Rinpoche’s Story

2 h 8 min · 5,910 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 128-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche teaches the core Buddhist insight: the root of all suffering is ignorance—the fundamental misperception that the self exists inherently and independently. He explains how this false view drives endless karma and rebirth. The bulk of the teaching focuses on understanding and meditating on emptiness through careful analysis. Using his cup as an example, Rinpoche demonstrates how to reason toward direct insight: since the cup is a dependent arising composed of many parts and causes, it cannot be inherently existing. He teaches the mirror reflection analogy and guides students through logical proof. He addresses questions on virtue, conceptual versus direct realization, and the bodhisattva path. For serious practitioners already familiar with emptiness teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0134.mp3

UUID: 0806109e-2c3c-40e6-8d99-a9d65137eaa4

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~5,901

So if we can when we attend teachings and when the teacher himself from his own side explains teachings, generate a good motivation, which means a motivation to help others to place them in a state of ultimate happiness, then we will most definitely accumulate a large collection of merit, and this will be highly beneficial to us and to others. So what do we mean by this motivation? This is motivation which reflects on the fact that while we ourselves are alone, single, the number of sentient beings which have all been our mothers in past lives is infinite. So their advantage far overweighs ours. And then reflecting like this, we should say to ourselves how profoundly unsuitable it is that all sentient beings are not endowed with happiness and the causes of happiness and how profoundly unsuitable it is that they are not freed from causes and suffering and the causes of suffering.

I myself will take the responsibility to place them in a state bereft of all suffering and endowed with all happiness. Reflecting in this way, we should then strive in our practice with the motivation that upon ourselves reaching full enlightenment, we will lead all other mother mother sentient beings to that state. Let us meditate on this motivation for a while. And then to generate this motivation, it’s very beneficial to have some experience of it. So to generate that experience, we will meditate for one or two minutes, and then the teaching will start.

Page one. One b, refuge and bodhicitta for teachings. If you’re not familiar with the Tibetan phonetic, you can read on a page two in English. Page five verse six Mandala offering. We recite the first and the last verse.

So as Candrakīrti said in his text, the root of the afflictions, which are the faults of all beings, that very view of the self. And this passage can be understood as follows. The afflictions, which are faults indeed, are the root of the suffering of beings. And the suffering of beings in turn can be traced back to ignorance. Now if we ask what precisely this ignorance is, it is that apprehension of the self which can also be called the view of the disintegrating collection or also the apprehension of an inherently existing self.

These three terms are synonymous. And this is precisely what the yogi must understand to put an end to generate a cessation of the afflictions. That basis on which emptiness is meditated upon is the person or the eye. So meditating on the emptiness of the person or the I, it is possible to gain liberation and in due course, full enlightenment.

And generally speaking, one can divide entire world we live in into two broad categories, what are called the container and the essence. The container refers to this world of flux, which is also called in Tibetan the basis of disintegration, jikten (world),, since this is what happens in the world. And this refers to all the countries which are the abodes of sentient beings, such as Australia. Australia would be a container. It is a basis of disintegration, a world, in other words.

It’s the abode of those sentient beings which are Australians. On the other hand, the essence refers to the sentient beings which abide in this world. These are persons which are afflicted by the four sufferings of birth, old age, disease, and death. For instance, Rinpoche said, if you were to take his cup as an example, his cup is a container and the fluid, the tea poured inside, is actually the essence in this terminology. Now all the beings in these worlds are afflicted with horrific sufferings.

We hear at present of the fears of a pandemic. This country and many other countries have been affected by floods and for that matter, by forest fires, which have killed many. Much of the world is prey to war and to famine. The sufferings of the world we live in are difficult to fathom. There are earthquakes and all of the afflictions which are connected with disruptions within the four elements of earth, water, fire, and air.

Now if we were to ask what precisely are the causes of all these sufferings, then they can be said to be the afflictions. And the afflictions themselves are caused by the view of the disintegrating collection, as Ārya Candrakīrti said. So all phenomena of the nature of the essence, in other words, all beings are afflicted by suffering. And if we were to inquire whether it is possible to eliminate suffering, it is actually possible to eliminate suffering. It is possible through understanding the root of suffering, which is that view of the disintegrating collection, that view of the inherent existence of a self through putting an end to this, through eliminating this, all the sufferings which it produces will be eliminated. So how should one engage in this?

One should engage in this through meditating on emptiness, through meditating on selflessness. And therefore, we have to understand this view of the disintegrating collection. Now this view of the disintegrating collection with which we have to become familiar is actually the I. It is this I which seems to exist without depending on anything by its own power, which is established by its own nature and by its own characteristics. If we check ourselves, we will find that we have a very powerful sense of I.

When we say I, it rises within us. Rinpoche says, whether you say I in English or in Tibetan, you know, the same sense of of self arises in the mind. And it is the mind which apprehends that inherently existing I, which is called the view of the disintegrating collection. This view sees the I as a phenomenon which does not depend on causes and conditions, which is defined by its own characteristics. And this I aspires to happiness.

It aspires to felicity. Now this I itself has possessions. The genitive of the I is my. And in dependence on the I accumulating my and mine, all of the countless afflictions are in turn engaged in. And Rinpoche pointed out the furniture which surrounds him or our bodily parts or sense organs, these are all part of the mind, which is invested by the I.

In dependence then on this sense of the true existence of the I and the mind, karma is accumulated, and the only way to put an end to this accumulation of karma is through the meditation on emptiness. It is through meditating on emptiness that the person ceases to accumulate karma. Otherwise, it is impossible not to accumulate an endless stream of virtuous and non virtuous karma. So the key here is to eliminate the sense of the I as truly existing or as truly characterized. And as a famous passage from the Heart Sūtra said, although there are five aggregates, they are to be seen as empty of nature.

Now the five aggregates on the basis of which the person is imputed is what is referred to here, and or the person imputed on the basis of the five aggregates is not established by its own characteristics. That mind which apprehends it as being established by its own characteristics is the view of the disintegrating collection. Now for generally speaking, the I does exist, it does not exist as a phenomenon which is established by its own characteristics. And the that very apprehension that it exists as a phenomenon established by its own characteristics is what gives rise to karma. So we have to understand here a clear distinction between the person, which is imputed on the basis of the five aggregates, The clinging to the self existence or the existence by its own characteristics of which is actually clinging to a self of persons.

And on the other hand, those five aggregates, which are the basis of imputation, the clinging to the inherent or existence of which or the existence by its own characteristics of which is actually an apprehension of the self of phenomena. It is through both this apprehension or this clinging to the self of persons and through this clinging of the self to the self of phenomena that we cycle in cyclic existence. And, therefore, we cycle through cyclic existence impelled by two different ignorances. The ignorance which apprehends

The, person as an inherently existing entity and that ignorance which apprehends the aggregates as inherently existing entities. Now the ignorance which apprehends the person as an inherently existing entity arises in dependence on the ignorance which apprehends the aggregates as inherently existing entities. The first is an apprehension of the self of persons, and the second is an apprehension of the self of phenomena. And as Candrakīrti says, that mind which apprehends selflessness is the means for liberation from cyclic existence. Now that mind which apprehends selflessness apprehends actually the two different types of selflessness which Rinpoche spoke about.

The first is the selflessness of phenomena, and the second is the selflessness of persons. There are only these two types of selflessness. And from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, they are only differentiated in terms of the basis on which they are formulated. So if the basis is the aggregate, then the selflessness which is formulated on those terms is the selflessness of phenomena. And if the basis is the person, then the selflessness formulated on that basis is the selflessness of persons.

And therefore, So, it is difficult to understand emptiness. It is difficult to realize emptiness. Emptiness is not the object of the countless divisions which one encounters in the subject studied, for instance, in the context of Paramita. There are, generally speaking, four divisions of emptiness. Emptiness can be divided into 20 different types of emptinesses, 16 different types of emptinesses, four different types of emptinesses or two different types of emptinesses.

Of these four broad divisions, only the three last have been explained by Tsongkhapa. So Jetsunkhapa considers that the 16 fold division is the elaborate division or yes, the elaborate division of emptiness. The four fold division is a middling division of emptiness, and the two fold division is the concise division of emptiness. Two fold division of emptiness is a division of emptiness into the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. And the four fold division of emptiness is a division of emptiness into the emptiness of all phenomena, the emptiness of self characterization, the emptiness of nonobservation, and the emptiness of nothingness.

As for the sixteen and twenty fold divisions, they include emptiness of the outer and the inner and so forth. But as Rinpoche explained, only the sixteenfold, fourfold, and twofold divisions have been explained by Tsongkhapa himself. Meditate on emptiness, and the question is how to proceed about it. Generally speaking, one first meditates on the selflessness or the emptiness of persons, and then only at that point does we meditate on the selflessness or the emptiness of phenomena. Now why is this the case?

It is not a matter of difference in terms of the object of negation. The actual object of negation of the selflessness of persons and of the selflessness of phenomena is the same that both are object of negations which refer to inherent existence. In the one case, the inherent existence of the person, in the other case, the inherent existence of the aggregates which constitute the person. The difference, however, arises in terms of ease or difficulty of realization. And the ease or difficulty of realization is connected with that which with which we have the most familiarity.

So it is much easier to realize the selflessness or the emptiness of inherent existence of the person than to realize the selflessness or the emptiness of inherent existence of phenomena. Therefore, first one realizes emptiness or selflessness on the basis of the person. And then once one has realized that, it is very easy to extend this realization to all phenomenon since the object of negation is the same. On the other hand, if one tries to realize it on the basis of a more difficult object of negation such as phenomena, one may end up by not being able to realize even the selflessness or the emptiness of inherent existence of the person. So today, we are going to talk about the I as the object of negation of emptiness.

I So the eye does exist. For instance, when we say I, I, we are referring to something. For that matter, the I of dogs, of cats, of horses does exist. However, when we start analyzing philosophically, then we realize that things are a little bit more complicated than we thought. If we posit the subject I, which means we isolate the I, we place it as an object of investigation on the table.

And then we examine it, we would say, this subject I, it follows that it is not established inherently because it is an interdependent phenomenon or because it is a dependent arising. So the subject I, it follows, this is a predicate that it is not established inherently. And then a reason is given for this. The reason which is given for this is that it is a dependent arising. In other words, everything which is a dependent arising and necessarily is not established inherently is not established by its own characteristics.

Through the reason of the dependent arising, the nonestablishment inherently and the nonestablishment by its own characteristics is established. But he says, to give an easier example to understand, it’s a little bit as if we were to accuse someone of being a thief. And we would say, this bald chap over there, that’s a subject. The predicate is he is a thief. We’re affirming something about him, but we have to ground.

We have to justify this. We say he is a thief because whenever he’s been in the shop, money has vanished. So then on that reason, we establish that he is a thief. From the reason of money money vanishing in the shop whenever he is there and only him, we establish that he is a thief. Now in this case, it is the same thing.

It is to again and again meditating and reflecting on the reason of interdependence or dependent arising that we eventually generate a sense of the noninherent establishment of the self, of the person. Now when we have generated a powerful sense of the noninherent establishment of the self of the person, we have realized the selflessness of persons. So, War, there’s been many, many explanations about emptiness. Rinpoche feels that there’s been very little explanation about how actually to meditate about emptiness. So he would like to explain to you how to meditate about emptiness.

And then if Rinpoche wanted to establish emptiness for somebody, let us say for a friend Nick here, then Rinpoche would take a subject, in this case, the cup. And he would say to Nick, the subject the cup, which Nick can see, it follows that it is not established inherently because it is a dependent arising. Now Nick actually knows that the cup exists and that the cup is a dependent arising. That he understands. And then he thinks again and again and again, but the cup being a dependent arising, the cup being interdependent, the cup arising in terms of its parts, the top and the bottom, the various sides of the cup, the particles which constitute it.

And he then reflects on the fact that everything which is a dependent arising actually cannot exist inherently, is necessarily a non inherently existing phenomena. And suddenly, realizes that for sure, the cup is a non inherently existing phenomenon because it is a dependent arising. So this would be how one would establish emptiness, the emptiness of a cup for a given person. And at this point, having formulated the syllogism, the subject Nick, it follows that he is not an inherently existing phenomenon because he is a dependent arising. In traditional Indian logic, an example would be given, and the example is just as the reflection of a face in a mirror.

Now when a face is reflected in a mirror, even though if we look in the mirror at our own face, all the elements of our face are present. Nonetheless, the reflection of our face in the mirror is not our face. It appears to be our face, but it is not our face. And the fact that it appears to be our face, but is not our face is a simile for the fact that phenomena appear to be inherently existing, appear to exist from their own side, but actually do not exist from their own side inherently. They only exist in terms of mere appearances.

Now for that matter, the appearance of our face in a mirror is actually contingent on both the existence of the mirror and the presence of our face. So if a mirror is not present, even if our face is present, the reflection of our face in the mirror cannot arise. Likewise, if our face is not present, but the mirror is present, then the reflection of our face in the mirror likewise cannot arise. It is only through the meeting of the presence of our face and the mirror that in dependence on the presence of these two factors, the reflection of a face in the mirror can arise. Therefore, this reflection of our face in the mirror is also a very powerful instance of dependent arising and of the fact that phenomena can only exist as dependent arising.

And for instance, if a child sees its face for the first time in a mirror, the instinctive reaction of the child will be to say, this is me. This is my face. The child does not realize that this is not its face. This is not it. This is actually a mere reflection of its face, which is not able to do what its face can do.

So we, in many respects, are similar to this childish being who apprehend phenomena as inherently existing when they are not. Now to return to the example of the cup, of Rinpoche’s cup which he gave, taking our syllogism, the subject, the cup, it follows that the cup is not inherently existing because it is a dependent arising. If we analyze carefully, we could see that if the cup were truly existing, if the cup were inherently existing, then the cup could not be a dependent arising. It could not be a dependent arising, but we know, as a matter of fact, it is a dependent arising. It is a dependent arising because it has been created by many actors, by a maker.

Many parts have gone into it. It was made in a factory. It is constituted of porcelain in the various constituents. If all of these constituents were not there, then the cup would not exist. What would an inherently existing cup be like?

An inherently existing cup would just be there. It would have no cause, no parts, no origination. It would just spontaneously be there. Rinpoche’s cup does not fulfill these conditions. So so through analyzing in this way, eventually, one gets a strong sense, the cup is not inherently existent, is not self characterized because it is not inherently existing because it is a dependent arising.

Excuse me. So if we take our example of the face the reflection of a face in a mirror, the reflection of a face in a mirror is a dependent arising, which arises in dependence on the presence of the face and the presence of a mirror. Now what would be a an inherently existing reflection of a face in the mirror if such a thing existed? An inherently existing reflection of a face in the mirror would be a reflection which does not arise in dependence on causes and conditions, but which would exist from its own side. So an inherently existing reflection of a face in the mirror would be a reflection of a face in the mirror, which did not need a face and did not need a mirror.

Such a thing obviously does not exist. A reflection of a face in the mirror occurs at the junction or through the collection of the two conditions, which are the presence of a mirror and the presence of a face. Returning to the example Rinpoche gave of his cup, if we take the syllogism, the subject Rinpoche’s cup, it follow

That it is not inherently existent because it is a dependent arising through analyzing again and again and again the reasoning of the dependent arising, understanding that the cup is produced by many actors and the factory in many different ways. Eventually, a sense that the cup cannot be inherently existing arises. And this is the case because inherent existence and interdependence are mutually contradictory. If something is inherently existing, it is necessarily not interdependent. If something is interdependent, it is necessarily not inherently existing.

The two have no common locus. They have no common denominator. So once we understand this and we understand that the cup is an interdependent arising, is a dependent origination, we will automatically eventually understand that the cup lacks inherent existence. Once we have understood that the cup lacks inherent existence, we have realized the emptiness of the cup. Got it.

I think the. And if we return then to our syllogism, the subject, the cup, it follows that it does not exist inherently because it is a dependent arising. On the basis of this syllogism, we can then understand how it is possible to establish that the self is not inherently existing. We replace the subject, the cup, by the self, and we say the subject I, the self, is not inherently existing because it is a dependent arising. Now the I is the dependent arising because it arises in dependencies on many conditions, such as, for instance, the accumulation of past karma, which acts as a cause for the arrival of the I in this life, the presence of one’s father and mother, and for that matter, the very specific connection between the spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother.

So if these conditions are not present, the eye cannot arise. It is only through the presence of these conditions that an eye arises. Therefore, the eye is necessarily a dependent arising. Now when we speak of a dependent arising, the Tibetan term dependent arising, has two syllables. rten means the basis.

It is a dependent arises arising because it arises in dependence on another basis, in dependence on another. A dependent arising is that which arises in dependence on another. And the second syllable, drelwa, means to connect. It is connected because it is connected intimately to another in as much as it arises from it. So that which arises from something else is necessarily a dependent arising.

Returning to our syllogism, the subject, the I, does not exist inherently because it is a dependent arising. We can understand best that the I is not inherently existing in the context of the syllogism if we understand clearly that being inherently existing and being a dependent arising are mutually contradictory as Rinpoche explained previously in the context of the example of the cup. So if something is a dependent arising, it is necessarily not inherently existing. If something is inherently existing, it is necessarily not a dependent arising. In the case of the self, if the self were to be inherently existing, which it is not, then the self would have to exist independently of any causes and conditions.

So it would have to exist independently of past karma and causality. It would have to exist independently of one’s parents. It would have to exist independently of the meeting of the spermatozoa and the ovum, which is obviously not the case. Therefore, we can say that the self is a dependent arising, and hence, that it lacks inherent existence. And then taking the instance of our syllogism, the subject I, it follows it lacks inherent existence or it is not inherently established because it is independent arising.

In this the case of this syllogism, the reason which is that the I is a dependent arising, in other words, that it is constituted of many parts, it is one of the multiple reason divisions of dependent arising is actually understood in the light of a direct valid cognizer. As you remember, valid cognizers are divided into two categories, direct valid cognizers and inferential valid cognizers. So the reason of the syllogism is understood using a direct valid cognizer. It is directly perceived. And then in dependence on this reasoning, the predicate, which is that the I is not inherently established, is understood relying on an on an inferential valid cognizer.

An inferential valid cognizer, which uses as a reason, the reason of interdependence of the I, which has been realized using a direct valid cognizer. Now generally speaking, inferential valid cognizers, are called in Tibetan, have a very clear etymology. Means after, means to ascertain. So jé pakpa tema is a valid cognizer which ascertains after. It ascertains after what?

After the reasons which are given. So even though these valid these inferential valid cognizers are conceptual, the inferential valid cognizer realizing emptiness is a very precious and powerful mind because it is a mind which has realized emptiness through countless reasoning, through countless analysis, and it is a stable mind. Unlike direct valid cognizers, which even though they are valid cognizers, because they’re non conceptual, tend to be unstable and shifting.

So therefore, it is not enough to when one tries to meditate on emptiness, just think emptiness, emptiness, and try to create some sort of vague emptiness in one’s mind and hope that one is getting somewhere with this. This leads absolutely nowhere. It is through analysis that the absence of the object of negation can be ascertained. Now regarding our present situation, we, through attending teachings on emptiness, have implanted the karmic imprints which have arisen from hearing within our mind stream. We have heard quite a bit about emptiness.

And in dependence on these karmic imprints which have arisen from hearing, in the future, we will meet teachings regarding emptiness. But these karmic imprints which have arisen from hearing remain very weak and unstable. And at this point, we have to engage in careful analysis of emptiness. We have to implant the karmic imprints, which have arisen through thinking, which are much more stable and strong, analyzing using many reasonings phenomenon and saying, well, does the I exist inherently or not? And if it existed inherently, it would not be a dependent arising and so forth.

And then in dependence on this powerful process of analysis, karmic imprints which have arisen from thinking will be implanted. And in turn, eventually, we may hope to gain a sudden realization. The I actually does not exist as it appears. It does not exist in here inherently. These are the karmic imprints which are arisen through meditation.

Now in dependence on these three in the future, we can hope to gain high realizations of emptiness. The reason we at present find it so difficult to understand this topic is because in the past, we have not been exposed to explanations of emptiness. So at present, we have to lay the groundwork for the future in the same way as when a seed is planted in fertile soil with manure, and it is watered at a later date, the seed instantaneously sprouts. In the same way, through implanting sound karmic imprints through hearing and thinking at this point, at a later date, we will gain instantaneous realization of emptiness when we are exposed to the concepts. If this happens, we will have made this human life meaningful.

So the question is, is grasping at phenomena existing or truly established from their own side considered to be a nonvirtuous action? So Rinpoche says, no, it’s not in our nonvirtuous action. Since basically in dependence on this view of the disintegrating collection or the ignorance which apprehends phenomena as inherently existing, both virtue and nonvirtue accumulated. For instance, when we prostrate thinking, I prostrate, we are prostrating under the influence of the ignorance which apprehends itself as inherently existing, but we are accumulating virtue. Likewise, when we say I meditate, then we are meditating under the influence of the ignorance which apprehends the self as inherently existing.

On the other hand, through this ignorance, can also accumulate non virtuous deeds. Therefore, such a mind is actually neutral, even though it does belong to the category of the afflictions. So in dependence on this mind is a motivating factor. Both virtue and non virtue can be accumulated. Therefore, this this mind has to be said to be neutral.

The question is, how does one develop an understanding or experience of insights gained from meditating on emptiness if our mode of apprehension, conceptuality is dualistic? So Rinpoche says, indeed, conceptual minds are necessarily dualistic, and every conceptual mind is actually a mistaken mind because it apprehends phenomena through a meaning generality. But even though conceptual minds are mistaken, they are the only means to realize emptiness which we ordinary beings have. And for that matter, valid inferential cognizers, even though they are conceptual minds and even though they are mistaken, are nonetheless correct minds. They are correct because they actually apprehend the phenomenon as they exist, an in dependence on an inferential valid cognizer realizing emptiness, it is eventually possible to gain direct realization of emptiness.

The reason for this is that the inferential valid cognizer apprehending emptiness apprehends phenomena in their mode of existence. And through repeated familiarization with this, eventually, the conceptual component of this mind disappears. The mistaken component of this mind disappears, and it realizes emptiness nakedly. So in the Heart Sūtra, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the dharani, gate, gate, paragate, parasamgate, and so forth, the first two gates actually refer to the mistaken level of the path since these are conceptual minds which are realizing emptiness. But at the time of the third, the parasamgate, then the conceptuality is dispelled, the mistakenness is dispelled, and emptiness is realized nakedly.

So the question is if a being has realized bodhicitta in the view, thus abandoning both self grasping and self-cherishing, how are there still subtle obscurations to enlightenment? Rinpoche explained this in the light of the grounds and the paths. So if we explain this in the light of the grounds and the paths, then the time of the first gate of the Heart Sūtra is the time of the path of accumulation of Bodhisattvas. The time of the time of the second gate is the time of the path of preparation. When a Bodhisattva enters on the path of accumulation, at that very instant, he abandons self-grasping and self-cherishing ceases to exist.

However, some bodhisattvas start to meditate conceptually and gain conceptual realization of emptiness at the time of the path of accumulation and some do at the time of the path of preparation. In both cases, however, this is a conceptual realization of emptiness. So as Rinpoche explained, it apprehends its object correctly, but is mistaken with respect to the way the object appears. At the time of the third path, which is the path of seeing, the bodhisattva realizes emptiness nakedly or directly. And then at this point, there still many objects of abandonment.

There’s tremendous effort which has to be put at the level of the third, the path of seeing, and the fourth path, which is a path of meditation to progress through the 10 grounds and countless objects of abandonment have to be abandoned, all forms of apprehension of true existence until the most subtle obstructions to omniscience are abandoned on the last ground. And when all objects of abandonment are abandoned and all objects of realization are realized, at that point, one reaches full enlightenment. Okay? On page nine.

We have a in June, we have a start new class on a Thursday night. Geshe-la is going to give teachings on a Thursday night, and there’s a pamphlets around you can Carol is going to distribute. And, of of course, on June 7 is, Sagadawa. It’s there is precept in the morning, 05:30, and, also refuge. If you haven’t taken refuge, there’s a you can chance to, you know, ring up at the at the register at the office.

And, also sūtra reading, and after that, normal teaching, you know, 11:00, etcetera. And there is, Elias is going to give a talk on the June 6. It’s, I think, Saturday. Self, no self, and the freedom, the what do you call the suffering of the anyway, there’s a template down there. I can’t see.

I really recommend, you know, to you can join and, come this, receive teaching. You know, Ilya, you know, it is a great opportunity to gain wisdom. And, of course, the the October retreat, you know, if you are thinking, you know, Guru Puja commentary, and, you better, sort out your plans. And, of course, Tibetan community in SA, South Australia, there is a plan for a dinner party for His Holiness’s birthday on July 11, and it’s very cheap. It’s $35.

And there is, it says here, buffet style menu. You know? And then there’s a heaps of entertainment. You know? You I think last year was fantastic.

You know? Those who came, they enjoyed, you know, our food. You know? And, we’re we’re hoping, you know, the same thing happen again. And this year is actually cheaper.

Last year was the 45. But, you know, there would be a great entertainment and a great musicians. And, you know, I think it’s a good idea to have a good fun one night. And, you know, I’ll go again. You know, the the Geshe-la is going to give teaching on a Thursday night again.

You know, if you this is going to be a Lam Rim teaching, and, it’s called Essence of Nectar Lamrim. You know? It’s fantastic. You know? If you like to join that, that’d great.

Thank you very much. Good. And there’s Chai. Oh, no. I think it’s better.

And to June, we have a sale on in the bookshop. And, if you have a web access, you know, the e the the newsletter, June, July, be ready. You can yeah. Or, you know, Saturday, Sunday, or maybe the beforehand, you know. But, you look at there’s lots of articles and, you know, fantastic, things in there.

And, and there is a shop. We have a small gift shop, which, we have a gift shop. And, you know, there’s a 20% off. You know, everything if you are member, don’t forget that. If you’re not member, you still have a good deal.

There’s a 15% off. You know? There we go. And, you can give buy things, you know, to help center and the same time to give you a birthday party for birthday present for somebody else. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How can we gain direct insight into emptiness through meditation if our conceptual mind, our way of apprehending, is dualistic?

Conceptual minds are necessarily dualistic, and every conceptual mind is mistaken because it apprehends phenomena through a meaning generality. Even so, conceptual minds are the only means ordinary beings have to realize emptiness. A valid inferential cognizer, though conceptual and mistaken, is still a correct mind because it apprehends phenomena as they exist. Relying on an inferential valid cognizer realizing emptiness, direct realization of emptiness can eventually be gained. Through repeated familiarization, the conceptual and mistaken component of the mind disappears and emptiness is realized nakedly.

If a being has realized bodhicitta in the view and abandoned self-grasping and self-cherishing, why do subtle obscurations to enlightenment remain?

The answer is explained through the grounds and paths. A Bodhisattva abandons self-grasping, and self-cherishing ceases, on entering the path of accumulation. But realization at that stage is still conceptual. Some bodhisattvas gain a conceptual realization of emptiness on the path of accumulation and some on the path of preparation. This realization apprehends its object correctly but is mistaken in the way the object appears. Only on the path of seeing is emptiness realized nakedly or directly, and even then many objects of abandonment remain. Great effort is needed on the paths of seeing and meditation to progress through the ten grounds.

Scroll to Top