches emptiness and interdependence: all phenomena are conceptual imputations, illustrated through concrete examples (naming a child, examining a cup, labeling rooms in a house). This understanding, not prayer or external force, is the path to liberation. The talk concludes with candid Q&A on an apparent contradiction between Mahāyāna compassion and eating meat, where Rinpoche reflects on his own practice and the conditions under which meat consumption is permissible in tantric Buddhism. Pitched at serious practitioners with Buddhist framework.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0130.mp3

UUID: f8b1e0c3-7dc9-4f91-b654-8ebd8a034b69

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~5,003

No. Alright. So with the motivation of benefiting both oneself and others, generating a good motivation motivation and thereby accumulating vast amounts of merit, we will, at present, as usual, generate the motivation. So since we ourselves are one and others are infinite in numbers, it is clear that their benefit and their welfare must outweigh us, and we should strive to perform their ultimate welfare. And this motivation to place them in a state endowed with all perfections and bereft of all faults is a motivation we must generate.

However, at present, we are well aware of the fact that we are incapable of doing this. Therefore, we should, from our side, strive first to eliminate all thoughts within our mind and to generate all qualities, and then, after doing this, to lead all others to the perfection of full enlightenment. This is the motivation we will try to generate for a couple minutes. So there is a greater benefit when one does not have merely an intellectual understanding of this, but when an experience, a feeling arises in within oneself, and this is the result of meditation. So we will meditate for one or two minutes on this.

Our teacher, the Buddha, gave the following advice. The teaching of the enlightened one is to abandon all non virtue and to practice perfectly virtue. Tame your mind. This is the teaching of the enlightened one. This advice of the Buddha is very profound because all we have to do to eliminate the suffering which plagues us is to abandon the cause of suffering.

Suffering is a result, and the cause of suffering are non virtuous deeds. Through simply abandoning non virtuous deeds and not committing nonvirtuous deeds, whether they be great or they be small, then their result suffering will cease in and of itself, by itself, without any particular effort.

And, therefore, this state of suffering and the abandonment of non virtue are totally incompatible. In other words, if we abandon non virtue, suffering will not arise because the causes of suffering will have been abandoned. On the other hand, if we don’t abandon non virtue and engage in non virtue, suffering will arise. Now what is meant here by non virtue are the 10 non virtuous deeds, which we all know, and what is meant by virtue are the 10 virtuous deeds. So clearly, if in addition to abandoning the 10 non virtuous deeds, we engage in the practice of the 10 virtuous deeds, which are the cause of happiness, then unavoidably, by its very nature, happiness will arise.

There is absolutely no point in praying for happiness and just expecting that happiness will come through the force of prayer. Happiness does not come through the force of prayer. Happiness comes from the accumulation of its causes. The causes of happiness are the practice of the 10 virtuous deeds. So if we accumulate the causes, then we can hope for the result.

Otherwise, to pray for happiness and expect it to come is somewhat akin to someone saying, please give me money, please give me money, as we would know that money doesn’t come. So if we look at things in those terms, then the most important thing is to abandon non virtue. And first, we should abandon completely the non virtues which are easy to abandon for us. Then for those which are more difficult for us to abandon, we should abandon them for one day. If we cannot abandon them for one day, then for one hour.

If we cannot abandon them for one hour, then just abandoning them for five minutes or a mere one minute is enough to be a an act of virtue because that mind of abandonment has been created. And for that matter, there is greater merit to be accumulated in abandoning in this dark age we live in. One non virtue for one hour, then practicing the abandonment of that non virtue for one full lifetime in the fortunate ages of the past. The reason for this is that in the fortunate ages of yore, the practitioners of virtue were many, and those who engaged in nonvirtue were few. Therefore, it was easy, and the benefit was more limited.

Nowadays, on the other hand, if we look around us, those who practice virtue are very rare, and those who engage in non virtue are very numerous. So in this day and age, to just abstain from non virtue for one hour is of greater benefit than abstaining from non virtue for one entire lifetime in the fortunate ages of the past. Nowadays, to be a monk with pure morality for one hour is far superior to having been a monk of virtue with pure morality for one full lifetime in days of yore. Nowadays, to be a layperson who abstains, abandons non virtue for one hour is far superior to having been a layperson who took vows and abstained from non virtue for one full lifetime in the past. So what is important is to take the pledge, the determination, to make the pledge in front of the Buddha that we will abandon nonvirtue for however long we are able to do so.

Now the mind is the root. And since the root is the mind in as much as the non virtues of body and speech arise initially from a mental motivation or by intention, then the mind is what must be trained, what must be tamed. If the mind is tamed, then the body and speech will be tamed by themselves. And the Buddha frequently gave the example of taming of a wild horse. Now a wild horse which is has just been captured is unmountable by the best rider.

And first, one must insert a bit in its mouth and then tame the horse, and it is only after taming the horse through controlling the bit that one can progressively train the horse to go to the left when it wants it to go to the left or to the right when it wants it to go to the right. Now likewise, the mind has to be tamed as one tames a wild horse, and the bit which we use are the antidotes to the afflictions. They put their this iron bit in their mouth, and then they couldn’t bite you, and they had to do whatever you told them to do. So Buddha himself gave the example of the taming of a wild horse, while Śāntideva gave the example of the taming of a wild elephant. The meaning is the same.

The mind must be tamed in the way we tame a wild horse. And for instance, when, let us say, the affliction of desire arises in the mind, then one uses if you want the horses moving to the right, one uses the antidote of meditation on the filthy, on the unseemly aspects of the body to reduce desire. And when on the other hand, the affliction of anger arises, then one uses the antidote of meditation on loving kindness and on bodhicitta to reduce that affliction. And then quietly, quietly, the mind becomes tamer. It doesn’t happen quickly.

It takes time. And then the three root afflictions are said to be the afflictions of desire, of anger, and of ignorance. Now to counteract desire when it arises in the mind, one meditates on ugliness and the filth of the human body. To counteract anger when it arises in the mind, one meditates on loving kindness, on compassion, and on charity. These are, however, temporary antidotes.

The third antidote is the base of all afflictions. It is this dark, stable, and hard base of afflictions, which is ignorance. To eliminate ignorance is very difficult, and the only way to do so is through the view which realizes emptiness.

So what is the foremost means for understanding emptiness? The foremost means for understanding emptiness is the understanding of interdependence. This is what was taught by Buddha Śākyamūni himself in many sutras. And when we refer to interdependence, we are referring to three different levels of interdependence. The coarse level of interdependence is causal interdependence, the interdependence of the effect on the cause and later on of the cause on the effect.

The subtle level of interdependence is particulate interdependence, the interdependence of the whole on the parts and of the parts on the whole. The subtlest level of interdependence is the interdependence which exists between the basis of imputation and the imputed phenomenon as well as the mind which imputes that phenomenon. This is very hard to realize. But the two first levels of interdependence we can hope to realize, and through realizing them, we can in turn hope to realize emptiness. Otherwise, the realization of emptiness is very difficult with the other lines of reasoning.

Now the relevance of this is that if we look around us and see the number of beings which are incapable of attaining liberation from the sufferings of cyclic existence and are endlessly cycling from suffering to suffering and ask ourselves what the cause of this is, whether some monstrous creator had plunged these beings in this abyss of suffering, the answer would have to be there is no such creator. The only cause for the sufferings the beings are facing is the nescience, the non knowledge of emptiness. It is because they do not know emptiness that, in turn, they accumulate through the afflictions, karma, and thereby are impelled from life to life. Therefore, this realization of emptiness, the realization of interdependence which leads to it, are the means to put an end to suffering. And our teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, after meditating some twelve years in the area around Nālānda, eventually reached full enlightenment under the Pipal tree at Bodh Gaya, and after reaching full enlightenment uttered the following verses.

This profound Dharma which is free of elaborations, these teachings of the emptiness of inherent existence and the uncompounded nature of phenomena, at present who would be able to understand them? And after uttering these verses, the Buddha thought it might be wiser to hide these teachings. How many great scholars and great meditators there were in ancient India who put so much effort in understanding the Prāsaṇgika view, and yet how few they were who actually realized emptiness. And after them in Tibet, in the glorious Sakya tradition, the five Sakya teachers who were known as the emanations of Mañjuśrī did indeed realize emptiness. And Je Tsongkhapa himself realized emptiness and some of his disciples did.

But how many great Geshes spent fifteen or twenty years of their lives studying the texts on emptiness, the great Madhyamaka texts, debating them, receiving teachings on emptiness, meditating on emptiness, and yet realized nothing? Emptiness is very profound and very difficult, and it is therefore not surprising that we find it difficult and say that we have no understanding of it. However, the very fact that we are assembled here today receiving teachings on is a result of karmic imprints from the past which connected us to these teachings on emptiness, and the good fortune we have today is one whereby we can at present implant karmic imprints to receive in the future more teachings on emptiness. So at present, we have to generate faith in the fact that the ultimate nature of phenomena is the emptiness of inherent existence, make strong prayers to receive teachings on emptiness in the future, and make prayers to realize emptiness eventually. This is the profound means which will enable us to realize emptiness.

Very good. However, what are the karmic imprints which we should implant in our mind stream regarding emptiness? There are three different categories of karmic imprints we should implant connected to the three activities of hearing, thinking, and meditating. So we should implant karmic imprints regarding hearing about emptiness, karmic imprints regarding thinking about emptiness, and the karmic imprints of meditating upon emptiness. All three karmic imprints must be implanted within our mindstream.

However, they differ in their power. The weakest of the three are the karmic imprints which arise through hearing. Yet without them, the other two activities are not possible. Therefore, we must attend teachings on emptiness and hear about emptiness. After hearing about emptiness, we must then implant the karmic imprints of thinking about emptiness, and this means to reflect about what we have heard again and again, looking at the understanding of emptiness from many different angles until we reach a firm conclusion.

This is probably the way emptiness is. And through these activities, we will implant the karmic imprints imprints of thinking about emptiness, which is stronger than the karmic imprints of hearing about emptiness. At this point, we have to implant the firmest karmic imprints of all, the karmic imprints of meditating on emptiness on the basis of our previous analyses. And then we meditate again and again on our understanding of emptiness, and this imprints the karmic imprints which are akin to a seed being planted in the field, which will eventually give rise to the wisdom which realizes emptiness directly.

So if one were to try to understand what is compatible with a presentation of emptiness and not in a very summarized way, said that one of the first points to understand is that all phenomena, without exception, are mere conceptual imputations. This means that there is nothing which dawns from the side of the phenomena itself. The phenomena itself, from its own side, does not exist. All that exists is that mere conceptual imputation from the side of the subject, from the side of the mind. And this is the case for all the objects we can think of, whether it is flowers, buildings, tables, books, or for that matter, to take the example of one of the students, Dale.

Until the name Dale was assigned to the child who eventually bore its name, it was not known as Dale. Told you, Randall. Could not perform that function. So the assignation of the name by a conceptual mind enabled it to perform this function. This is a case for all phenomena, and there is, in this respect, a very very famous quote in Sūtra in which Buddha says, the colors of all of the various flowers of the pure lands and all of the marvelous manifestations are mere conceptual imputations.

The meaning of this is that all of the extraordinary flowers, their colors, red, yellow, blue, and what not color of these flowers of the pure lands and of all phenomena for that matter, are merely projections or imputations from the side of the mind. So phenomena’s not being established by conceptual imputation, but being established from their own side, by their own power, by their own characteristics, by their own nature is what is meant by the true establishment of phenomena. Now the true establishment of phenomena doesn’t exist. Phenomena are mere conceptual imputations. Phenomena do not exist from their own side, through their own power, through their own characteristics, or by their own nature.

Yet all of us actually bear within us the conviction that phenomena exist in this way. Phenomena dawn to our minds as if they were established from their own side by their own characteristics and so forth. For instance, Rinpoche’s book seems to one who observes it to exist from its own side independently of conceptual imputation and nominal imputation. This is the appearance of the book as a truly established phenomena, and that is the ignorance which apprehends the self of phenomena. This is the cause of cyclic existence which abides in the mind of every single one of us.

Every single one of us is the cause of his or her own cyclic existence. And is it possible then to just impute without a basis? Obviously, no. There is no such thing as a space flower because the imputation of a flower on the basis of space is not possible. We do not see a flower in space above us.

So an imputation requires what is called a basis of imputation. The basis of imputation of a person, for instance, is the five or the four aggregates which constitute the person. It’s on this basis of imputation that the imputation is possible. In addition to this, one needs also an imputor, that whereby the imputation is performed. In the case of a person imputed on the basis of the four or the five aggregates, the imputer is the sound or the name person.

And the ultimate imputer would be the conception person, which gives rise to this proximate imputer, the sound of the name person. So phenomena therefore arise at the conjunction or at the confluence of the imputer and the basis of imputation. And in addition, therefore, to the first component for a valid imputation, which is a basis of imputation, and the second component, which is which which is interrelation of the basis of imputation and the imputer, which imputes the person on the basis of imputation in the case of a person. The third component, which is indispensable, is that the imputed phenomenon itself arise or be established dependent on other conditions. So it is through these three factors that a valid imputation may be said to have occurred and that a person can be said to be established.

And, therefore, one can say that it is only when all four of the conditions which Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche mentioned previously are fulfilled that an authentic imputation have been said to have occurred and as a dependence on those, a realization of emptiness is possible. These four are: first, the realization that all or the phenomena being considered is a conceptual imputation secondly, the realization that this imputation on the basis of a basis of imputation thirdly, that this imputation arises through the mutual relation of the basis of imputation and the imputor, both the proximate imputor, the sound, and the ultimate imputor conception. And finally, the realization that the imputed phenomenon itself is established dependent on other conditions. So it is through realizing this that a valid imputation can be said to have occurred, and this is the minimum necessary for understanding that the imputed phenomenon is empty of inherent existence.

And in the case of the imputation of a person on the basis of imputation of the four or the five aggregates, the imputation of a person on such a basis is possible because this actually is a valid basis of imputation for the person. So this condition having been met, the last of the four conditions which is mentioned must also be understood clearly. What is the last of the four conditions? That the imputed phenomenon, in this case, the person, actually is established dependent on other conditions. What are specifically the other conditions which are referred to here?

They are actually the existence of a basis of imputation, which is a four or five aggregates, and of an imputer. The imputer, as Rinpoche explained, is the sound person, which is itself a result of the conception thinking person. So it is through the meeting of these conditions that the basis of imputation person is affixed on the basis of imputation of the four or the five aggregates. Therefore, if we analyze things in this light, it is evident that the imputed phenomenon person, which exists validly, is however not an inherently existing phenomenon, because if it were an inherently existing phenomenon, it would exist without depending on other causes and conditions, nor is it a phenomenon which is self characterized because, again, it has other characteristics and so forth. And therefore, if phenomena were to exist through their own power or from their own side, they would be truly established, which they are obviously not.

So if we take, as the example of the cup he has put in front of him, this cup actually for one who sees us sees it for the first time That’s right. Is constituted of many parts. The northern, Eastern, western, southern part, the parts in the four directions, the top, the bottom, the constituents of the cup, and one observing it for the first time would look at it high and low and eventually decide, impelled by a conception, to call it cup. At that point, it becomes a cup. It is established as a cup and can perform the function of a cup.

Another example which is perhaps a little bit easier to understand is that of the three rooms in a new house. So if you have a new house with three rooms which look very similar, at first, one doesn’t really know what to do with the rooms. And then one examines the rooms, the owner of the new house decides, well, this room is gonna be the kitchen, and that room is going to be the meditation room, and that will be the sleeping room. Then he calls in kitchen, meditation room, sleeping room. Then they perform the function of a kitchen.

If he is hungry when he goes in the kitchen, and he feels tired when he goes in the sleeping And therefore, one should understand these four characteristics of the process of imputation, which is that phenomena are mere conceptual imputations, which arise secondly on a basis of imputation, which thirdly arise through the conjunction or the meeting of the basis of imputation and the imputor and fourthly, that the imputed phenomenon itself is established dependent on other conditions. Now, if these four, or for that matter the first two and the last one, in other words three of the four are established, then it is sufficient to gain an understanding of imputation, therefore of the fact that all phenomena are empty of inherent nature. And this is one of the uncommon features of Madhyamaka, which makes it very convenient, which is that if one understands this with respect to one phenomenon, one understands it with respect to all other phenomena. Situation is the same with respect to all others. If one doesn’t understand it with respect to one phenomenon, one doesn’t understand it with respect to any other phenomenon.

The number two says, therefore, start with one object of analysis, for instance, the person or the self, and try to find exactly how the self exists and then extend this to all phenomena. It is the same for all of them. So if we were to take the person as a basis of analysis, then first we have to see the person as a conceptual imputation, which does not arise through its own power or from its own side, but purely through the force of the conceptual mind imputing the named person. Then, secondly, it arises on a basis of imputation. In this case, the five aggregates for beings of the four realms, desire of four realms of four aggregates for the others.

Thirdly, it arises the interrelation of this basis of imputation and the imputor, which as Rinpoche explained, is the sound person, or the name person, and ultimately the conception, which has impelled the production or the creation of this name. And then finally, this imputed phenomenon, which has dawned, is to be understood as established in dependence on other conditions in as much as it is established on other conditions, as mentioned the basis of imputation, the imputor, the process of imputation and so forth, then it does not exist inherently. It does not exist from its own side. And this absence of inherent existence, this absence of existence by its own characteristics, is emptiness. So this is what we should meditate upon.

So the question is regarding the tree falling down to the ground and so forth, the doubt, why does it not exist without a perceiver? Isn’t its existence only dependent on causes such as seed, water, sunshine, good soil, spade? So in a nutshell, the phenomena are said to be that which is observed by a valid cognizer. A phenomenon which is not observed by a valid cognizer, which is not the object of a mind, does not exist.

So the question is, how can the aspiration to liberate all beings from suffering coexist with the conscious choice to eat the flesh of other living beings? By eating meat or supporting an industry which subjects countless living beings with extreme suffering and death, Isn’t this a non virtue? Why is permitted on the Mahāyāna path? I put it more bluntly during the chair, I said, but I think it’s the intention of asking the question. Basically a Mahāyāna practitioner who eats meat lacks compassion.

If he lacks compassion, is not a Mahāyāna practitioner. How is this possible? Now Rinpoche said there are two broad categories of Mahāyāna practitioners. Those who engage in the Pāramitāyāna and those who engage in the Tantrayāna. Now with respect to those who engage in the Pāramitāyāna, generally eating flesh is discouraged.

With respect to those who engage in the tantric vehicle, actually the eating of meat and the drinking of alcohol is compulsory in the context of the Guru Puja. The reason for the eating of meat and the drinking of alcohol being compulsory in the context of the Guru Puja is that designed in that context blessed substances. And as blessed substances, their consumption leads to a steady increase of bliss, and this bliss is in turn used to cognize emptiness. So in dependence on these substances and the increase in bliss which is used to cognize emptiness, one progresses very quickly up the grounds and paths. And therefore these substances being blessed in that context act as a cause for the yogis being able to attain quickly all grounds and paths.

On the other hand, Rinpoche says, one might think that being a vegetarian is a faultless lifestyle. This is actually a very naive view viewpoint since one who eats rice or one who eats wheat eats products which are produced through the extermination of a gigantic number of insects with the systematic use of insecticides. And it is an extreme case of discrimination to state that the life form of an insect is not worthy of one’s attention, but the life form, for instance, of a higher animal is. So Rinpoche feels that the faultless source of food, the source of food which does not lead to the suffering of others, perhaps does not exist. The one exception to this, he said, would be for those of you, like the asker of this question, who are advanced practitioners, to perhaps consume the essence of flowers or minerals or engage in the practice of Vajrayoginī of consuming the essence of space.

Perhaps this is And then for the great tantric practitioners and the great practitioners who develop śamatha, there is the experience of enjoying the food of Samādhi, and they can abide for centuries without eating just on the basis of the nourishment provided by samadhi. But for the rest of us, Rinpoche says, whether it is a child drinking its mother’s milk, the infant eating boiled food, or us eating meat, or nonflesh products, the faultless source of food, the source of food which does not entail nonvirtue maybe does not exist. And there is, in addition, a mantra which can be recited to bless meat before ingesting it, eliminates the thought of having ingested the flesh of another being. However, it is crucial to avoid eating any meat of which or regarding which the three observances have not been fulfilled. The three observances are the observance that it has not been killed for oneself, one has not heard that it has been killed for oneself, or one does not suspect that it has been killed for oneself.

In all of those three cases, Buddha has strictly forbidden the consumption of such meat as it is a grave non virtue. Generally speaking,, giving up the consumption of meat is an excellent thing. Unfortunately, in Tibet, they simply did not have the facilities. They had basically no vegetables in a very high altitude climate and were reduced to a very simple and spartan diet. But when he came to the West and especially to Buddha House, he was told rather directly that eating meat was a fault and giving up meat was a good thing. So Rinpoche from his his side then gave up meat for several months, and he tried really hard.

But he started to get a lot of bodily pains and he couldn’t concentrate, he couldn’t study, he couldn’t meditate. He had flashes of pain left and right. And then to his great regret, he started eating meat again. Says, since then, he has made very heartfelt prayers over his meals and recited many mantras, and he hopes there is some benefit. Thinks that if one makes strong prayers that the poor creature, the flesh one is eating of, takes a good rebirth.

And if these prayers are heartfelt, then probably that there there is some benefit for the the creature in question. Okay. Okay. Hello. I got, here this Saturday.

There is a talk here on Saturday two to four. There’s a fly around here. You might got the email already. And, that’s this Saturday teaching. And the Saka Dawa is coming soon in June, June 7, and, there will be precepts in the morning, 05:30.

And, 06:30, if you want to take a refuge, must make sure you are registered in the office and, of course, the tenants on Sunday. And, I think we distribute the texts around on a Sunday. Those who are coming on teaching, you can take the texts.

Thank you. No. This the new ones. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. You can you can pass around if those who, attend the teaching on Sunday. That’s it. Thank you very much. And, there’s a child outside there.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
Saka Dawa
One of four great holy days of the Tibetan calendar, falling on the fifteenth of the fourth Tibetan month, Saka Dawa commemorates the Buddha’s birth, enlightenment and parinirvana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top